ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

Subsidence, the lowering of Earth's land surface, is a potentially destructive hazard that can be caused by a wide range of natural or anthropogenic triggers but mainly results from solid or fluid mobilization underground. Subsidence due to groundwater depletion (1) is a slow and gradual process that develops on large time scales (months to years), producing progressive loss of land elevation (centimeters to decimeters per year) typically over very large areas (tens to thousands of square kilometers) and variably affects urban and agricultural areas worldwide. Subsidence permanently reduces aquifer-system storage capacity, causes earth fissures, damages buildings and civil infrastructure, and increases flood susceptibility and risk. During the next decades, global population and economic growth will continue to increase groundwater demand and accompanying groundwater depletion (2) and, when exacerbated by droughts (3), will probably increase land subsidence occurrence and related damages or impacts. To raise awareness and inform decision-making, we evaluate potential global subsidence due to groundwater depletion, a key first step toward formulating effective land-subsidence policies that are lacking in most countries worldwide.
By Gerardo Herrera-García1,2,3, Pablo Ezquerro1,4, Roberto Tomás2,5, Marta Béjar-Pizarro1**,
Juan López-Vinielles1,6, Mauro Rossi7, Rosa M. Mateos1,3, Dora Carreón-Freyre2,8, John
Lambert2,9, Pietro Teatini2,10, Enrique Cabral-Cano2,11, Gilles Erkens2,12,13, Devin Galloway2,14, Wei-
Chia Hung2,15, Najeebullah Kakar2,16, Michelle Sneed2,17, Luigi Tosi2,18, Hanmei Wang2,19, Shujun Ye2,20
Subsidence, the lowering of Earth’s
land surface, is a potentially destruc-
tive hazard that can be caused by
a wide range of natural or anthro-
pogenic triggers but mainly results
from solid or fluid mobilization un-
derground. Subsidence due to groundwater
depletion (1) is a slow and gradual process
that develops on large time scales (months
to years), producing progressive loss of land
elevation (centimeters to decimeters per
year) typically over very large areas (tens
to thousands of square kilometers) and
variably affects urban and agricultural ar-
eas worldwide. Subsidence permanently
reduces aquifer-system storage capacity,
causes earth fissures, damages buildings and
civil infrastructure, and increases flood sus-
ceptibility and risk. During the next decades,
global population and economic growth will
continue to increase groundwater demand
and accompanying groundwater depletion
(2) and, when exacerbated by droughts (3),
will probably increase land subsidence oc-
currence and related damages or impacts. To
raise awareness and inform decision-mak-
ing, we evaluate potential global subsidence
due to groundwater depletion, a key first
step toward formulating effective land-sub-
sidence policies that are lacking in most
countries worldwide.
A large-scale systematic literature review
reveals that during the past century, land
subsidence due to groundwater depletion oc-
curred at 200 locations in 34 countries [see
supplementary materials (SM)]. However,
subsidence extent is only known for one-
third of these records, information on the
impacts is scarce, and mitigation measures
were implemented only in a few locations. In
China, widespread subsidence affects cities
developed in the main sedimentary basins.
In Indonesia, coastal subsidence in Jakarta
is so severe that government authorities are
planning to move the capital to the island of
Borneo. In Japan, subsidence affected sev-
eral cities during the 20th century, includ-
ing more than 4 m of subsidence in Tokyo,
before groundwater management practices
mitigated further subsidence. Iran currently
hosts some of the fastest-sinking cities in
the world (25 cm year--1) because of unregu-
lated groundwater pumping. In Europe, the
greatest impact of subsidence occurs in the
Netherlands, where subsidence is primarily
responsible for placing 25% of the country
below the mean sea level and increasing the
flooding risk. Subsidence in the Po River
Plain in Italy started during the second half
of the 20th century and currently threatens
30% of the Italian population, contributing
to recurrent coastal flooding during extreme
high tides in Venice. In North America, in-
tense groundwater depletion triggers sub-
sidence from California’s Central Valley,
with as much as 9 m of subsidence in the
past century, to the Atlantic and Gulf of
Mexico coastal plains in the United States,
where subsidence is increasing flooding risk.
In México, subsidence rates are among the
highest worldwide (as much as 30 cm year-1),
affecting small structurally controlled in-
termontane basins where the main urban
centers developed, causing an important but
unaccounted economic impact.
Spatial analysis of subsidence locations
identified in our global database (see SM)
reveals that subsidence has preferentially
occurred in very flat areas where unconsol-
idated sediments accumulated in alluvial
basins or coastal plains, and where urban
or agricultural areas developed in temperate
or arid climates characterized by prolonged
dry periods. Land subsidence has generally
occurred in water-stressed basins, where the
combination of groundwater withdrawal and
natural groundwater discharge outpaced
groundwater recharge, resulting in ground-
water storage losses, groundwater depletion,
and compaction of susceptible aquifer sys-
tems. In the affected basins, land subsidence
mainly occurred in highly populated areas,
with half of documented occurrences in ar-
eas susceptible to flooding. In coastal zones,
the combined effects of absolute sea-level
rise and land subsidence contribute to rela-
tive sea-level rise (4). The contribution from
land subsidence may exceed the contribu-
tion from absolute sea-level rise by a factor
of 10 or more and could be especially critical
for 21% of the geographic locations identified
in our database, where land elevation is less
than 1 m above the mean sea level.
On the basis of the spatial analysis find-
ings, a global model is proposed to combine
the main variables influencing subsidence to
identify environmental settings favoring land
subsidence and the anthropogenic factors
leading to groundwater depletion (see SM).
Statistical analyses of lithology, land-surface
slope, land cover, and Koppen-Geiger climate
classes are used to predict global subsidence
susceptibility at a spatial resolution of 1 km2.
The probability of groundwater depletion
is estimated by identifying urban and irri-
gated areas suffering water stress and where
groundwater demand is high.
The analyses do not consider subsidence
magnitude and rate, owing to the lack of
this information at a global scale. Hence,
the combination of subsidence susceptibility
and the probability of groundwater deple-
tion is used to predict a “proxy” of subsid-
ence hazard, which permits identification of
exposed areas where the probability of land
subsidence occurrence is high or very high.
Even though these results do not necessarily
translate to direct impacts or damages, they
are useful for identifying potential subsid-
ence areas where further local-scale analysis
is necessary. The comparison of our model
predictions with an independent validation
dataset reveals a 94% capability to distin-
guish between subsidence and nonsubsid-
ence areas, according to the value of the area
under the receiver operating characteristic
curve (see SM). The global exposure to po-
tential subsidence is evaluated by calculating
the number of inhabitants living in potential
subsidence areas, i.e., subsidence hazard
proxy, and the equivalent gross domestic
product (GDP). This “proxy” of exposed
assets is calculated assuming that GDP per
capita is homogeneous within each coun-
try. Finally, the evolution of potential global
subsidence and the related exposure is pre-
INSIGHTS
34 1 JANUARY 2021 • VOL 371 ISSUE 6524 sciencemag.org SCIENCE
GEOSCIENCE
Mapping the global threat of land subsidence
Nineteen percent of the global population may face a high probability of subsidence
POLICY FORUM
See supplementary materials for author affiliations.
Email: g.herrera@igme.es
1 JANUARY 2021 • VOL 371 ISSUE 6524 35SCIENCE sciencemag.org
GRAPHIC: N. DESAI/SCIENCE
dicted for 2040 for a global change scenario
based on steady population growth and in-
creasing greenhouse gas emissions (Shared
Socioeconomic Pathways 2, Representative
Concentration Pathway 8.5), which accounts
for the greatest sea-level rise projections.
Our results suggest that potential sub-
sidence threatens 12 million km2 (8%) of
the global land surface with a probability
greater than 50% (MH to VH in the figure).
Potential subsidence areas are concentrated
in and near densely urban and irrigated ar-
eas with high water stress and high ground-
water demand, overlying some of the larg-
est and most depleted aquifer systems (5)
in Asia (e.g., North China Plain) and North
America (e.g., Gulf of Mexico coastal plain);
coastal and river delta areas worldwide (e.g.,
Vietnam, Egypt, or the Netherlands); and
inland sedimentary basins of México, Iran,
and the Mediterranean countries. Potential
subsidence is lower in Africa, Australia, and
South America, owing to the lower ground-
water depletion (6). In central Africa, poten-
tial subsidence only includes information on
the susceptibility, as groundwater depletion
is unknown. In this region, subsidence sus-
ceptibility (see fig. S6) could be useful to pre-
vent subsidence impacts on developing cities
that during the next decades could rely more
on the available groundwater resources.
To evaluate the exposure to potential sub-
sidence, we focus on areas where the poten-
tial subsidence probability is high or very
high (see the figure). The cumulative po-
tential subsidence area amounts to 2.2
million km2, or 1.6% of the land; includes
1.2 billion inhabitants, or 19% of the global
population; and has an exposed GDP of
US$ 8.19 trillion, or 12% of the global GDP.
High-income countries account for 62%
of the global exposed GDP but only 11%
of the global exposed population, whereas
low-income countries account for 54% of
the global exposed population and 12% of
the global exposed GDP. It is expected that
the capability of low-income countries to
implement the political, regulatory, and
socioeconomic measures necessary to pre-
vent and mitigate subsidence impact will
be less than that for high-income countries.
Potential global subsidence
The color scale indicates the probability intervals classied from very low (VL) to moderately low (ML) to moderately high (MH) to very high (VH), for every 30-arcsec
resolution pixel (1 km by 1 km at the Equator). The white hatched polygons indicate countries where groundwater data is unavailable, and the potential subsidence only
includes information on the susceptibility. For details on data and methods, and for maps of other regions, see supplementary materials.
60ºN30ºN
30ºS
120ºW 60ºW 120ºE60ºE
45ºN40ºN 35ºN
30ºN
110ºE 120ºE 130ºE
30ºN 40ºN 35ºN
115ºW120ºW
East Asia
North America
110ºW
VL L ML MH H VH
Potential global subsidence
The color scale indicates the probability intervals classied from very low (VL) to moderately low (ML) to moderately high (MH) to very high (VH), for every 30-arcsec
resolution pixel (1 km by 1 km at the Equator). The white hatched polygons indicate countries where groundwater data is unavailable, and the potential subsidence only
includes information on the susceptibility. For details on data and methods, and for maps of other regions, see supplementary materials.
60ºN30ºN
30ºS
120ºW 60ºW 120ºE60ºE
45ºN40ºN 35ºN
30ºN
110ºE 120ºE 130ºE
30ºN 40ºN 35ºN
115ºW120ºW
East Asia
North America
110ºW
VL L ML MH H VH
Potential global subsidence
The color scale indicates the probability intervals classified from very low (VL) to very high (VH), for every 30-arcsec resolution pixel (1 km by 1 km
at the Equator). The white hatched polygons indicate countries where groundwater data is unavailable, and the potential subsidence only includes information
on the susceptibility. See maps of other regions in supplementary materials.
INSIGHTS |
PERSPECTIVES
36 1 JANUARY 2021 • VOL 371 ISSUE 6524 sciencemag.org SCIENCE
Potential subsidence threatens 484 million
inhabitants living in flood-prone areas, 75%
of whom live in fluvial areas and 25% of
whom live near the coast. This number of
threatened inhabitants corresponds to 50%
of the global population exposed to flooding
hazards according to previous estimates (7),
demonstrating the importance of consider-
ing potential subsidence in global flooding
risk analyses.
Most of the global population exposed
to potential subsidence live in Asia (86%),
which is about 10 times the combined ex-
posed population of North
America and Europe (9%).
The results indicate that 97%
of the exposed global pop-
ulation is concentrated in
30 countries (see SM). India
and China share the top two
rankings of potential subsid-
ence in terms of spatial ex-
tent and exposed population.
Egypt and the Netherlands
have the largest populations
living in potential subsid-
ence areas that are below
the mean sea level. The greatest population
densities in potential subsidence areas oc-
cur in Egypt and Indonesia, whereas the
relative exposure per country, measured as
the exposed population normalized by the
total population, is greater than 30% for
Egypt, Bangladesh, Netherlands, and Italy.
The United States ranks first in terms of
GDP exposed to potential subsidence, ow-
ing to its high GDP per capita.
Combination of the aforementioned
metrics permits derivation of a potential
subsidence index ranking (see SM). Seven
of the first ten ranked countries have the
greatest subsidence impact, accounting for
the greatest amount of reported damages
(Netherlands, China, USA, Japan, Indonesia,
México and Italy).
During this century, climate change will
cause serious impacts on the world’s wa-
ter resources through sea-level rise, more
frequent and severe floods and droughts,
changes in the mean value and mode of pre-
cipitation (rain versus snow), and increased
evapotranspiration. Prolonged droughts
will decrease groundwater recharge and in-
crease groundwater depletion, intensifying
subsidence. The global potential subsidence
is predicted for 2040 using the same sub-
sidence metrics and available global pro-
jections of water stress, water demand var-
iations, climate, and population (see SM).
Although predicted potential subsidence ar-
eas increase only by 7% globally, the threat-
ened population is predicted to rise by 30%,
affecting 1.6 billion inhabitants, 635 million
of whom will be living in flood-prone ar-
eas. These changes will not be homogene-
ous. Between 2010 and 2040, the predicted
population exposed to potential subsidence
increases more than 80% in the Philippines,
Iraq, Indonesia, México, Israel, Netherlands,
Algeria, and Bangladesh. The increase will
be moderate, less than 30%, for China, the
United States, Italy, and Iran. Potential sub-
sidence is forecasted to decrease in Japan
and Germany, owing to effective ground-
water management policies and population
declines. Finally, potential subsidence is pre-
dicted to emerge in high-latitude northern
countries like Canada and to
increase in extent in Russia
or Hungary, where climate
change will favor longer dry
seasons.
Further advancements in
the global evaluation of sub-
sidence can be made when a
global historical database on
subsidence rate, magnitude,
and extent has been com-
piled, which could be largely
sourced from continental
monitoring of surface dis-
placements using satellite radar imagery (8).
Widespread continuous monitoring of sub-
sidence will permit better evaluation of the
potential impact of land subsidence, espe-
cially in countries like Indonesia, México, and
Iran, where local studies revealed the highest
subsidence rates worldwide, but the national
dimension of subsidence is still unknown.
Further research also is necessary to evalu-
ate the cost of damage caused by current and
historical subsidence worldwide. The combi-
nation of damage information with hazard
estimates will permit improved assessments
of potential loss and design of cost-effective
countermeasures. Presently, annual subsid-
ence costs are only published for China (US$
1.5 billion) and the Netherlands (US$ 4.8
billion) (9). The greater subsidence costs in
the Netherlands owe to the exposed popula-
tion below the mean sea level and the large
investments made to prevent flooding. Our
model, which does not yet consider mitiga-
tion measures, likely overestimates potential
subsidence exposure in the Netherlands and
Japan, where groundwater management has
effectively controlled subsidence over the
past decades (10).
Our results identify 1596 major cities, or
about 22% of the world’s 7343 major cities
that are in potential subsidence areas, with
57% of these cities also located in flood-
prone areas. Moreover, subsidence threatens
15 of the 20 major coastal cities ranked with
the highest flood risk worldwide (11), where
potential subsidence can help delimit areas
in which flooding risk could be increased
and mitigation measures are necessary.
Overall, potential global subsidence re-
sults can be useful to better define the spa-
tial extent of poorly documented subsidence
occurrences, discover unknown subsiding
areas, prevent potential subsidence impacts
wherever groundwater depletion occurs,
and better identify areas where subsidence
could increase the flooding risk. In any
of these scenarios, an effective land-sub-
sidence policy should include systematic
monitoring and modeling of exposed ar-
eas, evaluation of potential damages, and
cost-benefit analyses permitting implemen-
tation of adequate mitigation or adaptation
measures. These measures should consider
groundwater regulation and strategic long-
term measures, such as the development
of alternative water supplies and the pro-
tection and (or) enhancement of natural or
artificial recharge of aquifers.
Considering that the potential subsidence
may affect 635 million inhabitants living in
flood-prone areas in 2040, it is of prime im-
portance that potential subsidence is quanti-
fied and systematically included in flood risk
analyses and related mitigation strategies.
REFERENCES AND NOTES
1. D. L. Galloway, T. J. Burbey, Hydrogeol. J. 19, 1459 (2011).
2. J. S. Famiglietti, Nat. Clim. Chang. 4, 945 (2014).
3. K. E. Trenberth, Clim. Res. 47, 123 (2011).
4. J. P. M. Syvitski et al., Nat. Geosci. 2, 681 (2009).
5. P. Döll, H. Müller Schmied, C. Schuh, F. T. Portmann, A.
Eicker, Water Resour. Res. 50, 5698 (2014).
6. R. G. Taylor et al., Nat. Clim. Chang. 3, 322 (2013).
7. B. J ongm an, P. J. Ward, J. C. J. H. A erts, Glob. Environ.
Change 22, 823 (2012).
8. R. Lanari et al., Remote Sens. 12, 2961 (2020).
9. T. H. M. Bucx, C. J. M. Van Ruiten, G. Erkens, G. De Lange
in, Proceedings of the International Association of
Hydrological Sciences 372, 485 (2015).
10. K. A. B. Jago-on et al., Sci. Total Environ. 407, 3089
(2009).
11. S. Hallegatte, C. Green, R. J. Nicholls, J. Corfee-Morlot,
Nat. Clim. Chang. 3, 802 (2013).
12. G. Herrera, P. Ezquerro, Global Subsidence Maps, fig-
share (2020); 10.6084/m9.figshare.13312070.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Four anonymous peer reviewers and S. E. Ingebritsen (U.S.
Geological Survey) helped to improve the manuscript.
Funding for this study was provided partly by the Spanish
Research Agency (AQUARISK, PRX19/00065, TEC2017-
85244-C2-1-P projects) and PRIMA RESERVOIR project, and
by all the institutions represented in the Land Subsidence
International Initiative from UNESCO. G.H-G., P.E., R.T., M.B.-P,
and J.L.-V. designed the study, performed the analysis, and
wrote the initial manuscript with input from all other authors.
R.M.M., E.C.-C., and M.R. advised on the susceptibility
analysis. R.M.M., J.L., P.T., and G.E. advised on hazard analysis.
D.C.-F., J.L., P.T., E.C.C., G.E., D.G., W.C.H., N.K., M.S., L.T., H.W.,
and S.Y. advised on global exposure analysis. R.T., M.B.P.,
R.M.M., J.L., P.T., W.-C.H., N.K., L.T., H.W., and S.Y. contributed
essential data for the analysis. All the authors edited and
revised the manuscript through the different reviews. Any use
of trade, firm, or product names is for descriptive purposes
only and does not imply endorsement by the U.S. government.
The authors declare no competing interests. All data included
in this study are available at figshare (12).
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS
science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6524/34/suppl/DC1
10.1126/science.abb8549
“Subsidence
threatens 15
of the 20 major
coastal cities
ranked with
the highest flood
risk worldwide.
... The slow and gradual sinking of Earth's surface-land subsidence-is a present and growing hazard with costly environmental, social and economic impacts on urban centers [1][2][3][4] . Globally, the narrative of sinking cities has drawn widespread attention to rapidly sinking coastal areas, such as Jakarta, Bangkok, Venice and New Orleans 1,5-7 . ...
... Moreover, the anthropogenic drivers of subsidence, including groundwater extraction and the loading effect of urban development 15,16 , are likely to intensify as cities continue to grow and climate change exacerbates environmental stresses. The compounding effect of climate change and urban population and socioeconomic growth emerges as a critical concern, potentially accelerating subsidence rates and transforming previously stable urban areas into vulnerable zones 1,17,18 . Specifically, climate-induced droughts and the increasing demand for freshwater Next, we projected the corrected LOS velocity measurements in the vertical direction to obtain vertical displacement (that is, subsidence or uplift). ...
Preprint
Full-text available
The Douala coastland (DCL), situated within the Douala sedimentary basin along the Gulf of Guinea, is characterised by its low elevation and alluvial geology, making it particularly susceptible to coastal erosion, land subsidence, and relative sea-level rise. The DCL is home to numerous rapidly growing cities, such as Douala, Tiko, and Limbe, which are currently experiencing alarming rates of coastal erosion, frequent flooding, and significant loss of land. Regional and continental investigations have provided evidence of coastal subsidence in this region; however, knowledge of its drivers and impact on the DCL remains limited. To address this knowledge gap, interferometric synthetic aperture radar (InSAR) datasets from the Sentinel-1 C-band satellite were used to quantify vertical land motion (VLM) between 2018 and 2023 with respect to the IGS14 global reference frame and assumed to represents absolute VLM. Digital Elevation Model datasets were used to analyse the elevation of the study area. The results revealed that the rate of VLM ranges from -17.6 mm/year to 3.8 mm/year (standard deviation of 0.2 mm/year), with a mean and median land subsidence rate of 2.7 mm/year and 2.5 mm/year. The analysis of land cover datasets from 1992 to 2022 suggests that urbanisation increased fivefold from 1992 to 2022 and that all contemporary urban areas experienced land subsidence, with the highest rates observed in non-residential zones with building heights ranging between 3 and 6 m. Subsidence rates of the DCL are inversely proportional to the time at which a particular land use and land cover (LULC) class changed into an urban area, highlighting the impact of the timing of LULC changes and urban expansion on present-day subsidence. The land subsidence rates decreased with an increase in building height, suggesting the potential influence of foundation type on land subsidence.
Article
Full-text available
Ground deformation poses a major threat to socioeconomic development, especially in coastal regions where compounding effects of anthropogenic activities and natural processes exacerbate its destructive consequences. This urgency calls for comprehensive, spatially extensive, and temporally continuous deformation monitoring. In this study, we propose a joint track small baseline subset synthetic aperture radar interferometry (SBAS-InSAR) methodology that enhances conventional SBAS-InSAR workflows through integration of ascending and descending orbit data processing, enabling accurate extraction of vertical surface deformation. By analyzing 2348 Sentinel-1 acquisitions, we derived vertical ground deformation across coastal California. The proposed method demonstrates superior measurement accuracy (4.81 mm/year) compared to individual ascending track (7.19 mm/year) or descending track (7.07 mm/year) results. Our analysis identifies substantial deformation signals in coastal urban centers, reveals deformation-fault distribution correlations, and documents characteristic subsidence patterns induced by subsurface resource extraction. These comprehensive data and insights provide invaluable support for the prevention and mitigation of ground deformation in coastal California, and serve as a scientific basis for formulating effective prevention and control strategies, ensuring the safety and sustainable development of these vulnerable coastal regions.
Article
Land subsidence, the sinking of the Earth’s surface due to the movement of subsurface earth materials, affects nearly one-fifth of the global population and generates consequential and widespread damages to natural and human systems. Yet, the phenomenon has received little attention to date in the economic literature. Some effort has been undertaken to estimate the direct damages to buildings and infrastructure and the indirect damages that arise as flood risk increases, especially in coastal, urban areas that are vulnerable to the effects of sea-level rise. In addition, several studies have integrated hydrologic and economic models to identify efficient policies to regulate groundwater pumping, the leading driver of land subsidence. There are compelling opportunities for economists to extend the knowledge frontier on this topic, for example by estimating environmental damages, building integrated assessment models to evaluate policy options, and exploring parallels with the climate change literature.
Article
Full-text available
The over-extraction of groundwater for agricultural purposes in the Konya Closed Basin (KCB) has led to land subsidence and new cover collapse sinkholes (CCS) in regions like the Akgöl Wetland (AW), where such occurrences were previously absent. InSAR data from 2014 to 2023 indicate that the average annual subsidence in AW varies between 15 mm/year and 30 mm/year. Alarmingly, in specific locations, the cumulative subsidence has reached 230 mm over nine years. The significant subsidence observed in the southern region of the study area aligns with a fault line between limestone and alluvial deposits. Furthermore, several bedrock collapse sinkholes (BCS) are seen in the limestone south of the lake. The orientations and alignments of the long axes of these dolines are pointed towards the region where recent CCS has developed. This may suggest the existence of an ancient bedrock collapse structure beneath the alluvium. During intense rainfall, the former lake region experiences transient flooding, with surface water draining southward, converging at the fault line and concealed BCS beneath the alluvium. This flow has induced CCS formation due to the concentration of groundwater flow within the intersection zone. The results of this study emphasise that it is necessary to develop integrated hazard mitigation plans, considering hydrology, lithology, structural geology, remote sensing, and geomorphology to address issues such as the KCB and other global problems.
Article
Full-text available
Land Subsidence (LS) is one of the critical environmental hazards reported in many countries worldwide with prominent examples from Mexico City (Mexico), Houston (US), Beijing (China), and Jakarta (Indonesia). It is the gradual compaction of the aquifer usually caused by groundwater exploitation in regions with abundant silt and clay sediments susceptible to compression. In this study, the spatio-temporal subsidence analysis of five districts (Quetta, Gulistan, Pishin, Mastung, and Kalat) in Balochistan, Pakistan was done using multi-sensor Small Baseline Subset (SBAS) Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar (InSAR) employing datasets from Envisat ASAR, Sentinel-1 and Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS). This study represents the first comprehensive long-term analysis of LS in Pakistan, covering a 2-decade period (2003–2023) and encompassing multiple districts. For Sentinel-1, 193, 195, and 182 acquisitions on the Ascending track and 183 scenes in the Descending track were utilized to analyse LS from December 2015 to December 2022. For Envisat, 38 acquisitions in the descending track were processed to study LS from April 2003 to January 2010. These two SAR datasets were fused using GNSS data (2008–2023). A two-decade (2003–2023) LS analysis was conducted in Quetta, whereas a seven-year (2015–2022) analysis was performed in the other 4 districts. In the Quetta region, the maximum LS rate from 2003 to 2010 was − 11.4 cm/y which accelerated to −12 cm/y during 2010–2016 and then further increased to − 16 cm/y after 2016. This is likely caused by the decline in groundwater level (GWL) and the presence of clay-rich sediments susceptible to compaction. The maximum accumulative subsidence recorded in Quetta from 2003 to 2023 was − 273 cm. In Gulistan, Pishin, Mastung, and Kalat, the maximum subsidence rates were − 13 cm/y, − 9.6 cm/y, − 14.1 cm/y, and − 7.1 cm/y while the maximum accumulative LS from 2015 to 2022 in these districts was − 90 cm, − 74 cm, − 99.4 cm, and − 49.7 cm. Furthermore, the LS compared with the GWL decline in Quetta showed a correlation coefficient of 0.95 which illustrates that the GWL decline may be the primary reason for LS. A comparison of the ascending and descending tracks on two different frames showed standard deviations of 2.5 cm and 1.22 cm, indicating negligible horizontal deformation. The land use analysis revealed that LS is influenced by urbanisation in Quetta and agricultural activities in Gulistan, Pishin, Mastung, and Kalat regions. The geological analysis indicated that the LS mainly occurs in recent deposits rich in silt and clay. This correlation reveals the significance of sediment composition in understanding LS issues in the region. Large-scale fissures caused by uneven LS pose a threat to the infrastructure and aquifer contamination.
Article
Full-text available
We present in this work an advanced processing pipeline for continental scale differential synthetic aperture radar (DInSAR) deformation time series generation, which is based on the parallel small baseline subset (P-SBAS) approach and on the joint exploitation of Sentinel-1 (S-1) interferometric wide swath (IWS) SAR data, continuous global navigation satellite system (GNSS) position time-series, and cloud computing (CC) resources. We first briefly describe the basic rationale of the adopted P-SBAS processing approach, tailored to deal with S-1 IWS SAR data and to be implemented in a CC environment, highlighting the innovative solutions that have been introduced in the processing chain we present. They mainly consist in a series of procedures that properly exploit the available GNSS time series with the aim of identifying and filtering out possible residual atmospheric artifacts that may affect the DInSAR measurements. Moreover, significant efforts have been carried out to improve the P-SBAS processing pipeline automation and robustness, which represent crucial issues for interferometric continental scale analysis. Then, a massive experimental analysis is presented. In this case, we exploit: (i) the whole archive of S-1 IWS SAR images acquired over a large portion of Europe, from descending orbits, (ii) the continuous GNSS position time series provided by the Nevada Geodetic Laboratory at the University of Nevada, Reno, USA (UNR-NGL) available for the investigated area, and (iii) the ONDA platform, one of the Copernicus Data and Information Access Services (DIAS). The achieved results demonstrate the capability of the proposed solution to successfully retrieve the DInSAR time series relevant to such a huge area, opening new scenarios for the analysis and interpretation of these ground deformation measurements.
Article
Full-text available
The mechanism of land subsidence and soil deformation deals with the dissipation of excess pore water pressure and the compaction of soil skeleton under the effect of natural or man-made factors, which can lead to serious disasters in the process of urbanization. The negative effects of land subsidence include structural and fundamental damages to underground and aboveground infrastructures such as pipelines and buildings, changes in land surface morphology, and creation of earth fissures. Arid and semi-arid countries like Iran are highly prone to land subsidence phenomenon. In these regions, precipitation rate and natural recharges are relatively lower than those of the global average showing the importance of ground waters for agricultural and industrial activities. Land subsidence has already occurred in more than 300 plains in Iran. Semnan Plain is one of the most important areas facing this phenomenon. The purpose of this research was to assess land subsidence susceptibility using random forest machine learning theory. At first, prioritization of conditioning factors was done using random forest method. Results showed that distance from fault, elevation, slope angle, land use, and water table have the greatest impacts on subsidence occurrence. Then land subsidence susceptibility map was prepared in GIS and R environment. The receiver operating characteristic curve was applied to assess the accuracy of random forest algorithm. The area under the curve by value of 0.77 showed that random forest is an acceptable model for land subsidence susceptibility mapping in the study area. The research results can provide a basis for the protection of environment and also promote the sustainable development of economy and society.
Article
Full-text available
The modern era of scientific global-mean sea level rise (SLR) projections began in the early 1980s. In subsequent decades, understanding of driving processes has improved, and new methodologies have been developed. Nonetheless, despite more than 70 studies, future SLR remains deeply uncertain. To facilitate understanding of the historical development of SLR projections and contextualize current projections, we have compiled a comprehensive database of 21st century global SLR projections. Although central estimates of 21st century global-mean SLR have been relatively consistent, the range of projected SLR has varied greatly over time. Among studies providing multiple estimates, the range of upper projections shrank from 1.3–1.8 m during the 1980s to 0.6–0.9 m in 2007, before expanding again to 0.5–2.5 m since 2013. Upper projections of SLR from individual studies are generally higher than upper projections from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, potentially due to differing percentile bounds or a predisposition of consensus-based approaches toward relatively conservative outcomes.
Article
Full-text available
Global warming is expected to drive increasing extreme sea levels (ESLs) and flood risk along the world’s coastlines. In this work we present probabilistic projections of ESLs for the present century taking into consideration changes in mean sea level, tides, wind-waves, and storm surges. Between the year 2000 and 2100 we project a very likely increase of the global average 100-year ESL of 34–76 cm under a moderate-emission-mitigation-policy scenario and of 58–172 cm under a business as usual scenario. Rising ESLs are mostly driven by thermal expansion, followed by contributions from ice mass-loss from glaciers, and ice-sheets in Greenland and Antarctica. Under these scenarios ESL rise would render a large part of the tropics exposed annually to the present-day 100-year event from 2050. By the end of this century this applies to most coastlines around the world, implying unprecedented floodrisk levels unless timely adaptation measures are taken
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, we do a critical review of statistical methods for landslide susceptibility modelling and associated terrain zonations. Landslide susceptibility is the likelihood of a landslide occurring in an area depending on local terrain conditions, estimating “where” landslides are likely to occur. Since the first attempts to assess landslide susceptibility in the mid-1970s, hundreds of papers have been published using a variety of approaches and methods in different geological and climatic settings. Here, we critically review the statistically-based landslide susceptibility assessment literature by systematically searching for and then compiling an extensive database of 565 peer-review articles from 1983 to 2016. For each article in the literature database, we noted 31 categories/sub-categories of information including study region/extent, landslide type/number, inventory type and period covered, statistical model used, including variable types, model fit/prediction performance evaluation method, and strategy used to assess the model uncertainty. We present graphical visualisations and discussions of commonalities and differences found as a function of region and time, revealing a significant heterogeneity of thematic data types and scales, modelling approaches, and model evaluation criteria. We found that the range of thematic data types used for susceptibility assessment has not changed significantly with time, and that for a number of studies the geomorphological significance of the thematic data used is poorly justified. We also found that the most common statistical methods for landslide susceptibility modelling include logistic regression, neural network analysis, data-overlay, index-based and weight of evidence analyses, with an increasing preference towards machine learning methods in the recent years. Although an increasing number of studies in recent years have assessed the model performance, in terms of model fit and prediction performance, only a handful of studies have evaluated the model uncertainty. Adopting a Susceptibility Quality Level index, we found that the quality of published models has improved over the years, but top-quality assessments remain rare. We identified a clear geographical bias in susceptibility study locations, with many studies in China, India, Italy and Turkey, and only a few in Africa, South America and Oceania. Based on previous literature reviews, the analysis of the information collected in the literature database, and our own experience on the subject, we provide recommendations for the preparation, evaluation, and use of landslide susceptibility models and associated terrain zonations.
Article
Full-text available
Although the European Alps are one of the most investigated regions worldwide, maps depicting climate change by means of climate classification are still not-existent. To contribute to this topic, a time series of very high resolution (30 arc-seconds) maps of the well-known Köppen-Geiger climate classification is presented. The maps cover the greater Alpine region located within the geographical domain of 4 to 19 degrees longitude and 43 to 49 degrees latitude. Gridded monthly data were selected to compile climate maps within this region. Observations for the period 1800–2010 were taken from the historical instrumental climatological surface time series of the greater Alpine region, HISTALP. Projected climate data for the period 2011–2100 were taken, as an example, from the Rossby Centre regional atmospheric model RCA4. Temperature fields were spatially disaggregated by applying the observed seasonal cycle of the environmental lapse rate. The main results of this study are, therefore, 366 observed and predicted (two scenarios) very high resolution Köppen-Geiger climate maps of the greater Alpine region covering the period 1800–2100. Digital data, as well as animated maps, showing the shift of the climate zones are provided on the following website http://koeppen-geiger.vu-wien.ac.at. Furthermore, the relationship between the Köppen-Geiger climate classification and the altitudinal belts of the Alps is demonstrated by calculating the boundaries of the climate zones, i.e. the deciduous forest line, the mixed forest line, the forest and tree line (timber line) and the snow line. The mean altitude of the potential timber line in the greater Alpine region, for example, was calculated to be 1730 m by the end of the 19th century, 1880 m by the end of the 20th century and to lie between 2120 and 2820 m by the end of the 21st century. The latter altitudes were projected for the greenhouse gas scenarios RCP 2.6 (best case) and RCP 8.5 (worst case). The altitude of the timber line (and the other boundaries of the altitudinal belts) is generally higher in the Western Alps, showing a clear west-east slope.
Article
Full-text available
Nowadays, the development of high-resolution flood hazard models have become feasible at continental and global scale, and their application in developing countries and data-scarce regions can be extremely helpful to increase preparedness of population and reduce catastrophic impacts.The present work describes the development of a novel procedure for global flood hazard mapping, based on the most recent advances in large scale flood modelling. We derive a long-term dataset of daily river discharges from the hydrological simulations of the Global Flood Awareness System (GloFAS). Streamflow data is downscaled on a high resolution river network and processed to provide the input for local flood inundation simulations, performed with a two-dimensional hydrodynamic model. All flood-prone areas identified along the river network are then merged to create continental flood hazard maps for different return periods at 30'' resolution. We evaluate the performance of our methodology in several river basins across the globe by comparing simulated flood maps with both official hazard maps and a mosaic of flooded areas detected from satellite images. The evaluation procedure also includes comparisons with the results of other large scale flood models. We further investigate the sensitivity of the flood modelling framework to several parameters and modelling approaches and identify strengths, limitations and possible improvements of the methodology.
Article
Full-text available
Coastal plains are amongst the most densely populated areas in the world. Many coastal peatlands are drained to create arable land. This is not without consequences; physical compaction of peat and its degradation by oxidation lead to subsidence, and oxidation also leads to emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2). This study complements existing studies by quantifying total land subsidence and associated CO2 respiration over the past millennium in the Dutch coastal peatlands, to gain insight into the consequences of cultivating coastal peatlands over longer timescales. Results show that the peat volume loss was 19.8 km3, which lowered the Dutch coastal plain by 1.9 m on average, bringing most of it below sea level. At least 66%of the volume reduction is the result of drainage, and 34 % was caused by the excavation and subsequent combustion of peat. The associated CO2 respiration is equivalent to a global atmospheric CO2 concentration increase of ~0.39 ppmv. Cultivation of coastal peatlands can turn a carbon sink into a carbon source. If the path taken by the Dutch would be followed worldwide, there will be double trouble: globally significant carbon emissions and increased flood risk in a globally important human habitat. The effects would be larger than the historic ones because most of the cumulative Dutch subsidence and peat loss was accomplished with much less efficient techniques than those available now.
Article
Full-text available
In many delta cities land subsidence exceeds absolute sea level rise up to a factor of ten by excessive groundwater extraction related to rapid urbanization and population growth. Without change, parts of Jakarta, Ho Chi Minh City, Bangkok and numerous other delta (and coastal) cities will sink below sea level. Increased flooding and also other widespread impacts of land subsidence result already in damage of billions of dollars per year. In order to gain insight in the complex, multi-sectoral aspects of subsidence, to raise awareness and to support decision making on appropriate adaptation strategies and measures, an Integrated Assessment Framework (IAF) for subsidence is introduced, illustrated by several (delta) case studies. Based on that a list of 10 generic key issues and possible solutions is presented in order to further develop and support a (generic) approach how to deal with subsidence in current and future subsidence-prone areas. For exchange of experiences and knowledge development.on subsidence in deltas the Delta Alliance, a knowledge network of deltas worldwide, can be supportive.