Content uploaded by J. Marvin Herndon
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by J. Marvin Herndon on Sep 16, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
!
! !
!"#$%&'()*%)+,&*$-)+&*'%&'().'('$/&0)1,2/%$-)3)4,-5)67)8,5)9)
:2;-*&$<*,%)=$<'>!"#$%#&'#(!)*+!),)-!
=?@.-,/-01234566(7/38/-,3*-/!
Herndon, J. M., Williams, D. D., & Whiteside, M. (2021). Ancient Giant Sequoias Are Dying: Scientists Refuse to Acknowledge the
Cause. Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal, 8(9). 57-70.
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
!
!
!!
Ancient!Giant!Sequoias!Are!Dying:!Scientists!Refuse!to!
Acknowledge!the!Cause!
!!
15)A$/#*%)B'/%",%7):05=5)
9(5:6;<:#!=>($>(5%?>:!
--,00!@#;!@>AB!C(?D#+!"5:!C?#E>+!=F!8)-2-!G"F!
!
=$-')=5)C*--*$D(7)A5+5)
H-*1!=>D#:%(<!C(?D#+!"I5(%J!=(##B+!KL!03012!G"F!
!
A$/E)C0*<'(*"'7)A5=57)A5:5B5)
MN>(?;5!C#$5(%&#:%!>O!P#5N%Q!
--,,!"?&>:%>:!"%(##%+!R#<!S#6%+!MT!22,0,!G"F!
)
ABSTRACT!
California’s! Giant! Sequoias! and! Coast! Redwoods,! long! symbols! of! strength,!
longevity,!and!resilience,!have!survived!natural!climate!change!for!as!long!as!3,000!
years,!but!are!now!succumbing!to!human!manipulation!of!the!natural!environment.!
Scientists! concerned! with! the! wellbeing! of! these! magnificent! trees! blame! their!
recent!die-offs!on!climate!change,!drought,!and!insects!while!turning!a!blind!eye!to!
the!primary!underlying!cause:!environmental!modification!by!jet-emplacement!in!
the! troposphere! of! toxic! particles! evidenced! as! coal! combustion! fly! ash.! Said!
aerosolized! particulates! cause! droughts! and! deluges,! heat! the! troposphere,!
contaminate! rain,! snow,! and! fog! with! plant-killing! toxins! including! chemically-
mobile! aluminum,! coat! foliage,! and! exacerbate! forest! fires.! The! aerial! spraying!
depletes!stratospheric! ozone,!allowing! damaging!ultraviolet! radiation!B! and!C! to!
reach!Earth’s!surface.!These!environmental!stressors!weaken!the!trees!to!the!point!
they!are!attacked!by!insects!and!pathogenic!fungi.!Here!we!disclose!the!unspoken,!
underlying!cause!of!the!die-offs!of!Giant!Sequoias!and!Coast!Redwoods.!Through!a!
diabolically-deceptive,! Trojan' horse,! United! Nations’! International! Treaty! the!
governments! of! sovereign! nations! were! coerced! to! wage! environmental! warfare!
against!their!own!citizens!and!the!natural!environment!under!the!guise!of!peaceful!
environmental!modification.!Remaining!trees,!and!indeed!much!of!the!life!on!Earth,!
can!only!be!saved!if!this!environmental!modification!is!halted.!
)
@8F.?=GHF@?8)
9Q#! U?5:%! "#VW>?5+! Sequoiadendron+ giganteum+! E(>I6! >:! %Q#! I#6%#(:! 6N>$#! >O! %Q#! "?#((5!
X#D5;5/!9Q#!(#N5%#;!=5N?O>(:?5!=>56%!@#;I>>;+!Sequoia+sempervirens+!E(>I6!?:!5!:5((>I!'5:;!
5N>:E!%Q#!Y5A?O?A! =>56%! >O! %Q#!G:?%#;!"%5%#6/!9Q#!AW((#:%!;#&?6#!>O!%Q#6#!5:A?#:%+!&5E:?O?A#:%!
%(##6!?6!W6W5NN<!5%%(?'W%#;!%>!;(>WEQ%+!5%&>6$Q#(?A!I5(&?:E+!5:;!?:O#6%5%?>:+!#6$#A?5NN<!'<!'5(B!
'##%N#6!Z-+!)[/!"#VW>?5!O>N?5E#!;(>$!566>A?5%#;!I?%Q! ;(>WEQ%! I56! :>%?A#;!?:! ),-0+!Q>I#D#(+!5!
6#5(AQ!>O! %Q#! N?%#(5%W(#!(#D#5N#;! %Q5%!%Q5%! 566>A?5%?>:! Q5;!:>%! '##:!$(#D?>W6N<! >'6#(D#;! Z-[/!
9Q5%!I56!%Q#!65&#!<#5(!%Q5%!#\A#66?D#!AQ#&%(5?N!5A%?D?%<!?:!=5N?O>(:?5!'#A5&#!5!A>:A#(:!>O!>:#!
>O!%Q#!5W%Q>(6!]^KP_/!
!
!
!
58!
6*78(9:(;''/"(<:(!"=0"5>"#?@A@B!
C-$,+&"'(%+(!*&%,7(!&%"+&"'(D"'",#&E(F*/#+,7(GC!!DFH!
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
K5:<!>O!%Q#6#! &57#6%?A! %(##6!Q5D#!6W(D?D#;!;(>WEQ%6! 5:;! ?:O#6%5%?>:!>D#(!$#(?>;6!>O! %?&#! 56!
N>:E!56!2+,,,!<#5(6/!F!(#56>:5'N#!6A?#:%?6%!&?EQ%!56B+!`SQ<!:>I!?O!:>%!'#O>(#ab+!`SQ5%!A5W65N!
5E#:%6!5(#!'#?:E!6<6%#&5%?A5NN<!?E:>(#;ab!5:;!`SQ5%!5(#!%Q#!A>:6#VW#:A#6!O>(!>%Q#(!6$#A?#6ab!
"#D#:%<! <#5(6! >O! E>D#(:&#:%! 6A?#:%?O?A! (#6#5(AQcOW:;?:E! ;#A?6?>:6+! &5;#! >:! %Q#! '56?6! >O!
5:>:<&>W6!$##(c(#D?#I6!'<!A>&$#%?%>(6+!Q56!N#;!%>!5!A>:6#:6W6c>:N<!$5(5;?E&/!M#5(!>O!'#?:E!
;#:>W:A#;!?:!6#A(#%!(#D?#I6+!I?%Q!A>:A>&?%5:%!A5(##(!;5&5E#!>(!7>'!N>66+!B##$6!6A?#:%?6%6!O(>&!
AQ5NN#:E?:E!%Q#!A>:6#:6W6c5$$(>D#;!6%>(<cN?:#/!9Q5%!?6!:>%!6A?#:A#!5%!5NN/!"A?#:A#!?6!5'>W%!%#NN?:E!
%Q#!%(W%Q+!O?:;?:E!IQ5%!?6!I(>:E!I?%Q!$(#6#:%!$#(A#$%?>:6+!5:;!A>((#A%?:E!%Q#&/!=56#!?:!$>?:%+!
%Q#! ;#N?'#(5%#! 7#%c6$(5<#;! $5(%?AWN5%#c$>NNW%?>:+! 6>&#%?! (#O#((#;! %>! 56! chemtrails+!
?NNW6%(5%#;!?:!M?EW(#6!-!5:;!)/!
!
!
Figure!1.!Deliberate!aerosol!particulate!pollution!(chemtrails)!above!Yosemite!National!Park,!
California,!USA!in!2016,!one!of!the!locations!where!Giant!Sequoias!grow.!Courtesy!of!Christoph!
Bengtsson!Lissalde.!
!
!
!
!
!
!
59!
Herndon, J. M., Williams, D. D., & Whiteside, M. (2021). Ancient Giant Sequoias Are Dying: Scientists Refuse to Acknowledge the Cause. Advances
in Social Sciences Research Journal, 8(9). 57-70.
URL:%E00=IJJ-K8-*%8*#4JBA8BLMN9J,''#O89<8BA9PB!
!
Figure!2.!Dead!Coast!Redwood!standing!among!apparently!healthy!trees!in!Redwoods!National!
Park!in!Northern!California!USA.!Photo!in!2020,!courtesy!of!Eric!Cooper.!Note!the!white!haze!in!
the!sky!which!is!characteristic!of!dispersed!chemtrail!coal!fly!ash.!
!
^#%c#&$N5A#;!$5(%?AWN5%#!%(5?N6!Q5D#!'##:!>'6#(D#;!%>!'#!?:A(#56?:E!?:! O(#VW#:A<+!E#>E(5$Q?A!
(5:E#+!5:;!?:%#:6?%<!O>(!&>(#!%Q5:!%I>!;#A5;#6/!d?5!L:%#(:#%!$>6%?:E6!5:;!6>A?5N!&#;?5+!A?%?J#:6!
Q5D#!#\$(#66#;!A>:A#(:!56!%>!IQ5%!?6!'#?:E!6$(5<#;+!IQ<+!5:;!%Q#!A>:6#VW#:A#6!>:!QW&5:!5:;!
#:D?(>:&#:%5N!Q#5N%Q/!e%Q#(!%Q5:!'N5%5:%!#OO>(%6!%>!;#A#?D#!A?%?J#:6!Z2[+!6A?#:%?6%6!Z0+!*[!5:;!%Q#!
$W'N?A!Q#5N%Q!A>&&W:?%<!ZH[+!%Q#!6A?#:%?O?A!A>&&W:?%<+!I?%Q!>:#!#\A#$%?>:!Z1[+!?E:>(#6!%Q#!D#(<c
>'D?>W6!AQ#&%(5?N!5665WN%6!>:!%Q#!:5%W(5N!#:D?(>:&#:%!IQ?AQ!I#!;#6A(?'#;!?:!:W&#(>W6!$##(c
(#D?#I#;!6A?#:%?O?A!5:;!&#;?A5N!5(%?AN#6!Z3c0)[/!
!
9>!%Q#!'#6%!>O! >W(! B:>IN#;E#+! 6A?#:%?6%6! A>:A#(:#;! I?%Q!A5W6#6!>O!;#5%Q!>O!%Q#!U?5:%!"#VW>?5!
5:;! =5N?O>(:?5! =>56%! @#;I>>;! %(##6! ;>! :>%! &#:%?>:! >(! 5AB:>IN#;E#! %Q#! A>:6#VW#:A#6! >O!
;#N?'#(5%#!5#(>6>N!$5(%?AWN5%#!$>NNW%?>:!]AQ#&%(5?N6_!56!A5W65%?D#!5E#:%6!?:!%Q#!;#&?6#!>O!%Q#6#!
5:A?#:%! E?5:%6/! fW%! %Q#<! 6Q>WN;/! F6! I#! (#D?#I! Q#(#+! AQ#&%(5?N6! A5W6#! ;(>WEQ%6+! Q#5%! %Q#!
5%&>6$Q#(#+!5:;! 5N%#(!%Q#! :5%W(5N!#:D?(>:&#:%! ?:!I5<6! %Q5%!I#5B#:! (#6?6%5:A#!%>! $5%Q>E#:!
?:O#6%5%?>:6/!!
!
=IJ@KI.!FI)!I.?+?J):!.F@HGJ!FI):?JJGF@?8)LHBIAF.!@J+M)
=>:A#(:#;!A?%?J#:6!Q5;!6%5(%#;!%>!:>%?A#!IQ?%#!%(5?N6!%Q5%!6%(#%AQ#;!5A(>66!%Q#!6B<!5%!N#56%!56!O5(!
'5AB!56!%Q#!-88,6/!9<$?A5NN<+!?:!5!&5%%#(!>O!&?:W%#6+!%Q#6#!%(5?N6!6$(#5;!>W%+!'(?#ON<!(#6#&'N?:E!
A?((W6!AN>W;6!'#O>(#!OW(%Q#(!;?OOW6?:E!%>!'#A>&#!5!IQ?%#!Q5J#!?:!%Q#!6B</!F6!<#5(6!$566#;+!%Q#6#!
7#%cN5?;!IQ?%#!%(5?N6!'#A5&#!&>(#!O(#VW#:%!5:;!I#(#!>'6#(D#;!>D#(!I?;#(!E#>E(5$Q?A!(#E?>:6/!
f<!),-)!%Q#6#!%(5?N6!Q5;!'#A>&#!5!:#5(c;5?N<+!:#5(cEN>'5N!>AAW((#:A#!]M?EW(#!-_/!
!
!
!
!
60!
6*78(9:(;''/"(<:(!"=0"5>"#?@A@B!
C-$,+&"'(%+(!*&%,7(!&%"+&"'(D"'",#&E(F*/#+,7(GC!!DFH!
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
L:!%Q#! 5'6#:A#! >O!A(#;?'N#! ?:O>(&5%?>:! O(>&!5W%Q>(?%?#6+! 6>&#! A?%?J#:6!%>>B! 65&$N#6! >O!$>6%c
6$(5<!(5?:I5%#(!O>(!5:5N<6?6!5%!A>&&#(A?5N!N5'>(5%>(?#6!5:;!$>6%#;!%Q#!(#6WN%6!>:!%Q#!L:%#(:#%/!
K>6%!?:;?D?;W5N6!>:N<!(#VW#6%#;!5NW&?:W&!5:5N<6#6+!6>&#!5N6>!(#VW#6%#;!'5(?W&+!IQ?N#!5!O#I!
(#VW#6%#;! 5:5N<6#6! >O! 5NW&?:W&+! '5(?W&+! 5:;! 6%(>:%?W&/! e:#! $W'N?6Q#;! #\$N5:5%?>:+!
$(#6W&5'N<!&5;#!%>!&?6N#5;!>(!;#A#?D#!$#>$N#+!?6!%Q5%!AQ#&%(5?N6!A>:6?6%!>O!%Q#!>\?;#6!5:;4>(!
6WNO5%#6!>O!5NW&?:W&+!'5(?W&+!5:;!6%(>:%?W&+!IQ?AQ!5(#!(#N5%?D#N<!Q5(&N#66!6W'6%5:A#6!'#A5W6#!
%Q#<!5(#!$(5A%?A5NN<!?:6>NW'N#!?:!I5%#(/!9Q5%!#\$N5:5%?>:+!Q>I#D#(+!?6!A>:%(5(<!%>!$##(c(#D?#I#;!
5:5N<%?A5N!;5%5! %Q5%!6Q>I6!5NW&?:W&+!'5(?W&+!5:;!6%(>:%?W&! ]5:;!>%Q#(!#N#&#:%6_!5(#!?:!O5A%!
dissolved!?:!(5?:I5%#(g!
!
9Q#! &<6%#(<+! W:;?6AN>6#;! '<! 5W%Q>(?%?#6+! I56! %Q5%! 6>&#! W:B:>I:! $>I;#(#;! 6W'6%5:A#+!
A>D#(%N<! 7#%c6$(5<#;! ?:%>! %Q#! N>I#(! 5%&>6$Q#(#! ]%(>$>6$Q#(#_+! $(>;WA#6! AQ#&%(5?N6/! 9Q?6!
6W'6%5:A#! (#5A%6! I?%Q! &>?6%W(#+! A5W6?:E! 6>&#! >O! ?%6! AQ#&?A5N! #N#&#:%6! %>! '#! #\%(5A%#;! ?:%>!
5%&>6$Q#(?A!I5%#(/!=N#5(N<+!&5:<!&?NN?>:!&#%(?A! %>:6! >O! %Q?6!W:B:>I:!6W'6%5:A#!I#(#!'#?:E!
7#%c6$(5<#;!?:%>!%Q#!5%&>6$Q#(#!5::W5NN<+!'W%!%Q#(#!I#(#!:>!>'D?>W6!6>W(A#6!O>(!6WAQ!&566?D#!
VW5:%?%?#6!>O!5#(>6>N!$>NNW%5:%6+!:>!A>:6$?AW>W6!$(>;WA%?>:!O5A?N?%?#6/!9Q?6!W:B:>I:!6W'6%5:A#!
I56! ;#O?:?%#N<! :>%! 5! $(>;WA%! >O! :5%W(#+! 6WAQ! 56! ;#6#(%! 65:;+! '#A5W6#! %Q#! h5(%Qi6! 6W(O5A#!
5NW&?:W&!?6!E#:#(5NN<!AQ#&?A5NN<!'>W:;!%>!>\<E#:!5:;!;>#6!:>%!;?66>ND#!?:!(5?:I5%#(/!
!
9Q(>WEQ>W%!%Q#!5A5;#&?A!6A?#:%?O?A!N?%#(5%W(#!%Q#(#!5(#!:W&#(>W6!(#O#(#:A#6!%>!5!%>\?A!I56%#!
$(>;WA#;!'<!?:;W6%(?5N!A>5Nc'W(:?:E!A5NN#;!coal+fly+ash!Z02c0*[/!9Q#!5::W5N!EN>'5N!$(>;WA%?>:!>O!
A>5N!ON<!56Q!(#$>(%#;!?:!),-0!I56!-2,!&?NN?>:!&#%(?A!%>:6!Z0H[/!9Q?6!A>WN;!'#!5!6WOO?A?#:%!6W$$N<!
%>!7#%c6$(5<! 56! 5:!5#(>6>N!>:!%Q#!6A5N#!>'6#(D#;/!X>%5'N<+!5!"$5:?6Q!N5'>(5%>(<i6!#\$#(?&#:%6!
I#(#! A>:;WA%#;! ?:! ),,*+! &?\?:E! A>5N! ON<! 56Q! I?%Q! ;?6%?NN#;! I5%#(! O>(! )0! Q>W(6/! 9Q#! (#6WN%6!
6Q>I#;! %Q5%! 5%! N#56%! 23! #N#&#:%6! I#(#! $5(%?5NN<! ;?66>ND#;! ?:! %Q#! I5%#(! Z01[/! 9Q#! ;?66>ND#;!
#N#&#:%6!?:ANW;#;!5NW&?:W&+!'5(?W&+!5:;!6%(>:%?W&/!!
!
X>%!A>:%#:%!I?%Q!W6?:E!L:%#(:#%c$>6%#;!(5?:I5%#(!5:5N<6#6+!I#!$#(6>:5NN<!A>NN#A%#;!>(!5((5:E#;!
O>(!%Q#!A>NN#A%?>:! 5:;! A>&&#(A?5N!5:5N<6#6!>O! $>6%c6$(5<?:E!65&$N#6!>O! (5?:I5%#(! 5:;!6:>I/!
9Q#!5:5N<%?A5N! (#6WN%6!O>(! -,! #N#&#:%! $5?(6! 5(#! 6Q>I:! ?:! M?EW(#! 2! 5N>:E! I?%Q!%Q#! $(#D?>W6N<!
&#:%?>:#;!L:%#(:#%c$>6%#;!$5?(6/!
!
!
!
61!
Herndon, J. M., Williams, D. D., & Whiteside, M. (2021). Ancient Giant Sequoias Are Dying: Scientists Refuse to Acknowledge the Cause. Advances
in Social Sciences Research Journal, 8(9). 57-70.
URL:%E00=IJJ-K8-*%8*#4JBA8BLMN9J,''#O89<8BA9PB!
)
Figure!3.!From![48],!showing!the!similarity!of!element!ratios!measured!in!rainwater!and!snow!
with!the!range!of!comparable!element!ratios!measured!in!the!laboratory!lixiviate!of!water-
leach!experiments![47,!49].!
!
M5NN?:E! 6:>ION5B#6! %(5$! 5:;! '(?:E! ;>I:! $5(%?AN#6! 7#%c6$(5<#;! ?:%>! %Q#! N>I#(! 5%&>6$Q#(#/!
95B?:E!5!65&$N#!>O!%Q#!6:>I+!5NN>I?:E!?%!%>!&#N%+!5:;!%Q#:!%>!#D5$>(5%#!N#O%!5!(#6?;W#!%Q5%!A>WN;!
'#!5:5N<J#;!5:;!A>&$5(#;!%>!%Q#!(5:E#!>O!D5NW#6!8W(#;!?:!D5(?>W6!65&$N#6!>O!A>5N!ON<!56Q!
]M?EW(#!0_/!L:!5(#56+!6WAQ!56!:>(%Q#(:!G"F!5:;!=5:5;5+!6:>I!&>N;!6>&#%?!E(>I6!5%>$!E(566!
'#:#5%Q! 6:>I/! F6! %Q#! 6:>I! 6%5(%6! %>! &#N%+! %Q#! $5(%?AN#6! ?%! %(5$$#;! 5(#! (#N#56#;! 5:;! &5<! '#!
%(5$$#;!5E5?:!>:!%Q#!W:;#(N<?:E!6:>I!&>N;/!M?EW(#!0!5N6>!6Q>I6!5:5N<%?A5N!D5NW#6!O>(!#N#&#:%!
$5?(6!O(>&!6:>I!&>N;!5:;!O>(!$5(%?AN#6!;(>$$#;!O(>&!5:!5?(A(5O%!5:;!A>NN#A%#;!IQ#(#!%Q#<!O#NN!
>:!5:!5W%>&>'?N#!?:!h:A?:?%56+!=5N?O>(:?5!]G"F_/!!
!
!
!
62!
6*78(9:(;''/"(<:(!"=0"5>"#?@A@B!
C-$,+&"'(%+(!*&%,7(!&%"+&"'(D"'",#&E(F*/#+,7(GC!!DFH!
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
)
Figure!4.!From![39],!comparison!of!analytical!results!with!the!ranges!of!European![47]!and!
American![49]!coal!fly!ash!samples.!
!
F?(! $>NNW%?>:+! %Q#! I>(N;i6! N#5;?:E! A5W6#! >O! #:D?(>:&#:%5N! QW&5:! O5%5N?%?#6+! ?6! 5! &57>(!
A>:%(?'W%>(! %>! :>:A>&&W:?A5'N#! ;?6#56#/! F#(>6>N?J#;! A>5N! ON<! 56Q+! 5! $5(%?AWN5(N<! Q5J5(;>W6!
O>(&!>O! 5?(! $>NNW%?>:+!$>W(6! O>(%Q! O(>&!:W&#(>W6! 6&>B#6%5AB6! ?:!L:;?5! 5:;!=Q?:5/!P>I#D#(+!
A?%?J#:6!>O!%Q#!G:?%#;!"%5%#6+!%Q#!f(?%?6Q!=>&&>:I#5N%Q+!5:;!%Q#!hW(>$#5:!G:?>:!Q5D#!'##:!N#;!
%>!'#N?#D#!%Q5%!A>5Nc'W(:?:E!W%?N?%?#6!?:!%Q#?(!A>W:%(?#6!%(5$!%Q?6!D#(<!%>\?A!6W'6%5:A#!6>!?%!;>#6!
:>%!#\?%!6&>B#6%5AB6!5:;!;?(#A%N<!$>NNW%#!%Q#!5?(/!9Q#<!;>!6%>(#!%Q#!#\Q5W6%!$(#A?$?%5%#6!56!6>N?;!
I56%#+!'W%!%Q#:!%Q#! W%?N?%?#6! 6W((#$%?%?>W6N<!6W$$N<!%Q#! A>5N! ON<!56Q!%>! '#! A>D#(%N<!7#%c6$(5<#;!
?:%>!%Q#!D#(<!5?(!$#>$N#!'(#5%Q#+!5:;!$(#6W&5'N<!$(>O?%!Q5:;6>&#N</!
!
=>5N!ON<!56Q!$5(%?AN#6!A>:%5?:!A>:A#:%(5%?>:6!>O!%Q#!&>6%!Q5J5(;>W6!AQ#&?A5N!#N#&#:%6!?:!A>5N+!
#5AQ!>O!IQ?AQ!A5:!Q5(&!%Q#!:5%W(5N!#:D?(>:&#:%!?:!:W&#(>W6!I5<6/!M>(!#\5&$N#.!F#(>6>N?J#;!
A>5N!ON<!56Q!A>:%5&?:5%#6!%Q#!#:D?(>:&#:%!I?%Q!&#(AW(<+!>:#!>O!%Q#!&>6%!%>\?A!$>?6>:6!B:>I:+!
5:;!B:>I:!%>!&>D#!W$!%Q#!O>>;!AQ5?:!Z))[/!=>:%5&?:5%?:E!%Q#!#:D?(>:&#:%!I?%Q!%Q#!&566?D#!
VW5:%?%?#6!>O!?(>:!A>:%5?:#;!?:!A>5N!ON<!56Q!W$6#%6!%Q#!;#N?A5%#!?(>:!'5N5:A#!?:!:5%W(#!5:;!?:!%Q#!
'>;?#6!>O!#\$>6#;!'?>%5!Z0,+!0-[/!!
!
MNW>(?:#! 5:;! AQN>(?:#! O(>&! 5#(>6>N?J#;! A>5N! ON<! 56Q+! N>O%#;! ?:%>! %Q#! W$$#(! 5%&>6$Q#(#!
]6%(5%>6$Q#(#_+! ;#6%(><6! h5(%Qi6! >J>:#! N5<#(+! 5:;! #\$>6#6! 5NN! 6W(O5A#! N?O#! %>! %Q#! ;#5;N<!
WN%(5D?>N#%!(5;?5%?>:! O(>&!%Q#! 6W:!Z*,[/! L:A(#56#;! #\$>6W(#! %>! WN%(5D?>N#%! (5;?5%?>:! I#5B#:6!
%(##6+!?:ANW;?:E!U?5:%!"#VW>?56+!=>56%!@#;I>>;6+!5:;!9>((#<!Y?:#6+!&5B?:E!%Q#&!DWN:#(5'N#!%>!
?:O#6%5%?>:!'<!OW:E?!5:;!?:6#A%6!Z*-[/!
!
!
!
63!
Herndon, J. M., Williams, D. D., & Whiteside, M. (2021). Ancient Giant Sequoias Are Dying: Scientists Refuse to Acknowledge the Cause. Advances
in Social Sciences Research Journal, 8(9). 57-70.
URL:%E00=IJJ-K8-*%8*#4JBA8BLMN9J,''#O89<8BA9PB!
L:!:5%W(#+!5NW&?:W&!?6!W6W5NN<!N>AB#;!W$!56!?:>(E5:?A!>\?;#6/!=>:6#VW#:%N<+!'?>%5!;?;!:>%!5;5$%!
#D>NW%?>:5(<! ;#O#:6#6! %>! AQ#&?A5NN<! &>'?N#! 5NW&?:W&/! P>I#D#(+! A>5N! ON<! 56Q! AQ#&%(5?N!
$5(%?AWN5%#6!W$>:!#\$>6W(#!%>!I5%#(!(#N#56#!5NW&?:W&!?:!5!AQ#&?A5NN<c&>'?N#!O>(&/!F6!:>%#;!
'<! "$5(N?:E! 5:;! T>I#! Z*)[! ]?:! A>::#A%?>:! %>! A>:6#VW#:A#6! >O! 5A?;! (5?:_.! Forest+ die-offs+ and+
reduced+ survivorship+ or+ impaired+ reproduction+ of+ aquatic+ invertebrates,+ fish,+ and+ amphibians+
have+been+ directly+ connected+to+AI+ [aluminum]+toxicity.+Indirect+ effects+on+birds+ and+mammals+
also+have+been+identified.!S#!Q5D#!$(>D?;#;!#D?;#:A#!%Q5%!AQ#&?A5NN<!&>'?N#!5NW&?:W&!?:!O>E!
I5%#(!A>:A#:%(5%#6!>:!9>((#<!Y?:#6!5:;!$>?6>:6!%Q#&!Z20[/!S#!#\$#A%!%Q#!65&#!%>!'#!%Q#!A56#!
O>(!%Q#!U?5:%!"#VW>?56!5:;!=5N?O>(:?5!=>56%!@#;I>>;6!Z*2+!*0[/!
!
j#5(6!>O!:#5(c;5?N<! 5#(>6>N!$5(%?AWN5%#!7#%c#&$N5A#&#:%! 5N>:E!%Q#!Y5A?O?A! A>56%! >O!%Q#! G:?%#;!
"%5%#6! 5:;! ?:! %Q#! >A#5:! >OO! %Q#! A>56%! Q56! A5W6#;! ;(>WEQ%+! 5%&>6$Q#(?A! I5(&?:E+! 5:;! Q56!
#\5A#('5%#;! O>(#6%! O?(#6! Z)2[+! 5NN! >O! IQ?AQ! Q5D#! Q5;! ;#D56%5%?:E! A>:6#VW#:A#6! O>(! %Q#! U?5:%!
"#VW>?56! 5:;! =5N?O>(:?5! =>56%! @#;I>>;6/! P>I#D#(+! %Q#(#! Q56! '##:! :>! &#:%?>:! >O! %Q#6#! '<!
5W%Q>(?%?#6/!
!
:GKJ@H)=IHI:F@?8)H?8HI.8@8N)F.II)=IA@+I)
9>!W:;#(6%5:;!%Q#! $W'N?A!;#A#$%?>:!(#E5(;?:E! %Q#!;?#c>OO6!>O! =5N?O>(:?5i6! U?5:%!"#VW>?56! 5:;!
=>56%!@#;I>>;6+!>:#!:##;6!>:N<!%>!N>>B!%>!5:>%Q#(!(#N5%#;! 6?%W5%?>:+! %Q#!$W'N?A!;#A#$%?>:!5%!
9>((#<!Y?:#6!"%5%#!@#6#(D#+!:#5(!"5:!C?#E>+!=5N?O>(:?5!]G"F_/!SQ?N#!%Q#!$(#6#:%!5(%?AN#!&5<!'#!
%Q#! O?(6%! %>! 5;;(#66! %Q#! %>\?A! #:D?(>:&#:%5Nc&>;?O?A5%?>:! A5W6#! >O! U?5:%! "#VW>?5! 5:;! =>56%!
@#;I>>;!;?#c>OO6+!%Q#!(5(#+!#:;5:E#(#;!9>((#<!Y?:#6!Q5D#!'##:!%Q#!6W'7#A%!>O!6#D#(5N!<#5(6!>O!
?:;#$#:;#:%!6%W;<!%Q5%!5W%Q>(?%?#6!Q5D#!6<6%#&5%?A5NN<!?E:>(#;/!!
!
9Q#! :5%W(5N! (5:E#6! >O! U?5:%! "#VW>?56+! =>56%! @#;I>>;6! 5:;! 9>((#<! Y?:#6! 5(#! 5NN! I?%Q?:!
=5N?O>(:?5/!FNN!;#$#:;!W$>:!O>E!56!5!6>W(A#!>O!&>?6%W(#/!FNN!5(#!?:!;#AN?:#!5:;!%Q#!(#56>:6!E?D#:!
5(#!;(>WEQ%+!'5(B!'##%N#6+!5:;!AN?&5%#!AQ5:E#+!6$#A?O?A5NN<!?:ANW;?:E!5%&>6$Q#(?A!Q#5%?:E/!!
!
F%! 9>((#<! Y?:#6! "%5%#! @#6#(D#+! :>! %#6%?:E! Q56! '##:! ;>:#! #D#:! %Q>WEQ! %Q#! #D?;#:A#! ?6!
>D#(IQ#N&?:E!%Q5%!>%Q#(!O5A%>(6!5(#!?:D>ND#;/!M?(6%+!5:;!&>6%!>'D?>W6!?6!%Q#!O5A%!%Q5%! 9>((#<!
Y?:#!%(##6!5N6>!;?#;!>:!9>((#<!Y?:#6!U>NO!=>W(6#+!Q>6%!%>!%Q#!Y(>O#66?>:5N!U>NO#(6i!F66>A?5%?>:+!
5:;! ;?(#A%N<! 5;75A#:%! %>! %Q#! @#6#(D#/! 9Q#! 9>((#<! Y?:#6! ;?#;! 5%! 5$$(>\?&5%#N<! %Q#! 65&#!
$#(A#:%5E#!(5%#!5:;!?:! %Q#! 65&#!%?&#!O(5&#!56! %Q#! :>:c?((?E5%#;!%(##6!?:!%Q#! @#6#(D#/! 9Q>6#!
U>NO!=>W(6#!%(##6!I#(#!I5%#(#;!5:;!;(>WEQ%!A>WN;!:>%!$>66?'N<!'#!5!O5A%>(/!9Q?6!O5A%!?6!6?&$N<!
?E:>(#;!'<!5W%Q>(?%?#6/!
!
"#A>:;+!5!$##(c(#D?#I#;! 6A?#:%?O?A! 5(%?AN#! #:%?%N#;+!`Y(#D?>W6N<! G:(#A>E:?J#;! Y(?&5(<! M5A%>(6!
?:!%Q#!C#&?6#!>O!h:;5:E#(#;!9>((#<!Y?:#6k!F!K?A(>A>6&!>O!UN>'5N!M>(#6%!C?#c>OO6b!$W'N?6Q#;!?:!
%Q#!Journal+of+Geography,+Environment+and+Earth+Science+ International!Z20[! I56! 6#:%!%>!"%5%#!
5:;! N>A5N! 5W%Q>(?%?#6! ?:! ),-3/! 9Q5%! 5(%?AN#! ?:ANW;#;! 5:! 5:5N<6?6! >O! %Q#! A>:;#:6#;! O>E! %Q5%!
;(?$$#;! >OO! 9>((#<! Y?:#! :##;N#6/! L%! ?;#:%?O?#;! AQ#&?A5N! %>\?:6+! #6$#A?5NN<! AQ#&?A5NN<c&>'?N#!
5NW&?:W&+! 5:;! ?:A(#56?:E! WN%(5D?>N#%! (5;?5%?>:! 56! $(?&5(<! O5A%>(6! ?:! %Q#?(! ;#AN?:#/! 9Q5%!
6A?#:%?O?A!5(%?AN#!5N6>!?;#:%?O?#;!5!$(>A#66!'<!IQ?AQ!%Q#!AQ#&?A5N!%>\?:6+!#6$#A?5NN<!5NW&?:W&!?:!
5! AQ#&?A5NN<! &>'?N#! O>(&+! 5(#! A>:A#:%(5%#;! >:! $?:#! :##;N#6! '<! ;#$>6?%?>:! 5:;! #D5$>(5%?>:+!
#D#:%W5NN<! ;(?$$?:E! ;>I:! %>! $>?6>:! %Q#! (>>%6/! f>%Q! %Q#! AQ#&?A5N! %>\?:6! 5:;! ?:A(#56?:E!
WN%(5D?>N#%!(5;?5%?>:!5(#!A5W6#;!'<!%(>$>6$Q#(?A!7#%c#&$N5A#;!;#N?'#(5%#!$5(%?AWN5%#!$>NNW%?>:!
>O!>W(!6B</!
!
!
!
64!
6*78(9:(;''/"(<:(!"=0"5>"#?@A@B!
C-$,+&"'(%+(!*&%,7(!&%"+&"'(D"'",#&E(F*/#+,7(GC!!DFH!
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
9Q?(;+!OW:E5N!$5%Q>E#:!;5&5E#!I56!$(#6#:%#;!%>!#:D?(>:&#:%5N!$(>O#66?>:5N6!56B?:E!O>(!Q#N$!
O?:;?:E! >W%! IQ5%! ?6! A5W6?:E! ?%+! 'W%! :>! >:#! 6##&#;! ?:%#(#6%#;! ?:! N>>B?:E! ?:%>! %Q#! $(>'N#&/!
"5&$N#6! I#(#! ;#N?D#(#;! %>! "5:! C?#E>! =>W:%<! YN5:%! Y5%Q>N>E<! T5'>(5%>(<! >:! O?D#! 6#$5(5%#!
>AA56?>:6! ?:! ),-3/! 9Q?6! ?6! 5! N5'>(5%>(<! %Q5%! $(>D?;#6! $N5:%! ;?5E:>6%?A! 6#(D?A#6! %>! %Q#! N>A5N!
5E(?AWN%W(5N!?:;W6%(<!5:;!%Q#!E#:#(5N!$W'N?A/!9Q#<!A>WN;!:>%!;#%#(&?:#!IQ5%!?%!I56/!YQ>%>6!>O!
%Q#! $5%Q>E#:! ;5&5E#! I#(#! 6#:%! %>! %Q#! =5N?O>(:?5! C#$5(%&#:%! >O! FE(?AWN%W(#! ?:! "5A(5&#:%>/!
9Q#<! (#$N?#;! >D#(! 5! &>:%Q! N5%#(! 5:;! #66#:%?5NN<! 65?;! %Q#<! ;?;! :>%! B:>I! IQ5%! ?%! I56/! 9Q#!
$5%Q>E#:! ;5&5E#! I56! $(#6#:%#;! %>! %Q#! "5:! C?#E>! =>&&W:?%<! M>(#6%! F;D?6>(<! f>5(;! ?:!
X>D#&'#(+!),-3/!9Q?6!?6! 5!'>5(;!%Q5%!5;D?6#6! %Q#! "5:!C?#E>!K5<>(! >:! W('5:!O>(#6%(<!?66W#6/!
9Q#<!I#(#! 56B#;! %>! (#A>&&#:;! %>! %Q#! K5<>(!%>! Q#N$!?:D#6%?E5%#! %Q#! A5W6#! >O! %Q#!$5%Q>E#:!
;5&5E#+!'W%!%Q#<!;#AN?:#;/!M?EW(#!*!?NNW6%(5%#6!6>&#!>O!%Q#!6<&$%>&6!$(#6#:%#;/!!
!
!
Figure!5.!Examples!of!Torrey!Pine!symptoms!presented!to!San!Diego!County!Plant!Pathology!
Lab,!California!Department!of!Agriculture,!and!San!Diego!Community!Forest!Advisory!Board,!
showing!what!should!have!been!identified!as!pitch!canker!disease.!(A)!Branch!tip!die-back;!(B)!
Cross!section!shows!resin!of!infected!wood;!(C)!Oozing!on!main!trunk;!(D)!Infection!site!with!
honey!colored!lesion!beneath!the!surface.!
)
9Q#! $5%Q>E#:! I56! 6W'6#VW#:%N<! ?;#:%?O?#;! '<! 5! A#(%?O?#;! N5'! %>! '#! Fusarium+ circinatum+! %Q#!
A5W6#!>O!Y?%AQ!=5:B#(!C?6#56#!?:!$?:#6/!9Q#!N5'>(5%>(<!5:5N<6?6!?6!6Q>I:!?:!M?EW(#!H/!
!
!
!
65!
Herndon, J. M., Williams, D. D., & Whiteside, M. (2021). Ancient Giant Sequoias Are Dying: Scientists Refuse to Acknowledge the Cause. Advances
in Social Sciences Research Journal, 8(9). 57-70.
URL:%E00=IJJ-K8-*%8*#4JBA8BLMN9J,''#O89<8BA9PB!
!
Figure!6.!Laboratory!analysis!identifying!the!pathogen!as!Fusarium'circinatum,!the!cause!of!
pitch!canker!disease!in!pines.!
!
L:! 5:! 5%%#&$%! %>! %(<! %>! A>:D?:A#! 5W%Q>(?%?#6! %>! 5NN>I! %#6%?:E+! 5:! ?:O>(&5N! $#%?%?>:! I56! $W%!
%>E#%Q#(! #:%?%N#;+! `F6B! =5N?O>(:?5! "%5%#! Y5(B6! %>! 9#6%! 9>((#<! Y?:#! 9(##6! O>(! FNW&?:W&!
Y>?6>:?:Eb!]M?EW(#! 1_/! L%!I56! %Q>WEQ%!%Q5%! %Q?6!I>WN;! '#! 5!6?&$N#! 5:;!?:#\$#:6?D#! %#6%/! 9I>!
%Q>W65:;!$#>$N#!6?E:#;!%Q#!$#%?%?>:!5:;!?%!I56!6W'&?%%#;!%>!=5N?O>(:?5!"%5%#!Y5(B6+!%Q#!&5<>(6!
>O!"5:!C?#E>! 5:;! C#N!K5(+! 5:;! A>$?#6!I#(#!6#:%! %>! >D#(!*,!N>A5N! >OO?A?5N6! 5:;!#:D?(>:&#:%5N!
$(>O#66?>:5N6! ?:! F$(?N+! ),-8/! L%! I56! 5NN! ?:! D5?:+! 56! :>! (#$N<! A5&#! O(>&! 5:<! E>D#(:&#:%5N!
5W%Q>(?%</!!
!
!
!
66!
6*78(9:(;''/"(<:(!"=0"5>"#?@A@B!
C-$,+&"'(%+(!*&%,7(!&%"+&"'(D"'",#&E(F*/#+,7(GC!!DFH!
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
!
Figure!7.!2,000!people!signed!petition!asking!for!testing!of!trees!was!submitted!to!authorities!in!
April,!2019.!There!was!no!reply.!To!date,!no!testing!has!been!done.!
!
YW'N?A!;#A#$%?>:! (#E5(;?:E! %Q#!9>((#<!Y?:#! ;?#c>OO!(5:E#6!O(>&! "%5%#! Y5(B6!%>! >W(! D>NW:%##(!
;>A#:%! 6>A?#%<! %>! >W(! #:D?(>:&#:%5N! $(>O#66?>:5N6! %>! >W(! #N#A%#;! >OO?A?5N6! %>! >W(! 5A5;#&?A!
?:6%?%W%?>:6!5:;! %>! >W(!:#I6c&#;?5/!SQ?N#! %Q#(#! ?6!>D#(IQ#N&?:E! #D?;#:A#! >%Q#(!O5A%>(6!5(#!
?:D>ND#;! ?:! %Q#! 9>((#<! Y?:#! ;?#c>OO+! ]?:ANW;?:E! $Q>%>6! >O! $?%AQ! A5:B#(! 6<&$%>&6+! N5'>(5%>(<!
5:5N<6?6!?;#:%?O<?:E! %Q#!$5%Q>E#:! Fusarium+circinatum+! 5:;!5! 6A?#:%?O?A!$##(c(#D?#I#;! $5$#(!
;>AW&#:%?:E!AQ#&?A5N!%>\?:6+!#6$#A?5NN<!AQ#&?A5NN<!&>'?N#!5NW&?:W&+!5:;!;5&5E#!A5W6#;!'<!
?:A(#56?:E! WN%(5D?>N#%! (5;?5%?>:_! E>D#(:&#:%! 5W%Q>(?%?#6! O5?N! %>! 5AB:>IN#;E#! >(! N>>B! ?:%>!
5:<%Q?:E!%Q5%!;?OO#(6!O(>&!%Q#!>OO?A?5N!6%>(<cN?:#!>O!;(>WEQ%!5:;!'##%N#6/!!
!
9>((#<!Y?:#6!5(#!?&$>(%5:%!5:;!#:;5:E#(#;!%(##6/!9Q#!5W%Q>(?%?#6i!(#OW65N!%>!A>:6?;#(!$#(%?:#:%!
;5%5!>:! %Q#?(! ;#&?6#!$(#O?EW(#6! 6?&?N5(!'#Q5D?>(! (#N5%?:E! %>!W:;#(6%5:;?:E! >O!%Q#! ;?#c>OO6! >O!
U?5:%!"#VW>?56+!=>56%!@#;I>>;6+!5:;!>%Q#(!%(##6!?:!=5N?O>(:?5/!L6!?%!?E:>(5:A#a!L:A>&$#%#:A#a!
Y#(Q5$6!&>(#!N?B#N<+!5:;!I#!5NN#E#+!?%!?6!I?NN?:E!A>&$N?A?%<!?:!%Q#!>:E>?:E!EN>'5N!#:D?(>:&#:%5N!
I5(O5(#!65:A%?>:#;!'<!%Q#!G:?%#;!X5%?>:6/!
!
G8@FI=)8!F@?8+)+!8HF@?8I=)I84@.?8AI8F!J)C!.O!.I)
L:!-813+!%Q#!G:?%#;!X5%?>:6!#:%#(#;!?:%>!O>(A#!5:!L:%#(:5%?>:5N!9(#5%<!#:%?%N#;!Convention+on+
the+Prohibition+ of+ Military+or+ Any+ Other+Hostile+ Use+ of+Environmental+ Modification+ Techniques!
Z**[/!S?%Q!6WAQ!5!%?%N#+!IQ5%!A?D?N?J#;!:5%?>:!I>WN;!(#OW6#!%>!6?E:c>:a!K5:<!;?;!6?E:c>:!]M?EW(#!
3_/!
!
!
!
67!
Herndon, J. M., Williams, D. D., & Whiteside, M. (2021). Ancient Giant Sequoias Are Dying: Scientists Refuse to Acknowledge the Cause. Advances
in Social Sciences Research Journal, 8(9). 57-70.
URL:%E00=IJJ-K8-*%8*#4JBA8BLMN9J,''#O89<8BA9PB!
!
Figure!8.!Sovereign!nation!Parties!of!the!Convention!on!the!Prohibition!of!Military!or!Any!Other!
Hostile!Use!of!Environmental!Modification!Techniques!as!of!January!3,!2018.!From![33].!
!
FN6>!A5NN#;! hXKeC+!%Q#! Convention+on+ the+Prohibition+ of+Military+ or+Any+ Other+Hostile+ Use+of+
Environmental+Modification+Techniques!Z**[!?6!5!6Q5&/!L%!does+not+!56!?%6!%?%N#!6WEE#6%6+!$(>Q?'?%!
Q>6%?N#! W6#! >O! #:D?(>:&#:%5N! &>;?O?A5%?>:! %#AQ:?VW#6+! 'W%! ?:6%#5;! 65:A%?>:6! peaceful!W6#! >O!
#:D?(>:&#:%5N!&>;?O?A5%?>:!%#AQ:?VW#6!Z22[/!S>(6#+!AN>5B#;!?:!A>:OW6?:E!;#A#$%?D#!N5:EW5E#+!
%Q?6! L:%#(:5%?>:5N! 9(#5%<! ?6! 5! Trojan+ horse! %Q5%! &5:;5%#6! Y5(%?#6! %>! #:E5E#! ?:! Q>6%?N#!
#:D?(>:&#:%5N!I5(O5(#!5E5?:6%!%Q#?(!>I:!A?%?J#:6!5:;!A?%?J#:6!>O!>%Q#(!6>D#(#?E:!:5%?>:6!W:;#(!
%Q#!EW?6#!>O!peaceful+environmental+modification!Z)3+!2-[/!
!
^#%c#&$N5A#;! $5(%?AWN5%#! $>NNW%?>:! >O! %Q#! 5%&>6$Q#(#! ?6! 7W6%! >:#! >O! %Q#! &5:<! $>66?'N#!
#:D?(>:&#:%5N!&>;?O?A5%?>:!%#AQ:?VW#6+!IQ?AQ!5AA>(;?:E!%>!65?;!9(#5%<!refers+to+any+technique+
for+ changing+ l+ through+ the+ deliberate+ manipulation+ of+ natural+ processes+ l+ the+ dynamics,+
composition+ or+ structure+ of+ the+ Earth,+ including+ its+ biota,+ lithosphere,+ hydrosphere+ and+
atmosphere,+or+of+ outer+ space!Z**[/!P>6%?N#!?:%#:%!?6! AN#5(! '<!%Q#!Q?EQ! ;#E(##! >O!6#A(#A<+!O5N6#!
?:O>(&5%?>:+!5:;!%Q#!A>:A#(%#;!#OO>(%6!%>!;#A#?D#!%Q#!$W'N?A!>O!%Q>6#!>$#(5%?>:6+!#6$#A?5NN<!%Q#?(!
5;D#(6#! Q#5N%Q! (?6B6! Z2cH[+! %Q#! %>\?A! :5%W(#! >O! %Q#! 7#%c6$(5<#;! $>NNW%5:%6! 5:;! %Q#?(!
#:D?(>:&#:%5N!Q5(&!Z3c0)[/!
!
H?8HJG+@?8+)
C?#c>OO6!>O!U?5:%!"#VW>?56!5:;!=>56%!@#;I>>;6+!6>&#!>O!IQ?AQ!Q5D#!6W(D?D#;!:5%W(5N!AN?&5%#!
AQ5:E#!O>(!56!N>:E!56!2+,,,!<#5(6+!N?B#!;?#c>OO6!>O!%Q#!(5(#!5:;!#:;5:E#(#;!9>((#<!Y?:#6+!5(#!:>%!
:5%W(5N!A>:6#VW#:A#6! >O! :5%W(#/!L:6%#5;+! %Q#! A5W6#6!>O! %Q#?(! ;#&?6#!5(#! 6>&#! >O!%Q#! 5;D#(6#!
A>:6#VW#:A#6!>O! EN>'5N!E>D#(:5:A#!(W:!5&WAB/!h:D?(>:&#:%5N!I5(O5(#+!>(?E?:5NN<!#:D?6?>:#;!
O>(!W6#!'<!5;D#(65(?5N!:5%?>:6!Z2)+!*H[+! Q56! '#A>&#! EN>'5N?J#;!5E5?:6%!6>D#(#?E:!:5%?>:6!5:;!
%Q#?(! A?%?J#:6! Z)3+! 2,+! 2-[/! 9Q(>WEQ! 5! ;?5'>N?A5NN<c;#A#$%?D#! G:?%#;! X5%?>:6i! L:%#(:5%?>:5N!
9(#5%<!Z22[+!Convention+on+the+Prohibition+of+Military+or+Any+Other+Hostile+Use+of+Environmental+
Modification+ Techniques! Z**[+! %Q#! E>D#(:&#:%6! >O! 6>D#(#?E:! :5%?>:6! I#(#! A>#(A#;! %>! I5E#!
#:D?(>:&#:%5N!I5(O5(#!5E5?:6%!%Q#?(!>I:!A?%?J#:6!5:;!%Q#!:5%W(5N!#:D?(>:&#:%!W:;#(!%Q#!EW?6#!
>O!$#5A#OWN!#:D?(>:&#:%5N!&>;?O?A5%?>:/!C?(#A%!?:D>ND#&#:%!'<!%Q#!G:?%#;!X5%?>:6!?6!?:;?A5%#;!
'<!%Q#!Bulletin+of+the+ World+ Health+ Organization!(#7#A%?:E!I?%Q>W%!$##(c(#D?#I!5!Y#(6$#A%?D#!
I5(:?:E!>O!%Q#!$W'N?A!Q#5N%Q!A>:6#VW#:A#6!>O!%Q#!%(>$>6$Q#(?A!$5(%?AWN5%#!5#(?5N!6$(5<?:E!Z)*[/!
!
!
!
68!
6*78(9:(;''/"(<:(!"=0"5>"#?@A@B!
C-$,+&"'(%+(!*&%,7(!&%"+&"'(D"'",#&E(F*/#+,7(GC!!DFH!
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
Y5(%?A?$5%?>:!5:;4>(!5AVW?#6A#:A#!?:!%Q?6!#:D?(>:&#:%5N!I5(O5(#+!I#!5NN#E#+!A>:6%?%W%#6!A(?!
5E5?:6%!QW&5:?%<!5:;!%Q#!#:D?(>:&#:%/!!
!
.'P'/'%&'()
1.!Stephenson,!N.L.,!et!al.,!Patterns!and!correlates!of!giant!sequoia!foliage!dieback!during!California’s!2012–2016!
hotter!drought.!Forest!ecology!and!management,!2018.!419:!p.!268-278.!
2.!Preisler,!H.K.,!et!al.,!Analysis!and!out-year!forecast!of!beetle,!borer,!and!drought-induced!tree!mortality!in!
California.!Forest!Ecology!and!Management,!2017.!399:!p.!166-178.!
3.!http://www.nuclearplanet.com/USAF.pdf!
4.!Shearer,!C.,!et!al.,!Quantifying!expert!consensus!against!the!existence!of!a!secret!large-scale!atmospheric!
spraying!program.!Environ.!Res.!Lett.,!2016.!11(8):!p.!p.!084011.!
5.!Tingley,!D.!and!G.!Wagner,!Solar!geoengineering!and!the!chemtrails!conspiracy!on!social!media.!Palgrave!
Communications,!2017.!3(1):!p.!12.!
6.!http://www.nuclearplanet.com/Retraction_Deception.html!
7.!El!Husseini,!M.M.,!Weather!Engineering!and!its!Undesirable!Side!Effects!on!the!Environment,!Natural!
Resources,!Agriculture!and!Human.!Acta!Scientific!Agriculture,!2019.!3.7.!
8.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Aluminum!poisoning!of!humanity!and!Earth's!biota!by!clandestine!geoengineering!activity:!
implications!for!India.!Curr.!Sci.,!2015.!108(12):!p.!2173-2177.!
9.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Obtaining!evidence!of!coal!fly!ash!content!in!weather!modification!(geoengineering)!through!
analyses!of!post-aerosol!spraying!rainwater!and!solid!substances.!Ind.!J.!Sci.!Res.!and!Tech.,!2016.!4(1):!p.!30-
36.!
10.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Adverse!agricultural!consequences!of!weather!modification.!AGRIVITA!Journal!of!agricultural!
science,!2016.!38(3):!p.!213-221.!
11.!Herndon,!J.M.,!An!indication!of!intentional!efforts!to!cause!global!warming!and!glacier!melting.!J.!Geography!
Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Int.,!2017.!9(1):!p.!1-11.!
12.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Evidence!of!variable!Earth-heat!production,!global!non-anthropogenic!climate!change,!and!
geoengineered!global!warming!and!polar!melting.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2017.!10(1):!p.!16.!
13.!Herndon,!J.M.,!An!open!letter!to!members!of!AGU,!EGU,!and!IPCC!alleging!promotion!of!fake!science!at!the!
expense!of!human!and!environmental!health!and!comments!on!AGU!draft!geoengineering!position!statement.!
New!Concepts!in!Global!Tectonics!Journal,!2017.!5(3):!p.!413-416.!
14.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Air!pollution,!not!greenhouse!gases:!The!principal!cause!of!global!warming.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!
Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2018.!17(2):!p.!1-8.!
15.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Scientific!misrepresentation!and!the!climate-science!cartel.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!
2018.!18(2):!p.!1-13.!
16.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Fundamental!climate!science!error:!Concomitant!harm!to!humanity!and!the!environment!J.!
Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2018.!18(3):!p.!1-12.!
17.!Herndon,!J.M.,!Role!of!atmospheric!convection!in!global!warming.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2019.!
19(4):!p.!1-8.!
18.!Herndon,!J.M.,!World!War!II!holds!the!key!to!understanding!global!warming!and!the!challenge!facing!science!
and!society.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2019.!23(4):!p.!1-13.!
19.!Herndon,!J.M.,!True!science!for!government!leaders!and!educators:!Obama’s!U.S.!EnvironmentalProtection!
Agency!corruption.!Advances!in!Social!Sciences!Research!Journal,!2020.!7(7):!p.!520-531.!
20.!Herndon,!J.M.,!R.D.!Hoisington,!and!M.!Whiteside,!Chemtrails!are!not!contrails:!Radiometric!evidence.!J.!Geog.!
Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2020.!24(2):!p.!22-29.!
!
!
!
69!
Herndon, J. M., Williams, D. D., & Whiteside, M. (2021). Ancient Giant Sequoias Are Dying: Scientists Refuse to Acknowledge the Cause. Advances
in Social Sciences Research Journal, 8(9). 57-70.
URL:%E00=IJJ-K8-*%8*#4JBA8BLMN9J,''#O89<8BA9PB!
21.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Further!evidence!of!coal!fly!ash!utilization!in!tropospheric!geoengineering:!
Implications!on!human!and!environmental!health.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2017.!9(1):!p.!1-8.!
22.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Contamination!of!the!biosphere!with!mercury:!Another!potential!
consequence!of!on-going!climate!manipulation!using!aerosolized!coal!fly!ash!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!
2017.!13(1):!p.!1-11.!
23.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!California!wildfires:!Role!of!undisclosed!atmospheric!manipulation!and!
geoengineering.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2018.!17(3):!p.!1-18.!
24.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Further!evidence!that!particulate!pollution!is!the!principal!cause!of!global!
warming:!Humanitarian!considerations.!Journal!of!Geography,!Environment!and!Earth!Science!International,!
2019.!21(1):!p.!1-11.!
25.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Geoengineering:!The!deadly!new!global!“Miasma”.!Journal!of!Advances!in!
Medicine!and!Medical!Research,!2019.!29(12):!p.!1-8.!
26.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Geophysical!consequences!of!tropospheric!particulate!heating:!Further!
evidence!that!anthropogenic!global!warming!is!principally!caused!by!particulate!pollution.!Journal!of!
Geography,!Environment!and!Earth!Science!International,!2019.!22(4):!p.!1-23.!
27.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Unacknowledged!potential!factors!in!catastrophic!bat!die-off!arising!from!
coal!fly!ash!geoengineering.!Asian!Journal!of!Biology,!2019.!8(4):!p.!1-13.!
28.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Global!Environmental!Warfare.!Advances!in!Social!Sciences!Research!Journal,!
2020.!7(4):!p.!411-422.!
29.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Aerosol!particulates,!SARS-CoV-2,!and!the!broader!potential!for!global!
devastation.!Open!Access!Journal!of!Internal!Medicine,!2020.!3(1):!p.!14-21.!
30.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Technology!Bill!of!Rights!needed!to!protect!human!and!environmental!health!
and!the!U.!S.!Constitutional!Republic!Advances!in!Social!Sciences!Research!Journal,!2020.!7(6).!
31.!Herndon,!J.M.!and!M.!Whiteside,!Environmental!warfare!against!American!citizens:!An!open!letter!to!the!Joint!
Chiefs!of!Staff.!Advances!in!Social!Sciences!Research!Journal,!2020.!7(8):!p.!382-397.!
32.!Herndon,!J.M.,!M.!Whiteside,!and!I.!Baldwin,!Fifty!Years!after!“How!to!Wreck!the!Environment”:!
Anthropogenic!Extinction!of!Life!on!Earth.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2018.!16(3):!p.!1-15.!
33.!Herndon,!J.M.,!M.!Whiteside,!and!I.!Baldwin,!The!ENMOD!treaty!and!the!sanctioned!assault!on!agriculture!and!
human!and!environmental!health.!Agrotechnology,!2020.!9(191):!p.!1-9.!
34.!Herndon,!J.M.,!D.D.!Williams,!and!M.!Whiteside,!Previously!unrecognized!primary!factors!in!the!demise!of!
endangered!torrey!pines:!A!microcosm!of!global!forest!die-offs.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.!,!2018.!16(4):!
p.!1-14.!
35.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!Coal!fly!ash!aerosol:!Risk!factor!for!lung!cancer.!Journal!of!Advances!in!
Medicine!and!Medical!Research,!2018.!25(4):!p.!1-10.!
36.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!Aerosolized!coal!fly!ash:!Risk!factor!for!neurodegenerative!disease.!Journal!of!
Advances!in!Medicine!and!Medical!Research,!2018.!25(10):!p.!1-11.!
37.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!Aerosolized!coal!fly!ash:!Risk!factor!for!COPD!and!respiratory!disease.!
Journal!of!Advances!in!Medicine!and!Medical!Research,!2018.!26(7):!p.!1-13.!
38.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!Previously!unacknowledged!potential!factors!in!catastrophic!bee!and!insect!
die-off!arising!from!coal!fly!ash!geoengineering!Asian!J.!Biol.,!2018.!6(4):!p.!1-13.!
39.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!Aerosolized!coal!fly!ash:!A!previously!unrecognized!primary!factor!in!the!
catastrophic!global!demise!of!bird!populations!and!species.!Asian!J.!Biol.,!2018.!6(4):!p.!1-13.!
40.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!Role!of!aerosolized!coal!fly!ash!in!the!global!plankton!imbalance:!Case!of!
Florida's!toxic!algae!crisi.!Asian!Journal!of!Biology,!2019.!8(2):!p.!1-24.!
!
!
!
70!
6*78(9:(;''/"(<:(!"=0"5>"#?@A@B!
C-$,+&"'(%+(!*&%,7(!&%"+&"'(D"'",#&E(F*/#+,7(GC!!DFH!
!"#$%&"'()*#(!&%"+&"(,+-(.-/&,0%*+(1(2+%0"-(3%+4-*5!
41.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!Geoengineering,!coal!fly!ash!and!the!new!heart-Iron!connection:!Universal!
exposure!to!iron!oxide!nanoparticulates.!Journal!of!Advances!in!Medicine!and!Medical!Research,!2019.!31(1):!
p.!1-20.!
42.!Whiteside,!M.!and!J.M.!Herndon,!COVID-19,!immunopathology,!particulate!pollution,!and!iron!balance.!Journal!
of!Advances!in!Medicine!and!Medical!Research,!2020.!32(18):!p.!43-60.!
43.!Borm,!P.J.A.,!Toxicity!and!occupational!health!hazards!of!coal!fly!ash!(cfa).!A!review!of!data!and!comparison!to!
coal!mine!dust.!Ann.!occup.!Hyg.,!1997.!41(6):!p.!659-676.!
44.!Roy,!W.R.,!R.!Thiery,!and!J.J.!Suloway,!Coal!fly!ash:!a!review!of!the!literature!and!proposed!classification!
system!with!emphasis!on!environmental!impacts.!Environ.!Geology!Notes!#96,!1981.!
45.!Walls,!S.J.,!et!al.,!Ecological!risk!assessment!for!residual!coal!fly!ash!at!Watts!Bar!Reservoir,!Tennessee:!Site!
setting!and!problem!formulation.!Integrated!environmental!assessment!and!management,!2015.!11(1):!p.!32-
42.!
46.!Dwivedi,!A.!and!M.K.!Jain,!Fly!ash–waste!management!and!overview:!A!Review.!Recent!Research!in!Science!
and!Technology,!2014.!6(1).!
47.!Moreno,!N.,!et!al.,!Physico-chemical!characteristics!of!European!pulverized!coal!combustion!fly!ashes.!Fuel,!
2005.!84:!p.!1351-1363.!
48.!Herndon,!J.M.,!D.D.!Williams,!and!M.!Whiteside,!Previously!unrecognized!primary!factors!in!the!demise!of!
endangered!torrey!pines:!A!microcosm!of!global!forest!die-offs.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.!,!2018.!16(4):!
p.!1-14.!
49.!Suloway,!J.J.,!et!al.,!Chemical!and!toxicological!properties!of!coal!fly!ash,!in!Environmental!Geology!Notes!105.!
1983,!Illinois!Department!of!Energy!and!Natural!Resources:!Illinois.!
50.!Herndon,!J.M.,!R.D.!Hoisington,!and!M.!Whiteside,!Deadly!ultraviolet!UV-C!and!UV-B!penetration!to!Earth’s!
surface:!Human!and!environmental!health!implications.!J.!Geog.!Environ.!Earth!Sci.!Intn.,!2018.!14(2):!p.!1-11.!
51.!Vanhaelewyn,!L.,!et!al.,!Ultraviolet!Radiation!From!a!Plant!Perspective:!The!Plant-Microorganism!Context.!
Frontiers!in!plant!science,!2020.!11:!p.!1984.!
52.!Sparling,!D.W.!and!T.P.!Lowe,!Environmental!hazards!of!aluminum!to!plants,!invertibrates,!fish,!and!wildlife.!
Rev.!Environ.!Contam.!Toxicol.,!1996.!145:!p.!1-127.!
53.!Burgess,!S.!and!T.!Dawson,!The!contribution!of!fog!to!the!water!relations!of!Sequoia!sempervirens!(D.!Don):!
foliar!uptake!and!prevention!of!dehydration.!Plant,!cell!&!environment,!2004.!27(8):!p.!1023-1034.!
54.!Ewing,!H.A.,!et!al.,!Fog!water!and!ecosystem!function:!heterogeneity!in!a!California!redwood!forest.!
Ecosystems,!2009.!12(3):!p.!417-433.!
55.!http://www.un-documents.net/enmod.htm!
56.!https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP78-03425A002100020014-2.pdf!
!
!
!
)
!
!
)
)
!
!
!
!