ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

In this introductory paper we aim to critically analyze a possible research design on the correlation between curiosity and intrinsic motivation in students. In this sense, the background of the problem will be analyzed in an introduction that will emphasize the importance of this possible correlation in the current school context dominated by the new mental organization of digital students. Then they will be analyzed among the fundamental elements of a research. First of all, the choice of appropriate research tools, which will combine qualitative and quantitative research. Secondly, it is a discussion about the purposes of researching the mentioned correlation, the basic questions, the objectives, the sample and, finally, about the ways of analyzing the data and the necessary conclusions.
Jus et civitas
Vol. VIII(LXII)
No. 1/2021
51 - 56
A Journal of Social and Legal
Studies
CURIOSITY AND MOTIVATION, A POSSIBLE
CORRELATION
Dragoș Grigorescu
Petroleum - Gas University of Ploiesti, Bd. Bucharest, no. 39, Ploiesti, Romania
e-mail: dgrigorescu@upg-ploiesti.ro
DOI:10.51865/JETC.1.07
Abstract
In this introductory paper we aim to critically analyze a possible research design on the correlation
between curiosity and intrinsic motivation in students. In this sense, the background of the problem will be
analyzed in an introduction that will emphasize the importance of this possible correlation in the current
school context dominated by the new mental organization of digital students. Then they will be analyzed
among the fundamental elements of a research. First of all, the choice of appropriate research tools, which
will combine qualitative and quantitative research. Secondly, it is a discussion about the purposes of
researching the mentioned correlation, the basic questions, the objectives, the sample and, finally, about
the ways of analyzing the data and the necessary conclusions.
Keywords: education, motivation, curiosity, education research
Context
The life experience that the school offers to all today's students in Romania or from
anywhere is more complex than ever. The hectic pace of change that students have to
adapt to is astonishing compared to the pace of life in schools 30 or 50 years ago. The
emergence of new types of minds in the new generations, formed through the assistance
of digital and virtual, include mandatory pedagogical challenges to maintain the
connection between teachers and students. Challenges contain dangers and opportunities.
The dangers refer primarily to mental fractures between students and teachers, against the
background of the general crisis of value identity of contemporary society. This crisis is
best shown by T. Nichols, who, in a synthetic expression, says things by name, unlimited
digital information, makes us more stupid. (Nichols, 2019, p. 123). Opportunities refer to
the richer knowledge of human nature. Never in the history of mankind have teachers
been able to get to know their students better than they do today, even before entering the
classroom. Psychology, neuroscience, ethology, with their specific branches, elucidate
with the means of exact science more and more mysteries about man that for centuries
were the object of imagination and philosophical ingenuity. With a minimum of training,
a competent teacher today knows how a child's mind and soul work and has access to
scientifically accredited means of pedagogical intervention. Both the dangers and the
52 Dragoș Grigorescu
opportunities described above, to limit ourselves to just a few of them, make working as
an educator today a demanding experience, but at the same time motivating.
In the present research, we set out to investigate, in the current pandemic context, two
extremely important components of the educational process in Romanian schools: the
curiosity of high school students and their level of intrinsic motivation. Both internal traits
of children make a decisive mark on school success (performance, performance), but also
on the classroom environment or the well-being of students and teachers. Every teacher
wants motivated and interested students in the class, as any student is concerned with
finding out things that make him feel appropriate in relation to his classmates and society
as a whole, or finding answers to the challenges he faces. school training period. Both
teachers and students are looking for each other in this wonderful travel meeting called
education, and motivation and curiosity are key ingredients for this meeting to be a
success.
Research dedicated to motivation and curiosity is relatively numerous and diverse in the
last hundred years, but has not stood out for the great mass of educators in the last 50
years. The grounds for this situation are in turn a distinct object of study, but in recent
decades motivation has become an ever-present component in pedagogy treatises,
including in Romania (Cucoș, 2017; Pânișoară, 2018). Instead, the topic of curiosity
remained far from the attention of researchers. Therefore, we consider that this research
covers a need to know the educational environment in general and by investigating these
components, but at the same time connects the scientific educational environment in our
country to current mentalities of approach and research of education in international
communities. tradition.
Research design
Curiosity and motivation are internal components of students' minds, and their approach
requires probing the interior of each child, so it is recommended an investigative path to
start with the knowledge of subjective realities in which high school students live their
lives as students, then follow a quantitative measurement to extract any regularities. The
initially designed doctoral research provided for the combination of a qualitative research
with a quantitative one. The compelling pandemic reality meant that the qualitative
research approach, which meant a number of hours of classroom observation, interviews
and other qualitative tools, could not be carried out under conditions of scientific
objectivity. Therefore, we mainly used the classic tools of quantitative research through
which we tried to capture as accurately as possible the levels of motivation and curiosity
in the selected high school students.
The ethnographic research aimed to obtain a concrete database, extracted from the direct
realities of school life, which would have facilitated the creation of a quantitative research
tool adapted to these realities. In the absence of direct access, we resorted to standardized
tools that proved both their validity and scientific objectivity, but especially were
designed in such a way that by construction they allowed an adaptation to very diverse
school environments. For both curiosity and intrinsic motivation, the holders of the rights
to use the tools invited to test them in as diverse situations and environments as possible
with the obvious aim of increasing the validity and accuracy for each of these tools. Both
standardized questionnaires have reached a threshold of scientific maturity and have been
applied systematically for several years in schools in different countries. In the case of
Curiosity and motivation, a possible correlation 53
internal motivation we used one of the four variants of the I.M.I. (Intrinsic Motivation
Inventory) which has enjoyed considerable success over more than two decades, being an
integral part of the framework theory of self-determination (S.D.T.). For curiosity, we
chose the most relevant variant for the school environment, the test of the five dimensions
of curiosity (5D.CR - 5 Dimensions of Curiosity Revised), also applied in American
schools for several years, a process which has seen improved variants and revised.
It is important to emphasize that both tests are the result of a selection made successively
several years in a row, and the criteria that formed the basis of these selections were
among the requirements assumed in this research such as: application and specific
addressing on students and less on a non-school audience, relevance to school practice,
compliance with the restrictive conditions of research ethics with emphasis on parental
consent and mental well-being of the minors involved (minimum discomfort in
completing the questionnaire), respect for cultural diversity and local habits, ease in
application of tools (interaction as little as possible between researcher and students -
online environment), full transparency of the process of data collection, recording and
interpretation (possibility to restore statistical interpretation).
The two framework questionnaires, available online in open source mode, have a different
structure. The I.M.I. has a first set of fundamental items that aim at intrinsic motivation
in general, and another four sets of items that are dedicated to a more precise investigation
of internal motivation in relation to various benchmarks, for example: 1. motivation to
learn for a task or an exam; 2. the motivation measured in relation to the experience
(analysis) with a text; 3. the motivation resulting from questioning the subjects
'impressions about solving some tasks and 4. the motivation relative to the subjects'
perceptions about learning / effort / commitment. The 5D.C.R. (Kashdan, 2019) consists
of 5 groups of questions focused on:
a. joyful exploration (exploration researched from the perspective of the emotional state
associated with the experience of knowledge, eg solving a mystery or finding a solution
to a problem - joyous exploration);
b. sensitivity to the unknown, items that measure how much are disturbed, in our case
students subjects of incomplete data, missing parts, unknown, etc. - deprivation
sensitivity;
c. stress tolerance, a set of items that measure the negative impact of the exploration
experience, student resilience, management of inner effort associated with the unknown
or problems - stress tolerance;
d. social curiosity, a group of items dedicated to the relationship of subjects, learning or
discovery in teams or groups, managing their own behavior and social adaptability by
understanding the behavior of others - social curiosity;
e. the search for emotion, a group of items that aims to measure the availability to risk or
the risk profile corresponding to the exploration of the unknown, planning and the sense
of adventure and new things, the unpredictability of social relationships - thrill seeking)
Finally, a single questionnaire consisting of 36 items was reached, the first 18 dedicated
to curiosity research, which plays the role of an independent variable, and the next 18
questions aim at measuring intrinsic motivation, with the role of a dependent variable.
54 Dragoș Grigorescu
For the accuracy of the results, we translated and adapted the items from the original
questionnaire in relation to the specifics of the psychological and cognitive profile of the
high school students, including the language used. In this way we obtained short closed
questions, easy to read and understand, formulated in a colloquial language oriented
towards a casual and familiar reporting from the students.
The purpose of the research
Through comparative research on intrinsic curiosity and motivation, we aim to show that
we can have internally and long-term motivated students if we adequately stimulate
students' native curiosity. In general, although it is admitted that intrinsic motivation is
extremely important for the whole educational process and even methodological
suggestions are offered to stimulate it, in educational practice it is not among the assumed
teaching tasks for which resources are allocated. Indeed, although an intrinsically
motivated student is indisputably an optimal partner for the teacher, he is not so easy to
obtain. Moreover, we consider that stimulating curiosity seen as a way to motivate
students internally, respects or at least can be easily folded on the teaching methods used
intensively in the Romanian school environment, without the need for psychological
interventions, no less useful , but perhaps more difficult to implement. The enormous
advantage of stimulating curiosity is that the teacher responds to a native and instinctual
inner need of the student, the need for exploration, leaving only the role of orchestra this
need under professional conditions. Finally, we hope that after this research, teachers will
have a way to manage the long-term motivation of students.
Research questions
Any research starts from the researcher's curiosity. Scientific research itself is primarily
the result of the researcher's need to know. The question is the spark of any research, it
best expresses the need for exploration. Philosophy has its origin, according to Aristotle,
in wonder. Astonishment in front of the world shaped the philosophical investigation and
later the scientific one. The questions of this research center around students' curiosity
and inner motivation. Being a quantitative research, adapted to the distance research of
students, we wanted to know how and how much students in the selected group show
their curiosity and motivation in relation to learning for exams, theses or tests.
By exams we mean the national assessment exam that the 8th grade students were to take,
and by tests or theses, we mean all the stages of the end-of-year assessment process that
the 7th grade students took. during the study, respectively between 1 and 16 June 2021.
The fundamental questions of this study can be articulated in descending order, from
general to particular, as follows:
- How curious and motivated are the high school students in the sample?
- How can students' internal motivation be stimulated based on their basic needs?
- Does the level of intrinsic motivation vary if the curiosity in turn undergoes
changes?
- Is there a relevant positive correlative link between curiosity and intrinsic
motivation?
Curiosity and motivation, a possible correlation 55
- If we stimulate students' curiosity, then will they become more motivated to
learn? - What is the perception of high school students compared to learning for exams?
- Can the learning experience be a pleasant one for high school students?
General objectives
The main objective of the research is to show how important curiosity is for the whole
educational process. The innate need of students to learn about the things around them is
an important capital that is still insufficiently exploited by teachers. Another goal of the
research is to show that in order to have more motivated students we need to pay attention
to how we can stimulate and nurture their curiosity.
Secondary objectives
Let's explore the level of native curiosity of the high school students in the sample
Let's investigate how internally motivated the middle school students in the
sample are
Let's explore how students receive the learning and assessment experience
Let's investigate the emotional context associated by students' learning experience
for exams
Research hypothesis
The research hypothesis is formulated by highlighting the role of variables:
If we stimulate students' native curiosity, then they will become more intrinsically
motivated.
Secondary or additional hypotheses can be formulated as follows:
If we stimulate the students' native curiosity, then they will have better school
results (better results of exams / tests)
If the students are more curious, then learning / assimilation will be done faster /
easier. If students are (more) intrinsically motivated, then they will be more pronounced.
The sample
The first criterion for selecting the sample was an analysis of studies dedicated to school
cycles (primary, secondary and high school) which highlighted an unbalanced situation
between them. Thus, most studies, meaning scientific articles, bachelor's or master's
theses were dedicated to the primary and high school cycle, while for the gymnasium
level were the fewest studies. For example, from consulting two international databases,
Jstore and Ceeol, a search for a comparative keyword between primary school, middle
school and high school was sufficient. The results were as follows:
Ceeol: studies dedicated to primary education 2297, gymnasium 7, high school 2378
Jstore: primary 1,034,985, gymnasium 27,185, high school 2,182,104
The following criterion followed the distribution by classes, in the range of 5th grade to
8th grade, but favoring the final grades, 7th and 8th, because they have a higher number
56 Dragoș Grigorescu
of tests or exams. Then we followed a diversified dispersion of schools in terms of the
distinction between central urban, peripheral urban, respectively large urban (Ploiești),
small urban (Vălenii de Munte, Băicoi, Sinaia, Bușteni,) and rural.
Preliminary conclusions
Both the curiosity, through all the analyzed aspects, and the intrinsic motivation are in the
interviewed students in an important correlation degree and strongly impact the students'
commitment for exams or different tasks. Moreover, the results entitle us to highlight the
importance of curiosity as a means of stimulating the intrinsic motivation of
preadolescents. On the other hand, the accumulated data outline an image of the broader
context of school learning, for example how students feel the learning experience for
exams in terms of emotional involvement, cognitive stimulation, students' well-being. We
have a picture of the relationship between extrinsic motivation - students learn with a
sense of obligation - and intrinsic motivation to learn to experience curiosity.
Bibliography
1. Cucoș, C. 2014. Pedagogie. Editia a III-a, Polirom, Iași.
2. Pânișoară, G. 2019. Psihologia învățării. Cum învață copiii și adulții? Editura
Polirom, Iaș.i
3. https://selfdeterminationtheory.org/intrinsic-motivation-inventory/
4. Kashdan, Todd & Disabato, David & Goodman, Fallon & Mcknight, Patrick.
(2019). The Five-Dimensional Curiosity Scale Revised (5DCR): Briefer
subscales while separating general overt and covert social curiosity.
5. Nichols, T. (2017) The Death of Expertise: the Campaign against Established
Knowledge and Why It Matters, first edition Oxford University Press
Curiozitate și motivație, o posibilă corelație
Rezumat
În această lucrare introductivă ne propunem analiza critică a unui posibil design de cercetare privind
corelația dintre curiozitate și motivația intrinsecă la elevii. În acest sens se vor analiza fondul problemei
într-o introducere care va sublinia importanța acestei posibile corelații în contextual școlar actual dominat
de noua organizare mentală a elevilor digitali. Apoi se vor analiza pe rând elementele fundamentale ale
unei cercetări. În primul rând alegerea unor instrumente adecvate de cercetare, care vor îmbina cercetarea
calitativă cu cea cantitativă. În al doilea rând e vorba despre o discuție despre scopul cercetării corelației
amintite, întrebările de bază, obiectivele, eșantionul și, în cele din urmă despre modalități de analiză a
datelor și concluziile care se impun.
... Intrinsic motivation is defined as the motivation to engage in a behavior because of the satisfaction inherent in the activity rather than the desire for a specific reward or outcome (Azziz, 2017). When intrinsically motivated, a person will be moved to act for pleasure or challenge rather than because of external products, pressures, or rewards (Grigorescu, 2021). According to Morris et al. (2022), three things must be strived for to increase intrinsic motivation, namely: 1) Autonomy is the right or condition of self-government. ...
Article
This study aims to analyze the impact of disaster management leadership on human resources (HR) performance and their intrinsic motivation at the Regional Disaster Management Agency (BPBD) of West Kotawaringin Regency. Employing an explanatory research approach, this study involved all HR at the BPBD of West Kotawaringin Regency as the population, with a total sample of 53 respondents, selected through a census sampling technique. Primary data was collected using questionnaires containing questions related to the variables of disaster management leadership and HR performance, measured with a Likert scale from 1 to 5, and analyzed using the Partial Least Squares (PLS) statistical tool. The findings indicate that disaster management leadership has a positive and significant effect on HR performance and their intrinsic motivation at the BPBD of West Kotawaringin Regency. Furthermore, intrinsic motivation was also found to have a positive and significant effect on HR performance. These findings highlight the importance of effective leadership in disaster management to enhance HR performance and intrinsic motivation, which are crucial in disaster mitigation. This study provides new insights into the dynamics of leadership and motivation in the context of disaster management, offering a significant contribution to disaster management practices in Indonesia, especially at the BPBD of West Kotawaringin Regency.
Book
In The Death of Expertise: The Campaign against Established Knowledge and Why It Matters, Tom Nichols explores the rejection of experts and the ongoing assaults against knowledge and critical thinking. He notes several influences, including the ubiquity of the Internet, the emergence of a customer satisfaction model in higher education, and the transformation of the news industry into a continual entertainment machine, among others. In this updated and expanded edition, Nichols returns to these themes and he is more alarmed than ever, especially in the aftermath of a pandemic and the outbreak of war in Europe. The rejection of expertise—in which people are hobbled by narcissism and reliant on an overestimation of their own knowledge—is now the foundation for populist political movements. The attacks on science and knowledge have become attacks on democracy itself by an army of ill-informed and angry citizens who are lost in a maze of misinformation, conspiracy theories—and even paranoia.
Psihologia învățării. Cum învață copiii și adulții? Editura Polirom
  • G Pânișoară
Pânișoară, G. 2019. Psihologia învățării. Cum învață copiii și adulții? Editura Polirom, Iaș.i