Content uploaded by Greg J. Strimel
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Greg J. Strimel on Sep 26, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
36 technology and engineering teacher October 2021
by Viranga Perera, Greg J. Strimel, and
Alejandra J. Magana
engineering in action
using
Aladdin as
a tool to
empower
engineering
learning
With the publication of the Framework for P-12
Engineering Learning, engineering will hopefully
become more prominent and equitable across
secondary education in the coming years.
Introduction
Engineering learning, a three-dimensional construct that includes
Engineering Habits of Mind, Engineering Practices, and Engi-
neering Knowledge, has been well established and defined at the
post-secondary level (Reed, 2018). Meanwhile, engineering within
pre-kindergarten through 12th grade (P-12) classrooms continues
to grow steadily. Changes introduced by A Framework for K-12
Science Education (National Research Council, 2012) and Next
Generation Science Standards (NGSS Lead States, 2013) have
started to place engineering within secondary science educa-
tion, just as the inclusion of engineering design in Standards for
Technological Literacy did within technology education class-
rooms at the turn of the century (International Technology and
Engineering Educators Association, 2000/2002/2007). More and
more students are now exposed to engineering learning prior to
graduating from high school in a variety of courses like technol-
ogy, science, and career/technical education classrooms, as well
as informal learning programs. Nevertheless, engineering in its
own right often remains a missing or minimal component of the
learning experience for many students (Change the Equation,
2016; Miaoulis, 2010). To include engineering in a more prominent
manner, the Framework for P-12 Engineering Learning (2020)
has recently been published as a practical guide for developing
coherent, authentic, and equitable engineering learning programs
across schools. This guidance includes a definition of the three
dimensions of engineering learning, principles for pedagogical
practice, and common learning goals. The framework can support
the development of in-depth and authentic engineering learning
initiatives and provide building blocks toward the 2020 Standards
for Technological and Engineering Literacy. As a component of
the framework, engineering practices are detailed by describing
core concepts that can support performing these practices with
increased sophistication over time. Examples include making
data-informed design decisions based on material properties and
employing computational tools to analyze data to assess and op-
timize designs. In this Engineering in Action article, we introduce
a freely available, open-source computer-aided design (CAD)
software called Aladdin and discuss how it can support authentic
engineering practice within secondary classrooms. Earlier works
have suggested that Aladdin is an eective tool for implementing
Next Generation Science Standards (e.g., Chao et al., 2018; Gold-
stein, Loy, & Purzer, 2017). Similarly, we make a case for using
October 2021 technology and engineering teacher 37
Aladdin in secondary engineering education and discuss how
recommendations of the Framework for P-12 Engineering Learning
map to specific features of the software.
What is Aladdin?
Aladdin (formerly known as Energy3D) is a freely available, open-
source CAD program that has been developed specifically to
help students learn about designing energy-eicient buildings
and renewable energy solutions (Xie, Schimpf, Chao, Nourian, &
Massicotte, 2018). It also allows education researchers to study
actions that students perform within the platform (e.g., Seah &
Magana, 2019; Vieira, Seah, & Magana, 2018). Since the software
is easy to use and has built-in tutorials, students can quickly learn
how to model a simple building (e.g., see Figure 1). They can then
start to do analyses to understand if their designs meet their needs
(e.g., being within a certain budget and being an energy-neutral
building). Aladdin can be downloaded for free on both Mac and
Windows computers from the following website: https://intofuture.
org/aladdin.html. The development of a cloud-based version is
currently underway to make it even more powerful and accessible.
Is Aladdin an Eective Teaching Tool?
Previous education research suggests that Aladdin is an eective
tool for helping secondary education students specifically to learn
important engineering concepts. Goldstein, Omar, Purzer, & Adams
(2018) found that middle school students benefited by working on
a design project using Aladdin; importantly, even if their projects
were relatively simple. Furthermore, in their study, also with middle
school students, Dasgupta, Magana, & Vieira (2019) showed that
Aladdin helped students to learn principles of thermodynamics and
heat, and allowed them to perform systematic experimentation to
create better building designs. Magana et al. (in press) demonstrat-
ed dierent learning activities enabled by Aladdin within middle
school, high school, and pre-service teacher classrooms. They
found that students in all classrooms increased their conceptual
understanding of thermodynamics. Students in those classrooms
also produced feasible designs (i.e., met the design criteria and
were energy eicient).
How Can Aladdin Be Used With the New
Engineering Framework?
The Framework for P-12 Engineering Learning describes engineering
learning as being composed of three areas: Engineering Habits of
Mind, Engineering Practice, and Engineering Knowledge. We will
illustrate how Aladdin can be used to teach students each of these
areas within engineering learning.
Engineering Habits of Mind
Engineering Habits of Mind consist of optimism, persistence, collab-
oration, creativity, conscientiousness, and systems thinking. While
Engineering Habits of Mind should be modeled through specific
teaching practices, Aladdin can still help promote these habits.
Specifically, students can learn about systems thinking by model-
ing buildings within Aladdin. They can understand how designing
a building requires both identifying important components of a
building system (e.g., location, size, and energy) and quantifying
how those components interact with one another. Considering that
almost all contemporary engineering now relies on the extensive
use of CAD tools, early introduction of CAD concepts and usage in
P-12 education may foster engineering habits of mind in an even
more practical sense.
Engineering Practice
Engineering Practice involves engineering design, material process-
ing, quantitative analysis, and professionalism. Each of these com-
ponents of Engineering Practice involves a number of skills. Here
we will demonstrate how Aladdin can help students learn skills for
each component listed above.
Engineering design involves a number of skills such as problem
framing, information gathering, ideation, engineering graphics,
design communication, and decision making. We will particularly
focus on decision making, as Aladdin has built-in analysis tools to
help students make better design decisions. After students have
modeled a building, they can quickly perform an annual energy
analysis to determine the net energy usage of their building. Figure
2 shows an example annual energy analysis with net energy shown
in circular orange markers and connected by a thick black line.
The annual energy analysis tool allows students to quantify which
months of the year require more energy. They will additionally be
able to identify components of their building that require significant
energy and try to mitigate that energy use. Since the annual energy
analysis tool only takes a few seconds or a few minutes to run,
students can easily explore how changes to their building design
aect the energy use of the building.
In real-world engineering projects, engineers need to account for
material properties such as thermal, mechanical, and electrical
characteristics. The material processing component of Engineer-
ing Practice involves a number of skills such as manufacturing,
measurement and precision, fabrication, casting/molding/forming,
separating/machining, joining, conditioning/finishing, safety, and
Figure 1.
An example house in Aladdin
38 technology and engineering teacher October 2021
material classification. While it is a CAD software, presently Aladdin
does not easily allow fabrication, for example, by sending CAD
designs to a 3D printer (though it supports printing out 2D pieces
for assembling into 3D structures). Nevertheless, students can still
use the software to learn about material classification. Students can
explore how changing material properties (e.g., thermal insulation
of building walls) may aect the overall building design. Aladdin
allows students to set either the U-value or R-value for one or more
walls of a building (see Figure 3). The U-value is the overall heat
coeicient of a material and has units of W/m2 ·°C. In the case of a
hot summer day or a cold winter night, an ideal house should have
low U-values for its walls to minimize thermal energy transferring
through them. A low U-value will keep the inside of the building
insulated, thus allowing it to be cooler inside in the summer and
warmer in the winter. Alternatively, instead of setting the U-val-
ue, students can set the
R-value. The R-value is a
measure of the resistance
to heat conduction and
has units of h·ft2 ·°F/BTU.
As part of their building
design, students can
explore setting dierent
insulation values (either U-
or R-values), they can look
up typical insulation values
for real building construc-
tion materials, and they
can explore the consequences of setting dierent insulation values
for dierent walls to factor for solar irradiance.
Quantitative analysis involves a number of skills such as compu-
tational thinking, data collection, analysis and communication,
system analytics, modeling and simulation, and computational
tools. By the nature of the CAD software, Aladdin is ideal for teach-
ing all of these skills, but here we will particularly focus on how it
can help teach students to use computational tools. Aladdin allows
students to model buildings in a specific location (e.g., Indianapolis,
Indiana). Students can use the heliodon feature to visually study the
Sun’s path through the sky as a function of time (see Figure 4). In
the case of Indianapolis, since the city is located nearly 40 degrees
north of the equator, students will notice that the Sun’s path is
lower in the sky in the winter and higher in the summer. They can,
Figure 2.
The Aladdin built-in annual
energy analysis tool showing
energy use (in kWh) for various
components of a modeled
building as a function of
time (in months). The figure
has been modified from the
Aladdin output to improve
readability by increasing the
marker and font sizes and by
using colorblind safe colors
(electronic version only).
Figure 3.
Wall insulation can be
modified for buildings
in Aladdin
October 2021 technology and engineering teacher 39
for example, then think about how their building designs can take
advantage of the Sun’s path to maintain a certain temperature
throughout the year.
The final component of Engineering Practice is professionalism,
which involves a number of skills such as professional ethics,
workplace behavior/operations, honoring intellectual property, the
role of society in technological development, engineering-related
careers, and technological impacts. Since Aladdin allows students
to model buildings and to analyze them for their energy eiciency,
the software naturally lends itself to a discussion about technologi-
cal impacts, particularly impacts on the environment. Constructing
and operating buildings produces significant amounts of carbon di-
oxide emissions. In 2017, buildings accounted for 39% of the world’s
carbon dioxide emissions (Abergel, Dean, Dulac, & Hamilton, 2018).
Given that buildings are a significant contributor to climate change,
we need to both make current buildings more sustainable and
improve future building designs. Aladdin can help teach our youth
to be mindful of the impact that buildings have on the environment
and to work towards mitigating those negative eects.
Engineering Knowledge
Engineering Knowledge involves engineering sciences, engi-
neering mathematics, and engineering technical applications.
We will focus here on engineering sciences and engineering
technical applications.
Engineering sciences include statics, mechanics of materials,
dynamics, fluid mechanics, mass transfer and separation, chemical
reaction and catalysis, circuit theory, thermodynamics, and heat.
Aladdin can help students learn concepts in both thermodynamics
and heat. A lesson on the first law of thermodynamics would be a
good introduction to students using Aladdin. Students would then
use the software with the knowledge that maintaining a comfort-
able temperature inside a building (i.e., no change in its internal en-
ergy) means that the building needs to have no net heat (assuming
of course, there is no thermodynamic work done on the building).
Students can use the heat flux visualization tool in Aladdin (see
Figure 5) to understand how certain parts of a building have higher
heat fluxes (windows in this particular case) and can think about
ways in which thermal energy exchange between the inside of a
building and the outside environment can be minimized.
Engineering technical applications include concepts such as me-
chanical design, structural analysis, hydrologic systems, geotech-
nics, environmental considerations, and electrical power. Given that
Aladdin allows students to easily add solar panels onto their model
buildings, it is a convenient place to teach students about electrical
power generation. This is also a relevant topic to students since we,
as a society, will likely be using more solar power for our electri-
cal power generation in the coming years and decades. When a
student places a solar panel, they will have a number of options to
alter properties such as the model of the solar panel (e.g., ASP-
Figure 4.
Heliodon feature in Aladdin allows students to analyze energy use based on the Sun’s path across the sky
40 technology and engineering teacher October 2021
400M, CS6X-330M-FG, and FS-275), size, cell type (e.g., polycrys-
talline, monocrystalline, and thin film), cell eiciency, and inverter
eiciency (see Figure 6). Cell eiciency is defined as the fraction
of incident solar energy that is converted by the cell to electrical
energy. While solar energy is freely available, students may be
interested to learn that a contemporary limiting factor for solar
energy production is cell eiciency. Even today, the most eicient
solar cells tend to be under 40% eicient (Green et al., 2020). While
certain solar panel parameters are limited by current technology,
students can explore ways to alter the number, size, and orientation
of solar panels to increase electrical power production.
Conclusions
With the publication of
the Framework for P-12
Engineering Learning,
engineering will hopefully
become more prominent
and equitable across
secondary education in
the coming years. As this
occurs, teachers will need
eective tools to help
them teach engineering
concepts to students in an
authentic manner. Here
we demonstrate how a
freely available, open-
source CAD program can
serve that purpose. By doing so, we hope that we have provided
some examples and ideas for teachers to empower engineering
learning within their classrooms in authentic and rigorous ways.
In addition, this tool may provide options for teachers to continue
their instruction virtually in times of interruption, such as during
the COVID-19 pandemic.
Acknowledgments
We thank Charles Xie for developing Aladdin and Cynthia A. Brew-
er (Penn State) for the Color Brewer tool (https://colorbrewer2.org)
that helped us select colorblind-safe colors for Figure 2. The re-
search reported in this paper was supported in part by the U.S. Na-
tional Science Foundation (NSF) under the award DRL #1503436.
This content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not
necessarily represent the oicial views of the NSF.
References
Abergel, T., Dean, B., Dulac, J., & Hamilton, I. (2018). 2018 Global
Status Report: Towards a Zero-Emission, Eicient, and Re-
silient Buildings and Construction Sector. Global Alliance for
Buildings and Construction. www.worldgbc.org/sites/default/
files/2018%20GlobalABC%20Global%20Status%20Report.pdf
Advancing Excellence in P-12 Engineering Education & American
Society of Engineering Education (2020). Framework for P-12
engineering learning: A defined and cohesive educational foun-
dation for P-12 engineering. American Society of Engineering
Education. https://doi.org/10.18260/1-100-1153-1.
Change the Equation. (2016). Left to chance: U.S. middle schoolers lack
in-depth experience with technology and engineering. Vital Signs.
www.ecs.org/wp-content/uploads/TEL-Report_0.pdf
Figure 5.
Heat flux vectors demonstrating more energy loss through windows
than walls of the building
Figure 6.
Options to change solar panel
parameters in Aladdin
October 2021 technology and engineering teacher 41
Chao, J., Xie, C., Massicotte, J., Schimpf, C., Lockwood, J., Huang, X.,
& Beaulieu, C. (2018). Solarize Your School. The Science Teach-
er, 86(4), 40-47. www.jstor.org/stable/26611994
Dasgupta, C., Magana, A. J., & Vieira, C. (2019). Investigating the
aordances of a CAD enabled learning environment for pro-
moting integrated STEM learning. Computers & Education, 129,
122-142. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2018.10.014
Goldstein, M., Loy, B., & Purzer, Ş. (2017). Designing a sustainable
neighborhood. Science Scope, 41(1), 32. www.nsta.org/sci-
ence-scope/science-scope-september-2017/designing-sus-
tainable-neighborhood-interdisciplinary
Goldstein, M. H., Omar, S. A., Purzer, S., & Adams, R. S. (2018).
Comparing two approaches to engineering design in the 7th
grade science classroom. International Journal of Education
in Mathematics, Science and Technology, 6(4), 381-397. www.
ijemst.org/index.php/ijemst/article/view/280
Green, M. A., Dunlop, E. D., Hohl‐Ebinger, J., Yoshita, M., Kopidakis,
N., & Ho‐Baillie, A. W. (2020). Solar cell eiciency tables (Ver-
sion 55). Progress in Photovoltaics: Research and Applications,
28(1), 3-15. https://doi.org/10.1002/pip.3228
International Technology and Engineering Educators Association
(ITEA/ITEEA). (2000/2002/2007). Standards for technologi-
cal literacy: Content for the study of technology. Reston, VA:
Author.
International Technology and Engineering Educators Association
(ITEEA). (2020). Standards for technological and engineering
literacy: The role of technology and engineering in STEM edu-
cation. www.iteea.org/STEL.aspx.
Magana, A.J., Chiu, J., Seah, Y.Y., Bywater, J.P., Schimpf, C., Karabi-
yik, T., Rebello, S., & Xie, C. (2021). Classroom orchestration of
computer simulations for science and engineering learning: a
multiple-case study approach. International Journal of Science
Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2021.1902589
Miaoulis, I. (2010). K-12 engineering: the missing core discipline. In
Grasso D., Burkins M.B. (eds) Holistic Engineering Education.
Springer, New York, NY. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-
1393-7_4.
National Research Council. (2012). A Framework for K-12 Science
Education: Practices, Crosscutting Concepts, and Core Ideas.
Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. https://doi.
org/10.17226/13165
NGSS Lead States. (2013). Next Generation Science Standards: For
States, By States. Washington, DC: The National Academies
Press. www.nextgenscience.org/
Reed, P. A. (2018). Reflections on STEM, standards, and disciplinary
focus. Technology and Engineering Teacher, 7 7(7), 16-20.
Seah, Y. Y., & Magana, A. J. (2019). Exploring students’ experimen-
tation strategies in engineering design using an educational
CAD tool. Journal of Science Education and Technology, 28(3),
195-208. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10956-018-9757-x
Vieira, C., Seah, Y. Y., & Magana, A. J. (2018). Students’ experimen-
tation strategies in design: Is process data enough?. Com-
puter Applications in Engineering Education, 26(5), 1903-1914.
https://doi.org/10.1002/cae.22025
Xie, C, Schimpf, C, Chao, J, Nourian, S, & Massicotte, J. (2018).
Learning and teaching engineering design through modeling
and simulation on a CAD platform. Computer Applications in
Engineering Education, 26, 824-840. https://doi.org/10.1002/
cae.21920
Viranga Perera, Ph.D., is a postdoctoral
researcher at Purdue University (West Lafayette,
IN). He can be reached at viranga@purdue.edu.
Greg J. Strimel, Ph.D., is an assistant
professor of technology leadership and
innovation at Purdue University (West Lafayette,
IN). He can be reached at gstrimel@purdue.edu.
Alejandra J. Magana, Ph.D., is the W.C. Furnas
Professor in Enterprise Excellence at Purdue
University (West Lafayette, IN). She can be
reached at admagana@purdue.edu.
This is a refereed article.
ESCape the ordinary and join ITEEA’s Elementary
STEM Council! The Elementary STEM Council
(formerly ITEEA’s Children’s Council) oers
resources, lessons, news, and more about
programs in elementary STEM around the world.
Membership includes a subscription to
The Elementary STEM Journal,
a dynamic, practical journal for anyone interested
in STEM literacy in Grades K-6.
Learn more and join today at
www.iteea.org/ESC.aspx