ArticlePDF Available

Could virtual reality applications pose real risks to children and adolescents? A systematic review of ethical issues and concerns

Springer Nature
Virtual Reality
Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Virtual reality technologies (VRTs) are high-tech human–computer interfaces used to develop digital content and can be applied to multiple different areas, often offering innovative solutions to existing problems. A wide range of digital games is being also developed with VRTs and together with their components, the games' structural elements are appealing to children and engaging them more in virtual worlds. Our research interest is directed towards children's development and the effects of VRTs within gaming environments. Contemporary psychology studies perceive human development as a holistic and lifelong process with important interrelationships between physical, mental, social and emotional aspects. For the objectives and scope of this work, we examine children development across three domains: physical, cognitive and psychosocial. In this context, the authors review the literature on the impact of VRTs on children, in terms of software and hardware. Since research requires an wide-ranging approach, we study the evidence reported on the brain and neural structure, knowledge, behaviour, pedagogy, academic performance, and wellness. Our main concern is to outline the emerging ethical issues and worries of parents, educators, ophthalmologists, neurologists, psychologists, paediatricians and all relevant scientists, as well as the industry’s views and actions. The systematic review was performed on the databases Scopus, IEEE Xplore, PubMed, and Google Scholar from 2010 to 2020 and 85 studies were selected. The review concluded that findings remain contradictory especially for the psychosocial domain. Official recommendations from organizations and well-documented researches by academics on child well-being are reassuring if health and safety specifications and particularly the time limit are met. Research is still ongoing, constantly updated and consist of a priority for the scientific community given that technology evolves.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
... For children, excessive immersion in virtual worlds may disrupt physical, cognitive and social development, necessitating a balanced approach to virtual and realworld interactions 471 . For already vulnerable individuals, the immersive allure of Web 4.0 environments can exacerbate addiction, mental health challenges and other unforeseen harms 472 . Exposure to hyperrealistic virtual content, such as targeted advertisements, gambling simulations or explicit material, risks further normalising harmful behaviours and altering the cognitive patterns of users who are already at risk 473 . ...
Technical Report
Full-text available
This background document provides factual information and a detailed analysis of the technologies underpinning Web 4.0 and virtual worlds, along with the related challenges, needs and governance implications. The document supports the “Input Document for the Conference, based on Stakeholder consultation”, which is presented and discussed during the Global Multistakeholder High Level Conference on Governance for Web 4.0 and Virtual Worlds, hosted by the European Commission and the Polish Presidency of the Council of the European Union on 31 March–1 April 2025. The analysis presented in this document draws on extensive analysis of literature as well as expert interviews, workshops and online consultation.
... The study by Kaimara, et al. [37] asserted that the impacts of virtual reality technology and gaming on overall child development remain a subject of scholarly debate. The main research issues pertaining to ethical issues and concerns in students' use of advanced technologies are related to the bioethics of human research and potentially harmful consequences on students' development. ...
Article
Full-text available
The study aims to investigate the grand design and strategy for building a digital learning space culture, including its impact on learning in elementary schools. Data were gathered by conducting interviews with academics, observing learning processes, and reviewing school records. Throughout the data collection process, data were evaluated using data presentation, data condensation patterns, and conclusion drawing. The study's conclusions were validated using triangulation and data collection methodologies. The study's findings revealed that (1) the grand plan for creating a digital culture was not fully developed, and the provision of digital facilities was tailored to fit limited needs and budgets; (2) the principal implemented a strategy for creating a digital culture for teachers by providing digital facilities and infrastructure, establishing an IT team, and providing professional teacher training; the interaction of the three supported digital culture; and (3) the positive impacts included more engaging learning, increased teacher administration efficiency, and improved students' and instructors' technology skills, whereas the negative effects included a loss in students' fine motor skills and social competence. The implication is that a thorough investigation is required to determine the best formula for employing digital media in learning so that learning effectiveness can be maximized.
... Ethical considerations should be fundamental in any innovative practice to ensure compliance with the highest design and safety standards while protecting the rights and confidentiality of participants. All involved parties must undergo ethical review and approval, ensuring adherence to established expectations in the development of medications, devices, therapies, or other treatments [21,22]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Pediatric healthcare innovations are vital for addressing children's unique physiological, psychological, and developmental needs. Unlike adults, children require specialized medical approaches that consider their rapid growth and evolving health challenges. This paper examines advancements in pediatric care, including technological developments, nutritional interventions, mental health strategies, chronic disease management, emergency care improvements, vaccination initiatives, family-centered care, cultural competence, and ethical considerations. The integration of artificial intelligence (AI), genomic medicine, and telemedicine has significantly transformed pediatric care, improving diagnosis, treatment, and accessibility. However, challenges such as healthcare disparities, limited pediatric-specific medical equipment, and the need for a more holistic and ethical approach persist. Future directions emphasize collaboration across disciplines to enhance personalized and preventive pediatric healthcare solutions.
... According to Albert Bandura, selfefficacy governs the level of academic dedication and perseverance demonstrated by students in pursuit of their learning objectives. Learners who possess confidence in their capabilities engage more deeply with learning materials and persist in addressing challenging assignments (Kaimara et al. 2022). Extending beyond academic environment, self-efficacy impacts an individual's health-related behaviors, both physical and emotional, and shapes their vocational choices (Al-Ansi et al. 2023). ...
... Despite these significant advantages, the application of HCI and XR in BST still faces several challenges. First, head-mounted displays (HMDs), such as VR headsets and AR glasses, are currently the most widely used XR devices, but long-term use of HMDs can lead to motion sickness [12], eye fatigue [13] and other health problems [14][15][16]. Moreover, the design of HMDs (such as their weight and wearability) can also cause discomfort for users [17]. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study focuses on the innovative application of HCI and XR technologies in behavioral skills training (BST) in the digital age, exploring their potential in education, especially experimental training. Despite the opportunities these technologies offer for immersive BST, traditional methods remain mainstream, with XR devices like HMDs causing user discomfort and current research lacking in evaluating user experience. To address these issues, we propose the spatial reality display (SRD) method, a new BST approach based on spatial reality display. This method uses autostereoscopic technology to avoid HMD discomfort, employs intuitive gesture interactions to reduce learning costs, and integrates BST content into serious games (SGs) to enhance user acceptance. Using the aluminothermic reaction in chemistry experiments as an example, we developed a Unity3D-based XR application allowing users to conduct experiments in a 3D virtual environment. Our study compared the SRD method with traditional BST through simulation, questionnaires, and interviews, revealing significant advantages of SRD in enhancing user skills and intrinsic motivation.
Article
Purpose In marketing, virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) provide innovative ways to connect with audiences, transforming traditional advertising into dynamic and engaging storytelling. The purpose of this study is to explore ethical considerations in VR and AR marketing, analyze risks and perceptions among marketers, and propose guidelines for responsible immersive advertising practices. Design/methodology/approach This qualitative study employs semi-structured interviews with marketers from Saudi Arabia and Pakistan in the tourism and hospitality industry. Thematic analysis is used to analyze data by using NVivo 14. Findings The study identifies significant privacy concerns, psychological impacts and data security risks in immersive advertising. Marketers emphasize transparency, consumer consent and ethical boundaries. Originality/value This study contributes novel insights into the ethical dimensions of VR and AR marketing in Saudi Arabia and Pakistan, exploring unique cultural perspectives and proposing practical guidelines for ethical advertising practices.
Article
Full-text available
Background Smartphone overuse has been cited as a potentially modifiable risk factor that can result in visual impairment. However, reported associations between smartphone overuse and visual impairment have been inconsistent. Objective The aim of this systematic review was to determine the association between smartphone overuse and visual impairment, including myopia, blurred vision, and poor vision, in children and young adults. Methods We conducted a systematic search in the Cochrane Library, PubMed, EMBASE, Web of Science Core Collection, and ScienceDirect databases since the beginning of the databases up to June 2020. Fourteen eligible studies (10 cross-sectional studies and 4 controlled trials) were identified, which included a total of 27,110 subjects with a mean age ranging from 9.5 to 26.0 years. We used a random-effects model for meta-analysis of the 10 cross-sectional studies (26,962 subjects) and a fixed-effects model for meta-analysis of the 4 controlled trials (148 subjects) to combine odds ratios (ORs) and effect sizes (ES). The I2 statistic was used to assess heterogeneity. ResultsA pooled OR of 1.05 (95% CI 0.98-1.13, P=.16) was obtained from the cross-sectional studies, suggesting that smartphone overuse is not significantly associated with myopia, poor vision, or blurred vision; however, these visual impairments together were more apparent in children (OR 1.06, 95% CI 0.99-1.14, P=.09) than in young adults (OR 0.91, 95% CI 0.57-1.46,P=.71). For the 4 controlled trials, the smartphone overuse groups showed worse visual function scores compared with the reduced-use groups. The pooled ES was 0.76 (95% CI 0.53-0.99), which was statistically significant (P
Article
Full-text available
This review summarizes studies on the neurobiological correlates of internet gaming disorder (IGD), presently the most direct approach to analyzing the impact of digital technology and the internet on brain mechanisms. Brain imaging studies have shown that IGD shares, to a large extent, neurobiological alterations that are typical for other addictions, such as: (i) activation in brain regions associated with reward, as evident from cue exposure and craving studies and neurotransmitter systems studies that indicate an involvement of dopamine-mediated reward mechanisms; (ii) reduced activity in impulse control areas and impaired decision making; and (iii) reduced functional connectivity in brain networks that are involved in cognitive control, executive function, motivation, and reward. Moreover, there are structural changes, mainly reduction in gray-matter volume and white-matter density. Comorbidity studies indicate that executive control networks in attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) may increase the susceptibility to develop IGD. Most importantly, this review also outlines findings that show the effects of excessive use of screens, here referring to the playing of computer games, which activate many brain regions associated with cognitive, motor, and sensory function and not directly involved in other forms of addiction. This review describes and summarizes comprehensively the neurobiological correlates of addictive internet use in adolescents and young adults.
Article
Full-text available
Virtual reality provides a relatively inexpensive way to learn and repeatedly practice skills in personalized, controlled, and safe computer-generated settings. These systems are increasingly receiving attention as an innovative medium for delivering interventions to children with autism spectrum disorder. Although many virtual reality systems are commercially available and their use is increasing, little is known about the safety and usability of these systems for children with autism spectrum disorder. The aim of this study was a first step in addressing this gap. A convenience sample of 35 children with a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder participated in an immersive head-mounted display virtual reality experience and a control condition (monitor-displayed video). Levels of anxiety and negative effects experienced were not significantly different between the two conditions. Participants reported significantly enhanced spatial presence (p = 0.003; d = 0.3) and naturalness (p = 0.002; d = 0.47) for the head-mounted display–virtual reality condition, and 74% of participants preferred using head-mounted display–virtual reality over monitor-displayed video. These findings provide preliminary evidence to support the safety and usability of head-mounted display–virtual reality for children with autism spectrum disorder. Future studies are needed to replicate the results in a larger sample, a range of virtual reality experiences, and in the context of long-term exposure. Lay abstract This study investigated the safety and usability of a virtual reality experience for children with autism spectrum disorder in a laboratory setting. In our study, the negative effects of head-mounted display–virtual reality were similar to monitor-displayed video watching. At the same time, the participants indicated that the head-mounted display–virtual reality experience provided improved realism and sense of presence. This study is a first step in understanding the impact of head-mounted display on children with autism spectrum disorder.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this study is to develop a systematic review on the relationship between the use of active video games “exergames” and the practice of physical activity. The Web of Science (WOS) repository was used as the main search engine, using as criteria the selection of longitudinal and experimental studies published in the last five years. A total of eight research papers were obtained, in which intervention programs based on the use of exergames were applied to improve different parameters, such as adherence to Physical Activity practice or improvement on a psychological level. As the main findings, it was possible to observe the need to include these types of devices in the classroom since they can work transversally across much content, and the resources are so accessible that they allow improvements at academic level. Likewise, they favor motivation to physical exercise since with adequate volume and intensity parameters, they are related to healthier lifestyles, and the areas of motor skills and logical thinking benefited the most.
Chapter
Full-text available
The research initiative Emerging Technologies in Education (ETiE) was launched in 2015. Although not a formal project, a substantial number of studies were conducted under its umbrella. ETiE’s main objective is to examine the results of the educational uses of emerging technologies in primary and high school settings. In an educational context, emerging are technologies that recently found their way to classrooms and their instructional value is yet to be unveiled. For example, ETiE examined the educational uses of drones, virtual reality, 3D multi-user virtual environments, and augmented reality. Also, a portion of the research effort focused on digital games, because it was considered that their use in education presents interesting and still unexplored aspects.
Article
Full-text available
Stay-at-home mandates and quarantines related to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic have led to greatly increased participation in online gaming. Initiatives such as #PlayApartTogether that promote gaming for socializing and stress reduction may achieve positive outcomes. Although gaming can be a healthy coping strategy for the majority, it can also pose risks to some vulnerable individuals. Protracted periods of social isolation and technology-based activity pose the danger of solidifying unhealthy lifestyle patterns, leading to difficulties to readaptation when the COVID-19 crisis has passed. Balanced and effective approaches to gaming during the COVID-19 pandemic are needed to support physical and psychological wellbeing.
Chapter
Some clinicians have suggested using virtual reality environments to deliver psychological interventions to treat anxiety disorders. However, given a significant body of work on cybersickness symptoms which may arise in virtual environments – especially those involving simulated motion – we tested (a) whether being exposed to a virtual reality environment alone causes anxiety to increase, and (b) whether exposure to simulated motion in a virtual reality environment increases anxiety. Using a repeated measures design, we used Kim's Anxiety Scale questionnaire to compare baseline anxiety, anxiety after virtual environment exposure, and anxiety after simulated motion. While there was no significant effect on anxiety for being in a virtual environment with no simulated motion, the introduction of simulated motion caused anxiety to significantly increase, but not to a severe or extreme level. The implications of this work for virtual reality exposure therapy (VRET) are discussed.
Article
Purpose To review the impact of increased digital device usage arising from lockdown measures instituted during the COVID-19 pandemic on myopia, and make recommendations for mitigating potential detrimental effects on myopia control. Design Perspective Methods Review of studies focused on digital device usage, near work, and outdoor time in relation to myopia onset and progression. Public health policies on myopia control, recommendations on screen time and information pertaining to the impact of COVID-19 on increased digital device use were presented. Recommendations to minimize the impact of the pandemic on myopia onset and progression in children were made. Results Increased digital screen time, near work and limited outdoor activities were found to be associated with the onset and progression of myopia, and could potentially be aggravated during and beyond the COVID-19 pandemic outbreak period. While school closures may be short-lived, increased access, adoption and dependence on digital devices could have a long term negative impact on childhood development. Raising awareness among parents, children and government agencies is key to mitigating myopigenic behaviours that may become entrenched during this period. Conclusions While it is important to adopt critical measures to slow or halt the spread of COVID-19, close collaboration between parents, schools and ministries is necessary to assess and mitigate the long term collateral impact of COVID-19 on myopia control policies.
Chapter
In this paper, we present a study investigating the feasibility of using Virtual Reality (VR) to reduce disruptive classroom behavior of a child diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). The child shows extensive, aggressive behavior in the classroom, making it hard for the teacher to teach him and his classmates. Even when receiving one-to-one lectures by a professional teacher, without the presence of other students, the child shows disruptive behavior. However, when receiving lectures in a virtual environment by a teacher, the child was calm, focused, and capable of working on his assignments without showing any disruptive behaviors. Even if the study has been applied to one single child, the promising results can be extended to more children showing similar behaviors.
Chapter
Electroencephalography (EEG) systems and brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) are terms frequently involved in the field of neurological research. Under a technological point of view, BCI is considered to be a significant achievement within the frame of learning disabilities rehabilitation. Nevertheless, the specifications for efficient use for cognitive enhancement and its potential boundaries are under concern. Author's main objective is to discuss BCI concrete components and potential advances as well as depict potential limitations while using technological devices within the frame of the learning procedure. Within this context, requirements, advantages, possible addiction risks, and boundaries regarding the specifications for brain-computer interfaces and technology in order to serve long-term research and developmental learning goals are discussed.