ArticlePDF Available

Other knowings and experiencing otherness: Children’s perspectives of playing a hunting game in a nature reserve

Authors:

Abstract

This research study explored the experiences of children (aged 9–10 years), from four different primary schools, playing a hunting game in a nature reserve. Previous research shows that children’s play in green spaces can provide a number of benefits to children. However, there is a lack of research into children’s experiences of playing in bio-diverse environments. This study sought to find out how children (aged 9–10 years) “playing” the role of animals in a nature reserve could enable them to experience different ways of being and different ways of understanding their relationship with the world around them. The study employed a qualitative phenomenological design that aimed to interpret the first-person lived experiences of the children playing in the nature reserve. Four classes from four different primary schools took part in the study. Six children from each class were interviewed and analysis of their responses generated a number of different themes. The results suggest that playing the hunting game in a biodiverse environment does offer states of being and knowings that are not as accessible in schools. Playing the role of an animal had afforded the children with an accentuated, embodied experience, offering insight into the otherness of the more-than-human world.
ARTICLE
Other knowings and experiencing otherness:
Childrens perspectives of playing a hunting
game in a nature reserve
Dylan Adams* and Gary Beauchamp
Cardiff Metropolitan University, Cardiff, Wales
*Corresponding author. E-mail: dadams@cardiffmet.ac.uk
(Received 13 January 2021; revised 03 June 2021; accepted 11 June 2021)
Abstract
This research study explored the experiences of children (aged 910 years), from four different primary
schools, playing a hunting game in a nature reserve. Previous research shows that childrens play in green
spaces can provide a number of benefits to children. However, there is a lack of research into childrens
experiences of playing in bio-diverse environments. This study sought to find out how children (aged 910
years) playingthe role of animals in a nature reserve could enable them to experience different ways of
being and different ways of understanding their relationship with the world around them. The study
employed a qualitative phenomenological design that aimed to interpret the first-person lived experiences
of the children playing in the nature reserve. Four classes from four different primary schools took part in
the study. Six children from each class were interviewed and analysis of their responses generated a number
of different themes. The results suggest that playing the hunting game in a biodiverse environment does
offer states of being and knowings that are not as accessible in schools. Playing the role of an animal had
afforded the children with an accentuated, embodied experience, offering insight into the otherness of the
more-than-human world.
Keywords: experience; children; embodiment; ontology; biodiversity; community; outdoor education
Introduction
There are a growing number of voices who argue that children need to be engaged in activities that
are non-anthropocentric in nature. For example, Jickling Blenkinsop, Timmerman, and Sitka-Sage
(2018) call for wild pedagogiesthat disrupt anthropocentric dominance and seek to challenge a
human-centred, and human exclusive, understanding(p. 34) replacing it with approaches that
honour the voice and presence of nature and more-than-beings(p. 34). Furthermore,
Ärlemalm-Hagser and Sandberg (2017) challenge educators to facilitate learning within non-
anthropocentric ethics, that involve different intrinsic values of the human and the natural
world(p. 219). As Jardine says, we need to contemplate how we might understand ourselves,
not as an exception to this interweaving indebtedness and inter-relatedness to the Earth, but as an
instance of it(2016, p. 14). There is also an increasing body of research that demonstrates child-
rens play in green spaces can provide beneficial health impacts (Hiscock & Mitchell, 2011;
Vanaken & Danckaerts, 2018; Ward, Duncan, Jarden, & Stewart, 2016). Despite this, there is a
lack of research into childrens play in bio-diverse environments. This research study investigates
childrens experiences of playing a hunting game in a biodiverse environment. It draws on a
© The Author(s) 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press. This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative
Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/), which permits non-commercial
re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the same Creative Commons licence is included and the original work is properly
cited. The written permission of Cambridge University Press must be obtained for commercial re-use.
Australian Journal of Environmental Education (2021), 116
doi:10.1017/aee.2021.10
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
number of underpinning key concepts to provide a grounding that links to the experiences of the
children. These include Huizingas(1949) theory of play, the existential philosophies of Shepard,
(1998; 1973), Turner (1979; 1974), and Buber (1970), and Bones(2010) exploration of metamor-
phosis in childrens play. These are positioned alongside the pedagogical stances of Blenkinsop
and Beeman (2010), and Derby (2015), who argue that if we are to counter the gross ecological
abuse and neglect that we continue to inflict on the natural word, Western education needs to
reaffirm the importance of other ways of knowing in education.
In Wales, in the United Kingdom (UK), where this research took place, both outdoor expe-
riences and play are statutory parts of the curriculum for primary aged children (Welsh
Government, 2015). Nevertheless, there are a multitude of voices warning of the decline in child-
rens experiences of playing in nature places (Dowdell, Gray, & Malone, 2011; Gray, 2011;
OConnor, 2017; Waller et al.,2017). Research shows that childrens screen-time is increasing
(Šmahel & Blinka, 2012) and that this is potentially negatively impacting on childrens physical
and mental health (Kardefelt-Winther, 2017; Saunders & Vallance, 2017). Robertson (2015)
argues that technology and always-on connectivity to social-media help remove the material
world from the conscious mind(p. 7) and that this diminishes the opportunity for sensory expe-
riences of nature places. Sibthorp and Richmond (2015) note that even activities that were once
an escape from technology are becoming just another place where modern technology is present
(p. 212). Abram (2010a) states that due to our increasing presence indoors in front of flat screens,
we have traded the worlds visceral ambiguity for a flat representation(p. 13). All of these factors
potentially contribute to children spending less time playing outdoors in nature places (Bento &
Dias, 2017). Bragg, Wood, Barton and Pretty (2013) assert that this situation is not only damaging
for childrens health, but catastrophicfor the environment as children who are estranged from
nature when they are young are less likely to see the importance of taking care of it when they are
older(Bragg et al.,2013, p. 5).
To help counter this estrangement, Louv (2011) warns that we should facilitate immersive
experiences in nature for children, as they currently live in the era of algorithms(Louv,
2019, p. 20), where the quantitative is prioritised over the qualitative. Indeed, Abram (2010b)
claims we are increasingly blind, increasingly deaf increasingly impervious to the sensuous
world the technological mind progressively lays waste to the animate Earth(p. 287). Such
developments are particularly corrosive if maintained in nature places, as we sever ourselves from
the wonder of sensory experience and deny our essential reciprocity, as if cutting the earthly vocal
chords(Evernden, 1999, p. 100). The reduction in opportunities for todays children to experi-
ence in their play, risk taking and play outdoors in nature places (Lynch, Pike, & Beckett, 2017)is
also brought into sharp focus by OConnor (2017) who suggests that adultsmost memorable
learning experiences are often those that have occurred outside of the classroom within play sit-
uations(OConnor 2017, p. 94). In contrast, children today are being denied impactful learning
experiences and are inculcated into an anthropocentric view of the world (Bonnett, 2017; Louv,
2019). This, in turn, leads to future behaviours that are not only damaging to the planet, but also
perpetuate a culture that lacks an understanding of community with the natural world in which
our being is ultimately embedded(Bonnett, 2017, p. 80).
Shepard (1998) argues that the modern urban lives that most children in the West experience
impact negatively on their relationship with nature and the development of their psyche. Even
childhoods in rural communities are tainted by agricultural cultures that view animals as posses-
sions and nature as resource (Shepard, 1998). Shepard analyses what happens when childhoods
are deprived of encountering biodiverse environments, in a world in which that Other has mostly
disappeared(Shepard, 1998, p. 35). He highlights how this has detrimental and lasting psycho-
logical implications as children grow up away from the essential nourishment and nurturing that
is given by a childhood in contact with the diversity and otherness of the natural world (Shepard,
1998). It is claimed that the developing child needs non-human otherness, rather than the
2 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
inhuman urban civilizationand mechanization of lifethat is imposed on children in modern
Western societies (Shepard, 1998, p. 104). Living in sterile urban confinement, children are
deprived of understanding the plurality of the self(Shepard, 1998, p. 126). However, not all
is lost as the right attentive engagement with the more-than-human world can yield its own heal-
ing metaphysics(Shepard, 1998, p. 130). Shepard states that experiencing the archetypal role of
nature, that is found most complete in wilderness, matures the self for it embodies the poetic
expression of ways of being and relating to others(1998, p. 108).
This view is supported by Macy (2016) who calls for a spiritual practicethat holds life
sacredand encourages joyful communionwith all our fellow beings(p. 153). She refers
to this as the greening of the selfthat entails generating a sense of profound interconnectedness
with all life(2016, p. 152). Macy claims there are reasons to believe that this reality is being expe-
rienced by increasing numbers of people, as the conventional notion of the self with which we
have been raised and to which we have been conditioned by mainstream culture is being under-
mined(2016, p. 151). Cajete (2015) also feels that Western science has given rise to a mindset
that acts blind to our interrelatedness(p. 168). In contrast, Cajete (2015) shows that indigenous
approaches consider the implications of all actions and act on the truth that we are all related
(p. 197). This includes all of the more-than-human world, from the cosmos to what we eat and
breathe(Cajete, 2015, p. 197).
Macy and Brown warn that a shift in understanding is needed in occidental cultures as, though
there is much promise to unfold, we could lose it all as the web of living systems unravels
(2014, p. 3). Seed concurs and explains that the change required is not some new resistance
to radiation, but a change in consciousness(1988, p. 38). He argues that if we are truly empathetic
and tune in with the other-than-human world, we begin to realise our humannessis merely the
most recent stageof our existence (Seed, 1988, p. 36). What is described here is not just intellec-
tual knowledge, but involves our ontological reality. Ones sense of self and relationship with
nature changes from feeling as though one is protecting the rainforest to I am part of the rain-
forest protecting myself(Seed, 1988, p. 36). This change is a spiritual oneas years of imagined
separationend and we begin to recall our true nature(Seed, 1988, p. 36).
Embodiment and Play
Changes such as those outlined above are vital as it is through the vulnerability of bodily exis-
tencethat we are able to experience the deepest wellsprings of joy(Abram, 2010a, p. 7). Abram
points out that the body is nourished by the natural world and consequently the boundaries of a
living body are open and indeterminate; more like membranes than barriers, they define a surface
of metamorphosis and exchange(Abram, 1996, p. 46). Rather than standing apart from the nat-
ural world through acts of cognition and sedentary indoor practices, when we pay attention, whilst
being in the outdoor environment, we notice ourselves as a part of and utterly inside the physical
world(Abram, 2010b, p. 19). Humberstone (2015) similarly proclaims the value of embodied
learnings that challenge the traditional sporting narratives of body/mind separation(p. 63) that
tend to dominate education in the West. She calls for more attention on the non-cognitive, affec-
tive knowings that outdoor experiences grant to learners (Humberstone, 2015). Blades (2015) con-
curs, positioning the body as a place for meaning-making that can reveal dialoguewith the
natural world and invites a level of intimacy and mutual engagement(p. 16). Evernden
(1999) highlights that children intuitively understand this. He argues that children see the world
like themselves, alive and sensateand that only age and education can correct their view
(Evernden, 1999, p. 14). This is perhaps most powerfully expressed through childrens play in
nature places. Fasting (2017) describes childrens outdoor magical playas a world where chil-
dren protectthemselves against rationalityand explore for the sake of adventure to feel the
bodily and magical play(Fasting, 2017, p. 642). Childrens play has long been proclaimed as far
Australian Journal of Environmental Education 3
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
more important than just an escape from reality, instead involving entering into a superior reality
(Gadamer, 2004; Huizinga, 1949). It enables transformation back into true beingas the being of
all play is always self-realization, sheer fulfillment, energeia which has its telos within itself
(Gadamer, 2004, pp. 116117).
The idea of reaching sheer fulfillmenthas resonance with Turners(1974) theory of liminal-
ity. Turner recognised this, describing play or ludicexpressions as the essence of liminality,
liminality par excellence(Turner, 1974, p. 61). Turners(1979) liminality occurs when people
are freed from normal modes of behaviour, a time of enchantment when anything might, even
should, happen(p. 465). Turner argues that play enacts higher states of being that involve intui-
tive perceptions of a non-transactional order(Turner, 1974, p. 46). This is supported by Beckett
who asserts that in play relations are formed through moments of playing in the inbetweenand
during these moments the players are free of the demands of social exchange(Beckett 2017,
p. 32). Drawing on Winnicotts(2005) theory of play as occurring in an intermediate area
between our inner and outer reality, Beckett (2017, p. 33) calls this playing in the third zone,
where the inner and outer world combine.
Metamorphosis in play
In this research study, children aged 910 years were encouraged to play in this third zone by
imagining and acting as if they were animals during a hunting game. The playing of animals
by humans is an ancient practice and is described as being theriomorphic, that is the ascription
of animal characteristics to humans or gods, often found in mythology and religion. Huizinga
(1949) suggests that the theriomorphic factorcan be best understood through play.
Huizinga (1949), like Turner (1974), uses the practices of tribal cultures to uncover the seriousness
of play. He argues that when we truly play, the division between belief and make-believe breaks
down and play merges quite naturally with that of holiness(Huizinga, 1949, p. 25). Huizinga
claims that when tribal peoples dance in animal roles, they are not merely performing, but have
become the otheras there is a mystic unity(1949, p. 25). This resonates with Bones(2010)
conceptualisation of play as metamorphosis, suggesting that change and instability are inherent
in play(p. 405). Bone (2010) explores play that challenges human/non-human animal binaries
and argues that these enactments involve unfixedness and infolding: both features of the spiri-
tual(p. 402). Bone (2010) further contends that the metamorphosis enacted in childrensanimal
becomingsallows them to experience and become something more than their ordinary selves.
Turner (1982) similarly states that, despite the importance of play being an autotelic act, that is
playing for the sake of play, its significance is that we have something to learn in being disorderly
(p. 28). It is when there is a sense of becoming and the mood of maybe,might be,could beand
as if’” that play, in the full ambiguity of the term, may reign(Turner, 1982, p. 149).
Non-anthropocentric otherness
Nevertheless, Deleuze and Parnet (2002, p. 2) explain to become is never to imitate, nor to do
like, nor to conform to a model. The player has not suddenly been transformed into the animal
they are playing, as what he is becoming changes as much as he does himself(Deleuze & Parnet
2002). Bone (2010) supports this in her analysis of animal-becomings, claiming that children
become spiritually with the Other(p. 408). She explains that this is a spiritual mergingas
the differentiation between child and animal does not suddenly disappear, but is part of the
complexity as the difference holdsin this process(Bone, 2010, p. 411). This resonates with
Bubers(1970) existential I-Thouphilosophy that argues for dialogue with the Otheras
the route to authentic existential understanding. Buber (1970) declares that only when people
acknowledge the inter-subjective nature of an experience with another living being are they able
to enter into an I and Thou relationship. However, his dialogic philosophy does not advocate the
4 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
loss of self, otherwise the I and Thou dialogue perishes in the feeling of a unity that does not and
cannot exist(1970, p. 69). Blenkinsop and Beeman (2010) draw on Bubers philosophy of dia-
logue to analyse how attending to encounters with other-than-human alterity can teach us about
reciprocity and the fundamental nature of relation. They state that rather than viewing the other-
than-human-world as backdrop, educators need to embrace the other-than-human as a co-
teacher(Blenkinsop & Beeman, 2010, p. 27). To do this, we need to be in a state of attentive
receptivityso that we may hear the perspectives of our co- teacherand feel the possibility of
real difference(Blenkinsop & Beeman, 2010, p. 28).
Other ways of knowing
Blenkinsop and Beeman (2010) suggest that in this state of being we can make meaning that
appears to be co-created with an active, present and intendingother(Blenkinsop &
Beeman, 2010, p. 33). This involves ways of knowing that are more intuitive in contrast to the
logical, rational modes of thinking that dominate educational discourse (Beeman &
Blenkinsop, 2008). Derby (2015) concurs, and calls for new ways of knowing that can counter
the dominant narratives that view the other-than-human as natural resource. He declares that
educating for an ecological imaginationinvolves prioritising connection to the natural world
via narrative, place-based activities and learning opportunities that engage bodies, emotions
and imaginative possibilities(Derby, 2015, p. 46). This could include providing opportunities
for children to becomeother-than-human life and play with interspecies mimesis(Derby,
2015, p. 52). Children becoming animals during play involves allowing metaphors capacity
to elicit ontological attention(Derby, 2015, p. 52) as it provides a way of being that accentuates
an existential awareness (Turner, 1970). Furthermore, this state of being provides an epistemology
that contrasts with logico-mathematical ways of thinking(Derby, 2015, p. 31) and knowing. It is
argued that thinking metaphorically and imaginatively has pedagogical significanceas it evokes
ontological sensitivity to particularityor otherness (Derby, 2015, p. 53).
Research Question
Playing in this way allows children to think and act differently (Wood, 2014). In addition, Brown
(2009) reminds us that playing is a state of mind rather than an activityand that when children
play, they are in the emotional state of play(p. 60).
This led to the research question:
How could children (aged 910) playingthe role of animals, during a hunting game in a
nature reserve, enable them to experience different ways of being and different ways of
understanding their relationship with the world around them?
Despite a lack of research into the impact of childrens play in bio-diverse environments, White
and Stoecklin advocate natural bio-diverse places as play environments for children due to their
unending diversity; the fact that they are not created by adults; and their feeling of timelessness
the landscapes, trees, rivers described in fairy tales and myths still exist today(1998, p. 28).
Shepard (1998) warns of the homogeneity and lack of wilderness in modern play environments
where everything in sight belongs to meas even the buildings, streets, and cultivated fields are
all continuous with my voluntary nervous system, my tamed, controlled self(Shepard, 1998,
p. 35). As part of the remedy, he proposes that children experience more strenuous excursions
into the wild worldwhere they may, in a limited way, confront the non-human(Shepard, 1973,
p. 267).
Australian Journal of Environmental Education 5
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
The playing of a hunting game could arguably be seen to potentially steer children towards a
less caring attitude towards nature due to the roles of hunterand preyas viewed through
Western-centric optics. However, Shepard (1973) emphasises that for hunter gatherer societies,
all animals are seen as beings of reverence and the preyis universally cherished both for itself
and as a thing of beauty(p. 153). Cajete (1994) also elucidates how for indigenous cultures hunt-
ing involves coming to terms with elemental relationships at the physical, social, and spiritual
levels(Cajete, 1994, p. 58). For all people the nature of journeying towards completenessis
revealed in the metaphoric ideal of the hunter of good heart(Cajete, 1994, p. 58). This embraces
the firm belief in the interrelatedness of all life as the hunter represents the community to the
world of animals and spirits; therefore, the community as well as the hunter is judged through his
behaviour(Cajete, 1994, p. 59). Shepard (1998) also highlights how hunting involves an acute
attentiveness as the hunter does not know what is going to happen and, therefore, needs to pre-
pare an attention which does not consist in riveting itself on the presumed but consists precisely in
not presuming anything and avoiding inattentiveness(p. 22).
This study examines childrens lived experiences of a hunting game, where the children imag-
ined that they were animals. The hunting game took place during a visit to a local nature reserve
and some of the children were interviewed when back in school in order to collect data about their
experiences.
Methodology
The study employed a qualitative phenomenological design that aimed to interpret the first-
person lived experiences (DallAlba, 2010) of children playing a hunting game at a local nature
reserve. Following the game, the data collection involved unstructured interviews with small
groups of children as the intent was to understand the phenomena in their own terms to
provide a description of human experience as it is experienced by the person herself(Bentz
& Shapiro, 1998, p. 96). In this case, the children were purposively chosen as key informants
(Nowell & Albrecht, 2019, p. 353) about the phenomenon of interest. The questions during the
interviews were therefore open-ended and led by the childrens responses aiming to bring out the
originary personal experience(Patočka, 1998, p. 172).
Methods
The hunting game was facilitated by one of the researcher team as part of a series of mindful
activities at a local nature reserve. It consisted of the children of each class being split into
two groups. One group was identified as hyenas (the hunters) and the other group were deer
(the prey).
The following rules of the game aimed to ensure that the game enabled mindful attentiveness,
rather than being played in the spirit of aggressive and loud competition. The deer went and hid
somewhere within a designated area (approximately 150 m by 100 m) of the nature reserve. The
hyena group faced the teacher, closed their eyes and counted to 100 whilst the deer group hid. The
hyenas were not allowed to touch any of the deer and the deer were not allowed to touch any of the
hyenas. Neither group was allowed to communicate using vocal sounds. The aim of the game for
the hyenas was to find the deer. Once they had found any of the deer, they were to close their eyes,
so that the deer could escapeand hide to allow the game to continue. The aim of the game for the
deer was to stay hidden from the hyena. After all the deer had been found at least once, the two
groups swapped roles to ensure all children had experienced both aspects of the hunt experience to
reflect on later. During this game, the children therefore experienced both being the hunter
(including being active, listening, looking, being aware of their surroundings) and the hunted
(including being still, listening, looking, being aware of their surroundings).
6 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
One of the researcher team attended each trip and facilitated each hunting game. Before play-
ing the game, the children were told that hyena and giant deer used to live in the area, but had
become extinct. They were told that archaeologists had found evidence that nearby caves were
once inhabited by hyenas. The children were also told that giant deer lived at the same time
and would have been hunted and eaten by the hyena. The children were told this information,
so that the roles of hyena and deer were understood as being appropriate for their hunting game.
One of the research team also introduced the rules of the game to the children and then, with their
class teachers, monitored their activities to ensure that none of the rules were broken. It is impor-
tant to stress that the children had complete autonomy within the rulesand they could decide
where to go and how to get there. The role presence of one the research team was deliberate to
ensure consistency, but, more importantly, to begin to build a relationship with the children for
later interviews.
Location
The nature reserve location that the children visited is a site of special scientific interest (SSSI)
because of its rare plant life and diversity of floristic and insect communities. The combination
of sand dunes, grasslands and trees meant that there were natural areas ideally suited for the hunt-
ing game as they provided various hiding places.
Sample
After gaining informed ethical consent under university protocols, four different classes from four
different primary schools (A, B, C and D) in South Wales took part in the research. The schools
were selected through an opportunity sample of schools who had worked with the research team
on previous projects. In total, 104 children took part in the activities. They were all in school year
5, aged between 9 and 10 years. After the activities, two mixed-gender groups of three children
from each school a total of 24 children and each class teacher took part in semi-structured
interviews. This study reports on the interviews from the children only. Each interview was
recorded and transcribed for later analysis.
Data Analysis
This analysis involved a rigorous thematic analysis, which aimed to transform lived experiences
into a textual expression of its essence(Beck, 2019, p. 75). As such, phenomenological research
carries a moral force(van Manen, 1997, p. 12) as it seeks meaning embedded in everyday life.
These meanings are not always apparent to the participants but can be gleaned from the narra-
tives produced by them(Lopez & Willis, 2004, p. 728). It is acknowledged, however, that the
experiential accounts or lived-experience descriptions are never truly identical to the prereflective
lived experiences themselvesas they are inevitably interpretations or transformations(van
Manen, 2016, p. 313). It was also accepted that as researchers we come to this analysis with forest-
ructures of understandingshaped by our experience (Wojnar & Swanson, 2007, p. 175).
Therefore, it is hard to totally free ourselves of theoretical and epistemological commitments,
and data are not coded in an epistemological vacuum(Braun-Clarke, 2006, p. 12). Therefore,
to ensure rigour the inductive analysis followed a process of reflexive thematic analysis. As there
are many different approaches to thematic analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2019), our analysis followed
Nowell et al.s(2017) approach to ensuring trustworthiness. As such, we began with no pre-
conceived ideas or pre-existing coding frame. Themes were generated (Braun & Clarke, 2019)
through the development of initial codes. This initial generating of codes, facilitated though anal-
ysis software, has been called eclectic codingand is described as an open process(Salda˜na
2015, p. 5). Some of the responses from the children included descriptions that were not about
Australian Journal of Environmental Education 7
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
the hunting game and so these were discarded. Only the descriptions that related to the hunting
game were analysed. During this process, we were conscious that that coding is not a precise
science; it is primarily an interpretive act (Saldana, 2015, p. 5). Searching for links between
the codes enabled the codes to be grouped under larger umbrella headings, or themes. The
researchers transferred the codes from the data analysis software onto sheets of paper in order
to be able to visually compare and view the codes and themes more easily. This involved writing
the name of each code (and a brief description) on a separate piece of paperenabling the
researcher to play around with organising them into theme-piles(Braun & Clarke, 2006,
p. 19). This analysis was an iterative hermeneutic cycle as an act of dwellingwith the minutiae
of data, as when we stop and linger with something, it secretes its sense and its full significance
becomes ::: amplified(Wertz, 1985, p. 174). In the next stage, the themes were reviewed. This
included discarding themes if there was not enough data to support them, or the data were too
diverse. Some themes were also grouped together or collapsed into each other(Braun & Clarke,
2006, p. 20) as further analysis highlighted close links between them.
To organise the generated themes we used what van Manen (1997) calls lifeworld existentials
or essential themes, as they are what makes the phenomenon what it is. Put simply, without
those essential themes the phenomenon would not exist (van Manen, 1997). It was important
that this organisation took place after the establishing of the themes to maintain an inductive
approach.
Results and analysis
The analysis generated various related themes which are reported under the following headings
based on van Manen (1997):
Corporeality
Spatiality
Temporality
Relationality
The results and analysis are presented together, so that the themesrelationships with the rele-
vant theory can be explicitly explored.
Corporeality
All of these themes reflect what van Manen (2016) describes as body-knowledge, a noncognitive
knowing(p. 48). This noncognitive knowing is understood and enacted in and through the body
(van Manen, 2016).
Embodiment
One of the main themes expressed consistently in the childrens responses was that the hunt game
was an embodied, multisensory experience. The data show that the childrens experience of play-
ing the hunting game involved a heightened sensory awareness. For example, Pupil 2 (P2) from
School D (D) [P2D] said: You could hear more stuff :::and you could feel more stuff :::I used
my hearing, because I was hearing D go into the woods, yeah, and he was like in the woods looking
through, and then I heard him stepping on loads of sticks, and then he was breaking them.
Similarly, P1D said: when you were outside :::you could feel all the stuff under your feet, its
one of your senses, where you dont know what it is and you dont what youre feeling and
its just so weird to actually feel what is under your feet. This is further supported by P6C said:
When we was (sic) like doing the deer game, basically when me and my friend was like hiding we
8 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
hid like in this little trail thing and we was looking at all like the leaves and that. And then
the sand.
The children were asked if they felt the same sensory experiences would have been felt if they
had played the game in the school grounds. In response, all of the children stated that playing the
game in the school grounds would not have produced the same experience. All of the children
interviewed felt that the hunting game at the nature reserve had enhanced their sensory experi-
ences. For example, P3D said: It was kind of the sound world. No, it wasnt the same ::: it was a
different world, because you felt like youre human but then you feel like, when I was playing the
hunting game, you actually felt like a hyena or deer and you could hear all the sounds around you.
The sense of an amplified embodied experience, which allows for a greater feeling of relation with
other-than-human life, is what Abram (1996, p. 47) describes when he describes the body as
a creative shape-shifting entity, that is the very means of entering into relation with all things.
When we are attentive to our ongoing, animal experience in the midst of this world, then the
flatness dissolves, and the enigmatic depth of the world becomes apparent(Abram, 2014,
p. 125). This idea of experiencing the enigmatic depth of the world when playing the game at
the nature reserve came through consistently in the childrens responses. For example, P1B com-
pared playing the hunting game in the nature reserve to playing on the school playground but said:
It was different because we wasnt even on a flat surface, so we was on bumps and stuff, and I like
being out in the world and in nature.
Analysis of the childrens responses also revealed that the children had experienced a height-
ened sense of excitement during the hunting game, exemplified by this interview extract:
P3C: Yeah, I never knew what was going to happen, maybe an animal could jump
out at me or maybe something just amazing was going to happen, like
Interviewer: Was that a bad thing, then?
P3C: No, its just thrilling, never knowing what is coming next, but if you always
know what is coming next its just going to be boring, like a video game; you
play the level all over again, you know what is going to happen, but in nature
you dont know what is going to happen, like every time is different.
This unpredictability of the play realm reflects the liminal nature of play (Huizinga, 1949;
Turner, 1974; Wood, 2014). In addition, P4C said: Well I felt really ::: well I felt terrified well,
kind of terrified but like scared. And then like happy at the same time because like I dont want to
get caught because Im really determined to like, yeah, just not get caught. But then really happy at
the same time because I was just really enjoying it. Such feelings can be linked to Woods(2014)
assertion, as discussed above, that childrens play is able to pivot between feelings of risk and
safety. She contends play safely explores exaggerated emotional states such as fear, bravery, sor-
row, excitement, happinessand children enjoy what she calls emotional hyperventilation
(Wood, 2014, p27).
Joy and happiness
The children consistently reported that their multisensory experiences had been accompanied by
feelings of joy. For example, P5A said: I think it feels great, because in school, when you play
football, say if you wanted to slide tackle, you cant because youd get muddy and then youre
not really meant to be muddy, you cant go down the grass here like there.Likewise, P3B said:
So I felt like :::happy, yeah, but because it was all, like, energetic. So :::and I like to use my
energy :::so it was just fun.
This resonates with Abrams(1996) assertions, as discussed above, that we insulate ourselves
from the deepest wellsprings of joy(p. 58) by shielding ourselves from our corporeal knowings.
When we allow affective bodily experiences in education all that is rigid and certain melts away
Australian Journal of Environmental Education 9
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
and what we are left with is wonder(Derby, 2015, p. 4). Derby (2015, p. 30) suggests that when
teaching remediates the kinship between knowing and life as it is lived and attunes to the polyph-
ony of being, we experience learning and the world as resonant.
Spatiality
All of these themes reflect how space impacts on the experience of the children whilst playing the
hunting game. This includes how they experience outside space differently from interiorities
(van Manen, 2016, p. 304).
Freedom
Another theme consistently reported was that being away from school and playing the hunting
game had induced an enhanced sense of freedom for the children. For example, P4A said:
When we were playing the animal game and when we got into the habit of pretending to be
animals, I felt free from being in the school, because in the school, theres lots of rules and we
cant do as much stuff. When we went out into there, it felt as if we were just free. We werent
in an enclosed space; we could go anywhere.
This is supported by P5C: I also felt :::we were free to roam, roam wherever Id like.
Likewise, P1B said: I think its more free, because theres more space with not everyone, like,
annoying you.This sense of ludic freedom instead of having to do certain things with rules
relates clearly to Turners(1974) claim that the liminal nature of play activities means they
are imbued with liberation. This is because they exist in a place that is not a place and a time
that is not a time(Turner, 1974, p. 239). It also concurs with Huizingas(1949) analysis of play as
being a free activityas it is consciously outside ordinary life(p. 13).
This is clearly expressed in this response from P1C who asserted that I felt like I could do
anything. Like I could jump! ::: and like I felt I could fly!Such feelings resonate with Bones
(2010) assertion that metamorphosis in play engenders a feeling of freedom as normal roles
are transcended. It also coalesces with Turner (1974), who argues that freedom in play is where
the value of the liminal lies, warning against rules or limits that signify the intrusion of normative
social structure(Turner, 1974, p. 61).
Absorption
The childrens responses show that they felt the place they were playing in and the sense of free-
dom allowed for an absorption in the activity of their play. When asked if they felt that the same
sense of freedom could have been achieved by playing the game in the school grounds the children
all agreed that it would not have been the same. For example, P1D said:
I wasnt thinking about anything just the game. ::: When you are like in a building or like
you are given hiding spots by people that have put the stuff there, it is just a game of hide and
seek. But when you go out into nature and nature gives you it, you are playing a hunt-
ing game.
This idea that the absorption in their play had meant that there was an authentic sense of play-
ing is a theme that repeatedly emerges throughout the childrens responses. For example, P2C
said: So when we were there, it felt like we were actually the animals within ::: if we were
in the classroom, we would just feel like people because we were in a classroom :::but it felt like
::: you are an animal and just you can explore and you can go anywhere, pretty much ::: I really
felt in nature ::: I just feel like I am free and I dont care about anything anymore.
10 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
This feeling of complete immersion in the seriousness of play supports Huizingas declaration
that childrens play proceeds with the utmost seriousness, with an absorption, a devotion that
passes into rapture(1949, p. 9). This absorption is as a result of the liminal freedom of play
and also in turn provides further freedom to the one who plays. When asked if the same experi-
ence could have been achieved by playing the game in the school grounds, the children again
consistently reported that it would not have been the same. For example, P2C said: It feels like
a different world because :::it feels like you have just stepped into a new dimension where all
there is grass, sand and everything natural.
Temporality
All of the themes reflect how the children experienced timewhilst playing the hunting game.
This includes how they experience subjective or lived timein comparison to clock time(van
Manen, 2016, p. 305).
Timelessness
The children reported that they had felt liberated because of a feeling of timelessness. For example,
P1A said:
It feels kind of odd because on the daily basis I look at my watch quite a lot because I have a
lot of clubs and stuff, so I have to know when I have to go ::: but when we were trying to
track down the girls, I didnt really care about time because I had nothing to go anywhere or
anything.
Similarly, P1D believed that:
I wasnt thinking about the time at all, because it felt like time didnt matter at all, because
here, pupil two is right, outside, we only have a certain amount of time, so were like, hurry
this game of football, hurry doing that. But there, we could just play for as long as we needed,
so I dont feel like there was any time.
Links can be made here with Turners(1974) liminality and BubersI-Thouphilosophies,
which are positioned as moments in and out of time(Turner, 2008, p. 96). The children con-
sistently reported that this sense of timelessness was an enjoyable experience. For example, P1C
said: It just felt like time froze and it was nothing mattered anymore and you didnt need any-
thing it just felt ::: it just made me happy, just looking over everything and everyone.The chil-
dren appeared to have transcended time when playing because their total absorption in the game
and in the present moment. As Buber (2002) explains the pure present knows no specific con-
sciousness of time(p. 167).
Weird time
There was also a consistent response from the children that described them feeling weird and
different in comparison to school for the duration of the game. For example, P3D said:
When I was playing the hunting game you actually felt like a hyena or a deer, but then when
I came back home, I didnt feel like that anymore. Similarly, P3C said: when I was playing
the game, I felt ::: like I ::: and like I hadnt come on a trip and I had come with nobody else,
as if I was back in the past and actually living there, way, way back in the past and actually living
there. When asked if this weirdness was a good or bad experience the children all stated that it
was a good experience. For example, P3B said: It felt weird :::a good weird.
Australian Journal of Environmental Education 11
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
Relationality
All of these themes reflect how the children experienced self and otherswhilst playing the hunt-
ing game. This includes whether the otheris experienced as object or as otherness(van
Manen, 2016, p. 303).
Togetherness
One of the consistent responses that emerged from the analysis of the data was a sense of togeth-
erness and unity with everyone who was playing the game. For example, P4A:
Well, when youre in the school, we just fall out over anything. Its like people are looking for
a chance to get angry with someone else, but out there, it feels different and youre not, it
doesnt, youre not like ::: it doesnt matter, whether you trip up, you trip over someone else
or they trip over you, because youre in nature and something is going to happen, but when
youre enjoying yourself, it doesnt really matter.
The children explained that they felt more together because they felt different during the hunt-
ing game. For example, P4A said: Because when youre in school you feel like you just, with
everyone else you dont feel close and then when youre out there, you feel different to everyone,
you know that this is like a good thing to do, because you dont feel the same way as you do in
school, by being ::: youre a different person.
Experiencing Otherness
This feeling of being otherwas also echoed by P1C who said that the whole class was a lot calmer
and that this was because When we were there, it felt like we were actually the animals within.
This feeling of difference due to experiencing a sense of othernessis also expressed in this inter-
view extract:
P2D said: I felt I was the animal; it was because that:::when Ive said, when I saw the
prey, the deer, yeah, when I saw the prey and the deer, I didnt, I just kept stalk-
ing it, it was getting ready and getting closer, and closer, and closer, but they
didnt see me.
Interviewer: How does that feel?
Pupil 2: It feels like I was a hyena and then I was catching prey, ready.
Pupil 3School D: It felt like you had a different life, so it felt like you werent human, you were like
an animal because youve had one life and now, youre in another life
This is view is similarly expressed by Pupil 1 from School C: Yeah, so when I was there, I just
felt like I was an animal, I didnt feel like I was a human anymore, I just felt like I was an animal.
This experience of existential change during the hunting game was repeated throughout the
childrens responses. We can draw parallels here with Bubers(2002) I-Thou existential philoso-
phy, as examined above, that involves an augmented sense of being leading to an improved or
spiritual sense of relation with others. Buber (2002, p. 37) describes this as a dynamic facing
of the other, a flowing from Ito Thouthat leads to an enhanced feeling of community.
Community with nature
There was a significant pattern in the responses that showed the children had experienced a sense
of community with nature whilst playing. For example, P6B said: So I felt like I was like :::close to
nature, so when I was hiding, yeah, I felt like I was an actual part of nature. Likewise, P5C said:
12 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
well, I did feel like I was part of nature because like it felt like I blended in with like the trees and
the grass and the hills and all the plantsThis was echoed by P4A who stated that
When we were playing the game, it felt like we were part of nature, it wasnt just like being in
the school and playing a game, it actually felt like we were nature :::and its so calm and
peaceful out there that you feel really relaxed.
This was further explained by P1C said: Because when you are there, you have like :::
you ::: everything is calm because ::: because you just ::: you are there and you are like bond-
ing with nature.
This sense of being in naturerelates clearly to Abrams contention that when we feel the
sensate depth of the natural environment, we experience ourselves within the animate landscape
(2010b, p. 9). It also resonates with Buber & Friedman, 1964) philosophy as he declares that dur-
ing an authentic I-Thou experience one realizes the unity of the world in the unity of his soul
(p. 141). The childrens responses suggest a sense of relation or community that can be realised
from a meeting with nature where one can be lifted out of the physicalworld and experience the
spiritual form of natural solidarity of connexion(Buber, 2010, p. 51).
We can also draw links here with Blenkinsop and Beeman (2010) and Derby (2015) who accen-
tuate metaphors capacity to elicit ontological attention(Derby, 2015, p. 52). If teaching can be
readjusted to make room for activities that facilitate other states of being, involving metaphorical
and embodied ways of knowing the more-than-human world, then the other-than-humancan
become a co-teacher and children can experience a dynamic equilibrium(Blenkinsop &
Beeman, 2010). Childrens play in general is metaphorical, existing in the imagination, but it does
not always involve empathic attunement with the other-than-human world. The hunting game in
this study engaged the childrens bodies, emotions and imaginations within the natural world and
also involved them in dialogue with the other-than-human. They did not see the more-than-
human world as it, but were bound up in relationand seized by the power of exclusiveness
(Buber, 2010, p. 14). The liminality of their play led to an expanded sense of self.
Whilst playing the hunting game, the children not only recognised the animate being of nature
but they also felt part of it. When specifically asked if playing the hunting game on the playground
in school would have been the same, the children repeatedly said that they would not have felt the
same sense of community with the other-than-human world. For example, P1C explained: Its
not the same feeling :::you are there and you are like bonding with nature and then on the play-
ground :::you are like playing with your friends and there is a lot of noise and you are running
around a lot. Similarly, P4A said: When youre in the school there are so many people around
you, and its hard because you cant hear. All you can hear is people shouting and screaming but
when we were there :::the people arent like in the school, they wont disturb you :::some of the
girls arent really friends, but when we were playing the game, it felt like our friendships came
closer to each other, as being part of nature.
The children were also adamant that the experience would have been different if the game had
been played on the school field or any part of the school grounds because they felt that the nature-
rich environment of the nature reserve, being free from urbanity, had allowed for a greater sense of
community with nature. For example, Pupil 1D said: It feels different because, like, youre actu-
ally more intact with it and youre not more, like, fenced off of it. This is also illustrated by Pupil
2C who revealed: Like Im part of it like. Like because everything I can see was nature and it felt
like I was in nature, like I could see everything for the first time. These responses clearly support
Derbys(2015, p. 42) assertion that developing the capacity to think metaphoricallycan be a
means to critically distanciate from ontological presuppositions ::: to come into intimate eco-
poetic attunement with ecological form. Moreover, this awareness had been reached due to the
metaphorical nature of the childrens play combined with the biodiverse, nature-rich location of
their playing. In addition, they support Blenkinsop and Beemans(2010) affirmation that when
Australian Journal of Environmental Education 13
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
people are allowed to interact with the other-than-human world unencumbered, then nature can
become a teacher providing ontological insight.
Conclusion
At the start of this paper, we posed the research question: How could children (aged 910 years)
playingthe role of animals in a nature setting enable them to experience different ways of being
and different ways of understanding their relationship with the world around them? The evidence
from the children in this study suggests that playing the hunting game had enabled the children to
experience the alterity of the non-human world. The wide-open expanse of the nature reserve the
lack of urbanity and the biodiversity of the location thathelped to augment the childrens sense of
participation with the more-than-human world. The childrens play provided them with an appar-
ent ingress into the perspective of an otheranimal. In addition, playing the role of an animal had
afforded them with an accentuated, embodied experience that engaged the children with the nat-
ural world and encompassed a sense of joy. In turn, this engagement offered an experience and
insight into the otherness of the more-than-human world through direct egalitarian interaction
(Blenkinsop & Beeman, 2010, p. 33).
This moved beyond using nature as a resource or to provide rational and logical understand-
ings. Instead, the epistemological knowings were felt through an ontological disruption (to their
normalsense of self and being) that involved an authentic sense of reciprocity and communion
with the natural world and each other. The childrens lived-experiences of playing the hunting
game had resulted in their accessing different ways of being and had apparently given them a
heightened empathic attunement with the more-than-human world. This enhanced insight into
the more-than-human world had been made accessible to the children through the multisensory,
liminal nature, and location, of their play. This provides evidence for the value of play for children
as offering knowings that can be afforded by playing in bio-diverse environments. These expanded
knowings involve feelings of joy and a sense of kinship with nature that could help the children to
cultivate healthy relationships with the other-than-human world. In turn, these healthy relationships
could help to foster healthy attitudes, and behaviours, that ameliorate the gross toxicity that often
characterises peoples current relationship with nature in the modern Western world. Moreover, it
reveals how understanding the more-than-human world as co-teacher(Blenkinsop & Beeman,
2010) is a fundamental part of the process, as non-anthropocentric perspectives are crucial if more
empathic attunement with the more-than-human world is to be achieved.
References
Abram, D. (1996). The spell of the sensuous: Perception and language in a more-than-human world. New York: Vintage.
Abram, D. (2010a). Becoming animal: An earthly cosmology. New York: Penguin Random House.
Abram, D. (2010b). Becoming animal. Green Letters,13,721.
Abram, D. (2014). The Invisibles: toward a phenomenology of the spirits. In G. Harvey (Ed.), The Handbook of Contemporary
Animism (pp. 132140). London: Routledge.
Ärlemalm-Hagser, E., & Sandberg, A. (2017). Early childhood education for sustainability: The relationship between young
childrens participation and agencychildren and nature. In T. Waller, E. Ärlemalm-Hagsér, E. B. H. Sandseter, L. Lee-
Hammond, K. Lekies, & S. Wyver (Eds.), The SAGE handbook of outdoor play and learning (pp. 213228). London: SAGE
Publications.
Barton J., & Pretty J. (2010). What is the best dose of nature and green exercise for improving mental health? A multi- study
analysis. Environmental Science and Technology 44, 39473955.
Beck, C. T. (2019). Introduction to phenomenology: Focus on methodology. London: SAGE Publications.
Beckett, C. (2017). Making life worth living: Theories of play enlivened through the work of Donald Winnicott. In S. Lynch,
D. Pike, & C. À. Beckett (Eds.), Multidisciplinary perspectives on play from birth and beyond (pp. 2537). Singapore:
Springer.
Beeman, C., & Blenkinsop, S. (2008). Might diversity also be ontological? Considering Heidegger, Spinoza and Indigeneity in
educative practice. Encounters in Theory and History of Education,9,95107.
14 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
Bento, G., & Dias, G. (2017). The importance of outdoor play for young childrens healthy development. Porto Biomedical
Journal,2, 157160.
Bentz, V. M., & Shapiro, J. J. (1998). Mindful inquiry in social research. London: Sage Publications.
Blades, G. (2015). Walking the ground. In M. Robertson, R. Lawrence, & G. Heath (Eds.), Experiencing the outdoors.
Researching environmental learning (pp. 1324). Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.
Blenkinsop, S., & Beeman, C. (2010). The world as co-teacher: Learning to work with a peerless colleague. The Trumpeter,26,
2739.
Bone, J. (2010). Metamorphosis: play, spirituality and the animal. Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood,11, 402414.
Bonnett, M. (2017). Sustainability and human being: Towards the hidden centre of authentic education. In B. Jickling &
S. Sterling (Eds.), Post-sustainability and environmental education (pp. 7991). Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Bragg, R., Wood, C., Barton, J., & Pretty, J. (2013). Measuring connection to nature in children aged 812: A robust meth-
odology for the RSPB. University of Essex. Available at: http://rackspace-web1.rspb.org.uk/Images/methodology-report_
tcm9-354606.pdf (Accessed on 9 January 2021).
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology,3,77101.
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2019) Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis, Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health,
11, 589597.
Brown, S. L. (2009). Play: How it shapes the brain, opens the imagination, and invigorates the soul. London: Penguin.
Buber, M. (2002). Between man and man. New York: Routledge.
Buber, M. (1964). Daniel: Dialogues on realization (trans. M. Friedman). New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Buber, M. (1970). I and Thou (trans. W. Kaufmann). Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark
Buber, M. (2010). I and Thou (trans. R. G. Smith). London: Continuum.
Cajete, G.A. (2015). Indigenous community: Rekindling the teachings of the seventh fire. Minnesota: Living Justice Press.
DallAlba, G. (Ed.). (2010). Exploring education through phenomenology: Diverse approaches. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.
Deleuze, G., & Parnet, C. (2002). Dialogues II, trans. Hugh Tomlinson and Barbara Habberjam, London: Continuum.
Derby, M. W. (2015). Place, being, resonance: A critical ecohermeneutic approach to education. New York: Peter Lang.
Dowdell, K., Gray, T., & Malone, K. (2011). Nature and its influence on childrens outdoor play. Journal of Outdoor and
Environmental Education,15,2435.
Evernden, L. L. N. (1993). The natural alien: Humankind and environment. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Fasting, ML. (2017) The magic of outdoor play: A phenomenological hermeneutic approach merete lund fasting. In T. Waller,
E. Ärlemalm-Hagsér, E. B. H. Sandseter, L. Lee-Hammond, K. Lekies, & S. Wyver (Eds.), The SAGE handbook of outdoor
play and learning (pp. 630644). London: Sage.
Gadamer, H. G., (2004). Translation revised by Weinsheimer, J., & Marshall, D. G. Truth and method. New York: Bloomsbury
Publishing USA.
Gray, P. (2011). The decline of play and the rise of psychopathology in children and adolescents. American Journal of Play,3,
443463.
Hiscock, R., & Mitchell, R. (2011). What is needed to deliver places that provide good health to children? Transport,12, 15.
Huizinga, J. (1949). Homo Ludens: A study of the play-element in our culture. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Humberstone, B. (2015). Embodiment, nature and wellbeing: More than the senses?. In M. Robertson, R. Lawrence, &
G. Heath (Eds.), Experiencing the outdoors (pp. 6172). Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.
Humberstone, B., Prince, H., & Henderson, K. A. (Eds.). (2015). Routledge international handbook of outdoor studies.
London: Routledge.
Jardine, D. W. (2016). In praise of radiant beings: A retrospective path through education, Buddhism and ecology. Charlotte,
NC: Information Age Publishing.
Jickling, B., Blenkinsop, S., Timmerman, N., & Sitka-Sage, M. D. D. (Eds.). (2018). Wild pedagogies: Touchstones for re-
negotiating education and the environment in the Anthropocene. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Jickling, B., & Sterling, S. (Eds.). (2017). Post-sustainability and environmental education: Remaking education for the future.
Singapore: Springer.
Kardefelt-Winther, D. (2017). How does the time children spend using digital technology impact their mental well-being, social
relationships and physical activity?: An evidence-focused literature review. Florence, Italy: UNICEF Office of Research-
Innocenti. Available at: https://tinyurl.com/y3z7a69f (Accessed on January 6, 2021).
Lopez, K. A., & Willis, D.C. (2004). Descriptive versus interpretive phenomenology: Their contributions to nursing knowl-
edge. Qualitative Health Research,14, 726736.
Louv, R. (2011). The nature principle: Human restoration and the end of nature-deficit disorder. New York: Algonquin Books.
Louv, R. (2019). Our wild calling: How connecting with animals can transform our livesand save theirs. New York:
Algonquin Books.
Lynch, S., Pike, D., & Beckett, C. À. (Eds.). (2017). Multidisciplinary perspectives on play from birth and beyond (Vol. 18).
Singapore: Springer.
Macy, J. (2016). The Greening of the Self. In L. Vaughan-Lee (Ed.), Spiritual Ecology: The Cry of the Earth. Point Reyes Station,
California: The Golden Sufi Centre.
Australian Journal of Environmental Education 15
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
Macy, J., & Brown, M. Y. (2014). Coming back to life: The guide to the Work that Reconnects. Gabriola Island: New Society
Publishers.
Nowell, B., & Albrecht, K. (2019). A reviewers guide to qualitative rigor. Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory,
29, 348364.
Nowell, L. S., Norris, J. M., White, D. E., & Moules, N. J. (2017) Thematic analysis: Striving to meet the trustworthiness
criteria.International Journal of Qualitative Methods,16,113.
OConnor, D. (2017). Loving learning: The value of play within contemporary primary school pedagogy. In S. Lynch, D. Pike,
& C. À. Beckett (Eds.), Multidisciplinary perspectives on play from birth and beyond (pp. 93107). Singapore: Springer.
Patočka, J. (1998). Body, community, language, world. Chicago: Open Court Publishing.
Robertson, M. (2015). An early morning walk. In M. Robertson, R. Lawrence, & G. Heath (Eds.), Experiencing the outdoors
(pp. 112). Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.
Robertson, M., Lawrence, R., & Heath, G. (Eds.). (2015). Experiencing the outdoors: Enhancing strategies for wellbeing.
Rotterdam: Sense Publishers.
Salda˜na, J. (2015). The coding manual for qualitative researchers. London: Sage.
Saunders, T. J., & Vallance, J. K. (2017). Screen time and health indicators among children and youth: current evidence,
limitations and future directions. Applied Health Economics and Health Policy,15, 323331.
Seed, J. (1988). Beyond anthropocentrism. In J. Seed & D. Pugh (Eds.), Thinking like a mountain: Towards a council of all
beings (pp. 3540). Gabriola Island: New Society Publishers.
Shepard, P. (1973). The tender carnivore and the sacred game. Georgia: University of Georgia Press.
Shepard, P. (1998). Nature and madness. Georgia: University of Georgia Press.
Sibthorp, J., & Richmond, D. (2015). Adventure education. Crucible, catalyst and inexact. In B. Humberstone, H. Prince, &
K. A. Henderson (Eds.), Routledge international handbook of outdoor studies (pp.207213). London: Routledge.
Šmahel, D., & Blinka, L. (2012). Excessive internet use among European children. Children, Risk and Safety on the Internet:
Research and Policy Challenges in Comparative Perspective,191, 204.
Turner, V. (1974). Liminal to liminoid, in play, flow, and ritual: An essay in comparative symbology. Rice Institute Pamphlet-
Rice University Studies,60,3.
Turner, V. (1979). Frame, flow and reflection: Ritual and drama as public liminality. Japanese Journal of Religious Studies, 6/4
December 1979, 465499.
Turner, V. (1982). From ritual to theatre: The human seriousness of play. New York. Performing Arts Journal Publications.
Van Manen, M. (1997). Researching lived experience: Human science for an active sensitive pedagogy. Ontario, Canada: The
State University of New York.
Van Manen, M. (2016). Phenomenology of practice: Meaning-giving methods in phenomenological research and writing.
London; Routledge.
Vanaken, G. J., & Danckaerts, M. (2018). Impact of green space exposure on childrens and adolescentsmental health: A
systematic review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,15, 2668.
Vaughan-Lee, L. (2016). Spiritual ecology: The cry of the earth. Point Reyes Station, California: The Golden Sufi Centre.
Waller, T., Ärlemalm-Hagsér, E., Sandseter, E. B. H., Lee-Hammond, L., Lekies, K., & Wyver, S. (Eds.). (2017). The SAGE
handbook of outdoor play and learning. London: Sage.
Ward, J. S., Duncan, J. S., Jarden, A., & Stewart, T. (2016). The impact of childrens exposure to greenspace on physical
activity, cognitive development, emotional wellbeing, and ability to appraise risk. Health & Place,40,4450.
Welsh Government. (2015). Curriculum for WalesFoundation phase framework. Available at: https://hwb.gov.wales/
curriculum-for-wales-2008/foundation-phase/foundation-phase-framework (Accessed on 12th January, 2021).
Wertz, F.J. (1985). Methods and findings in a phenomenological psychological study of complex life-event: Being criminally
victimized. In A. Giorgi (Ed.), Phenomenology and psychological research (pp. 155216). Pittsburgh, PA: Duquesne
University Press.
Winnicott, D. W. (2005). Playing and reality. London: Routledge.
Wojnar, D. M., & Swanson, K. M. (2007). Phenomenology. Journal of Holistic Nursing 25, 172180.
Wood, E. (2014). I wonder why our dog has been so naughty? Thinking differently from the perspective of play. In S. Robson
& S. F. Quinn (Eds.), The Routledge international handbook of young childrens thinking and understanding (pp. 5364).
London: Routledge.
Cite this article: Adams D and Beauchamp G. Other knowings and experiencing otherness: Childrens perspectives of playing
a hunting game in a nature reserve. Australian Journal of Environmental Education.https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
16 Dylan Adams and Gary Beauchamp
https://www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/aee.2021.10
Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 193.149.21.228, on 23 Aug 2021 at 18:30:57, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Institutions are useful for advancing methodologies within disciplines. Through required coursework, doctoral students are indoctrinated into basic guidelines and frameworks that provide a common foundation for scholars to interact with one another. Lacking such forums in many of our doctoral granting institutions (Stout 2013), the field of public management continues to struggle with an ambivalence toward qualitative approaches. Lack of shared understanding concerning basic tenets of qualitative methodology abounds. This article is intended for qualitative consumers, those not formally trained in qualitative methods but who serve as peer reviewers, content experts, and advisors in arenas where qualitative methods are encountered. Adopting a postpositivistic stance dominant in the field, we seek to offer a pragmatic perspective on qualitative methods with regards to some basic tenets of rigor appropriate (and inappropriate) for assessing the contribution of qualitative research. We argue that the first step in this effort is to stop conflating data type (qualitative versus quantitative) with inductive versus deductive modes of inquiry. Using deductive modes as the basis for comparison, we discuss both common, as well as, diverging criteria of quality and rigor for inductive modes of inquiry. We conclude with a discussion of rigor in emerging methods which utilize qualitative data but from within a deductive, mixed, or hybrid mode of inquiry. © 2018 The Author(s). Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Public Management Research Association. All rights reserved.
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, the interest in the relationship between exposure to green spaces and children’s and adolescents’ mental health has risen. This systematic review aims to provide an overview of observational studies assessing the association between empirical green space exposure with standardized outcome measures of mental health problems, mental well-being and developmental problems in children, adolescents and young adults. The PRISMA statement guidelines for reporting systematic reviews were followed. A PubMed and Scopus search resulted in the inclusion of 21 studies. The evidence consistently suggests a beneficial association between green space exposure and children’s emotional and behavioral difficulties, particularly with hyperactivity and inattention problems. Limited evidence suggests a beneficial association with mental well-being in children and depressive symptoms in adolescents and young adults. These beneficial associations are resistant to adjustment for demographic and socio-economic confounders, which thus may represent independent links. Mediating factors and the variability of this association between different age groups are discussed. From a precautionary principle, evidence up to now demands the attention of policy makers, urban planners and mental healthcare workers in order to protect children’s and adolescents’ mental health in light of rapid global urbanization by providing sufficient exposure to green spaces.
Article
Full-text available
A growing body of literature indicates that humans need contact with nature for their wellbeing, however at the same time young children are becoming increasingly separated from the natural world as their access to the outdoors diminishes. The importance of school and prior-to-school settings in Connecting children with nature has been acknowledged. This study sought to find out how opportunities to engage with nature would influence children’s play and social behaviours. Two early childhood centres with contrasting outdoor environments were selected for the study, and twelve focus participants were observed over a twelve-week period in concert with interviews and field notes. The findings suggest that natural environments support children’s imaginative play, the development of positive relationships and allows for the environment to become a place of learning. The authors conclude that in order to make effective use of the outdoors, early childhood centres need to provide children with access to the natural environment and teachers who support children in developing a relationship with nature.
Article
Full-text available
Based on an evidence-focused literature review, the first part of this paper examines existing knowledge on how the time children spend using digital technology impacts their well-being across three dimensions; mental/psychological, social and physical. The evidence reviewed here is largely inconclusive with respect to impact on children’s physical activity, but indicates that digital technology seems to be beneficial for children’s social relationships. In terms of impact on children’s mental well-being, the most robust studies suggest that the relationship is U-shaped, where no use and excessive use can have a small negative impact on mental well-being, while moderate use can have a small positive impact. In the second part of the paper, the hypothetical idea of addiction to technology is introduced and scrutinized. This is followed by an overview of the hypothetical idea that digital technology might re-wire or hijack children’s brains; an assumption that is challenged by recent neuroscience evidence. In conclusion, considerable methodological limitations exist across the spectrum of research on the impact of digital technology on child well-being, including the majority of the studies on time use reviewed here, and those studies concerned with clinical or brain impacts. This prompts reconsideration of how research in this area is conducted. Finally, recommendations for strengthening research practices are offered.
Article
Since initially writing on thematic analysis in 2006, the popularity of the method we outlined has exploded, the variety of TA approaches have expanded, and, not least, our thinking has developed and shifted. In this reflexive commentary, we look back at some of the unspoken assumptions that informed how we wrote our 2006 paper. We connect some of these un-identified assumptions, and developments in the method over the years, with some conceptual mismatches and confusions we see in published TA studies. In order to facilitate better TA practice, we reflect on how our thinking has evolved – and in some cases sedimented – since the publication of our 2006 paper, and clarify and revise some of the ways we phrased or conceptualised TA, and the elements of, and processes around, a method we now prefer to call reflexive TA.
Article
In the last decade, there has been growing interest in both ‘outdoor play and learning’ and ‘gender balance’ in the Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC) profession (Edström, 2009; Rohrmann & Emilsen, 2015; Waller, Sandseter, Wyver, ÄrlemalmHagsér, & Maynard, 2010). It has been argued that outdoor play is both an important context for the development of children (Bilton, 2005; Waller et al., 2010) and a means to encourage a gender-balanced workforce (Emilsen & Koch, 2010). In nearly every country in the world, there are very few men working in ECEC (Oberhuemer, Schreyer, & Neuman, 2010; Peeters, Rohrmann, & Emilsen, 2015). Similarly, in most countries outdoor play seems to have minor importance in comparison to indoor play. However, in some countries, outdoor and indoor play are considered equally important and in some of these countries, such as Norway, the proportion of men in ECEC is above average. In this chapter, we will provide an overview of a range of studies, perspectives and understandings regarding outdoor play and gender, and also discuss the role of ECEC institutions as gendered spaces. The aim of this chapter is to investigate the connection between the number of men working in ECEC and the incidence of outdoor play. In addition we aim to explore whether outdoor activities attract more men as ECEC workers, and reflect upon whether outdoor preschools are an arena for recruiting men to the ECEC profession
Article
By considering the work and words of some Anishinaabe Elders, Heidegger, and Spinoza we argue that these point at another state of being, a different ontological position, from the one most broadly expressed in modern western culture and in its schools. We call this state attentive receptivity. While leaving the door open for still other states of being, we sketch in some key conditions and qualities including its interdependence with the more-than-human world. We argue that the condition of attentive receptivity can be seen as a different ontological position because of fundamental differences in what is understood and enacted as self, place, community, and the environment. We also think that accompanying arguments for different ways of knowing imply a different way of being. Through this reflexively coupled loop of ontology and epistemology we end by suggesting that education, if it is serious about diversity, would do well to consider both ontology and epistemology in creating a truly diverse education.
Book
‘This book leads an attack on the domestication of learning, the creeping formality, the structures and control, the standardizing, the separation of each of us from ourselves and our physical reality. This is a portrait of the physicality of children and the need to embrace this in education; the need to see education as humans in the world; the need to experiment with ideas and words that give meaning to our intuitions. An important argument. An important book.’ —John Ralston Saul, essayist and novelist This book explores why the concept of wild pedagogy is an essential aspect of education in these times; a re-negotiated education that acknowledges the necessity of listening to voices in a more than human world, and (re)learning how to dwell in a place. As the geological epoch inexorably shifts to the Anthropocene, the authors argue that learning to live in and engage with the world is increasingly crucial in such times of uncertainty. The editors and contributors examine what wild pedagogy can truly become, and how it can be relevant across disciplinary boundaries: offering six touchstones as working tools to help educators forge an onward path. This collaborative work will be of interest to students and scholars of wild pedagogies, alternative education and the Anthropocene, and for all those engaged in re-wilding education. Bob Jickling is Professor Emeritus at Lakehead University, Canada. Sean Blenkinsop is Professor at Simon Fraser University, Canada. Nora Timmerman is Lecturer at Northern Arizona University, USA. Michael De Danann Sitka-Sage (formerly Michael W. Derby) is Researcher at Simon Fraser University, Canada.