ArticlePDF Available

Environmental Risk Assessment in the Masrik River Basin

Authors:
  • Institute of Geological Sciences of NAS of Armenia

Abstract and Figures

The purpose of this study is to assess the environmental risks of water pollutionin the Masrik River catchment area. The risk assessment studies are based on the results of thehydrochemical monitoring of the Masrik River Basin water quality in 2012‒2014. The main riskfactors for pollution of the river basin area are mining, agriculture, uncontrolled utility flows.Zoning was performed and areas of zones were calculated using a digital elevation model (DEM)in the ArcGIS software environment and taking into account sampling points and river basins. Atthe same time, the territory was ranked by population density. Then a geodatabase (GDB) wascompiled. GDB presents the point assessments of the state of river waters according to the level ofthe pollutant concentration factor and population density. The thematic layers based on the resultsof the indicators in the ArcGIS program were compiled. A map was obtained according to a pointassessment of environmental risk. An integrated assessment of river water pollution was carriedout in different parts of the basin. The population density and total risk index were calculated. Thethree risk zones were identified in the river basin: high, medium and low. In addition to presentingtheoretical value, the conclusions are also of practical importance and can be used in the developmentof river basin risk management programs, measures for quality management and control ofpollution sources in the aread.
Content may be subject to copyright.
AGROLOGY
AGROLOGY | Volume 4 | Issue 271
Environmental Risk Assessment
in the Masrik River Basin
M. A. Nalbandyan, A. O. Nersisyan
Instute of Geological Sciences Naonal Academy of Sciences, Yerevan, Republic of Armenia
Received: 16 March 2021
Revised: 18 March 2021
Accepted: 19 March 2021
Institute of Geological Sciences,
Marshal Baghramyan Ave., 24a, Yerevan,
0019, Republic of Armenia
Tel.: +37-41-052-44-26
E-mail: marinen3@yahoo.com
Cite this article: Nalbandyan, M. A.,
& Nersisyan, A. O. (2021). Environmental
risk assessment in the Masrik River Basin.
Agrology, 4(2), 71‒76. doi: 10.32819/021009
Abstract. The purpose of this study is to assess the environmental risks of water pollution
in the Masrik River catchment area. The risk assessment studies are based on the results of the
hydrochemical monitoring of the Masrik River Basin water quality in 2012‒2014. The main risk
factors for pollution of the river basin area are mining, agriculture, uncontrolled utility ows.
Zoning was performed and areas of zones were calculated using a digital elevation model (DEM)
in the ArcGIS software environment and taking into account sampling points and river basins. At
the same time, the territory was ranked by population density. Then a geodatabase (GDB) was
compiled. GDB presents the point assessments of the state of river waters according to the level of
the pollutant concentration factor and population density. The thematic layers based on the results
of the indicators in the ArcGIS program were compiled. A map was obtained according to a point
assessment of environmental risk. An integrated assessment of river water pollution was carried
out in different parts of the basin. The population density and total risk index were calculated. The
three risk zones were identied in the river basin: high, medium and low. In addition to presenting
theoretical value, the conclusions are also of practical importance and can be used in the develop-
ment of river basin risk management programs, measures for quality management and control of
pollution sources in the aread.
Keywords: environmental risk; river water quality; modeling and mapping.
ISSN 2617-6106 (print)
ISSN 2617-6114 (online)
Agrology, 4(2), 71‒76
doi: 10.32819/021009
Оriginal researches
Introduction
This article examines the area of the catchment of the Masrik
River with its tributaries, in order to assess the environmental risk of
river water pollution, taking into account the nature and volume of
negative impact on water quality, presented in a spatial representa-
tion. The main environmental problems of the region are the pollu-
tion of soils and river waters with heavy metals, the accumulation
of biogenic components in soils in the zones, the ow of untreated
municipal wastewater into the river. The pollution of natural envi-
ronments with heavy metals is associated with the mining activity
of the Sotk gold deposit in the catchment area. Meantime the accu-
mulation of nutrients in soils is mainly due to agricultural activity.
The Sotk gold ore deposit industrial zone is located in the
Gegharkunik region at the north ‒ eastern part of Sevan or 20 km
East of Vardenis, 2 km from the Sotk pass, at an absolute altitude of
2300‒2500 m. This area was known in antiquity, as evidenced by
numerous ancient workings and archaeological nds dating back
to the 11th century BC. This territory was re-discovered by a team
of geologists “Kavzolotorazvedka” in 1951 from mining point of
view. The deposit occupies a signicant area and located in the
zone of development of parallel tectonic faults and multiple cru-
shing of rocks, which bear signs of intense hydrothermal alteration
and chemical weathering processes, expressed in the oxidation and
replacement of rock-forming minerals with iron carbonate and hy-
droxides. The main ore controlling structure of the deposit is the
Sotk fault, which is traced for 20 km, of which 12 km in Armenia
(Sidorenko et al., 1974). Ore processing is carried out at the Ararat
mining plant, where the ore is delivered by train.
The reserves of pure gold at the deposit are estimated at more
than 120 tons. The ore eld has been in operation since 1976, and
since 2007 ‒ under the leadership of GeoProMining (Nature of Ar-
menia, 2006)
According to a number of studies, the waters of the Sotk and
Masrik rivers are distinguished by high concentrations of lead,
chromium, sulfate ions, nitrates (IV hazard class), phosphates (III
hazard class) and are caused by the inuence of uncontrolled waste-
water and technogenic impact of the Sotk deposit (Hambaryan &
Nalbandyan, 2015). Studies to assess the mobility of a number of
microcomponents in the soil and in the soil-plant system in the
catchment of the Masrik River with the main tributary, the Sotk Ri-
ver, revealed quite interesting patterns of the heavy metals migra-
tion. The analysis of trends and revealed patterns showed the pres-
ence of a high level of copper solubility in the soil, as well as a
signicant biological availability by plants. The tendency of low
solubility in soil was found for lead. Meantime lead ion exhibits
intermediate behavior in terms of bioavailability by plants. As for
nickel, both in the soil and in the transfer to plants, it exhibits the
lowest chemical activity (Nalbandyan & Saakov, 2019).
In a number of studies, when assessing the hydroecological state
of territories under the inuence of anthropogenic activity, special
attention is paid to the study of the role of anthropogenic factors in
the formation of extreme hydrological situations (Koronkevich et
al., 1995; Koronkevich & Barabanova, 2015) and forecasting ne-
gative hydroecological situations (Koronkevich & Zaitseva, 1992).
The hydroecological risk was estimated by the method of point as-
sessment using indicator of water quality, population density (in-
dicator of anthropogenic load) and gradations of the intensity of
the ecological situation in the studied territory (Reshetnyak et al.,
2017). The assessment of the hydroecological situation is important
for the strategy of river basin management is characterized with a
slightly different approach.
Five particular parameters of the state of the basins, characterizing
the ecological value of a given territory were as following: the coef-
cient of economic use of land, the degree of water pollution, the density
of the river network, the degree of land reclamation, the groundwa-
ter level. These parameters were summed up (Belov & Zotov, 2008).
This article goal was to assess the environmental risk of water
pollution in the Masrik river basin, through territorial zoning, as-
sessing the level of river pollution in the designated zones, taking
into account the nature of the distribution of the population in the
basin.
M. A. Nalbandyan, A. O. Nersisyan
Environmental risk assessment in the Masrik River Basin
72 AGROLOGY | Volume 4 | Issue 2
Material and methods
Hydrochemical studies are based on monitoring data covering 9
sampling points for 2012‒2014 (Fig.1).
The Masrik River is located in the southeastern part of Lake
Sevan (40°00'‒40°15'N, 45°3' 45°59'E). The sampling site net-
work includes Masrik River with main tributaries. The Masrik River
has the largest drainage basin (685 sq.km) among the 28 tributa-
ries of Lake Sevan. The source is located at an altitude of 2880 m,
and the mouth at 1901 m. It crosses an area of 45 km covering
three high-altitude climatic zones: a) cold mountainous; b) mode-
rate, with short, cool summers and cold winters; c) moderate, with
relatively dry, warm summers and cold winters. The gradient of the
river is 27%, the average ow is 3.42 m, the ow in the lower part of
the course is relatively stable throughout the year due to 78% of the
underground recharge (Vardanian, 2012). The shape of the valley
changes from V-shaped to U-shaped, then to a at valley (Asatryan
& Dallakyan, 2018).
The bed of the Masrik River in the mountainous conditions of
the basin has a oodless character, the oodplain is developed only
within its at course. On the longitudinal prole of watercourses, a
change in the types of channels is traced ‒ from mountain-rapids to
plain-meandering with pronounced rifts and stretches. The river has
a great erosional force. Changes in temperature and precipitation by
seasons and heights cause uneven runoff. One of the main phases
of the river's water regime is the spring ood. In summer, there is
a sharp decrease in runoff. The Sotk River (the main tributary of
the Masrik River) originates at the pass of the same name at alti-
tudes of about 2500 m. The catchment area of the river is 18.5 km2,
strongly dissected by deep V-shaped erosional and tectonic valleys.
The slopes of which are steep and covered with grassy vegetation
(Sidorenko et al., 1962). Due to the articial drainage of Lake Gilly,
which was located in the river basin, the Masrik River currently
ows into Lake Sevan along an articially dug channel. The river
ow is regulated. Water is used for irrigation. The river is fed main-
ly underground (78%). The highest water level (36% of the annu-
al runoff) was observed in spring (Krylova, 2010). Geologically,
Mesozoic intrusive rocks and alluvial formations covering them are
widespread: eluvial ‒ deluvial, technogenic and alluvial ‒ proluvial
deposits. They are represented by sandy-loamy, clastic and sandy
gravel varieties of soils. The source of groundwater recharge is
atmospheric precipitation, the annual amount of which in the de-
scribed area is 500 mm, and evaporation is 250 mm (Hydrological
Atlas of Armenia, 1990). Methodologically, at the rst stage of the
study, on the basis of the previous study of the basin, those pollution
indicators that have a signicant contribution to this process were
identied and a database was compiled for these indicators. Further,
the river basin is divided into sub-districts, based on the territorial
characteristics of pollution. A comprehensive assessment of water
quality was carried out using selected indicators after ranking the
territory for each subarea at the appropriate sampling points relative
to the background concentrations of these quality indicators in the
Masrik river basin. Moreover, the background values are considered
the values of indicators characteristic of a watercourse devoid of
any anthropogenic impact. Concentration coefcients were calcu-
lated according to the method of geochemical assessment of surface
waters (Saet et al., 1982). As a result, the coefcients of the concen-
tration of pollutants in the waters of the river were obtained for the
corresponding monitoring points, taking into account the charac-
teristic of pollution. The zoning was performed and areas of zones
were calculated using a digital elevation model in the ArcGIS soft-
ware environment, taking into account sampling points and river
basins. At the same time, the territory was ranked using population
density data. These data were taken from reports on the website
of the Statistical Committee of RA (Statistical Committee of the
Republic of Armenia, 2021). The population density was calculated
from the data on the areas of the zones and the population size.
Then a geodatabase (GDB) was compiled, which presents the point
assessments of the state of river waters according to the level of the
pollutant concentration factor and population density.
The thematic layers based on the results of the indicators in the
ArcGIS program, were compiled on the basis of which a map was
obtained according to a point of environmental risk assessment.
The nal score, reecting the environmental risk, was deter-
mined by the formula (Zakrutkin et al., 2014):
, (1)
where: Bs ‒ a score of environmental risk;
B1 ‒ is an assessment of the state of river waters according to
the level of the pollutant concentration factor;
B2 – point estimate of population density.
Results
According to calculations for determination of the concentra-
tion coefcients for the considered heavy metals and basic ions, the
total and averaged coefcients were obtained for each identied
subarea of the catchment (Table 1).
Compared to other monitoring points, relatively high values of
nickel, lead, copper and zinc are observed in points 1 and 2, which
Fig. 1. Map of the Masrik River Basin and Sampling Locations
Sampling points: 1. Sotk River ‒ near gold ore deposit; 2. Sotk
River ‒ 1.5 km after the deposit, downstream; 3. Sotk river ‒ after
the deposit, the rst bridge; 4. Sotk river ‒ agricultural territory;
5. Left tributary of the Masrik-Aziz River, under the bridge; 6. Mas-
rik River ‒ near the village of Shatvan; 7. Masrik River ‒ near the
village. Metz Masrik; 8 Masrik River ‒ to Ghilli Bridge; 9. Masrik
River ‒ after Gilly Bridge
M. A. Nalbandyan, A. O. Nersisyan
Environmental risk assessment in the Masrik River Basin
AGROLOGY | Volume 4 | Issue 2 73
Moni-
toring
points
1
КС
2
КС
3
КС
4
КС
5 6
КС
7
КС
8
КС
9
КС
Back-
ground
data
Cu 0.4 0.6 2.3 3.7 0.6 1 0.5 0.9 1 0.8 1.35 0.7 1.16 0.7 1.22 0.7 1.16 0.6
Zn 0.7 1.38 2.0 4.25 0.4 1 0.2 0.5 1 3.5 7.47 5.1 11.22 0.6 1.17 2.8 5.96 0.5
Pb 1.5 2.86 0.6 1.05 0.7 1.21 0.7 1.22 1 0.6 1.14 0.5 1 0.7 1.21 0.7 1.27 0.6
Cd 0.2 1.87 0.2 2.5 0.1 1.25 0.1 1.25 1 0.1 1 0.2 1.87 0.1 1.62 0.1 1.62 0.1
Ni 6.8 6.7 9.0 9 5.0 5 0.1 0.1 1 0.0 0 0.0 0 5.0 5 3.0 3 0.0
Na+8.2 2.04 9.4 2.34 9.7 2.42 10.2 2.53 1 6.1 1.52 8.2 2.039 8.7 2.15 9.9 2.46 4.0
K+1.7 1.06 1.8 1.1 1.7 1.03 2.0 1.19 1 1.4 0.86 2.6 1.59 3.0 1.87 2.9 1.78 1.7
Ca2+ 44.5 4.23 48.7 4.63 46 4.38 44.0 4.18 1 20.5 1.95 35.9 3.41 27.0 2.56 26.4 2.51 10.5
Mg2+ 26.4 6.47 32.5 7.97 25 6.17 22.3 5.46 1 4.8 0.46 10.5 2.58 8.6 2.1 8.7 2.13 4.1
Cl-10.9 4.93 10.7 4.82 9.1 4.11 8.1 3.64 1 2.8 1.28 6.4 2.87 5.5 2.46 5.2 2.36 2.2
NO3- 6.3 7 6.9 7 6.8 7 4.0 4 1 1.3 1 6.3 6 4.5 4 5.7 6 1.0
sum 39.14 48.36 34.57 24.97 18.03 33.74 25.36 30.25
Average
for each
point
3.56 4.39 3.14 2.27 1 1.64 3.07 2.3 2.75
Table 1. Coefcients of excess of concentrations of chemical elements and compounds in river waters over background values
M. A. Nalbandyan, A. O. Nersisyan
Environmental risk assessment in the Masrik River Basin
74 AGROLOGY | Volume 4 | Issue 2
is due to the inuence of the Sotsk deposit. The pollution is local,
weakly expressed. The values of the calculated concentration co-
efcients for zinc decrease towards the monitoring point number 7
and signicantly increase at points 8 and 9, which may be caused
by the inuence of lowland type peat from Lake Gilly. According
to literary sources, low-lying peats are characterized by a high zinc
content in the surface layer (Mining encyclopedia, 2021).
Lead is characterized by relatively high values at point 1 near
the Sotk gold deposit and a tendency of decreasing coefcients from
the source of this river to the Masrik mouth. Already in point 2, the
value of the coefcient decreases, since lead, in view of the peculi-
arities of its chemical behavior in water, is adsorbed, binds, settling
and forming hard-to-dissolve salts. Consequently, for this metal in
the upper reaches of the river, there is a dependence on the anthro-
pogenic factor of an industrial nature, which does not manifest itself
in the lower reaches of the Sotk River and does not affect the quality
of water in the river basin as a whole.
The value of the sodium ion concentration coefcient at all
monitoring points is almost the same, with the exception of point
4, which is located within the agricultural lands and in the zone
of their impact, as indicated by the maximum value of the coef-
cient among all points. At point 6, a sharp decrease in the coefcient
is observed, which is associated with the conuence of a left-side
tributary in this section into the river, which is not subject to any
economic inuences.
The conuence of the inow leads to an increase in the water
discharge in this area and, in conditions of relatively low concentra-
tions of the ion in the water, leads to a sharp decrease in the value of
the coefcient. In the last two points, relatively high ion contents are
observed, which is due to the presence of residual peats of the Gilly
wetland lake, which belongs to the lowland type (Vardanyan, 1961)
and whose peats are distinguished by a higher sodium content and
its accumulation in the surface layer.
The potassium ion is characterized by relatively equal values of
the coefcient throughout the entire river watercourse with a slight
increase towards the river mouth, which is probably associated with
the inuence of municipal and agricultural ows into the river. In
point 6, the same tendency is observed for potassium as was found
for sodium.
In the direction from the source to the mouth, calcium, magnesi-
um and chlorine tend to decrease in concentrations in water, which
is probably due to the formation of salt formation of poorly soluble
compounds, in particular, chlorides. Sampling point 6 is highlighted
by the minimum values of the coefcient for these ions. Considering
the data in points 8 and 9 in comparison, we notice the proximity
of the values of chemical elements in these points, which is due to
the specic conditions of the Gilly wetland lake located here in the
past and low-lying peat soils (Agriculture from “A” to “Z”, 2013).
Summarizing the revealed patterns of dynamic changes in
chemical parameters throughout the basin of the Masrik River with
tributaries and taking them as the basis, we distinguish the follo-
wing subareas:
a) including the rst 3 monitoring points, characterized mainly
by natural features with a manifested anthropogenic inuence of the
Sotk deposit in the river catchment area;
b) including monitoring points 4, 5, 6 and 7 characterized by the
inuence of the agricultural factor in the conditions of the inow
into the main river, which has a natural quality characteristic of wa-
ter with low mineralization;
c) including monitoring points 8 and 9, characterized by specic
landscape conditions, low peat soils3 and corresponding geochem-
ical conditions.
As a result the corresponding risk zones were formed (table 2,
Fig. 2).
According to the calculation of the environmental risk score, the
total index for the rst zone was 9, for the second zone 6.4 and for
the third ‒ 15.9. Zones of environmental risk of water pollution in
the Masrik River are shown after mapping as well (Fig. 2).
The rst zone is characterized by a relatively average indica-
tor of population density, a high indicator of water pollution and a
relatively high total indicator of risk. On the basis of a comparative
analysis of all risk factors within the zone, it was revealed that a
high indicator for the rst zone is mainly due to industrial pollution.
The risk is assessed as medium. The second zone is characterized
by a low population density, a relatively low level of water pollu-
tion and, accordingly, a low total risk index. The current picture is
due to the conuence of the left-bank tributary of the Masrik River,
which, being devoid of any anthropogenic impact, is also characte-
rized by low mineralization. As a result, due to the additional vol-
ume of water, the river ow in this area increases, and even if there
Zones Density of the population Pollution level Total index
I 22 3.69 9
II 15 2.72 6.4
III 94 2.68 15.9
Table 2. Calculation of the environmental risk score
Fig. 2. Zones of environmental risk of water pollution
in the Masrik River
M. A. Nalbandyan, A. O. Nersisyan
Environmental risk assessment in the Masrik River Basin
AGROLOGY | Volume 4 | Issue 2 75
is an agricultural risk factor (use of chemical fertilizers) in the zone,
the level of the total environmental risk does not pose a serious dan-
ger. The vulnerability of this section of the river is minimal. Thus,
the second zone has a low environmental risk. The rst zone includ-
ed three sampling points. The second zone covered four subsequent
sampling points. The third area included the last two monitoring
sampling points. The third zone is characterized by a high coef-
cient of population density, although the nature of pollution is not
very toxic. At the same time it contributes to the formation of the
maximum total risk index among the calculated three zones. Thus,
a high risk of contamination is inherent in this area. Taking into
account the fact that the high risk is due to the density of the popu-
lation in the zone, it can be concluded that it is necessary to develop
appropriate measures for the management of untreated municipal
wastewater in the river basin, which is the main source of pollution.
Discussion
The characteristic of trends in concentration factors (excess over
background concentrations) of chemical indicators of water quality
in the Sotk - Masrik catchment was used as a justication for divi-
ding the catchment into sub-regions. As a result of the assessment
of natural conditions and factors of anthropogenic inuence for sol-
ving the problem, the Masrik river basin was divided into 3 zones.
The considered dynamic trends made it possible to reveal the
commonality of factors in the formation of water quality for indi-
vidual areas of the catchment area and formed the basis for the rank-
ing of the river catchment basin.
Heavy metals in rivers originate from multiple sources such as
weathering, industrial and domestic efuents, fertilizers etc. One of
the most important contributors to metal pollution of river basins is
(historic) mining activities. Acid-mine drainage, produced by the
oxidation of geological layers rich in pyrite, forms the most impor-
tant source (Fo¨rstner & Wittmann, 1983).
Heavy metal pollution in mining regions is widespread and
can be studied by relatively simple analysis and has therefore been
the subject of investigation in many rivers in the world (Farag et
al., 1997; Velde & Leuven, 1999; Sheykhi & Moore, 2012), which
demonstrated high concentrations of copper, lead, zinc, nickel in
river water.
The results of some investigations regarding the water quality
assessment suggested ю that tributaries were affected by local mi-
ning activity. Both natural weathering and mining contribute HMs.
Cr and Ni were homologous with a source from the weathering of
basic gabbro and serpentine at Yushigou. Mn appeared to be inu-
enced more by articial activities such as agriculture and grazing.
Depending on the mining technique involved, two pathways for the
release of HMs were distinguished in this area. For open-pit mining,
mining promoted the release of HMs primarily via enhanced wea-
thering (Wenhao et al., 2018).
According to the similar investigations with negative impact of
untreated domestic and industrial wastewater, loss of the capacity
for self-purication, due to prolonged and excessive discharge of
contaminated or insufciently puried wastewater, inevitably lead
to contamination of aquatic ecosystems of surface reservoirs of Dni-
propetrovsk region (Kulikova et al., 2018). Some studies conrm
the possibility of using not only GIS, but also remote sensing me-
thods, for environmental assessment of the surface water quality
state. Investigations of the state of the water bodies of the Dnipro
river tributaries show they varies considerably (Kharytonov et al.,
2018; Kharytonov et al., 2019) The similar tendencies of different
level of pollution and environment risk in river catchment observed
in our investigations as well.
Conclusion
The purpose of this study was to assess the environmental risk
of water pollution in the Masrik River basin. Among the sources
and pollution factors taken into account, in addition to natural and
anthropogenic ones, population density was also considered as a
demographic indicator calculated for each specic area of the catch-
ment area. As a result, using GIS technologies, a map of separate
subareas of the basin was obtained, reecting the level of environ-
mental risk in its respective 3 zones. According to the studies, it can
be concluded that environmental risk factors are diverse in nature
and degree of impact on water quality and are unevenly distributed
over the basin. A high dependence of the ecological risk on the po-
pulation density in the lower reaches of the river was found. The
low value and instability of the environmental risk in the middle
reaches are due to an increase in runoff due to lateral tributaries and,
at the same time, high variability of water discharge in tributaries
during a hydrological year. In addition to the theoretical importance,
the results are also of practical importance in terms of their use-
fulness and application in risk management programs in the basin,
measures to control the quality of pollution sources.
Acknowledgments
This study made throughout the basin of the Masrik River car-
ried out within the framework of the institute's budget program, sup-
ported by Science Committee of the Republic of Armenia.
References
Agriculture from “A” to “Z”. (2013). Retrieved from http://
racechrono.ru/torfyanye-pochvy/3210-sostav-mineralnoy-chas-
ti-v-torfyanyh-pochvah-chast-5.html
Asatryan, V. L., & Dallakyan, M. R. (2018). Assessment of seasonal
differences of ecological state of lotic ecosystems in the basin
of Lake Sevan (Armenia) by bioindication methods: case study
of Masrik River. Water Supply 19. doi: 10.2166/ws.2018.182
Belov, N. S., & Zotov, S. I. (2008). Assessment of the Hydroeco-
logical State of the River Systems of the Kaliningrad Region,
Natural Sciences, 1, 6‒16 (in Russian).
Farag, A. M., Woodward, D. F., Goldstein, J. N., Brumbaugh, W., &
Meyer, J. S. (1997). Concentrations of Metals Associated with
Mining Waste in Sediments, Biolm, Benthic Macroinverte-
brates, and Fish from the Coeur d'Alene River Basin, Idaho.
Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 34,
119–127. doi: 10.1007/s002449900295
Fo¨rstner, U., & Wittmann, G. T. W. (1983). Metal Pollution in the
Aquatic Environment. Springer Verlag, Berlin, Second Edition,
486. doi: 10.1007/978-3-642-69385-4
Hambaryan, L. R., Nalbandyan, M. A., & Poghosyan, A. M. (2015).
Peculiarities of Development of Phytoplankton as an Indicator
of the Ecological State in Modern Hydrochemical Conditions of
Masrik River, American Journal of Environmental Protection,
4(3‒1), 44‒50. doi: 10.11648/j.ajep.s.2015040301.18
Hydrological Atlas of Armenia. (1990). Publishing house of the
Academy of Sciences of RA, 68 (in Russian).
Kharytonov, M. М., Pugach, A. М., Stankevich, S. А., & Кozlova,
A. O. (2018). Geospatial assessment of the Mokra Sura river
ecological condition using remote sensing and in situ monitor-
ing data. Journ. Geol. Geograph. Geoecology, 27(3), 422–430.
doi: 10.15421/111866
Kharytonov M., M., Babenko, M. H., Sytnyk, S. A., & Maslikova,
K. P. (2019). Ecological assessment of water quality of Samot-
kan river in the area of polymetallic ores mining. Agrology,
2(1), 22‒26. doi: 10.32819/2617-6106.2018.14013
Koronkevich, N. I., & Zaitseva, I. S. (1992). Geographical direction
in the study and prediction of hydroecological situations. Izves-
tia RAS, Geographical series, publishing house Science (M.), 3,
23–32 (in Russian).
Koronkevich, N., I., Zaitseva, I. S., & Kitaev, L. M. (1995). Ne-
gative hydroecological situations. Izvestia RAS, Geographical
series, publishing house Science (M.), 1, 43–53 (in Russian).
M. A. Nalbandyan, A. O. Nersisyan
Environmental risk assessment in the Masrik River Basin
76 AGROLOGY | Volume 4 | Issue 2
Koronkevich, N. I., & Barabanova, E. A., (2015). Hydrological
Consequences of Economic Activity in the Watersheds, Funda-
mental problems of water and water resources: Proceedings of
the Fourth All-Russian Scientic Conference with international
participation, Moscow, IWP RAS, 305‒308.
Krylova, A. V. (2010). Ecology of the lake Sevan in the period
of its increase. Results of research of the Russian-Armenian
biological expedition on hydroecological survey of Lake Sevan
(Armenia). Makhachkala, Nauka DNTS, 348.
Kulikova, D. V., Kovrov, O. S., Buchavy, Y. V., & Fedotov, V. V.
(2018). GIS-based Assessment of the Assimilative Capacity
of Rivers in Dnipropetrovsk Region. Journ. Geol. Geograph.
Geoecology, 27(2), 274‒285. doi: 10.15421/111851
Mining encyclopedia. (2021). Retrieved from https://www.armstat.am
Nalbandyan, M. A., & Saakov, A. S. (2019). The patterns of heavy
metals accumulation in water, soil and their transfer in the soil-
plant system in the catchment area of the Sotk and Masrik ri-
vers, Agrology, 2(2), 112‒116. doi: 10.32819/019016
Nature of Armenia. (2006). Armenian Encyclopedia (in Armenian).
Reshetnyak, O. S., Nikanorov, A. M., Tromchuk, M. M., &
Grishanova Y. S. (2017). Assessment of hydroecological risk
in the OKA river basin. Water and ecology, 3, 159–171. doi:
10.23968/2305–3488.2017.21.3
Saet, Y. E., Aleksinskaya, L. N., & Yanin, E. P. (1982). Methodical
recommendations for geochemical assessment of pollution of
surface water courses by chemical elements, Edited by Grigory-
an. USSR Ministry of Geology, Moscow (in Russian).
Sheykhi, V., & Moore, F. (2012). Geochemical characterization of
Kor river water quality, Fars Province, Southwest Iran. Water
Quality, Exposure and Health, 4, 25–38. doi: 10.1007/s12403-
012-0063-1
Sidorenko, A. V., Mkrtchyan, S. S., Vardanyants, L. A., Gabrielyan,
A. A., Magakyan, I. G., & Paffengolts, K. N. (1974). Geology
of the USSR, Ministry of Geology of the USSR Department
of Geology of the Council of Ministers of the Armenian SSR,
Mineral Resources, 43(2) (in Russian).
Sidorenko, A. V., Mkrtchyan, S. S., Vardanyants, L. A., Gabrielyan,
A. A., Magakyan, I. G., & Paffengolts, K. N. (1962). Geology of
the USSR, Geomorphology, Publishing house of the Academy
of Sciences of Arm. SSR, 1, 90–97 (in Russian).
Statistical Committee of the Republic of Armenia. (2021). Retrieved
from https://www.armstat.am.
Vardanian, T. G. (2012). On Some Issues of the Anthropoge-
nic Transformation of Water Ecosystems (Case Study of Lake
Sevan). National Security and Human Health Implications of
Climate Change, Springer, 29, 325‒336. doi: 10.1007/978-94-
007-2430-3_29
Vardanyan, T. T. (1961). Brief botanical characteristics of peat in
Armenia. Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Armenian
SSR, 10, 98‒102 (in Russian).
Velde, G. V., & Leuven, R. S. E. W. (1999). Polluted river sys-
tems:Monitoring and assessment of ecotoxicological risks.
Acta Hydrochimica et Hydrobiologica, 27(5), 251–256. doi:
10.1002/(SICI)1521-401X(199911)27:5<251::AID-AHE-
H251>3.0.CO;2-I
Wenhao, W., Rui, M., Ziyong, S., Aiguo, Zh., Jianwei, B., Xiang, L.,
& Yunde, L. (2018). Effects of Mining Activities on the Release
of Heavy Metals (HMs) in a Typical Mountain Headwater Re-
gion, the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau in China. International Journal
of Environmental Research and Public Health, 15(9), 488. doi:
10.3390/ijerph15091987
Zakrutkin, V. E., Arkhipova, O. E., Gibkov, E. V., & Sklyarenko,
G. Y. (2014). The use of gis-technologies in the analysis of the
hydroecological situation in coal-mining regions (on the exam-
ple of the Eastern Donbass). Izvestiya Vuzov, North Caucasian
Region, Natural Sciences, 2, 85‒89 (in Russian).
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
The problem of pollution of the catchment area of the Masrik river, located in the basin of lake Sevan, is associated with the gold mining plant in the basin of its Sotk tributary, where ore is mined and crushed. Industrial activity changes the natural background of the formation of the quality of various media within the river basin in terms of the heavy me-tals content in them. Geo-ecological studies in areas of mining activity are relevant from the point of view of assessing the level of pollution and environmental quality control. The object is the drainage basin of the Masrik river with the Sotk tributary that flows near the territory of the gold ore plant. The subject of research is heavy metals in various environments ‒ in water, soil, plants, their behaviour, accumulation and transfer. The contents of Cu, Zn, Pb, Cr, Co, Cd and Ni were determined in water samples, floodplain soils and plants collected in the basins of the Sotk and Masrik rivers. The regularity of the prevalence of summer concentrations of copper over spring was established. It is associated with the difference in water flow in the river, when summer low water is characterized by a sharp decrease in the water content of the rivers. Lead is characterized by the predominance of spring concentrations in the upper reaches of the Sotk river and summer concentrations in the lower reaches of the Masrik River basin. This trend can be due to the washout of storm drains in spring in the Sotk River basin, which is characterized by steep banks and accumulation in the summer period in the flat part of the Masrik river. In general, for both seasons, zinc and nickel differ in relatively high concentrations. According to studies, the values of the distribution coefficient of heavy metals in soils showed a dependence on pH level. The distribution coefficients increased with decreasing acidity values. Pb was among the highest coefficients studied, and the minimum values were typical for Cu. The obtained values of the distribution coefficient indicate that copper has a high solubility and, under favourable conditions, passes into the soil solution. High lead coefficients indicate its low solubility and high adsorption in the soil. The results of the trends analysis and revealed patterns confirmed the presence of a high level of copper solubility in the soil, as well as the significant bioavailability of this metal to plants. For lead, trends of low solubility in soil have been found, but on the issue of bioavailability to plants, it exhibits ambiguous behaviour. Nickel, in terms of accumulation of soil–plant migration in the soil, shows the lowest chemical activity
Article
Full-text available
The industrial enterprise for the extraction of polymetallic ores Vilnohirskyi Mining and Metallurgical Integrated Works (MMIW) has assumed the responsibility for the removal and sewage treatment of industrial and communal significance. An essential part of the total wastewater discharge enters into the Samotkan river from the largest waste dump called as Skazhena ravine. Sludge setting tank in Skazhena ravine is located on the left bank of the Samotkan river. Kamianske reservoir is a receiving water of debalance wastewater of the plant according to the current permit for special water use, issued for the Vilnohirskyi MMIW. The discharge of waste water from the storage tank into the Skazhena ravine is carried out in the sanitary protection zone of Verkhniodniprovskyi and Aulskyi water intakes. The site of the water object, which is the release of wastewater from the reservoir in the Skazhena ravine is located within the boundaries of the settlement of the city of Verkhniodniprovsk. The tail farm in the Skazhena ravine is a place of waste depository, which are formed at the enriching plant in the process of developing the Malyshevskyi deposit of polymetallic ores. The chemical composition of the Samotkan river is formed under the influence of surface run-off and groundwater run-off, a drainage inflow from the Kamianske reservoir, evaporation of water from swamps, bodies of water, and discharges from the sludge setting tanks (reservoirs) of the Vilnohirskyi MMIW. Comparison of the calculation data of complex pollution with established by means fishery maximum permissible concentrations showed that the water of the Dnipro river at the place of its sampling in the Verkhniodniprovskyi water intake was estimated as “moderately polluted”. But, taking into account the requirements for communal needs, water is characterized as “pure”. The concentration of substances in the return water does not exceed the maximum permissible concentrations in the conditions of communal use of the water object. Changing the channel of the Samotkan river, transformation of several beams into slime tanks, and dumping the quarry waters in Kamianske water storage is a challenge for urgent search of the optimal technologies for solving these problems.
Article
Full-text available
The use of remote sensing methods for environmental monitoring of the surface water quality is proved. Regression relationships are consistent with ground-based measurements at sampling sites in water bodies and are an effective tool for assessing the ecological status of water bodies. The state of the water bodies of the Mokra Sura river basin varies considerably. The best is the water quality in the upper part of the Mokra Sura river, the worst – in the middle and lower parts. The factors of water pollution are discharges of not enough treated wastewater of industrial enterprises of the Kamyans’koy and Dniprovs’koy industrial agglomeration. The purpose of our search included the following tasks: (a) calculation of integrated environmental water quality indices; b) obtaining satellite information, processing of multispectral satellite images of water bodies using appropriate applied software techniques; c) establishment of statistical dependencies between water quality indexes obtained for biotopically space images and data of actual in situ measurements. The results of systematic hydrochemical control of the Mokra Sura river basin from 2007 to 2011 years were initial data in 4 control areas located in the Dnipropetrovsk region: 1 – the Sursko-Litovske village; 2 – the Bratske village; 3 – the Novomykolayvka village; 4 – the Novooleksandryvka village. Environmental assessment of the water quality of the Mokra Sura river within the Dnipropetrovsk region was based on the calculation the integrated environmental index ( IEI ). Priority pollutants in this case are oil products and ions 2−SO 4, 2 + Mg , 2 + Zn , 6 + Cr . Two images with a difference in three years in April 2015 and May 2017 were used to determine the current changes in the land cover of the study area. Geomorphological assessment of the water network of the Morka Sura river was performed using satellite radar interferometry. Multispectral images of Landsat 5/TM (2007-2011) and Sentinel 2B/MSI (2017) satellite systems were used forremote assessment of water bodies in the study area of the Mokra Sura river basin. The multispectral index TCW (Tasseled Cap Wetness) was used to measure the spectral reflection of the aquatic environment along of the Mokra Sura river flow. The main advantage of the studies is a demonstration of remote sensing capabilities to estimate Mokra Sura river ecological status not only in individual sites, but also throughout the flow – from source to mouth. Follow the necessity to use water from the Mokra Sura river for irrigation, the level of soil water erosion can only increase and enhance the negative processes of eutrophication of reservoirs. Long term technogenic pollution requires information about the state of surface water of fishery, drinking and municipal water use facilities as an integral part of the aquatic ecosystem, the habitat of aquatic organisms and as a resource of drinking water supply. Over 80% of the Mokra Sura river basin surface (IEI 4-12) belong to the classes with the assessment of dirty, very and extremely dirty. The results of studies using remote sensing indicate the need to reduce the streams of not enough treated wastewater to the the Mokra Sura river. The obtained data can be used for ecological assessment of the current and retrospective state of water bodies, development of forecasts of rivers pollution.
Article
Full-text available
The objective of this paper is to identify the level of changes in the ecological status of surface reservoirs of Dnipropetrovsk region under the impact of anthropogenic factors and to find a rationale for the limit loads on aquatic ecosystems, based on a quantitative assessment of their assimilative capacity values using GIS-technologies.To characterize and evaluate economic activity in the river basins of Dnipropetrovsk re- gion, the data of state statistical reporting by the form of 2-TP "Water resources management" of the State Agency for Water Re- sources of Ukraine were used. Parameters characterizing the assimilative capacity of water bodies were determined by taking into consideration the perennial average values of river runoff resources of the priority watercourses of Dnipropetrovsk region in the years with varying degrees of supply: with an average (50%), a low (75%) and a very low (95%) river water content. The main indicators characterizing the assimilative capacity of the water bodies of Dnipropetrovsk region are actual and necessary multiplicity of waste- water dilution, the limit to assimilative capacity of surface reservoirs, index of assimilative capacity utilization of river runoff re- sources of varying degrees of supply. A classification that characterizes the level of assimilative capacity utilization for water bodies is proposed. The level of assimilative capacity utilization of the Dnipro River in the reservoir areas, regardless of the degree of river runoff supply, is estimated as “allowable” . At 95% degree of river runoff supply, the level of assimilative capacity utilization of the Oril and Vovcha Rivers is characterized as “moderate”, the Samara River (after the confluence with the Vovcha River) as “high” and the Ingulets River with tributary the Saksagan River, and the Samara River (before confluence with the Vovcha River) as “veryhigh”. It should be noted that irrespective of the level of river runoff supply, the index of assimilative capacity utilization of the Samara River (before its confluence with the Vovcha River) exceeds the limit value by 19-115 times. For the spatial analysis of hydrological parameters and visualizion of the data in the form of thematic maps, the geoinformation system “Rivers of Dnipropetrovsk region” was developed on the basis of the ESRI ArcGIS Desktop10 software package. Using the geoprocessing tools, on the basis of hydrological indices of 7 priority watercourses for each of the 22 administrative-territorial districts of Dnipropetrovsk region, the main indicators characterizing the assimilative capacity of water resources were calculated and ranked. The use of indicatorscharacterizing the assimilative capacity of river runoff resources allows us to identify the threshold levels of anthropogenic transfor- mation of aquatic ecosystems, develop and implement environmental measures to improve the ecological status and ensure environ- mental safety of surface reservoirs.
Article
Full-text available
Understanding the heavy metal (HM) contamination in alpine mountain headwaters regions is important to maintaining the ecosystem stability of the basin. A total of 119 water samples and 104 sediment samples were collected along tributaries and the main course of Heihe River. The concentrations of eight heavy metals (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn) in water and sediment were measured to describe their spatial variability and to assess water quality. To identify the origins and pathways of HMs, anions, cations, and trace elements, as well as δD/δ18O stable isotopes in water samples were also measured. The results of water quality assessment suggested that tributaries were affected by local mining activity. Factor analysis in sediments showed that all HMs in sediments were inherited from the parent bedrock. Both natural weathering and mining contribute HMs. Cr and Ni were homologous with a source from the weathering of basic gabbro and serpentine at Yushigou. Mn appeared to be influenced more by artificial activities such as agriculture and grazing. Depending on the mining technique involved, two pathways for the release of HMs were distinguished in this area. For open-pit mining, mining promoted the release of HMs primarily via enhanced weathering. For underground mining, HMs might have contributed to greater acid mine discharge at high elevations due to the weak weathering processes. As the elevation decreases, precipitation increases, and a series of complex hydrological factor significantly affect leaching and runoff. The study results can be applied to improve water management efficiency.
Chapter
Full-text available
This paper discusses the influence of economic development in the basin of Lake Sevan. It shows that the decrease of lake’s water level has led to changes in the hydrological regime. The development in the basin has caused disruption of thermal and hydro-chemical regimes of the lake, deteriorating the water quality and increasing the water turbidity. The circulation of biological and chemical species has changed as well. Studies of the chemical composition of the water were launched at the end of the nineteenth century, and the first salt balance was determined in the 1930s. According to routine observations, 1 l of the lake’s water contains about 0.7 g salt in ionic form, which has changed by about 5–10% as a result of the decrease of water level. There have been changes in the general mineralization that are related to the decrease of the water level and the magnitude of its flow. In 1928–1930, well before artificial changes to the lake’s water level were realized, the total mineralization was 718.4 mg/l, while today it is 673 mg/l (1999–2002). The decrease of total general mineralization of lake water is strongly related to the massive outflow of salty water, which removed salts that have been accumulating in the lake for centuries. The studies of separate components of Lake Sevan balance show that under conditions of the global climate warming, evaporation from the lake’s surface may reach up to 145 × 106 m3/annum. Averaging of the consequences of possible climate change on river runoff points at the possible decrease of water resources of the lake’s basin by −2.51% by the end of the first half of the twenty-first century. It is hard to predict the future developments of these processes. However, the issue of Lake Sevan is not entirely settled as the ecosystem of the lake is damaged and is undergoing the process of eutrophication. The flora and fauna of the water and coast have undergone serious and irreversible changes.
Article
Full-text available
This paper is related to the study of hydro chemical characteristics and the phytoplankton of the river Masrik. For planktonic study, algae were selected from 3 sampling sites: two from tributaries of the river and one from the river Masrik. Hydro chemical monitoring includes 9 sampling points. The study includes the spring of 2014 and the summer of 2013. According to the hydro chemical research of water, the pH ranged from 6.5-7.3. In 2014, the pH was lower compared with the spring of the previous year. Among tested anions, in some areas, relatively high level of sulfates were reached 80-120 mg /L. Total hardness ranged from 0,6-5,6 mg-eqv /L, and the total mineralization-was ranged from 60 to 430 mg /L. Studies of heavy metals revealed a relatively high content of lead, nickel and chromium in water. Visual assessment revealed a significant organic pollution of Masrik river, which confirmed by high levels of BOD5 in water in 2014. In Masrik river mainly 3 groups of algae were detected: diatoms, green and blue-green. Dominant group was diatoms. Dominated types of algae were β-mezosaprobs (about 53%), which indicated the average level of organic pollution of the river. As a part of the green algae Spirogira sp. was found. The maximum number of phytoplankton in the investigated areas was 16,854,000 cells / L, and the biomass was 162g /m3, the minimum rates-respectively 464 000 cells /l in and 2.8 g/m3 for biomass. In water samples well developed whorls algae of the genus Chara were found, which presence indicates anthropogenic pollution. Thus, in a more acidic environment, the presence of high levels of organic pollution creates favorable conditions for the growth and development not only phytoplankton such as algae, but also for macrophytes, which indicates the reduction of ecological status of rivers.
Article
Full-text available
A study was conducted on April, 2010 to evaluate the surface water quality from 29 sampling points along the Kor River in Fars province SW Iran. The Kor River plays a key role in supplying water for municipal and industrial users, and for irrigation. In the last few decades rapid industrialization and urbanization along the river course has increased the pollution load of the river water. In this study, 13 physicochemical parameters (pH, EC, NO3, TA, PO4, SO4, As, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mo, Ni, and Zn) are determined and the quality of water is evaluated using various tools, such as piper, sodium absorption ratio (SAR), U.S. salinity laboratory classification (USSL), heavy metal pollution index (HPI) and heavy metal evaluation index (HEI). Results show that the effluents discharged from industrial units and municipal sources has led to increased EC (6500–21510 μs/cm), TDS (4566–12632 mg/l), NO3 (15–1421 mg/l), Cl (1205–7161 mg/l), SO4 (2400–7008 mg/l), Hg (0.1–6.3 ppb), Cr (6–268 ppb), Mo (18.3–78.2 ppb) and Ni (7.4–24.1 ppb) in at least four sampling stations. The Piper plot reveals the dominance of Na+–K+–Cl− type of hydrogeochemical facies. In the USSL plot 34.48% of water samples fall in C2S1, C3S1 and C3S2 zones, which are suitable for irrigation. Also, a reclassification of the HPI and HEI categories using median values show that 3.5% of HPI values and 13.8% of HEI values are classed as high. Sewage inputs from industrial and municipal sources are responsible for the observed high concentration of many physicochemical parameters in the Kor River.
Article
Full-text available
In the past chemical, ecological, and toxicological research was carried out in a separate way. Nowadays, more and more studies are undertaken considering these three approaches in an integrated way (triad studies). A sophisticated combination of chemical and biological monitoring and bioassays can improve water quality management of polluted rivers. Application of quantitative structure-activity relationships (QSARs), algorithms for mixture toxicity of known substances, chemical group parameters, and response-oriented sum parameters, may reduce uncertainties in ecotoxicological risk management.Verschmutzte Flußsysteme:: Monitoring und Bewertung der ökotoxikologischen RisikenIn der Vergangenheit wurden chemische, ökologische und toxikologische Forschungen nebeneinander durchgeführt. Heutzutage jedoch werden immer mehr Untersuchungen gemacht, die alle drei Herangehensweisen integrieren (triad studies). Eine fortentwickelte Kombination von chemischem und biologischem Monitoring und Bioassays kann das Wasser-Qualitäts-Management verschmutzter Flüsse verbessern. Die Anwendung von quantitativen Struktur-Aktivitäts-Beziehungen (QSAR), Algorithmen für Mischungstoxizität bekannter Substanzen, chemischen Gruppenparametern und reaktionsorientierten Summenparametern kann die Unsicherheiten im ökotoxikologischen Risikomanagement herabsetzen.
Article
Complex studies of seasonal differences of the ecological state of Masrik River (Armenia) were realized in 2017. Water quality was assessed by BMWP, ASPT and FBI indices based on studies of qualitative and quantitative structures of benthic macro-invertebrates. Potential reference sites in the basin were revealed using the %EPT taxa index in addition to water quality assessment by bioindication methods as well as hydro-chemical, -physical and -morphological measurements. The applicability of the used biotic indices for the different parts of Masrik River was discussed.