Content uploaded by William Gomes
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by William Gomes on Feb 13, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
A psychosocial conceptualisation of refugee experiences: Involuntary loss
of home, torture and trauma
MA Refugee Care Disseration
Table of contents
!" #$
%&$
'!!$
!" ()
#)
*!)
$ (+
) "!
+ !!
!"",
(*&
-
.
$ (**
(!"*
/.
0
,*.,,")
!"$
$ #
$ 12
$ %*!34*
$$ !"$
$) !"5+
$+ !6"7+
!") '*
) $)
%"!*$
Chapter 1. Introduction
1.1 Background
1.2 Structure of the thesis
!"", " 84!3 !"!
"3".!"4!!4!*!&*
! ,* ! ! 4 4
,4!*4 !4!"*!4&
5"3!4!"*&*,*4!
,*3!4!.
!"5,",,!
!445!",3,34*.,"!
&4,*,1,"91:
# !"$3!""!;*,,!4
4,!!4!*
!34*<"!,,
5!<!"4!!"
5 , ! ,,7 "!* !
""!"5!!
8*3 !")3!"""*!!"#
"*!"5"
$
Chapter 2. Home
2.1 Introduction
4!673!"&"*!
"",3 4!! ! "5 ! "! 9""3
: ! 4 67 6"*!
7.!!!9""3<:
!""""!!3!!!*
!,!!!""3!
7!354"!#4
!4!&!4!3!!;"
""93"$:!"!*&
6# ! " 4! ! !3 4!* !*
"*!!"*=#"*!!"*"!!=7
!""4!>!"!
!!"!?!!
,*!!*!,!,*3",
3*9""3:!"","3
4*5"!!!4
,*
2.2 Psychosocial dimension
#,*!;&,!!#
,, * , 7 !
"!*34!!!,,&"!*4!9@3:<
34!!!&,;*943)$:<",34!!
& ",* 9""3 :< 3 4!! &
!49?3:<"34!!!&!"
""9""@&3:!!,*
"*!!!","*!!"A
!! 3! 3* !"3
",*3*4!9""3:
)
! 4!"34 4&!4
"*!" ""9:!!!6!7
!"!*A!,!
!"!"*!,,3"
."
2.3 Human needs
!*"33!,3
!"3*4!* 3 3&3!34!3*33
43*943)$<B3+:&*
!,,*!!"!*!,4!
!9""3:!*,*!
!!!*4!7
!!!!47!!*(4!
!"* "!*!!33
""943)$<""3<B3+:(4,3!
"5*!*",",
,*!*7 " >!3
!",49""3:
(*!!!*4!!
* ! 4! !
"7,3*5" ""93":
""!*4!!!3
<! !6! *7 !
4! ! 4!3 4!! 6. 7
9""33"$:!3!"**3
!5"!9""33"+:
@,!!!*!7!&*
* 3 " ! !
"5*9""33"A:
""9:3 ""! 5 ! "5* !
!.**!! "* A !
7,4!"!!3!!
+
!""*""!*(!
!",!67!"7
6*7!!"!
4!!!!"*!!
**! 9""33":!""&
4!!"!!""3,"!
!!!"*,,
2.4 Conceptualisation of home
( "53 . 4! * *
!"9""3<:#"*!*
* !
4"3!"",*"3*"*!
!"*!"9',3<:
#4!!3#&5"*
**3&#&4!!!""3
"3 91"C3 < @3 <
""3<B3+:
8 "!"! "3 ! ! ! !,
*&4!44",
!4#!&Poetry, Language, Thought3(4
6!4"!!3!,!4!
43 ! !* , 4D! 7 !
!3!,!&!"!4
!"!=E,!!!!3*
!*&"43!!
!479(3+:
D!("!4!&4!D
4!"!,!,!&!
34&!>4!44!4=
( 3 "* 3 * ,,
,*"!!4,D5!
!,,,"!"4!
!3(
(!,*&
#" ! ! ! !53
F*3""!(3!"!!
6,4!35!!4!!44
4!!4*43,4!
!**79"!33"$:
@,!4!!!!5,3*&4!
,7*#!"!*
3"!93"$:!
6( ! * ,
*3!4"(;!!*!""
,3!!*4!3!5!3
"7
2.5 Attachment and home
!!","3*,*3"!
" * , @, ! & * *3
!!!!!*&*@9:""!!*
! "" " ! 4 4!! !* ,3
!";34!%!9+:!""*4!
!*;3"#,3 !&*
9$:!4!,!"3!*6"*7
@ 9:3 " " ! !*3 "" ! 4!
,!"4!!!3!*!
6!7
2.6 Phenomenological perspectives
# 4!!4! 5"
5 ! ! 7 ! , 4!
."5"*"!
"", 91"C3 :! ," ""!
" * ! ! ! ! !
, 4! " !! ! 1"C 93 ":
!
6!"!*5"GHI"
,!5"!7
'!!!!!!!!,7!""
, !! " " , 4&
!4!,!!,'!!
!!4!!6!
5">*!"4!",4!
"4!5"!!793":
(4,3',9:!"!""!!
>*!!,4!,7"
!(!!!!
!*5"*
6G!I;,5"
""*!,!,!!!*
!,5"*793+$:
'!!,&!54!!!,!,!
!!4!!,, ""1493": !
! " 4! " 4! !*
*3 *3 !* * ,*3 1 93 ":
&""!3"!!4!,
! * ! 6G!I * * *
7 ! ""! 6* *7 !
" 4 ! , * ! ,
5"4!!5!*(4,3"!,
!* ,,5"!"
& ""! 4! & ! @7 9:
!";1"C9:&"!,"
""!!,!4!,74!
!!!!!""!&*"
!!!"!
-",", !3 ""
9: " "!, 4!! " ! , ,
3!","3!!!
6!!*!*"*3*!3
4&33"549:"39:
9:!"793++:.
D!"3!5"!!5"!4!,"!"
!,4!!5""(!!
" "!*3 !3 "! "
5 ! !, 5" ! ! 3 3 "3 !3
"*!33!3"(*
3!!"#!",!,*
>&*,!"!","4!""4!
!3""8 !"3 5"!6!"
7!!3!!4!!!"*4!""3!
!,"!"4!;3,33"
,
2.7 Home as an identity maker
2.7.1 Essentialism
!>!4",",!!
"!4!>3"!34!
3!" ,!4""
! ! " ! ! ! '* 9:
!,4"33!3!3!
""*4!!2!(,!!
""!!*.3
2.7.2 Anti-essentialism
"".3%!!9:!*!
4!!!!"*3!
,"!***"D!
! ,4 *3 ! 4& , ! 4*
""793:"*34!!
2.7.3 Hybridity
@,! * *,3 ! 4
#!&The Location of Culture3%!!9):!
4* 5 * ! * !** *
! # 5" ! !**3 -!" 93
")+:!!,6!,4
!7!!*!4!3*
* ( ! ! & !
* ! ," ! " !
!!!"4!>4!
,!!4!&"34!,
!!4!!!4,5"%!!76!**734!
!4!,34'",&7
9$:>36 !''"&=7!,3!*
! "" 93 : , "*
*3 !"5 ! 5" ! "
4!,"!,*
2.8 Home as the fundamental locus and starting point of identity
4! ! ! " 5" 4!! 4 " "
! 4 ! 1"C9: ,! !
" 4! ! 4 4!
,!,'!!!!*!
4!!!""!!4!*
*3"4!!!!!3
4!!!", "" 9: 4! ! ! !
!" 4 ! * "" " "
*
"" 9: ! * 4 " ! !
! , ! 3 3 "!*
"*! !3 3 "3 * 3 "
33,!33*3!*7
4*!4!!!*#"
,"*!,36"33!3""
<34!!*3!.3!,3<
<<!79""33"+A:
2.9 Onto-ecological settledness
D!!"*4!!4!!!3
4!* ,* "5"@*9:
"!!"7,*3",
!"*!!*<!3
6*7 4!7 6..!.47
9(3:@*9:!,!!4
4!!,,!!"!
! 4 ! ! ! ""
* 4 , !
(4,34!*!44!!*"
*3!".! ""93
: ! ! ! ," " !
*3, * * ! !
, & * ! 5" ! 4! ,
* "* ! > ! 4!
""6.793"$:(!!
!3!
634!!3!>5",
, 3 * 3 *3 *
"*A!4**79""3
3"+:
! . * " 4!! 4*
!"!,!,"
2.10 Nostalgic disorientation
""""!4!,4!,*!3
! * < ! ! 6
793"+:!4!,**3"!
4!* 3
!,
*!"*!
!,"!!!*"*!4
,&!!"5*!!"
"7*3!3""9:!4!
*"*!"*!"!
!3!*!!!!*!,!!3!!
!.(!4!!!3
&* ! 5"!
""93"):
6G4!I!3!&4"
! "* ! , ! ,.
",< ! *.,< ! .J.
",7
( ! 6 7 ! , "*!
5"!"*!!"
3"!
!*4!!",&
8!3 """ ! !
5"3!!!!*!*4""
"!9""3:D!!*4!
!!3!""!"!
#!9""3:
! ", " * ", !
9""33"+:("!!!"7
,4!! & ! !* !& ! " ! !
!!9""3:
(4,3!!!*",,!"5!**
!! "!4!!!*
5! 9""3:#*!7"!3
!<!<"!4!!
!*!!!!*"
""9:!"*"""!
!!4!!"!*!
"*3!*!4!!!,
&4(! *!!*
; * 3 "!
*!! ( !!*!!
*!
69: ! 4 * "" ! 4!! !
"", ", , 4 < 9: !
!9"!*
*:<9:!4,!!"
95 3 "!* "*!3 :7
93""+A:
#,* !
4!!""*!"
3,*3!9""3:(4,3!
!""!,*3!"* 4!!
5.5*3!5!3!
!!
! "5 "
* 9""3 :" * *
* ! ,, !3 ! "
!& 3 "" !
!!""!!!*!,9""
@&3:""9: !!",,!"
, " " !
"34&>!
?& ! "! *3 ,9$: > ( 9:
"!""!4!(4
6"!,*4!GHI"!"!**!"
* 4! 43 ! "!"!3 ! ,*4! !
,*4!4*3*34!4!!
4!4!4"79(33,3
$3"):
,"!4!,5"3*,
3"!!"4!!"4!4!4
*834!!*!!3!*
!4"!4!!5.!
!!!!4!F&9:4!!"!3
$
D!3!4!""34!!!
!!!3""*
!"" "5 # ",
5" ! "5*3 "" 9: 4 ! " 5,*
", ! , ", ! , !
4!&4!",""!,*
!3!,6,*74!!!
"!!"!5!7"9""3<
:!,*!!9:!, < 9: !
!"<9:!",9""33"$:!"
!.5,>!"*!4*A
",,""*!,34,
!, 9""3):8*3!
" >3 ! ! !"" 4 &*
9""33<B3+:
2.11 Adversity-activated development
,*., ," 91: * " *
"" 9:3 4!! ! 5 5"
,*14,4!*
3 4!! > * ! ,* , 4!!
9""3:/*4!!,!;!
1 ! ! 3 4!! 5"
3 * " " 4 !K * ! ",*
9""3:
D!,*!3,7,4*
""9: "!,*!
!!"!3!
""!4!5"F*!
, 4!! , ; ! 4* !
5"*!"(9:!,*
! * * *
)
F* *!*!"! ."!
5"331
!""44!""9:!4&
4! ! ! 4 , 4!
"**,*#3,
" ! ! ! "! ! ,
9""3:!,!&
"4&4!!!"#!"5*
" " ! > &4 ! ! 53 !
", , !, !3 ! ,* 4 " 7
",*34!!*,**3!!!",
9"":
!4!""!>*"9",3,:!
"*!,,,9,33*:!7
*9""33""$.):!",!
!! " "! *3 >
"5 ! "3 ", "*! "",
9""33"):
+
Chapter 3. Torture
3.1 Introduction
,"!,"*>
" ! !3 3 ""3 ,* !
,!""*!3!,*"53
!5>!,9""3:?93"5:!
&Torture, Psychoanalysis and Human Rights!
6"53"!4!"333
"*!3 "!"! " /4 ! "5*3
>"5*"",7
?93"5:"!36"!7#,3
""9:A!Refugees, Trauma and Adversity-Activated Development
A!
67",*
,*.,1,"91:7
(!5,*"*!<!3
.""!4!"*!>#
5 ! " ! 3 * "*!
",,7;*
;5"!,*!"!*!4
!5"9""3:!"""
"*!""!!!3"*
!4!,,9?3<""3:#5"
"*! , "*!3 " ." ! ! *
! 67 #! 4*3 4 ! !
! ! "53 ! ! * ! "!
"*!"",9""3:
3.1.1 Definition
#)3!L0@*"! ,/! 3
#!1 !9L0 :<! M
6* * 4!! , " 3 4!! "!* 3
*"!""!
!"3"!!!!
"! "!, 3
!!"3**
&34!!"*!4!!
>"!"
"*#"*3!
47
"!!4
43 ! "!"!* 43 * ! "
!:!,*"
N<: ! ! ""< $: ! > "" 9*3 3
"):
%! ! ! ", ! 4!
5*4!,!"*"",4*
!" ! ! (4,3 ! "! !
** "*! !!;3 ! "4
,,!>*!4"!
!9""3:!?.!!3
3!!,O3"O
!, 4! 93
:-!!4!,"!!!">*
#"!!*4!"*!
3!&*"""9"3$:
! 6GI ; "*! ! * 53
,.,7(!
4!!"!*
4& !! " ! 4! ! 7
!#4&4!3"!.!"
!""9"3$:"!6*!"
"*!94""*!
:4"4!,,!4!7
3.2 Body as home, witness and storyteller
!""!!*!34*""
"*!,,9.*3<0
""3<B3+:
!?.!*389:34!!6,
GI"7!(/34!!!*&
"#"3Beyond Belief3""
,4!!!,,7*!,
! "; " .! ( / 98
3:!!*>,*,!!*
",4$,,,4*!(/
",4,,+,,
4!*,44
!*,4!"!3
" #!"3 ,,
5"!*,4
6#47,4<4H3;
4!*,4GIH*5"4!4
,43,*,4*#4*798
33":
',,4!*!LP!"
!!4!*"!!!!;*
4.!*4!!9'!&3+:
8,,3!*4!!!43*
, " 83 !*! ! 4"*
**!44!!!*'!,*>
", * * " * 5" 53
*"5*!"!**3
!"" 98 3 : ! ,, *
6#7 ! G! * ,4
I !* G( / I Q 4! #Q
*!4#!=79833":
#**!!"!!!3!&
" ,4!! 4 "3 , 4!" !
> * ! Manual on the Effective Investigation and
Documentation of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or
Punishment3&4!# 9/( (3):!"
!*,43(/4&,*
4,,!"!!"*!"
,,7" 9/( (3)3"): !3
"3,4,,*!
(/!LP%!*;*33"*!
3!,,3"!*3
"5>;!,,
!!4*!!"!7
!,!3! 4*
,B9+:!33!**
34!"3*!
*"!""34!B73"!!
"*,4!""!,,B9+3"+:"
!!"!5"!
*,*7,6"7!3
!""!,44!4!!>
! ! 5" 9.*3
:
#4!!"!!*4!
4!"!*5!5"
,, .* 9:3 4! *
!""!! "" 4! !*, !! 4!.!
&4!4!,(!
9*: 5* &3 5" 4! !* *
9.*33".:*,75"
!>! ! "! 9B3
+:
'!!"&4<
!3 !* * * ! * !
!"4!4!&4;.*9:!
! 5 ! 53 ! "*
4(!!!!4!!4*
" 4! ! " &4 9: ; &44! ,< 9:
54!!,<9$:!"&44!!!
5" 4! 4 ;&4 5 9.*3
3B3+3":
!5"4!*!5"*"5!,3.
*4
6**GI,*5"A#",3!
**5"< " * ""GI
/!"!*!"5"#,!"
!,*!%#*5"*4*
"",79.*33B3+3":
#,3!!!*3%9:"!!
*,*3"*(!!
!!*4!!&!,
"454&#!&Steps to an Ecology of
Mind3!93")+:4
6#""3*45"*!!!,3
* 4* 4! 3 " ! !
*7
% ! * * ," 4! !
4!,!5,34!!!"!*#
!""5!,,4!67!,
4! 673 ! * "* 4! !
,#!4*!3"!,!!6*7!
! 4!! 5 ,3 ""
*!"
4!!4!*",34!"*.
* ! , # ! & Trauma and Recovery: The
Aftermath of Violence – From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror 35"4!3
( 9+3 "$): 4 ! ! !, ", !
"",!%4!!""3!
6!!*.,4!K-!
"! *" 3!, *3
"5!,79(3
+3"$):
F"!!>!,
5"!,"*6,7
!;,*3(93":"!6,>
;3"!**3,.
&"7(4,3!5!3!6
,GI,57
9":
!!3(93"):3!,
!;!,*&!
"",*!;Q*!,,
4!!"Q;,3!4*!!*!!,!
",*-5 ! ! ;, 3 R!!
93"$: ! 3 "" 4* " ! 4
!!4.""*!,(!
4!,5",3!**5"S
!!,7""!4!"!
!54!!!&*"*%93"):34!
!
64!!!*H*
!7"!47*3
,!4!!!*7
%5",&!!!!"!4!*,
#"!5!,,&!!*
!"!*
!"4!!!,4"!#
!5"4!!",;3;4!!!
5!4!9.*3:#!,,
3",*!!!*4!4
!*,*,4!!""!
! " ,! 93
"$:3*!"",3!!
"Q*3!!!!>3
& ! ,! 93 "3 ): ! 6! *
"45!!;;3;7
# * ! !3 % 93 "): ! !
,,5"6,A!"73"
"3"3/!3%93").:!!,
,!!6,75"!"
4!!""5!
/",,7,4!!&*
3!3!!""79:"!!4
!!&*54&4!
0""9:!!**,4!7
!!!" 3!4&6!*
!7,!,,,'!!
!!**!!3"
!"*!!93"+.:
*3*3*<
"!<
$!<
)%*<
+14<
,<
!*",!,5"<
T*"*!!"!*5"
(4,,!,!6454&79%3
:***"*!"
3.3 Trauma and the range of responses
!5,*!3*,,
*4!4!".9'1:*
"*! " ' ! "5 " !
,3 89+3"$:!"5&6
;,!",73!!
!!"*!*""*"
'1(4,3!""!,."!!!"
!" 4!!,,!!"!
!!!!""*4!!
,,9""3:
!! ! 4& ! 3 ' 9+< <
<<< $< +: "" 9< < < : !
"53"*!*!!
"! ,, ' 9+: !
"", "*! 4 " *
", "!, "" !*
""","*!4(!!,
" 5 4! 4! !3 !
*3*"*("!!,
,, !! 3 4! 3 9: ( !
U5",3!*"!4!4,
"!"'9+<$:"!3!!!
1' 13)! -91'#F: !
", !" "*! ! '13!
" ! "5 4* 4!! ,3 ,
, 3 ! ,
5"!!!!&4
7!"4!!4!*3
"9'9+<$<+:
> ! * 7 " 5,* "*!
,"!3'93")+):!
6' 3 , 3 53 !" * !
"" , ! , !
5"4!"*!
"!;"3!3,!
!,,,
7
$
!"4!*,,"!,4!
! 3 !! " ! * !
!,,9'3+3$:'9:"
!!;*4"4!,*,,*3&
"*! ! !!,!3 ! 4
"*!,*";!
4!4&!!3!!.4
"
9:!!,9:!""
5!,74""!
",*!*!
!,74&",!,!""7
!3;4!"!!
"!!,'""!!4",*,*
&*93"$:4!!4*
6!, 4&4!, ! ;
""#"3&&!"*4!!
!3!!&4!""7
!!"34!"4*
!"*!,,,*3"",
!!(9+$:4
6#"*!3!"",*!
!"4"'*!""7
# * 3 ! "" & ! * !
,#!!*3!&!
GI!"4!""3!!",
*3!"*!",7
D&4!,,3"!5
;3,3"4""4!!,
"" 9: ! 4 !, ,
*3"!33"5(,!
"*,!."
" * ,4 "! (4,3 ! ! ",
"*,,#!4!!
)
5"!!""4!5"
5*,,,
3.4 The political and social context of trauma
#!!!!!"!!,3!45
P9+3":"!
6!!*!,,*!
*3"3!,!
,!"!!7
!,&4!!!*9%3:!*
>,P9+3":*!
!4 !** !, " !
6"!"7(!!"!
" ! 3 ! ! * !,
""3!!!!!,*"
4,,"!5*
!3*!,!4!
",*
3.5 The illusion of ‘post’
D!!*,,,*
"!45!*4!!!*!, !
*!,!4'15"!5"
,, P 9+3 "$: ! 4 !
"'1!6".7<!
!"!,#3*"*
,,36"7!*!!*
# ! ! >! "3*
" 4! 4& ! !!
!".(4,3!5"
!&!"*,,>*D!
6"7 ! , ! " , 3 !
,"5*!5""
! ! ! ! "! * ""
9'3$:
+
1!"5*3""*!!
4*!!!!""9:4
!!&!!*4*!4!!,!
"" * "! ! ,, ! ! ! ! 5
,,( ! "! ,, &* *!
44!*4!!,5"""
4!,,3*,"4
D93": "!6!"7!!!"
!".5#!,,3, 5
!"3!*!!"!&4
(&9:4!
6 * " "
""3 5"3 "" # 4 * ,4 ! 3
&!"",3!!"
"3"!",4*!,*
79(&33D33":
D93":!6"!GI4!
GIffi!*7!"
*""93$:!!!"5
!34!!"!,5!!,
","!3"*!,,
, 9""33 "$+A$: "" 9:
1*","!55"!,*34!!4
,44!,,""9:5"
!*4!!,!;!1
!""!1",,34!
!,!&!!*4*""9:
!34!,!!34,"!*3
4!!*""4!K*!",!>!
*!,*,*!4!!
Chapter 4. Summary and conclusion
,*"4 !"3!,4&!
!" "6!7 "*!4&
5"!""!*4!!!*""
9333:!!!4!"!
""(4&!!!!""3!
!"*!"!4!!"5,,
!!!"5*"!!
! "5* > ! "! ! !
,*" 9""3:#!,*3!"!
! ,3 3 !3 , "
,3 ! ", 9""3 : !! ! ""3 !
,* ! * ! " " !
!*!,5"
""79:"*!4!&*!""
4!5"3!"*!
,3"."!"!*
**!!"5*
! 4!"34 4&!4
"*! " 6!7 ! 4& ! !" " ! 4!
"*!"""7*("
"!5"*!!*!,
4!!,*!!!!!*
!! >* * 4!!* 4 4! !*!,
3 " * & ! * 4!!
"!,*!"
-4*"7*,4
3,3!33""*!
!3
9'*3:!3!"*!
!4! !& ,3
%!! 9):3 . 4! > ! !3
"!!**3!6!**7!
""!,!*!"!,
!"*!?&%!!9):3""93:
,"*!*3!"5!*
?9:,!"**4*
! 3 !4,3 , 983 < '",&3 ): 4!
!,!53!"!4!,
3!"
""(4,3!""4!35"3!!
'* !
,!#!34!!***
3!,,>*,*"*!
;!!*!!!!!!!
4&4!4!!!"Q4&5"&!
,!"*!,,7!,*
,&!53!!!!!*!,
; 4!!!"!4!*!"
! , *U/* ,* 4 ! !, !!* !
"3 ! 4! !, " "" 9$< <:
'9+<<<<<$<+:
%V9:D&89:"!!"5
*" ! 5 " ! 1 1
'91'.+:9*!3$:!*"!!
" " " !
* %V " ! "
! . ",
633 !74!!! " *
!,"!4*
"" 93 : ! ! 5!
!"!4!!3!!*
(!*!"!""!
!*!!3,
!!5!5,
!" ! " 9""3 :3
4!!" "5 " 4! " , !
, 4! "" ! 4!
, 4! ,* !3 ! 6.
7 4! ! !! !
"3 ! ! , * " ,
," !3 4! ,*3 ! ,
4&4!,
!""!4&%!!9):"*!6!**73
4!!""9:!!,!"!
!"$,,35!!!,
4!& * # " " ,7 * ! "*
6!740""79:!*!!**,4!
7!3!4&.*93:
! > ! "" ! ; 4! *
,,!,!!!!LP4!&*<!*!,
",!!*!,!*>!!4
;*4!*!*4,!!*
* * * ,, ! *
4!!3!(/34!!,
!" ! "" !"" ! *! !
, ! 4* ! ",, !
*!!4!!
!!!!4!
344&""'#
4! ""79: ! "*!
"**5,4!!
4!!!&*"!!""","*
" ""7 9: ,* @ !* 1 !
'1"!4"!
!"3!",3*!,#
!!4***4!"*!!
,* @ " ! "5 *
;!"!""4!
! "," "*!" # > ,* "
!!",""*!
"!&4!#!*!!
, ! * 4! !, , 4
5"!*#1>*4.
!!,,4!!*!!
!,4!!*4!
""9:!""!,.!"!4*
&"4!4&4!!&!4!
,,!4!#4!344&
! "! "4!! 4!, > !3 !
!*!*,
!""!'1!
"53"*3!"!*"!"*!
"#!,,
3 0 ""7 9: 4& "" , !
!!*,4!7 !
!! " 3 ! 4& !!* ,
!,*,,
'" "!! " ! " ! "! ""!
*.*9:!*,,
! ! "" ! " ,3 5
#!!!!4!* *!"
* ! ! * , !
",3,!,*@!*"
$
"*!3(/!*4&4!*
* 4& 4! D! 3 ,,
! " ! ""! 4 * ! * !
34!""!"
!;*!",,""
'9+3 $3 +: ! ! !
!"!""4!!!
!* ! !"! ! ,3 !4 5
,*!*!*4!!!*&
!"!3!*!,!!,
8*3",!!!*
4*3!*4!!,*3
4!! ( ! ! ** 4!
!"5!
! "" &4 ! ! "" !,
" * "
*, 3" 4! # >*
4!"34!
!!""!**!!79'*3:'
"" * ! > ! 6!7
"67!"""!
!""79:!!"
4!!4&35"!!*4!,
"*3!!""4&4!
%!!79):9M"!3+<?3$:!34!!&!
!!"*4!""3!
! - ! ! ""
""9:!!!!!3!*
! ! ! ,* ! " ! 4K
!!74!,!*
$
4.1 Conclusion
,*!!"*!6(7
! "*! 4& ! 4 " "*!
>*!,*!**
"*!#"!,!*34&
! 3 ! ! !* * !
,,**4!<
!!4*
"!**!!!",
4!!*!4!!! 4! !
,,!!*&*
!LP!,!!!!!,,
""*!""!4&!4!
"*!!*,4!!
!4*("!"5!!
!!4!",&**34!!!
!,
$
Bibliography
;F9:Heidegger and the Issue of Space: Thinking on Exilic Grounds.
L,*&*,'L,
89:Trauma, Culture, and PTSD*3L',
*!9:9:Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders: DSM-IV-TR)!35,D!31 *!
*!9:9$:Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders: DSM-5+!D!31 *!
13!'3%4039:!
* '& ! ! W (!
', ! 0(' # Oxford Textbook of Migrant Psychiatry ?/5
L,*
*-!" 9: ( %!!3 !** *3 1 , ?
Hungarian Journal of English and American Studies (HJEAS) )9J:#
-!'3L,*1)+
%@9: Steps to an Ecology of MindL,* ! !
L,* !
%??&9:!' *!
'*P4(4!
%!!(P9:9:Nation and Narration?X<04E&
%!! (P 9): The Location of Culture ?X< 04 E&
%V 9: 5 (!1 'K !
1'.+ , Journal of Medical Humanities )9$: $)A$$ 1/#
J..+.
%!#9+:!!*"""#%!#D
- 9: Growing Points of Attachment Theory and Research "! !
'* ! ! 1,"Y +3J ! ! L,
!3""$A$+
%'M9:0,!&!'#%3 4MF3
'"K?9: Acts of Memory: Cultural Recall in the Present(,30(
1! XL,*04-3"")A+)
9$:#*1*! 5!0?'#
? - 9: Identities: Race, Class, Gender, and Nationality
3%&43""++A
,!D9:Torture and Eucharist: Theology, Politics, and the Body of Christ
!"*!*/53LP%&4!
1"C 9:!!?,4!
! ," Journal of Architectural and Planning Research 9:
?&'! "*3#A+
$$
19:!#(P'"Social Research+9:!04
'!A$
8117(-9+:!!!%* L
-, * '& American Anthropologist 9): +A 1/#
++J+)+
8 9: %* % 8 ,
!"JJ*J"J=Z"Y*.
WZY4WZY9+M*:
819:-*'"&830W104E&
@PM9:Relational Being: Beyond Self and Community/5/5L,*
@9:*'.#*''*!?
" *
@F9:4*"!!!
Journal of Architectural and Planning Research 9: ?& ' !
"*3#$$A)
@* 3 L,* % '! , L ' 9: The
Meaning of Home in the Decade of Owner Occupation: Towards an Experimental
Research Agenda.L,*%3'!,L'
(9:Poetry, Language, Thought04E&("
(9:Being and Time%&4
(9:!"!*Questions of Philosophy Magazine
A$
(M? 9+: ,* ! ! F . 8 1
+04E&%%&
(M9:F!""!!F!
# ?4 ?3 '! ?P3 ' 9: Violence and
Meaning !'"#!3""A+1/#J.$.
$.$.Z
(&% 9: * # 8 04
"*9: Out there: marginalization and contemporary cultures
"1*"*) 3#
M&9+:At Home in the World1!1&L,*
M"!M9+:!*-!
!! Disability & Society $9: A)
1/#J++
P M 9+:-" # P M3 8* 3 @ %9: Beyond
Trauma: Cultural and Societal Dynamics 04E& 3 ""A$+
, !"JJ"&">J!J""5=
"Y$$$9$M*:
PM38* 3@%39+: Beyond Trauma: Cultural and Societal
Dynamics 04 E& ,
$)
!"JJ"&">J!J""5="Y$$$
9+":
?19:/*#The Divided Self: An Existential Study in Sanity
and Madness?3""$+A
?9:Torture, Psychoanalysis, and Human Rights?3*W
8@"
4(9)$:!*!, Psychological Review +9):$A$
1/#$J!+)$)
8 9+:!',*!##
'1#PM38* 3@%9: Beyond Trauma:
Cultural and Societal Dynamics04E&3""$A+$,
!"JJ"&">J!J""5="Y$$$
9$M*:
?@9$:'*3-!*European Journal of
Social Theory9:A1/#J$)$$+
.*9:Phenomenology of Perception?
.*9:Phenomenology of Perception?
R!!89:F3F3M!"!""!%
?
/( (9):L0/!(! (!9/( (:3
! -, #, 1 /! 3
#!1!96#7:,
!"JJ4444JJ)$!9M*:
""09:!%*(4&4!,*
"" P 9: * ", Journal of
Family Therapy$9):)+A)1/#J).)$
""P9:9:Therapeutic Care for Refugees: No Place like Home?
"" P 9$: 3 ! # "" P 9:
Therapeutic Care for Refugees: No Place like Home?P%&3""A
$
"" P 9: 3 ,*., 1,"
European Journal of Psychotherapy & Counselling 9$: $A$ 1/#
J$)+$)$
""P9:(53 "5F1*#%!'
[%9:Thinking Home: Interdisciplinary Dialogues?%*
3""+$A1/#+)J$+$
""P9:9:#;**L(!
(D04E&30E
""P @&0 9:! "5 !
Psychotherapy and Politics International9:)$1/#J"")$
$+
, - 9$: 0 * 0 * Journal of
Analytical Psychology+9:$)A+1/#J;).+$5
&*#3 1&&3 8@3 9: 4 ;
8 ! # - 9: Advancing Social Justice
Through Clinical Practice 3 ""A) 1/#
)$)J$$
!&* (3 8 P P 9$: .* !* 4
K ! Journal of Environmental Psychology $9:+A$ 1/#
J'.)))9$:.
""0149:9:Migrants of Identity: Perceptions of Home in a World
of Movement/53LPX<04E&%
9: Torture of refugees and migrants ? ,
!"JJJ.4&J....J 9 + M*
:
"!- 9: Place and Placelessness" ! "
?'@-
* 0' 9: ! 19: # ?4 Current Legal
Problems++9:)A)$1/#$J"J++)
'*9:-3' 3*The Sociological Review
)+9$:)+$A)1/#J).+)\$
'!&P3P, 9+:#"*,4!
!!K*&European Journal of Psychotraumatology9:
1/#$)J;",
'!K 9: Collected Papers I. The Problem of Social Reality 9 0:
! 1! '" 0! 1/# J.)..
+.
'! 9:The Body and Social Theory!!*3W*?
'
', 9: ( 4 ! ' D
Housing Studies)9:$A1/#J$$)
',9:(!(=
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 9): +A+$ 1/#
J;).))5
',9:!!Journal of Architectural and Planning
Research)9$:?&'! "*3#A)+
'K?9+:P*4"*!"?58
'K?9+:P*4"*!"5
?58
'",& @ 9$: ! ' '"&= Die Philosophin )9: )A+ 1/#
+)J"!"!$)+
'",&@ 9):#/!D-*
$
'19+:("D*; !
! !? D*! #
PM38* 3@%9:Beyond Trauma: Cultural and Societal
Dynamics 04 E& 3 ""A ,
!"JJ"&">J!J""5="Y$$$
9+":
' 1 9: > , " ! "*!
"4. Social Science & Medicine )9: ))A)
1/#J'.+$9:)+.\
'19: !!3D367! T
(! Transcultural Psychiatry $9$: )A)$$ 1/#
J$$)+$$
' 1 9: ! , ". !
"*! * BMJ $9: +A 1/#
$J;$+
'19$:!!British Journal of Psychiatry$9+:)+A
)1/#J;"$+)+.
'19+:]*D!%*'&H*?@^##*19:
Forced Migration and Mental Health# *!*'
04E&'".F3""A)1/#J.$.$.Z
L09): ,/! 3#!1
! L 03 * ' ,
!"JJ444!!JJ"J"J"5
F&F19:0?&!Journal of Applied Psychoanalytic
Studies9:A1/#$J$$$)
D9:1"33!"".!"*4!,,
#8& 3 !*#3'!!M9:Hope and Despair in Narrative and
Family Therapy: Adversity, Forgiveness, and Reconciliation04E&3
""$A) , !"JJ"J!J""5=
"Y$$9:
D&M 8 % 9: *" 5 ! 5
", 1'
1 Comprehensive Psychiatry +$9: $A$ 1/#
J;""*!$
DP 9:(" " # 8& 3 !*#3
'!!M 9: Hope and Despair in Narrative and Family Therapy: Adversity,
Forgiveness, and Reconciliation (,3 - '5< 04 E&
, !"JJ"J!J""5="Y$$
9*:
B@9+:-5"!"5*!5"4
L,* -5 ,
!"JJ"*5&JJ"J++
$