Content uploaded by Yonatan Lupu
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Yonatan Lupu on Nov 08, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Oine Events and Online Hate
!"#$
%&'((&()*"+&",&-&+&").//#,0
%&()*"+&",&-&+&").//#,0
.1.+&").,0
2'3))*((4%&'("+&",&-&+&").
//#,0
#".,0
5. (6"7
Abstract
8&(&(&'( 7&"!*7&9*&&"(&* &
:* &(&(& ( &;&-&-+&*("
!* &&"&( (&< *'3
((!*&* 3&":*+( (-& *(&
&"&3=3&(>&(( &:*+
< ;&&""-( ('?37 !&(&
3&(!*&"&@((' &"-A&
((!*&* 3&":* &* 'B&&"7
('!'&!7;&- &(7
&*&('3&(* '
8& 9*&*(&'( 7&"!*("!8&
"3&CD*& E &( & &-& ((**&'(&* &:*
7(&7**! *'*( &;&!-&"
? 7&(**&' &9((-
&*"'-((FG0'*&('-&(3&"D<
-&((>@(C,.&2&"("
&""- !37 !&(&(FG(&C&
(-3!7 &(&*&&C&-&
(&*FD>D=GA&((&(&('&!7;&&""-
&((( &(&&!"&&"
+3 (('!7&( ;&-"
-(&("+3(37&"'HI7 &
((;&&""-J)(' &B(*&*-3&"
:*J0;&-37 !&(& &(
-J8((!C& !;&- **!3&
(**&' !&"("&*&" "J
%&7C* &"&<(" ('" &"&(+&
379('F=DKG9&'"7C3(&(&3&"&(!&
(*(&3&"*3(FLDGM&7C
7 3*(&* &:**&* * :*
FD/G0(-3 A7&@7!3* & (&'(
&"* ('3&(F>G((-7&*&'7
*&'"$&(&&C-*'(!7*
3&":*( *(*&-(&<('3(&
!@ @3&(37&";&-
+( (*(*&- 3&(!&( &""3(&
* &:* (&3&"'-"3(+( (
-& *(&&"&3=3&(&"#L*&&N"&D
"" 73*#/&(**&'>(&* &:*-
(3L*8(- -"$&7&( ('-
* *&*:*O$(!CPC 2"*O-
3(Q-&" "R&(&"&(7D*
:*!A"* (A&7(&(7
!< 3* :*( !(&3&"! "33
(!&"7!97&(;&-37
! &B3&($& (('B!"&!(('"
&(**&'(:*F#D=G7&"
N9(-3&&-&!F#D>G
(&(7&&*&C&!!3 ?;&&""
-
Data and Methods
8 (('B!"&!& '3&"&(**&'M(&* &
:*B& &-& *E&(**&'3&CD*& (3
"$(!C(A"* **"! (+
& '< ( & &(**&'!&"7!*&"( (&! &
" &&2+&( (**&& (**&&3*
3/*((**&&( ($&&
(7 < (&QR(7 3 -&&3
,& . " &"(&*((( &")*3
'("& &SQ!R(*$(&& "&"&*
Q&9*'&* T(&& '&&*RA *&'37
&(**&&(**&7* *&"(&&+& '<
#/&(**&'&( &&
7/L )(*!//7(
(**&'&"(*!&'3* ** +*- D
N"&D""!&""U.*("")(8 &(
93#L*&& &( &*"-& &A2-&
&3*' &&!'3 (**&'(&9:*
8 ( 3=3(H("'"(" &"&"
& 'T9&'Q2T8R&**&"'&(&T& '&T'&*QNT2TR
7'D*&'*A2-& &'&3*'!77 <
3(+(3(!(&*-&73
(**&'7!- &'"&!3*(
Q" (D((R
A((&&" 37& *( 7
(& (3=3(+& * &'"&
!7* &(&3& (" &'"&!7D3
&(!( (&(0( &&(&!( (&&"
!7/ =3(2&&" &( *
( S2-& &'&3*'!( &"( &&"
+ (( ""&(('30"3*
!( &,& ! & &(&3,&'(!
3 &(&3N& 3N"&DC&"(&+
*C*'!""&(('3
,&""&* - !FKG7& &># &
*(& L>L 3*(+(* 3*(3>* 7&
&B&"(&<(' 9'* A!3*&"*
7C(&<7&NA*! &"FLGA* U(((" 3*L=V
LKV &"3(A2-& &'&3*'
(*&"3*(3* 7 (&!&"&" &
3*(3* 7(A !7! =*(&
&""&*&"&* (37&((&<7
(&"&-3(
Results
+!"&&!3(&" &&!'33(7&&
%03$&"77*(& (3(3*
(**3(&(**&'7(C &(&*7&(&
=*&&M &&"&'"3*(**&' & (&
(7&%A(**&'? &( & *
3 (97&(7 & 0!/V3
(& *3(%. &(73(&3
((D(( 7&&*M&7C&'-(
7&9('!&"" 'D*&'*7&(&7C"'-A*&"
( &&( NT2TS*(&(&""(&""
"'"(&<(&("
#
!"##
$#%
+9 7((" -'*$&"&("&
(&(**&'-'*%07* &
(3 &(#/(**&'0('-&&(**&' &B
*'(! 37C 7 &(=D
&"-"A*!3 *7 -
& &(&"!!>=V3*!>///////// &
A7(&!&C&('-&H&MT// &
-*!//AC;&- &( & &"&
7QRM#C&&"3"$ !M&&&(W( &"
"& !(C&-M@QMR*-*S QR-*!//,
('%773* &"7
-7&(&M&*& &(
&"& 3& (';&('-&('-&&&
(**&'&( *'(
%.7-& &( &"7-("3
(& ( ( 27 &"-&( -
"$&%)7**!3(
A2-& -&3!:*
>
(& &*& &(&-'*A7'-*
((( &"-*' !-
&
#'(# #
(#$(#)
%(#
+('&"7&((" -'*!3(&"(3
($&"7* &(3(
M-((&"!;& &(B(&(S73(
"("&'*D& &" & +& '3-"
&C&&('-&((&"&// 37&" HQR
7&(&"& '*&'*SQR$!L7&(&**&"'SQR
M7&((" 2T8NT2T '*&'*S QR-*!
7&(&"&" 2T8 &**&"'#
A2-& -&3!:*
#(!C&(<*("& 7&&7&&
@3(QX///R "!C&'*D&
=
*++
((#
,-.!/0%
+*-&7 3*& &"&C ((
(& 7&37&";&-HQR&'32&
Y*&*&SQR(&&! 3AC ("& !&(&7
"*!3*&3""N,&SQR"
$ * &"S QR-*!//,('>
+3(9&-N(&$&"7("&&
(37&"3-( &B3(
&B7*&-3(3(//! -D
&"-"&-$&"37'-("&
3(3(3(?(-$7&"&*&&'
>N- 7&"!&(& @7 &B(
*!&&'-+3* *&7&*
&(&(<*&C&7 -23
&
K
-3(&( &"&<(7&"&(&&"&QL/VR
'D*&'*Q>#VR2'"&"&9 &7"
2*!&(7&&'D*&'*3( ('27!&
&'A("&(('-& &"ACD(! (&&&
73-7 & H"&(&'D&**&"'(7&
'-&@("&
A"&(&('-& &" & 37 3"
$ (' &"&"A3(&(&( !
#/V! ! 3*& ! !7& !&
&-A&&&&""&-"'-('&*
"*3!&(+&&&"7-&3(3*
3(&( *'(&'*(&2T8Q=#VRNT2TQ>/VR
" Q#/VR 'D*&'*Q/VR+&$ U 7"
3* !&"!(&&&&&&'-(7'&-
-&339*" 9&'
A//,('&'"(,&C-7-
9*& ('7( &(**&'*&"(&'(&'3&
A&$&"7*&(-*&-37
&2** &!3('7"&(&&"&*3
7&(&2*!&(S&!&--&N
('N(')Q-*!R ('&"" ('
3& 7&!0(& %Q-*!=R7"&(&
2T8(Q-//VR &**&"'(Q#/VRS7-3"
37 2*77-3(&&"23"
& ' 9&'7*& &"(*&"S&"7-3
(& &(!"(3*&"'DAY
&"& **&"7& "3&'("(( & '
-&C7&&**&"'7*&(*&"&& !&
/>!?& U-&(&(&( ('7
* ,&**&"'&(A&"7-3" (!
" 7 &(%& P*I&! *-&73
-2'""(&&733 &"(*&"
&(((" '-&@!3 ?('A&*!
!(3(( &-&" 3*&&"&*&
- "&& (* & &"$ U Q
$&"R
L
12+(2+#((
(
/
(('-&&( "9?$ U 73(&*
&&-$&"#7&*&3$&"!!C 7!
:*=A@("37-@(:*
!((*C*E&3 M&&"&'-"
&(&($(!C8$(!C &-"3(&&"(
(&( !3(3/7&& 3$ U *& &"
- Q#9R*83((&'D*&'*"
2T8&( !"*$(!C &";&-+!-
&*&@! A"*H-"&(&(("7&
*!!&(&-3 -
7C?-8PC7-7'-&@('
-!(@ ,&'(K
=2"*&9( 3*$&"#!(7" & &"
&& *C*&"3&3(!("&('-&
KA&(&2T8('-&PC&*& D!
-
3%4,56)+
(5(4
Discussion
8< &"--&*&('3( (''A<&&
(&" "7&"!*B(!*&* 3&":*
8- & &-*3!"-"3////C
#//// #///*&7C3 -*
9*&( ('-& (& A!* :*FKDLG7
< :*7 & &( &"* (
&( &&( B(&&!* :*'( &"
( 33//0"*:*&(&"(**&@ *-&"
( *&(&((&(:*Q39*
2$&"KR)&B!*&*:**-(&"7&
-*3&":*(( A"*Q2$&"= LR8&9*&
C7*&"D* :*?!&"*- 3**&*
:*F>G7&(*!('!!&( &(*C
2&3((&('7*&*:*U(* '
B(-("3&(2'(< &"&-
('$&"&-&< &"3 (39*&(A!
< &"3&(&(* :*7 !@3
&"3( &' 7&(:*(!*B('-&* '"
(P3(&( 3(Q"((*
9*&(R3*3(Q"9--& R -&"
&-3*&(&(;&-2 &'"&-7&(C
C7*&"(:*C&33(&-&*(3&
*&"'*&(&(+9*& 7*&(&(
:* 3**&*:*7*3**&"3&":*J)
*&- 9* !&"*(37&""
7&*J0?(*&"' 3*&(&(((
("J)&(!(**9*37&*&(&J
( &C&&(37&";&-&*& 3&"
:*+C73*&7C&((("37&"
;&-FG! 7(*&3&((
:* 3(7&(& &*70? 3
"$ 39*"&(&&(&!*Q&
*!3R7(!&"&(7
$(!CQ$&"#RA&&'(&C&""&-$(!CU&( @'
(* 'A&*&('3&3:*& !(&
7(3 &"(& !&(&(3&":**!
&('-3'&*&&(&7:*&79&
3(
$& *&*7< &(( &B&";&
-& &B *'*(D&&'-7+*&"((&
3;&-&*3@3(37*$&
7 !;&-( &!!37 !&"&<(&(&(
Q&-&--&"3"3(R! 7&@('3*&
(**&'$9*M(//&-&P(C&(3
03&(D0*&(7** A&*AC&&"737 !
'-* &(&&&(**&'7(C Z&("
('* 3"$ 7*0( 3;&-&
&37 ! &(&(&&(! &(
;&- &&'-&(CA&'3&*&
AC&DC! (&&!-3&0& 3;&-&
37 !&(& ! (( 3&(!&
'3**&" &'3&&';&- "
"&9&- *&"& &(&*&*N-3&(-
"D'"B(@ -*3&(2 &
* 3"$ ,N('!-3&2*!
&&'-39*&(" &"(7 &( &"M
"&-7-7( !E(3(*
3&(&( &"'*&( &"39*2T8
7&(3(7 -& &((('&3&(!&
(
+3(9& &B'&!7& &-& ;&- &
(J0 & &3&'&! (3&!!
9&'"7C& F/DG7(E(C3(*!* &
@'2*!(!-* -&3&(';&
- &&(3-&* &$9*C&&"
3A(&- &@@'&,'* &&7C37 &
Q!(&(( &"'*7*,E& &('7(&"
<(C 73.82)DL *&(R !(*&"&<(*& &"
37 $ * A&*&&' N,! (&&
(&- * &@'!3'*M ,('
A!-'""* &@'*!3C3(9&
7@3&(37&"& &-& ;&- &B
+37C7&&-'"&&!&&73(*9&
@!- &0'(&*'337C&
&-'"7&((*&C!37 !! *&"
& &(&*&(( 3&(&C7&&'3
7&((&"" !(-*&C!37
!((( &3(
8 3(7&*&*&'A<&*3&
(**&'&7&*(*&-&&*7&7C
(-&(*+ !&-7-( *3**& ('-
&(**&'7&((&" < &"
((&&*& !&((**&'7& '< '&
("-& &-& 7:*+(&33*'&
!7;&- 3(*3*&&
(**&'!7(&33*7&'& (
&("A&("3(&* &:*&- (
("&"07:**" (* 'B("& &-&
(**&'(*-&"3*:*:*&- (
(7 & ((A(C&" (&" :*&&*&
!*D3D-&( &-(((2&3&!('
("3&((< (&**3((&
'-3("
0( &*&'37C&& 73(&3(!7
!- ;& &*+-&7 (& 7&&C&
&( &( !- (( !'- &""
-7 (&! $7&" 3"$ 39*"
&(&(& ((Q$&"R&( *
3( $ (&(*( &"& &" &"
(( &(&&(7 ;&-
+(( !'"*(7C*&! !@
'&!7;&- &(+-( ( 7& D
"&"&3&(Z(3(*&(**&'
&-3:*+--& -& (""(*9'&
!7;&- &!7 &B3& !7
* 3&":*A&&*'3((
*' &(&& ""-"&3*&'"'"&($&
(* !&(&"7(33;&- B*
!"* 37&"&"&-( B(3;&-&
(*! &W( &( *&(C-- ! 7&(3
""! & *&'"'B&(&(-
&('-3;&(&*FD>D=G'9&3;&&""-
!37 !! (( 3&(&( (&*3
&&'-A& !(B(3;&- &B
3:*?&*&(* *&*:*(
-(&B!*'(!-&""&" -*3&"
:*
#
References
FG8C0I7 IC&N[&M4[[%Q/RN9&
*""(&* &2(7
N* %!&&"&*&
FG%4+&&*MQ/>R, *H& '3&"(!A7&@(
*'( ((&'(+8)3D#
FGM\P4(7.Q//R$*"(&*HA7&@ 'D*&&
'*(%9:*1;<*
FG+&&*M%- 0&I48Q//RI&*(&H0'D
(C 'DM&*(&* & &(3;&(& &"&
""- (&* #8$=<QRLD=
F#G(*& 04+&" MQ/=0&R0-( ('&"
""(&"2>,#'
QD/R
F>G$%4Q/KR0-*'( ('3(&
9$?$#(-$@9.3QRD/
F=G&- M&(CM )&.$!&(&- 2"*+!
/>]0&"A"3I&8&(&M &^A(=<*<BB<;C$DM(
@HTT9&-"T!T>//==/L
FKG0&+3%I& M@7+&&*/K]AN*0*",H
)('"I(7&A _8&"U""N*! &"^01&-HK//=L#
F.GM(@HTT9&-"T!TK//=L#
FLG*E)E&(&"`!&M&M&E!-&( -E-&(
*& &'/#I( ('7&(***! &"2%( &"
32'.3(+ +& +!.*&2'+
+& +!.3(&".**&@"LZ/
F/G.&C&!A0(&A*M &."/>
0!&-"")('&8&,.2%( &"3#2'
.3(+ +& +!2'+ +& +!.3(&"
.**&@"#Z#
FG%4+&&*MQ/#R.!(7&@H0&('3
*(&(&<(' ''(* &"3&( (&&*C&"7
BQRD
FG"1&"&$&"+"I" ./)('"B&-
7-&&(3 &(--"(7&@(2%( &"3
>
0.M&'(3(23*' C7 "*"*"LK/ZLK
M&I2,00.M
FG`"`4Q/LRI( ('H0- !*J("&"(
3"&7&@#E%<Q#RL#DL#
FG)&"$.&*&0)U8@$%((&M4A(&MQ/=RI*
*HI( ('3(!C2F$
$%-F+$B.QK>DL#R
F#G$`"M!-!&0Y&IM&%
)N".4+(Q/>R7&("3 -&
"""H22 ! *3&Q>LR#LD>
F>G$`"MM&%)-C
%4+(Q/LRI& &&( '- *&(3"!&
(":3B*Q===R>D>#
F=G$!&N8 `"M
M&%+(4Q//RA&(*''!7D 'D
-((&'-&7:3G&Q=KR/D
FKG(& &PA*C4-2Q/*!R8'<('3*'D
! 28+$?HI)(
)%Q#D#KR&"&I& !"
FLG)-&."M+P4A-PQ/KRH%D&&"3
!& &('3*3"" &"A(A(G<<1G<3
F/G"& A%4P'Q/L0"R-3&&-&*
2&<;F+++J$?F#$(:'
?QKDK=R
FGM&@AQ/R.&"&N9*&* &(&(F#
2K#D
FG(".-&&(AM&4C)Q/KR)"(H
0('("& )L
FGMMQ//R.*!& ",&-&%
FG(& &PA*C4-2Q/*!R8'<('3*'D
! 28+$?HI)(
)%Q#D#KR&"&I& !"
F#G+3A.* )!)".M&040MQ//
8(!RA3*HD3DD""(&"2
=
&<&<$+?:H
)#QKD#R
F>GM\P4(7.Q/R$&"a*3H(&* &
(&*8++#;QRD>=
F=GP)0&C N.I /b&"D+&"(&M & %&'(,b
(01&-)82H/#T3&T#
FKGM"P4%&&Q//R&"D+&"A!H0 *
('-F#8J#L/>/L>=>=
FLGI&* &I*&0.0M!&M(& )M4+@)
Q/RN9*&&"(*'3 &((A!:#
GQR
F/G@+4N*MQN RQ///R?#$#
.*!& ",&-&%
FG.MQ/R$#8,%893
List of Supplementary materials:
).('
A&&")
M(&&"M M ('
0* A&(0&
# 0 &'
K