ArticlePDF Available

Dismissal and public demotion of professors: An empirical analysis of structural commonalities in apparently different ‘cases’ (translated from original)

Authors:
Heike Egner
Heike Egner
Anke Uhlenwinkel at University of Salzburg
Anke Uhlenwinkel
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

The article examines dismissals and public demotions of (female) professors in Ger-many, Austria and Switzerland. Through media analyses, standardised questionnaires and qualitative interviews, structural similarities and differences are sought out. With the aim to identifying constitutive patterns. The results show (a) three clearly distinguishable media narratives, (b) that none of the professors were dismissed or demoted due to scientific misconduct, (c) anonymous accusations often formed the basis for escalation, (d) women and foreigners were particularly affected, (e) the number of ‘cases’ has markedly increased since 2015, (f) procedures that were used within the science institutions to clarify the circumstances of the case do not meet legal requirements, and (g) management in particular acted in an unacceptable way as both plaintiff and judge.
Content uploaded by Heike Egner
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Heike Egner on May 03, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
"#!
!BCDEFC!GHD*,+*I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&*N?A?=O*0$.*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$2*9:*N=>?O8*P*Q?>R9*
!
"#$%#$$&'!&()!*+,'#-!).%/0#/(!/1!*2/1.$$/2$3!4(!.%*#2#-&'!&(&'5$#$!
/1!$02+-0+2&'!-/%%/(&'#0#.$!#(!&**&2.(0'5!)#11.2.(0!6-&$.$7
!
!
!
$%&'%!()*%+,!-*'%!./0%*1&*'%0!
!
! !
2/%!3+4&50%! %637&*%8!9&87&88308! 3*9!:;<0&5! 9%7=4&=*8!=>! ?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8! &*!A%+73*B,!
-;84+&3!3*9!C1&4D%+03*9E!2/+=;)/!7%9&3!3*30B8%8,!843*93+9&8%9!F;%84&=**3&+%8!3*9!F;30&43G
4&H%!&*4%+H&%18,!84+;54;+30!8&7&03+&4&%8!3*9!9&>>%+%*5%8!3+%!8=;)/4!=;4E!I&4/!4/%!3&7!4=!&9%*4&>BG
&*)!5=*84&4;4&H%!:344%+*8E!2/%!+%8;048!8/=1!?3@!4/+%%!50%3+0B!9&84&*);&8/3<0%!7%9&3!*3++34&H%8,!
?<@!4/34!*=*%!=>!4/%!:+=>%88=+8!1%+%!9&87&88%9!=+!9%7=4%9!9;%!4=!85&%*4&>&5!7&85=*9;54,!?5@!
3*=*B7=;8! 355;834&=*8! =>4%*! >=+7%9! 4/%! <38&8! >=+! %853034&=*,! ?9@! 1=7%*! 3*9! >=+%&)*%+8!
1%+%!:3+4&5;03+0B!3>>%54%9,!?%@!4/%!*;7<%+!=>!J538%8K!/38!73+'%90B!&*5+%38%9!8&*5%!#LMN,!?>@!
:+=5%9;+%8!4/34!1%+%!;8%9!1&4/&*!4/%!85&%*5%!&*84&4;4&=*8!4=!503+&>B!4/%!5&+5;7843*5%8!=>!4/%!
538%!9=!*=4! 7%%4!0%)30!+%F;&+%7%*48,! 3*9! ?)@!73*3)%7%*4! &*! :3+4&5;03+!354%9! &*! 3*!;*35G
5%:43<0%!13B!38!<=4/!:03&*4&>>!3*9!O;9)%E!
! !
!
M!P*4+=9;54&=*Q!P*9&H&9;30!538%8!=+!84+;54;+30!5=77=*30&4&%8R!
P*!4/%! +%5%*4!:384,!7=+%!3*9!7=+%!538%8!/3H%!5=7%!4=!0&)/4!&*!1/&5/!:+=>%88&=*300B! +%5=)G
*&8%9!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8!/3H%!<%%*!+%7=H%9!>+=7!4/%&+!:=8&4&=*8!4/+=;)/!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!
9%7=4&=*!?%E)E,!S;5//=+*!T!U+%&8&*)%+,!#L#LV!W;<*%+,!#L#L@E!I/%*!1%! 0=='! 34! 4/%!H3+&=;8!
538%8,!4/%B!&*&4&300B!3::%3+!4=!<%!&*9&H&9;30!538%8!4/34!3+%!&*9%:%*9%*4!=>!%35/!=4/%+Q!4/%!13B!
3!:%+8=*!?:+=>%88=+@!9%304!1&4/!843>>!3*9!84;9%*48!138!3::3+%*40B!8=!&*3::+=:+&34%!3*9!&*4=0G
%+3<0%!4/34!J5=;+3)%=;8!1/&840%<0=1%+8K!739%!4/&8!:;<0&5!3*=*B7=;80B!3*9!/&)/%+G0%H%0!3;G
4/=+&4&%8!?+%54=+34%8,!:+%8&9%*5&%8!=>!+%8%3+5/!&*84&4;4&=*8@!:;4!3!84=:!4=!4/%!;*355%:43<0%!5=*G
9&4&=*8E!S;4!&>!8%H%+30!=>!4/%8%!&*9&H&9;30!538%8!3+%!5=7:3+%9,!5=77=*30&4&%8!<%5=7%!H&8&<0%E!
I/34!&8!84+&'&*)!3<=;4!4/%!9&87&88308!3*9!9%7=4&=*8!&8!4/34!?3@!4/%!+%38=*8!)&H%*!1%+%!*%&4/%+!
85&%*4&>&5!7&85=*9;54!*=+!:+=>%88&=*30!&*5=7:%4%*5%,!<;4!7=840B!
J7&85=*9;54!&*!0%39%+8/&:K
,!
?<@!4/%!%853034&=*!=>4%*!4=='!:035%!=*!4/%!<38&8!=>!3*=*B7=;8!355;834&=*8!&*!1/&5/!4/%!:%+G
8=*! 5=*5%+*%9! 138! 9%85+&<%9! 38! J9&>>&5;04K,! 355;8%9! =>! J3<;8%! =>! :=1%+K! 3*9! 5+%34&*)! 3*!
!
!
!
** S(*L,4&)*&0M(*',*'7#$M*,4"*%0T*P"(>"(U0(L("%*+,"*'7(0"*U("V*6,$%'"46'0U(*#)U06(8*6,--($'%8*%422(%'0,$%*
+,"*(T'($%0,$%*#$)*"(W4(%'%*+,"*-,"(*)('#0&8*#%*L(&&*#%*'7(*"(U0(L("%*+,"*'7(0"*%422(%'0,$%;*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
"X!
J347=8:/%+%!=>!>%3+K,!?5@!>%730%!:+=>%88=+8!&*!:3+4&5;03+!1%+%!3>>%54%9,!?9@!4/%!*;7<%+!=>!538%8!
/3H%!3::3+%*40B!<%%*!&*5+%38&*)!8&*5%!#LMN,!3*9!?%@!:+=5%9;+%8!;8%9!1&4/&*!4/%!&*84&4;4&=*8!
4=!503+&>B!4/%!5&+5;7843*5%8!=>!4/%!538%!9&9!9=!*=4!7%%4!0%)30!+%F;&+%7%*48E!$%*5%,!4/%!%6G
4%*8&H%!3*9!53+%>;0!+%8%3+5/!=*!4/%!7=84!+%5%*4!:+=7&*%*4!538%!&*!3!8%+&%8!=>!3+4&50%8!&*!4/%!
C1&88!*%18:3:%+!
W%:;<0&'
!#LMY!%6:=8%9!3*!&7:=+43*4!38:%54!=>!:+354&5300B!300!4/%!J538%8KQ!3!
84=+B!&*!1/&5/!4/%!:=1%+!&*4%+%848!=>!4/%!9&H%+8%!354=+8,!>+=7!4/%!;*&H%+8&4B!73*3)%7%*4!4=!
4/%!=7<;9873*Z8!=>>&5%!3*9!3*B!5=77&88&=*8!3::=&*4%9,!4=='!:+%5%9%*5%!=H%+!+;0%G=>G031!
:+&*5&:0%8,!8=!4/34!4/%!355;8%9!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+!138!*=4!)&H%*!4/%!=::=+4;*&4B!4=!503+&>B!4/%!
>3548!34!/3*9E!P*84%39,!8/%!138!9&87&88%9!;*9%+!&*4%*8%!7%9&3!85+;4&*BE!
!
2/%!+%8%3+5/!=*! =4/%+! :;<0&50B! 3H3&03<0%!538%8! +%H%30%9! 8&7&03+! :+=5%9;+%8E!2/%B!+%>%+!*=4!
=*0B!4=!3*=*B7=;8!355;834&=*8,!<;4!308=!4=!538%8!&*! 1/&5/!<3*30&4&%8!8;5/!38!%++=+8!&*!39G
7&*&84+34&H%!5=*9;54!1%+%! ;8%9! 38! +%38=*8!>=+! 9&87&8830,! &*50;9&*)!>=+78! 8;<7&44%9! 4=!4/%!
1+=*)!:035%! =+!7&88&*)! 397&*&84+34&H%! 9343E! W%)3+90%88! =>!4/%! 8%%7&*)0B!9&>>%+%*4! 5&+5;7G
843*5%8,!4/%!9&87&88308!3*9!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*8!8/=1!84+&'&*)!8&7&03+&4&%8!&*!4/%!84+;54;+%!=>!4/%!
:+=5%9;+%8!3*9!%H%*!4/%!3+);7%*434&=*E!
!
2/%!3+4&50%!43'%8!4/%8%!=<8%+H34&=*8!38!3!843+4&*)!:=&*4!3*9!:;+8;%8!4/%!+%8%3+5/!F;%84&=*!=>!
1/34!:344%+*8! 53*! <%! &9%*4&>&%9! &*! 4/%! 9&87&88308!3*9! :;<0&5! 9%7=4&=*8! 4/34! /3H%! <%5=7%!
'*=1*
E!P*!399&4&=*!4=!8=7%!=4/%+!38:%548,!4/%!>=5;8!/%+%!&8!:+&73+&0B!=*!4/%!
:+=5%9;+%8
!1&4/&*!
4/%!;*&H%+8&4B!=+!+%8%3+5/!&*84&4;4&=*!4/34!0%9!4=!4/%!9%5&8&=*!4=!+%7=H%!4/%!:+=>%88=+!>+=7!/%+!
:=8&4&=*E!P*!:+&*5&:0%,!&4!53*!<%!388;7%9!4/34!:+=5%9;+%8!53++&%9!=;4!&*8&9%!3539%7&5!&*84&4;G
4&=*8!=*!4/%!<38&8!=>!9%5&8&=*G73'&*)!3+%!38!0%)&4&7&8%9!<B!4/%!+;0%!=>!031!38!:+=5%9;+%8!&*!
8&7&03+!%*H&+=*7%*48,! %8:%5&300B!?<;4! *=4!=*0B@! <%53;8%!4/%B! /3H%!4/%! 7=84! 9+384&5!5=*8%G
F;%*5%8!>=+!4/%!355;8%9!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8E!$=1!%08%!8/=;09!4/%!>3548!=>!4/%!538%!<%!503+&G
>&%9R!-*9!/=1!%08%!5=;09!3!0%3+*&*)!%6:%+&%*5%!<%!4+&))%+%9!&*!4/=8%!&*H=0H%9R!2/%!&9%3!=>!
J0%)&4&734&=*!4/+=;)/!:+=5%9;+%K!?[;/73**,!MY"Y@!&8!=*%!=>!4/%!5%*4+30!&9%38!=>!3!0&<%+30!8=5&G
%4BE!\*!4/%!=*%!/3*9,!4/%!:3+4&5&:34&=*!=>!4/=8%!3>>%54%9!&*!4/%!:+=5%9;+30!+=0%8,!38!:+=H&9%9!
&*!5=*84&4;4&=*30!:+=5%9;+%8,!8%+H%8!4=!%*8;+%!3*9!&7:+=H%!4/%!F;30&4B!=>!4/%!9%5&8&=*G73'&*)!
:+=5%88V!=*!4/%!=4/%+!/3*9,!&4!=>>%+8!4/%!=*0B!&*/%+%*4!:=88&<&0&4B!=>!5=*H&*5&*)!4/%!:3+4&%8!=>!
4/%!5=++%54*%88!?4+;4/,!O;84&5%@!=>!4/%!9%5&8&=*,!308=!&*!4/%!8%*8%!=>!3!0%3+*&*)!3&9!?]&%8%+0&*),!
#LM#,!:E!M^N!>E@E! _%H%+4/%0%88,! 4/%!+%8;048!=>!4/%! :+%8%*4!8;+H%B!8/=1!4/34! &*! 300!4/%!538%8!
&*H%84&)34%9,!84+=*)!9=;<48!3+%!+3&8%9!38!4=!1/%4/%+!4/%!:+=5%9;+%8!;8%9!:+&=+!4=!9&87&8830!
=+! 9%7=4&=*! 834&8>B! 4/%! :+&*5&:0%8! =>! 4/%! +;0%! =>! 031E! 2/%! =<H&=;8! F;%84&=*! =>! 1/%4/%+! 4/%!
3>>%54%9!:+=>%88=+!5=;09!<%!O;84&>&3<0B!355;8%9!=>!4/%!?=>4%*!3*=*B7=;80B!+%:=+4%9@!354&=*8!&8!
4/%+%>=+%! &++%0%H3*4! >=+! 4/&8! 84;9B! G! 4/&8! 8/=;09! /3H%! <%%*! &*H%84&)34%9!&*! 4/%! :+=5%9;+%8!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
"^!
:+%5%9&*)!4/%!9&87&8830!=+!9%7=4&=*!9%5&8&=*E!-)3&*84!4/%!<35')+=;*9!=>!4/%!=H%+1/%07&*)!
&7:+%88&=*!=>!8B84%734&5!9&8+%)3+9!>=+!4/%!:+&*5&:0%8!=>!4/%!+;0%!=>!031!&*!4/%!&*4+3G&*84&4;4&=*30!
:+=5%%9&*)8,!1%!3::0B!4/%!:+&*5&:0%!=>!4/%!:+%8;7:4&=*!=>!&**=5%*5%!/%+%E!-8!3!8&)*30!>=+!4/&8!
9=;<4,!1%!:;4!4/%!4%+7!J538%K!&*!&*H%+4%9!5=7738E!
!
2/%734&5300B,!4/%!:+%8%*4!84;9B!%*4%+8!*%1!3539%7&5!4%++&4=+BE!2/%+%!&8!3!03+)%!<=9B!=>!0&4%+G
34;+%!=*!4/%!8:%5&>&58!=>!9%84+;54&H%!<%/3H&=;+!1&4/&*!4/%!8=5&=4=:%8!=>!3539%7&5!&*84&4;4&=*8,!
1/&5/!53*!<%!8;773+&8%9!<B!'%B1=+98!8;5/!38!
3539%7&5!7=<<&*)!=+!<;00B&*)!&*!/&)/%+!%9G
;534&=*
!?%E)E!`+31>=+9,!#LMYV![%84%+,!#LMXV!a+%H=84!T!$;*4,!#LMbV!I%84/;%8,!#LL"3@!=+!7=+%!
)%*%+300B!<B!4/%!5=*5%:4!=>!
3539%7&5!&*5&H&0&4B
!?%E)E!P4D'=H&5/!%4!30E,!#L#LV!2130%!T!c%![;53,!
#LLb@E!$=1%H%+,!1%!3+%!*=4!313+%!=>!3*B!8:%5&>&5!84;9&%8!=*!9&87&88308!=+!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*8!
34!4/%!0%39%+8/&:!0%H%0!=>!3539%7&3E!
!
#!c343!<38&8!3*9!7%4/=9=0=)B!
2/%!843+4&*)!:=&*4!>=+!4/%!%7:&+&530!3*30B8&8!1%+%!4/%!J538%8K!9=5;7%*4%9!<B!4/%!J_%41=+'!=>!
c&87&88%9!I=7%*! a+=>%88=+8K
!
!=*!4/%! <38&8!=>! 7%9&3!+%:=+48! >+=7!A%+73*B,! -;84+&3!3*9!
C1&4D%+03*9!?cG-G`$!5=;*4+&%8@!34!4/%!<%)&**&*)!=>!#L#LE!\;+!+%8%3+5/!+%H%30%9!>;+4/%+!%6G
37:0%8,!8=!4/34!38!=>!d;*%!#L#L!1%!1%+%!313+%!=>!3!4=430!=>!#X!J538%8K!>+=7!4/%!:384!41%*4B!
B%3+8
"
V! e! =>! 4/%7! &*! A%+73*B,! ^! &*! -;84+&3,! b! &*! C1&4D%+03*9,! 3*9! ^! =;48&9%! 4/%! A%+73*G
8:%3'&*)!:3+4!=>!4/%!(.
#
!?23<0%!M@E!\*0B!4/%!9343!=>!4/=8%!MY!J538%8K!4/34!=55;++%9!&*!4/%!cG
-G`$!5=;*4+&%8!3+%!&*50;9%9!&*!4/%!>;+4/%+!3*30B8&8E!
!
f%4/=9=0=)&5300B,!1%!;8%!4/%!538%!3*30B8&8!3::+=35/,!&*!1/&5/!4B:&530!538%8!3+%!9%85+&<%9!
3*9!3*30B8%9!&*!=+9%+!4=!9%H%0=:!534%)=+&%8!3*9!%6:03*34=+B!3::+=35/%8!>=+!/&4/%+4=!03+)%0B!
&)*=+%9!8=5&30!5&+5;7843*5%8!?5>E!S;9%,!#LLXV![37*%'!T!]+%00,!#LM",!:E!#bN!>>E@,!1/&5/!308=!
&*50;9%!4/%!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*!=>!0%39&*)!:+=>%88&=*308!&*!+%8%3+5/!&*84&4;4&=*8E!
!
!
!
?
** 7''P%.@@'L0''(";6,-@D(PD('3L("M;**
:
** S(*#%%4-(* '7#'* L(*7#U(* YV* $,* -(#$%*%466(()()* 0$*6,U("0$2* #&&*)0%-0%%#&%* ,"*P4Y&06* )(-,'0,$%;*G$*
#))0'0,$*',*-()0#*"(P,"'%8*L7067*),*$,'*(T0%'*0$*(U("V*Z6#%(Z8*L(*"(6(0U()*0$)06#'0,$%*,+*+4"'7("*Z6#%(%Z*
'7",427*'7(*0$'("U0(L%;*
9
** !7(*"(%(#"67* +,64%* L#%* ,$*X>C>[58* '7(* +,4"* \6#%(%]* +",-*,'7("* IK* 6,4$'"0(%*6#-(* ',* ,4"*#''($'0,$*
"#'7("*YV*67#$6(;*!7(%(*#"(*+,4"*+(-#&(*P",+(%%,"%8*#&&*+,"(02$("%*0$*'7(*6,4$'"V*L7("(*'7(V*L("(*)0%>
-0%%()*,"*)(-,'()8*'7"((*,+*'7(-*,+*^("-#$*,"020$;*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
"N!
U=+!4/%! &7:0%7%*434&=*!=>! 4/%! 538%! 3*30B8%8,! 3!7&6%9G7%4/=9! 3::+=35/! 138!;8%9,! 1/&5/!
&*50;9%9!4/+%%!9&>>%+%*4!3::+=35/%8!=>!F;3*4&434&H%!3*9!F;30&434&H%!8;+H%B8Q!
ME
g;30&434&H%!5=*4%*4!3*30B8&8!=>!7%9&3!+%:=+48
Q!P*!=+9%+!4=!385%+43&*!4/%!%64%+*30!:%+8:%5G
4&H%,!1%!5=*9;54%9!3!F;30&434&H%!5=*4%*4!3*30B8&8!?355=+9&*)!4=!f3B+&*),!#LM"@!=>!7%9&3!
+%:=+48!=*!8%0%54%9!J538%8KE!-!4=430!=>!Mb!3+4&50%8!1%+%!3*30B8%9,!1/&5/!+%>%++%9!4=!e!&*9&G
H&9;308E!U=+!%35/!J538%K,!34!0%384!41=!5=*4+&<;4&=*8,!&>!:=88&<0%,!>+=7!9&>>%+%*4!8=;+5%8,!1%+%!
4=!<%!5=*8&9%+%9V!&*!4/+%%!J538%8K,!5=*4+&<;4&=*8!>+=7!41=!5=;*4+&%8!+%8:%54&H%0B!1%+%!&*G
50;9%9E! `=*4+&<;4&=*8! >+=7! 4/%! >=00=1&*)! 7%9&3! 1%+%! 3*30B8%9! ?&*! <+35'%48Q! *;7<%+! =>!
5=*4+&<;4&=*8@Q!
3E!-a-!h!-;84+&3*!a+%88!-)%*5B!?#@!
<E!c%+!S%=<35/4%+!?M@!
5E! c(W!2-A(CCaP(A([!?M@!
9E!!c&%!i(P2!?X@!
%E!!U=+85/;*)!T![%/+%!?M@!
>E!!]0%&*%!i%&4;*)!?M@!
)E!73*3)%+!73)3D&*!?M@!
/E!!_ii!h!_%;%!ij+5/%+!i%&4;*)!?X@!
&E!!a__!h!a=48937%+!_%;%84%!_35/+&5/4%*!?M@!
OE!!W%:;<0&'!?X@!
'E!!C:&%)%0!=*0&*%!?M@!
#E
C43*93+9&8%9!F;%84&=**3&+%Q
!P*!399&4&=*!4=!4/%!%64%+*30!H&%1!=>!4/%!7%9&3,!4/%!:%+8:%54&H%!
=>!4/%!3>>%54%9!:+=>%88=+8!+%)3+9&*)!4/%!5&+5;7843*5%8!=>!4/%&+!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!9%7=G
4&=*!138!8B84%734&5300B! 8;+H%B%9! <B! 7%3*8! =>! 3! F;%84&=**3&+%E! g;%84&=*8! 1%+%! 38'%9!
3<=;4!4/%!+;0%!=>!031!=>!4/%! :+=5%9;+%,! 3*9! 3<=;4!4/%!354=+8!&*H=0H%9,!38!1%00!38! 3<=;4!
38:%548!=>!4/%!:+=>%88=+K8!:=8&4&=*!3*9!8%0>G&73)%E!\>!4/%!Me!F;%84&=**3&+%8!8%*4!=;4,!MN!
1%+%!+%4;+*%9!>;00B!5=7:0%4%9!?+%8:=*8%!+34%!bb!k@E!2/%!MX!F;%84&=**3&+%8!+%034&*)!4=!4/%!
%H%*48!&*!4/%!cG-G`$!5=;*4+&%8!1%+%!&*50;9%9!&*!4/%!3*30B8&8E!!
XE
g;30&434&H%!&*4%+H&%18
Q!2/%!5&+5;7843*5%8!4/34!0%9!4=!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*!3+%!H%+B!
5=7:0%6!&*!%35/!&*9&H&9;30!J538%KE!2/%!8%3+5/!>=+!:344%+*8,!9&>>%+%*5%8!3*9!5=77=*30&4&%8!
4/%+%>=+%!+%F;&+%8!3::+=35/%8!4/34!)=!<%B=*9!4/%!:=88&<&0&4&%8!=>!843*93+9&8%9!8;+H%B8!=*!
4/%! =*%! /3*9! 3*9! 7%9&3! 3*30B8%8! =*! 4/%! =4/%+E! -)3&*84! 4/&8! <35')+=;*9,! MX! &*G9%:4/!
&*4%+H&%18!1%+%!5=*9;54%9!1&4/!9&87&88%9!=+!9%7=4%9!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8,!=>!1/&5/!4/=8%!
M#!&*4%+H&%18!3+%!&*50;9%9! &*!4/%!3*30B8&8!&*! 1/&5/!4/%!%6:%+&%*5%8!=>! 4/%! &*4%+H&%1%%8!
+%034%!4=!=*%!=>!4/%!cG-G`$!8434%8E!
!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
""!
(35/! 3::+=35/! &*! &48%0>! 8%%78! 4=! ;8! 4=! <%! =*0B! :3+4&300B! 39%F;34%! 38! 3! 8=;+5%! >=+! 8=5&30G
%7:&+&530!5=7:3+&8=*Q!f%9&3!+%:=+48!3+%!*34;+300B!&*5=7:0%4%!&*!4/%&+!:+%8%*434&=*!?38!4/%B!
:&5'!=;4! 8:%5&>&5!38:%548! 4/34! 8%%7! &*4%+%84&*)! >+=7! 4/%! 7%9&3Z8! :=&*4! =>!H&%1@,! 38!1%00! 38!
<&38%9!&*!H3+&=;8!+%8:%548!3*9!30+%39B!5=*84+;%9!?38!3!+%8;04!=>!4/%&+!&*H%84&)34&=*8!=>!9&>>%+G
%*4!8=;+5%8@E!2/%!&*4%+*30!H&%18!=>!4/%!3>>%54%9!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8!3+%!:3+4&30!&*!=4/%+!13B8,!
38!4/%B!>=5;8!=*!&*9&H&9;30!%6:%+&%*5%!3*9!+%:=+4!=*!4/%!:+=5%88!=>!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!9%G
7=4&=*!>+=7!4/%!:%+8=*30!H&%1!=>!4/%!355;8%9E!2/%!7%4/=9=0=)&530!7&6!=>!3*!?30+%39B!&*4%+G
:+%4%9@!%64%+*30!H&%1!3*9!3!?84+;54;+300B!<&38%9@!&*4%+*30!H&%1!8%%78!4=!;8!1%00G8;&4%9!4=!4/%!
8:%5&>&5!+%8%3+5/!F;%84&=*,!:+=H&9&*)!3!7%3*8!4=!&*H%84&)34%!:=88&<0%!:344%+*8!38!1%00!38!9&>G
>%+%*5%8!3*9!8&7&03+&4&%8!<38%9!=*!9&>>%+%*4!:%+8:%54&H%8E!
!
[&7&434&=*8Q!&*!4/%!%637&*34&=*!=>!J538%8K,!%843<0&8/&*)!5=*4354!1&4/!4/=8%!3>>%54%9,!3*9! %*G
5=;+3)&*)!4/%7!4=!:3+4&5&:34%!&*!4/%!8;+H%B,!:+=H%9!4=!<%!3!5/300%*)%E!-!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!
9%7=4&=*!&8!%64+%7%0B!84&)734&8&*)!3*9!4+3;734&8&*)E!I/&0%!4/&8!&8!4+;%! >=+! 3*B! 9&87&8830!=+!
:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*,!&4!&8!%8:%5&300B!4+;%!>=+!:%=:0%!&*!85&%*5%,!38!4/%&+!J+%:;434&=*K!&8!4/%!5;++%*5B!
=>!4/%&+!1=+'Q!4+;84!&*!4/%!+%8;048!=>!4/%&+!85&%*4&>&5!1=+'!+%F;&+%8!4+;84!&*!4/%!:%+8=*!9=&*)!4/%!
85&%*5%E!c&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*!4/%+%>=+%!*=4!=*0B!/38!3!7388&H%!&7:354!=*!4/%!+%:;G
434&=*!=>!4/%!:%+8=*!355;8%9!?J84&)73!=>!/=*=;+K,!A=>>73*,!MY"e@,!<;4!308=!5=*84&4;4%!3!F;38&!
J:+=>%88&=*30!7;+9%+KE!2/%!9&87&8830!=+!9%7=4&=*!%6:%+&%*5%!0%9!73*B!=>!4/=8%! 3>>%54%9!4=!
<%! H%+B! /%8&43*4! 4=! :3+4&5&:34%! &*! 4/%! 84;9BE! C=7%! +%>;8%9! 4=! :3+4&5&:34%! 304=)%4/%+,! :3+40B!
<%53;8%! =>! >%3+8! =>! +%G4+3;734&834&=*! 3*9! +%G84&)734&834&=*,!:3+40B! <%53;8%! 4/%B! 8&)*%9! 3!
5=*>&9%*4&30&4B!3)+%%7%*4!?&*!4/%!538%!=>!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*@!&*!=+9%+!4=!'%%:!4/%&+!O=<8E!2/=8%!
1/=!%H%*4;300B!/3*9%9!&*!3!5=7:0%4%9!F;%84&=**3&+%!=>4%*!=*0B!9%5&9%9!4=!9=!8=!3>4%+!3!9%G
43&0%9!&*4%+H&%1E!
!
P*!H&%1!=>!4/%!4+;84!:035%9!&*!;8,!1%!:+%8%*4!4/%!>&*9&*)8!<%0=1!=*0B!&*!8;773+&8%9!3*9!3*=*G
B7&8%9!>=+7E!2/&8!308=!3::0&%8!4=!4/%!7%9&3!3*30B8&8,!&*!1/&5/!1%!9=!*=4!8:%5&>&5300B!*37%!
4/%!8=;+5%8!?1&4/!4&40%,!934%!3*9!7%9&;7!=>!4/%!&*9&H&9;30!5=*4+&<;4&=*8@,!'*=1&*)!>;00!1%00!4/34!
4/&8!&8!3!+34/%+!;*;8;30!:+=5%9;+%!&*!8=5&30!85&%*5%!3*30B8&8,!1/&5/!53*,!/=1%H%+,!<%!*%5%8G
83+B!>=+!8%*8&4&H%!+%8%3+5/!F;%84&=*8!?5>E!(003+9GA+3B!%4!30E,!#LMN@E!
!
!
!
!
!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
"e!
!
X!c&>>%+%*5%8!3*9!5=77=*30&4&%8!=>!9&87&88308l9%7=4&=*8!
2/&8! 5/3:4%+! :+%8%*48! 4/%! >&*9&*)8! =>! 4/%! +%8%3+5/! 3*9! 9&85;88%8! 4/%7! 3)3&*84! 4/%! <35'G
)+=;*9!=>!8%0%54%9!4/%=+%4&530G5=*5%:4;30!:%+8:%54&H%8E!
!
XEM!f%9&3!3*30B8&8Q!_3++34&H%8!3<=;4!:=1%+,!3<;8%!=>!:=1%+!3*9!H&54&78!1=+4/B!=>!:+=4%54&=*!
U=+!307=84!41=!4/&+98!=>!4/%!cG-G`$!J538%8K!4/%+%!&8!7=+%!=+!0%88!9%43&0%9!7%9&3!5=H%+3)%E!
2/%8%!7%9&3!+%:=+48!0=='!34!4/%! J538%8K! :+&73+&0B!>+=7!3!O=;+*30&84&5!+34/%+!4/3*!3! 85&%*4&>&5!
:=&*4!=>!H&%1E!2/&8!=:%*8!;:!4/%!=::=+4;*&4B!=>!85+;4&*&D&*)!4/%!5=*4+&<;4&=*8!85&%*4&>&5300B,!38!
3*!=<8%+H34&=*! =>! 4/%!=<8%+H34&=*!?[;/73**,!MYY#,!H=*!U=%+84%+,!MYb^@E!2/%!>=5;8!/%+%!&8!
=*!4/%!8=5&30!*3++34&H%8!4/34!3+%!:3+40B!5+%34%9,!3*9!:3+40B!43'%*!;:!3*9!+%4=09!<B!4/%!7%9&3!
&*!=+9%+!4=!7%%4!4/%!3;9&%*5%!H&%1,!=+!34!0%384!4/%!O=;+*30&84K8!&73)%!=>!4/34!H&%1E!_3++34&H%8!
3+%!;*9%+84==9!38!84=+&%8!4/34!)&H%!&*9&H&9;30!8434%7%*48!3*!&**%+!5=/%+%*5%!3*9!4/;8!300=1!
+%034&=*8/&:8!=+!:+=5%88%8!4=!<%!:+%8%*4%9!38!5=*8&84%*4!&*!4/%78%0H%8!?]%00%+,!#LMM@E!21=!
73O=+!*3++34&H%8!53*!<%!&9%*4&>&%9!&*!4/%!5=+:;8!=>!3*30B8%9!*%18:3:%+!3+4&50%8Q!4/%!Jd=8%>!]E!
*3++34&H%K!3*9!4/%!JW=<&*!$==9!*3++34&H%KE!S=4/!53*!<%!50%3+0B!9&84&*);&8/%9!>+=7!%35/!=4/%+!
&*!4%+78! =>! 5=*4%*4!3*9! 4&7%,!1/%+%<B!4/%! d=8%:/!]E! *3++34&H%! 5/3*)%8!80&)/40B! =H%+! 4&7%,!
1/&5/!1%!&*9&534%9!<B!4/%!03<%0!Jd=8%:/3!]EK!>=+!4/%!4/&+9!&9%*4&>&%9!*3++34&H%!?U&);+%!M@E!
!
!
!
!*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
"b!
_024"(*=.
*`,)(&*,+*'7(*$#""#'0U(%*,+*)0%-0%%#&%@P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$%*,+*P",+(%%,"%*0$*-()0#*6,U("#2(;*
!
!
!
XEMEM!d=8%>G]E!
2/%!d=8%>!]E!*3++34&H%!&8!5=*84&4;4&H%!>=+!4/%!>&+84!J538%8K!=>!9&87&88%9!:+=>%88=+8E!C=7%!%3+0B!
:3:%+8!30+%39B!9+31! =*! 4/%! 5/3+354%+! >+=7!]3>'3Z8! *=H%0!J2/%! 2+&30K! &*!4/%&+! 4&40%8!?C3:%+%!
3;9%,!#LL#V!C&7=*,! #LMM@E!2/%! ;*9%+0B&*)! 5=*>0&54!&*! 4/&8!*3++34&H%!&8!<%41%%*! 3!:+=>%88=+!
1/=!&8! 9%85+&<%9! &*! 300! J538%8K! 38!3539%7&5300B!=;4843*9&*),!1/=!/38!+%0%H3*4!:;<0&534&=*8,!
35F;&+%8!4/&+9G:3+4B!>;*9&*)!3*9!&8!/%09!&*!/&)/!%84%%7!<B!84;9%*48,!843>>!3*9!5=00%3);%8!=;4G
8&9%!4/%!&*84&4;4&=*!&*!F;%84&=*!3*9!4/%!73*3)%7%*4!=>!/%+!=1*!&*84&4;4&=*E!-55=+9&*)!4=!4/%!
*3++34&H%,!4/%!5=*>0&54!&8!;04&734%0B!3<=;4!+%8=;+5%8,!%E)E,!&*!4/%!>=+7!=>!53:35&4&%8!>=+!4/%!%6G
:3*8&=*!=>!5%+43&*!+%8%3+5/!>=5&!=+!4/%!9%H%0=:7%*4!=>!:+=>&0%!3+%38V!=+!&*!4/%!>=+7!=>!3!:=8&4&=*!
4/34!138!:%+/3:8!&*4%*9%9!&*4%+*300B!>=+!3!5=7:%4&4=+,!<;4!1/&5/!138!>&00%9!<B!4/%!:+=>%88=+!&*!
F;%84&=*E!P*!4/&8!*3++34&H%,!4/%!;*&H%+8&4B!73*3)%7%*4!9%5&9%8!3)3&*84!4/%!=;4843*9&*)!:+=G
>%88=+!3*9!<%)&*8!4=!8;::=+4!4/%!5=7:%4&4=+8!3*9!4/%&+!8:=*8=+8!<B!9%0&<%+34%0B!8%3+5/&*)!>=+!
8;&43<0%!>3548!=+!%H%*!:+=9;5&*)!4/%7!4/%78%0H%8E!2/%!>3548!5&4%9!&*!4/%!7%9&3!5=H%+3)%!3+%!
73&*0B!>+=7!4/%!3+%3!=>!397&*&84+34&H%!5=*9;54!34!4/%!0%H%0!=>!4/%!:+=>%88=+8/&:V!4/%B!+%034%,!&>!
34!300,!34!<%84!:%+&:/%+300B! 4=! +%8%3+5/!=+!4=!4%35/&*)E!P*!8=7%! 538%8,! +%>%+%*5%!&8!739%!4=!
1+&44%*!355;834&=*8!<B!843>>!7%7<%+8,!<;4!4/%!355;8%9!:+=>%88=+8!1%+%!;8;300B!+%>;8%9!35G
5%88! 4=! 4/%8%!9=5;7%*48E! C=7%4&7%8,! &4! &8! 9%85+&<%9! /=1! 4/%! ;*&H%+8&4B! 397&*&84+34&=*8!
!"#$%&'(##)*'&+,,+-%./
$011%/)'/231#4//5'
6'
1/+)/,57%3'2%58#&)08-'$4'3,#9/55#,
!:#5/37+';<*'&+,,+-%./
!"#$%&'(&)'*%+&",&-&.'++#)/0'1&'(&2%!3%+$40)
5%)0./0'1&"%('+%&6789
■"#22,01:&!$&!&)%+$'11%2&)'20.,
■+%!$'1;&.'<)%/0/0'1&'1&/4%&$!<%&2%=%2>&
.'<)%/0/0'1&('+&+%$'#+.%$>&)+'(02%&!+%!$
■<0$/!?%$&!+%&$'#:4/&'+&.'1$/+#./%3
5%)0./0'1&$01.%&6789
■"#22,01:&!$&!&)%+$'11%2&)'20.,
■+%!$'1;&)+'/%./0'1&'(&,'#1:&$.0%1/0$/$
■(%%201:$&!+%&!$$%+/%3
@((%./
■')%1&/'&!//!.?>&!$&(!./$&!+%&=%+0(0!"2%
■0<!:%&2'$$&('+&#10=%+$0/,&<!1!:%<%1/&
@((%./&AB'"01&C''3DEF!++!/0=%
■4!+32,&+%(#/!"2%>&!$&!//+0"#/0'1$&/'&/4%&)%+$'1&
■0<!:%&%14!1.%<%1/&('+&2%!3%+$40)&!$&
$!=0'#+&!13&.2%!1%+
@((%./&AG'$%)4!&HIDEF!++!/0=%
■')%1&/'&!//!.?>&!$&(!./$&!+%&=%+0(0!"2%
■0<!:%&2'$$&('+&#10=%+$0/,&<!1!:%<%1/
!"#"$%&'()*%+,-(
. %/0#1")%/&(%/$%2%$3"4%)",%5/(
. '5#"4%)",%5/(5+(05/+4%0,)
!:#5/9';<!'&+,,+-%./
3,#9/55#,'+5'2#$$%&='.%8-%2
6'
+$05/'#9'3#>/,'$4
0&%./,5%-4'2+&+=/2/&-
?%52%55+15@A0$1%8'?/2#-%#&5'%&'B/)%+'C#./,+=/
!"#$%&$"'()$* +",)&$ -./$)0%)&$/
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
"Y!
9%:+&H%9!3>>%54%9!:+=>%88=+8!=>!397&*&84+34&H%!3*9!>&*3*5&30!+%8=;+5%8,!4/;8!+%*9%+&*)!4/%7!
;*3<0%!4=!1=+'E!
!
P*4%+:+%434&=*!
P*!0&*%! 1&4/! =4/%+!3539%7&5! >&*9&*)! =*! 4/%! 4=:&5,! 4/%!d=8%>! ]E! *3++34&H%!&*! 7%9&3! 5=H%+3)%!
+%>%+8!4=!3!50388&5!7&5+=G:=0&4&5300B!7=4&H34%9!?_%;<%+)%+,!#LMN@!7=<<&*)!8&4;34&=*,!4/%!43+)%4!
=>!1/&5/! &8!4/%! /&)/G:%+>=+7&*)!:+=>%88=+E! P*! 4/&8! 5=*4%64,! 7=<<&*)!&8! 9%>&*%9!38! +%:%34%9!
*%)34&H%!354&=*8!<B!8%H%+30! :%=:0%,! 1/&5/!3+%!9&+%54%9!3)3&*84!=*%! :%+8=*! 1&4/!4/%!3&7! =>!
:8B5/=0=)&5300B! 9%843<&0&8&*)! 3*9! &8=034&*)! 4/34! :%+8=*! 3*9! ;04&734%0B! +%7=H&*)! /&7! =+! /%+!
>+=7!4/%!1=+'!%*H&+=*7%*4!?]=0=9%O,!#LMeV!C7;4*B,!#LMe@E!(7:&+&530!84;9&%8!308=!8/=1!4/34!
4/%!43+)%48!=>!<;00B&*)!&*!4/%!;*&H%+8&4B!5=*4%64!3+%!=>4%*!%7:0=B%%8!1&4/!&*4%)+&4B,!&**=H34&H%!
&9%38!3*9!/&)/!7=4&H34&=*!?I%84/;%8,!#LL"3V!i3:>!T!(&*3+8%*,!#L#L@E!
!
P*!355=+93*5%!1&4/!4/%!<38&5!5=*84%0034&=*!=>!4/%!d=8%>G]E!*3++34&H%,!;*&H%+8&4B!397&*&84+34&=*8!
=>4%*!3::%3+!&*!3!<39!0&)/4Q!4/%B!3+%!4/%!=*%8!1/=!%*)3)%!&*!&*4+&);%,!:+%H%*4!4+3*8:3+%*5B,!
9=!*=4!>=00=1!:+=5%9;+30!:34/8!3*9!&)*=+%!%H%+B4/&*)!4/34!1=;09!8:%3'!>=+!4/%!355;8%9E!2/%B!
3::%3+!38!:03&*4&>>8
$
!3*9!O;9)%8!34!4/%!837%!4&7%,!8=7%4&7%8!308=! 38!:%+:%4+34=+8!1/=!35G
4&H%0B!5=*84+;54!7&843'%8E!
!
!
!
!
XEME#!W=<&*!$==9!
U+=7!3+=;*9!#LMN!=*13+98,!3!9&>>%+%*4!*3++34&H%!/38!<%%*!)3&*&*)!)+=;*9!&*!4/%!7%9&3,!1/&5/!
1%!5300!W=<&*G$==9!=*!4/%!<38&8!=>!4/%!0&4%+3+B!8;<O%54!7344%+E!P4!&9%*4&>&%8!3*!304%+%9! <38&5!
5=*84%0034&=*Q!4/%!8;::=8%9!5=*>0&54!&8!*=1!<%&*)!:03B%9!=;4!<%41%%*!4/%!:+=>%88=+!1/=!%6G
5%08!&*!+%8%3+5/!3*9!4%35/&*)!3*9!4/%!B=;*)!3539%7&58!388&)*%9!4=!/%+E!P*!4/%!7%9&3!+%:=+48,!
4/%!B=;*)!3539%7&58!3+%!307=84!3013B8!9%85+&<%9!38!;*9%+35/&%H&*)!=+!;*3<0%!4=!7%%4!4/%!
+%F;&+%7%*48E! 2/%B! 9=! *=4! 5=7:03&*! 3<=;4! 4/%! 035'! =>! :+=>%88&=*30! 8;::=+4! >+=7! 4/%&+!
!
!
"
** G$*'7(*I$2&0%7*6,$'(T'8*,$(*L,4&)*P("7#P%*4%(*'7(*'("-*\P",%(64',"]*0$%'(#)*,+*\P&#0$'0++];*G$*'7(*^("-#$*
6,$'(T'*'7(*\P",%(64',"]*NE'##'%#$L#&'8*a%'#'(*#'',"$(V]O*0%*#&%,*&(2#&&V*,Y&02()*',*#6'0U(&V*0$U(%'02#'(*60">
64-%'#$6(%*0$*+#U,4"*,+*'7(*#664%();*!70%*0%*(T#6'&V*L7#'*,$(*L,4&)*(TP(6'*+",-*'7(*-#$#2(-($'*,+*
%60($'0+06*0$%'0'4'0,$%8*#$)*L7067*'7(V*7#U(* $,'* ),$(;* !7#'*0%*L7V*L(*4%(*'7(*'("-* \P&#0$'0++]*0$%'(#)* ,+*
\P",%(64',"]*NE'##'%#$L#&'O*0$*'70%*6,$'(T';*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
eL!
8;:%+H&8=+8,!<;4!3<=;4!J4==!7;5/!:+%88;+%K,!3*!J347=8:/%+%!=>!>%3+K!3*9!J:8B5/=0=)&530!4%++=+KE!
2/%!8;:%+H&8=+8!3+%!*=4! 8%%*! 38!8;::=+4&H%,!&*50;9&*)!1/%*!4/%! 8;:%+H&8=+! 43'%8!4/%!0%)30!
+%F;&+%7%*48!>=+!4/%!%6%+5&8%!=>!/%+!:+=>%88=+8/&:!8%+&=;80B!3*9!&7:0%7%*48!4/%7,!>=+!%637G
:0%,! 8%44&*)! 9%390&*%8! >=+! 4/%! 8;<7&88&=*! =>! 1=+'! =+! 73'&*)! =<O%54&H%! 5+&4&5&878! =>! :%+>=+G
73*5%E!2/%!5=7:03&*48!5;07&*34%!&*!355;834&=*8!=>!7=<<&*)!3*9!3<;8%!=>!:=1%+!<B!4/%!:+=G
>%88=+E!2/%!355;834&=*8!3+%!739%!5+%9&<0%!:+&73+&0B!<B!+%>%++&*)!4=!4/%!03+)%84!:=88&<0%!*;7G
<%+!=>!:%=:0%!3>>%54%9,!1/=!/3H%!4=!+%73&*!3*=*B7=;8!>=+!J:+=4%54&=*!+%38=*8KE!P*!4/&8!*3+G
+34&H%,!4/%!:+=>%88=+! &8! *=! 0=*)%+! 5=*>+=*4%9! 1&4/! 3*! &*H&*5&<0%! &*84&4;4&=*,! <;4! 8/%! /%+8%0>! &8!
:=+4+3B%9!38!3!J:%+:%4+34=+K!1/=!+;4/0%880B!3<;8%8!4/%!:=1%+!344+&<;4%9!4=!/%+!<B!H&+4;%!=>!/%+!
:=8&4&=*,!/3+78!=4/%+8!3*9!73'%8!&4!7=+%!9&>>&5;04!>=+!4/%!0%88!53:3<0%!O;*&=+!843>>!4=!39H3*5%E!
!
P*4%+:+%434&=*!
P*!5=*4+384!4=!4/%!d=8%:/!]E!*3++34&H%,!3!<;00B&*)!5=*5%:4!&8!;8%9!/%+%!&*!1/&5/!3!8&*)0%!:%+8=*!
?&*84%39!=>!3!)+=;:@!&8!<;00B&*)!3*!;*9%>&*%9!*;7<%+!=>!=4/%+8E!2/%!:%+8=*!300%)%90B!<;00B&*)!
&8!4/%*!4/%!:%+8=*!1/=!&8!&8=034%9!3*9!;04&734%0B!+%7=H%9!>+=7!4/%!%7:0=B7%*4!+%034&=*8/&:E!
P*!:8B5/=0=)B,!8;5/!3!5=*84%0034&=*!&8!5300%9!7%*430!:%+:%4+34=+GH&54&7!+%H%+830!=+!H&54&7!<037G
&*),!9%>&*%9!38!4/%!344%7:4!4=!:+=5%88!3!*%)34&H%!%H%*4!<B!<037&*)!4/%!H&54&7!?m%;*)!T![;*,!
#L#L@E! 2/&8! +%H%+830! =>! <037%! 308=! 8/&>48! 4/%! %6:03*34=+B! 5=*4%64Q! &*84%39! =>! %64%+*30! 3*9!
:=88&<0B!84+;54;+30!9%>&5&%*5&%8!?/%+%Q!4/%!;*&H%+8&4B!&48%0>@,!4/%!>=5;8!&8!*=1!=*!4/%!:%+8=*30&4B!
4+3&48!=>!4/%!43+)%4!:%+8=*!?:+=>%88=+@!?&<&9E@E!
!
P*!4/&8!*3++34&H%,!4/%!;*&H%+8&4B!397&*&84+34=+8!3::%3+!&*!3!:=8&4&H%!0&)/4Q!38!3!8%%7&*)0B!*%;4+30!
3*9!=<O%54&H%!3;4/=+&4B,!4/%B!4+B!4=!+%8=0H%!4/%!5=*>0&54!>+=7!3!8;:%+&=+!:=8&4&=*E!2/&8!/3::%*8!
<=4/!&*!4/%!:+%8%*4,!1/%*!4/%!355;8%9!:+=>%88=+!&8!9%7=4%9!=+!9&87&88%9,!3*9!&*!4/%!>;4;+%,!
1/%*!4/%B!:+=:=8%!4/%!&*8430034&=*!=>!*%1!5=77&88&=*8!3*9!5=*4354!:=&*48!>=+!4/%!8;>>%+&*)!
B=;*)!3539%7&58E!
!
!
!
XEMEX!d=8%:/3!]E!
-0=*)8&9%!4/%!W=<&*!$==9!*3++34&H%,!3!7=9&>&%9!d=8%:/!]E!*3++34&H%!9%H%0=:%9!&*!4/%!7%9&3!
3+=;*9! 4/%! 837%! 4&7%,! 1/&5/! 1%! 5300!4/%! Jd=8%:/3! ]E! *3++34&H%K! &*! +%5=)*&4&=*! =>! 4/%! *=1!
=H%+0B!50%3+!3>>%54%9*%88!=>!1=7%*E!P*! 4/&8! *3++34&H%,!4/%!<38&5!5=*>0&54! =H%+! +%8=;+5%8!<%G
41%%*!4/%!=;4843*9&*)!>%730%!:+=>%88=+!3*9!/%+!5=00%3);%8!+%73&*8E!2/%!73*3)%7%*4,!/=1G
%H%+,!*=1!;8%8!*%1!:=88&<&0&4&%8!4=!+%8=0H%!4/%!5=*>0&54!&*!&48!=1*!&*4%+%84Q!&4!843*98!;:!>=+!4/%!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
eM!
&*4%+%848! =>! B=;*)! 3539%7&58,! 1/=! &*! 4/&8! *3++34&H%! ?38! &*! 4/%! W=<&*! $==9! *3++34&H%@! 3+%!
7=840B!8%%*!38! +34/%+! ;*9%+35/&%H&*)E!$%+%,!4==,!4/%! 8;:%+H&8=+8! 3+%!355;8%9!=>! 7&8;8&*)!
4/%&+!:=1%+!&*!354&=*8!+%034&*)!4=!)%*;&*%!3+%3!=>!+%8:=*8&<&0&4B,!8;5/!38!388%88&*)!1=+',!8%4G
4&*)!9%390&*%8!=+!=;40&*&*)!1=+'&*)!/=;+8E!-4!4/%!837%!4&7%,!4/%!7%9&3!5&4%!355;834&=*8,!8=7%!
=>!4/%7! 8%+&=;8!?+3*)&*)! >+=7!0&<%0!4=! 803*9%+@,! 4/34! 5=;09! 308=! /3H%! <%%*! :+=8%5;4%9,! <;4!
1/&5/!1%+%!*=4!<+=;)/4!4=!4+&30!&*!3*B!=>!4/%!=<8%+H%9!J538%8KE!
!
P*4%+:+%434&=*!
2/%! 355;834&=*! =>! 3<;8%! =>! :=1%+! *=1! 8%%78! 4=! <%! +%39&0B!>=+7;034%9Q!-! 8;+H%B! 34! (2$!
i;+&5/!>=;*9!4/34!#^k!=>!4/%!9=54=+30!84;9%*48!F;%84&=*%9!<%0&%H%!4/%B!/3H%!30+%39B!%6:%+&G
%*5%9!3<;8%!=>!:=1%+!=+!34!0%384!0%39%+8/&:!7&85=*9;54!?U%/+%*<35/,!#L#L@E!\>4%*,!/=1%H%+,!
4/%! 355;834&=*8! 8&7:0B! 5=*5%+*! 4/%! ;8%! =>! 0%)&4&734%! :=1%+,! 1/&5/! &8! F;&4%! *%5%883+B! >=+!
84%%+&*)!=+)3*&834&=*8!?&<&9E,!:E!X##@E!U+=7!4/%!:%+8:%54&H%!=>!3!<;8&*%88!%*4%+:+&8%,!3<;8%!
=>!:=1%+!<%)&*8!1/%+%!4/%!;8%!=>!:=1%+!J/38!*=4/&*)!4=!9=!1&4/!4/%!&*4%+%848!=>!4/%!5=7:3*BK!
?_=H3+4&8,!#LLM,!:E!M^@E!-55=+9&*)0B,!3<;8%!=>!:=1%+!=55;+8!1/%*!8;:%+&=+8!;8%!4/%!9%:%*9G
%*4!:%+8=*!>=+!:+&H34%! &*4%+%848,!1/%*!4/%B!9=! *=4!39/%+%!4=!+%);034&=*8! 3*9!<B0318!4=!4/%!
9%4+&7%*4!=>!9%:%*9%*4!:%+8=*8,!=+!1/%*!4/%B!388&)*!4/%! 9%:%*9%*4!:%+8=*!;*5/300%*)&*)!
1=+'
%
!4/34!9=%8!*=4!5=++%8:=*9!4=!/&8!=+!/%+!O=<!:+=>&0%!?5>E!&<&9E@E!
!
2/%!;*&H%+8&4B!397&*&84+34&=*8!4/34!43'%!;:!4/%!=>4%*!;*9&>>%+%*4&34%9!355;834&=*8!=>!7=<<&*)!
3*9!3<;8%!=>!:=1%+!3)3&*!3::%3+!&*!3!<39!0&)/4!&*!4/%!d=8%:/3!]E!*3++34&H%Q!4/%B!+%)3+9!%H%+B!
5=7:03&*4!38!3*!;*5/%5'%9!>354!3*9!=>4%*!5=*9;54!>;+4/%+,!/&)/0B!=*%G8&9%9!&*H%84&)34&=*8!<B!
8%3+5/&*)!>=+!>;+4/%+!*%)34&H%!8434%7%*48E!2/%B!4/;8!9%:3+4!>+=7!3!*%;4+30!:=8&4&=*!3*9!<%G
5=7%!3*!&*4%+%84G9+&H%*!354=+E!a=8&4&H%!8434%7%*48!>+=7!=4/%+,!;8;300B!7=+%!8;55%88>;0,!7%7G
<%+8!=>!4/%!O;*&=+!3539%7&5!843>>,!84;9%*48!=+!5=00%3);%8!3+%!8B84%734&5300B!&)*=+%9E!-0+%39B!
1&4/!4/&8!=*%G8&9%9!:+%8%*434&=*!=>!4/%!538%!3*9!4/%!13B!&4!&8!9%304!1&4/!&*!4/%!7%9&3,!;*&H%+8&4B!
397&*&84+34&=*8!9&8+%)3+9!4/%!:+&*5&:0%!=>!4/%!:+%8;7:4&=*!=>!&**=5%*5%E!P*!399&4&=*,!+%);03+!
:+=5%9;+30! 84%:8! 3+%! 9&8+%)3+9%9Q! C&*5%! O;*&=+! 3539%7&58! 3+%! );3+3*4%%9! 3*=*B7&4B,! 4/%!
355;834&=*8!=>!4/%!:+=>%88=+!&*!F;%84&=*!3+%!=*0B!7%*4&=*%9!&*!)%*%+30&8%9!4%+78,!3*9!355%88!
4=!4/%!>&0%8!3*9!4/%!=::=+4;*&4B!4=!5=77%*4!3+%!9%*&%9E!P>!3!:+=>%88=+!4/;8!3::+=35/%9!9%*&%8!
4/%!5+&7%,!8/%! &8! 355;8%9! =>! J&*4+3*8&)%*5%K,!1/&5/!=*0B!5=*>&+78!4/%!&*&4&30!8;8:&5&=*!&*!4/%!
!
!
Q
** G'*0%*L,"'7*$,'0$2*0$*'70%*)(+0$0'0,$*'7#'*,$&V*\4$67#&&($20$2]*'#%M%*#"(*-($'0,$()*#%*#*+,"-*,+*#Y4%(*,+*
P,L("8*L70&(*Y(0$2*\,U(">)(-#$)0$2]8*#%*0'*L#%*,+'($*+,"-4&#'()*0$*'7(*#$,$V-,4%*#664%#'0,$%*,+*V,4$2*
#6#)(-06%*#2#0$%'*N+(-#&(O*P",+(%%,"%8*),(%*$,'*#PP(#"*#%*#$*#%P(6'*#'*#&&;*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
e#!
%B%8!=>!4/%!;*&H%+8&4B!397&*&84+34&=*E!-!:&54;+%!=>!=09!<=B!*%41=+'8!3*9!5=++;:4&=*!%7%+)%8,!
3*9!3<=H%!300!3! 8B84%734&5!+%:%30!=>!4/%!+;0%! =>!031!1&4/&*!4/%! 13008!=>!&*84&4;4&=*8!4/34! 3+%!
354;300B!5=77&44%9!4=!4/%!8%3+5/!>=+!4+;4/!38!:3+4!=>!4/%&+!5=+%!7&88&=*E!
!
!
!
XE#!I/=!138!9&87&88%9!=+!:;<0&50B!9%7=4%9!>=+!1/34!+%38=*8R!
S38%9!=*!4/%!8;+H%B!9343,!4/%!>&+84!F;%84&=*!4=!503+&>B!&8!1/%4/%+! 4/%!9&87&88%9!=+!9%7=4%9!
?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8!/3H%!8&7&03+!8=5&=G8434&84&530!5/3+354%+&84&58!?23<0%!M@E!2=!<%)&*!1&4/,!&4!&8!
84+&'&*)!4/34!4/&8!13B!=>!9%30&*)! 1&4/! 5=*>0&548!8%%78!4=!<%!&*5+%38&*)Q!7=+%!4/3*! /30>! =>!300!
J538%8K!=>!9&87&8830!=+!9%7=4&=*!/3H%!=55;++%9!8&*5%!#LMNE!-08=,!4/%+%!&8!3!+%73+'3<0B!/&)/!
:+=:=+4&=*!=>! 3>>%54%9!1=7%*! ?e^! k@! 3*9! =>!>=+%&)*%+8! ?eL!k@V! 4/%! /&)/! :+=:=+4&=*! =>!9&8G
7&88%9! 3*9! 9%7=4%9! 1=7%*! &8! 307=84! &*H%+8%0B! :+=:=+4&=*30!4=! 4/%! 84&00! 0=1! :+=:=+4&=*! =>!
1=7%*!1&4/&*!4/%! :+=>%88=+&34%! &*!)%*%+30! ?#N!k,! ISC! A+=;:,!#LMY@E! \+!4=! :;4! &4!3*=4/%+!
13B,!&4!&8!73&*0B!4/=8%!1/=!<%0=*)!4=!3!7&*=+&4B!1/=!3+%!3>>%54%9!?I%84/;%8,!#LL"<,!:E!Mb@E!
!
! !
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
eX!
23<0%!M
Q! \H%+H&%1!=>!4/%!'*=1*!J538%8K!?3@,!4/=8%!>+=7!cG-G`$!?<@!38!1%00!38!4/=8%!5=00%54%9!
<B!7%3*8!=>!F;%84&=**3&+%8!?5@E!
!
*
!"#$%&'(&$)*"+,+-$
!.#$/01023$
$*
b*
$*
b*
$*
b*
[,4$'"V*
*
*
*
*
*
*
^("-#$V*
c*
:A*
c*
:c*
d*
:R*
C4%'"0#*
9*
=c*
9*
?=*
9*
:=*
EL0'3("&#$)*
R*
:d*
R*
9?*
9*
:=*
,'7("*IK>6,4$'"V*
9*
=c*
*
*
*
*
*
?:*
=AA*
=e*
=AA*
=:*
=AA*
!VP(*,+*(%6#&#'0,$*
*
*
*
*
*
*
X0%-0%%#&*
=:*
dc*
=A*
d:*
c*
d9*
X($0()*'($4"(**
N$,*6,-P"(7($%0Y&(*"(#%,$O*
9*
=c*
9*
?=*
?*
=d*
f4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*
Q*
?Q*
d*
?Q*
9*
:=*
*
?:*
=AA*
=e*
=AA*
=:*
=AA*
!0-(*
*
*
*
*
*
*
g*?AAd*
9*
=c*
9*
?=*
=*
R*
?AAdh?A=9*
Q*
?Q*
9*
?=*
:*
?:*
%0$6(*?A=d*
=:*
dc*
==*
dR*
e*
Qe*
*
?:*
=AA*
=e*
=AA*
=:*
=AA*
E(T*
*
*
*
*
*
*
_(-#&(*
=c*
c9*
=:*
QR*
==*
Rd*
`#&(*
Q*
?Q*
Q*
:?*
?*
=d*
*
?:*
=AA*
=e*
=AA*
=:*
=AA*
_,"(02$("*
*
*
*
*
*
*
i(%*
=Q*
cA*
=?*
Q:*
c*
d9*
D,*
c*
:A*
c*
:c*
Q*
9Q*
*
?:*
=AA*
=e*
=AA*
=:*
=AA*
_0"%'*2($("#'0,$*#6#)(-06*
*
*
*
*
*
*
i(%*
*
*
*
*
Q*
9Q*
D,*
*
*
*
*
c*
d9*
*
*
*
*
*
=:*
=AA*
E,4"6(.*%4"U(V*,+*P"(%($'*%'4)V*
*
!
!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
e^!
2/&8!:&54;+%!&8!73&*43&*%9!&*!%637&*&*)!=4/%+!>354=+8Q!307=84!/30>!=>!4/%!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8!
3>>%54%9!3+%!>&+84!)%*%+34&=*!3539%7&58,!&E%E,!4/%B!9=!*=4!5=7%!>+=7!3*!3539%7&5!7&0&%;E!c%G
8:&4%!035'&*)!8=5&30!3*9!5;04;+30!53:&430!?S=;+9&%;,!#LML@,!4/%B!/3H%!+%35/%9!4/%!:=8&4&=*!=>!
:+=>%88=+!3*9!:+=H%9!4=!<%!H%+B!8;55%88>;0!4/%+%!?7%38;+%9!<B!4/%!=>>&5&30!:%+>=+73*5%!:3G
+37%4%+8!=>!3539%7&3!8;5/!38!+%8%3+5/!>;*98!313+9%9!3*9!:;<0&534&=*8@E!c;%!4=!4/%&+!%6:%G
+&%*5%8!38!%3+0B!%9;534&=*30!35/&%H%+8,!300!=>!4/%7!9%H%0=:%9!3!84+=*)!1=+'!3*9!:%+>=+73*5%!
%4/&5,!1/&5/!308=!>%%98!&*4=!4/%&+!%6:%5434&=*8!=>!843>>!3*9!84;9%*48E!2/%!>354!4/34!8;5/!1=7%*,!
=>!300!:%=:0%,!3+%!3>>%54%9!<B!9&87&8830l:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*!5=++%8:=*98!4=!4/%!>&*9&*)!4/34!%0&4%8!
+%:+=9;5%!4/%78%0H%8!:+&73+&0B!4/+=;)/!/3<&4;8!?3*9!4/;8!=+&)&*@,!1/&0%!4/%!*3++34&H%!=>!85&G
%*5%!38!3!7%+&4=5+34&5!8B84%7!&8!=84%*8&<0B!73&*43&*%9!?5>E!$3+473**,!#LL#V!fn00%+,!#LMN@E!
!
[=='&*)!34!4/%!+%38=*8!)&H%*!>=+!9&87&8830!=+!9%7=4&=*!?23<0%!#@,!&4!&8!8;+:+&8&*)!4=!>&*9!4/34!
&*!*=!?o@!J538%K!9&9!85&%*4&>&5!7&85=*9;54!?&E%E,!9%5%:4&=*,!:03)&3+&87,!85&%*4&>&5!>+3;9!=+!4/%!0&'%@!
=+!3!>&*9&*)!>300&*)!;*9%+!5+&7&*30!031!0%39!4=!4/%!4%+7&*34&=*!=>!4/%!%7:0=B7%*4!+%034&=*8/&:E!
W34/%+,!&*!300!J538%8K,!4/%!355;834&=*!=>!7&85=*9;54!+%>%++%9!%&4/%+!4=!*=!3::3+%*4!+%38=*8!=+!
4=!:%+8=*300B!344+&<;4%9!38:%548,!1/&5/!53*!<%!9&84&*);&8/%9!38!>=00=18Q!
§ 7&85=*9;54!&*!0%39%+8/&:!p!7=<<&*),!:8B5/=0=)&530!:+%88;+%,!347=8:/%+%!=>!>%3+!=+!4%++=+V!
§ :==+!:%+>=+73*5%!p!7&85=*9;54!&*!4/%!:%+>=+73*5%!=>!:+=>%88=+&30!9;4&%8,!%E)E,!%H30;34&=*!
=>!4%35/&*),!:;<0&8/&*)!=*!4/%!J1+=*)K!+%8%3+5/!4=:&5!=+!&*!0=1G0%H%0!O=;+*308V!3*9!
§ 7&85=*9;54!&*!%6%5;4&*)! 438'8! p!7&85=*9;54! &*! +%034&=*!4=! 397&*&84+34&H%! 354&H&4&%8! :%+G
>=+7%9!&*!3!73*3)%+&30!53:35&4BE!
!
23<0%!#Q!
W%38=*8!>=+!9&87&8830!=+!9%7=4&=*E
!
!
B(#%,$*20U($*N2($("#&03()O*
"#$!%&'&()!
"*$!+,-./0122#03-!
$*
b*
$*
b*
f("%,$#&&V*#''"0Y4'()*"(#%,$%*
=:*
QR*
=A*
cc*
`0%6,$)46'*0$*&(#)("%70P**
c*
:c*
d*
:R*
f,,"*P("+,"-#$6(*
9*
?=*
:*
?:*
`0%6,$)46'*0$*(T(64'0$2*'#%M%
*
?*
==*
?*
=d*
`#$0+(%'*"(#%,$%*
A*
A*
A*
A*
E60($'0+06*-0%6,$)46'*
A*
A*
A*
A*
["0-0$#&*"(#%,$%*
A*
A*
A*
A*
D,'*#PP#"($'*,"*,'7("*"(#%,$%*
Q*
:?*
:*
?:*
*
=e*
=AA*
=:*
=AA*
E,4"6(.*%4"U(V*,+*P"(%($'*%'4)V*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
eN!
C;+:+&8&*)0B,!4/%+%!3+%!3!+%034&H%0B!/&)/!*;7<%+!=>!J538%8K!4/34!>300!&*4=!4/%!534%)=+B!J*=4!3:G
:3+%*4K!?7%9&3!3*30B8&8@!=+!J=4/%+!+%38=*8K!?F;%84&=**3&+%@E!2/&8!&*50;9%8!8434%7%*48!8;5/!38!
J<39!<%/3H&=;+K!?o@!=+! J&*39%F;34%! >;0>&07%*4!=>!>=+730!+%F;%848! 1&4/=;4!%H&9%*5%!<%&*)!:+=G
H&9%9KE!
!
XEX!W;0%!=>!031!:+=5%9;+%8!
2/%!F;%84&=*!=>!4/%!+;0%!=>!031!=>!4/=8%!:+=5%9;+%8!4/34!0%9!4=!4/%!9%5&8&=*8!=>!4/%!73*3)%G
7%*4!=>!;*&H%+8&4&%8!=+!+%8%3+5/!&*84&4;4&=*8!4=!9&87&88!=+!:;<0&50B!9%7=4%!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8!
138! 3! >=5;8! =>! +%8%3+5/! &*4%+%84!&*! 4/%! :+%8%*4! 84;9BE! P*! :+=5%9;+%8! 4/34! ?1=;09! /3H%! 4=@!
:+%5%9%!3!9%5&8&=*!1&4/!8;5/!8%+&=;8!5=*8%F;%*5%8!>=+!4/%!3>>%54%9!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+,!&4!&8!
4=!<%!%6:%54%9!4/34!)%*%+300B!3::0&53<0%!0318!?%E)E,!5+&7&*30!031,!03<=;+!031,!%7:0=B7%*4!031,!
/&)/%+!%9;534&=*!031@!3+%! 308=! H30&9! &*! 4/%! >&%09! =>!85&%*5%,!3*9!4/%!;*9%+0B&*)!:+&*5&:0%8!=>!
4/%!+;0%!=>!031!3+%!308=!=<8%+H%9!&*!;*&H%+8&4B!:+=5%%9&*)8E!2/%8%!&*50;9%Q
&
!
§
>3&+*%88
!G!300!8&9%8!3+%!4+%34%9!%F;300BV!
§
4+3*8:3+%*5B
!G!=>! 4/%!:+=5%9;+%! 38! 3!1/=0%,! =>!4/%!&*9&H&9;30! :+=5%9;+30!843)%8,! =>! 4/%!
5+&4%+&3!;8%9!34!%35/!843)%,!%45V!
§
5=*>&9%*4&30&4B
!G!1/&5/!3::0&%8!%F;300B!4=!300!8&9%8V!
§
:+%8;7:4&=*!=>! &**=5%*5%
!G!38!3!5%*4+30! >;*937%*430! :+&*5&:0%! =>! 5+&7&*30! :+=5%%9&*)8!
;*9%+!4/%!+;0%!=>!031V!
§
+&)/4!4=!<%!/%3+9
!G!&*!3*B!5=77&44%%!9%30&*)!1&4/!4/%!>3548!=>!4/%!538%V!
§
+&)/4!4=!73'%! 3!8434%7%*4
!G!4/&8! +%F;&+%8!4/34!4/%! 300%)34&=*8!3+%!<%&*)!739%! '*=1*!&*!
1+&4&*)!3*9!4/34!8;>>&5&%*4!4&7%!&8!)&H%*!4=!:+=H&9%!3!1+&44%*!8434%7%*4V!
§
+&)/4!4=!5=*>+=*4!5=7:03&*3*48
!G!4/&8!+%F;&+%8!4/%!+%7=H30!=>!4/%&+!3*=*B7&4B!)+3*4%9!&*!4/%!
8%*8%!=>!3!:+&H&0%)%!3)3&*84!4/%!355;8%9V!
§
+&)/4!4=!0%)30!5=;*8%0
!G!&*!300!=+30!5=77;*&534&=*8!5=*5%+*&*)!=*%Z8!%7:0=B7%*4E!
!
2/%!7%9&3!+%:=+48!=*!4/%!9&87&88308!3*9!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*8!30+%39B!)&H%!50%3+!&*9&534&=*8!4/34!
4/%!&*4%+*30!:+=5%9;+%8!*%%9!4=!<%!+%)3+9%9!7&*&7300B!38!=:3F;%!=+!%H%*!&*5=7:+%/%*8&<0%E!
2/%!+%8;048!=>!4/%!9343!5=00%54&=*! 50%3+0B!8;::=+4!4/&8!&7:+%88&=*E!U&);+%! #! 8;773+&8%8!4/%!
3*81%+8!>+=7!4/%!843*93+9&8%9!F;%84&=**3&+%8!3*9!8/=18!4/34,!>+=7!4/%!:=&*4!=>!H&%1!=>!4/=8%!
3>>%54%9,!300!)&H%*!:+&*5&:0%8!=>!4/%!+;0%!=>!031!1%+%!9&8+%)3+9%9!4=!3!5=*8&9%+3<0%!%64%*4E!\*0B!!
!
!
c
** C&&* P"0$60P&(%* 0$* 0'#&06%* L("(* -($'0,$()* YV* U#"0 ,4%* %P(#M("%* #'* '7(* 6,$+("($6(* ZC664%#'0,$%* L0'7,4'*
%($)("Z*N?A@?=*_(Y"4#"V*?A?A*0$*f#%%#4O8*"#'7("*0$*P#%%0$2*#$)*#%*%(&+>(U0)($'*(&(-($'%*,+*'7(*"4&(*,+*
&#L;*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
e"!
_024"(*?
.**HY%("U#$6(*,+*'7(*P"0$60P&(%*,+*'7(*"4&(*,+*&#L*0$*'7(*0$'("$#&*P",6()4"(%*'7#'*P"(6()()*)0%-0%>
%#&*,"*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$;*G$*'7(*W4(%'0,$$#0"(8*'7(*P"0$60P&(%*L("(*%4"U(V()*L0'7*#*%(U($>P,0$'*
F0M("'*%6#&(j*0$*'7(*(U#&4#'0,$8*'70%*%6#&(*0%*6,$)($%()*',*'7"((*U#&4(%;*
!
$k=:*
!
&*!4/%! 538%!=>!41=!=>!4/%!%&)/4!:+&*5&:0%8!9&9!+%8:=*9%*48!8434%!4/34!4/%B!1%+%!+%8:%54%9!&*!
4/%&+!:+=5%%9&*)8Q!4/+%%!=>!4/%!4=430!=>!4/&+4%%*!+%8:=*9%*48!3*81%+%9!4/34!4/%B!1%+%!)+3*4%9!
4/%!+&)/4! 4=!0%)30! 388&843*5%!&*! &*4%+H&%18!4=! 3*!%64%*4! 4/34!8%%7%9! 8;>>&5&%*4!4=! 4/%7V!41=!
=4/%+8!8434%9!4/34!4/%B!/39!+%5%&H%9!4/%!+&)/4!4=!3!1+&44%*!8434%7%*4E!-00!4/&+4%%*!+%8:=*9%*48!
3*81%+%9!4/34! 4/%! :+=5%%9&*)8! 1%+%! ;*>3&+! >+=7! 4/%&+! :=&*4! =>! H&%1V! 41%0H%!=;4!=>! 4/&+4%%*!
?Y#!k@!7&88%9!4/%!:+%8;7:4&=*!=>!&**=5%*5%,!4/%!4+3*8:3+%*5B! =>! 4/%!:+=5%%9&*)8!3*9!4/%!
+&)/4!4=!<%!/%3+9!+%8:%54&H%0BE!`=*>&9%*4&30&4B!&*!4/%!:+=5%%9&*)8!38!1%00!38!4/%!:=88&<&0&4B!=>!
5=*>+=*434&=*!1&4/!4/%!5=7:03&*3*48!1%+%!>=;*9!4=!<%!035'&*)!<B!%0%H%*!=;4!=>!4/&+4%%*!?bN!k@E!
2%*!=;4!=>! 4/&+4%%*! &*4%+H&%1%%8!?ee!k@!1%+%! 9%*&%9!4/%! +&)/4!4=! 5=77%*4!3*9! 4/%!+&)/4! 4=!
0%)30!39H&5%!&*!9&85;88&=*8!5=*5%+*&*)!4/%&+!%7:0=B7%*4E!
!
2/%+%>=+%,!&*!4/%!:+=5%9;+%8!4/34!:+%5%9%9!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*,!4/%!73*3)%7%*4!=>!
4/%!85&%*5%! &*84&4;4&=*8! &*! F;%84&=*! 8B84%734&5300B!9&8+%)3+9%9! =+! 354&H%0B! =H%++;0%9! >;*93G
7%*430!:+&*5&:0%8!=>!4/%!+;0%!=>!031E!2/%!%6:%+&%*5%8!<%/&*9!4/%8%!388%887%*48,!1/&5/!3+%!
+34/%+!9&8384+=;8!>=+!3!85&%*4&>&5!&*84&4;4&=*!&*!3!5=*84&4;4&=*30!8434%,!3+%!8/=1*!<B!8=7%!%637G
:0%8!>+=7!4/%!&*4%+H&%18Q!
!
!"# $!"# %!"# &!"# '!"# (!!"#
righ t t o leg al assistanc e
righ t t o comment (written stat ement)
righ t of confrontation with co mplainants
confidentiality (on all sides)
righ t t o b e heard (in a com mittee / board)
transparency of the procedure
assump tion of innocence
fairness (all sides were treated equally)
!"#$%#$%&&$ '''$()*$+, -*$.*$/ '''$01&&2$(3*$4,
"The following aspects are regarded as fundamental principles of the rule of law.
Please indicate which principles have been respected in the run-up to and in the
course of your dismissal / public demotion procedure."
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
ee!
2/%! :+=>%88=+! 4/+%34%*%9! 1&4/! 9&87&8830! 38'8! 4/%! 9%3*Z8! =>>&5%! >=+! 4/%! 0%)30! <38&8! >=+! 4/%!
:+%:3+34&=*!=>!3!4%35/&*)!%H30;34&=*!9%73*9%9!34!8/=+4!*=4&5%E!-!>%1!93B8!034%+!8/%!%*F;&+%8!
3<=;4!4/%!1/%+%3<=;48!=>!4/%!&*>=+734&=*!3*9!&8!4=09!<B!+%4;+*!=>!:=84!4/34!8/%!1&00!+%5%&H%!&4!
4/%!*%64!93BE!I/34!3++&H%8!4/%!*%64!93B!&8!3!9%5&8&=*!934%9!>+=7!4/%!93B!<%>=+%E!2/%!0%)30!
<38&8!>=+!4/%!9%73*9!>=+!4/%!%H30;34&=*!138!4/%+%>=+%!3!+%8=0;4&=*!4/34!138!=*0B!:388%9!3>4%+!
4/%!9%73*9!>=+!4/%!0%)30!<38&8!/39!<%%*!H=&5%9E!
!
2/%!&*84&4;4%Z8!<=3+9!313+98!4%35/&*)!388&)*7%*48!4/34!=>>%+!304%+*34&H%8!=>!&9%*4&530!5=*4%*4!
:3+300%0! 4=! 4/%! 5=;+8%8! =>! 4/%! :+=>%88=+! &*! F;%84&=*E! 2/%! 84;9%*48! 3+%! 4=09! 4/34! =*0B! 4/%8%!
:3+300%0!5=;+8%8!3+%!+%0%H3*4!4=!4/%&+!84;9&%8E!`=*8%F;%*40B,!4/%!:+=>%88=+Z8!5=;+8%8!+%73&*!
%7:4B!1&4/=;4!/%+!&*4%+H%*4&=*E!2/%!+%38=*!>=+!9&87&8830!&8!4/%*!5=*84+;54%9!38!4/%!355;834&=*!
4/34!8/%!9&9!*=4!8:%*9!4/%!4&7%!85/%9;0%9!>=+!4/%!5=;+8%8!&*!4/%!%7:4B!8%7&*3+!+==7!>=+!4/%!
%*4&+%!8%7%84%+E!!
!
2/%! ;*&H%+8&4B!73*3)%7%*4! 38'8! 843>>! 7%7<%+8! 4=! >=+7;034%! %H30;34&=*8! 3*9! 8434%7%*48!
3<=;4!3!:+=>%88=+E!C%H%+30!=>!4/%!:+=>%88=+Z8!+%F;%848!4=!&*8:%54!>&0%8!3+%!+%>;8%9E!I/%*!8/%!
>&*300B!)%48! 355%88! 4=!4/%! >&0%,!8%H%+30! :3883)%8!3+%! <035'%9! =;4E!P*! 4/%!>&0%! 4/%+%!&8! 308=! 3!
+%>%+%*5%!4=!J03*);3)%!+%);034&=*8K!>=+!4/%!%64%+*30!:+%8%*434&=*!=>!4/%!538%E!
!
P*4%+:+%434&=*!
P*!300!4/+%%!%637:0%8,!4/%!+%8:%54&H%!;*&H%+8&4B!73*3)%7%*4!3548!38!3!:%+:%4+34=+!&*!4/%!+;*G
;:!4=!4/%!9%5&8&=*E!2/%B!;8%!:+=5%9;+%8!&*!=+9%+!4=!<%!3<0%!4=!%*>=+5%!4/%!H&%18!4/%B!13*4E!
_=4! %*4&+%0B! 8;+:+&8&*)0B,! 8;5/! :344%+*8! =>! 354&=*! 3+%! 7=+%! =>4%*!>=;*9!&*! J538%8K! &*! 1/&5/!
355;834&=*8!=>!7=<<&*)!?p!J7&85=*9;54!&*!0%39%+8/&:K@!:03B!=*0B!3!8;<=+9&*34%!+=0%!=+!*=!+=0%!
34!300E!$=1%H%+,!4/%B!&00;84+34%!:3+4&5;03+0B!50%3+0B!4/%!0%88!4/3*!5=*84&4;4&=*30! 344&4;9%! =>! 4/%!
;*&H%+8&4B!397&*&84+34&=*8!1&4/!1/&5/!3>>%54%9!:+=>%88=+8!3+%!5=*>+=*4%9E!
!
P4!&8!5/3+354%+&84&5!=>!
300
!J538%8K!%637&*%9!/%+%!4/34!4/%!73*3)%7%*4!5=7<&*%8!4/%!+=0%8!=>!
:03&*4&>>!3*9!O;9)%!&*!=*%!:%+8=*,!<B!8&9&*)!1&4/!4/%!5=7:03&*3*4!1&4/=;4!73'&*)!3*!%>>=+4!4=!
503+&>B!4/%!>3548,!3*9!%H%*!<B!354&H%0B!;*9%+43'&*)!4=!84+%*)4/%*!4/%!355;834&=*8E!2/%!&*4%+G
H&%18!308=!8/=1!3!50%3+!:&54;+%!/%+%Q!4/=8%!1/=!739%!355;834&=*8!1%+%!/%3+9V!4/=8%!1/=!
8:='%!>=+!4/%! 355;8%9!1%+%!&)*=+%9,! 38! 1%+%!4/%! 355;8%9! 4/%78%0H%8E!$=1%H%+,! 4/%! 8;5G
5%88>;0!%6%+5&8%!=>!4/%!>;*54&=*!=>!O;9)%,!1/&5/!3!+%54=+l:+%8&9%*4!39=:48,!+%F;&+%8!4/34!4/=8%!
3>>%54%9!<B!4/%!9%5&8&=*8!
J/3H%!3!5%+43&*!9%)+%%! =>!5=*>&9%*5%!&*!4/%! 5=++%54*%88K
!?$n+*0%,!
#LMe@E!2=!4/&8!%*9,!4/%B!7;84!/3H%!3!5/3*5%!4=!<%!5=*H&*5%9!=>!4/%!O;9)%Z8!*%;4+30&4B,!1/&5/!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
eb!
&8!*=4!4/%!538%!&>!4/%!O;9)%!3548!38!3!:03&*4&>>!>=+!3!:3+4B!=+!38!3!:%+:%4+34=+!&*!39H3*5%E!2/&8!
3::+=35/! 9+318! =*! 4/%! *=4&=*! =>! J0%)&4&735B! 4/+=;)/! :+=5%9;+%K! ?[;/73**@! <B! %7:0=B&*)!
:+=5%9;+%8,!<;4! ;*9%+7&*%8! 4/%!:+=5%9;+30!:+&*5&:0%,!8&*5%!4/%!9%5&8&=*!=*!4/%!=;45=7%!=>!
4/%!:+=5%%9&*)8!/38!<%%*!739%!%08%1/%+%!30+%39BE!
!
-)3&*84!4/%!<35')+=;*9!=>! 4/%8%! +%8;048,!4/%!F;%84&=*!3+&8%8! 38! 4=!4/%!0%)30!;*9%+843*9&*)!
:=88%88%9!<B!4/%!;*&H%+8&4&%8!3*9! 85&%*4&>&5! &*84&4;4&=*8!&*H=0H%9E!c%!C=;83!C3*4=8Z! ?MYbe@!
9&84&*54&=*!<%41%%*!
$=7%+&5
!3*9!
<&<0&530
!O;+&8:+;9%*5%!53*!/%0:!/%+%E!$=7%+&5!O;+&8:+;9%*5%!
&8!3<84+354!3*9!9&84&*);&8/%8!<%41%%*!>3548!3*9!031V!&4!3++&H%8!34!3!O;9)%7%*4!<B!8;<8;7&*)!
4/%!>3548!;*9%+!4/%!0%)30! +;0%8E! S&<0&530!O;+&8:+;9%*5%,!=*!4/%!=4/%+!/3*9,! &8! 8&4;34&=*30,!=+&G
%*4%9!4=13+98!%H%+B93B!0&>%,!%H30;34%8!:+&73+&0B!*3++34%9!>3548!?U=+9,!MYYY@!3*9!&8!=+&%*4%9!
4=13+98! 4/%! 8/3+%9! 7=+30! &9%38! =>! 3! 5=77;*&4BE! 2/%! /%4%+=)%*%=;8! 8=5&%4&%8! =>! 7=9%+*!
5=*84&4;4&=*30! 8434%8! 3+%! 388;7%9! 4=! /3H%! &*84300%9! 3! 03+)%0B! $=7%+&5! O;+&8:+;9%*5%! ?c%!
C=;83!C3*4=8,!MYbeV!U=+9,!MYYY@E!2/%!>&*9&*)8!>+=7!4/&8!84;9B!=*!4/%!4+%347%*4!=>!?>%730%@!
:+=>%88=+8,!=*!4/%!=4/%+!/3*9,!8%%7!4=!8/=1!3!+%03:8%!&*4=!3!<&<0&530!;*9%+843*9&*)!=>!031!&*!
4/%! ;*&H%+8&4B! 5=*4%64,! &*! 1/&5/! *3++34%9! :%+5%:4&=*8! 3+%! %H30;34%9! 38! >3548,! 5=*4+3+B! 35G
5=;*48! 3+%! &)*=+%9,! &88;%8!3+%! 344+&<;4%9! 4=! 8;::=8%90B! :%+8=*30! :+=<0%78! ?=>! 4/%! >%730%!
:+=>%88=+@!3*9!9%5&8&=*8!3+%!=+&%*4%9!&*!>3H=;+!=>!4/=8%!&*!:=1%+!=+!=>!:3+4&5;03+!&*4%+%848E!
!
XE^!C43'%/=09%+8!&*!4/%!9&87&88308l9%7=4&=*8!
[&'%! =4/%+! =+)3*&834&=*8,! ;*&H%+8&4&%8! /3H%! 3! *;7<%+! =>! &9%*4&>&3<0%!
843'%/=09%+8
E! .*0&'%!
8/3+%/=09%+8
,!1/=!:;+8;%!3*!&*4%+%84!4/34!&8!30&)*%9!1&4/!4/%!5=7:3*BZ8!=<O%54&H%!?U+&%973*,!
MYeL@,!843'%/=09%+8!3+%!83&9!4=!/3H%!4/%&+!=1*!&*4+&*8&5!&*4%+%848!4/34!4/%B!1&8/!4=!388%+4!&*!
+%034&=*!4=! 4/%!5=7:3*B! ?c=*3098=*! T! a+%84=*,! MYYN@E! P*! 4/%! 5=*4%64! =>! ;*&H%+8&4&%8,! 4/%+%!
/3H%!<%%*!8&)*&>&53*4!8/&>48! &*! 4/%!9%85+&:4&=*!=>! 3*9! &*4%+354&=*!1&4/!9&>>%+%*4!843'%/=09%+8!
=H%+!4/%!0384!41%*4B!B%3+8E!U=+!%637:0%,!84;9%*48!3+%!*=1!;*9%+84==9!38!5;84=7%+8!&*!73*B!
:035%8!?`+=;5/,!#LMe@V!34!4/%!837%!4&7%,!4/%!*%1!5;84=7%+8Z!>;*937%*430!3<&0&4B!4=!84;9B!&8!
&*5+%38&*)0B! F;%84&=*%9! ?-%85/0&73**! %4! 30E! #LMYV! [39%*4/&*,! #LMb@,! 1/&5/! 8&)*&>&53*40B!
5/3*)%8!4/%! 438'8! =>! 4%35/%+8E! a/c!84;9%*48!&*! A%+73*G8:%3'&*)! 5=;*4+&%8,! =*! 4/%!=4/%+!
/3*9,!3+%!*=1!*=4!=*0B!%7:0=B%%8!<;4!308=!84;9%*48,!1/&5/!&*!4;+*!73'%8!4/%7!5;84=7%+8Q!
4/%B!3+%!4/;8!&*!3*!37<&H30%*4!+=0%!38!<=4/!%7:0=B%%8!3*9!%7:0=B%+8E!
!
(F;300B!8%+&=;8!5/3*)%8!3>>%54!4/%!+=0%!3*9!;*9%+843*9&*)!=>!4/%!73*3)%7%*4!=>!;*&H%+8&4&%8!
3*9!85&%*4&>&5! &*84&4;4&=*8E! -04/=;)/!4/%! 4B:&530!;*&H%+8&4B! /38! 3013B8!<%%*! 3!
J4%*8&=*G039%*
!
=+)3*&834&=*K!
?C5/&73*',! #LMe,! :E! NL@,! 4/%! %6:%5434&=*8! 3*9! ;*9%+843*9&*)! =>! <=4/!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
eY!
;*&H%+8&4&%8!3*9! 85&%*5%! /3H%! >;*937%*4300B! 5/3*)%9! 8&*5%!4/%! S=0=)*3! +%>=+7! 3*9! 4/%!
+=;)/0B!8&7;043*%=;8!+%0%38%!=>!;*&H%+8&4&%8!&*4=!8=G5300%9!J3;4=*=7BK!4=)%4/%+!1&4/!4/%!9%G
H%0=:7%*4!=>!*%1!>=+78!=>!)=H%+*3*5%E!C5/=0D!3*9!C4%&*!?#LML@!8%%!3!8/&>4!&*!4/%!<38&5!;*G
9%+843*9&*)!=>!;*&H%+8&4&%8!>+=7!3!'&*9!=>!
J>35;04B!>%9%+30&87K
!?<%>=+%!S=0=)*3,!&<&9E!:E!#"@!4=!
3!7=+%!J
:+%8&9%*4&30!>%;930&87K
!?&<&9E@,!&*!1/&5/!:+%8&9%*48!354!38!J/%397384%+8K!3*9!300!=4/%+!
;*&48!/3H%!4=!8;<=+9&*34%!4/%78%0H%8!38!4/%&+!J3)%*48K!?8;<=+9&*34%8!3*9!:+=4%54=+8@E!
!
P4!&8!1&4/&*!4/&8!7%8/!=>!5/3*)%8!3*9!5=*>0&54&*)!&*4%+%848!4/34!9&87&8830!3*9!9%7=4&=*!9%5&G
8&=*8!3+%!739%E!I%!38'%9!3<=;4!4/%!%6:%+&%*5%8!=>!4/=8%!3>>%54%9!1&4/!9&>>%+%*4!)+=;:8!=>!
354=+8Q!1/%4/%+!4/%B!1%+%!:%+5%&H%9!38!/%0:>;0l8;::=+4&H%,!*%;4+30!=+!354&*)!3)3&*84!4/%!35G
5;8%9,!=+!1/%4/%+!4/%B!1%+%!*=4!&*H=0H%9!&*!4/%!:+=5%88%8!:+&=+!4=!9&87&8830l9%7=4&=*E!\*!
4/%!=*%!/3*9,!4/%!+%8;048!8/%9!0&)/4!=*!4/%!5=7:0%6&4B!=>!4/%!%7:0=B7%*4!8&4;34&=*!&*!85&%*5%!
=+)3*&834&=*8V!=*!4/%!=4/%+!/3*9,!50%3+!:344%+*8!%7%+)%,!4/+%%!=>!1/&5/!3+%!8;+:+&8&*)!?U&)G
;+%!X@E!
§
P*4%+354&=*!=>!73*3)%7%*4!?+%54=+l:+%8&9%*4@,!397&*&84+34&=*!3*9!0=1%+!73*3)%7%*4!0%HG
%08!?9%3*Z8!=>>&5%l9%:3+47%*4!73*3)%7%*4@Q
!c;%!4=!4/%&+!=>>&5%8!3*9!+=0%8,!&4!&8!4=!<%!%6G
:%54%9!4/34!4/%!&*84&4;4&=*30!354=+8!43'%!3!*%;4+30!843*5%!&*!4/%!&*4%+*30!503+&>&534&=*!=>!8&4G
;34&=*8,! +%)3+90%88! =>! :%+8=*30! 8B7:34/&%8l3*4&:34/&%8! 3*9! +%)3+90%88! =>! %6&84&*)! 8%0>G
&*4%+%848E!U;+4/%+7=+%,!+%54=+8l:+%8&9%*48! /3H%! 3!9;4B!=>! 53+%!>=+!4/%&+!%7:0=B%%8,! 3*9!
4/&8!&*50;9%8!:+=>%88=+8E!2/%!8;+H%B!*%H%+4/%0%88!+%H%30%9!4/34!4/%!:+%8&9%*5Bl+%54=+34%!
4=='!3!:=8&4&=*!3)3&*84!4/%!355;8%9!:+=>%88=+!&*!307=84!300!J538%8K!G!=*0B!=*%!+%8:=*9%*4!
8434%9!4/34! 4/%! ;*&H%+8&4B!73*3)%7%*4! /39!43'%*! 3! *%;4+30! :=8&4&=*! &*!4/%! &*4%+*30!:+=G
5%%9&*)8E!2/%!41=!=4/%+!)+=;:8!=>!354=+8!34!4/%!73*3)%7%*4!0%H%0!?9%3*%+&%8!3*9!397&*G
&84+34&=*@!1%+%!344%84%9!8&7&03+!<%/3H&=;+,!=*0B!80&)/40B!0%88!:+=*=;*5%9E!$%+%,!4/%!;*&4&*)!
=>!4/%!+=0%8!=>!:03&*4&>>!3*9!O;9)%!<B!;*&H%+8&4B!73*3)%7%*4,!1/&5/!&8!5=*4+3+B!4=!4/%!+;0%!
=>!031,!53*!<%!>=;*9!3)3&*,!+%&*>=+5%9!=*5%!7=+%!<B!4/%!5=*8:&5;=;8!:3+4&83*8/&:!=>!4/%!
354=+8!=>!4/%!397&*&84+34&=*!3*9!0=1%+!73*3)%7%*4!0%H%08E!
§
P*H=0H%7%*4!=>!843>>!=+!1=+'8!5=;*5&08,!=7<;98:%+8=*8!3*9!%F;30!=::=+4;*&4&%8!=>>&5%+8Q!
SB!H&+4;%!=>!4/%&+!=>>&5%!3*9!73*934%,!4/%8%!)+=;:8!=>!354=+8!3+%!4=!<%!&*H=0H%9!&*!538%8!
=>!5=*>0&54V!34! 4/%!837%!4&7%,! 4/%&+!7%7<%+8!3+%! =<0&)%9!4=! <%! =<O%54&H%!3*9! *%;4+30E! P*!
4%+78! =>! 4/%&+! <38&5! 73*934%,! 4/%8%! <=9&%8! 3+%! %88%*4&30! %0%7%*48! =>! 4/%! :+=5%9;+%8!
4/+=;)/! 1/&5/! 9%5&8&=*8! 3+%! 0%)&4&7&8%9! &*! 0&<%+30! 9%7=5+35&%8E! _%H%+4/%0%88,! &*! eek!
?843>>l1=+'8!5=;*5&0@!!3*9!!bN!k!!?%F;30!!=::=+4;*&4&%8!!5=77&88&=*%+!!3*9!!=7<;9873*Z8!!
!
*
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
bL!
_024"(*:
.**f("6(P'0,$*,+*'7(*0$U,&U(-($'*,+*)0++("($'*2",4P%*,+*#6',"%*0$*'7(*P"(P#"#'0,$*,+*'7(*)0%-0%>
%#&@P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$;*G$*,")("*',*),*l4%'06(*',*'7(*)0U("%0'V*,+*%60($'0+06*L,"M*%0'4#'0,$%8*%(U("#&*
#$%L("%*6,4&)*Y(*'06M()*0+8*+,"*(T#-P&(8*'7("(*L("(*'7,%(*#-,$2*'7(*6,&&(#24(%*L7,*%4PP,"'()8*
'7,%(*L7,*"(-#0$()*$(4'"#&8*#%*L(&&*#%*'7,%(*L7,*#6'0U(&V*#6'()*#2#0$%'*'7(*#664%()*P("%,$;*
!
$k=:8*-4&'0P&(*"(%P,$%(%*P,%%0Y&(*
!
=>>&5%@!=>!4/%!J538%8K,!4/%!+%8:=*9%*48!8434%9!4/34!4/%!+%8:%54&H%!<=9&%8!1%+%!%&4/%+!*=4!
&*H=0H%9!&*!4/%!:+=5%%9&*)8!=+!4=='!8&9%8!3*9!4/%+%<B!4=='!3!:=8&4&=*!3)3&*84!4/%!355;8%9!
:+=>%88=+E!
§
2/%!+=0%!=>!84;9%*48,!9=54=+30!84;9%*48!3*9!:=849=58Q
!P*!4/%!7%9&3!+%:=+48,!&4!&8!73&*0B!4/%!
355;834&=*8!3*9!5=7:03&*48!>+=7!4/%8%!)+=;:8!4/34!3+%!5&4%9!38!+%38=*8!>=+!9&87&8830!=+!
9%7=4&=*E!2/%!+%8;048!=>!=;+!84;9B!8/=1!3!7=+%!9&>>%+%*4&34%9!:&54;+%Q!304/=;)/!84;9%*48,!
9=54=+30!84;9%*48! 3*9!:=849=58! 1%+%! &*H=0H%9! &*! 8=7%! J538%8K,! =>4%*! 4/%B! 1%+%!*=4!&*G
H=0H%9!34!300E!P*!4/%!J538%8K!1/%+%!4/%B!1%+%!&*H=0H%9,!4/%B!354%9!&*!+=;)/0B!%F;30!7%38;+%!
38!5=7:03&*3*48!3*9!8;::=+4%+8!=>!4/%!355;8%9E!
!
!
!
!
0 % 20 % 40 % 60 % 80 % 100 %
!"#$%&"'(%)(%!%&"*"+,&
-,(.'/,#&/ +0'1'!"*22'*!!,/+* "+,&
),!"$,/!
345!
678#$!7*&9!'622+/%'1':(8+"(*"+,&';,77+!!+,&
/,00%*<#%!'=!*7%'0%>%0?
)%(7*&%&"'!/+%&"+2+/'!"*22
%@#*0',)),( "#&+"A'8,$A
$%*&%(A '1'$%)*(" 7%&"'7*&*<%7%&"
*$7+&+! "(*" +,&'=BCD'0%<*0'$%)ED'%"/E?
(%/" ,(*"%'1 ')(%!+$ %&/A
acting aga inst me were not involve d don't know neutral helpful/supported me
!"#$%&%$'"($)*+),&)-.)$/0)$1"22"#&-3$&-/),-42$5"%&)6$7$4./",6$&-$."--)./&"-$#&/0$'"(,$%&68&6642$7$+(52&.$%)8"/&"-9$
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
bM!
^!`=*50;8&=*Q!-*30B8&8!=>!3!84+;54;+%!=>!>3&0;+%!
!
"#$%&#'()'%'*+%&,-.%/()0'12334)(&56'
78.2'1%/#-9':)5;%5<'&.#'=2()&'(-'&.%&'>'1%)?&'-&%)@'A%+*'BC++#/'%)5'32/#9''
>'/#%++5'1%)?&'-&%)@'.(3'%)532/#9'>&';%-'%'3(-&%D#'*/23'&.#'-&%/&''
&2'32E#'()';(&.'.(39'F#'.%-'&2'029'8(++'524'&%D#'.(-'/223GH'
78#++<'>?@'+2E#'&2<'$4&'&.%&?-')2&';.5'>'.%E#'&2999H'
7I.#)'(&?-'-#&&+#@9'>?++'&%D#'1%/#'2*'(&9'"#32/%+(-%&(2)'(-'&.#'2/@#/'2*'&.#'@%59''
I%1&(1-<'-&/%&#05'%)@'&.%&?-'(&9H'
JKE#)'A#0#)#/'JLMMNO9'P#4#'Q%./'KC@<'=9'LMRO'
!
(H%+B!9&87&8830!=+!:;<0&5!9%7=4&=*!=>!3!:+=>%88=+!&*&4&300B!3::%3+8!38!3*!&*9&H&9;30!538%!4/34!
&8!5=7:0%6,!7;04&G03B%+%9!3*9!9&>>&5;04!4=!:%*%4+34%!>+=7!4/%!=;48&9%E!W%54=+8!3*9!:+%8&9%*48!
=>!3539%7&5!&*84&4;4&=*8!3+%!5=*8&9%+%9!4=!/3H%!3!/&)/!9%)+%%!=>!+34&=*30&4B,!=<O%54&H&4B!3*9!
+%38=*G!3*9! %H&9%*5%G<38%9!O;9)%7%*4E!P4!&8!)%*%+300B!388;7%9!4/34!4/%B!73'%!4/%&+!9%5&G
8&=*8!3>4%+!53+%>;0!5=*8&9%+34&=*!3*9!>=00=1!G!38!4/%!/%39!=>!3!85&%*4&>&5!&*84&4;4&=*!G!1/34!4/%!
A%+73*!U%9%+30!`=*84&4;4&=*30!`=;+4!/38!9%>&*%9!38!85&%*4&>&5!:+=5%9;+%,!*37%0B!J1/34!&8!4=!
<%!+%)3+9%9!38!3!8%+&=;8!3*9!:03**%9!344%7:4!4=!&*H%84&)34%!4/%!4+;4/!&*!4%+78!=>!5=*4%*4!3*9!
>=+7K!?I%+*873**,!#L#L,!:E!NbN@E!2/&8!8;))%848!4/34!3!9&87&88%9!=+!:;<0&50B!9%7=4%9!:+=G
>%88=+!7;84!&*9%%9!/3H%!9=*%!8=7%4/&*)!8%+&=;8!4/34!O;84&>&%8!8;5/!3*!%853034&=*!=>!4/%!%7G
:0=B7%*4!+%034&=*8/&:!G!1/%+%!4/%+%Z8!87='%,!4/%+%Z8!>&+%,!38!4/%!=09!83B&*)!)=%8E!2/&8!&8!308=!
4+;%!&*!4/%!538%8!;*9%+!&*H%84&)34&=*,!<;4!&*!3!9&>>%+%*4!13B!4/3*!%6:%54%9E!
!
`=*4+3+B!4=!4/%!>&+84!&7:+%88&=*!=>!8%%7&*)0B!9&>>%+%*4!&*9&H&9;30!538%8,!4/%!+%8;048!=>!4/&8!84;9B!
=*!9&87&88308! 3*9! :;<0&5! 9%7=4&=*8! =>! >%730%! :+=>%88=+8! 8/=1!8;+:+&8&*)0B! >+%F;%*4!5=7G
7=*30&4&%8!=*!3!84+;54;+30!3*9!3+);7%*434&H%!0%H%0E!2/%!)+%34%84!5=77=*30&4B!&8!>=;*9!&*!4/%!
8B84%734&5!9&8+%)3+9!=>!+;0%G=>G031!:+&*5&:0%8!&*!4/%!&*4%+*30!:+=5%9;+%8!=>!+%0%H3*4!3539%7&5!
&*84&4;4&=*8!&*!+%034&=*!4=!300!4/%!J538%8K!&*H%84&)34%9E!2/&8!8/%98!0&)/4!=*!4/%!=*%!/3*9!=*!4/%!
:%+8=**%0!73*3)%7%*4!&*!9%30&*)!1&4/!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8!34!;*&H%+8&4&%8!3*9!+%8%3+5/!&*84&G
4;4&=*8,!3*9! =*! 4/%!=4/%+! /3*9!=*! 4/%! %6:+%88%9!0%)30! ;*9%+843*9&*)!=>! 4/%!73*3)%7%*4E!
2/%!:+=5%9;+%8! &*! 4/%! J538%8K! &*H%84&)34%9! 3::%3+!3+<&4+3+B!3*9!=:3F;%,! 3*9! 4/%!+%38=*8!
)&H%*!>=+!9&87&8830!=+!9%7=4&=*!5=*84+;54%9!1&4/!9%4+&7%*430!&*4%*4,!84+34%)&5300B!3*9!4354&5300B!
9%8&)*%9!>=+!%0&7&*34&=*!3*9!9&8384+=;8!&*!4/%&+!%>>%54!=*!4/=8%!3>>%54%9E!2/%!+%8;048!8;))%84!
4/34!4/%!3<=H%G7%*4&=*%9!>&+%,!1/&5/!;*9%+0&%8!300!87='%,!&8!4=!<%!>=;*9!3<=H%!300!&*!4/%!;*&G
H%+8&4B! 84+;54;+%8! 3*9! 4/%! 8=5&=G:=0&4&530! 8%44&*)! &*! 1/&5/! +%8%3+5/! 3*9! 4%35/&*)! 5;++%*40B!
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
b#!
=:%+34%E!2/%B!=<H&=;80B!300=1!4/%!'&*9!=>!9%5&8&=*8!4/34!53*!<%!>=;*9!&*!3<<+%H&34%9!>=+7!&*!
4/%!%:&43:/!4=!4/&8!5/3:4%+Q!8=7%=*%!J9=%8*K4!>&4K!3*9!7;84!0%3H%E!
!
I/34!:+354&530!5=*50;8&=*8!53*!<%!9+31*!>+=7!4/%!>&*9&*)8!=>!4/&8!84;9BR!2/%!3*81%+!4=!4/&8!
F;%84&=*!&8!3*B4/&*)!<;4!4+&H&30,!38!&4!4=;5/%8!=*!3! 5=7:0%6! 1%<! &*!1/&5/!4/%!9%73*98!3*9!
+=0%8!=>!:+=>%88=+8/&:8,!84;9%*48!3*9!B=;*)!3539%7&58,!;*&H%+8&4&%8!3*9!+%8%3+5/!&*84&4;4&=*8,!
&*84&4;4&=*8!3*9!8=5&%4B!3+%!;:!>=+!9&85;88&=*!3*%1E!2/%!13B!&*!1/&5/!&*84&4;4&=*8,!84+;54;+%8,!
:+=5%88%8!3*9! :+=5%9;+%8! 3+%! ;*9%+84==9! &*!3! 8=5&%4B! 9%:%*98! 03+)%0B! =*!4/%! ;*9%+0B&*)!
&9%3!=>! 4/34! 8=5&%4BE! 2/%! >&*9&*)8!=>!4/&8!84;9B!9%7=*84+34%!4/34!4/%!4+3*8>=+7%9!5=*9&4&=*8!
;*9%+!1/&5/!85&%*5%!3*9!&48!&*84&4;4&=*8!=:%+34%!/3H%!=:%*%9!;:!*%1!85=:%!>=+!5/3*)%!53*!
<%!;8%9!4=!4/%!9&839H3*43)%!=>!?>%730%@!:+=>%88=+8E!P4!8%%78!;+)%*4!4=!+%7%9B!4/&8!8&4;34&=*E!
!
[&4%+34;+%!
!"#$%&'()**+,-.+,/0%&"1+,2.,3,4##5)&6+,2.,789:;<.,=!&#,5>1"*,-?@6'"1"*6",A)1?"+,#$%5)$%"+,%'&BC
&D#",E"#"*F.,G*?"1H'"5,('?,I"**"?%,E"#?%@"#.,
J"K@L&'M
+,8N.9O.89:;.,,
/D@16'"@+,P.,789:9<.,QMD*D('#$%"#,I)K'?)&,R,I@&?@1"&&"#,I)K'?)&,R,-DA')&"#,I)K'?)&.,G*,2.,I'(('C
#$%+,-.,-$%)%)6)?.,3,S.,T)@#$%'&6,7"6#.<+,
I@&?@1?%"D1'",
7-.,8U:R8VU<.,/'"&"B"&6W,?1)*#$1'K?.,,
/@$%%D1*+,X.,3,Y1"'#'*Z"1+,[.,\.,78989<.,\'##'D*W,J@B(D16.,
()*)Z"1,()Z)A'*
+,8+,V]RVV.,,
/@6"+,T.,7899O<.,Y)&&1"MD*#?1@M?'D*.,G*,J.,/D%*#)$M+,E.,\)1D?AM',3,\.,\"@#"1,7"6#.<+,
T)@K?L"C
Z1'BB",^@)&'?)?'H"1,-DA')&BD1#$%@*Z,
7-.,_9R_:<.,4K&)6"*W,`"#M",a,/@61'$%.,,
b1)5BD16+,b.,\.,7"6.<.,789:;<.,
bD*B1D*?'*Z,)$)6"('$,(DLL'*Z,'*,%'Z%"1,"6@$)?'D*
.,T"1#%"c+,P!W,
G[G,[&DL)&.,,
b1D@$%+,b.,789:U<.,2'",L"A'BB"1?",E"&?.,E'",6'",`DZ'M,6"1,Y'*)*A(>1M?",6)#,E'##"*,L"61D%?.,/"1C
&'*W,-@%1M)(K.,,
2",-D@#),-)*?D#+,/.,7:;VU<.,`)5W,!,\)K,DB,\'#1")6'*Z.,SD5)16#,),PD#?(D6"1*,bD*$"K?'D*,DB,
`)5.,
dD@1*)&,DB,`)5,)*6,-D$'"?c+,:]
7O<+,8U;RO98.,,
2D*)&6#D*+,S., 3,P1"#?D*+,`., 7:;;N<.,S%", #?)M"%D&6"1,?%"D1c, DB,?%", $D1KD1)?'D*.,bD*$"K?#+,"H'C
6"*$",)*6,'(K&'$)?'D*#.,
!$)6"(c,DB,\)*)Z"("*?,J"H'"5+,89
7:<+,_NR;:.,,
X&&)16C[1)c+,!.+,d"BB1"c+,e.,I.+,b%D@L)M+,\.,3,b1)**+,-.,X.,789:N<.,Y'*6'*Z,?%",%'66"*,K)1?'$'K)*?.,
-D&@?'D*#, BD1, 1"$1@'?'*Z, %'66"*+, %)16C?DC1")$%+, )*6, H@&*"1)L&", KDK@&)?'D*#.,
G*?"1*)?'D*)&,
dD@1*)&,DB,^@)&'?)?'H",\"?%D6#+,:]
7N<+,:R:9.,,
Y"%1"*L)$%+, T.,[., 78989<., \)$%?('##L1)@$%, '*, 6"1,E'##"*#$%)B?., Y0*B, \c?%"*.,
YD1#$%@*Z,3,
`"%1"+,8U
7]<+,O88RO8].,,
YD16+,J.,S.,7:;;;<.,`)5f#,?"11'?D1c.,!,%'#?D1c,DB,g@1'#6'$?'D*.,
\'$%'Z)*,`)5,J"H'"5+,;U
7]<+,V]OR;O9.,,
Y1'"6()*+,\., 7:;U9<., S%",#D$')&, 1"#KD*#'L'&'?c, DB, L@#'*"##,'#, ?D, '*$1")#",'?#, K1DB'?#.,
e"5,hD1M,
S'("#,\)Z)A'*"
+,:O.9;.:;U9.,,
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
bX!
[DBB()*+,X.,7:;_U<.,
-?'Z().,
iL"1,S"$%*'M"*,6"1, /"5>&?'Z@*Z,L"#$%>6'Z?"1,G6"*?'?>?
.,
Y1)*MB@1?,
)(,\)'*W,-@%1M)(K.,,
T)1?()**+,\.,78998<.,2"1,\c?%D#,HD*,6"*,`"'#?@*Z#"&'?"*.,-K'?A"*M)11'"1"*,@*6,#DA')&",T"1M@*B?,
'*,E'1?#$%)B?+,PD&'?'M+,d@#?'A,@*6,E'##"*#$%)B?.,Y1)*MB@1?je"5,hD1MW,b)(K@#.,,
Tk1*&"+, S.,789:U<., E)1@(,l"1?1)@"*,'*,6'",e"@?1)&'?>?, 6"1,d@#?'A, "'*, #$%0?A"*#5"1?"#,l"1B)#C
#@*Z#Z@?,'#?.,l"1B)##@*Z#L&DZ,m,4*,()??"1#,$D*#?'?@?'D*)&.,!LZ"1@B"*,)(,:V.9_.8989,HD*,
%??K#WjjH"1B)##@*Z#L&DZ.6"j5)1@(CH"1?1)@"*C'*C6'"C*"@?1)&'?)"?C6"1C, g@#?'AC"'*C#$%@"?A"*#C
5"1?"#CH"1B)##@*Z#Z@?C'#?j.,,
G?AMDH'$%+,h.+,!&?+,2.,3,2D&"H+,e.,78989<.,
S%",$%)&&"*Z"#,DB,)$)6"('$,'*$'H'&'?c
.,b%)(W,-K1'*Z"1,
e)?@1",-5'?A"1&)*6.,,
I"&&"1+,J.,789::<.,
2'#M@1#BD1#$%@*Z
.,E'"#L)6"*W,l-,l"1&)Z,B01,-DA')&5'##"*#$%)B?"*.,,
I'"#"1&'*Z+,!.,789:8<.,`"Z'?'()?'D*,6@1$%,l"1B)%1"*,7:;_;<.,G*,4.,d)%1)@#+,!.,e)##"%'+,\.,[1'A"&g+,
G.,-))M"+,b.,I'1$%("'"1,3,d.,\0&&"1,7T1#Z.<+,
`@%()**,T)*6L@$%.,`"L"*,R,E"1M,R,E'1M@*Z,
7-.,:]NR:N9<.,-?@??Z)1?W,d./.\"?A&"1.,,
ID&D6"g+,b.,789:U<.,\DLL'*Z.,X'*,P%>*D("*,'(,E)*6"&,6"1,n"'?.,
EG-4+,]9
7]<+,U:RV_.,,
`)6"*?%'*+,l., 789:V<., -?@6'"1B>%'ZM"'?., 2), &>@B?, "?5)#, Z)*A,#$%'"B.,
YD1#$%@*Z, 3,`"%1"+,8N
7U<+,
_8]R_8V.,
`)(*"M+,-.,3,I1"&&+,b.,789:_<.,
^@)&'?)?'H",-DA')&BD1#$%@*Z,
7_.,"6.<.,E"'*%"'(W,/"&?A.,,
`"#?"1+,d.,7"6.<.,789:O<.,
ED1MK&)$",L@&&c'*Z,'*,%'Z%"1,"6@$)?'D*
.,e"5,hD1MW,JD@?&"6Z".,`@%()**+,
e.,7:;_;<.,
`"Z'?'()?'D*,6@1$%,l"1B)%1"*.,
Y1)*MB@1?,)(,\)'*W,-@%1M)(K.,,
`@%()**+,e.,7:;;8<.,2'",/"DL)$%?@*Z,6"1,/"DL)$%?"1,'(,KD&'?'#$%"*,-c#?"(.,n@1,S%"D1'",6"1,
kBB"*?&'$%"*,\"'*@*Z.,G*,d.,E'&M",7"6.<+,QBB"*?&'$%",\"'*@*Z,7-.,UURV_<.,Y1"'L@1Z,7/1"'#Z)@<,
@.).W,!&L"1.,,
\)c1'*Z+,P.,789:_<.,
X'*B0%1@*Z,'*,6'",o@)&'?)?'H",-DA')&BD1#$%@*Z,
7_.,"6.<.,E"'*%"'(W,/"&?A.,,
\k&&"1+,b.,789:N<.,T"1M@*B?,A>%&?,7B)#?<,'(("1.,-DA')&",p*Z&"'$%%"'?"*,@*?"1,p*'H"1#'?>?#CK1DB"#C
#D1'**"*,@*6,CK1DB"##D1"*.,E"'*%"'(W,/"&?A.,,
e"@L"1Z"1+,4.,789:N<.,
\'M1DKD&'?'M,@*6,\D1)&,'*,41Z)*'#)?'D*"*,
78.,"6.<.,-?@??Z)1?W,`@$'@#,3,`@C
$'@#.,,
eDH)1?'#,7899:<.,-"q@"&&",/"&>#?'Z@*Z,@*6,\)$%?('##L1)@$%,)(,!1L"'?#K&)?A.,/)#"&W,-"&L#?H"1C
&)Z.,,
P1"HD#?+,b.,3,T@*?+,X.,789:V<.,/@&&c'*Z,)*6,(DLL'*Z,'*,)$)6"(".,!,&'?"1)?@1",1"H'"5.,
X@1DK")*,
-$'"*?'B'$,dD@1*)&
+,:]7V<+,:R:N.,,
J@L*"1+,d.,78989<.,2'",!*Z"M&)Z?"*.,
2GX,nXGS
+,O9.9:.8989+,O;.,
-)K"1",)@6",78998<.,=d"()*6,(@##,dD#"B,I.,H"1&"@(6"?,%)L"*F.,E'",E'##"*#$%)B?&"1,@(,'%1",
Xq'#?"*A,Z"L1)$%?,5"16"*,Mk**"*.,
YD1#$%@*Z,3,`"%1"
+,;7:9<+,N:VRN8O.,,
-$%'()*M+,p.,789:U<.,p*'H"1#'?>?#1"BD1("*,)&#,/)&)*$")M?W,E)1@(,@*6,5'",p*'H"1#'?>?#C&"'?@*Z"*,
2D@L&",S)&M,K1)M?'A'"1"*,(0##"*.,
/"'?1>Z",A@1,TD$%#$%@&BD1#$%@*Z
+,O;7:<+,N9R_9.,,
I2$("*J*K7&($L0$M(&.*X0%-0%%#&*#$)*P4Y&06*)(-,'0,$*,+*P",+(%%,"%*
!
!"#$%&#'()*+",-.
*/(0'"12(*34"*5,67%674&+,"%674$28*9:;*<#7"2#$28*=>?@?A?=*
b^!
-$%D&A+,b.,3,-?"'*+,l.,789:9<.,/'&6"1,HD*,p*'H"1#'?>?"*.,X'*,?1)*#)M?'D*#)*)&c?'#$%C,)Z"*?@1?%"DC
1"?'#$%"1,!*#)?A.,
/"?1'"L#5'1?#$%)B?&'$%",YD1#$%@*Z,@*6,P1)q'#+,
_878<+,:8;,R:];.,,
-'(D*+,J.C\.,789::<.,=d"()*6,(@##,P1DB"##D1,-.,H"1&"@(6"?,%)L"*,...F.,iL"1,"'*"*,-$%5"'A"1,
=YD1#$%@*Z##M)*6)&F.,
YD1#$%@*Z,3,`"%1"
+,:V7N<+,OUVROV9.,,
-(@?*c+,P.,789:U<.,\DLL'*Z,R,1"$%?&'$%",iL"1&"Z@*Z"*.,
EG-4+,
]97]<+,VUR:9].,S5)&"+,2.,d.,3,2",
`@$)+,/.,\.,7899V<.,
Y)$@&?c,'*$'H'&'?c.,S%",1'#",DB,?%",)$)6"('$,L@&&c,$@&?@1",)*6,5%)?,?D,6D,
)LD@?,'?.,
-)*,Y1)*$'#$DW,E'&"c.,
HD*,YD"1#?"1+,T.,7:;V]<.,
4L#"1H'*Z,#c#?"(#,
78.,"6.<.,-")#'6"W,G*?"1#c#?"(#,P@L&'$)?'D*#.,,
E/-,[1@KK".,789:;<.,Y1)@"*o@D?",)*,6"@?#$%"*,TD$%#$%@&"*,@*6,p*'H"1#'?>?"*.,T'"1,)1L"'?"*,
6'", ("'#?"*, P1DB"##D1'**"*., !LZ"1@B"*, )(, 9O.9V.8989, HD*, 555.5L#CZ1@KK"., 6"j'*C
6"q.K%Kr'6s::_.,,
E"1*#()**+,J.,78989<.,-c#?"()?'#$%",ID*?1D&&".,/1)@$%?,E'##"*#$%)B?,bD(K&')*$"r,
YD1#$%@*Z,
3,`"%1"+,
8U7U<+,NV]RNVN.,,
E"#?%@"#+,I.,7899_)<.,X*Hc,DB,"q$"&&"*$".,!6('*'#?1)?'H",(DLL'*Z,DB,%'Z%C)$%'"H'*Z,K1DB"##D1#.,
`"5'#?D*+,e"5,hD1MW,X65'*,\"&&"*,/DDM#.,,
E"#?%@"#+,I"**"?%,7899_L<.,S%",@*M'*6&c,)1?,DB,(DLL'*Z.,
!$)6"('$,\)??"1#
+,7Y)&&,899_<+,:VR:;.,,
h"@*Z+,d., b.,3, `@*+,l., \.Cb.,78989<., p*$1'?'$)&,@#", DB,*D*C"H'6"*$"CL)#"6, #"&BC%"&K,()?"1')&#,
'*6@$"#, H'$?'(CL&)('*Z, D*, ?%", 6"K1"##"6.,
dD@1*)&, DB, PD#'?'H", P#c$%D&DZc+,
24GW:9.:9V9j:U]O;U_9.8989.:UN8UV9.,,
n)KB+,2.,3,X'*)1#"*+,-.,78989<.,G*6'H'6@)&,)*?"$"6"*?#,DB,L@&&c'*Z.,G*,-.,X'*)1#"*+,T.,TD"&+,2.,n)KB,
3,b.,bDDK"1,7"6#.<+,
/@&&c'*Z,)*6,%)1)##("*?,'*,?%",5D1MK&)$",
7-.,8;]R,O9]<+,/D$),J)?D*W,
bJb,P1"##.,,
!
2/%!3;4/=+8!
a+=>E!c+E!$%&'%!()*%+,!/%&'%E%)*%+q)76E34,!111E/%&'%G%)*%+E*%4E!!
!
.*&HEGa+=>E!c+E!-*'%!./0%*1&*'%0,!a+=>%88=+!=>!c&9354&58!>=+!A%=)+3:/B!3*9!(5=*=7&58,!!
.*&H%+8&4B!=>!C30D<;+),!3*'%E;/0%*1&*'%0q8<)E35E34E!!
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.