ArticlePDF Available

Using the Working Model of Adjustment to Chronic Illness to explain the burden of recurrent urinary tract infection: A survey-based study

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Introduction The treatment of recurrent urinary tract infection (RUTI) with antibiotics is causing concern as patients are often prescribed an inappropriate course of antibiotics, and the recurrence rate remains at 30–44% following treatment (1). Overprescription of antibiotics can also cause antimicrobial resistance. Given the current lack of adequate clinical guidelines for RUTI treatment, it is necessary for this population to adjust to living with a chronic condition, and research suggests that RUTI may be associated with poor mental health and a lower quality of life. Thus, there is a need for a more interdisciplinary approach to understanding RUTI, to inform additional treatment options. Aim The current study aimed to use the Working Model of Adjustment to Chronic Illness (WMACI) (see Figure 1) to explore the personal, physical and social burden of RUTI (2). Methods A cross-sectional survey was employed, which was informed by existing questionnaires and reviewed by experts including pain specialists (n = 6). 5,078 participants accessed liveutifree.com to seek information regarding their condition and completed the Live UTI Free survey. Participants provided information on their experiences with RUTI (recurrence rate, symptoms, pain intensity, triggers and comorbidity) and the associated burden. Binomial logistic regressions were conducted to assess the effect of RUTI characteristics on the likelihood of experiencing personal, physical and social burden. Results RUTI predicted greater likelihood of personal burden (enjoyment of life; enjoyment of favourite activities; mental health) (R² = 18.8 – 20.8, p = <.001), physical burden (sleep; activities of daily living; maintaining a healthy lifestyle; sexual behaviour) (R² = 21.1 – 35.9, p = <.001), and social burden (normal work; finances; relationships with friends and family; relationships with partners) (R² = 17.0 - 25.8, p = <.001), with the burden associated with sexual behaviour showing the largest amount of variance. Rate of recurrence, symptom burden, pain intensity, and having an additional diagnosis of Interstitial Cystitis (IC) were most predictive of participant burden. Conclusion RUTI was associated with all areas of burden. Some factors, including pain intensity and having an additional diagnosis of IC, affected a majority of areas. Predicted burden from having an additional diagnosis of IC may be a result of lack of clarity between the two diagnoses, which have shared symptom indicators and rely on urine culture testing, which has been demonstrated to be inaccurate. Misdiagnosis, or a dual diagnosis, may consequently contribute to burden. The WMACI was used to suggest how burden can lead to poor illness adjustment. Limitations of the study were that it did not explore the possibility of misdiagnosis and its impact, or investigate the effects of SES and country-level differences. However, the findings of the study have important clinical implications, as patients worldwide who are suffering with RUTI are required to manage significant burden that is associated with the condition, and this is an important issue which needs to be addressed in primary care settings. An interdisciplinary approach in primary care settings is recommended, which acknowledges the psychosocial burden that persists when treatment fails to resolve physical symptoms. References 1. Gupta K, Trautner BW. Diagnosis and management of recurrent urinary tract infections in non-pregnant women. BMJ (Online). 2013; 346: f3140. 2. Moss-Morris R. Adjusting to chronic illness: Time for a unified theory. British Journal of Health Psychology. 2013; 681–686.
Content may be subject to copyright.
International Journal of Pharmacy Practice, 2021, Vol. 29, No. S1 i5
services, service users were a similar age (mean 68years), but
were taking more medications (mean 3.6 versus 2.8), were
more often female (64.1% versus 54.2%), had higher educa-
tional attainment, and had higher GP visitrates.
Controlling for other factors, the following were associated
with a high likelihood of availing of pharmacy services: female
gender (odds ratio (OR) 1.32, 95%CI 1.14–1.52), third level edu-
cation (OR 1.85, 95%CI 1.51–2.27), higher rates of GP visits,
private health insurance (OR 1.29, 95%CI 1.07–1.56), higher
number of medications, loneliness, and a diagnosed respiratory
condition (OR 1.42, 95% CI 1.14–1.74). The relationship be-
tween these factors and requesting medicines advice were similar.
Conclusion: A high proportion of middle-aged and older
adults visit community pharmacy and a quarter avail of speci-
ed pharmacy services. Despite advances in the services offered
in pharmacies, medicines advice remains at the core of pharma-
cists’ practice. Those on multiple medications, who may derive
greater benet from such services, are more likely to avail of
them. Number of GP visits was also associated with service use,
suggesting patients may avail of pharmacy services as a com-
plement, rather than a substitute, to visiting their GP. Services
were more often used by people who are lonely, and pharma-
cists should consider interventions to support these people.
PATIENT AND HEALTHCARE PRACTITIONER
PERSPECTIVES
USING THE WORKING MODEL OF ADJUSTMENT TO
CHRONIC ILLNESS TO EXPLAIN THE BURDEN OF RE-
CURRENT URINARY TRACT INFECTION: A SURVEY-
BASED STUDY
K.Maxwell1, L.Roberts2, M.Kramer3 and K.Finlay4, 1.
University of Buckingham, Buckingham, UK. 2. Oxford
University Hospitals, Oxford, UK. 3. Live UTI Free. 4.
University of Reading, Reading, UK.
Introduction: The treatment of recurrent urinary tract infec-
tion (RUTI) with antibiotics is causing concern as patients are
often prescribed an inappropriate course of antibiotics, and the
recurrence rate remains at 30–44% following treatment (1).
Overprescription of antibiotics can also cause antimicrobial re-
sistance. Given the current lack of adequate clinical guidelines for
RUTI treatment, it is necessary for this population to adjust to
living with a chronic condition, and research suggests that RUTI
may be associated with poor mental health and a lower quality
of life. Thus, there is a need for a more interdisciplinary approach
to understanding RUTI, to inform additional treatment options.
Aim: The current study aimed to use the Working Model
of Adjustment to Chronic Illness (WMACI) (see Figure 1)to
explore the personal, physical and social burden of RUTI (2).
Methods: A cross-sectional survey was employed, which was
informed by existing questionnaires and reviewed by experts
including pain specialists (n=6). 5,078 participants accessed
liveutifree.com to seek information regarding their condition
and completed the Live UTI Free survey. Participants provided
information on their experiences with RUTI (recurrence rate,
symptoms, pain intensity, triggers and comorbidity) and the as-
sociated burden. Binomial logistic regressions were conducted
to assess the effect of RUTI characteristics on the likelihood of
experiencing personal, physical and social burden.
Results: RUTI predicted greater likelihood of personal burden
(enjoyment of life; enjoyment of favourite activities; mental
health) (R²=18.8 – 20.8, p=<.001), physical burden (sleep;
activities of daily living; maintaining a healthy lifestyle; sexual
behaviour) (R² = 21.1 – 35.9, p = <.001), and social burden
(normal work; nances; relationships with friends and family;
relationships with partners) (R²=17.0 - 25.8, p=<.001), with
the burden associated with sexual behaviour showing the lar-
gest amount of variance. Rate of recurrence, symptom burden,
pain intensity, and having an additional diagnosis of Interstitial
Cystitis (IC) were most predictive of participant burden.
Conclusion: RUTI was associated with all areas of burden.
Some factors, including pain intensity and having an add-
itional diagnosis of IC, affected a majority of areas. Predicted
burden from having an additional diagnosis of IC may be a
result of lack of clarity between the two diagnoses, which have
shared symptom indicators and rely on urine culture testing,
which has been demonstrated to be inaccurate. Misdiagnosis,
or a dual diagnosis, may consequently contribute to burden.
The WMACI was used to suggest how burden can lead to
poor illness adjustment. Limitations of the study were that it
did not explore the possibility of misdiagnosis and its impact,
or investigate the effects of SES and country-level differences.
However, the ndings of the study have important clinical im-
plications, as patients worldwide who are suffering with RUTI
are required to manage signicant burden that is associated
with the condition, and this is an important issue which needs
to be addressed in primary care settings. An interdisciplinary
approach in primary care settings is recommended, which ac-
knowledges the psychosocial burden that persists when treat-
ment fails to resolve physical symptoms.
Figure 1: The Working Model of Adjustment to Chronic
Illness
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ijpp/article/29/Supplement_1/i5/6188870 by guest on 28 October 2022
i6 International Journal of Pharmacy Practice, 2021, Vol. 29, No. S1
References
1. Gupta K, Trautner BW. Diagnosis and management of re-
current urinary tract infections in non-pregnant women.
BMJ (Online). 2013; 346:f3140.
2. Moss-Morris R.Adjusting to chronic illness: Time for a unied
theory. British Journal of Health Psychology. 2013; 681–686.
AN EXPLORATION OF COMMUNITY PHARMACISTS’
EXPERIENCE, KNOWLEDGE AND PERSPECTIVES OF
FRAILTY AND MEDICINES OPTIMISATION IN FRAIL
OLDER PEOPLE: A QUALITATIVE STUDY
L.Faulkner, C.M.Hughes and H.E.Barry, Primary Care
Research Group, School of Pharmacy, Queen’s University
Belfast, Belfast, UK
Introduction: Frailty is a heightened state of vulnerability
due to an accumulation of age-related defects in separate
physiological systems (1). Frailty is becoming increasingly
common, with up to 50% of older adults being diagnosed
with mild, moderate or severe frailty (35%, 12% and 3%
respectively) (2). Community pharmacists may often be
the primary healthcare professional with whom frail older
people have most frequent contact due to their convenience
and accessibility. Therefore, it is hypothesised that commu-
nity pharmacists could play a wider role in frailty identica-
tion and medicines optimisation for frail older people.
Aim: To explore community pharmacists’ knowledge of frailty
and its assessment, their experiences and contact with frail older
patients in the community pharmacy setting, and their percep-
tions of their role in optimising medicines for frail older people.
Methods: Two strategies were used to recruit community phar-
macists registered in Northern Ireland (NI). Community pharma-
cists were recruited through the Pharmacy Forum NI bi-monthly
newsletter and the School of Pharmacy Undergraduate Placement
Network, followed by snowballing. The interview topic guide
was developed based on the published literature, current frailty
guidelines and through discussion within the research team; it
was piloted with four pharmacists. Semi-structured interviews
commenced in March 2020. Due to the Covid-19 pandemic,
face-to-face interviews were logistically not possible, therefore
telephone interviews were conducted at a time convenient to par-
ticipants. All interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim and
analysed using inductive thematic analysis.
Table 1. Characteristics of interview participants and the
community pharmacies in which they worked(n=14)
Participant characteristics n (%)
Female 9 (64.3)
Male 5 (35.7)
Time qualied in years n (%)
<5
5 to 9
10 to 15
>15
4 (28.6)
1 (7.1)
5 (35.7)
4 (28.6)
Location of pharmacy n (%)
Urban
Suburban
Rural
7 (50)
4 (28.6)
3 (21.4)
Size of pharmacy n (%)
Independent
Small/medium chain
Large chain
5 (35.7)
2 (14.3)
7 (50)
Results: To date, 14 interviews have been conducted,
lasting between 24 and 72 minutes. Apart from one inter-
view, all were conducted over the telephone. Participant char-
acteristics are summarised in Table 1. Analysis of interview
transcripts is ongoing. Findings to date have highlighted the
key role community pharmacists feel they play in assisting
frail older patients with their medicines (especially during
the current pandemic). Many saw themselves as a ‘point of
contact’ for frail older people and highlighted the holistic ap-
proaches they used to care of such patients: “It’s easier to get
in contact with us than other healthcare professionals and we
tend to be the rst port of call really [CP2]. Interviews high-
lighted a lack of pharmacist knowledge surrounding frailty
as a condition and its assessment, with participants primarily
focusing on the physical aspects of frailty (e.g. weight loss,
weakness) when observing or ‘informally assessing’ patients.
None of the participants reported formally assessing their
patients using validated frailty tools or checklists: “It’s not
something that I’ve ever thought about. We don’t have any
tools readily available to us that I know of and certainly
nothing that would be standardised [CP1].
Conclusion: This study has highlighted that community
pharmacists felt they could contribute to optimising medi-
cines for frail older people. However, the ndings emphasise
the need for more formal training for community pharma-
cists about the clinical aspects of frailty, frailty assessment
and future interventions to address the medicines-related
issues they have encountered with this patient population.
References
1. Shaw RL, Gwyther H, Holland C, Bujnowska M, Kurpas
D, Cano A, et al. Understanding frailty: meanings and
beliefs about screening and prevention across key stake-
holder groups in Europe. Ageing & Society. 2018;38(6):
1223–1252.
2. Hollinghurst J, Fry R, Akbari A, Clegg A, Lyons RA,
Watkins A, et al. External validation of the electronic
Frailty Index using the population of Wales within the
Secure Anonymised Information Linkage Databank. Age
and Ageing. 2019;48(6): 922–926.
A QUALITATIVE STUDY EXPLORING PATIENT
SUGGESTIONS FOR THE DESIGN, FUNCTIONALITY
AND IMPLEMENTATION OF DIGITAL HEALTH
TECHNOLOGIES BEFORE AND AFTER BARIATRIC
SURGERY.
A.Robinson1,2, A.K.Husband1,2, R.D.Slight2,3 and
S.P.Slight1,2,3,4,5, 1. School of Pharmacy, Newcastle
University, UK. 2. Population Health Sciences Institute,
Newcastle University, UK. 3. Newcastle upon Tyne
Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, UK. 4. The Centre for
Patient Safety Research and Practice, Division of General
Internal Medicine and Primary Care, Brigham and Women’s
Hospital, USA. 5. Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA.
Introduction: Health behaviour changes made
during the pre-operative period can positively impact on
post-operative outcomes and the success of bariatric sur-
gery.(1) Digital technologies present an opportunity to
support patients with this. Currently, little is known about
the optimal design or delivery of digital technologies for
this patient cohort. In order to develop useful and effective
digital strategies for this unique patient cohort, it is im-
portant to rst understand how bariatric surgery patients
want to be supported.(2)
Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ijpp/article/29/Supplement_1/i5/6188870 by guest on 28 October 2022
... 42 Over a decade ago, Birmingham and Ashe 43 reviewed the literature on the impact of UTIs on quality of life and found that across 12 studies UTIs had a detrimental effect across all aspects of life. Since then, additional studies have shown a decreased overall quality of life in women who suffer from UTIs, including an impact on mental health, 38,44 sexual activity, 45 everyday activities, 38,44,46 and severity based on UTI incidence. 38,44,47 The study of these three infections differs often using different questionnaires and including different popula tions (Tables 1 and 2). ...
... Since then, additional studies have shown a decreased overall quality of life in women who suffer from UTIs, including an impact on mental health, 38,44 sexual activity, 45 everyday activities, 38,44,46 and severity based on UTI incidence. 38,44,47 The study of these three infections differs often using different questionnaires and including different popula tions (Tables 1 and 2). For example, UTI and VVC studies use the Short Form (SF)36 questionnaire which is a vali dated quality of life survey that measures physical, social, and psychological aspects through 36 questions, 48 while BV studies do not ( Table 2). ...
... Ennis et al. 41 used the SF36 questionnaire to compare the results from patients with rUTI to those from the general population adjusted for age, gender, and ethnicity. They found that pain had the highest impact on overall quality of life 41 In fact, Ciani et al. 45 found that women with UTIs are in significantly more pain than healthy individuals, and Maxwell et al. 44 found that pain, rate of recurrence, and symptom burden had the greatest effect on an rUTI wom en's overall quality of life. ...
Article
Full-text available
Recurrent urogenital infections such as bacterial vaginosis, vulvovaginal candidiasis, and urinary tract infections have a high prevalence and pronounced psychosocial impact. However, no review has compared the psychosocial impacts across infection types. This narrative review discusses the impact of common recurrent urogenital infections on psychosocial aspects, including quality of life, stress, mental health, sexual health, work productivity, race and ethnicity, and satisfaction of medical care. Validated questionnaires show that women with recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis and urinary tract infections have decreased scores on all aspects of quality of life. Those with recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis and urinary tract infections show lower mental health scores compared to the general population, with increased risk of anxiety and depression. Recurrent urogenital infections affect sexual relationships and intimacy, including avoidance due to symptoms or as a method of prevention. Recurrent infections also increase medical cost and negatively affect work productivity, leading to a combined estimated cost of over US$13 billion per year. There are clear effects of racial inequality involving minority populations that affect diagnosis, treatment, prevalence, and reporting of recurrent urogenital infections. Satisfactory medical treatment improves quality of life and mental health in those suffering from these conditions. Research evaluating psychosocial aspects of recurrent urogenital infections is variable and is not comparable across vulvovaginal conditions. Even so, psychosocial factors are important in understanding contribution and consequence of urogenital infections. Education, awareness, normalization, community support, and access to care can help to alleviate the negative implications of recurrent urogenital infections.
... 70 Another survey found that recurrent UTIs were not only associated with physical impact on sleep and healthy lifestyle, but with mental health burdens, such as anxiety and depression, and also with damage to women's social relationships with colleagues, family, and friends. 71 Furthermore, lower urinary tract symptom-induced depression has been found to worsen the perception of physical symptoms, resulting in a vicious cycle. 72 A more recent study even found that self-esteem was significantly impacted and that social functions were more severely affected than physical functions in women with recurrent UTIs, emphasizing the need for future studies to include quality-of-life measures when determining the effectiveness of UTI management strategies. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article aims to bring clinicians’ awareness to the widespread impact of urinary tract infection (UTI) on the lives of women and to the advances that offer hope for future improvements in the diagnosis and management of UTI. Thanks to physiological, anatomical, and lifestyle factor differences, women face heightened vulnerability to UTIs compared to men. In fact, women are four times more likely than men to develop a UTI and around half of these women encounter UTI recurrence, which is a significant source of both physical and psychosocial burdens. Despite the current shortcomings in diagnosis and management, emerging diagnostic technologies promise to identify UTIs more accurately and rapidly, offering women hope for a revolution in UTI management. Meanwhile, clinicians have the opportunity to reduce the psychosocial burden by recognizing the value of patients’ lived experiences and ensuring their care plan is in alignment with their patients’ goals and expectations for medical care.
Article
Full-text available
Background: frailty has major implications for health and social care services internationally. The development, validation and national implementation of the electronic Frailty Index (eFI) using routine primary care data has enabled change in the care of older people living with frailty in England. Aims: to externally validate the eFI in Wales and assess new frailty-related outcomes. Study design and setting: retrospective cohort study using the Secure Anonymised Information Linkage (SAIL) Databank, comprising 469,000 people aged 65-95, registered with a SAIL contributing general practice on 1 January 2010. Methods: four categories (fit; mild; moderate and severe) of frailty were constructed using recognised cut points from the eFI. We calculated adjusted hazard ratios (HRs) from Cox regression models for validation of existing outcomes: 1-, 3- and 5-year mortality, hospitalisation, and care home admission for validation. We also analysed, as novel outcomes, 1-year mortality following hospitalisation and frailty transition times. Results: HR trends for the validation outcomes in SAIL followed the original results from ResearchOne and THIN databases. Relative to the fit category, adjusted HRs in SAIL (95% CI) for 1-year mortality following hospitalisation were 1.05 (95% CI 1.03-1.08) for mild frailty, 1.24 (95% CI 1.21-1.28) for moderate frailty and 1.51 (95% CI 1.45-1.57) for severe frailty. The median time (lower and upper quartile) between frailty categories was 2,165 days (lower and upper quartiles: 1,510 and 2,831) from fit to mild, 1,155 days (lower and upper quartiles: 756 and 1,610) from mild to moderate and 898 days (lower and upper quartiles: 584 and 1,275) from moderate to severe. Conclusions: further validation of the eFI showed robust predictive validity and utility for new outcomes.
Article
Full-text available
Innovative methods to manage frailty are critical to managing the needs of an ageing population. Evidence suggests there are opportunities to reverse or prevent frailty through early intervention. However, little is known about older adults’, families’ and practitioners’ beliefs about the malleability of frailty. This study examined European stakeholders’ accounts of the acceptability and feasibility of frailty screening and prevention to inform future intervention development. Semi-structured focus groups and individual interviews were conducted in three European Union countries (Italy, Poland and the United Kingdom) with key stakeholders – frail and non-frail older adults, family care-givers, and health and social care professionals. Thematic analysis identified four themes: synchronicity between the physical and the psychological in frailty, living with frailty in the social world, the need for a new kind of care, and screening for and preventing frailty. Findings emphasised the need for a holistic approach to frailty care and early intervention. Integrated care services and advocacy were important in the organisation of care. Central to all stakeholders was the significance of the psychological and social alongside the physical elements of frailty and frailty prevention. Support and care for older adults and their family care-givers needs to be accessible and co-ordinated. Interventions to prevent frailty must encompass a social dimension to help older adults maintain a sense of self while building physical and psychological resilience.