Content uploaded by Rebecca Alice Karp
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Rebecca Alice Karp on Feb 17, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Handbook of Peer Production
Chapter 11: Governing for Growth in Scope: Cultivating a Comparative Understanding of
How Peer Production Collectives Evolve
!" #$
"
%
ABSTRACT
& &$&
$'(
&&)
&$*'+& &
&&$&%
$$&&&'$
$)&&
,* &$$
&$$$ $&
&$'+* , & &
$&& )&
'
-
Governing for Growth in Scope:
Cultivating a Comparative Understanding of How Peer Production Collectives Evolve
!" #$"
!" #$"
!" #$"
1. Introduction
&$
$'&$$
*&&&$$
.&&$$&&'
&$*&*$
/0*12 %345$&
$ $&&/''+1 %3367
%385$/19&%3345'
( 1!* &&:
,&&$$&&$
&$;/%336'<5'
!*/%3<5&$*&
$&'+
,&&$
$
&&/'' 1(%3347=&1
%3719%385'9$)&&
8
$$&$ &$$&&'(
)(& /%3%5$&=&
$ >&&$ &
&$&'?$&&
$$&&$/1@,
%3A5 &$' /''!1=$$&
%337@1+BB7@*129%3385&
&&/=&& %35'
&&&$*
&& & */=&1
%3719%385'+
&$)&)
&$'
$&$&&
&$&& &
'!$&$$
&&&&C/@*@,.1?$
%3-7@,.%3657&&/*
%387!$&$@1@*%35
&'$&&$&
$$$&$'&@,$
&$:$)$& )*&
&$&>;/%3A'<A-5&$'
A
&&,&
/*&$5, &/D19B667
0@1+%33A5'!$&D&9/B665&&
E , '+*
$
&*&
$&/$&?$12&2%3-5' )&
, *&&& $&'
?)& &
)$&/1F&%33B7+B457&
&$/%33357&&/91F&%3385'
$ $& &$
& *'"*
&*/&%335&* &$
& &/''1@,%3A5'
!$$&)&$ $&
&$)/''1 %3B5'
&$$&
)&&$ $&$/''
&1 %345'
G&$*$ $$
&&&$/9%33A7!&19%37 1
@*%37&@1%3<7!*%345&)
&$&
<
$'G&)$
&$'+$ )$*&/''
! 1$&%335&*: )
;/1@,%3A5'+ .&&
&$ &
&$&'!$&$&?$&2&2/%3-5&
E&&
&'+$&$&$ &&$&
$.$& %$)&&
$&&&'
+$ $&)&&
* )&&
, *&')&
&'9& $&
$)'+&&&&
&$/Collaborative, Co-creative or Aggregative5&$
'= $&&$
$&$$&
/!* 1 %3A5&
'
2. Case Analysis
?&$&$&&)
&$&'F)&
4
$&$&$
$ ,/$5*/?$*57
$ $ /$+*&5/!*%3<5'?&
$)&$&
* & &'+,&
& &E
$& $
&$&&'+ .&$&
$&$'
+&&A& &$&$$
'&Idea Generation &&&
$'&Innovation Search and Reference
&$$$&
&'&Funding and Sourcing
$$&$&$'& Post
Production &$& $&&&&*&
)/&910%365'End to End$
&&&$'+&%
$&$&
& .Innovation Search and Reference'+
$$&& &$/''
%33<7+1 %3365&&$&
&&,&&*/'' %3345'+$
3 &$ &'
6
+$&$&>
&$&$ &'?&&&
$&$& &
&$&'
Insert Table 1
? &$
&$&$$*&
'+&&&$ $
'$&$&&
&'+$& )&$
& & )
&/1&%3<7&%3335'(& H$/IBB87
F&1%3345&&
&'+&&& &&
'
+*)&&
&&)vertical scope'()0&
$&$ $
$$&&$&&0
)&'0&$$
&$'+)&&&&&
$&&&)horizontal scope'()I)&&
$$*$*&
B
&&),'I&&
&$&$)&&&&'
+&&&
'+)&&*&
$ &$&$&
/5$&&'+&
$ &&'F
&&&'
(&&&&
&$$&'()$&
?& & &'9%36$&
:20;$& /?&%365'
&)&*&$what&$&&
how&$&&'()F& G!G!&&&
$&'9%338&
&$&/ 15'
?&&$&$& $
&$&'()%334I$?$&$&
2&G= &*
$&/%3%5'
+&)&,
& &$&&& ,&&
& '+$&&&)
)&$&&&& )
3
&$&'?$&$
&&$/7.5'Collaborators
&&$*$)& 'Co-creators
$&&&$$& *'Aggregators
$$$$&$
*'?&&$)$$
&&$**& '!&
*)&$&&
&$$'
3. Scope of the Innovation LifeCycle
/B%5&/ *
5,/
&&&$&53.%3 $&$%36'
/+*&*&?&5)&
$ $$$
&$&/%3B7+*&'%3B5'
Insert Table 2
Expanding Horizontal Scope'9/<%5&)&&
,/F?&?&G&I5&
&&$'()%33)&&$&
$&$$'?$&
$&!0$ &F$&)&&$
%38&&$&.$&/%385'I
)&&,$*&
/ $'5'! *&I)&&
&&&$&'
Expanding Vertical Scope') /A%5/?&
GI$?$&&&05)&&
'()?&)&&
&&&$&'$&$&
.&&&&$
?&$ &&$/@*1>%3367
@1&%3A5'G%3<?&:
;&&$$&&& ?&'?
&&&$&&$*&&
&& 33333& 'D+$E:GJ
**4 .&&&$ $&
& & & '$ &
> & $&';/?&
%3B5'?&)&&$& E
$&& $ ?&&&&$'
Maintaining Scope' &&$&$
/?&*&+*&5'+*& &
$&&$$&$&&
$&$$$&$&>'&
*&/*1&%3A5E:(*
%
$&&$&>';
?,*>&>$&&
&&'?*&
$>$ &$&>'
$&$&:$&&
&&&$$&$&&
& & ;/+*&($&%3B5&
$&$H$ &$)&'+*&&$&$&
H$ &&$&/1
@,%3A5&$ *&'$&D
+&E:+H$ ;/@%33<5'!
*&+*&& :**;&
H$ >&)
'
4. Governance Rights
$ *&
$&$&&
)/+1 %336'8<5'?$&
/$5&/
&$&&5&G0/$ &$&
&&$&5'?$$$&
&$ $ $
$/ 15' &
-
$& F$ $$&
$ $&$'
&)/?&&*5 &
/$ &5
$&&
'()?&
&$:&; &&$
&.*E:$&
$ &&&$
*&;/@1&%3A'A-85'&
/&5$$
* $$&&$
&$'
Distribution of Governance Rights'+&$&&
$ &$+*&$
/0**1%3471@,%3A5'!+*&&&&
&&$&.'&&$&
&$&&&$$&&&
&&'&&$&&
$&&$$K$&&'
&$& $&E:GJ*
$&&L$&&M';?H$
&$$/=&1 %35
8
&/$0$1?$%3%5&.
'
$&$$&&&$&) &
$/%3%'A465'$$&&
/0**1%3471@,%3A5&
&/ 1(%3347=&1 %37(1
%3%5)&&&
$$&/''$ 1 %3345'=
&&$N=&1
/%35$&&$$
&&'&9/%385$
*& * &&
'+&$&
&$&& /''
19%385&) /$%3%5'($
$&&$&
'
Types of Governance Rights' /3%5)&&
&$
&$&&/B%5'?/<%5&$
/A%5 &$&'
$$&/ 1%3B7!$&$%335
*$')$&&)&
A
$&
/?&FG&?&5'()
G!$&&&>F'
&&& F&&&
>$&
&>/ 15')& $&
F)$= H$$:$';?
&$: &F;'
& * &$
'
&&&&$&&'!
+*&&&&&&$&
&'()&&$& &&$&$
&$&&&$$&&&
/$&&5&&/!&%365'
?&&F&$&&&&
&$&&$'
& &&* &$&
$&'
( $&&&*$
*'(&$&$
$/?&FG?&&I$?$5'(
)F&$&?&
&I$?$* &'
<
G *&&&&
$ *$/@*D@10
%3347%3385'+H$0&
&& *' &
$ )H$/?&
?&&G5$$&&$&.)$&'
*I$?$&0 $
&
'G$
* $ '
0$ H$&$$
&&$$&* $$&
$)&&'
5. Patterns of Growth
($&/**&
?&5* )'&
,*
'H$ &$&
* )&$
&'()?&&G&&,
&&$& &$.&$&&
&&)&&$
4
'($&*))&
)'
Insert Figure 1
? &$%&$&&$
/CollaboratorsCo-creators&Aggregators5$&&$$
$& '?
$$aggregators
collaborators'+&)
$)& &$*&
&'
Collaborators. 0&$&&$
*$)& 'G
?&F&?&&& $&&$
$&$&&$&&$
$& '$&G
&*$&$&&
&/%3387@*%33B5' &&&
&G&&&
&$&%33&&$'&
GE:LM $
L&&$M&*&&*O$L&&$M
* H$ $';?&&&&$
&*&$&'
6
&$&
$?&/@*1@%335 &F$&
*&&&$'F$&
/''BB35$$&&
$&$&& &H$ / 1
5'?$&&$
$&H$&>'?
F)$=$&,&&&$
$&$H$ E: $&
)&H$ H$$'
O$*& ';
+& $&$&&
$/D1@*%335 &&
*&/(%33%3347$ 1 %3345
H$ $&'$$&
$&&*&&*&
/%3%'A65'&$
$& &$$$&
$'()&&G$
$H$H$ ) $N($$$&&)
&&$&&&
&$$$'
Co-Creators.+&$.&&$*
& $&* &$/'
B
!&1*%3335$ &&$
& *'()+*&$&&$&
$&$&$&$
&*'$&
$&& $&&$&
/(@1!$*%33B7!*1
9%3A5'D +).&&$&&$$&
*&&&$$&E:I$$
$&Denver Guardian& P0F&?$&*
+*&$ '? '? &'? &
$H$ $';?+*&$&
$&&$@&
/?%345'
++*& $&.&&$&&&
&&$.&&$
&$& $*& $&'!
&&&+*&H$ &$&&
&$&>$
$H$ &$&/''BBB7%3%5'@
&&.H$
/''(1 %3%5 '.
&&$*+*&&&&)&
$&$&'@ &$
&&*&'+
%3
$)&&.*$*+*&
&&&'
Aggregators'+&$&$&&$
$$$$&$
*'$*&
&&&$
$>$ &$&$'9/<%5$&&
/?&*I$?$I0&5&
&&$$&&$&&$
'&.$&
$&&&&$'
()?&&$ &$*&
&&$$ &&& &>$&'
)& **&/%3A'66A5E:?$
?&&&&& &;'?
&$+*&/''1@,%3A5'"*
&&&+*&& $
&&,&'()?&
&& &'?&
,&$ /''
**1%3A5$.'?&I$?$I&0
&:> ;$&&
$$&
$'? ) &$
%
E$& &&
'G$&)$
&$'
0$&$&&&$
$&**.&'(
)*$&$
*$&&'*$$&&$
&$&&& E:G $J$$ $*
;/*5'*$&
$&& ,&$
&&'?,*)&
*$&&$
'&&) .
&$$*&'+&*$
&&&'
$
&*/''$ 1 %3345$
)&*& '
6. Advancing a Research Agenda
$$&&$&
&'$&$
&&*$&&
'!$&&@,/%3A5
%%
& &$*/!
1$&%335&$& $&$'+
&$ &
'!&&$&&
&&$&$&&
&'?-&'
Insert Table 3
+Collaborators$&& &$&
&Co-creators '
Aggregators &H$$*$ &$$'
($$&&& &&'+ &
)&N+N
$ &$
$)&'9&
$H$ &$N
?H$&,
/$B6%7CB6<7+BB719B6<791BB37
9BBA7*1BB37%3337F 1 %33<7
1F&%33B5$ &&$
'0&& )
&&'()&$&&
$$$$&
$& '
(
%-
&&$ $'=$
H$$&& ,$$&
&$&&&H$&
'
+&$)
&$*&$
$&&$&&'+)& $
&&&&$'()
&&.$ &$
/**BB%7%3335'I?&&I$$ *
&$$'($$$&
)*$&$&&
$'
$*!*&$$&:
&$&H$ &$
*&$;/%3A'B5'$$& *$
*&$&$'+$&
&$
& &$ &$'
? &$$$,&
/''!*%3<5&$$'
9$ $&&
&$&&&&)
&$'?$$$H$&&E:+
%8
& &$N;$:+)
&$ N;+$&&
&&.
'
%A
References
&0''/%335'* &$E?*& &$$
'QOrganization scienceQ12/%5%A.%-8'
'1@,'('/%3A5'!$&
&$EG+*&'QOrganization StudiesQ36/%5<8B.<4-'
'D'/%3385'FEG&'QStrategy
& LeadershipQ32/858.B'
!&'I'1*'!'/%3335'QDesign rules: The power of modularityQ/2'5'
G?''
!&'129F'/%35'&&E(&$
$&'QOrganization
ScienceQ22/<5-BB.84'
! ''1$&'/%335'!**'QOrganization scienceQ12/5
4<.BA'
!* !''1 '/%3A5'@&&
'QHandbook of qualitative organizational research, innovative
pathways and methods<6.4<'
!*I'/%33%5'J0$@$)&R?C$(R'QYale law
journal-<B.88<'
!*I'/%3<5'0&$&'QHandbook on the Economics of the
InternetQ91'
!*I''19!''/%3A5'0&$E
'QHandbook of collective intelligenceQ175'
!&D''/%36%5'"&&&&E$&
'&%B%3B
EKK'& &'K&$K..&&K
!$&$'/%335'&E'
&'QManagement scienceQ56/3568B.64%'
!$&$'D'@C'1@*''/%35'G&
$ E 'QManagement
scienceQ57/A568-.6<-'
!D''1=$$&0'/%335'&&,E.
'QOrganization scienceQ12/%5B6.%-'
%<
=&@'1J '/%35'0E&>
*'QOrganization scienceQ22/85B<.B4B'
F&''1'F'/%3345'? $&E$
&'QAcademy of management journalQ50/5%A.-%'
(('1 '/%3%5'$&:;>'QThe
emergence of organizations and marketsA8A.A<A'
(@'/%335'$ 'QManagement
scienceQ47/54.-%'
(@'/%3345'!*$&RR'QMIT Sloan
Management ReviewQ49/5<B'
('@2'1!$*'/%33B5'=,+*&
'QJournal of Management Information SystemsQ26/58B.4%'
$&'1?$0'12&2''9'/%3-5'QPerspectives on innovation
process. Academy of Management AnnalsQ7/544A.6B'
'/%385'!&&E?&
*'QResearch policyQ43/45%-B.%8B'
'19&'/%3345'0 &
*EF&G'QJournal of Economics &
Management StrategyQ16/5.-8'
&0'C'/%3335'9&*&
.* 'QJournal of Marketing ResearchQ37/%5A<.4%'
&'1 '/%345'9&&&&N
F)&$ &,'QAcademy of Management
JournalQ60/A563.6%4'
'D'19'='/B6<5'?&E
&'QJournal of political economyQ94/85<B.4B'
$'0$0'1?$'/%3%5'S,&E*
&,&$ )'QStrategic management
journalQ33/<5A4.A6<'
9'/BBA5'QFirms, contracts, and financial structure'&'
9'1D'/BB35'0 &C$('QJournal of
political economyQ98/<5B.A6'
%4
9'F'1F&''/%3385'GS
,&$ && &'QStrategic
Management JournalQ25/-5%4.%-%'
D@'!'1@*''/%335' &.
&'QOrganization scienceQ21/A53<.3--'
D''19'+'/B665'? S$$
'QStrategic management journalQ9/%5AB.4%'
'/%385'&2D(F)&$&@
=+&L0M'&%B%3B
EKK'*'KKT%383%%A'&
'D'1&'/%3<5'=$&&E
$&$ $/B84BA65'QStrategic
Management JournalQ37/58B.<<'
*'1'/BB35'!&&$E
$N'QManagement scienceQ36/35%<.%-%'
*'/%3B5'&%%%3B
EKK'**'K$
D'/%3%5'?$,I$?$E($.&
&'QMedia, culture & societyQ34/5A-.<4'
@*''/%33B5'QRG'/5'RQ9&!$'
@*''=''1@F'/%335'?&/5E=
$&$'QHarvard Business School General Management Unit
Case/<3.3-%5'
@*''D@'!'@0''10D''/%3345'?$
'
@*''&>U'/%3365'?&E$$ /?C5'
9&!$$&K2&'
@*''@,.9'1?$'/%3-5'&
,$&E*&*&&$&
$'QHandbook of economic organization: Integrating economic
and organizational theory-AA.-6%'
@*''129F'/%3385'9$*E:;$.
.$'GQProduktentwicklung mit virtuellen CommunitiesQ/'-3-.
--B5'2'
%6
@!'1&2'0'/%3A5'$)&E?
&$& $&,'QJournal of Product
Innovation ManagementQ32/85A%%.A-6'
@D'1+F'/BB5'QSituated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation'
&$ '
@'/%33<5'CI?''? 2+*&9&0'
&%B%3B
EKK' 'K%33<K36K34K K34*'
@,.9'/%365'=*&$&CE?
& 'QAdministrative science
quarterlyQ63/8548<.46%'
(''&J '/%3B'5=*'+*0'
*F'/%385'?& &$&E) $& 'QJournal of
business venturingQ29/5.<'
$ ('1J '/%3345'F)$&$$E
G,'QOrganization ScienceQ18/<533<.3%'
C=''/B6<5'?$'QJournal of Institutional and
Theoretical Economics (JITE)/Zeitschrift für die gesamte
StaatswissenschaftQ142/5%-3.%-4'
'/%3345'?$E&
$ &NQJournal of Management & GovernanceQ11/%5-B.A3'
J '1!* !''/%3365'!$& ,EF
$)&'QAdministrative science quarterlyQ53/-58%%.8AB'
J '1(('/%3345'?$
$ 'QAcademy of Management JournalQ50/A534B.3<'
'&''/%3B5'+&2(F$C
2$=N('
J '1@*''/%35',&$'
GQCommunities and organizationsQ/'-.-<5'F&$0$@&'
**+'D'1'2'/%3A5'F)S&$
'QJournal of management studiesQ52/A5<B4.43A'
**+'D'/BB%5'?&$ E*
,'QOrganization scienceQ3/-5-B6.8%4'
%B
**+'D'/%3335'" &$$$E
$& ,'QOrganization scienceQ11/85838.8%6'
F'/BB35'QGoverning the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective
action'&$ '
F'/BBB5'G$'QTheories of the policy process-A.4%'
0*'12 '/%345'G&
'QManagement ScienceQ64/45-3A.-3-%'
0'+'@'9'1+='I'/%33A5'+&
N$$&'QAcademy of Management
ReviewQ30/-5<%%.<--'
0**'D'1V'/%345'?.
EF&+*&'QAmerican Journal of SociologyQ122/85
6-.%%%'
$'0'/B6%5'= & 'QStrategic management
journalQ3/85-AB.-<B'
K$&&'&%%%3B
EKK'&&'KK$&&
(''1F&''/%33B5'$*&$&E
F$&'QAcademy of Management JournalQ52/85
<8-.<4'
&2'0'9?'10C'/%365'$$&&
E?&$*
$'QAcademy of Management Review.'
''/%33<5'& &
$&'QManagement scienceQ52/45333.38'
'19!''/%385'@ N9)&
&$'QJournal of CommunicationQ64/%5%A.%-6'
?'/%3%5'&&E$&
'QAmerican Economic ReviewQ102/5-3A.-<'
'/%3335'@** $E$
&$ 'QStrategic Management JournalQ21/A5A44.AB%'
'F '''1 '/%33<5'C&&E
,&'QStrategic Management
JournalQ27/35BA.B-<'
-3
'/%3B%5'*E$&>
*%3B'&%B%3B
EKK''KK%66-8AK$...&..**.
>.*K
'/%3B5'?&EC$$&
?&&&%38%36/5'&%B
%3BEKK''KK<686<%K&.$..
K
*I'0'1&'/%3A%5'*!
'&%%%3B
EKK'**'KK**.....
?D'/%34=5'+*&D +)N
&%%%3BEKK''KK4<-AB3.&8B&.4.
6B.&B3A6&AB
?&'/%36D$ 85'!?&20EC0. &
%%%3BEKK'&'K&...K
?&'/%3B5'?F+ I$.&
%%%3BEKK'&'K.K$K
29F'/%33A5'=,E?$
'QJournal für BetriebswirtschaftQ55/5<-.46'
+D'/%33-5'9$NE& &$
'QResearch policyQ32/45%AB.%6A'
+D'1J '/%3365'?$
&$$'QIndustry and innovationQ15/%58A.<6'
+*&($&'/%3B5'&%%%3B
EKK*&$&'K$KK
+*&''/%3B5+*&E&+*&'&%B
%3BEKK'*&'K*K+*&E&T+*&
W%4T
+'F'/BB5',E? &
$$'QAdministrative science quarterly%<B.%B<'
-
Table 1: Peer Production Collectives Founding Characteristics
Innovation
Lifecycle Definition Collective Year Founded Ownership
What was Produced
public or privately available
Idea Generation
&
$&$$&
?& %333 & ?.&public
G %33 & K$private
Innovation
Search and
Reference
$
$
$
+*& %33 $
&
F &public
I$?$ %33A & ".&&public
&& %33A & &&&public
0 %33B & $&K&public
Funding and
Sourcing
($&
*
%33A & public
* %33B & *&&$public
Post Production
0&
&&*&$
&
?& %333 & &public
I %338 & $public
End to End
$
F BB6 & & public
?& %33 & & private
-%
--
Table 2: Change in Scope and Governance Rights
Initial Scope Change in Scope Adapted Scope Change in Governance Rights
Vertical
Expansion
Horizontal
Expansion
Technical
Control
Decision
Rights
IP Rights
Observed initial role in
the innovation lifecycle
Expansion into different
activities
across the innovation
lifecycle
Expansion
into new
domains
Observed current role in
the innovation lifecycle
Technical
rules
governing
participation
What is being
produced,
and how
Rights over
intellectual
property
produced
IG ISR FS PP IG ISR FS PP IG ISR FS PP
F
?&
?&
G
+*&
I$?$
&&
0
*
?&
I
@&
GXG&
GXG&
(X($&&$
00X00&$
CEF&&& $
'
Black =G&&&
Light Grey =
Dark Grey X
-8
Table 3: Advancing a Research Agenda on Governing for Growth
Mode of
Production Definition
Distribution of
Governance
Rights
Example Advancing a Research Agenda
&
'
9
G&&$&
%33'(
)
,&
&$
&'
G&&$
&&$ &
)$ &$ N
9&
&
$N
$
)* &&
$,&
$N
.
0&$
$&&
$*
$
$&
&&$'
&$
+*&$&&$&
'?
&$E$&&*&
&&$&
&$
&&/('
%33B7!*'%3A5'RF&
+*& RE
Wikipedia: FAQ/Editing, 2019'
9&.&
H$ N
G&&.
&N
9&$
&J N
$
$
$&
&&
$
&
$$'
@
?&&&$$
$&&&
&>$&'0&
&$
&&&&&*
*/**1%385'
9&
$ &$$
*&N
9&$$$G0
$$N
9&*
& N
-A
Figure 1: Modes of Collective Production
CE&&$&& &&H$&
!*&&&&$
&&&&$ $&
+&$&&&$$&&$