Content uploaded by Mariana Braga
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Mariana Braga on Feb 03, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Design for Resilience: Mapping the Needs of
Brazilian Communities to Tackle COVID-19
Challenges
Mariana Fonseca Braga a * | Eduardo Romeiro Filho b
Rosângela Míriam L.O. Mendonça c | Lorena Gomes Ribeiro de Oliveira c
Haddon Galvão Guimarães Pereira d
!"# "#$!%&!'(&(!
%"#%"#)!$&!'(&(!
!"# "#*!!#+&!'(
&(!
,-!.
ABSTRACT
* /0$123 !
.4!4
! ! 1 !1
!./0$123!! 5
!!!!!*4
! 6! ! 4 !
/0$123 !
!! 7 8 &! '(
44!!!!
* 4 !
! 4 9#/
! !4 !!!
!! ! : " ;<* :
!=>:4!
4!!!
9/0$123!!$7!!
)!+$
1. INTRODUCTION
* 6!!2 /0$123 !! !1!
: !
66!!1
!1!!!6
! !! * 4 : 4 !
! 9#/?
"#
%"#!4!!4
page 374
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
*!4!
..!
!
@
!(!!!
!
!
4.!
!
!!4!:
!4
1.1. COVID-19
/ 2A $ AB23 : 4 4 :!!
< ' !! 4
!4>=C2DC1 !&!
ABAB * 4! <!'! /( <'/ 22
"ABAB <'/ABAB 4!!
!4!!6!)!!
4 !2 6 !
5 " !ABAB A! 4
!!5*!ABABE!
! ! ABABF !
! (( !ABAB ; !
! ! ! &! ! ABAB
6 !1! ! 4!4
4!!"ABAB!
&& ABAB 4
%!$ABABG
"#ABAB
&(!5"/2=")78
: .! /0$123 !?
!!!
+#! % 7 8 ABAB&! '(! !H1
!I 4. +
"!&!'(ABAB
&!'(=BBB:2FF/0$1232
8! '! )) "! )J ABAB 7
8 4 ;KBBB : ==2D
'!)78))%)J
78ABAB
page 375
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
1.2. Informal-settlement communities
+!6/0$123!!!
!1! !ABAB&(!
!!!.4H!!)&#IA
&#% AB2BHI H!!!@I !
*!!!
! ! !
(!.!!4!!
44 ! !&#%
AB2B*!!!.4!4!4
!! ! ! !41
! 4.4 . !!!1 !
"AB2=
'!!4 !!
!*( :! ?
5!!.!!!!&#%
AB2B*1!!!!AB2B
&#%AB2B 22F !!! = &(! ! !
7 8 ! ! ! )&# 4 2F
!! ! K=E ! &! '( EBKBBB !! 2=3
! * :! : ABAB 4
! & !.:! 5!
&#%AB2B
*!!!
!! !
! ? 5!
! ! 9!
H! >I) 2333
EK3 '4 ! !!
!4.46L
1.3. Participatory design for community resilience
7!H*!6(
(
! : !
!.I9)$7AB2=AA
H !
(46!!
! !!4 ! !
!I9)$7AB2=2E*
page 376
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
% !! 4 !1!
45
6!!!!!!9)$7AB2=
" !. !
6 ! 6
!!!1!!
!1 4. !!
!1!!!&.
!AB22
)! 1
4 4 ! 1!
4!:! . .!
! ! ! ! *
! ! ! ! 1!
!14.
! &. ! AB22G & M & AB23G )! M
AB22G0M&(AB2K
#!!!(
.9)$7AB2;G9)$7AB2=!
1!! !!? :!
!!!
!1!! !! !
! )? 2333! 6 !
44!#
$ + #$+ ! H
! !I2D4!! !! !!H
! . !!1 !I 2D !!
!! 1! 4!!1
!1!%AB2D
*. 23=B
!1.)!23KB
) )M)ABBDG )ABBK *
1!!2?!.!!!!
! ) M ) ABBD A
!!4)ABBK1
H!! ! 4!
I:1H
!4.!I)M
)ABBD=
+ !!! 4
.! ( ! *
! ! :
!'!AB2D
page 377
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
A *!!N4!!!4(
!O!!!!4
ODEG
E *!:!N4*!
.4!!.4!!
!G
F *!N!H:(
!.!!IDE:!
!
!!4!!4
+!AB2B!
! ! ! .
!!!64
: " !AB2D+ !!
!
!!
!! + 7 +7
'!P?)ABBK
1!!16!!1!
'!4!!14!?
! !! !! 1 !
! /%$ABAB ABAB+
< ) '
<)'141"!1+')
*+')* . !AB2AG $ ! AB2E
'4 !!16! <)'1!
4!!
2. METHODOLOGY
* 5! 6! ! 4 ! . !!
4 "# %"# *! %
23D3G Q 233F 4 ! ! ! ! !
! . * !
4 4 !! !
44!!!!!4
+4!!4!!448
*! ! 4!!!1!
/!!4&!'(
7 8 % ! !
4!4!!
* !! ! ! 9#/? ?
. 4 4 ! 4
!1!
page 378
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
/0$1234!&(!4
&(!
*!4!!*
6!4
*4
44!4
!!! :!6! !
114!!
!
Table 1: Belo Horizonte (BH) online roundtable
Roundtable role Gender Related Community / Role
Participant 1 Male Community A / NGO representative and community member
Participant 2 Male Community A / NGO representative
Participant 3 Female Community B / Kindergarten teacher, community member and volunteer
Participant 4 Male Community B / NGO representative and community member
Mediator Female Lancaster University / Research Associate
Time moderator Male UFMG / Master student
Observer 1 Male UFMG / Professor
Observer 2 Female UEMG / Professor
Observer 3 Female UEMG / PhD candidate
Table 2: Rio de Janeiro (RJ) online roundtable
Roundtable role Gender Related Community / Role
Participant 5 Female Community C / Nurse, doula and community member
Participant 6 Female Community D / Journalist and community member
Participant 7 Male Community D / NGO representative and community member
Participant 8 Female Community D / Educational project founder and community member
Participant 9 Female Community E / Social movement representative and community member
Mediator Female Lancaster University / Research Associate
Time moderator Male UFMG / Master student
Observer 2 Female UEMG / Professor
Observer 3 Female UEMG / PhD candidate
Note: informal-settlement community E refers to an occupied building in RJ. The notes regarding this informal
settlement specifically are identified as ‘RJ (building)’ on the maps (results).
*!!4:! * 4
!*! ?!. 4
!!!!
: 2 GA
GEGF;
+!4:?:
*?4!!4
1 !)<!!!
!!!!
!! 4 6! ! 4 !
'4"< R'"<S 5R$%/ S )<!! R
page 379
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
:"SR)$*!S;<R/R233KS
? !!? ! 4 ! 1
6!'"<5;<!:
=!!!
:
!! 4 ! ! !
4 1! ! 1
.!!. 5
!
/:4!64
!!/0$1231!
9#/? 4 4
/ ! ! 4 ! ).
ABBBFF=1FFK H+!!
I 4
4H!I)2333EDE
3. RESULTS
* !4 4 ! !
!!!49!6&!
'( 4 :4 PBH?9 ! 7 8
4 : 4 PRJ?9 ! %!
! 4 :4PRJ !? * 4
4
Figure 1. Theme 1: news arrival - sources of information, means of communication and impact on
routine.
page 380
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
Figure 2. Theme 2: prevention.
Figure 3. Theme 3: diagnosis and treatment.
Figure 4. Theme 4: support (public sector, institutions and other organisations).
page 381
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
Figure 5. Areas of challenges.
(a)
(b)
Figure 6. Needs related (a) to themes 1, 2, 3 and (b) to themes 4, 5, 6.
page 382
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
4. DISCUSSION
+! !
1!!2
! !! ! !A !1
4. ! !
!6!*!!!
& !
. ! !! ! 1
!!
* ! !. ! ! !
: 4 :
!6 !
! 1! ! !
4/0$1234
/0$123!66!!!
!1! ! !
5!>:4:
* 4
16
*!
*!!4!:
*!!!!!
/0$123
=!
* !! :! ! 4
!4!!!? P?! !!
:! ! /0$123 2
! ! F !
! !? F
!.4!!!9#/
!! 4 /0$123
2AEF"
1!
2166A
>4E !
44! =*!
!:!'!AB2D4
!!!5!!!
2 ; = !! !
1!!!!
page 383
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
5. FUTURES RESEARCH AND LIMITATIONS
* T
4 !!
!*1
!1 ! 1! ! /
: !! : ! 4 !!
4! :!!!:
!! ! !
5*!
! 6 !6 +!!
AB2; " .4! ? !1!
!!
6!! !!*
!!:!!
! 1 !!
!!1
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
<.!!9#/?
4 4 ! !
<!.$%!*.!+!7
ENDNOTES
!"#
$%
&'()"'*+
,&""-"---#&'+."--$
REFERENCES
&$UV9!1)"$+ #ABAB"2A7!
!!!4/0$123ABKKKE$/2B2B2=@)2FKE1
EB33ABEB23;1V
&!880&.&+)!ABAB!!
/0$123FF=BNFK2$/2B2BED@F2;=A1BAB1BDDF1(
&&ABAB"2F78A3ABAB
@@444.@4@!1;A==AE;=
&.+78)!$)!.$M7AB22&!
!6 E221AB$/2BEE3B@EB2BBB2
&1"M&&AB23'4!!(L4.
6!)&!"
#$$EK213$/2B2B2=@>>AB232B22KK
(("$8>!!"!ABAB*!AB23
!/0$123.%E=D=FD3E3;1FBB78A3ABAB
@@@@E=D@=FD3@E3;
page 384
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
80!$"&!ABAB)!'!/0$123<!!1
&!)!"& 3KEEFD1E;K
$/2B2BBK@22;AF1BAB1BBFED1=
9ABAB%''&4)!
$78&<41" AB2E$!
+')*!!1!
42EA;2A1;2K
$/2BFE2FCA 2EAFF
%"23D3&!*)7()
$2FF;EA1;;B$/2BAEBK@A;D;;K
%AB2D#)''%%)
$$.+
%!$ABAB8;!(WN9X!
'4.194!!78!;ABAB
@@@1!(111111!111
@
'$M'&AB2D&!!*$
$!#)!EFFDB13;$/2B22=A@YYBB;2E
()*7$AAB2K@@444.@@
E
&!#:%AB2B#)+,-./.)
01$RAB2B)!!N 7!S7
8&(!&#%
.8#"89>" "%"9(.)".)AB2A
"?')+7)
*.$"EK22D;N2232$/2B2BBK@2B3BB1B2A1
3;=21B
9)!!"'7'!8ABAB"A2$!1230+
)2)"(EDA23=3123KE$/2B2B;=@9%8"ABB;=EB
"ABAB"A=2)3#')
7!EBABAB@@444@@1.11
.1111!1BE1A=1ABAB@
""'."94#$"8'8*)##9
'8&.+Z)M*AB2D+!
!!"#$23
F@;FBA1F23$/2B22BD@8$7&%1BA1AB2K1BB2;
")"). (."<!!7)++)8$<Z
")&'#!+ABAB!E+>!!(
/0$123.)122K2=32AA132A=
$/2B2BKE@ABBFB=F22K
"AB2=1,)+,&11$
"R):!!4++78S
*!778%)[\"
%)78!AABAB
@@444@41@!@AB2=@BE@+:!1CEC2:1
111!11++
/*233K4'567'56)R**
!1!S+!&.
/%1$!ABAB89-.-.()*0
)+ /%$+!$/2B2KDK@3DKBE3E1
+/<! M+!AB2B*7!$7!
"!1'$1$A3A2AK12F2$/2B2BBK@2222E1BB3132EE16
+!+&7"$.88!1"7AB2;
&!)%6!):;K=2BK=12B3F
$/2B22KK@BB2DKABD2;;KBEKF
+"!&!'(ABAB"2K$]2KA3DR$2KA3DS
7!EBABAB@@!=@@%L
^$!M.^2AA=3==
+#!%78ABAB"2=$]F=3KER$
F=3KES7!EBABAB@@>@23@!@
page 385
Fonseca Braga, M., Romeiro Filho,
E., Mendonça, R. M. L. O., Oliveira,
R. G. L. & Pereira, H. G. G. (2020).
Design for Resilience: Mapping the
Needs of Brazilian Communities to
Tackle COVID-19 Challenges.
Strategic Design Research Journal.
Volume 13, number 03, September
– December 2020. 374-386. DOI:
10.4013/sdrj.2020.133.07
)%&19M)+8ABBD14!0#)F2
;12D$/2B2BDB@2;K2BDDBKB2DK;B=D
)'ABBK"!!04+$!"
$A2;K1=37!EBABAB@@@!@;2BA
)!*M"AB227!4!!!!L*4!1
22BE1FA2D1AE2$/2B2BDB@2KFKKD32AB22;3DF3K
)%)J78ABAB8!29_&!$W
R9!$!&!!S78!AABAB
@@>@!@!11B21BK12B123D11122;1AKD11
:11>@
)"!)JABAB8!2&!%!`!/0$1239]
;2@ABABR%!!&!!/0$1239];2@ABABS78!AABAB
@@@@!@:!@11@@ABAB@
!Y!Y!Y;2Y123YB21BK1ABAB12
)2333#'/6/6+
)$*!*7 ADABAB
@@!@!@14!!
).7%ABBB)9$(MQ)!% ;$
AFE;1F;F*/.!)+!
))2333*%FEEEKK1E32
$/2B22KK@BBBAK=F33A23;;EA=
*7"!&&9"!!8"
Z!!9%!"++0!#$&"
#).9$<!88ABAB+!5
!4./0$123++%1) %!
";3KB1K;@@@2B2B2=@>>ABABB=BB;
9!)$7AB2=)#$
$9)$79!)$7#
7!DABAB444@4@@!@;2KFD
9/:$7.7AB2;
-./<0-.3.9)$79/:$7.7#7!D
ABAB444@4@@14.
!"#ABAB:56=) 0/>
!!
12378!AABAB@@444@!1!11
11>11123111111!(@
0"M&(&AB2K41&!"
#$2DEEB=1E23$/2B22BD@8$7&%12B1AB2;1BB;2
<!'!/(ABAB"22*4#0?8')
,)4@!#0/>0//(-.-.7"2AABAB
@@4444@@@!@411!111.1111
:111231112211ABAB
Q7233F$#)(A)+!
page 386
