ArticlePublisher preview available

Examining Agency in Children’s Nonfiction Picture Books

DOI:10.1007/s10583-021-09435-y
Authors:
Margaret Vaughn at Washington State University
Margaret Vaughn
Vera Sotirovska at University of Idaho
Vera Sotirovska
Janine Julianna Darragh at University of Idaho
Janine Julianna Darragh
Mohamed Elhess at Minnesota State University, Mankato
Mohamed Elhess
Read publisher preview
Download citation
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Given increased attention toward nonfiction and informational texts due to recent educational reforms in the nation, it is critical to examine how various cultural identities are depicted in nonfiction children’s picture books. Focusing on the Orbis Pictus honor and awarded texts (n = 60) from 1990 to 2019, this article reports the findings of a critical multicultural analysis of the depictions of age, sex, socio-economic status, ethnicities, and geographic regions of these awarded texts. Using a secondary analysis of opportunities for agency, we examine how focal subjects (Crisp in Lang Arts 92(4):241–255, 2015) exert their agency in their respective contexts. Our aim in doing so is to problematize the notion of agency in these texts, specifically understanding who exerts agency, how, and for what purposes. Findings suggest that the authors of these awarded texts rely on highlighting White, European males where agency is typically depicted as an act that occurs in adulthood. As a result, discussion focuses on how such texts, although well-meaning, perhaps perpetuate the traditional notion and passivity of young children in relation to their agency and calls to question the lack of multiple perspectives and voices in the awarded texts.
  • A preview of this full-text is provided by Springer Nature.
  • Learn more
Preview content only
Content available from Children's Literature in Education
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
Children’s Literature in Education (2022) 53:33–51
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10583-021-09435-y
1 3
ORIGINAL PAPER
Examining Agency inChildren’s Nonfiction Picture Books
MargaretVaughn1 · VeraSotirovska2· JanineJ.Darragh2· MohamedElhess2
Accepted: 4 January 2021 / Published online: 29 January 2021
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature B.V. part of Springer Nature 2021,
corrected publication 2021
Abstract
Given increased attention toward nonfiction and informational texts due to recent
educational reforms in the nation, it is critical to examine how various cultural iden-
tities are depicted in nonfiction children’s picture books. Focusing on the Orbis Pic-
tus honor and awarded texts (n = 60) from 1990 to 2019, this article reports the find-
ings of a critical multicultural analysis of the depictions of age, sex, socio-economic
status, ethnicities, and geographic regions of these awarded texts. Using a secondary
analysis of opportunities for agency, we examine how focal subjects (Crisp in Lang
Arts 92(4):241–255, 2015) exert their agency in their respective contexts. Our aim
in doing so is to problematize the notion of agency in these texts, specifically under-
standing who exerts agency, how, and for what purposes. Findings suggest that the
authors of these awarded texts rely on highlighting White, European males where
agency is typically depicted as an act that occurs in adulthood. As a result, discus-
sion focuses on how such texts, although well-meaning, perhaps perpetuate the tra-
ditional notion and passivity of young children in relation to their agency and calls
to question the lack of multiple perspectives and voices in the awarded texts.
Margaret Vaughn is an associate professor at Washington State University. Her research explores
adaptive and equitable practices to support student agency and literacy learning.
Vera Sotirovska is a doctoral student at the University of Idaho. Her research explores children’s
literature and literacy opportunities to support all learners.
Janine J. Darragh is an associate professor at the University of Idaho. Her research explores
sociocultural issues in children’s and young adult literature.
Mohamed Elhess is a doctoral student at the University of Idaho. His research explores students’
sense of belonging and identity in learning spaces.
In the original publication of the article unfortunately contained a mistake in the name of co-
author Vera Sotirvoska. The correct name should be Vera Sotirovska. The original article has been
corrected.
* Margaret Vaughn
margaret.vaughn@wsu.edu
1 Washington State University, 1155 College Avenue, Pullman, WA99164-2114, USA
2 University ofIdaho, 875 Perimeter Drive, P.O. Box443082, Moscow, ID83844, USA
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Espandendo la conoscenza e la comprensione del mondo circostante da parte dei giovani lettori, la nonfiction può favorire anche l'empatia, rispetto e consapevolezza, contribuendo a formare una generazione di cittadini più informati e coinvolti. L'articolo Examining Agency in Children's Nonfiction Picture Books (Vaughn et al., 2022) esamina la rappresentazione dell'agency nei libri illustrati nonfiction che hanno ricevuto l'onorificenza o il premio Orbis Pictus dal 1990 al 2019, ovvero la capacità di prendere decisioni e di avere un certo grado di controllo sulle proprie azioni e sulle conseguenze che ne derivano, concentrandosi su chi la esercita, come e a quali scopi. I risultati emersi suggeriscono che, valutando criticamente le rappresentazioni di età, sesso, status socio-economico, etnie e regioni geografiche nei libri esaminati, i testi premiati mettono in risalto principalmente uomini bianchi europei e ritraggono l'agency come qualcosa che si verifica principalmente in età adulta, sollevando preoccupazioni sulla passività dei bambini riguardo alla loro agency e alla mancanza di molteplici prospettive e voci espresse nei libri premiati (Vaughn et al., 2022). ...
... L'articolo Examining Agency in Children's Nonfiction Picture Books (Vaughn et al., 2022) esamina la rappresentazione dell'agency nei libri illustrati nonfiction che hanno ricevuto l'onorificenza o il premio Orbis Pictus dal 1990 al 2019, ovvero la capacità di prendere decisioni e di avere un certo grado di controllo sulle proprie azioni e sulle conseguenze che ne derivano, concentrandosi su chi la esercita, come e a quali scopi. I risultati emersi suggeriscono che, valutando criticamente le rappresentazioni di età, sesso, status socio-economico, etnie e regioni geografiche nei libri esaminati, i testi premiati mettono in risalto principalmente uomini bianchi europei e ritraggono l'agency come qualcosa che si verifica principalmente in età adulta, sollevando preoccupazioni sulla passività dei bambini riguardo alla loro agency e alla mancanza di molteplici prospettive e voci espresse nei libri premiati (Vaughn et al., 2022). ...
Creative evolution of children's and adolescents' nonfiction literature. An international perspective. L'evoluzione creativa della letteratura nonfiction per l'infanzia e l'adolescenza. Una prospettiva internazionale
Article
  • Jul 2023
In the field of publishing for children and adolescents, nonfiction literature has not only flourished, but is experiencing a golden age of creativity and reader interest. Today's nonfiction literature moves beyond the boundaries of traditional popular literature in terms of writing methods, content, purpose, and target audience, informing and engaging young readers through the use of a narrative dimension. Authors and illustrators of nonfiction children’s books share historical information, scientific processes, and portray marginalized and minority communities, offering models of active learning. This study examines emerging trends in nonfiction through a narrative literature review and investigates the main changes observed in the variety of topics, storytelling techniques, and the use of visual elements in nonfiction children’s books over the period 2013-2022. At the same time, it attempts to highlight how these developments reflect a cultural shift towards inclusivity and social awareness. https://journals.francoangeli.it/index.php/ess/article/view/15697
View
... Por otra parte, la investigación educativa en torno al libro de no ficción ha experimentado un cambio de rumbo significativo en los últimos años. La aprobación en eeuu de los Common Core State Standards and the Next Generation Science Standards supuso el espaldarazo curricular definitivo para el libro de no ficción (Brugar, 2019;Cain, 2015;Job y Coleman, 2016;Vaughn et al., 2021) que se convirtió en objeto de reflexión crítica y se situó en el centro de propuestas didácticas cuya pretensión era lograr una presencia equilibrada en los procesos de alfabetización frente a la supremacía de las lecturas de ficción (Duke, 2000;Shimek, 2018 Paradójicamente, los estudios centrados en los libros de no ficción han ido descubriendo unas claves con las que identificar a un lector infantil que se explica en el marco del nuevo ecosistema cultural, de tal modo que las características del libro ilustrado de no ficción han condicionado asimismo las producciones ficcionales para identificar una nueva propuesta discursiva. ...
Entre papeles y pantallas. Lecturas no ficcionales de libros ilustrados de ficción
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 2023
En el marco de la sociedad digital, el ecosistema de lectura se modifica en todas sus instancias y propone nuevos desafíos en la formación de lectores (Wolf, 2020). Por ello, resulta de interés analizar los procedimientos de construcción del libro y el álbum ilustrados con el objetivo de determinar las claves con las que se define el lector en la actualidad (Goga et al., 2018; Grilli, 2020; Tabernero-Sala et al., 2022). Con este fin, este artículo de investigación propone identificar la hibridación de lecturas ficcionales y no ficcionales en los libros infantiles como uno de los ejes por los que evoluciona el modo de lectura en los parámetros del siglo xxi en el contexto de formación. Partiendo de las claves de lectura que propone el libro ilustrado de no ficción en el nuevo ecosistema de lectura, se han seleccionado para su análisis, con este objetivo, tres álbumes de ficción significativos en esta línea: Mexique. El nombre del barco de M. J. Ferrada y A. Penyas (Editorial Libros del Zorro Rojo, 2017), Onsen ¿Qué hacen los monos? de Pato Mena (Editorial A buen paso, 2021) y Dos ositos de Ylla (Editorial Kalandraka, 2021). El estudio se ha centrado en la hibridación como procedimiento de construcción del discurso y en los factores que definen un lector curioso esencial en los nuevos modos de lectura. Las conclusiones identifican un lector modelo infantil que combina las lecturas ficcionales con las no ficcionales en la recuperación del clásico “instruir deleitando” horaciano como seña de identidad.
View
... Estos procesos formativos han permitido acercarse a los LINF, que, si bien son herederos de la corriente racionalista del siglo XIX, han proliferado tan vertiginosamente en el marco editorial que es preciso dotar a los docentes de elementos para acercarse críticamente a estos y determinar si son válidos o no para su utilización en el aula (Lartitegui, 2018). Por ello, en los últimos tres años han aflorado investigaciones muy útiles para el profesorado, bien porque se acercan a obras concretas y las analizan con detalle (Colón, 2021;Sampériz, Hernández et al., 2020;Vaughn et al., 2022), bien porque aportan claves para el aula (Calvo et al., 2021;Sampériz, Tabernero et al., 2020b;Sanjuán et al., 2022;Shimek, 2019;Tabernero et al., 2022) o bien porque contribuyen a seleccionar las obras estableciendo criterios de calidad (Goga et al., 2021;, pues las últimas investigaciones apuntan a que los docentes demandan directrices claras para ejercer adecuadamente la mediación lectora y literaria (Neira & Martín-Macho, 2020). ...
Desarrollar el pensamiento crítico con el libro ilustrado de no ficción en el marco del tercer espacio educativo
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2022
Este trabajo estudia las posibilidades que ofrece la implementación de libros ilustrados de no ficción para desarrollar el pensamiento crítico en el alumnado de segundo de Educación Primaria. Desde la creación de un tercer espacio educativo, se diseña e implementa una secuencia didáctica para abordar desde una perspectiva crítica e interdisciplinar los inventos en el área de Ciencias Sociales. Las sesiones fueron grabadas y transcritas para analizar las habilidades de pensamiento crítico que se activaron en el alumnado y las estrategias didácticas aplicadas por los mediadores. Se utilizó un guion de observación para sistematizar la información y se realizó un análisis categórico e interpretativo utilizando NVivo-12. Los resultados indican que las estrategias de lectura compartida aplicadas por los mediadores durante la implementación de la secuencia didáctica fueron efectivas para permitir que el alumnado desarrollara habilidades de pensamiento crítico asociadas al nivel inferencial de comprensión lectora. Se concluye que el libro ilustrado de no ficción y su modelo de lectura constituyen una práctica idónea para propiciar el pensamiento crítico en edades tempranas, incidiendo en el lugar que, en este proceso, ocupa la formación inicial y permanente del profesorado y la ayuda que ofrecen los programas para la innovación educativa.
View
... Además, las investigaciones que se han llevado a cabo hasta ahora se han centrado, en la mayoría de los casos, en el álbum ilustrado narrativo, insistiendo en la "narratología textual" (Duran 2000: 27) y en general en el carácter "narrativo" del álbum ilustrado: carácter que lleva, por ejemplo, a Van der Linden a denominar "narrativo" el álbum donde texto e imagen van de la mano 3 o a Bosch a negar que haya álbumes ilustrados no narrativos (2015: 6) 4 . Solo en los últimos años, investigaciones procedentes de diferentes áreas geográficas se han centrado en otras formas de hibridación del álbum con géneros que van más allá de lo estrictamente narrativo, como el álbum informativo (Barò 2021;Shimek 2018Shimek , 2021Tabernero-Sala et al. 2022;Vaughn et al. 2021) y el álbum poema (Boutevin 2017;Neira Piñeiro 2016. Pero no tenemos constancia de estudios centrados en el álbum dramático, lo cual nos permite afirmar que este trabajo constituye un primer estudio exploratorio de un subgénero que no ha recibido todavía la atención de la crítica. ...
El álbum ilustrado dramático de hoy
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2022
This research reflects for the first time on the dramatic picture book, an emerging literary subgenre of today that has not been studied yet. Analyzing a corpus of works for children and young readers, the role of the iconographic component and its relations with the theatrical text are studied, to find out how the specific characteristics of the dramatic genre are reflected in the format of the picture book: among them, the lack of narrator, the presence of stage directions and dialogues and the scenographic elements.
View
Respuestas lectoras infantiles comparadas ante libros de no ficción narrativos y no narrativos
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 2023
El libro de no ficción ha experimentado un auge en las últimas décadas. El creciente desarrollo de su marco teórico de análisis trasluce la situación editorial en la que se inserta, que camina paralela al desarrollo del libro álbum y el libro ilustrado, con un fuerte predominio del componente visual. Además, en los últimos años ha cobrado especial relevancia la emergencia de un corpus importante de libros de no ficción narrativa, que se encuadra en una ficción marco y posee un carácter híbrido que resulta difícil de definir, desde una perspectiva semiótica. Sin embargo, todavía existe un vacío bibliográfico que atañe a las experiencias de lectura de libros de no ficción por parte de los niños, tanto en el aula como en el ámbito familiar; mayor, si cabe, en lo que concierne a la diferenciación entre lecturas de no ficción narrativa y de no ficción no narrativa, que permitieran una delimitación más precisa de estos conceptos. En esta investigación se ha llevado a cabo, mediante métodos de investigación cualitativos, un análisis de las respuestas lectoras de 34 niños de entre 8 y 9 años de un colegio español a una selección de libros de no ficción no narrativa y no ficción narrativa, atendiendo a sus actitudes y estrategias de lectura.
View
TÜBİTAK Çocuk Hakları Serisi Kitaplarının Konu, Tema, İleti ve Yazınsal İlkeler Açısından İncelenmesiInvestigation of TUBITAK Child Right Picture Book Series in terms of Subject, Theme, Message and Literary and Educational Principles
Article
  • Jul 2023
Alan araştırmaları arasında çocuk hakları ile bilgi veren resimli çocuk kitaplarına ilişkin araştırmaların önemli olduğu düşünüldüğünden bu araştırma ile çocuk haklarıyla ile ilgili bilgi veren resimli çocuk kitaplarının konu ve kurgu, tema, ileti, yazınsal ve eğitsel ilkeler çerçevesinde incelenmesi amaçlanmıştır. Araştırmada nitel araştırma yöntemlerinden doküman analizi yöntemi kullanılmıştır. Veri toplama aracı olarak Sever (2014) tarafından hazırlanan “Çocuk ve Gençlik Edebiyatı Yapıtlarını Değerlendirme Ölçeği” kullanılmıştır. Araştırmada, ölçekte bulunan 8 alt boyuttan “Konu ve Kurgu, İzlek (Tema), İleti, Yazınsal ve Eğitsel İlkeler” boyutları kullanılmıştır. Araştırma kapsamında incelenen çocuk haklarını ele alan resimli çocuk kitaplarının konu ve kurgu bakımından yeterli ve çok iyi oldukları, izlek (tema) bakımından kısmen yeterli, yeterli ve çok iyi oldukları görülmüştür. İncelenen kitapların ileti bakımından ise ve yeterli ve çok iyi oldukları görülmüştür. Son olarak seride yer alan kitapların yazınsal ve eğitsel ilkeler bakımından yeterli ve çok iyi oldukları görülmüştür. Araştırmadan elde edilen sonuçlar incelenen resimli çocuk kitaplarının içerik olarak yeterli ve iyi olduğunu, çocuklara erken yaşlardan itibaren haklarını öğretmek için kullanılabileceğini göstermektedir.
View
Enhancing Educators' Theoretical and Practical Understandings of Critical Literacy
Book
  • Aug 2023
This Element explores ways to promote critical literacy in teacher education. First, the authors define critical literacy in the context of teacher education through established theoretical frameworks and models of critical literacy pedagogy and share their collective findings on critical literacy research over the course of a decade. Building from these theoretical understandings of critical literacy, they outline ways to actualize critical literacy in teacher education as a transformative pedagogy coupled with resources and activities that support equitable teaching practices. Next, they illustrate how adaptive teaching supports critical literacy pedagogy and underscore autoethnography as a reflective tool to engage pre-service teachers in critical literacy practice. They model this approach with mentor text analyses using critical literacy as a lens to facilitate critically-oriented mindsets in teachers through visioning. They conclude with implications for classroom practice at the intersections of critical literacy and teacher preparation and provide directions for future research.
View
Critical Depictions of Agency in Pura Belpré Awarded Texts
Article
Full-text available
Given the need for multiple representations of historically underrepresented voices in children’s literature, this research study explored critical depictions of agency of Latinx youth within the Pura Belpré awarded texts from 1996 to 2021. The findings report a critical multicultural analysis of depictions of age, sex, socio-economic status, ethnicities, and geographic regions of these awarded texts. Using a secondary analysis of opportunities for agency, we examine how focal subjects (Vaughn et al., 2021; Crisp, 2015) exert their agency in their respective contexts. Our aim in doing so is to highlight the notion of agency in these texts of Latinx children and youth, specifically understanding who exerts agency, how, and for what purposes. Implications for practice and future research are discussed.
View
Negotiating Intersectional Identities through Visioning
Article
  • Sep 2021
Through a collaborative self-study approach, a critical discussion of visioning is presented that focuses on the perspectives of two international students from southeastern Europe and North Africa. The authors explore their visions as doctoral students in light of recent changes to immigration policies in the United States. Discussion centers on their evolving visions as emerging scholars, teachers, and doctoral students considering the complexities of the current cultural and racial conditions in the United States. The paper has implications for the preparation of future professors and scholars of education broadly and reminds educators to open more inclusive and equitable spaces in education.
View
The Portrayal of Characters with Dyslexia in Children’s Picture Books
Article
Full-text available
Children's literature can be a useful tool to share the experiences of students with disabilities. Given the increased focus on dyslexia legislation in schools across the United States, it is important to examine how characters with reading differences, specifically dyslexia, are portrayed in picture books and the role these artifacts play in equitable pedagogical practices. We conducted a critical content analysis, focusing on characters with dyslexia in picture books and the literacy opportunities, barriers, and consequences. Findings show an imbalance in representation regarding race, ethnicity, and geographic location. While some picture books portray characters with self-advocacy and agency, others perpetuate stereotypical "blueprints" for characters with dyslexia with limited children's school experiences, classroom interactions, and peer exchanges. We conclude that characters with dyslexia should resemble people from the real world, embodying complexity just as they would outside their storied lives. Findings and implications for practice are discussed.
View
“Beyond the Boundaries:” Negotiations of Space, Place, Body and Subjectivity in YA Fiction
Article
Full-text available
Where and how do I belong? As Erin Spring (2016a) notes in her examination of space, place, and youth engagement with literature, “young adult fiction is fraught with implications for identity, of which place often takes center stage” (p. 432). Yet despite the ubiquity of adolescent characters’ negotiations within and across physical and cultural spaces in contemporary texts for young people, few scholars address the interconnectedness of those spheres with perceptions of subjectivity and the material body. Drawing on the theoretical framework of feminist cultural geography (Massey, 1994; Rose, 1993) and relevant scholarship on conceptualizations of the body (i.e., Butler, 1990; Longhurst, 2001), I aim to uncover some of the ways in which young protagonists respond to the perceived barriers, boundaries, and borders of their bodies, subjectivities, and worlds—including the subtle ways in which they actively shape and redefine them (Bavidge, 2006). In addition to examining the experiences of displaced or somehow othered protagonists in three works of youth fiction—Sonya Harnett’s Surrender, Jacqueline Woodson’s Brown Girl Dreaming, and Thanhha Lai’s Inside Out & Back Again—I consider how literary spatial analyses of subjectivity and body might enable readers to critically reflect on the real world constraints and freedoms encountered by young people across the spaces and places of their everyday lives.
View
Navigating Award‐Winning Nonfiction Children's Literature
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2019
Nonfiction children's literature has changed in recent years, including an increase in organizational, design, and text features. The authors conducted a content analysis of 112 nonfiction award‐winning and honor books from 2000 to 2018 to examine how the books have changed over time. The authors discuss the patterns, changes, and complexities found in nonfiction children's literature and provide text sets and guiding questions for classroom instruction and exploration of three features that appear in books in a variety of ways and may be challenging for students: atypical text, graphics with information, and supplemental expository information.
View
View
View
Student Agency in Literacy: Validation of the Student Agency Profile (StAP)
Article
  • Jul 2020
There have been recent calls to support student agency in the field of literacy. Agency, which we define in the context of schooling, is a multidimensional construct where individuals exert influence and create opportunities in the learning context through intentions, decisions, and actions. We propose highlighting agency as an interconnected construct, which includes self-perception as readers and writers, intentionality, choice-making, persistence, and interactiveness. Elementary students (n = 1,726) completed surveys of their agency along with standardized literacy assessments. Statistical analyses largely aligned with the hypothesized dimensions of agency. Relationships to student literacy achievement were stronger in grades 3rd–5th than in 1st–2nd grades. Discussion highlights how elementary students have a voice in their agency as it pertains to literacy. Implications for future research and practice are discussed.
View
Student Agency in Literacy: A Systematic Review of the Literature
Article
  • Jul 2020
Scholars contend that agency is at the heart of cultivating equitable learning spaces for all learners. While it is intuitive that literacy educators support agency during instruction, there is diverse terminology surrounding the concept of agency in the field. As a result, aligning the construct to instructional practices and developing a conceptual understanding of agency in practice has been challenging. Our research team completed a systematic literature review of agency during literacy instruction. In this article, we describe findings of this review of empirical research on agency in literacy spanning from 1975–2017. Findings highlight the complexities associated with defining agency as well as the need for diverse methodological approaches to examining agency in literacy contexts.
View
Where to from Here: Fostering Agency across Landscapes
Article
  • Dec 2019
This culminating article synthesizes the collection of articles to discuss conceptualizations of student agency across contexts. Themes that exist across the collection of articles include agency as multidimensional, agency as a navigational tool, and agency as advocacy. In this concluding article, ideas from across the articles are presented to define and describe student agency and identify the benefits that come from agency in schools. A focus is examining where to from here with implications for educators, administrators, teacher educators, researchers, and policy makers on ways to cultivate student agency in classrooms today.
View
What is Student Agency and Why is it Needed Now More than Ever?
Article
  • Dec 2019
In this article, research tracing the historical progression of agency within recent educational reforms and empirical research from a variety of classrooms (geographic regions and grade levels) is discussed to document the power of agency across contexts. This article aims to propose a collaborative way of thinking about student agency from across the literature and provides insight into how to promote agency in classrooms today. A main focus is placed on examining structures and supports conducive to supporting student agency.
View
View
Using Multicultural Picture Books to Promote Racial Justice in Urban Early Childhood Literacy Classrooms
Article
Recent census data indicate that student populations in U.S. classrooms continue to become increasingly racially diverse. Despite these changes, many early childhood teachers remain reluctant to teach children about race and racial justice. In this article, I argue that multicultural picture books can and should be used to promote racial awareness and racial justice among young children. I discuss reasons why early childhood teachers should abandon colorblind approaches to race and racism in their classrooms. Then, I provide a framework of multiple approaches to teaching children about race through multicultural picture books. Practical considerations are presented.
View