Content uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill on Mar 27, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill on Mar 25, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill on Mar 25, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill on Mar 22, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dr Muhammad Sajjad Ali Gill on Mar 21, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Pakistan Social Sciences Review
December 2018, Vol. 2, No. 2 [312-319]
P-ISSN 2664-0422
O-ISSN 2664-0430
RESEARCH PAPER
Comparative Study of Male and Female Athletes about Effect of
Stretching Exercises on Flexibility
Sana Tallat 1Sajjad Ali Gill2Zain Arshad3
1. Lecturer, Department of Sports Sciences and Physical Education, Govt. College for
Women Township Lahore, Punjab, Pakistan
2. Lecturer, Department of Sports Sciences and Physical Education, The University of
the Punjab, Lahore, Punjab, Pakistan
3. Student, Department of Sports Sciences and Physical Education, The University of the
Punjab, Lahore, Punjab, Pakistan
PAPER INFO
ABSTRACT
Received:
November 25, 2018
Accepted:
December 24, 2018
Online:
December 30, 2018
The present experimental research investigated the effectiveness
of the stretching exercises to flexibility and Eighty athletes
selected of age 18-24 years included (N=40) Female and (N=40)
male athletes selected from different Universities of Punjab. The
selected individuals divided into female and male group’s
separately along with 6 weeks training sessions, have stretching
protocol which included separate sessions along with warm-up
sessions. The six weeks stretching program showed
improvement of 2.8% in female group and 1.7% in the male
group respectively. The female stretching training revealed 1.1%
more improvement as compared with male group. A group of
control subjects (N=40) were also maintained for further
comparison. The flexibility was measured through sit and reach
test evaluated before training sessions as a pre-exercise and after
6 weeks as a post-exercise measurement. Pre and post-exercise
evaluation had been analyzed by paired sample test and effect
size of subjects also calculated through Cohen’s D resulted 1.41
and 3.55 respectively. The subjects were followed for 4 months
and check the recurrence rate of injuries, resulted 12.2% injuries
in control group subjects while intervention group showed 7%
and 9% respectively.
Keywords:
Flexibility,
Recurrence
Sit and Reach Test
Corresponding
Author
sajjad.sspe@pu.ed
u.pk
Introduction
Flexibility is defined as the range of motion, or movement around a
particular joint or set of joints in other words it allows a subject to bend or turn to
its max (Bernhart, 2013). During flexibility training the main emphasized on
muscles and their fascia (sheath),while bones, joints, ligaments, tendons and skin
do contribute to overall flexibility which has limited control over these factors
Pakistan Social Sciences Review (PSSR)
December, 2018 Volume 2, Issue 2
313
(Alter,2004). On the other hand, flexibility is different in every individual due to
change in their muscle length and multi-joint muscles. Stretching on daily basis
resulted change in characteristics of tissues and muscles within the body
(Behmand and Chaouachi, 2011). Other tissues begin to adapt to the stretching
process include the fascia, tendons, skin and scar tissue (Gleim& McHugh, 1997).
The stretching exercises are commonly done before or after exercise as it perceived
to loosen muscle, which allow muscle to go for workout condition by reducing
their risk of injury (Ingraham, 2003;McHugh & Cosgrave, 2010).
Athletes has special requirement when it comes to flexibility which is
common fitness component among female and male athletes which increase the
range of motion (ROM) of athlete’s around joints and muscles as well (Frederick
and Frederick, 2017).According to the proponents, an increase in the performance
of the flexibility before and after practice session or strength and conditioning
workout lead to an increase in athletic performance as well as reducing the
incidence of injury (Ingraham, 2003; McHugh & Cosgrave, 2010).It also increases
the muscle length and its range of motion. There are procedures and latest
techniques that exploit the doles and diminish the risk of injury (Manoel et al.,
2008).There are many different ways for strength training Similarly, many different
ways of stretching exercise (Olivieretal.,2016),which were not only one specific
way of stretching was better than other stretching exercise, each type has its own
rewards and difficulties, the most important stretching types is perfectly related to
the purpose or goals of a subject needs to achieved (Reese and Bandy, 2016).For
example, Ballistic stretching, dynamic stretching, PNF stretching static stretching
and etc. Consequently, athletes and coaches regularly include stretching exercises
in both training programs and in pre-event warm-up activities (Gleimand and
McHugh, 1997). However, Stretching is commonly used in sport as a method of
preparing the specific muscles to be used during the activity, as well as relaxing
the muscles following exercise (Anderson,2010). Upon undertaking a regular
stretching program, frequent changes begin to occur within the body and
specifically within the muscles itself as other tissues that begin to adapt the
stretching process include fascia, tendons, skin and scar tissue (Pamboris, 2018)
An individual performance depends upon a number of components i.e.
health related and skill related fitness and flexibility is an important factor among
these components. Although flexibility is an important physical fitness component
among others and it can be enhanced through regular exercise or training program
which also help to all the components of physical fitness (Singh, 2018). Flexibility is
directly proportional to the performance of athlete performance, if muscle is
excessively tight and not as strong as it can ideally be (Manoel et al., 2008). A weak
muscle did not put load and thus, another muscle or group of muscles must do
more work and becomes fatigued which put more load on the weak muscles. In
athletes, it leads to decreased speed of movement, decreased strength and power
which lead to injuries (Walsh, 2017). Regular flexibility training helps maintain
range of motion, strength of muscles and prevent injury therefore it is important to
Comparative Study of Male and Female Athletes about Effect of Stretching Exercises on Flexibility
314
stretch all major muscles group regularly before and after workout during training
session if you are an athlete(Norris, 2015). Stretching is commonly undertaken in
practice and matches as before and after performing in game or it can also be done
as part of training session as well which is suppose as a relaxation of muscles, that
prepared for a specific training session and helped in reduction of risk in sports
injury (McHugh and Cosgrave 2010). With stretching, subsequent gains in muscle
lengths which resulted in lead to improved recital and reduce recurrence of injury.
The scholar has evidence that male adaptation to fitness was better than female,
whereas female has been shown to reveal enhanced flexibility as compared with
male (Jan and Yaday, 2017). Additionally, the current study has examined the
changes over 6 weeks exercises resulted that, male athletes did not get as much as
values of range of motion (ROM) as female athletes do (Manoel et al., 2008). There
are number of researchers that conduced research on stretching exercises and
concluded that no effect could be calculated after static stretching exercises but
Proprioception Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF) exercises has strongly impacted
on the flexibility (Funk et al., 2003).
Hypothesis
The study hypothesized that comparison of male and female athletes about
effect of stretching exercise on flexibility (ROM) is an effective method to manage
the impact of flexibility and also cut down the injury rate.
Material and Methods
Eighty athletes were selected of age (18-25 years) which includes (N=40)
female athletes and (N=40) male athletes from university of Punjab, Lahore
campus. The method of study was an experimental with purposive sampling
technique was utilized. Additionally, athletes had no history of injuries in past 6
months or one year. To examine the hypothesis of the study, pre-experimental
design was used to examine the effect of stretching exercises on performance. The
Kolmogorov-Smirnovtest applied to the data and it was observed that data was
assumed to be slightly normal. The pre-exercise evaluation had been taken to get
the initial or started values through sit and reach test of flexibility. After 6weeks
stretching exercises program (SEP) and included separate stretching training
session as well. The stretching exercises divided into two training sessions (N=40)
of male athletes SEP and (N=40) of female athletes (SEP) that participated in this
research, while (N=40) subjects were taken as a control group including male and
female athletes to analyze the comparison of male and female athletes in
accordance to the stretching exercises on flexibility. Then the researcher conducted
pre-exercise evaluation (measurements) of male athletes (N=40) and female
athletes(N=40) that were enlisted in data collection program before starting of SEP
program. The test has been conducted without warm-up. For attain affective
results, the researcher designed two session of training program in which each
session keeps mixture of active static warm-up stretching protocol (ASWS) and
active dynamic warm-up stretching protocols (ADWS) to increase flexibility of the
subjects. Principal of progression specificity and overloading has been
Pakistan Social Sciences Review (PSSR)
December, 2018 Volume 2, Issue 2
315
implemented throughout the SEP. No one has been dropped from the sessions
throughout the study as shown in Figure 1.
Figure.1 Shows the flow chart of the Stretching Exercise Program (STP).
Shows the flowchart of the research, the data has been analyzed separately
as pre-exercise and post-exercise values evaluated through sit and reach test
evaluation. For both sessions the researcher selected at-least 8 dynamic stretching
exercises protocols and 15 static stretching exercise protocols for the subjects.
Fortnight, exercises has been added as per subject condition and situation. After 6
weeks training session program of male and female athletes the post-exercise
evaluation has been taken from the subjects that were participated in either
experimental group (N=80) or in control group (N=40) to check the improvement
in flexibility of athlete due to stretching exercise.
Results and Discussion
The experimental research descriptive techniques like frequency, mean,
median, standard deviation and inferential techniques with paired sample t-test
was applied and analyzed through statistical package for social sciences (SPSS)
version 22.0. The effect size was also calculated for the comparison.
Comparative Study of Male and Female Athletes about Effect of Stretching Exercises on Flexibility
316
Table 1
Showing Pre and Post-exercise values evaluated through paired sample t-test
along with difference, percentage t-value and p-value as well
Subjects
Male/Female
Pre-exercise Post-exercise
Diff
(%)
t-value
p-value
Cohens D
Male
45.8 ± 5.4 47.5± 5.5
1.7
(3.7)
-18.9
***
0.000
3.55
Female
42.4 ± 7.4 45.2 ± 6.9
2.8
(6.6)
-7.6
***
0.000
1.41
***p<0.001 highly significant
The pre and post exercise values (Male) showed difference of 1.7 and 2.8
along with improvement (%) of 3.7 and 6.6respectively. The result also showed
significant improvement (p<0.001) through paired sample t-test.
Research Tool
Sit and reach test was used to test the individual’s flexibility. This test was
first described by Wells and Dillon (1952) this test is the most valid and reliable test
to measure flexibility. The dimensions of the flexibility box were ((30×30)cm and
(12×12)inches with height length and width respectively. The scale which was
pasted at the top of the board showed measurements in both centimeter and
inches. The measuring scale was extended from 0 started at the front edge of the
top board of the box to the 53cm (21inches) just before the opposite edge of the top
board of the box. The top board was extended 22.86cm (9inches) behind the place
where foot was placed. The flexibility of subjects was measured in centimeters and
the test was performed thrice as the average of 3 measurements was taken. The
shoes should be off and the legs were straight in sitting position throughout the
test.
Training Session
Stretching program was designed that worked on the specific muscles of
the subject which was completed in duration of 6 weeks which include 2 sessions
***
***
10
20
30
40
50
60
Male
Female
Pre-exercise
Post-exercise
Pakistan Social Sciences Review (PSSR)
December, 2018 Volume 2, Issue 2
317
of training program in which each session keeps a mixture of active static warm-up
stretching protocol (ASWS) and active dynamic warm-up stretching protocols
(ADWS) to increase flexibility of the subjects. For both sessions the researcher
selected 8 dynamic stretching exercises protocols and 15 static stretching exercise
protocols for the subjects.
The researcher focused on 12 major muscle groups stretching during
training sessions which includes Shoulder muscle (deltoid, trapezius and scapula),
Hamstring (bicep-femoris, semitendinosus and semimembranosus), Calf
(gastrocnemius & soleus), Groin (adductor brevis,adductorlongus, adductor
magnus, gracilis and pectineus), Gluteus Maximus, Lower back,Middle back
(paraspinal muscle or erector spinae and trapezius), Latissimusdorsi, Triceps
brachii, Biceps brachii, Rectus abdominis, Quadriceps (rectus femoris).
Discussion
The main purpose if the study was to investigate the comparative study of
male and female athletes about effect of stretching exercises on flexibility. This
study was limited to all male and female athletes at University of the Punjab,
Lahore. Main research questions were formulated in relation to the objective of the
study, which was to identify comparison of male and female athletes about effect
of stretching exercises on flexibility.
Conclusion
The major objective of the study was elaborating the “comparative study of
male and female athletes about effect of stretching exercises on flexibility”. After
careful handling and supervision of subjects and analysis of pre-exercise and post-
exercise measurements of flexibility of the female and male athletes, researcher
concluded that the flexibility of male and female athletes improved by the mean of
pre-test 42.38 cm to post-test 45.19 cm and male athletes improved by in pre-
exercise evaluation was 45.84cm to post-exercise evaluation 47.50cm respectively
and thus performance definitely was increased. Results revealed that stretching
exercises has a positive effect on flexibility of male and female athletes. Results also
revealed that stretching exercises such as dynamic and static exercises along with
Proprioceptive Neuromuscular facilitation (PNF) had positive effect on flexibility
of players’ performance except this Result reveals that flexibility of female athlete’s
flexibility measurement was increased as compared with male athletes. At the end
researcher concluded that male and female athletes should perform stretching
exercises on regular bases to enhance their flexibility and performance and
flexibility of male athletes increased then flexibility of female athletes.
Comparative Study of Male and Female Athletes about Effect of Stretching Exercises on Flexibility
318
References
Abolhasani, E. (2018). Operant Conditioning of Human Upper-Limb Stretch Reflexes.
Plumx Metrics.
Anderson, B. (2010). Stretching. Shelter Publications, Inc.
Baxter, C., McNaughton, L. R., Sparks, A., Norton, L., & Bentley, D. (2017). Impact
of stretching on the performance and injury risk of long-distance
runners. Research in Sports Medicine,25(1): 78-90.
Behm, D. G., & Chaouachi, A. (2011). A review of the acute effects of static and
dynamic stretching on performance. European journal of applied physiology,
111(11): 2633-2651.
Bernhart, C. M. (2013). A review of stretching techniques and their effects on exercise.
Human Kinetics.
Funk, D. C., Swank, A. M., Mikla, B. M., Fagan, T. A., & Farr, B. K. (2003). Impact
of prior exercise on hamstring flexibility: a comparison of proprioceptive
neuromuscular facilitation and static stretching. Journal of Strength and
Conditioning Research, 17(3): 489-492
Gleim, G. W., and McHugh, M. P. (1997). Flexibility and its effects on sports injury
and performance. Sports medicine, 24(5): 289-299.
Frederick, A., and Frederick, C. (2017). Stretch to win. Human Kinetics.
Ingraham, S. J. (2003). The role of flexibility in injury prevention and athletic
performance: have we stretched the truth? Minnesota medicine, 86(5): 58-61.
Jan, M., &Yaday, J. S. (2017). A Comparative Study on Effect of Selected Exercises
on Flexibility and Co-Ordination of Badminton and Tennis Players.
International Journal of Physical Education, Sports and Health, 4(3): 139- 142.
Manoel, M. E., Harris-Love, M. O., Danoff, J. V., and Miller, T. A. (2008). Acute
effects of static, dynamic, and proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation
stretching on muscle power in women. The Journal of Strength & Conditioning
Research, 22(5): 1528-1534.
McHugh, M. P., and Cosgrave, C. H. (2010). To stretch or not to stretch: the role of
stretching in injury prevention and performance. Scandinavian journal of
medicine & science in sports, 20(2): 169-181.
Norris, C. M. (2015). The complete guide to stretching. Bloomsbury Publishing
Pakistan Social Sciences Review (PSSR)
December, 2018 Volume 2, Issue 2
319
Olivier, M. H., Horan, S. A., Evans, K. A., & Keogh, J. W. (2016). The effect of a seven-
week exercise program on golf swing performance and musculoskeletal
measures. International Journal of Sports Science & Coaching, 11(4): 610-618.
Pamboris, G. M. (2018). An investigation into the mechanisms of acute effects of
dynamic stretching on ankle joint mechanics and running economy (Doctoral
dissertation, Brunel University London).
Reese, N. B., & Bandy, W. D. (2016). Joint range of motion and muscle length testing-E-
book. Elsevier Health Sciences.
Singh, M. K. I. (2018). Effectiveness of myofascial release on balance and flexibility in
sepak takraw players (Doctoral dissertation, Pusat PengajianSains Perubatan,
UniversitiSains Malaysia).
Walsh, G. S. (2017). Effect of static and dynamic muscle stretching as part of warm up
procedures on knee joint proprioception and strength. Human Movement Science,
55: 189-195.