ArticlePDF Available

Histrionic personality disorder: Definition, clinical profiles, differential diagnosis and therapeutic framework

Authors:

Abstract

Starting from the general concept of “histrionic personality”, the present work focuses on the essential aspects of personality disorder that define the clinical and diagnostic contexts, laying the foundations for a correct differential diagnosis, without neglecting the neural characteristics developed by the scientific community. The discussion ends with the best suggested therapeutic approaches
001
Citation: Perrotta G (2021) Histrionic personality disorder: De nition, clinical pro les, differential diagnosis and therapeutic framework. Arch Community Med Public Health
7(1): 001-005. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/2455-5479.000123
https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/acmphDOI:
2455-5479ISSN:
MEDICAL GROUP
Abstract
Starting from the general concept of “histrionic personality”, the present work focuses on the essential aspects of personality disorder that de ne the clinical and
diagnostic contexts, laying the foundations for a correct differential diagnosis, without neglecting the neural characteristics developed by the scienti c community. The
discussion ends with the best suggested therapeutic approaches.
Mini Review
Histrionic personality disorder:
De nition, clinical pro les,
differential diagnosis and
therapeutic framework
Giulio Perrotta*
Psychologist sp.ing in Strategic Psychotherapy, Forensic Criminologist, Lawyer sp.ed SSPL, Researcher,
Essayist, Italy
Received: 18 December, 2020
Accepted: 04 January, 2021
Published: 05 January, 2021
*Corresponding authors: Dr. Giulio Perrotta,
Psychologist sp.ing in Strategic Psychotherapy,
Forensic Criminologist, Lawyer sp.ed SSPL, Researcher,
Essayist, Italy, E-mail:
https://www.peertechz.com
Contents of the manuscript
Histrionic personality disorder is a personality disorder in
Cluster B of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-V) [1], in which impulsivity,
high emotionality and drama predominate, along with
Borderline, Antisocial and Narcissistic Disorder. It is essentially
characterised by intense emotionality, expressed in a theatrical
manner, and by constant attempts to obtain attention, approval
and support from others through covert or overtly seductive
behaviour; in addition to the dramatic and inappropriately
seductive interpersonal style, impressionability, a tendency to
somatisation and novelty seeking characterise this disorder.
This disorder would appear to be more common among women
than men, but this could be due to cultural conditioning of the
diagnoses rather than a real difference in distribution between
the sexes [2,3].
One of the most widely accepted aetiological theories for
histrionic personality disorder is that it has a dual origin:
biological and psychosocial. From the biological point of
view, people suffering from this disorder are said to have
a temperament characterised by hypersensitivity and an
external search for grati cation. On the psychosocial level,
people who have developed histrionic personality disorder
often experienced dif culties in satisfying their legitimate
needs for attention and care during childhood. Some of these
persons were appreciated by signi cant gures, particularly
their parents, for their pleasant appearance and for their skills
as entertainers, rather than for their way of being, so they
learned that, in order to satisfy their affective needs, one must
use physical appearance and seductiveness. Other people with
these disorders received attention and care as children only
when they were ill, so they learned to seek care only through
physical complaints [2,4-7].
For a diagnosis of histrionic personality disorder, patients
must present a persistent pattern of excessive emotionality
and attention-seeking, characterised by at least ve of the
following clinical signs [3].
a) Distress when they are not the centre of attention.
b) Interaction with others that is inappropriately sexually
seductive or provocative.
c) Changeable instability and often shallow expression of
emotions.
d) Constant use of physical appearance to draw attention
to themselves.
002
https://www.peertechz.com/journals/archives-of-community-medicine-and-public-health
Citation: Perrotta G (2021) Histrionic personality disorder: De nition, clinical pro les, differential diagnosis and therapeutic framework. Arch Community Med Public Health
7(1): 001-005. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/2455-5479.000123
e) Language that is extremely impressionistic and vague.
f) Dramatisation of the self, theatricality, and extravagant
expression of emotions.
g) Suggestibility (they are easily in uenced by others or
situations).
h) Interpretation of relationships as more intimate than
they are.
In addition, symptoms must begin in early adulthood.
Comorbidities are common, especially other personality
disorders (antisocial, borderline, narcissistic) [8,9], suggesting
that these disorders share a biological vulnerability or
questioning whether histrionic personality disorder is a separate
disorder. Common are anxiety, mood, depressive, bipolar and
somatic disorders, as well as delusional and paranoid symptoms,
addictions and sexual behaviour disorders, and often simulated
attempts at suicide risk (to attract attention) [3,10-35]. In the
new nosographic formulation contained in the PICI-1 (version
TA), histrionic disorder retains its characteristics, but is better
integrated with the symptomatology shared with the other
disorders in its cluster [36-38].
Histrionic personality disorder can be distinguished
from other personality disorders based on the following
characteristics: [3].
Narcissistic personality disorder
Patients with narcissistic personality disorder also seek
attention, but unlike those with histrionic personality disorder,
they want to feel admired or elevated; patients with histrionic
personality disorder are not as demanding about the kind of
attention they receive and do not mind being thought of as cute
or silly.
Borderline personality disorder
Patients with borderline personality disorder see themselves
as bad and feel emotions intensely and deeply; those with
histrionic personality disorder do not see themselves as bad,
although their dependence on the reaction of others may result
from low self-esteem.
Dependent personality disorder
Patients with dependent personality disorder, like those
with histrionic personality disorder, try to be close to others,
but are more anxious, inhibited, and submissive (because
they are worried about rejection); patients with histrionic
personality disorder are less inhibited and more exuberant.
People with histrionic personality disorder feel
uncomfortable or unappreciated when they are not the centre
of attention. For this reason they continually try to capture
the interest of others with behaviour that is theatrical (e.g.
exaggeration of life episodes, invention of stories, dramatic
descriptions of their physical and emotional state), provocative
(e.g. instigation) or seductive (e.g. attery, sexual provocation,
gifts). These persons may initially fascinate new acquaintances
by their enthusiasm, hyper-sociability, tendency to involve,
display of con dence and seductiveness. In particular, their
seductive behaviour is inappropriate in inappropriate contexts
(e.g. at work) and also towards people for whom they have no
real emotional or sexual interest (e.g. employers, friends). The
body can be used to attract the attention of others, becoming
not only seductive, but also sick. The focus on the approval
of others, rather than on one’s own internal experiences,
results in a propensity to consider oneself only in relation to
others and, therefore, to experience a poor sense of personal
identity. Dramatic and super cial emotional expression is
another distinctive feature of this disorder. People suffering
from histrionic personality disorder have intense and blatant
emotional displays (e.g. crying uncontrollably over a minor
event, hugging people they have only just met), which are
up and die quickly and do not seem to be experienced in
depth. These people can be accused of simulating feelings
that they would not authentically experience. In particular,
the communication style of people with histrionic personality
disorder is theatrical (e.g., gesticulating, use of facial
expressions), impressionistic and lacking in detail: these people
may express opinions convincingly, but the underlying reasons
are often lacking in data and details to support them. Another
characteristic feature of histrionic personality disorder is that
people consider their relationships to be more intimate than
they really are (e.g. regarding an acquaintance as a close friend,
fantasising about acquaintances in a romantic way, allowing
themselves to call people they have just met by their rst
name). In reality, sufferers have dif culty in achieving genuine
emotional intimacy with the people with whom they relate. In
their relationships, they may, for example, play a part (e.g., the
victim, the princess) or try to control the other person through
emotional manipulation and seduction, without being aware
of it. They are extremely dependent on external attention,
approval and support, are very sensitive to rejection and
fearful of separation. In order to avoid relationship breakdown,
they may resort to extreme behaviour aimed at attracting the
attention of the other person (e.g. sexual promiscuity, self-
harm, suicide attempts). In relationships, they may seek out
authority gures to whom they attribute extraordinary gifts
and magical solutions to their problems. Another characteristic
of people with this disorder is a high degree of suggestibility:
their opinions and feelings can be easily in uenced by the
beliefs and moods of others, by impressions and enthusiasms
of the moment, by simple circumstances. Personal values
and interests, for example, may vary with the values and
interests of the partner of the moment. They may also be
intolerant of frustration and exposed to boredom, so they may
seek immediate grati cation of their needs (e.g. abandoning
a project after initial enthusiasm because it is tiring) and
considerable stimulation (e.g. seeking new and exciting
activities such as promiscuous sex, neglecting a lasting
relationship and seeking excitement in a new relationship).
People with histrionic personality disorder are often concerned
about their physical appearance and take great care of it (e.g.
they spend a considerable amount of time, energy and money
on clothing and body care) as a means of attracting attention to
themselves. These people frequently seek compliments on their
003
https://www.peertechz.com/journals/archives-of-community-medicine-and-public-health
Citation: Perrotta G (2021) Histrionic personality disorder: De nition, clinical pro les, differential diagnosis and therapeutic framework. Arch Community Med Public Health
7(1): 001-005. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/2455-5479.000123
appearance and can be easily and excessively upset by a critical
comment on it. The manifestation of histrionic personality
disorder may be in uenced by sex-role stereotypes, whereby a
man and a woman with this disorder may embody caricatures
of masculinity (the athletic, womanizing ‘macho’) and
femininity (the over-emotional, aesthetically well-groomed
‘femme fatale’) respectively. On the other hand, this disorder
can also manifest itself in men in the form of approval-
seeking and passive behaviour [10]. A recent study has shown
that histrionic individuals, such as borderline and narcissistic
individuals, have very high levels of alexithymia and thus a low
ability to recognise their own and other people’s emotions [14].
Certain features of histrionic personality disorder can also
be found in other disorders, from which this disorder should be
distinguished. Rapidly changing emotions, attention-seeking
and manipulative behaviour, for example, are also characteristic
of borderline personality disorder, but in the latter there is
also self-destructiveness, angry breakdowns of interpersonal
relationships and more intense states of emptiness and altered
identity. Both people with histrionic personality disorder and
those with antisocial personality disorder tend to be super cial,
manipulative, seductive, impulsive and in search of new and
exciting situations, but the former, unlike the latter, show
more intense emotional reactions, typically do not engage in
antisocial behaviour and carry out manipulations to obtain
attention and care, rather than pro t, power and material
grati cation. Narcissistic personality disorder sufferers also
crave the attention of others, but whereas they usually seek
praise for their supposed superiority, histrionic personality
disorder sufferers are also willing to appear fragile and
dependent in order to gain attention. Narcissistic personality
disorder sufferers may also exaggerate the intimacy of their
relationships, but generally emphasise the social or economic
position of their acquaintances. People with dependent
personality disorder are also highly dependent on others
for praise and support, but they do not have the excessive
emotionality and theatrical style that characterises histrionic
personality disorder [10].
Sufferers of this disorder can compromise their emotional,
social and professional relationships by implementing
strategies that tend to be manipulative. The theatrical
interpersonal style may lead others to consider them super cial
and inauthentic. Pressing and dramatic demands for help and
care (e.g. showing fear or being very depressed, threatening
or attempting suicide), carried out when one feels that one is
not considered or has to face life’s dif culties alone, may drive
away exasperated partners, relatives and friends. Provocative
or seductive behaviour can also be perceived by people of the
same sex as threatening to their relationship and can lead to
competitiveness or distance in the relationship. At work, this
behaviour may be inappropriate and may lead to low esteem or
devaluation at work [12].
It is useful to analyse the psychological characteristics of
individuals with histrionic personality disorder in terms of
their views of themselves and others, intermediate and deep-
seated beliefs, coping strategies and core emotions [11,14].
Self-image
Since they feel inadequate and vulnerable to being ignored,
they manifest a compensatory self-image of fashionable people
who make their mark and therefore deserve attention.
View of others
They view others favourably as long as they manage to
attract their attention, entertainment and affection. They try
to form strong alliances with others, with the condition that
they are at the centre of the group and that others play the role
of attentive audience. In contrast to narcissistic personalities,
histrionics are very involved in minute-to-minute interactions
with others and their self-esteem depends on receiving
continuous expressions of appreciation.
Intermediate and deep beliefs
Histrionics may have rules that fall under intermediate
beliefs, such as ‘you should express your feelings’, ‘you should
be funny’, ‘you should show others that they have hurt you’.
Some of their assumptions are “if I entertain or amuse others
then I am worthy”, “if I fail to capture the attention of others,
then I am worthless, others will abandon me”, “if others do not
respond, they are unfair”, “if I fail to capture their attention,
I am powerless”. Deep-seated beliefs are “I am fundamentally
unattractive” and compensatory beliefs include “I am lovable,
funny and interesting”, “I am deserving of admiration”,
“people are there to admire me and I make my bet”, “they
don’t have the right, they deny me my due”.
Coping strategies
They use dramatisation and demonstrate in every way to
keep people attached to them. When they fail to do so, they
believe they are being treated unfairly, and try to gain approval
through theatrical expressions of grief and anger: they cry,
engage in aggressive behaviour, attempt suicide, etc.
Main emotions
The most prevalent is joy, often combined with hilarity
and other high-tone emotions when successfully entertaining
people. Histrionic individuals usually experience an
undercurrent of anxiety and mild dysphoria, re ecting fear of
rejection. When they are rejected, their emotion can quickly
change to anger or sadness.
Studies showing which treatments are effective in treating
histrionic personality disorder are currently scarce. Among
the treatments with some evidence of effectiveness are the
following. The preferred treatment is individual psychotherapy,
accompanied by pharmacotherapy if necessary. Psychodynamic
psychotherapy, postulating that the basic dynamic in people
suffering from histrionic personality disorder is the unresolved
attempt to have all their needs satis ed by someone else,
attempts to identify with the patient the origin of this dynamic
and the so-called neurotic strategies (e.g. seduction, illogical
thinking) used to satisfy their needs. A distinctive feature of
this type of treatment is the interpretation of the transference
(emotions and thoughts experienced in a past signi cant
004
https://www.peertechz.com/journals/archives-of-community-medicine-and-public-health
Citation: Perrotta G (2021) Histrionic personality disorder: De nition, clinical pro les, differential diagnosis and therapeutic framework. Arch Community Med Public Health
7(1): 001-005. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/2455-5479.000123
relationship and shifted to a current gure) of the patient
towards the therapist. Although the evidence for the ef cacy
of group treatments for this disorder is currently scarce,
psychodynamic group psychotherapy seems to be effective
for histrionic patients who present greater dif culties and
suffering. The group context, in fact, would help them to
modulate both the transference with the therapist and the
search for attention, approval and care. The literature also
contains protocols for the treatment of these people as a couple.
Such treatment is usually required after strong disagreements
within the couple or because of an imminent threat of
separation. Sperry and Maniacci have developed a treatment
that integrates the systemic, psychodynamic and cognitive-
behavioural approaches and is aimed at couples consisting of
one partner with histrionic personality disorder and the other
partner with obsessive-compulsive personality disorder (this
type of couple is frequently formed because in it the partners
assume complementary roles, such as ‘support seeker’ and
‘responsibility taker’). This treatment process involves three
phases: establishing the therapeutic alliance, restoring balance
within the couple and modifying the partners’ individual
dynamics. The rst two phases involve both partners at the
same time, while the third is carried out in individual sessions.
In the case of histrionic personality disorder, pharmacological
therapy is essentially used to support individual psychotherapy.
This recourse occurs when the patient presents symptoms such
as depression, anxiety and physical symptoms of psychological
origin (e.g. psychogenic migraine). In particular, in the presence
of depression, cyclic antidepressants or serotoninergics
may be indicated, while in the presence of depressive
symptoms accompanied by intense sensitivity to rejection,
desperate attention-seeking, pretentiousness, hyperphagia
and hypersomnia, anti-MAO drugs are the most effective.
SSRIs such as uoxetine and sertraline have been shown to
be effective for people with greater dif culties, particularly
those with emotional instability and impulsiveness. Within the
framework of cognitive behavioural therapy, several treatment
programmes have been implemented for personality disorders.
The following treatments have already shown some evidence of
effectiveness in treating histrionic personality disorder. Beck
and Freeman’s cognitive therapy for personality disorders is a
cognitive-behavioural treatment that focuses on recognising
and challenging dysfunctional beliefs about oneself, others and
the world. These beliefs are said to be generated by distortions
of reality (cognitive distortions) and to constitute cognitive
schemata (basic cognitive structures that allow experience
and behaviour to be organised). In the treatment of histrionic
personality disorder, the patient is rst of all helped to identify
his emotions, thoughts and the events to which they are related,
as he would nd it dif cult to carry out these operations. This
work, together with the evaluation of the consequences of
one’s actions, would help the patient to lower his dysfunctional
impulsiveness. Then the therapist works with the patient to
identify and modify his dysfunctional central beliefs: “I am
inadequate and unable to manage my life”, “I must be loved
by everyone to be of value” and “The loss of a relationship
is disastrous”. The belief that one is incapable of taking care
of oneself leads people with this disorder to constantly seek
attention and care from others. The second belief induces
rejection sensitivity, approval seeking, and the urge to act
in relation to others in order to capture their attention and
approval. The belief that the interruption of an emotional
relationship can be disastrous also encourages these people
to maintain unsatisfactory and inauthentic relationships and,
therefore, maintains their sense of inability to cope on their
own and their feeling of inauthenticity. The modi cation of
these beliefs is implemented by resorting to various techniques
(e.g. imaginative techniques, behavioural experiments,
assertiveness exercises, problem solving) that help the patient
to increase their sense of ef cacy. The therapeutic process takes
place through the so-called collaborative empiricism, whereby
it is the patient who gradually identi es and learns to meet his
or her own needs in functional ways, rather than still expecting
others to do so or an omnipotent, saviour-like therapist to do
so. For one subtype of patients, a behavioural intervention that
can be integrated with Beck and Freeman’s therapy has also
proved effective: social skills training aimed, in particular, at
modulating emotions and impulsive behaviour and developing
empathy (by focusing on the emotions and needs of others).
Jeffrey Young’s schema-focused therapy is a treatment that
integrates the cognitive-behavioural approach with object
relations and Gestalt approaches. According to this approach,
the dysfunctional patterns of ‘emotional deprivation’ (a belief
that other people will not provide the emotional support the
person needs), ‘imperfection’ (a belief that one is imperfect,
inadequate and unpleasant or inferior to others) and ‘approval
seeking’ (a belief that one must always seek acceptance at
the expense of a real sense of self) are active in patients with
histrionic personality disorder. The central aim of this type of
therapy is the identi cation and modi cation of these patterns,
through cognitive, relational, experiential and behavioural
strategies (e.g. cognitive restructuring, corrective emotional
experiences, empathic confrontation, imaginative exercises,
homework) [3,10,13,39-41].
References
1. APA (2013) DSM-V, Washington.
2. French JH, Shrestha S (2020) Histrionic Personality Disorder. In StatePearls.
Link: http://bit.ly/3hJVtiK
3. Perrotta G (2019) Psicologia clinica. Luxco Ed., 1st ed.
4. Perrotta G (2020)Bisexuality: de nition, humanistic pro les, neural correlates
and clinical hypotheses. J Neuroscience and Neurological Surgery 6. Link:
https://bit.ly/2LpzwJx
5. Perrotta G (2020)Human mechanisms of psychological defence: de nition,
historical and psychodynamic contexts, classi cations and clinical pro les.
Int J Neurorehabilitation Eng 7: 1000360. Link: http://bit.ly/2LiUn1p
6. Perrotta G (2019)The reality plan and the subjective construction of one’s
perception: the strategic theoretical model among sensations, perceptions,
defence mechanisms, needs, personal constructs, beliefs system, social
in uences and systematic errors. J Clinical Research and Reports 1. Link:
https://bit.ly/3hPoGsz
7. Perrotta G (2020)Dysfunctional attachment and psychopathological
outcomes in childhood and adulthood. Open J Trauma 4: 012-021. Link:
http://bit.ly/2Xo4LYx
005
https://www.peertechz.com/journals/archives-of-community-medicine-and-public-health
Citation: Perrotta G (2021) Histrionic personality disorder: De nition, clinical pro les, differential diagnosis and therapeutic framework. Arch Community Med Public Health
7(1): 001-005. DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.17352/2455-5479.000123
8. Perrotta G (2020)Narcissism and psychopathological pro les: de nitions,
clinical contexts, neurobiological aspects and clinical treatments. J Clin Cases
Rep 4: 12-25. Link: https://bit.ly/2X8wzzF
9. Perrotta G (2020)Borderline Personality Disorder: de nition, differential
diagnosis, clinical contexts and therapeutic approaches. Ann Psychiatry
Tream 4: 043-056. Link: http://bit.ly/3rTWR71
10. Gabbard GO (2007) Psichiatria psicodinamica. Cortina Editore, Milano.
11. Perrotta G (2019) Psicologia dinamica. Luxco Ed., 1th ed.
12. Novais F, Araújo A, Godinho P (2015) Historical roots of histrionic personality
disorder. Front Psychol 6: 1463. Link: http://bit.ly/3oePG7n
13. Perrotta G (2019) Psicologia generale, Luxco Ed., 1st ed.
14. Ritzl A, Csukly G, Balázs K, Égerházi A (2018) Facial emotion recognition
de cits and alexithymia in borderline, narcissistic, and histrionic personality
disorders. Psychiatry Res 270: 154-159. Link: http://bit.ly/3rVuR32
15. Perrotta G (2019)Tic disorder: de nition, clinical contexts, differential
diagnosis, neural correlates and therapeutic approaches. J Neurosci Rehab
2019: 1-6. Link: https://bit.ly/3okeCdy
16. Perrotta G (2019)Anxiety disorders: de nitions, contexts, neural correlates
and strategic therapy. J Neur Neurosci 6: 046. Link: http://bit.ly/3hGJwuf
17. Perrotta G (2019)Neural correlates in eating disorders: De nition,
contexts and clinical strategies. J Pub Health Catalog 2: 137-148. Link:
https://bit.ly/3cTvr9m
18. Perrotta G (2019)Post-traumatic stress disorder: De nition, contexts, neural
correlations and cognitive-behavioral therapy. J Pub Health Catalog 2: 40-47.
Link: https://bit.ly/2WMQCo1
19. Perrotta G (2019)Sleep-wake disorders: De nition, contexts and neural
correlations. J Neurol Psychol 7: 09. Link: http://bit.ly/2MzwZxa
20. Perrotta G (2019)Depressive disorders: De nitions, contexts, differential
diagnosis, neural correlates and clinical strategies. Arch Depress Anxiety 5:
009-033. Link: http://bit.ly/2zSl1Zh
21. Perrotta G (2019)Panic disorder: de nitions, contexts, neural correlates and
clinical strategies. Curr Tr Clin Med Sci 1: 2019. Link: http://bit.ly/2Xk0d4T
22. Perrotta G (2019)Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: de nition, contexts, neural
correlates and clinical strategies. Cienti c Journal of Neurology 1: 08-16. Link:
https://bit.ly/3hGJ5A7
23. Perrotta G (2019)Behavioral addiction disorder: de nition, classi cations,
clinical contexts, neural correlates and clinical strategies. J Addi Adol Behav
2. Link: http://bit.ly/3pPYf96
24. Perrotta G (2019)Delusions, paranoia and hallucinations: de nitions,
differences, clinical contexts and therapeutic approaches. Cienti c Journal of
Neurology 1: 22-28.
25. Perrotta G (2019)Paraphilic disorder: de nition, contexts and clinical
strategies. Journal of Addiction Neuro Research, Neuro Research 1: 4. Link:
http://bit.ly/3q1OlRV
26. Perrotta G (2019)Internet gaming disorder in young people and adolescent: A
narrative review. J Addi Adol Beh 2. Link: https://bit.ly/3rTbAyZ
27. Perrotta G (2019)Bipolar disorder: de nition, differential diagnosis, clinical
contexts and therapeutic approaches. J Neuroscience Neurological Surgery
5. Link: https://bit.ly/3hKPdqM
28. Perrotta G (2020)Psychological trauma: de nition, clinical contexts, neural
correlations and therapeutic approaches Recent Discoveries. Curr Res
Psychiatry Brain Disord CRPBD-100006. Link: http://bit.ly/3gbRCto
29. Perrotta G (2020)Suicidal risk: de nition, contexts, differential diagnosis,
neural correlates and clinical strategies. J Neuroscience Neurological Surgery
6: 114. Link: http://bit.ly/3hUtVaF
30. Perrotta G (2020)Pathological gambling in adolescents and adults: de nition,
clinical contexts, differential diagnosis, neural correlates and therapeutic
approaches. ES J Neurol 1: 1004. Link: https://bit.ly/3rT9H5A
31. Perrotta G (2020)Pedophilia: de nition, classi cations, criminological and
neurobiological pro les and clinical treatments. A complete review. Open J
Pediatr Child Health 5: 019-026. Link: http://bit.ly/2XdyjI9
32. Perrotta G (2020)The concept of altered perception in “body dysmorphic
disorder”: the subtle border between the abuse of sel es in social networks
and cosmetic surgery, between socially accepted dysfunctionality and
the pathological condition. J Neurol Neurol Sci Disord 6: 001-007. Link:
http://bit.ly/2DOAM5n
33. Perrotta G (2020)Sexual orientations: a critical review of psychological,
clinical and neurobiological pro les. Clinical hypothesis of homosexual
and bisexual positions. Int J Sex Reprod Health Care 3: 027-041. Link:
http://bit.ly/3pLwaQb
34. Perrotta G (2020)Cuckolding and Troilism: de nitions, relational and clinical
contexts, emotional and sexual aspects and neurobiological pro les. A
complete review and investigation into the borderline forms of the relationship:
Open Couples, Polygamy, Polyamory. Ann Psychiatry Treatm 4: 037-042. Link:
http://bit.ly/38fDdKZ
35. Perrotta G (2020)Dysfunctional sexual behaviors: de nition, clinical contexts,
neurobiological pro les and treatments. Int J Sex Reprod Health Care 3: 061-
069. Link: https://bit.ly/356izLi
36. Perrotta G (2020)Perrotta Integrative Clinical Interview. LK ed., I ed., 270. Link:
https://bit.ly/2Lpz6CX
37. Perrotta G (2020)The structural and functional concepts of personality: The
new Integrative Psychodynamic Model (IPM), the new Psychodiagnostic
Investigation Model (PIM) and the two clinical interviews for the analysis
of personality disorders (Perrotta Integrative Clinical Interview or PICI-1).
Psychiatry. Link: http://bit.ly/35bcpts
38. Perrotta G (2020)First revision of the Psychodiagnostic Investigation Model
(PIM-1R) and elaboration proposal of a clinical interview for the analysis of
personality disorders (Perrotta Integrative Clinical Interview or PICI-1) for
adults, teenagers and children, Psychiatry.
39. Perrotta G (2020)The strategic clinical model in psychotherapy: theoretical
and practical pro les. Journal of Addiction and Adolescent Behaviour 3: 5.
Link: http://bit.ly/3n8Ecko
40. Perrotta G (2020)Accepting “change” in psychotherapy: from consciousness
to awareness. J Addiction Research and Adolescent Behaviour 3.
41. Perrotta G (2020)Neonatal and infantile abuse in a family setting. Open J
Pediatr Child Health 5: 034-042. Link: https://bit.ly/3hGHaeG
Copyright: © 2021 Perrotta G. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
... Histrionic personality disorder (HPD) is a less common disorder with prevalence rates ranging (depending of the source) from 0.6% to 1-3% (Babl et al., 2023). People with HPD are ego-syntonic and believe their behavior is normal, leading to underdiagnosis until the disorder affects productivity and relationships (French & Shrestha, 2022). Establishing a trusting therapeutic alliance between healthcare providers and HPD sufferers is crucial for effective medical care. ...
... After psychiatric assessment, she was diagnosed with HPD, also known as dramatic personality disorder, with exaggerated emotionality and attention-seeking behaviors. This disorder causes feelings of undervaluation and neglect, leading to border-crossing behaviors in therapy, such as extreme neediness and requesting special attention from therapists (Babl et al., 2023;French & Shrestha, 2022). A physician and psychologist employing a personality-type can enhance motivation, ensuring appropriate actions and understanding of the condition. ...
... Personality disorders (PD), stemming from problematic interpersonal behavior, significantly impact treatment compliance and interventions with each type requiring a unique approach to overcoming psychological barriers (Kruisdijk et al., 2020). Patients' personalities, encompassing ideas, emotions, and behavioral patterns, influence their psychological, social well-being, and disease acceptance, particularly for those with specific PD traits like high negative emotionality, associated with increased risk of chronic illnesses and worse prognosis (French & Shrestha, 2022;Lahey, 2009). ...
Article
Full-text available
Cauda Equina Syndrome (CES) becomes more common as the population ages, making diagnosis challenging and leading to underdiagnosis and poor management. Person-centered care is crucial for successful rehabilitation outcomes, and patient’s personality influences it. Female, 77 years old, diagnosed with CES caused by nucleus pulposus herniation at fourth to fifth lumbar vertebrae, with a complication of pressure injury grade IV due to immobilization. Her family’s lack of caregiving skills, poverty, and histrionic personality disorder were her barriers to comply to rehabilitation program. Adding a psychotherapy based on personality on rehabilitation program increased her functional outcome. This case highlight the significance of assessing each patient’s personality to optimize outcomes, emphasizing the importance of tailoring rehabilitation programs to individual needs, including psychosocial and environmental factors.
... One of the most widely accepted etiological theories for HPD is that it has a dual origin: biological and psychological. From a biological perspective, individuals with this disorder are said to have a highly sensitive temperament and may seek external validation to satisfy their psychological needs (Perrotta, 2021). Psychosocially, some individuals may have been praised for their physical appearance by significant others, especially their parents, rather than their skills. ...
... Consequently, they may have learned that their body can be used to satisfy their emotional needs. Others may have learned to seek support only through physical complaints, as they received care and attention primarily when they were sick (Perrotta, 2021). As a result, individuals with histrionic personality disorder are often preoccupied with attracting the attention of others as a means of meeting their psychological needs. ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of a combination of Schema Therapy and ACT (Acceptance and Commitment Therapy) in reducing overcompensation coping strategies associated with early maladaptive schemas in patients diagnosed with histrionic personality disorder (HPD). Methods: A randomized quasi-experimental design with a comparison group was used, involving pre-test, post-test, and a two-month follow-up assessment. Participants were 30 HPD patients selected from three psychology centers in 2021–2022 in Tehran who met the inclusion criteria for HPD diagnosis based on clinical interviews and Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory-III (MCMI-III). Patients were randomly assigned to either the intervention or waitlist group. The intervention group received ten 90-minute sessions of combined therapy. MCMI-III and the Young Compensation Inventory (YCI) were used as research instruments. Multivariate analysis of covariance was used to control for pre-treatment differences between the intervention and waitlist groups and to assess the effect of the intervention on the outcome measures. Results: The intervention group had significantly lower MCMI-III Disclosure scores and lower YCI levels immediately post-treatment and at the two-month follow-up assessment compared to the waitlist control group. The effect sizes for these comparisons were large to very large, indicating a significant and clinically meaningful improvement in the intervention group. Conclusions: The findings suggest that combined Schema Therapy and ACT may be effective in reducing overcompensation coping strategies in HPD patients. The study's limitations included the absence of random sampling in the first stage of screening. Future research should aim to replicate these findings with larger samples and diverse populations.
... Histrionic [108] Concentrator (or type I) ...
Article
Full-text available
According to the PICI model, there are six personality disorders in the neurotic area (anxious, phobic, obsessive, somatic, avoidant, and manic), and the diagnosis of psychopathological disorder is determined based on the persistence of certain dysfunctional traits present in the personality framework. Based on clinical experience and through the application of the IPM/PICI, Deca, PDM, PHEM and PPP-DNA models, it was found that all disorders in the neurotic area had anxiety traits in common and that symptoms of the six different disorders were often present in comorbidity. This assumption led to the hypothesis of a different and better way to group them into one all-encompassing category: "Neurotic Personality Disorder" (NPD). Based on this construct, it is suggested to perform the same nosographic operations for the other personality disorders, grouping 7 personality disorders (bipolar, depressive, borderline, histrionic, narcissistic, antisocial, psychopathic) from the psychopathological area related to Cluster B of DSM-5-TR and PICI-3 into "Dramatic Personality Disorder" (DPD) and 4 other personality disorders (delusional, paranoid, dissociative, schizophrenic spectrum) from the psychopathological area related to Cluster A of DSM-5-TR and Cluster C of PICI-3 into "Psychotic Personality Disorder" (PPD). This paper aims to suggest their use to facilitate psychopathological framing.
... Starting from the defi nitions found in the literature of deviant [12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19], histrionicism [20][21][22], borderline [23][24][25], narcissism [26][27][28], antisociality [7,[29][30][31], and psychopathy [32][33][34][35][36] (different from the concept of psychosis [37][38][39][40][41][42][43]), it is, therefore, possible to defi ne the "criminal spectrum" as Dysfunctional pattern consisting of a clinically relevant crosssectional condition, in which the subject manifests deviant, borderline, histrionic, narcissistic, antisocial, and psychopathic behaviors, such that they foster their emotional, cognitive, and behavioral dysfunctionality in comparison with the conduct concerning social and legal norms that would be expected from another fellow member of their same environmental context ( Table 2). ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: Absent in the literature is the category of “criminal spectre” as a macro container that includes all those deviant, antisocial, and psychopathic behaviors, thereby generating confusion and interpretative distortions, as in the case of antisociality and psychopathy among them considered in some cases as synonyms. Methods: Updated the Perrotta-Marciano Questionnaire on the state of awareness of one’s deviant and criminal behaviors (ADCB-Q), from 30 items to 40 items and with 2 subscales to differentiate deviant from antisocial behaviors (ADCB-Q-2), to make comparisons with the Deviant Behavior Variety Scale (DBVS) and the Hare Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R). Results: Statistical analysis showed that the second edition of the test has a well-defined and stable construct (R = 0.999; p ≤ 0.001), and is positively correlated with the other 2 compared tests, the DBVS (R = 0.943) and the PCL-R (R = 0.966). A comparison of comparable items returned an R = 0.999 with a 99.9% equal value. Conclusion: Defining the “criminal spectre” as a dysfunctional pattern consisting of a clinically relevant cross-cutting condition in which the subject manifests deviant, borderline, histrionic, narcissistic, antisocial, and psychopathic behaviors, the Perrotta-Marciano Questionnaire on the State of Awareness of One’s Deviant and Criminal Behaviors (ADCB-Q-2) is a valid, efficient, effective and stable psychometric tool to identify in behavioral profiles all the behaviors that fall within the “criminal spectrum”.
... Trap houses were abandoned, run-down apartments in the Atlanta suburbs where drugs were dealt; moreover, the word "trapping" in slang means "dealing". The drum sounds typical of trap fi nd their origin in the Roland TR-808 drum machine, particularly its deep (also simply called "808") and often syncopated kick drum, combined with hi- The present research hypothesizes the existence of a link between the choice of preference of this music genre and the psychopathological profi le of those who choose their fi rst preference, hypothesizing that such individuals have on average a higher level of dysfunctional traits typical of Cluster B (borderline, narcissistic, histrionic and antisocial) [4][5][6][7] according to the PICI model [8][9][10][11][12][13] and compared with the population. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and aims: In the last decade, a musical strand has emerged in the Italian national scene that has international roots since the 1990s of the last century: “Trap Music” and younger generations are increasingly fascinated by this genre, for various reasons. The present research hypothesizes the existence of a link between the choice of preference of this musical genre and the psychopathological profile of those who choose their first preference, hypothesizing that such individuals have on average a higher level of dysfunctional traits typical of cluster B (borderline, narcissistic, histrionic and antisocial), according to the PICI model and compared to the population. Materials and methods: Clinical interview, and administration of the battery of psychometric tests. The population sample was selected based on previous clinical contacts and voluntary participation through recruitment in major social networks (Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, TikTok), a total of 4,368 participants, divided into three age groups (18-25, 26-37, 38-46) and two groups (the first “clinical” and the second “control”). SPSS, Anova test (with Bonferroni). Results and discussion: On average, the users selected in the clinical group population sample presented 81% of cases with a psychopathological personality profile (PICI-2) with at least 5 dysfunctional traits afferent to cluster B (bipolar, borderline, histrionic, narcissistic, antisocial, and psychopathic) and at least 4 dysfunctional traits afferent to cluster C (paranoid, delusional, schizophrenic spectrum, dissociative), according to the PICI model, compared to 23.1% of the cases in the control group, which, however, shows traits more oriented toward neurotic tendencies (anxious, phobic-avoidant, obsessive, somatic). The investigation of dysfunctional sexual behaviors then showed, in the clinical group, the marked presence of the clinical condition of the users, with an average of 96.8% compared to 24% in the control group; in particular, the presence of a tendency toward pedophilic (under 13 years old) and pederastic (13-17 years old) paraphilia is noted for the average value between only the markings of the second and third clinical groups equal to 54.3% (with an overall phenomenon slightly more inclined toward the male group). Conclusion: It is concluded, therefore, that the starting hypothesis can be confirmed, as the hypothesized link between the primary preference choice of “Trap Music” and the psychopathological profile afferent to the dysfunctional traits of Cluster B (borderline, narcissistic, histrionic, antisocial and psychopathic), according to the PICI model and compared with the control group (CG) population, which has significantly lower pathological values (57.9% - 72.8%) than the clinical group (CG), appears credible and non-random.
Chapter
Personality disorders, characterized by enduring patterns of behavior, thinking, and feeling, significantly diverging from societal norms, pose complex challenges for psychiatric-mental health nurse practitioners (PMHNPs). Personality disorders often co-occur with other mental health conditions, including depression, anxiety, and substance use disorders. Despite their prevalence, personality disorders remain enigmatic due to their multifaceted nature influenced by genetics, environment, and culture. Stigmatization and media portrayal further complicate diagnosis and treatment efforts, contributing to misconceptions and under-recognition. Treatment hurdles persist, as entrenched patterns resist change, and pharmacotherapy options remain limited. However, evidence-based interventions like dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) offer promise, particularly for borderline personality disorder. PMHNPs play a crucial role in supporting individuals with personality disorders, facilitating symptom management, and enhancing overall well-being through education, therapy, and collaboration with families. This chapter provides comprehensive insights into DSM-5 personality disorder clusters, encompassing diagnostic criteria, pharmacological interventions, therapeutic modalities, and their respective implications for PMHNPs.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: Social norms represent the system of expectations of a community at a given point in time. Based on the education received and lived life experiences, everyone reacts to social norms with conformity or rebellion. Whether or not one adapts to a new social norm depends on many factors, which have been studied in the social-anthropological fi eld but not yet fully explored in scientifi c literature. Method: The clinical population sample (CG) that was selected for this pilot study consisted of 60 Italian participants (30 males; 30 females), aged 18 to 77 years (M: 47.5; SD: 17.0). Through a clinical interview and administration of the Perrotta Integrative Clinical Interviews, version TA-3 (PICI-TA-3), the included adult patients were analyzed, based on the experiment described in the protocol. A control group (Cg) with the same characteristics was constructed, in the absence of positive clinical data for a personality disorder identifi ed by the PICI-TA-3, for a total of 120 participants (60 males; 60 females). Results: In the clinical group (CG), subjects in the neurotic subgroup (pure anxious, phobic-obsessive and manic) responded to the acquisition of the new social rule within the third positive reinforcement stimulus, while subjects in the psychotic subgroup (paranoid-delusional, dissociated and schizophrenic spectrum) in some cases responded within the second stimulus while others hyperactivated and stopped the experiment; fi nally, subjects in the dramatic subgroup (depressive, bipolar, borderline, narcissistic-histrionic, antisocial-psychopathic) partly responded after the third stimulus or with attitudes of rebellion or contrariness, seeking clarifi cation, explanation, or resistance in the social group. Conclusions: The research data showed that the acquisition of a new social rule is conditioned by several subjective factors, including structural and functional personality profi les. Keywords: Social rule, acquisition of a new social rule, conformity, rebellion, society, personality disorders. Abbreviations/acronyms: Perrotta Integrative Clinical Interviews (PICI-C-3), Clinical group (CG), Control group (Cg).
Article
Full-text available
Starting from the general concept of “Behavior and Conduct Disorder in Childhood”, the present review seeks to highlight the main predictive elements that, in preadolescent and adolescent age, can correlate with the symptomatological picture of distinctive disorders in deviant and criminal conduct. Early educational intervention, prevention in all its forms and the use of therapeutic corrective tools can encourage expected and expected behavioral improvement, especially in subjects who are still not adults and with a family and social environment that responds to corrective stimuli. Understanding such passages is functional from a strategic point of view, to prevent, educate, plan, intervene, and/or correct certain psychopathological inclinations, also from a socio-environmental, family, and personal perspective
Preprint
Full-text available
Background In this study, it was aimed to determine whether there is a relationship between childhood traumas and emotional intelligence levels and personality beliefs. Methods University students who applied for a health board examination, did not have any psychiatric disease history, had childhood trauma (CT (+), 45.0%, n = 174) and had no childhood trauma (CT (-), 55.0%, n = 213) were included in the study. students participated. Sociodemographic data form and Childhood Trauma Scale, Bar-On Emotional Intelligence Scale and Personality Beliefs Scale were given to the participants. Statistical analysis was performed using the SPSS (ver.22.0, Chicago, II, USA) program. Results Of the students, 91.0% (n = 352) were male and 46.3% (n = 179) were in the 20–21 age group. Most of them were studying at the faculty of engineering. In those with CT (+), avoidant-personality beliefs, dependent-personality beliefs, passive-aggressive-personality beliefs, antisocial-personality beliefs, histrionic-personality beliefs, schizoid-personality beliefs, paranoid-personality beliefs and borderline-personality beliefs levels and intrapersonal skills, interpersonal skills, adaptability, stress management and general mood emotional intelligence levels were statistically significant compared to those with CT (-) degree was higher. A moderate, positive, statistically significant relationship was found between childhood trauma levels and personality beliefs and emotional intelligence levels, excluding obsessive-compulsive personality beliefs. Furthermore, there was no statistically significant relationship between obsessive-compulsive-personality beliefs and emotional intelligence levels in those with childhood traumas. Conclusion Childhood traumas, which can be effective in personality development, may contribute to the development of different components of emotional intelligence and different personality beliefs. Different dimensions of emotional intelligence can also be effective in the emergence of personality beliefs. We would like to emphasize that childhood traumas and emotional intelligence levels are not related to the emergence of obsessive-compulsive beliefs.
Article
Full-text available
Background: In popular culture, the medium is a subject of seemingly controversial psychic abilities, as he or she seems to be able to communicate telepathically and physically with the various spirit entities present on the astral plane, i.e., a plane parallel to the physical one that can interact with it. In the literature, such assumptions rise to mere speculation, the result of superstition and personal beliefs, using the abilities of mental manipulation; however, some research has challenged these beliefs. Objectives: To demonstrate whether the personality profile of the psychic mediums analyzed exhibits pathological personality traits and whether such is sufficient to confirm a clinical diagnosis. Materials and methods: Clinical interview, based on narrative-anamnestic and documentary evidence, and battery of psychometric tests. Results: The totality of the clinical group (CG) is found to be pathological, with at least 5 dysfunctional traits, and a corollary of secondary traits reinforcing the primary condition; the pathological differential from the control group (Cg) is +70.7%. At the individual sexual matrix questionnaires, just over 1/4 of the CG show a dysfunctional tendency to sexual behavior with a differential from the Cg of +42.8%. Slightly more than one-fifth of the CG also exhibit affective dependence, with a pathological differential with the Cg of +17%, while the CG sample concerning ego defense mechanisms exhibits the pathological totality of the sample, with a differential for the Cg of +45.7%. Conclusion: This research confirms the psychopathological nature of the personality profiles of mediums, with a higher prevalence of delusional, dissociative, and narcissistic disorders of the overt type, although these results do not prove the fraudulent nature of the mediumistic activity boasted by the subjects, and therefore what has been obtained should be read more generally, subjecting psychic mediums (in mediumistic activity) to technical instrumentation (electroencephalogram, functional magnetic resonance imaging and signal potential and audio-video) in the future to verify the outcomes.
Article
Full-text available
This work focuses on the study of neurobiological and functional profiles in terms of bisexuality, to carefully evaluate the direct correlation between anatomical and physiological elements and the choice of sexual preferences oriented on both sexes, hypothesizing any clinical profiles.
Article
Full-text available
This work focuses on the theme of “dysfunctional sexual behaviours” and in particular on clinical, psychopathological, and anatomy physiological elements, to fully understand the different grades of the behavior under consideration: hypersexuality, persistent sexual arousal disorder, and sex addiction. The work is completed with an analysis of the etiological elements and the best treatments, emphasizing the clinical importance of the use of pornography in sexual addictions.
Article
Full-text available
Starting from the general concept of "narcissism", the present work focuses on the essential aspects of personality disorder that define the clinical and diagnostic contexts, laying the foundations for correct differential diagnosis, without neglecting the neural characteristics developed by the scientific community. A new classification of the narcissistic disorder is presented that better defines the different types, in a more general framework of the "narcissistic spectrum". The discussion ends with the best suggested therapeutic approaches.
Article
Full-text available
Accepting to face a path of psychotherapy is not in itself sufficient to achieve the goals set in the therapeutic agreement between patient and professional. The present work analyses the differences between "consciousness" (and knowledge) of one's dysfunctional state, "will" to achieve change and "awareness of change", passing through all the traps that the mind can set for us, starting from the alterations of the states of consciousness to the wrong perceptual processes (which rework the external sensory data collected by the sense organs) to the not necessarily dysfunctional use of defense mechanisms, the imperfect centering on the knowledge of one's own needs and requirements, the excessive rigidity of one's system of beliefs, certainties and mental constructs, the use of irrational ideas based on empirical data falsely considered correct, the subjection of social influences and conditionings to impressions and systematic errors determined by cognitive dissonances and social and moral disengagements. The present work then focuses on the goals that the therapist must achieve to help the patient in his or her process of awareness and acceptance of change, and on recent techniques focused on the patient's emotional and emotional needs.
Article
Full-text available
Starting from the concept of “cuckold” and having placed the substantial differences with the “troilism”, despite the terminological error committed by almost all the researchers who consider these two terms of synonyms, we proceeded to analyze the clinical, neurobiological and relational profiles, to then investigate the borderline forms of troilism: Open couples, polygamy and polyamory. By analyzing the possible etiological causes, which are the basis of these manifestations, it was concluded that probably the multifactorial is the most suitable answer, with a clear orientation towards the psychological causes deriving from a post-traumatic stress adaptation (substantially in the field of paraphilias or narcissism with adaptive forms, therefore self-destructive).
Article
Full-text available
This work deals with the analysis of the theoretical and practical profiles of the strategic clinical model in psychotherapy, starting from the examination of the historical and evolutionary contents of this particular model, passing through the main theories and techniques used in the clinic.
Article
Full-text available
Starting from the categorical definitions of “TIC disorder”, we proceeded to list the individual forms provided by the DSM-V, with a particular focus on clinical, neurobiological and therapeutic profiles, concluding the analysis of the possible strategies to be used to finalize the resolutions to problems arising from the disorder in question
Article
Full-text available
In clinical psychology and psychiatry, the states "delusions", "paranoia" and "hallucinations" are quite distinct and present the precise symptoms of different pathologies, which in turn also use to be correlated by a comorbid condition. In the present discussion, starting from the concepts of common use, from the popular less popular way, we are dealing with clear distinctions using the manual of psychiatric disorders DSM-V, about the characteristics related to the organisational aspects of related psychiatric syndromes. I conclude with a general overview of the clinical contexts and the best therapeutic approaches known today.
Article
Full-text available
The strategic theoretical model is mainly based on the patient's perceptive-reactive system and its functioning profiles, putting the typical nosographic descriptions of DSM-V in the background-in clinical practice. This methodological choice is aimed at favouring a more integrated and general approach, enhancing the particular individual components, typical of the patient, far from an excessively rigid approachable only to cage the patient in a scheme that does not value all the nuances of his clinical symptomatology. This model is then integrated with other theories able to fully explain the subjective nature of reality and the re-elaboration of it in a perceptive key.
Article
Full-text available
Starting from the general concept of "bipolarity", the present work focuses on the essential aspects of the disorder defining the clinical and diagnostic contexts, laying the foundations for correct differential diagnosis, without neglecting the neural characteristics elaborated in the scientific community. The discussion concludes with the best therapeutic approaches suggested on the subject, hypothesizing that borderline disorder may be the evolution of bipolar disorder.