ArticlePDF Available

RACI Matrix Design for Managing Stakeholders in Project Case Study of PT. XYZ

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Stakeholders are one of the most significant factors in the success of a project. The creation of good team performance in a project is caused by clear work responsibilities given to each project stakeholder so that stakeholders have responsibility for their work and can complete their work correctly. The responsibility assignment matrix is a method for managing the roles of each resource and describing the relationship between jobs for each job in the project, which is classified into four parts, namely Responsible, Assignment, Consult, and Informed. In this paper, a matrix will be designed to manage the work assignments of each stakeholder involved in the case of delays in project completion at PT. XYZ uses the RACI Matrix method as a guide. The results of the work assignment matrix design in the case study project of PT. XYZ shows that 12 stakeholders are grouped into four classifications according to the RACI components, which are arranged based on the level of interest and responsibility of each stakeholder to the project.
Content may be subject to copyright.
VOL. 05 NO. 02 (2021)
© Telkom University
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INNOVATION IN
ENTERPRISE SYSTEM
Journal homepage: https://ijies.sie.telkomuniversity.ac.id/index.php/IJIES/index
e-ISSN: 2580-3050
*putrasuhanda@student.telkomuniversity.ac.id 122
RACI Matrix Design for Managing Stakeholders in Project Case Study of PT.
XYZ
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda1*, Devi Pratami2
1,2 School of Industrial and System Engineering, Telkom University, Indonesia
Jl. Telekomunikasi Terusan Buah Batu, Bandung, 4025, INDONESIA
*putrasuhanda@student.telkomuniversity.ac.id
ARTICLE INFO
ABSTRACT
Article history:
Received 16 June 2021
Accepted 26 July 2021
Published 31 July 2021
Stakeholders are one of the most significant factors in the success of a project. The creation of good
team performance in a project is caused by clear work responsibilities given to each project
stakeholder so that stakeholders have responsibility for their work and can complete their work
correctly. The responsibility assignment matrix is a method for managing the roles of each resource
and describing the relationship between jobs for each job in the project, which is classified into four
parts, namely Responsible, Assignment, Consult, and Informed. In this paper, a matrix will be
designed to manage the work assignments of each stakeholder involved in the case of delays in project
completion at PT. XYZ uses the RACI Matrix method as a guide. The results of the work assignment
matrix design in the case study project of PT. XYZ shows that 12 stakeholders are grouped into four
classifications according to the RACI components, which are arranged based on the level of interest
and responsibility of each stakeholder to the project.
Keywords:
Business Process;
Responsibility Assignment
Matrix; Project
Management; RACI Matrix;
1. Introduction
Projects can be said to be successful when they can achieve the goals that have been set at the beginning of project
planning [1]. The thing that must be done when determining a goal for a project to be carried out is by considering the
quality of the project. The quality management plan is one way that can be used to outline all the activities that must be
carried out by the team as well as other activities such as managing the resources needed to achieve the expected level of
project quality [2]. Delay is one of the things that are not desirable in completing a project. The 85 percent of problems
with project quality are caused by improper management of project resources such as teamwork systems to an
inappropriate division of work responsibilities on teams [2]. Stakeholder management is critical to every project's success
that can affect the result of the project [3]. Stakeholder management is one of the project managers' strategies to streamline
all aspects related to their project [4]. To create a good team performance in a sustainable manner, it is necessary to have
clarity of work responsibilities given to each team member so that each team member has responsibility for their own
work and is able to complete their work well [5]. Stakeholder involvement can be controlled by identifying the roles of
each stakeholder. Stakeholder management is focused on providing the ease of communication needed during project
implementation [6].
In carrying out the project, a document is needed to facilitate the exchange of information. Communication will be
successful if the sender of information is able to convey information well, which results in feedback from the recipient
of the information [7]. Therefore, this study aims to redesign the matrix for managing the roles and responsibilities of
stakeholders as outlined in the responsibility assignment matrix. The responsibility assignment matrix can assist the
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
© Copyright by Telkom University 123
project owner in managing the roles and responsibilities of each project stakeholder so that the project can run according
to plan. besides that, responsibility assignment matrix is a simple method, which has high flexibility, so it is very easy to
use by new users and applied to projects that have an uncertain character [8].
1.1. Objective
The development of today increasingly digital human lifestyle also affects project life with increasing virtual media due
to teams scattered in various locations, requiring project managers to communicate in different ways, one of which is
virtually [9]. The increase in the use of virtual meeting applications will automatically increase the number of internet
users significantly. The increase will impact the quality of the internet, which will further decline if there is no increase
in infrastructure on the internet network. PT. XYZ is a company engaged in information and communication technology
(ICT) services and telecommunications networks in Indonesia. In fulfilling the demands of the increasing internet needs,
PT. XYZ is currently modernizing and expanding its infrastructure network. One of the projects is currently being carried
out by PT. XYZ is a fiber optic feeder construction project. Fiber optic feeder is one of the network transmission media,
which is one of the components of FTTH (Fiber To The Home). Fiber optic is a type of cable made of glass fiber or
smooth plastic that can transmit light signals from one place to another. Fiber optic path width is larger and capable of
carrying a lot of data, loading very large information with transmission speeds of up to gigabytes per second, capable of
delivering long-distance information without repetition [10]. The other advantage of using fiber optic is that it has a large
bandwidth capacity than copper cables and is not susceptible to interference, one of which is from electrical frequency
[11].
Currently, there are projects underway, one of which is the construction of a fiber optic feeder or what is commonly
known as a feederization project. This project is targeted for completion in June 2021, but in reality, this project has
experienced several obstacles in its implementation, which resulted in the completion of the project not being following
the plan. One of the factors that cause delays is the unclear roles and responsibilities of each stakeholder involved in the
project. The following is the delay data presented in the form of an s-curve. The results of interviews that have been
conducted with one of the project managers said that there were several factors causing the delay in the completion of
the project, which was grouped by type. Delays based on the grouping of human resources in the project are caused by
several factors such as unclear roles and responsibilities of each stakeholder, a lack of understanding of the workforce
regarding the technicalities of the work being carried out, as well as supervision of suboptimal workforce performance.
2. Literature Review
2.1 Resource management
Project Resource Management is a stage in identifying, obtaining, and managing the resources needed to achieve project
objectives. This stage aims to ensure that each project resource has been allocated to the right place. When resources are
not managed and controlled properly, it will increase the risk that can hinder project completion [7]. There are many
methods of data representation used in resource management that aim to document and communicate the roles and
responsibilities of team members. In comparison, the data representation is presented in a hierarchical, matrix, or text-
oriented form. The other purpose of documentation is to ensure that each activity has a clear responsibility and that all
team members clearly understand their roles and responsibilities [7].
2.1.1 Outputs
The resource management plan is something that to do during project management. The purpose is to provide guidance
to the project in managing, allocating, and categorizing the project resources. The following are some human resource
management plans [7].
1. Resource identification: Resource identification is a technique for identifying and considering the human resources
needed for a project.
2. Roles and responsibility such as:
a. Role: The role is the behavior expected of someone who holds the status
b. Authority: The authority is a right to act owned by human resources on the project
c. Competence: Competence is a skill that must have by every human resource involved in the project
d. Responsibility: The responsibility is something that has to be completed by every person involved in the project.
2.2 RACI Matrix
Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed (RACI), or often called the Responsibility Assignment Matrix (RAM),
is a helpful tool for describing the work responsibility assignment matrix. RACI Matrix can manage the assignment of
resources for each job on the project. The RACI Matrix is usually used to describe the relationship between jobs,
determine the roles, responsibilities, and levels of authority for each activity in the project. [7]. Responsible, Accountable,
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
124
Consulted, Informed (RACI ) has a very strong influence because this matrix can provide ease of communication between
the project manager and his team in determining their role in the project [8]. According to [12] Responsible, Accountable,
Consulted, Informed (RACI) also has several other benefits, such as:
1. Make team communication easy
RACI makes it easy for team members involved in the project to communicate. With this method, the tasks for each team
are clearly defined so that communication between team members is easier to do because each team already knows the
role they are playing.
2. Set the number of teams in one task
The RACI matrix can determine who is the most suitable in carrying out a task according to the position held by the
candidate in charge. Thus, an effective division of roles is easy to do using the RACI Matrix so that there is no excess of
people in certain positions.
3. Adjust the proportion of workload.
RACI also provides benefits in managing the proportion of workload for each team member not to experience overload.
When someone does too much work, it will certainly result in less than optimal performance, so that employees are at
risk for experiencing stress at work caused by high workload pressure. By using RACI Matrix, each team member will
be positioned according to his ability.
RACI functions as a baseline for the communication plan by determining who receives information, how often, and at
what level of detail. The RACI Matrix must be defined at the final stage of the planning phase, which will later be
included in the Project Charter. The definition of the RACI matrix method can be seen below.
1. Responsible
Provides information that the team member is the person who is responsible for carrying out a task until it is completed.
2. Accountable
It is information that members of this team are responsible for all tasks delegated to team members. This person also has
the authority to make decisions regarding the assignment. This role is crucial because this person is responsible for every
decision he has made.
3. Consulted
Those who get this role have expertise in their field because they will be in charge of providing information on the project
being worked on.
4. Informed
Those who get this role is always informed of the progress of a project that is being carried out. Any changes and the
results of decisions taken must be notified to someone who has this role.
3. Methodology
Based on the research objective, which is to design an assignment matrix for each stakeholder involved in the PT. XYZ,
the RACI Matrix method, is used for the solution.
Fig. 1 Conceptual Model
The conceptual model is a framework that shows the relationship between several ideas to solve a problem. Conceptual
models can explain the relationship between these concepts [13]. Based on the conceptual model in Figure 1 above, it
can be seen how the relationship between each data in this research process in designing the RACI Matrix. At the initial
stage, identifying and collecting project data is carried out and describes the activities carried out on the project following
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
© Copyright by Telkom University 125
the work breakdown structure (WBS), which will be a reference in designing the business process. Based on the business
process results, an assignment matrix is determined using the RACI Matrix, which will result in the roles and
responsibilities of each stakeholder involved in the project. The data collected includes the project stakeholder list, project
organizational structure, work breakdown structure, and project activity list. Furthermore, data processing will be carried
out starting with analyzing business process documents for each job description on the project, which will later be
followed by designing an assignment matrix using the RACI Matrix Method.
4. Data Collection
At this stage, the data collection process needed in this research will be carried out, which will then be processed to obtain
the research results. The following are supporting data in this study.
4.1 Statement of Work
The statement of work (SOW) is a detailed narrative description of all the work to be done on the project. The document
clarifies the project description to be undertaken so that prospective vendors or stakeholders who will complete the project
can decide whether they can complete the project [14]. The following is a statement of work for the PT.XYZ project.
1. Project Owner
The project owner of feederization project is PT. XYZ
2. Company Profile.
PT. XYZ is a company engaged in telecommunications services that provide internet network services to meet the needs
of its customers. With the increasing use of the internet, the impact of increasing customer demand in the use of services
from PT. XYZ. Efforts made by PT. XYZ to meet the needs of its customers, namely by increasing the capacity and
quality of the internet it produces, namely by replacing copper cables into optical fiber as a more effective internet
network distribution medium.
3. Project Title
The project title is Arengka STO Fiber Optic Feeder Development
4. Project Places
The project location is across 7 points in the STO Arengka area, Pekanbaru Riau
5. Project Duration
The project duration starts in February 2021 to June 2021.
6. Project Description
The feederization project aims to increase the slot capacity in the Optical Distribution Cabinet, which will be connected
to the Optical Distribution Point. This project aims to increase the number of users of internet services offered with good
quality internet.
4.2 Work Breakdown Structure
Work Breakdown Structure, better known as WBS, is a hierarchy of all the work that must be done by the teams involved
in the project to be completed so that the objectives of the project can be achieved [7]. WBS is one of the things needed
in project management to provide clarity of work in each project scope broken down into work packages [2]. The
following is a WBS from a case study of the PT.XYZ project.
Based on the work breakdown structure in Figure 2. This shows that the case study of the PT. XYZ divides its project
work into two stages of work, namely the feeder tracking stage and the ODC development stage.
Fig. 2 - Work Breakdown Structure
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
126
4.3 Stakeholders Register
Stakeholder Register is a document used for project management in identifying, assessing, and classifying stakeholders
involved in the project. The Stakeholder Register can provide an overview of the role of each. The stakeholder register
for the PT. XYZ will be shown in the Table 1 as follow:
Table 1 - Stakeholder Register
No
Stakeholders
Stakeholders Classification
1
Manager
Internal
2
Manager Assistant
Internal
3
Site Coordinator
Internal
4
Asset Manager
External
5
Vendor
External
6
Work Member
External
7
City government
External
8
Urban Village
External
9
Neighborhood and Hamlet
External
10
Land owner or community
External
Based on the stakeholder register table as shown in Table 1. We know that there are several stakeholders involved in the
case study of PT. XYZ. The stakeholders involved from the project owner point of view are called internal stakeholders,
namely Manager, Manager Assistant, Site Coordinator. Meanwhile, stakeholders who are working partners of the project
owner are referred to as external stakeholders, namely Asset Manager, Vendor, Work Member, City government, Urban
Village, Neighborhood and Hamlet, Landowner or community.
4.4 Project Organizational Structure
Organizational structure is one of the most critical things in a project. With the organizational structure, it will be clear
how the relationship between the team in the project or the relationship between different projects. It will also show the
level of authority, oversight of communication lines, coordination, and collaboration of each project team. The projectized
organizational structure is an organizational structure that gives the project manager great authority to have substantial
control over the project and is also fully responsible for the project's success. Team members are specially assigned only
to manage projects from different departments according to project requirements. This organizational structure builds a
strong focus on running the project and having a good understanding of the project objectives. Large organizations often
use this organizational structure to produce significant, valuable, and long-term projects [15]. The following is the project
organization structure in the case study of PT. XYZ
Fig. 3 - Project
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
© Copyright by Telkom University 127
4.5 Activity List
Activity List is data that contains a description of the project activities. The Activity List also explains the scope of work
and job descriptions for each work package in detail, making it easier for the project team to understand the work
completion. Table 2 has shown the activity list for the feederization project.
Table 2 - Activity List (Part-1)
No
Job description
Activity List
1
Government Licensing
1. The field supervisor completes the requirements in applying for a city
government permit.
2. Submit the required documents to the relevant city government.
2.
HDPE Material
Procurement
Submission of phase 1 materials by the field supervisor to the Asset Manager of PT.
XYZ
3.
Manhole Construction
1. Carry out a land clearing for the project.
2. Make a cube-shaped iron frame with a side length of 1.5 square meters as a cast
frame.
3. To do excavating square-shaped soil.
4. Install the iron frame into the hole.
5. To do Installing the manhole wall castings and trimming the HDPE installation
grooves.
6. To do casting using cast cement.
7. To do tidying up the area around the construction of the manhole and closing
the manhole.
8. Checking the work
4
HDPE Installation
1. Installing HDPE
2. Connecting HDPE
3. Installing HDPE accessories (sockets, rings, etc.)
4. Ensure that there are no gaps in the connection
5. Ensure that the HDPE is positioned correctly.
6. Check the installation results.
5
Feeder Cable Installation
1. Feeder cable withdrawal from nearest STO
2. To do Installing the feeder into the previously made HDPE pipe.
3. Provide spare or allowance on cables under certain circumstances or as a
preventive measure.
4. Doing job checks.
6
Citizen Licensing
Request permission from a resident or the owner of the land where the ODC is
built.
7
Procurement of Material
To do Submitting ODC development materials to the asset manager of PT. XYZ by
the implementing supervisor.
8
ODC Foundation
Development
1. Excavating for the ODC foundation
2. Install the iron frame foundation into the hole that has been dug.
3. Install the ODC buffer as high as 60 cm from the surface area
4. Casting the foundation hole until the mold is complete.
5. To do installing a black ceramic floor on the ODC leg.
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
128
9
ODC Installation
1. Installation of Dina Bolt
2. Lifting ODC to the feet
3. Locking Dina Bolt
4. Installing the grounding system
6. Checking
10
Feeder Cable Installation
1. Connecting the end of the feeder cable to the pigtail
2. Install bestray into ODC
3. To do connecting feeder cable that has been linked with the pigtail to the bestray
contained in the ODC.
5. Commissioning Test and Acceptance Test
5. Graphical Results
The following is the result of managing the assignment matrix for stakeholders involved in the PT. XYZ project. The
RACI Matrix is designed into two separate parts, which are classified into two parts, namely the internal stakeholder and
external stakeholders.
5. 1 Activity Diagram Document
An activity diagram is a chart with certain symbols representing the flow of a series of work activities in detail and
describing the relationship between one process and another in an activity. An activity diagram is a tool used to describe
a process in detail. Activity diagrams have symbols consisting of squares, diamonds, and other shapes connected by
arrows. Activity diagrams combine symbols and flow lines to describe an operation on an activity.[16]. The following is
an example of a business process that has been designed for HDPE material procurement activities.
Fig. 4 - Activity Diagram of HDPE Material Delivery
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
© Copyright by Telkom University 129
5. 2 RACI Matrix
The following is a RACI Matrix table that has been adapted to the project business processes. Ten project activities have
been adjusted to the activity list and WBS, and there are nine stakeholders involved in this case study project.
Table 4 - RACI Matrix for Internal Stakeholder
NO
Activity
Manager
Manager Assistant
Site Coordinator
1
Government Licensing
A
C, I
R
2
Citizen Licensing
A
C, I
R
3
HDPE Material Procurement
A
C, I
I
4
ODC Material Procurement
A
C, I
I
5
Manhole Construction
A
I
C, I
6
HDPE Installation
A
I
C, I
7
Feeder Cable Installation
A
I
C, I
8
ODC foundation development
A
I
C, I
9
ODC Box Installation
A
I
C, I
10
Feeder cable Installation to ODC
A
I
C, I
Table 4 shows the results of the preparation of the assignment matrix based on internal stakeholders from the project
owner point of view. The following will show the results of the RACI Matrix design based on external stakeholders.
Table 5 - RACI Matrix for External Stakeholder
NO
Activity
Work
Member
Asset
Manager
City
Government
Urban
Village
Neighborhood
and Hamlet
Community
1
Government Licensing
-
-
I
I
I
-
2
Citizen Licensing
-
-
-
-
I
I
3
HDPE Material
Procurement
R
I, R
I
-
-
-
4
ODC Material
Procurement
R
I, R
I
-
-
-
5
Manhole Construction
R
-
I
I
I
I
6
HDPE Installation
R
-
-
I
I
I
7
Feeder Cable Installation
R
-
I
I
I
I
8
ODC foundation
development
R
-
I
I
I
I
9
ODC Box Installation
R
-
I
I
I
I
10
Feeder cable Installation
to ODC
R
-
I
I
I
I
Based on the results of the formation of the RACI Matrix in the table. 4-5. Determination RACI Matrix elements are
formed based on the roles and responsibilities of each stakeholder that has been established in the business process. As
for R (Responsible) Provides information that the team member is the person who is responsible for carrying out a task
that he gets to completion. A (Accountable) is information that this team member is responsible for all tasks assigned to
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
130
his team members. This person also has the authority to make decisions related to the assignment. This role is crucial
because this person is responsible for every decision he has made. C (Consulted) is someone who gets this role and has
expertise in their field. Usually, this role is often used as a consultant on project activities. I (Informed) is a person who
always gets information on the project progress being carried out, and every decision taken must be communicated to the
person assigned to this role.
6. Results Analysis
Based on Tables 4 and 5. RACI Matrix above has formulated the roles and responsibilities for each stakeholder involved
in the PT.XYZ project. The management of the work assignment matrix using the RACI Matrix method has been formed.
There are nine stakeholders involved in the PT.XYZ project which is classified into four classifications according to the
components in the RACI Matrix and has been adjusted to the roles and responsibilities of stakeholders sourced from
business processes and activity list projects. The other method used is by observing a series of project activities and
conducting interviews with several parties from the project owner and the project vendor who handles the project.
With the formation of the RACI Matrix in the PT.XYZ project, all roles, and responsibilities of each stakeholder have
been clearly defined. To produce a RACI matrix that can assist project owners in managing all the roles and
responsibilities of project stakeholders, it is necessary to document activity diagrams per project activity as previously
mapped and the organizational structure used in the project. Furthermore, interviews with several experts involved in the
feederization project are also required. If the management of previously an obstacle to project completion has been
resolved, then the project can run normally as planned.
Based on the results of the preparation of the RACI Matrix in Tables and the previous data processing, it can be seen
that to run the project in the PT.XYZ case study it takes five stakeholders who have important job descriptions on the
project, namely Manager, Assistant Manager, Site Coordinator, Asset Manager, Work Members. The roles and
responsibilities of each relevant stakeholder can be seen in the following table:
Table 6 - Stakeholder Job Description
Manager
Responsible
1. Take full responsibility for the sustainability and success of the project.
2. Responsible for maintaining the performance of team members and responsible for
time and cost minimization.
3. Organizing meetings related to project vendors on the project and cost minimization
Authority
1. Have the authority to make the right decisions to use on the project
2. Signing the handover document
3. Make a selection in choosing vendors or partners
Competencies
1. Have high knowledge of project
2. Good analytical skills
3. Have good ethics
4. Ability in influencing
5. Communication skills
6. Ability to lead
Qualifications
1. Have certified in the project field.
2. Has passed the assessment as AOM manager from the PT. XYZ company.
3. Have a leadership certificate
4. Have a minimum S1 diploma in the field of telecommunications or IT
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
© Copyright by Telkom University 131
Manager Assistant
Responsible
1. Assist the manager in analyzing the data needed for the project
2. Responsible for the master plan design process.
3. Forward every progress report from the field supervisor to the AOM manager.
4. Provide information about the data needed by the team
Authority
1. Give instructions to the field supervisor
2. Monitoring and controlling the project
3. Evaluate the performance of each stakeholder
Competencies
1. Have the ability to communicate
2. Have good ethics
3. Have the ability as a leader
4. Have the ability to process financial data
5. Have the ability in project data documentation.
Qualifications
1. Minimum education degree
2. Have a license or certificate of expertise in operating Microsoft
3. TOEFL certification
4. Have experience as assistant manager
5. Have knowledge and certification in the project field
Site Coordinator
Responsible
1. Responsible for supervising project work directly at the project site.
2. Checking the quality of the work
3. Make progress reports and project results to be submitted to asman. Construction &
Spv.
4. Follow the technical instructions for project work based on the direction of the assistant
manager.
5. Reporting obstacles that occur at the project site
Authority
1. Determining the feasibility of the work
2. Determine the results of the work member performance evaluation
3. Submit a request for material procurement or increase the number of work members
Competencies
1. Have the ability in quality control
2. Have the ability to communicate
3. Have the ability as a leader
4. Have good ethics
5. Have understanding and experience in the project field
Qualifications
1. Have certification in the project field
2. Have completed the assessment test given by the company as an eligibility
requirement
3. Have a minimum diploma S1
Table 7 - Stakeholder Job Description
Asset Manager
Responsible
1. Responsible for ensuring the availability of goods needed on the project.
2. Check the availability of goods.
3. To do checking the quality of the material to be sent to avoid product defects.
4. To do check the goods to be submitted to minimize material mismatches.
5. Responsible for fulfilling all material requests.
6. Responsible for all warehouse inventory assets.
Authority
1. Has the authority to determine the acceptance order from Asman. construction & spv
2. Have the authority to select logistics vendors for the material mobilization process.
3. Has the authority to determine the right supplier in meeting material stock needs.
Competencies
1. Have high knowledge of project materials
2. Good analytical skills
3. Have good ethics
4. 4bility in influencing
5. Communication skills
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
132
6. Ability to lead
Qualifications
1. Certified in the project field
2. Has passed the assessment as an asset manager from the PT.XYZ company
3. Have a leadership certificate
4. Have a minimum diploma of S1 in the field of telecommunications or IT
Work Member
Responsible
1. Complete all physical work on project activities
2. Reporting the progress of the work to the field supervisor
3. Report incidents in the project area to the field supervisor
4. Propose procurement following project needs.
Authority
Have the authority to accept or reject the work contract for the next project.
Competencies
1. Have basic skills as a construction worker (builder).
2. Have good ethics
3. Able to operate construction work equipment
Qualifications
1. Have experience in working as a construction worker (builder)
2. Maximum age 40 years old
3. Physically and mentally healthy
7. Conclusion
This research concludes that the human resources on the project must be appropriately managed so that the project
completion is as expected. The RACI matrix can provide convenience in managing stakeholders in this feederization
project. The RACI matrix groups the roles of each stakeholder involved in the project into four components: responsible,
accountable, consulted, and informed. The design of the RACI Matrix on the case study project of PT. XYZ was formed,
starting with conducting interviews and identifying stakeholders involved in the PT.XYZ case study project. With the
formation of the RACI Matrix, the roles and responsibilities of each stakeholder in the project will be more precise, and
Job description documents can be more easily determined. The purpose of designing the RACI Matrix is to overcome the
delay factor caused by the stakeholder and resource aspects, the project owner's responsibility as a decision-maker. With
the RACI Matrix, it is hoped that it will facilitate communication between the project owner and all stakeholders involved
in the case study of PT. XYZ and the role for each stakeholder has been well managed so that the risk of obstacles caused
by resource management factors at the next project stage becomes smaller. As for suggestions that can be given to the
next research, namely, to analyze the limitations and efforts at the next research object to implement RACI Matrix. As
for the analysis of efforts to simplify the process of implementing the RACI Matrix on research projects, namely based
on aspects of man, methods, money, machines, time.
Disclaimer
The authors whose names are written certify that they have no conflict of interest.
References
[1] M. F. Sufa, “Identifikasi Kriteria Keberhasilan Proyek,” Performa, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 1922, 2012.
[2] R. Mulcahy, PMP Exam Preparation 9th Edition, 9th ed. RMC Pubns Inc, 2018.
[3] D. Pratami, N. A. Puspita, and I. Haryono, “Designing Project Stakeholder Management Plan at Coffee Plant
Construction Project for Sucessful Initiating Phase in Ciwidey,” Int. J. Innov. Enterp. Syst., vol. 01, no. 01, pp.
1928, Jul. 2017, Accessed: Jun. 15, 2021. [Online]. Available:
https://ijies.sie.telkomuniversity.ac.id/index.php/IJIES/article/view/6/4.
[4] J. B. Forman and R. Discenza, “Got Stake? Holder Management in Project - Stakeholder Management Plan,”
Oct. 2012, Accessed: May 30, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/stakeholder-
management-plan-6090.
[5] P. Bristol, “The brick and mortar of project success,” Paper presented at PMI® Global Congress, 2012.
https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/project-success-core-values-key-accountabilities-6262 (accessed Oct. 14,
2020).
[6] P. W. Ihuah, I. I. Kakulu, and D. Eaton, “A review of Critical Project Management Success Factors (CPMSF)
for sustainable social housing in Nigeria,” Int. J. Sustain. Built Environ., vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 6271, Jun. 2014,
doi: 10.1016/j.ijsbe.2014.08.001.
[7] PMI, A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge, 6th ed. Project Management Institute, 2017.
Rahmad Dwi Putra Suhanda et al., International Journal of Innovation in Enterprise System Vol. 05 No. 02 (2021) p. 122-133
© Copyright by Telkom University 133
[8] A. S. Elhady and H. M. Abushama, “RACI Scrum Model for Controlling of Change User Requirement in
Software Projects,” Int. J. Appl. or Innov. Eng. Manag., vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 214220, 2015.
[9] P. Pullan and P. Evi, “Leading Virtual Project Teams,” Paper presented at PMI® Global Congress 2016
EMEA, May 13, 2016. https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/leading-virtual-project-teams-10190 (accessed
Dec. 19, 2020).
[10] D. Kho, “Pengertian Fiber Optik (Optical Fiber) dan Jenis-jenisnya,” Komponen Elektronika, Sep. 2020.
https://teknikelektronika.com/pengertian-fiber-optik-optical-fiber-jenis-jenis-fiber-optik/ (accessed Oct. 02,
2020).
[11] M. Koswara, “Benefit Of Optical Termination Premises In The Fiber To The Home Network,” Elektro
Telekomun. Terap., pp. 215, Dec. 2016.
[12] S. Haworth, “Example RACI Chart For Project Managers & How To Make It,” thedigitalprojectmanager.com,
Aug. 10, 2020. https://thedigitalprojectmanager.com/raci-chart-made-simple/ (accessed Oct. 16, 2020).
[13] B. S. Yudha, I. Haryono, and L. W. Suwarsono, “Perancangan Job Description Berdasarkan Kerangka
Business Process Pada Cv . Gradient Job Description Design Based on Businees Process Framework At Cv .
Gradient,” vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 25292534, 2017.
[14] D. H. Syahchari, “The Statement of Work Management,” Binus University, Dec. 11, 2019.
https://bbs.binus.ac.id/management/2019/12/the-statement-of-work/ (accessed Jun. 15, 2021).
[15] J. R. San Cristóbal, V. Fernández, and E. Diaz, “An analysis of the main project organizational structures:
Advantages, disadvantages, and factors affecting their selection,” Procedia Comput. Sci., vol. 138, pp. 791
798, 2018, doi: 10.1016/j.procs.2018.10.103.
[16] S. F. Wamba and D. Gnanzou, “A Literature Review on Business Process Management , Business Process
Reengineering , and Business Process Innovation A Literature Review on Business Process Management ,
Business Process Reengineering , and Business Process Innovation,” Enterp. Organ. Model. Simulation, no.
June, 2013, doi: 10.1007/978-3-642-41638-5.
... В ході аналізу моделей та методів управління командами автором були виокремлені найбільш відомі: підхід до формування та управління командою проєкту через визначення та розподіл ролей за Р.М. Белбіном [14]; модель ситуаційного лідерства П. Герсі та К. Бланшара, ідея якої полягає в адаптації стилю управління залежно від ситуації та зрілості і компетенцій команди [15]; модель етапів розвитку команди Брюса Такмана, яка визначає 5 етапів і допомагає менеджеру покращити ефективність команди, в залежності від етапу, який вона зараз проходить [16][17]; модель GRPI Річарда Бекхарда, яка фокусується на цілях, ролях, процесах та міжособистісних стосунках [18]; метод RACI, який використовує матрицю відповідальності з чітко визначеними ролями по кожному виду робіт [19]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The article is devoted to the theoretical and methodological aspects of developing a method for forming rational creative project teams under conditions of uncertainty by selecting candidates for the project team based on their riskiness. The relevance and necessity of this development is caused by the need to provide art project managers with effective tools for selecting candidates for the project team. An analysis of project team management models and methods, including the stage of candidate selection and team formation, has shown that the executors of these projects are creatively gifted individuals who have their own psychological aspects that differ from the psychology of rational people. This category requires a different approach. In addition, the creative sphere has its own specifics, which are reflected in the process of implementing art projects. All these factors cause additional risks that significantly reduce the percentage of successfully implemented art projects. Given the importance of art and the creative sector for the socio-economic development of a country, art project managers need models and methods to help them minimise the number of risks and/or their consequences and increase the success rate of projects. The development of this method is based on the concept that a manager should recognise and take into account that risks do not always occur in isolation. Rather, risks can be combined to create new risk situations, and/or one risk can cause or exacerbate the likelihood of occurrence or impact of another risk. This idea is reflected by the author in the conceptual model ‘Palette’, which was the impetus for the development of a mathematical model with an algorithm for calculating the degree of riskiness, taking into account the interconnectedness of risks through their sources of origin. The method of forming rational teams is based on the selection of candidates with the lowest riskiness indicators.
... Dalam hal ini perusahaan telah menetapkan Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed atau yang kerap disebut RACI. Matriks RACI digunakan oleh perusahaan untuk menentukan peran, tanggung jawab, dan tingkat wewenang untuk setiap aktivitas dalam perusahaan termasuk dalam menyampaikan kabar buruk (Suhanda & Pratami, 2021). Untuk memastikan kabar baik tersampai dengan benar, perusahaan melakukan penyampaian melalui konten-konten sosial media secara rutin. ...
Article
Keselamatan dan Kesehatan Kerja (K3) merupakan standar operasional yang harus dijalankan oleh setiap perusahaan. Salah satunya pada PT Pelindo Terminal Petikemas yang bergerak di jasa bongar muat petikemas. Dalam pengoperasiannya, dibutuhkan kesadaran dan budaya K3 pada setiap diri karyawan. Maka dari itu, untuk memberikan komunikasi dan internalisasi K3 yang baik pada karyawan, Humas PT Pelindo Terminal Petikemas turut berperan dalam melakukan strategi komunikasi internal. Penelitian ini menggunakan metode kualitatif deskriptif dengan instrumen wawancara dan dokumentasi. Dalam hal ini, PT Pelindo Terminal Petikemas sudah melakukan strategi komunikasi internal sesuai dengan visi dan misi perusahaan. Namun, strategi dan pendekatan komunikasi internal yang dilakukan tergolong normatif dan belum bisa terimplementasi hingga menjadi budaya K3. Humas masih fokus melakukan publikasi dan pembangunan citra ke eksternal terkait program kerja K3 yang dilakukan. Saran untuk Humas PT Pelindo Terminal Petikemas ke depannya adalah dapat berfokus melakukan komunikasi terhadap karyawan internal perusahaan dan mejadikan leader yang ada di setiap terminal menjadi ‘Humas’di terminalnya. Dengan ini, Humas tidak harus langsung turun ke setiap terminal untuk melakukan penyampaian komunikasi K3.
... Selain itu, RACI digunakan untuk mengidentifikasi hubungan antara tugas dan peran, tanggung jawab, dan tingkat otoritas yang terkait dengan setiap aktivitas proyek. Dengan menentukan siapa yang menerima informasi, seberapa sering, dan pada tingkat detail apa, RACI berfungsi sebagai dasar untuk rencana komunikasi [22]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Untuk mengurangi risiko yang terkait dengan suatu organisasi, identifikasi dan pengendalian risiko disebut manajemen risiko. Tujuan manajemen risiko adalah untuk melindungi dan memperkecil setiap kegagalan keamanan sistem informasi perusahaan dari tingkat risiko yang paling tinggi sehingga tidak dapat mencapai tujuan perusahaan. Metode FMEA (Failure Mode and Effect Analysis) adalah salah satu metode yang digunakan dalam penilaian dan pengelolaan risiko . Penelitian ini menganalisa risiko pada sistem informasi suatu industri yang bergerak dibidang kesehatan, yaitu RSU Indah Bagan Batu. RSU Indah Bagan Batu menerapkan sistem informasi yang Bernama SIMRS Khanza. Menentukan tingkat risiko yang ada pada sistem informasi RSU Indah Bagan Batu adalah tujuan dalam penelitian ini, karena SIMRS Khanza harus melindungi data pasien, dokter, obat-obatan, dan staf lainnya dari potensi ancaman. Berdasarkan penilaian risiko menggunakan metode FMEA yang dihitung melalui perkalian severity, occurrence, dan detection maka mendapatkan hasil RPN dengan 34 risiko yang terdapat pada sistem informasi yang digunakan. Dari 34 RPN yang dihasilkan terdapat 5 kategori level RPN yaitu 3 kategori very high dengan rentang 500-504, 5 kategori high dengan rentang 120-180, 6 kategori moderate dengan rentang 84-108, 17 kategori low dengan rentang 20-72 dan 4 kategori very low dengan rentang 8-15.
... Thus, non-technical analyses that support the growth and application of urban wind energy can be conducted. Another tool used to identify stakeholders and their roles in projects or management is Responsible, Accountable, Consult, and Informed (RACI) [40]. The RACI matrix can be applied to the energy sector to identify the responsible actors [41]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Renewable energy solutions are essential for addressing several pressing issues, including climate change, the fossil fuels supply chain fragility and fuel price fluctuations. One promising technological solution is rooftop-mounted turbines into buildings. This study presents an evaluation of the potential for wind energy utilization on the rooftop of a 29 m tall building. The primary objective of this research is to develop a methodology that can effectively investigate the integration of small wind turbines (SWTs) into urban buildings, intending to promote energy sufficiency in urban areas. A robust framework has been developed that consists of seven steps. These steps include site selection, evaluating urban wind energy with computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation and on-site measurements, selecting an appropriate SWT, estimating the annual energy production (AEP), conducting an evaluation of the environmental impact, resilience, and economic analysis, and finally, installing the system. This straightforward yet reliable framework provides a comprehensive approach to assessing the viability of wind energy utilization in urban areas. The findings revealed that the most suitable location for installation had an estimated AEP of around 1030 kWh, leading to a reduction in emissions of 0.64 tCO2/y. Additionally, it was observed that the building's geometry and orientation significantly affected the wind flow, causing a substantial decrease in wind speed downstream. Selecting optimal sites and considering wind patterns are essential for maximizing energy generation in wind energy projects.
... Therefore, this research uses the RACI matrix method to analyze stakeholder management in a renewable energy-based tourist village development project. The RACI Matrix is a project management tool that aids in identifying the roles and responsibilities of each stakeholder in a specific project or task [17]. The RACI matrix classifies stakeholders into four categories: Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, and Informed. ...
Article
Full-text available
The tourism village offers cultural, natural, and authentic culinary experiences, but the growth of tourism villages must be managed sustainably to address adverse environmental impacts. Stakeholder management becomes a critical factor in planning a sustainable energy-based tourism village development project. This research aims to identify key stakeholders in the development project of the "Kampung Emas" tourism village based on renewable energy, understand their roles and responsibilities, and formulate stakeholder management strategies. The research was conducted by interviewing key stakeholders in the project and analyzing the results using the RACI Matrix table. The analysis identified four main stakeholders: the Village Head, the Tourism Awareness Group Chair, the Restaurant Manager, and the Academician. The Village Head plays a strategic role as the information disseminator at the village level; the Tourism Awareness Group Chair is fully responsible for the critical phases of the project, the Restaurant Manager has responsibilities in technical and strategic tasks, and the Academician contributes significantly to the analysis of each task. The proposed stakeholder management strategy positions the Village Head as an information disseminator, the Tourism Awareness Group Chair as the primary spokesperson, the Restaurant Manager in strategic decision-making, and the Academician as a consultative partner. This approach is expected to support successfully implementing the renewable energy-based tourism village development project.
Article
This study aims to analyze operational risk management at PT Sugiarto Jaya Mandiri Transport, a logistics company that focuses on transporting heavy equipment. Using an approach based on SNI ISO 31000:2018, this study identifies the operational risks faced, analyzes the level of risk based on its probability and impact, and formulates risk mitigation strategies. Data was collected through in-depth interviews, surveys, questionnaires, and document reviews. The Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (FMEA) method is used to analyze and prioritize risks.The results of the study showed that there were 19 operational risks identified, including process, HR, system, business, and incidental aspects. Key risks include delivery delays, fleet breakdowns, accidents, and operational system mismatches. Recommended mitigation strategies include improving operational processes, strengthening oversight, and implementing ISO 31000-based risk procedures. This research makes an important contribution to the management of operational risks in the logistics sector, with practical implications to improve efficiency, reduce losses, and ensure business sustainability. Keywords: Failure Modes and Effect Analysis (FMEA), logistics, operational risk management, SNI ISO 31000:2018.
Article
Метою статті є дослідження впливу адміністративного менеджменту на здійснення проектів у інвестиційній діяльності. Адміністративний менеджмент виступає як організатор проєктної діяльності в інвестиційній сфері. Автори дослідили алгоритм адміністративного управління та виокремили його складові, що мають бути застосовані у практиці інвестиційної діяльності. Як методика досліджень був використаний системний підхід та структурний аналіз а також метод порівнянь. Процес адміністративного управління інвестиційним проєктом було представлено як послідовність кроків або етапів, які включають в себе планування, організацію, виконання та контроль. Наведено загальну схему цього процесу. Цей процес може бути ітеративним, з внесенням змін і корекцій на різних етапах проєкту в залежності від змін у внутрішніх та зовнішніх умовах. Основна мета адміністративного управління інвестиційним проєктом – забезпечити ефективне використання ресурсів та досягнення поставлених цілей проєкту.
Chapter
Full-text available
With the introduction of the Land Administration Domain Model (LADM), countries started adapting this new standard into their real estate systems. This research describes a sustainable supply chain framework model to implement a digital land registry in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The proposed research evaluates and analyzes the existing land registries and their digital aspects. It also conforms to capture the best practices for designing new processes and procedures by inheriting and satisfying current laws and regulations of the country. It discussed how blockchain can be a useful asset in the supply chain digital land registry model. The work also aims to design a framework for such implantation and fitting it to the model such as the Software Development Life Cycle (SDLC). The research followed an exploratory research approach, which is more suitable for qualitative-based researches. The data used in the research was collected through interviews with key individuals in organizations that are related to real estate. The results discussed the viability of the framework, its advantages, and shortcomings with the detailed discussion of the future directions.
Article
Full-text available
CV Trianom Agrotektur is a company engaged in coffee industry. Due to high demand and expanded business process the company owner is going to build a new plant in Ciwidey. The current plant cannot cover the whole business process of in processing coffee beans. The extensification towards the plant requires some guidance to lead the successful contruction project. However, building plants in rural area is not a simple thing. There should be some investigation towards stakeholders’ needs/interests or requirements. The project should also face an issue pertaining to management, i.e. how to manage stakeholders who still keep their local tradition. This study is aimed at designing project stakeholder management plan based on PMBOK 5 edition. The study shows that there are 21 stakeholders classified in 4 quadrants. Those stakeholders will be managed based on their power and interest level. Keywords— Stakeholder, Communication, Project, Coffee Plant
Article
Full-text available
Generally, we can define project organizational structures as organizational forms, based on temporary teams that are created to perform particular tasks and disappear after achieving the established goals. Whereas simple projects may require a limited number of steps and specializations, complex projects may be composed of plentiful of steps and require diverse and different specializations. As the project increases in size and design more units and specializations are added to the organizational structure contributing to both more vertical and horizontal organizational differentiation. Thus, when designing a project organizational structure the following questions must be answered: How many different specializations are included in the design of the project? How are the interrelatedness between the different elements of the project and between the different specializations? How many different activities are to be managed? In this paper, we analyse the three generic project organizational structures that are presented in the extant literature; functional, pure project, and matrix, together with their advantages and disadvantages. Furthermore, the most important factors that should be considered when designing a proper organizational structure are also analysed.
Article
Full-text available
Requirement’s evolution is mandatory for any software project . Users can propose requirements changes at any stage of SDLC. Although changes in requirement may affect on cost, schedule and quality of a software project; but change should be allowed when it is inevitable to meet the customer expectations. Traditional software development processes are not much efficient to manage the rapid change in requirements. This paper explains why users change their requirement and what is the impact of change in a project’s cost, schedule and quality and it attempts to decrease change in required by proposed model can do this task
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of the study is to investigate and establish the Critical Project Management Success Factors (CPMSF) for the sustainable social (public) housing estates delivery/ provision in Nigeria. The current housing estate deficit faced in the country is credited to poor and inadequate housing delivery and provision by various agencies. Method/Design- Documentary analysis of data collection was used in the study which involved an extensive and investigative theoretical review of online and visual document resources, followed by an interpretative identification of categories and limits of various materials and information considered vital to the phenomenon in the study. The documents were analysed with a content analysis approach under four criteria of how: authentic; credible; representative; and meaningful. Findings/ Results- The study reveals that 22 Critical Project Management Success Factors (CPMSF) are essential for the achievement of sustainable social (public) housing estates delivery / provision in Nigeria. These relate to: the project managers’ performance; the organization that owns the development project; the characteristics of the team members; and the external project environment. At the same time, the study reveals that these are social, economic, and environmental factors that are associated with the triple objectives of sustainable development. Originality/Value: This study reflection aims to resolve or reduce to a minimum the acknowledged housing estate delivery and provision inadequacy problems in the country, and by exploring this phenomenon, best practice project management techniques will be understood and used to provide sustainable social (public) housing estate units for the Nigerian populace.
Identifikasi Kriteria Keberhasilan Proyek
  • M F Sufa
M. F. Sufa, "Identifikasi Kriteria Keberhasilan Proyek," Performa, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 19-22, 2012.
Got Stake? Holder Management in Project -Stakeholder Management Plan
  • J B Forman
  • R Discenza
J. B. Forman and R. Discenza, "Got Stake? Holder Management in Project -Stakeholder Management Plan," Oct. 2012, Accessed: May 30, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/stakeholdermanagement-plan-6090.
The brick and mortar of project success
  • P Bristol
P. Bristol, "The brick and mortar of project success," Paper presented at PMI® Global Congress, 2012. https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/project-success-core-values-key-accountabilities-6262 (accessed Oct. 14, 2020).
Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge
  • A Pmi
PMI, A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge, 6th ed. Project Management Institute, 2017.
Leading Virtual Project Teams
  • P Pullan
  • P Evi
P. Pullan and P. Evi, "Leading Virtual Project Teams," Paper presented at PMI® Global Congress 2016-EMEA, May 13, 2016. https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/leading-virtual-project-teams-10190 (accessed Dec. 19, 2020).
Pengertian Fiber Optik (Optical Fiber) dan Jenis-jenisnya
  • D Kho
D. Kho, "Pengertian Fiber Optik (Optical Fiber) dan Jenis-jenisnya," Komponen Elektronika, Sep. 2020. https://teknikelektronika.com/pengertian-fiber-optik-optical-fiber-jenis-jenis-fiber-optik/ (accessed Oct. 02, 2020).