ArticlePDF Available

The male breadwinner nuclear family is not the 'traditional' human family, and promotion of this myth may have adverse health consequences

The Royal Society
Philosophical Transactions B
Authors:

Abstract

The importance of social support for parental and child health and wellbeing is not yet sufficiently widely recognized. The widespread myth in Western contexts that the male breadwinner–female homemaker nuclear family is the ‘traditional’ family structure leads to a focus on mothers alone as the individuals with responsibility for child wellbeing. Inaccurate perceptions about the family have the potential to distort academic research and public perceptions, and hamper attempts to improve parental and child health. These perceptions may have arisen partly from academic research in disciplines that focus on the Western middle classes, where this particular family form was idealized in the mid-twentieth century, when many of these disciplines were developing their foundational research. By contrast, evidence from disciplines that take a cross-cultural or historical perspective shows that in most human societies, multiple individuals beyond the mother are typically involved in raising children: in evolutionary anthropology, it is now widely accepted that we have evolved a strategy of cooperative reproduction. Expecting mothers to care for children with little support, while expecting fathers to provide for their families with little support, is, therefore, likely to lead to adverse health consequences for mothers, fathers and children. Incorporating evidence-based evolutionary, and anthropological, perspectives into research on health is vital if we are to ensure the wellbeing of individuals across a wide range of contexts. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Multidisciplinary perspectives on social support and maternal–child health’.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... In modern times, professional childcare services and schools provide a vital system of cooperation whereby parents can safely leave their children to develop the skills needed for adulthood while parents work. Yet an isolated nuclear family with a male breadwinner and female child-rearer continues to be idealized as standard, even though rigidly adhering to these roles can be counterproductive for families facing dynamic challenges and opportunities (Sear, 2021;Ruggles, 2015). ...
... In fact, when childcare falls exclusively to mothers, without support from extended family or professional services, outcomes for both women and children are often suboptimal (Sear, 2021;Yerkes and others, 2021). This was perhaps most vividly demonstrated during the COVID-19 pandemic, when lockdowns and school closures produced adverse impacts, including poorer mental health, poorer social development, learning loss and school dropout -the list goes on (Moscoviz and Evans, 2022;Connor and others, 2020;Singh and others, 2020). ...
Book
Full-text available
The State of World Population report 2023 looks at the milestone of 8 billion recently reached by the human population and the narratives surrounding population change. The report looks in particular at discourses which put forward ideas of 'too many' or 'too few' people and at the harm this can cause women and girls whose reproductive choices are on the line.
... Ambilocal, bilocal and neolocal systems make up 31.9% of marriage systems and happen in a diverse range of contexts, from urban centres to rural hunter-gatherers. Neolocality is most commonly associated with large-scale market economies in the West as well as rapidly developing and urbanising areas worldwide (Stone, 2009), and is deeply embedded into Western concepts of the 'traditional' nuclear family (Sear, 2021). Natalocal is particularly rare, representing only 0.5% of marriage systems cross-culturally. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
A family is a network of individuals tied to each other by blood, marriage, adoption or fostering and comes in many forms and sizes. There is no singular or universal type of family. Some common family types or structures include a single parent and children, a ‘nuclear’ family comprising two parents and children, or extended families consisting of one or two parents, children and other relatives. However, a range of different family types exist within this spectrum. A household is a commonly used term or unit of analysis to describe a group of people’s living arrangements and relationships to each other. What comprises a household can vary across cultures, social contexts and even seasons. While family and households are often conflated in the literature, in reality they are different. Families refer to specific kinship structures, whereas not all members of a household are necessarily kin but instead are tied to each other through co-residence and roles and responsibilities around the production and consumption of food and labour. One key reason we see so much variation in families and households is because people usually tend to live with other people - although, of course, living alone is also a type of household. Thus, family and household size, structure and composition can vary for multiple reasons across cultures including the number of children a parent/couple have, child and adult survival rates, the types of marriage which form the family and the post-marital residence systems which influence the generational configuration of households. This chapter underlines how flexible and context-specific human family systems are, and how the vast diversity present in humans leads to endless types of families and households.
... Our chapter has demonstrated none of these assumptions hold based on theory and evidence. However, they remain because they are deeply embedded into Western perspectives which dominate social science research, based on concepts of gender, sex roles which stem from mid 20th century concepts of the 'traditional' male-breadwinner nuclear family (Sear, 2021). When studying marriage from cross-cultural perspectives it is important to explicitly question the assumptions we make because of who we are as researchers. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
If we take a cross-cultural view of human societies, there are few institutions or systems which can be argued to be ‘universal’. Marriage may be the exception. It is found in virtually all societies, and likely has a deep evolutionary history (Shenk, 2024). However, this universality only holds if we define marriage extremely loosely, as the socially recognised union between two or more individuals (Fortunato, 2015). Beyond this, we see significant variation. Given that a key function of marriage is the legalisation and regulation of sex and reproduction, it is easy to see marriage as the cultural analogy of mating systems (chapter 20). Certainly, marriage type often is used as a proxy for mating success. But sex and reproduction occurs outside of marriage and marriage is about much more than just reproduction. It is interwoven with concepts of family and kinship: influencing and being influenced by kin obligations, how descent and inheritance is traced and economic and subsistence systems (Shenk, 2024). We need to understand a lot more about human kinship, inheritance and cultural systems to understand marriage from an evolutionary perspective. In this chapter, we will focus on evolutionary perspective to marriage types in terms of spousal number, reflecting on the diverse forms regularised human partnerships take.
... Ironically, such restrictive cultural norms and policies may have the effect of reducing, rather than increasing, fertility. Rigid gender ideologies which force women into only "home-making" roles are unlikely to suit women's evolved preferences, since women have combined work with childrearing throughout human history (Sear 2021). In at least some cases, increased abortion restrictions may lead to a decline in fertility, perhaps because of risk aversion on the part of women who are denied the option of comprehensive reproductive healthcare (Matysiak and van der Velde 2023). ...
Article
Full-text available
The edited volume “The Politics of Replacement” covers “population replacement” ideologies—fears that a particular population will be replaced by a different kind of people, because of the higher fertility of the latter group, and/or their immigration into the former group’s “territories.” The book does a good job of outlining the evolution of replacement ideologies, highlighting their widespread nature, and emphasising how population data may be misused in such ideologies. The book is therefore recommended reading for demographers (and other researchers); understanding how demography is politicised is important in order to guard against such misappropriation.
... Indeed, the prominence of monogamous marriage in Western societies today may be driven in large part by the cultural transmission of norms regulating marriage, such as those propagated by state democracies and religious institutions (11). This may in turn explain why public health scholars have been quick to view this as a favorable marriage form (16). ...
Article
Nuclear family structures are often thought to be essential for the well-being of children. Divorce, the loss of either biological parent, the presence of step-parents, and the practice of polygynous marriage have all been claimed to negatively impact child well-being. However, empirical research on these topics has been limited by the routine use of cross-regional and cross-sectional databases. Cross-regional data render research vulnerable to the ecological inference fallacy, and cross-sectional data prevent assessment of age-specific impacts of time-varying family-structure variables. When longitudinal data are available, they tend to be drawn from Western/urban contexts. Detailed data on family structure and children’s well-being are rarely collected in more marginalized communities. In many rural and traditional communities, nonnuclear family structures are indeed prevalent and viewed as socially permissible—and, as such, may have different impacts on children’s well-being than in Western contexts. Here, we draw on a detailed, longitudinal dataset from a 20-y prospective study in rural Tanzania, where polygyny and serial monogamy are common. We analyze survival outcomes for 3,693 children born between 1931 and 2014, growth outcomes for 881 children born between 1976 and 2014, and educational outcomes for 1,370 children born between 1976 and 2014. Our analyses indicate that monogamous marriage is not consistently associated with better outcomes for children—contrary to some popular and public health perspectives on human family structure.
... The prioritisation of financial security and individual success has created immense stress for Christian couples, leading to tension between worldly aspirations and spiritual fulfilment. The prevalent economic realities have also necessitated a shift towards a nuclear family structure, reducing the influence and support of extended family networks (Alabi and Olonade 2022;Sear 2021). This has led to feelings of isolation and a lack of accountability, potentially making couples more susceptible to drifting apart or engaging in unethical behaviour without familial oversight. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study explores the ethical dilemmas in contemporary Igbo Christian marriages as couples navigate the interaction between modernity and cultural identities. Marriage in traditional Igbo society is entrenched in strong cultural and religious values. However, Christianity and modernity have brought new dynamics to this institution in contemporary times. This paper, therefore, examines the influence of Christianity and modernity on Igbo traditional marriage, discussing ethical dilemmas arising from these influences. It specifically addresses areas where the traditional Igbo practices often clash with Christian doctrine and modern ideals, such as Igbo communalism, gender roles, family obligations, and marital expectations. The study also highlights strategies for resolving these dilemmas, including effective communication, cultural adaptability, and external support systems. Utilising a qualitative case study and descriptive–analytical methods, the research provides invaluable insights into the emerging dilemmas in Igbo marriage, offering a nuanced understanding of how individuals and communities can navigate these ethical complexities in a fast-shifting world. This work contributes to the broader discussions on cultural identities, religious practices, and ethical challenges in modern times.
Article
Although structural sexism in state-level institutions is harmful to women’s and men’s health, less is known about how micro-level structural sexism relates to well-being. Using the 2017 and 2021 Gallup Values and Beliefs of the American Public surveys (N = 1,501 in 2017; N = 1,248 in 2021), we investigate diverse approaches to internalized sexism. Although we find no significant associations with self-rated health, gender traditionalism is linked to greater depressive and anxiety symptoms for women and men, providing the first population evidence for its universal harm in the United States. Although benevolent sexism shows no associations with mental well-being, hostile sexism is linked to greater symptoms among men. A diminished sense of mastery consistently accounts for these relationships, showing promise as a potential mechanism. These findings are suppressed by political conservatism and religious involvement, both of which lead to reporting greater—rather than diminished—well-being.
Article
Full-text available
Family and work are essential components of modern life in both advanced and developing societies. Devoting excessive time to one of these domains’ conflicts with the other; they are interdependent and crucial to existence. Based on spillover and role theory, this study examines the impact of family–work and work–family conflict on job satisfaction, life satisfaction, and mental and physical health. Moreover, the research examines whether or not resilience moderates this association. In a cross-sectional design, a sample of 242 married female high school teachers administered a questionnaire. The study used the most recent PLS-SEM (partial least square structural equation modeling) software for data analysis. According to the findings, family–work conflict has a negative and statistically significant impact on job and life satisfaction. Work–family conflict, on the other hand, has a significant positive effect on life satisfaction. The results also revealed that both family–work and work–family conflicts have insignificant effects on mental and physical health. Moreover, the research showed that resilience plays a moderating role in the association between family–work conflict and both job and life satisfaction. This study contributed an additional understanding of the impacts of work and family conflict and aids policymakers and the Ministry of Education in developing efficient family-friendly policies.
Chapter
Full-text available
Human evolutionary demography is an emerging field blending natural science with social science. This edited volume provides a much-needed, interdisciplinary introduction to the field and highlights cutting-edge research for interested readers and researchers in demography, the evolutionary behavioural sciences, biology, and related disciplines. By bridging the boundaries between social and biological sciences, the volume stresses the importance of a unified understanding of both in order to grasp past and current demographic patterns. Demographic traits, and traits related to demographic outcomes, including fertility and mortality rates, marriage, parental care, menopause, and cooperative behavior are subject to evolutionary processes. Bringing an understanding of evolution into demography therefore incorporates valuable insights into this field; just as knowledge of demography is key to understanding evolutionary processes. By asking questions about old patterns from a new perspective, the volume—composed of contributions from established and early-career academics—demonstrates that a combination of social science research and evolutionary theory offers holistic understandings and approaches that benefit both fields. Human Evolutionary Demography introduces an emerging field in an accessible style. It is suitable for graduate courses in demography, as well as upper-level undergraduates. Its range of research is sure to be of interest to academics working on demographic topics (anthropologists, sociologists, demographers), natural scientists working on evolutionary processes, and disciplines which cross-cut natural and social science, such as evolutionary psychology, human behavioral ecology, cultural evolution, and evolutionary medicine. As an accessible introduction, it should interest readers whether or not they are currently familiar with human evolutionary demography.
Article
Full-text available
In this piece, I reflect on the current model of motherhood that prevails in Western countries, often termed ‘intensive mothering'. I will briefly trace the history of this approach, focusing in particular on how theory from developmental psychology has, to some extent, functioned to reinforce it by foregrounding the mother–child dyad and emphasizing the importance of maternal practices for children's developmental outcomes. I will then consider the particular implications of this cultural approach to motherhood for women's experiences of motherhood and maternal wellbeing. Finally, I reiterate that we need to continue to challenge this western-centric model of motherhood, which risks both isolating and overburdening women, by highlighting the ways in which both women and children benefit from wider social support systems, yet also by making it permissible for women to access social support without compromising a ‘good mother' identity. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Multidisciplinary perspectives on social support and maternal–child health'.
Article
Full-text available
Male partners/fathers are key support persons for many childbearing women and their involvement in pregnancy, childbirth and the postpartum/postnatal period has beneficial effects on a wide range of outcomes related to maternal and child health and family wellbeing. Social support is implicated in the relevant causal pathway, but has received largely tangential attention in the public health literature. This discussion paper aims to reframe men's participation in maternity care as an opportunity to enhance their readiness and ability to provide social support to women, contributing to the debate on the definition and rationale for male partner involvement, and paving the way for further empirical work. I begin by presenting a theory of change illustrating the causal pathway leading from male partner participation, through the key intermediate step of social support, to improved health and wellbeing for women and children. I proceed by arguing that many people desire male partner participation in maternity care; however, in practice, this is often limited owing to cultural, social and institutional barriers. I use examples from the intervention literature to demonstrate how participation in care can boost men's motivation to support women and enhance their ability to do so by increasing their knowledge and skills. Finally, I draw up general implications for further male partner involvement programmes, suggesting that in order to achieve meaningful and sustainable gains, attention to design is crucial in order to avoid reinforcing patriarchal gender norms. Programmes should be implemented alongside other efforts to improve quality and promote woman-centred care. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Multidisciplinary perspectives on social support and maternal–child health’.
Article
Full-text available
The early years are critical and inform the developmental trajectory of children. This is justifiably attracting growing policy attention. Much of this attention is focused on interventions and policies directed at parents, especially mothers. Yet emerging evidence suggests that increasing numbers of children in rapidly urbanizing low- and middle-income countries are now spending much of their day with other formal and informal childcare providers, including largely unregulated paid childcare providers. This paper summarizes the limited literature about the use of such paid childcare in low- and middle-income countries in sub-Saharan Africa, before considering possible reasons behind the lack of research evidence. Finally, key research gaps and their implications for public health practice are explored, with reference to the ongoing British Academy funded Nairobi Early Childcare in Slums research programme in Nairobi, Kenya. We argue that improving childcare may be an under-explored strategy to help some of the world's most disadvantaged children in the most important period of their lives, and that interventions in this largely informal market should be built on a rigorous research base. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Multidisciplinary perspectives on social support and maternal–child health’.
Article
Full-text available
In humans, high levels of investment are required to raise offspring, because of the prolonged developmental period and short interbirth intervals. The costs borne by individual mothers may be mitigated by obtaining social support from others. This strategy could be particularly valuable for first-time mothers, who lack first-hand experience and whose offspring have higher mortality risk than later-born siblings. As raising children is potentially stressful, mothers may gain from others sharing their experience, providing knowledge/information and emotional support. Being genetically related to both mother and grandchild, maternal grandmothers may be especially well placed to provide such support, while also gaining fitness benefits. We tested the over-arching hypothesis that first-time mothers and their young children supported by the maternal grandmother would have lower levels of stress and better health outcomes, compared to mother–infant dyads lacking such grandmaternal support. A cohort of 90 mother–infant dyads (52 with grandmaternal support, 38 without) was recruited in Merida, Mexico. We assessed anthropometry and body composition in both mother and child, along with maternally perceived stress and child temperament, and documented maternal social relationships. No differences were found in perceived stress/temperament or anthropometry of either mothers or children, according to the presence/absence of grandmaternal support. However, a composite score of whether grandmothers provided advice on infant feeding was positively associated with child nutritional status. Mothers without grandmaternal support reported seeking more informational and emotional support from other female relatives for childcare, potentially compensating for limited/absent grandmaternal support. Our findings may help develop interventions to improve maternal and child health by targeting the dynamics of maternal social networks.
Article
Full-text available
Non-maternal carers (allomothers) are hypothesized to lighten the mother's workload, allowing for the specialized human life history including relatively short interbirth intervals and multiple dependent offspring. Here, using in-depth observational data on childcare provided to 78 Agta children (a foraging population in the northern Philippines; aged 0-6 years), we explore whether allomaternal childcare substitutes and decreases maternal childcare. We found that allomother caregiving was associated with reduced maternal childcare, but the substitutive effect varied depending on the source and type of care. Children-only playgroups consistently predicted a decrease in maternal childcare. While grandmothers were rarely available, their presence was negatively associated with maternal presence and childcare , and grandmothers performed similar childcare activities to mothers. These results underscore the importance of allomothering in reducing maternal childcare in the Agta. Our findings suggest that flexibility in childcare sources, including children-only playgroups, may have been the key to human life-history evolution. Overall, our results reinforce the necessity of a broad conceptualization of social support in human childcare. This article is part of the theme issue 'Multidisciplinary perspectives on social support and maternal-child health'.
Conference Paper
Background Postnatal depression (PND) is highly detrimental for both mother and baby, with a pre-COVID-19 estimated prevalence of up to 23% in Europe. Low social support is a key risk factor for developing PND. Social distancing measures designed to limit COVID-19 transmission likely created unprecedented barriers for mothers to access social support. We explore how social support networks existed during the UK’s first national lockdown amongst London mothers with infants, and their associations with postnatal depressive symptoms. Methods Using self-reported social network data from 162 London-based mothers with infants aged ≤6 months collected in May-June 2020 (during the first lockdown), we conduct a concurrent design mixed-method study. We quantitatively describe communication within maternal support networks, using quasi-Poisson regression models to analyse associations with postnatal depressive symptoms using the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS). In parallel, we thematically analyse open-text data to explore and understand the experiences of mothers with infants during England’s lockdown. Results Quantitative findings: Levels of depressive symptoms were high in our sample, with 47.5% of participants meeting the >=11EPDS cut-off for potential postnatal depression.On average, women kept in contact with 10–11 people remotely (via WhatsApp, Zoom etc), and saw one family member other than their partner, suggesting high compliance with lockdown rules. The number of seen in person, and remote communication with a higher proportion of those not seen, negatively predicted depressive symptoms (RRR = 0.950 – 0.996 across models). However, a higher proportion of relatives seen in person was associated with increased depressive symptoms (RRR=1.003; 95% CI 1.001–1.006), suggesting family members may have broken lockdown rules to support mums in need. Qualitative findings: We identified four themes. Some mothers in our sample felt lockdown ‘protected’ family time which led to better bonding, often facilitated by high levels of support from the partner (theme 1). However, many experienced the ‘burden of constant mothering’ without anyone around to help (theme 2). Mothers felt remote contact was ‘not as good’ and led to reduced or inadequate support (theme 3). Mothers grieved for lost opportunities for them and their baby, and worried about the developmental impact on their baby (theme 4). Overall, these experiences coexisted with feelings of isolation, exhaustion, worry, inadequacy, guilt, and increased stress. Conclusion Results suggest the strict lockdown in the UK may have increased the risk of postnatal depression, reflected in the high levels of PND symptoms and poor maternal experiences in our sample.