ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

A collection from Phou Chom Voy Provincial Protected Area, Bolikhamxai, represents the first records for the family Akaniaceae as well as the genus Bretschneidera and the species Bretschneidera sinensis in Laos. Here we report the new and extended distributional range. A detailed description and photographs are provided for easy identification.
Content may be subject to copyright.
THAI FOREST BULL., BOT. 49(2): 231–235. 2021.
DOI https://doi.org/10.20531/tfb.2021.49.2.10
© 2021 Forest Herbarium
INTRODUCTION
The high moist mountainous area “Phou Chom
Voy”, part of the Annamite Mountain Range, is
located in the Phou Chom Voy Provincial Protected
Area of Bolikhamxay Province. It extends to the
Laotian-Vietnamese border and encompasses the
Khamkeut and Xaychamphone Districts. “Phou
Chom Voy” has been shown to have a rich biodiversity
and natural water resources, as well as potential
recreational and tourist opportunities. It is a diversity
hotspot of taxa, home to moist and clouded high
montane evergreen forests, at elevations of 800–
1,820 m asl. The area is difcult to access and probably
contains many endemic and unexplored species. At
present, scientic data of the ora from this area are
insufcient (V. Lamxay pers. comm.).
In the past few years, there were two new records
of orchids for Laos, namely Odontochilus elwesii
C.B.Clarke ex Hook.f. and O. putaoensis
X.H.Jin,
L.A.Ye & A.T.Mu. (Lanorsavanh et al., 2019).
A year
later, the new species, Begonia phouchomvoyensis
Lanors., Lamxay & Souvann., was discovered from
the same area (Lanorsavanh et al., 2020).
Botanical surveys in the Phou Chom Voy
Provincial Protected Area were undertaken between
2018 to 2021. Some plant collections, identied with
Akaniaceae, a new family record for Laos
SOULIVANH LANORSAVANH1,*, VICHITH LAMXAY1, SAWAI MATTAPHA2,
KEOOUDONE SOUVANNAKHOUMMANE1, KHAMFA CHANTHAVONGSA1 & SOMCHANH BOUNPHANMY1
ABSTRACT
A collection from Phou Chom Voy Provincial Protected Area, Bolikhamxai, represents the rst records for the family Akaniaceae as
well as the genus Bretschneidera and the species Bretschneidera sinensis in Laos. Here we report the new and extended distributional
range. A detailed description and photographs are provided for easy identication.
KEYWORDS: Brassicales, Bretschneideraceae, extended distribution, Indo-China.
Accepted for publication: 11 October 2021. Published online: 25 October 2021
1 Department of Biology, Faculty of Natural Science, National University of Laos, Vientiane, Laos.
2 Department of Biology, Faculty of Science, Udon Thani Rajabhat University, Udon Thani 41000, Thailand.
* Corresponding author: s.lanorsavanh@nuol.edu.la
Hemsley (1901), Niyomdham (1991), Lu & Boufford
(2005) and Gardner et al. (2007), appeared to be
Bretschneidera sinensis Hemsl. (Akaniaceae), a new
family, genus and species record for Laos. Vouchers
are deposited in the Biology Herbarium of the
National University of Laos and distributed to the
National Herbarium of Laos (HNL).
Bretschneidera Hemsl. was formerly placed
in the family Sapindaceae by Hemsley (1901) and
later in Bretschneideraceae with a possible close
relationship to Hippocastanaceae and Sapindaceae
(Boufford et al., 1989; Tobe & Peng, 1990; De
Craene et al., 2002; Lu & Boufford, 2005). More
recently, proof was provided that the genus has to
be included in the family Akaniaceae Stapf (Soltis
et al., 2000; APG IV, 2016). This position was already
earlier pointed out by Tobe & Peng (1990), Rodman
(1991), Rodman et al. (1993), Tobe & Raven (1995),
Doweld (1996) and De Craene et al. (2002).
Akaniaceae, a small family of owering plants
classied in the order Brassicales, comprises two
monotypic genera, Akania Hook.f., a native species
of Australia, and Bretschneidera, conned to South-
East Asia (Lu & Boufford, 2005; APG IV, 2016).
The family is characterized by combinations of
being a tree, having compound leaves, opposite to
THAI FOREST BULLETIN (BOTANY) VOL. 49 NO. 2
232
subopposite leaflets, absence of stipels, bisexual
owers, campanulate calyces with 5 lobes, corolla
with 5 lobes, a superior ovary with 3–5 locules, axile
placentation and capsular fruits.
The genus Bretschneidera differs from Akania
by having imparipinnate leaves (vs paripinnate in
Akania), entire leaet margins (vs serrate in Akania),
a racemose inorescence (vs paniculate inorescence
in Akania), zygomorphic owers (vs actinomorphic
owers in Akania) and presence of a oral disk (vs
absent in Akania).
In this communication, we report Bretschneidera,
a monotypic genus, and Bretschneidera sinensis as
new records for Laos. Previously, the species was
reported ranging from India, southern China and
northern Vietnam to confined areas in Northern
Thailand (Doi Phu Kha National Park, Nan Province;
Niyomdham, 1991; Gardner et al., 2007; Kumar
et al.,
2017),
but now it is known to have a wider
distribution, extending into Laos. The species was
not yet recorded in the plant check-list of Laos
(Newman et al., 2007; Jin et al., 2016), and the online
check-list, which is continuously updated by the
Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh (https://padme.
rbge.org.uk/laos/list/). Although, it was assumed to
occur in Laos by Lu & Boufford (2005); Wang et al.
(2018), but no specimen was recorded yet.
NEW RECORD
Akaniaceae Stapf, Bull. Misc. Inform. Kew, 1912:
380. 1912; C.Bayer & O.Appel in Kubitzki, Fam.
& Gen. Vasc. Pl. 5: 21. 2002; APG IV, Bot. J. Linn.
Soc. 181: 18. 2016; Chamch. et al., Threat. Pl.
Thailand. 25. 2017. Type: Akania Hook f.
Trees. Leaves alternate, paripinnate or impari-
pinnate; stipules present or absent; veins pinnate;
stipels absent. Inorescence racemose or paniculate,
axillary or terminal, erect; bracts present. Flowers
bisexual, actinomorphic or zygomorphic, 5-merous,
white or pink. Calyx broadly campanulate, 5-lobed.
Petals 5, convolute or imbricate. Stamens 5–10;
laments liform, hairy; anthers dorsixed, opening
length-wise. Disk absent or present. Ovary superior,
3–5 locules; placentation axile; ovules 2 per locule,
pendulous; style longer than stamens; stigma capitate
,
small.
Fruit a capsule, ellipsoid-globose to subglobose
to ovoid or obovoid to pyriform; loculicidally
dehiscent. Seeds red or yellow, ellipsoid-globose to
ovoid, compressed, without endosperm and aril.
Two genera: Akania and Bretschneidera. The
rst genus is native to Australia. Only Bretschneidera
was previously recorded from India, S China,
Taiwan, N Thailand and N Vietnam. It is now also
known for Laos.
Bretschneidera Hemsl., Hooker’s Icon. Pl. 28(1):
2708. 1891; L.L.Lu & Boufford in C.Y.Wu &
P.H.Raven, Fl. China 8: 197. 2005; C.Bayer &
O.Appel in Kubitzki, Fam. & Gen. Vasc. Pl. 5: 23.
2002; Chamch. et al., Threat. Pl. Thailand: 25.
2017. Type: Bretschneidera sinensis Hemsl.
Tree
10–25 m
tall. Bark grey-brown
, young twigs
with lenticels and leaf scars. Leaves imparipinnate,
with 8–31 leaets; venation pinnate; stipules present,
caducous; leaets opposite or lower ones alternate,
margin entire. Inflorescence racemose, terminal.
Flowers zygomorphic. Calyx 5-lobed. Petals 5,
imbricate, free, adnate at middle to upper part of
calyx tube, upper petal hood-like, covering stamens
and style. Stamens 8 (4+4). Disk present. Ovary
3-locular, hairy; ovules pendulous; style apically
bent abruptly downward.
A monospecic genus; Bretschneidera sinensis
;
previously known from India, S China, Taiwan,
N Thailand and N Vietnam, it is now also known
for Laos.
Bretschneidera sinensis Hemsl., Hooker’s Icon.
Pl. 28: t. 2708. 1901; Gagnep. in Lecomte, Fl.
Indo-Chine, Suppl. 1: 1001. 1950; Santisuk, Nat.
Hist. Bull. Siam Soc. 37(2): 173. 1989; Niyomdham
in Smitinand & K.Larsen, Fl. Thailand 5(3): 239.
1991; L.L.Lu & Boufford in C.Y.Wu & P.H.Raven,
Fl. China 8: 197. 2005. Type: China, Szemao,
Yunnan, at 5,000 ft., A. Henry 11651 (lectotype K
[K000681003!], designated by Kumar et al. 2017;
isolectotypes A [A00050653!], K [K000681002!]).
Fig. 1.
Bretschneidera yunshanensis Chun & F.C.How,
Acta Phytotax. Sin. 7(1): 68. 1958. Type: China,
Hunan, Hengshan, Fangkwang, Tzu, 9 May 1955,
K.H. Chu 99 (holotype SCBI).
AKANIACEAE, A NEW FAMILY RECORD FOR LAOS (S. LANORSAVANH ET AL.) 233
Leaves: petioles 11–17.2 cm long; rachis 11–21
cm long, pubescent; ultrajugal part 1.4–4.2 cm long,
slightly greenish, reddish adaxially, sparsely hairy,
glabrescent. Leaets 7–17; petiolules 3–9 mm long;
lamina obliquely lanceolate, oblong-lanceolate,
ovate-lanceolate or elliptic, 6–19.5 × 2.7–7.7 cm,
chartaceous, base obtuse to rounded to cuneate, apex
acuminate to acute or caudate, adaxial surface green
to somewhat pale green, glabrous, abaxial surface
grey, minutely pubescent, lateral veins 10–16 pairs.
Racemes 12–30 cm long, hairy. Flowers pink or
pink-white or rose-white. Pedicels 2–3.2 cm long,
hairy. Calyx broadly campanulate, 1.1–1.7 × 2–2.5
cm; lobes broadly triangular, 2–3 mm long, hairy
Figure 1. Bretschneidera sinensis Hemsl.: A. Leafy twig with inorescences; B. Bark; C. Flowers; D. Corolla with 5 lobes (dissected).
E. Calyx (corolla lobes removed) showing inside of calyx, attachment of ovary and stamens (above) and outside of calyx with minute
lobes (below). F. Stamens. Scale bars: 1 cm. All from SL2157 by S. Lanorsavanh.
THAI FOREST BULLETIN (BOTANY) VOL. 49 NO. 2
234
on both sides. Petals broadly spatulate to obovate,
1.8–2.7 × 1.5–2.2 cm, base cuneate, apex weakly
notched; upper petal pink to white, becoming darker
with age, red striate. Stamens: laments 2.2–2.5 cm
long, hairy at base, curving downward apically;
anthers oblong, 5–6.5 × 1.5–2 mm. Disk annular.
Ovary ellipsoid-globose to subglobose to ovoid or
obovoid, 3–4 × ca 3 cm; style 2.2–2.4 cm long, hairy;
stigma ca 1 mm diam. Fruit not seen.
Distribution.— See under genus.
Ecology & Phenology.— In Laos collected
near a stream in evergreen forest at ca 1,100 m alt.
Flowering in March.
Vernacular.— ດອກພວງບົວຈອມວອຍ (Dok
phuang boua chom voy).
Specimens examined.— Laos: Bolikhamxai,
Khankeut District, Nahueng Village, Phou Chom
Voy Provincial Protected Area, 18°25′10.3″N,
105°03′13.4″E, 1,084 m, 3 Mar. 2021, Lanorsavanh
et al. SL2157 (HNL, NLS=National University of
Laos, Faculty of Natural Science).
Conservation status— The species is present
with less than a 100 individual trees in Laos over an
area of ca 10 km2 that is only at one site a Protected
Area; therefore, in Laos it is rare and Endangered
(Sun, 1998).
Note.—
Bretschneidera sinensis
is characterized
by its imparipinnate leaves, erect racemes, 5-lobed
corolla, corolla lobes broadly spathulate to obovate,
base cuneate, upper petal hood-like covering the
stamens and the style, 8 stamens and a 3-locular
ovary.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank the staff of
the Department of Biology, Faculty of Natural
Science, National University of Laos and the
Department of Biology, Faculty of Science, Udon
Thani Rajabhat University, Thailand, for use of their
facilities during the study and the staff of the herbaria
for their collaboration. We are especially grateful
to the Environment Protection Fund (EPF) under
the Project of Capacity Enhancement of Laos’s
Natural Sciences, in the Sub-Project Number PICE-
LENS2-010, for supporting the eld survey at Phou
Chom Voy Provincial Protected Area. We also express
our gratitude to Pongkham Phommachan for assisting
during the eld work. Finally, thanks to Jeffrey Nash
who kindly reviewed the English and two reviewers
for helpful comments for improving the manuscript.
REFERENCES
APG IV (2016). An update of the Angiosperm
Phylogeny Group classication for the orders
and families of owering plants: APG IV.
Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society 181
(1): 1–20.
Boufford, D.E., Kjaer, A., Madsen, J.O. & Skrydstrup,
T. (1989). Glucosinolates in Bretschneideraceae.
Biochemical Systematics and Ecology 17:
375–379.
De Craene, L.P.R., Yang, T.Y.A., Schols, P. & Smets,
E.F. (2002). Floral anatomy and systematics of
Bretschneidera (Bretschneideraceae). Botanical
Journal of the Linnean Society 139: 29–45.
Doweld, B.A. (1996). The Carpology and Taxonomic
relationships of Bretschneidera
(Bretschneider-
aceae). Acta Botanica Malacitana 21: 79–90.
Gardner, S., Sirisunthorn, P. & Anusarnsunthorn, V.
(2007). A eld guide to Forest Trees of Northern
Thailand: 139. Kobfai publishing project,
Bangkok. p 139.
Hemsley, W.B. (1901). Bretschneidera sinensis.
Hooker’s Icones Plantarum 28: t. 2708.
Jin, H.Y., Ahn, T.H., Lee, H.J., Song, J.H., Lee, C.H.,
Kim, Y.J., Yoon, J.W., Chamg, K.S., Kang, H.S.,
Cheng, H.C., Park, J.H., Bang, M., Bouahom,
B., Phongoudome, C., Thammavong, V.,
Soukladeth, P., Bouamanivong, S., Phasaysombath,
T., Chanthavongsa, K., Lanorsavanh, S., Sayyalath,
S., Bounithiphonh, C. & Phonephanome, P.
(2016). A Checklist of Plants in Lao PDR. Korea
National Arboretum of the Korea Forest Service.
Kumar, V., Dash, S.S., Panday, S., Lahiri, S., Sinha,
B.K.
& Sihgh, P. (2017). Akaniaceae: a new family
record for ora of India and lectotypication of
the name Bretschneidera sinensis. Nelumbo
59(1): 1–9.
Lanorsavanh, S., Hughes, M., Souvannakhoummane,
K.
& Lamxay, V. (2020). Begonia phouchomvoy-
ensis
(Begoniaceae), a new species from Laos.
Taiwania 65(1): 37–40.
AKANIACEAE, A NEW FAMILY RECORD FOR LAOS (S. LANORSAVANH ET AL.) 235
Lanorsavanh, S., Souvannakhoummane, K., Kumar,
P., Gale, S.W., Lamxay, V., Bounphanmy, S. &
Chanthavongsa, K. (2019). Two new distribution
records of Odontochilus Blume (Orchidaceae)
from Laos. Thai Journal of Botany 11 (2):
85–93.
Lu, L.L. & Boufford, D.E. (2005). Bretschneideraceae.
In: C.Y. Wu & P.H. Raven (eds), Flora of China
8: 197. Science Press, Beijng; Missouri Botanical
Garden, St. Louis.
Newman, M., Ketphanh, S., Svengsuksa, B., Thomas,
P., Sengdala, K., Lamxay, V. & Armstrong, K.
(2007). A checklist of the vascular plants of Lao
PDR. Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh.
Niyomdham, C. (1991). Bretschneideraceae. In: T.
Smitinand & K. Larsen (eds), Flora of Thailand
5: 239–240. The Forest Herbarium, Bangkok.
Rodman, J.E. (1991). A taxonomic analysis of
glucosinnolate-producing plants. Part 1.
Phenetics. Systematic Botany 16: 589–618.
Rodman, J.E., Price, R.A., Karol, K., Conti, E.,
Sytsma, K.J. & Palmer, J.D. (1993). Nucleotide
sequences of the rbcL gene indicate monophyly
of mustard oil plants. Annals of the Missouri
Botanical Garden 80: 686–699.
Soltis, D.E., Soltis, P.S., Chase, M.W., Mort, M.E.,
Albach, K.C., Zanis, M., Savolainen, V., Hanh,
W.H., Hoot, S.B., Fay, M.F., Axtell, M., Swensen,
S.M., Prince, L.M., Kress, W.J., Nixon, K.C. &
Farris, J. (2000). Angiosperm phylogeny inferred
from 18S rDNA, rbcL, and atpB sequences.
Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society 133:
381–461.
Sun, W. (1998). Bretschneidera sinensis. The IUCN
Red List of Threatened Species 1998:
e.T32324A9697750. Downloaded on 08 October
2021.
Tobe, H. & Peng C.-I (1990). The embryology and
taxonomic relationships of Bretschneidera
(Bretschneideraceae). Botanical Journal of the
Linnean Society 103(2): 139–152.
Tobe, H. & Raven, P.H. 1995. Embryology and
relationships of Akania (Akaniaceae). Botanical
Journal of the Linnean Society 118: 261–274.
Wang, M.N., Duan, L., Qiao, Q., Wang, Z.F.,
Zimmer, E.A., Li, Z.C. & Chen, H.F. (2018).
Phylogeography and conservation genetics of
the rare and relict Bretschneidera sinensis
(Akaniaceae) PLOS ONE 13(1): e0189034.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Chapter
Full-text available
Begonia phouchomvoyensis, a new species from Phou Chom Voy Provincial Protected Area, Bolikhamxai province, Lao PDR, is described and illustrated. It is placed in Begonia sect. Platycentrum, and is assessed as belonging to the Vulnerable IUCN Category.
Article
Full-text available
Bretschneidera sinensis, a class-I protected wild plant in China, is a relic of the ancient Tertiary tropical flora endemic to Asia. However, little is known about its genetics and phylogeography. To elucidate the current phylogeographic patterns and infer the historical population dynamics of B. sinensis, and to make recommendations for its conservation, three non-coding regions of chloroplast DNA (trnQ-rps16, rps8-rps11, and trnT-trnL) were amplified and sequenced across 256 individuals from 23 populations of B. sinensis, spanning 10 provinces of China. We recognized 13 haplotypes, demonstrating relatively high total haplotype diversity (hT = 0.739). Almost all of the variation existed among populations (98.09%, P < 0.001), but that within populations was low (1.91%, P < 0.001). Strong genetic differentiation was detected among populations (GST = 0.855, P < 0.001) with limited estimations of seed flow (Nm = 0.09), indicating that populations were strongly isolated from one another. According to SAMOVA analysis, populations of B. sinensis in China could be divided into five geographic groups: (1) eastern Yunnan to western Guangxi; (2) Guizhou-Hunan-Hubei; (3) central Guangdong; (4) northwestern Guangdong; and (5) the Luoxiao-Nanling-Wuyi -Yangming Mountain. Network analysis showed that the most ancestral haplotypes were located in the first group, i.e., the eastern Yungui Plateau and in eastern Yunnan, which is regarded as a putative glacial refugia for B. sinensis in China. B. sinensis may have expanded its range eastward from these refugia and experienced bottleneck or founder effects in southeastern China. Populations in Liping (Guizhou Province), Longsheng (Guangxi Province), Huizhou (Guangdong Province), Chongyi (Jiangxi Province), Dong-an (Hunan Province), Pingbian (Yunnan Province) and Xinning (Hunan Province) are proposed as the priority protection units.
Article
Full-text available
Bretschneidera sinensis Hemsley, an IUCN Red Listed Endangered tree species has been collected from Namdapha National Park and Tiger Reserve, Arunachal Pradesh, India which constitutes the first distributional record of the monotypic genus Bretschneidera and the family Akaniaceae in India. Lectotypification of the name Bretschneidera sinensis proposed here along with detailed taxonomic account of the species.
Article
Descriptions, updated distribution data, conservation status and illustrations of two newly recorded orchids, Odontochilus elwesii and O. putaoensis are provided. An identifi cation key to all four species of Odontochilus now known to occur in Laos is also provided.
Article
An update of the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group (APG) classification of the orders and families of angiosperms is presented. Several new orders are recognized: Boraginales, Dilleniales, Icacinales, Metteniusiales and Vahliales. This brings the total number of orders and families recognized in the APG system to 64 and 416, respectively. We propose two additional informal major clades, superrosids and superasterids, that each comprise the additional orders that are included in the larger clades dominated by the rosids and asterids. Families that made up potentially monofamilial orders, Dasypogonaceae and Sabiaceae, are instead referred to Arecales and Proteales, respectively. Two parasitic families formerly of uncertain positions are now placed: Cynomoriaceae in Saxifragales and Apodanthaceae in Cucurbitales. Although there is evidence that some families recognized in APG III are not monophyletic, we make no changes in Dioscoreales and Santalales relative to APG III and leave some genera in Lamiales unplaced (e.g. Peltanthera). These changes in familial circumscription and recognition have all resulted from new results published since APG III, except for some changes simply due to nomenclatural issues, which include substituting Asphodelaceae for Xanthorrhoeaceae (Asparagales) and Francoaceae for Melianthaceae (Geraniales); however, in Francoaceae we also include Bersamaceae, Ledocarpaceae, Rhynchothecaceae and Vivianiaceae. Other changes to family limits are not drastic or numerous and are mostly focused on some members of the lamiids, especially the former Icacinaceae that have long been problematic with several genera moved to the formerly monogeneric Metteniusaceae, but minor changes in circumscription include Aristolochiaceae (now including Lactoridaceae and Hydnoraceae; Aristolochiales), Maundiaceae (removed from Juncaginaceae; Alismatales), Restionaceae (now re-including Anarthriaceae and Centrolepidaceae; Poales), Buxaceae (now including Haptanthaceae; Buxales), Peraceae (split from Euphorbiaceae; Malpighiales), recognition of Petenaeaceae (Huerteales), Kewaceae, Limeaceae, Macarthuriaceae and Microteaceae (all Caryophyllales), Petiveriaceae split from Phytolaccaceae (Caryophyllales), changes to the generic composition of Ixonanthaceae and Irvingiaceae (with transfer of Allantospermum from the former to the latter; Malpighiales), transfer of Pakaraimaea (formerly Dipterocarpaceae) to Cistaceae (Malvales), transfer of Borthwickia, Forchhammeria, Stixis and Tirania (formerly all Capparaceae) to Resedaceae (Brassicales), Nyssaceae split from Cornaceae (Cornales), Pteleocarpa moved to Gelsemiaceae (Gentianales), changes to the generic composition of Gesneriaceae (Sanango moved from Loganiaceae) and Orobanchaceae (now including Lindenbergiaceae and Rehmanniaceae) and recognition of Mazaceae distinct from Phrymaceae (all Lamiales).
Article
Nucleotide sequences for the chloroplast rbcL gene were obtained from representatives of 11 of the 15 plant families known to produce glucosinolates (mustard oil glucosides). Parsimony analyses indicate that these constitute two widely separated groups and thus imply two independent origins of the mustard oil/myrosin cell syndrome. A strongly supported, major group comprises the mustard family Brassicaceae and its near relatives Capparaceae, Resedaceae, and Tovariaceae along with such morphologically diverse taxa as Bataceae, Bretschneideraceae, Caricaceae, Limnanthaceae, Moringaceae, and Tropaeolaceae. The second mustard oil group is restricted to the euphorbiaceous genus Drypetes. Akania, the subject of an independent rbcL analysis, pairs with Bretschneidera, and these are collateral with Tropaeolum at the base of the major mustard oil clade. Gyrostemonaceae, Pentadiplandra, and Salvadoraceae have not been analyzed for rbcL sequences. The gene data corroborate many aspects of Rodman's recent cladistic analysis based predominantly on morphological characters; together the molecular and morphological evidence support Dahlgren's radical classification of an expanded order Capparales.
Article
Similarities among taxa of glucosinolate-producing plants and putative relatives were evaluated using numerical methods applied to a dataset of 93 characters. These include anatomical and morphological (vegetative and reproductive), chromosomal, palynological, phytochemical, and ultrastructural features. Principal components and coordinates analyses reveal considerable complexity, hence little redundancy in this dataset. Cluster analyses show that glucosinolate taxa as a whole are not phenetically coherent. With or without glucosinolate characters included in the analyses, a core capparalean group comprises Brassicaceae, Capparaceae, Resedaceae, and Tovariaceae, to which are linked the non-glucosinolate Koeberlinia and the families Bataceae, Gyrostemonaceae, and Salvadoraceae but not Moringaceae. Based on a sparser dataset, Drypetes clusters with Euphorbiaceae; Akania and Bretschneidera cluster together but not close to Sapindaceae; Pentadiplandru is too poorly known to be placed with confidence. Caricaceae, Limnanthaceae, Moringaceae, and Tropaeolaceae remain problematic.
Article
TOBE, H. & PENG, C.-I, 1990. The embryology and taxonomic relationships of Bretschneidera (Bretschneideraceae). We present the first report on the embryology of Bretschneidera, the only genus of Bretschneideraceae (which are one of 15 glucosinolate-producing families), to clarify its relationships. Embryologically Bretschneidera is characterized by the following features: ovule campylotropous, bitegmic and crassinucellate; outer integument thick, multiplicative and vascularized; embryo sac formation of the Allium type; seed exalbuminous; seed coat ‘exotestal’ with a palisade of columellar, thick-walled exotestal cells; mesotesta thick with the inner half aerenchymatous. These features suggest that Bretschneidera is distinct from any of the taxonomically related families but resembles both Hippocastanaceae and Sapindaceae (Sapindales) more closely than Moringaceae or Capparaceae (Capparales) which have been considered alternative allies, supporting most of the modern taxonomic treatments that place Bretschneidera as a separate family in Sapindales.
Article
We present the first extensive study of embryology of Akania, the only genus of Akaniaceae (one of the 15 glucosinolate-producing families). Akania has a distinctive combination of embryological features, which includes bitegmic and crassinucellate ovules; thick, multiplicative and vascularized outer integument; a Polygonum-type embryo sac; albuminous seed; ‘exotestal’ seed coat with a palisade of columellar, thick-walled cells and a thick and sclerotic mesotesta with the inner tissue aerenchymatous. A comparison of its embryological characteristics with those of some other groups indicates that Akania closely resembles Bretschneideraceae (another glucosinolate-producing family) and Sapindaceae, but it retains some archaic embryological features and is best treated as a separate family in or near Sapindales, as in most modern general classifications. Based on evidence from embryological and other data, Akaniaceae appear to be the sister group of Bretschneideraceae, possibly near to Sapindales. With the data at hand, we cannot fully assess the recent suggestion that Akaniaceae-Bretschneideraceae are a basal group in Capparales.