ArticlePDF Available

A systematic review of higher education students' experiences of engaging with online therapy

Authors:

Abstract

Aim The prevalence of mental health difficulties and the demand for psychological support for students in higher education (HE) appear to be increasing. Online therapy is a widely accessible resource that could provide effective support; however, little is known about such provision. The aim of this study was therefore to answer the research question ‘What factors serve to influence higher education students' levels of engagement with online therapy?’ Method A systematic review of qualitative scholarly and peer‐reviewed literature was conducted across 10 databases. Six papers met the inclusion criteria, were assessed for quality and were analysed using thematic synthesis. Findings Factors that serve to motivate HE students to engage with online therapy included the perception that it might enhance the quality of the therapeutic relationship, that it would facilitate more autonomy in the work, and that it might enable them to be anonymous and avoid face‐to‐face contact. In contrast, demotivating factors were primarily practical in nature. Fitting therapeutic work into their busy lives, technological challenges and persisting mental health stigma proved important factors. Conclusion This review synthesises the reasons why HE students might engage with or withdraw from online therapy. It highlights that students appear to view online therapy positively, but they can be inhibited by both personal and practical issues. Therapeutic services therefore need to ensure that information about the work they offer online is clear and transparent and that the platforms they work on are secure and stable. Finally, the need for further research, to keep abreast of technological developments, is recommended.
Couns Psychother Res. 2020;00:1–13.
|
  1wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/capr
Received: 27 August 2020 
|
  Revised: 15 November 2020 
|
  Accepted: 16 Nove mber 2020
DOI: 10.1002/capr.12371
SPECIAL SECTION ONLINE TECHNOLOGIES
A systematic review of higher education students' experiences
of engaging with online therapy
Terry Hanley | Claire Wyatt
This is an op en access arti cle under the ter ms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial Licen se, which permi ts use, distri bution and repr oduction
in any medium, provided the original work is properl y cited an d is not use d for comm ercial purposes.
© 2020 The Authors. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research published by John Wiley & So ns Ltd on behalf of British Associat ion for Counselling and
Psychotherapy
Contri buting autho r: Terr y Hanley (terr y.hanley @manc heste r.ac.uk )
University of Ma nches ter, Manchester, UK
Correspondence
Claire Wyatt, University of Ma nches ter,
Manche ster, UK
Email: clairewyatt76@hotmail.com
Abstract
Aim: The prevalence of mental health difficulties and the demand for psychological
support for students in higher education (HE) appear to be increasing. Online therapy
is a widely accessible resource that could provide effective support; however, little
is known about such provision. The aim of this study was therefore to answer the
research question ‘What factors serve to influence higher education students' levels
of engagement with online therapy?’
Method: A systematic review of qualitative scholarly and peer-reviewed literature
was conducted across 10 databases. Six papers met the inclusion criteria, were as-
sessed for quality and were analysed using thematic synthesis.
Findings: Factors that serve to motivate HE students to engage with online therapy
included the perception that it might enhance the quality of the therapeutic relation-
ship, that it would facilitate more autonomy in the work, and that it might enable
them to be anonymous and avoid face-to-face contact. In contrast, demotivating
factors were primarily practical in nature. Fitting therapeutic work into their busy
lives, technological challenges and persisting mental health stigma proved important
factors.
Conclusion: This review synthesises the reasons why HE students might engage with
or withdraw from online therapy. It highlights that students appear to view online
therapy positively, but they can be inhibited by both personal and practical issues.
Therapeutic services therefore need to ensure that information about the work they
offer online is clear and transparent and that the platforms they work on are secure
and stable. Finally, the need for further research, to keep abreast of technological
developments, is recommended.
KEY WORDS
COVID-19, engagement, higher education, online therapy, student
2 
|
   HANLEY ANd W YAT T
1 | INTRODUCTION
The increasing prevalence of mental health difficulties in higher
education students is a growing concern that requires considerable
critical attention (Deasy et al., 2014). In the summary of equality
and diversity data issued by the United Kingdom's (UK) Office for
Students (OfS), reporting of mental health conditions by students
increased from 0.6% in 2010/11 to 3.1% in 2017/18, an inc rease big-
ger than the reporting of any other disability (May, 2019). A recent
briefing paper by Hubble and Bolton (2019, p.3) also draws attention
to 33.9% of students who have experienced a ‘serious psychological
issue for which they felt they needed professional help’.
Students engaging in higher education are a particularly vulnera-
ble population due to the developmental transition they are experi-
encing (Conley et al., 2014). The additional impact of the COVID-19/
coronavirus global pandemic (ECDC, 2020) has been a current and
highly per tine nt con ce rn for th e prov ision of appr op riate, he lp fu l on-
line psychological support during challenging times (Sahu, 2020). As
a consequence, within some countries, all educational institutions
(schools, colleges and universities), and retail and non-essential ser-
vices were instructed by governments to close and populations were
advised to stay home with the exception of essential travel or work.
The implications of measures such as these for well-being and men-
tal health are vast. Arguably, this is further heightened for young
people and HE students whose education, physical–social interac-
tion and support networks have been dramatically curtailed.
Prior to the outbreak of COVID-19, the number of HE students
experiencing mental health difficulties had already appeared to in-
crease, reflected in the rising demand for support. In a survey con-
ducted by the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR; 2017), 61%
of higher education institutions reported an increase in demand
for counselling services of more than 25% over a five-year period
(T ho rl ey, 2017). The mounti ng dem an d on ins ti tu ti on s to provide ad-
equate and effective counselling services, combined with limite d re-
sources, has contributed to the development and provision of online
therapy services in addition to traditional support pathways (Inglis
& Cathcar t, 2018). HE students communicate and relate to other
people pervasively via technology online, repor tedly spending more
than 55 hr/week online (Hyperoptic, 2019). Services such as online
support networks (e.g. Big White Wall, SilverCloud), university on-
line therapy services (Kooth Student) and interactive self-help pro-
grammes have been established to tr y to meet this demand. Despite
the increasing demand for, and supply of, online therapy services
for HE students, data from several studies suggest that student en-
gagement in, and completion of, online therapy are consistently low
(Clarke et al., 2014; Musiat et al., 2014; Santucci et al., 2013).
1.1 | HE student well-being
The term ‘h igher educat ion’ in this review ref ers to individ uals who are
18 years or older attending institutions of education such as colleges
and universities. HE students are vulnerable to the development of
mental health problems as they are faced with a spectrum of internal
intrapersonal, interpersonal, educational, financial and cultural pres-
sures (Clear y et al., 2011). Internal risk factors relate to the individual
person and situation. Students transition through a signific ant phase
of intrapersonal growth and development during their time in higher
education (e.g. Chickering, 1969).
Chickering (1969) proposed seven areas that impact upon the
identity development for students. These include developing
competence, managing emotions, moving through autonomy, de-
veloping mature interpersonal relationships, establishing identity,
developing purpose and developing integrity. Chickering's (1969)
theory is supported by research that demonstrates that disruption
of the intrapersonal developmental process may contribute to the
onset of ment al health difficulties (Clear y et al., 2011; Eisenberg
et al., 2007). Most HE students are living away from home, often
for the firs t time, in an unfamiliar town , city or even cou ntr y, away
from an established network of family and friends, and experi-
ence subsequent homesickness and social isolation (Thurber &
Walton, 2012). International students are also confronted with
cultural–transitional factors, such as adapting to a different lan-
gu age , cu l t ure and cus tom s of a new cou ntr y. Fu r t h e r more, HE stu-
de nts mu s t man a ge fi nan c ia l inse cur i t y (Ei sen b erg et al., 20 07) an d
the establishing, developing and maintaining of a social network
Implications for practice
• Higher education institutions might of fer online therapy
as an alternative to face-to-face support. Online therapy
can provide a means of supporting students who might
not ordinarily access therapy, with the convenience, and
in some cases the anonymous nature of the communica-
tion, proving attractive to some individuals.
• Technological problems and personal concerns about
accessing therapeutic services can act as a major de-
terrent to engaging with online services. To limit de-
motivating factors, online therapy ser vices need to be
offered on secure and stable platforms. Further, they
should provide clear and transparent descriptions of the
online therapeutic support that they offer. Such content
will help to manage the expect ations of those accessing
support.
• Currently, there is a very limited body of work explor-
ing online therapy with students in higher education.
Further research is needed to explore new developments
in online therapy with students in higher education.
Implication for policy
Those involved in developing counselling and psycho-
therapy services in higher education settings should
consider online therapy as a viable way of increasing
engagement with the support they offer.
  
|
 3
HANLE Y ANd W YATT
(Vazquez et al., 2011). Of consideration, during the COVID-19
global pandemic, are the stay-at-home policies and the psycho-
logical, emotional and financial pressure of unfolding events
(Sahu, 2020). HE student s have had to return to their homes, and
families all over the world and, in some instances, individuals are
solely reliant on technology to retain contact with educational
services, friends, social networks and support systems.
To support HE students in need of additional support, the re-
sources available vary from institution to institution. In general,
however, they comprise of services such as pastoral services, tele-
phone help lines, face-to-face institutional counselling services,
institutional online self-administered and supported services, work-
shops and online psychoeducation information (Broglia et al., 2017;
Hanley et al., 2020; Mair, 2016).
1.2 | Online therapy
Online therapy is an evolving therapeutic way of working that en-
deavours to provide an alternative pathway to support individuals
experiencing mental health difficulties (Hanley & Reynolds, 2009;
Sweeney et al., 2019). It assists in meeting a demand for psycho-
logical support that traditional face-to-face therapeutic resources
are not always able to meet (Stallman, 2011). For instance, online
services can support younger individuals in accessing services that
they may not ordinarily approach (Ersahin & Hanley, 2017). Online
provision of therapeutic support is recognised and referenced in
the literature by various terms including online therapy, e-therapy,
e-counselling, computerised cognitive behavioural therapy (cCBT)
and electronic cognitive behavioural therapy (eCBT) (Ostrowski &
Collins, 2016). The term ‘online therapy’ in this review refers to all
types of online therapeutic support, including asynchronous (email)
and synchronous (instant messaging) communication, video support
and self-administered Internet-delivered systems (SAID) of support.
The ongoing development of online therapy can be aligned to the
research reflecting upon the help-seeking behaviour of HE students.
This indicates an increasing demand by young people for psychologi-
cal support and help-seeking predominantly via the Internet in the
first instance (Hanley et al., 2019).
1.3 | Engagement with online therapy
The term ‘engagement’ in this review is interpreted as ‘to partici-
pate in, and to complete an agreed number of therapeutic sessions’.
There is considerable literature relating to online therapy, includ-
ing studies on engagement with online therapy. This includes re-
flections on the broad territory of online therapy and also focuses
on specific areas such as cCBT, eCBT, and asynchronous and syn-
chronous approaches, and concerns different presentations and
populations. However, most of the research is currently quantitative
(Musiat et al., 2014; Richards & Timulak, 2012) and focuses upon re-
ported fallout rates, dropout figures, levels of attrition, efficacy and
satisfaction. For instance, in Santucci et al.'s (2013) study evaluat-
ing university-implemented computerised CBT, 88% of participants
(n = 43) did not complete the course of eight sessions. High levels
of attrition, 61.7% of participants (n = 1,141), were also repor ted
in Musiat et al.'s (2014) paper investigating the efficacy for HE stu-
dents of a CBT-informed transdiagnostic online intervention. There
seems to be limited research, however, that considers how students
are engaging and experiencing online therapy or why levels of attri-
tion are consistently high for this medium of therapy.
1.4 | Rationale
Given the increasing prevalence of online therapy for HE students,
alongside the limited understanding of why this group might engage
with such services, this review provides a synthesis of the research
reflecting upon this topic. As such, the following research question
is posed:
What factors serve to influence higher education stu-
dents' levels of engagement with online therapy?
2 | METHODOLOGY
A systematic review is a rigorous and methodical review of the litera-
ture that, unlike a standard literature review, utilises a ‘pre-specified
protocol to minimise bias’ (Dempster, 2011, p.15) to appraise and
synthesise qualit y research findings (Hanley & Cutts, 2013). In this
paper, a systematic review of the peer-reviewed literature was con-
ducted, investigating HE student s' engagement with online therapy.
2.1 | Search terms and strategy
The search strategy comprised of an initial search of Google Scholar,
PsycINFO and EMBASE to confirm no existing systematic reviews
relating to HE students' experiences of online therapy had been
conducted. A total of 10 dat abases, plus additional sources such as
Google Scholar and reference list s of relevant articles, were used in
the search strategy, including the following: PsycINFO, ERIC , Scopus,
Cochrane Library, American Periodicals, British Periodicals, Humanities
Index, Periodicals Archive Online, SciTech Premium Collection and Social
Science Premium Collection. Following a number of pilot searches,
the following search terms were developed: “higher education” OR
“HE” AND “student*” AND “online therapy” OR “e-therapy ” OR “in-
ternet counselling” OR “online therapy” OR “internet therapy” AND
“engagement” OR “attending” OR “attend” OR “engage” AND “com-
puterised cognitive behaviour therapy” OR “ccbt”. Searches were
limited to scholarly journals and peer-reviewed journal articles for
the time period 20 09–2019 and included only English-language ar-
ticles where full text was available. All searches were completed in
November 2019.
4 
|
   HANLEY ANd W YAT T
2.2 | Eligibility criteria
Studies retrieved from the searches were transferred to Mendeley
to facilitate removal of duplicates and assessment against the inclu-
sion and exclusion criteria (Figure 1).
Studies included a population sample of students aged 18 years
or older, which focused upon those attending higher education and
related explicitly to mental health. Additionally, eligible studies in-
cluded an online therapy intervention via computer, smar tphone or
other computer-mediated devices delivered synchronously (by text
message, chat room, Voice over Internet Protocol [VoIP], instant
messaging or videoconferencing) or asynchronously (by email, online
discussion boards) or via an independent programme or application,
for example cCBT. Qualitative studies reporting on engagement, at-
titudes and experience, access, adherence, repetition, completion,
attrition, dropout, premature termination or non-usage were con-
sidered for inclusion.
The database and Google Scholar searches followed the
Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-
an alys es (PR ISMA) prot o c o l (see Figur e 2 for a PRIS MA flow di a gr am
of search process), generating a total of 1,315 records. Following
a screening by title and removal of duplicates, 181 records were
screened by abstract according to the inclusion and exclusion cri-
teria; of these, 151 records were excluded. The full-text articles
were then read, and of the remaining 30 records, 24 records were
excluded that were either unpublished, did not focus upon mental
health, did not relate explicitly to higher education and where the
population sample was below 18 years old. Thirteen additional re-
cords were identified within the articles as potentially eligible but
were further excluded due to not relating to mental health, not fo-
cusing on engagement or not pertaining to online therapy. The re-
maining six studies were deemed to meet the inclusion criteria for
the review, subject to quality appraisal.
2.3 | Quality appraisal
The final papers identified through the PRISMA process were as-
sessed for methodological qualit y using an adapted version of the
guidelines prepared by the National Institute for Health and Clinical
Excellence (NICE, 2009), devised by Ersahin (2014). The criteria con-
sidered to assess the quality of the papers focused upon (a) the aims
of the research, (b) the study design, (c) the recruitment and data
collection, (d) the data analysis, (e) the findings/interpretation, and
(f) the implications for research.
The overall quality assessment of the papers resulted in four of
six papers being rated as high quality and two of six papers rated
as medium quality (due to lack of clarity regarding ethical consider-
ations of the studies). Due to the limited number of papers involved
in the review, it was decided to include all six in the analysis.
FIGURE 1 Inclusion and Exclusion
criteria
noisulcxEnoisulcnI
Participants: aged between 18yrs
+, in Higher Education, Students,
related to mental health
Participants: under 18yrs, not in
Higher Education, not students
Intervention: Online therapy
o Interventions delivered via
computer / Smart phone / other IT
devices
o Type of interventions:
Synchronous: text message /chat
room / VOIP / Instant messaging /
video conferencing or
Asynchronous: Email / Online
discussion boards or
Independent: Programme /
Application e.g. Computerised
cognitive behavioural therapy
(cCBT)
Intervention: Not mental health, not
technology-based
Outcomes: Engagement
o Attitudes and experience
o Accessing, adherence, repetition
and completion
o Attrition, drop-out, premature
termination or non-usage
Study type: Not a study
Study type: Qualitative
Publication status: Published
studies
Publication status: Unpublished
studies due to possible lower
methodological quality
Country of origin: Worldwide
Language: English Language Language: Not English language
  
|
 5
HANLE Y ANd W YATT
2.4 | Data extraction and synthesis
The results/findings sections of the six papers that were identified
were utilised as data for thematic synthesis in this review (Thomas
& Harden, 2008). Thematic synthesis is an example of integrative
synthesis that is often more deductive when concepts in primar y
research are clearly defined (Flemming et al., 2019). There are three
stages to the process of thematic synthesis, including the following:
(a) line-by-line coding, (b) development of descriptive themes, and (c)
generation of analy tical themes. The analysis involved both deduc-
tive analysis of the data and explorator y inductive analysis. Themes
were explicitly looked for that reflected motivating and demotivating
factors related to student engagement with online therapy. Within
these high-level categories, a more explorative inductive analysis
was conduc ted to present the nuances reported in the papers.
2.5 | Ethical considerations
This review was a desk-based study that did not include human
participants. As such, the study was conducted in accordance
with the University of Manchester ethical guidelines, the British
Psychological Society (BPS, 2014) and Health and Care Professions
Council (HCPC, 2012) research guidelines and the National Institute
for Health and Care E xcellence guidelines (NICE, 2012) for under-
taking systematic reviews.
3 | FINDINGS
The systematic search process (Figure 2) identified six peer-reviewed
journal articles for thematic synthesis in this review.
3.1 | Characteristics of Included Studies Table
A summary of the characteristics of the six identified articles was
produced and is reported in Figure 3 below. This included the
author(s) and year of publication, the primary aim and focus of the
article, the sample, the research design and the location of the au-
thor. The referenced numbers within the findings section relate to
the numbered papers on the characteristics table.
All of the papers focus upon therapeutic work with HE stu-
dents aged 18 years or older. As indicated in Figure 3, the primar y
FIGURE 2 PRISMA flow diagram of
the systematic search process
6 
|
   HANLEY ANd W YAT T
aim and focus of the papers varied, but each explicitly focused
upon the experiences of students accessing online therapeutic
services.
3.2 | Summary of findings from data synthesis
The findings from the six papers are presented in three major
strands. Firstly, the motivating and demotivating factors are
presented. Following this, a final strand of unique factors is pre-
sented. This final strand included elements that did not naturally
fit into either of the first strands but related directly to the stu-
dents' experience of accessing online therapy. Sixteen subordinate
themes were identified from the data synthesis that fit into these
three overarching strands. Figure 4 illustrates these subordinate
themes and includes the number of coded references observed in
the papers in parenthesis.
3.3 | Motivating factors
Factors motivating individuals to engage with online therapy were
evident in all six studies and were strongly linked to the client's per-
sonal experiences of, and feelings about, engaging in online therapy.
These motivating factors were categorised into the following nine
subordinate themes: (a) enhancing the therapeutic relationship, (b)
facilitating autonomy, (c) avoiding face-to-face support, (d) providing
additional thinking time, (e) therapy tool, (f) reducing isolation, (g)
the value of the ra peutic wr it in g, (h) ano ny mit y, an d (i ) so ci al sup por t.
3.3.1 | Enhancing the therapeutic relationship
Clients reported greater engagement with online therapy when the
therapy was more personalised, offering support and understand-
ing, ack no wl edgement, a sen se of being heard and cared ab ou t (1–5).
FIGURE 3 Characteristics of included
studies
No
.
Author
(year)
Primary Aim and
focus
Sample Design Location
1 Dunn
(2012)
Online therapy
relationship and
therapeutic
engagement.
Focus:
Asynchronous (by
email) counselling
experiences.
University
students
(n=10)
Qualitative
(IPA)
Portsmouth,
UK
2 Fang et al
(2017)
Understand benefits,
challenges &
experiences of online
therapy.
Focus: Experiences
of text-based online
therapy.
Undergradu
ate students
aged 18-
45yrs
(n=33)
Qualitative
(Content
analysis)
Toronto,
Canada
3 Mishna,
Bogo &
Sawyer
(2013)
Perspectives of cyber
and face-to-face
counselling.
Focus: Benefits &
challenges of cyber
and face-to-face
counselling for
students.
Undergradu
ate students
aged 18yrs-
34yrs
(n=34)
Qualitative
(Grounded
theory)
Toronto,
Canada
4 Walsh &
Richards
(2017)
Evaluation of
students’ experiences
and engagement with
internet-delivered
treatment programme
for anxiety.
Students
aged 18yrs
to 34yrs
(n=7)
Qualitative
(Thematic
analysis)
Dublin,
Ireland
5 Richards
& Timulak
(2012)
Helpful and hindering
events in therapist-
delivered vs self-
administered online
CBT in college
students.
University
students
19yrs to
59yrs
(n=80)
Descriptive
-
interpretive
qualitative
analysis
Dublin,
Ireland
6 Richards
& Timulak
(2013)
Satisfaction with
therapist-delivered vs
self-administered
online CBT in college
students
University
students
19yrs-59yrs
(n=80)
Descriptive
-
interpretive
qualitative
analysis
Dublin,
Ireland
  
|
 7
HANLE Y ANd W YATT
even when you didn't even read the email yet, you
know that somebody is caring for you.
(Mishna et al., 2013, p.173)
Further, in Dunn's (2012) analysis of semi-structured interviews,
10 former email counselling clients revealed aspects of the therapeu-
tic relationship necessary for positive engagement in therapy. These
included the establishment and maintenance of clear boundaries,
consistent unconditional positive regard and not feeling judged by the
therapist. Clients were seen to be more inclined to engage in face-to-
face therapy after a positive experience of the therapeutic relationship
in online therapy (1).
I felt she honestly cared ab out me and my problems and
I felt better about counsellors in general which made
me feel more comfortable meeting someone in person.
(Dunn, 2012, p.323)
In both Dunn (2012) and Fang et al.'s (2018) studies, the findings
supported the idea that the online environment can offer relational
distance within the therapeutic relationship, and create a sense of se-
curity, and that this is preferred over relational absence (i.e. computer-
ised cognitive behavioural therapy).
email just gives you that little bit of distance that pro-
tects you.
(Dunn, 2012, p.321)
3.3.2 | Facilitating autonomy
Dunn (2012) linked the client's feelings of disempowerment in face-
to-face therapy to the perceived positions of power between the
therapist and client. In contrast, in online therapy the clients in the
study reported a greater locus of control with the therapy process.
if my issues were made light of or if I was told that
I was overreacting…I could just ignore the advice if
I wanted to and not reply. I guess it has to do with
a feeling of having more control over the counselling
and the directions it would take.
(Dunn, 2012, p.323)
Distinctive advantages of online therapy reported in Fang et al.'s
(2018) study included ‘autonomy and agency in the counselling pro-
cess’ (Fang et al., 2018, p.1781). In their study, clients report having
autonomy over when and how they chose to engage with online ther-
apy as being a factor that maintained engagement in online services.
typing stuf f out in whatever order I feel like, taking
as much time as I need to, directing the conversation
however I want and in whatever order I want…this is
one of the things that drew me to this programme.
(Fang et al., 2018, p.1781)
3.3.3 | Avoiding face-to-face contact
Clients reported experiencing difficulty with direct or face-to-face
contact. This linked with fear and preconceptions of judgement,
criticism and the perception of wasting another person's time
(1– 4) .
I don't like counsellors bec ause I always feel kind of
guilty that I'm wasting someone's time and it's very
intimidating sitting one on one with someone and
chatting about yourself.
(Walsh & Richards, 2017, p.26)
Consequently, for some, engaging in online therapy seemed to be a
safer and less intimidating alternative for seeking support.
FIGURE 4 Themes identified in findings
8 
|
   HANLEY ANd W YAT T
3.3.4 | Providing additional thinking time
In five of the studies (1–5), asynchronous online therapy was offered
to participants either by email, text-based or programme-based for-
mats. Individuals repor ted that thinking time was important to them
(1). Furthermore, convenience for those living at long distance, sup-
por t be ing available 24/7 and flexibilit y wi th lifest yle, espe cially dur-
ing examination and holiday periods, were key motivating factors for
engagement with online therapy (2–4).
you know it's easy, it fits into your lifestyle, it's
convenient.
(Walsh & Richards, 2017, p.22)
3.3.5 | Therapy tool
Clients report using past online therapy sessions as a ‘therapy tool’
(1–4), notably being able to refer to previous work to gain a sense
of progress and accomplishment, as well as a set of resources
available in the prac tice and acquiring of new skills. Having a re-
cord of the therapeutic work completed appeared to motivate cli-
ents to engage with the therapeutic work as it facilitated change
and acted as a therapy tool for use in the present and future. Fang
et al. (2018) reported the provision of instant resources, such
as online tools and links, also encouraged engagement in online
therapy.
you can read back over the reply again and again. This
helped me and I did it a lot. I would read them at dif-
ferent points throughout the week and in various dif-
ferent frames of mind.
(Dunn, 2012, p.322)
3.3.6 | Reducing isolation
Findings in four of the papers (1–4) reviewed reported that
clients engage with online therapy due to their experience of
physical and psychological isolation. For instance, findings in
Dunn's (2012) study suggest that difficult y asking for help and
self-doubt can psychologically isolate clients, preventing indi-
viduals from seeking help face-to-face. Engagement in online
therapy for these clients can therefore be within personal levels
of tolerance and reduce psychological pressure and the sense of
isolation.
I had a problem with asking for help…online therapy
attracted me because I thought it would indicate to
me whether I was worthy of talking to someone and
getting help.
(Dunn, 2012, p.323)
3.3.7 | Value of therapeutic writing
Mishna et al. (2013) report the value of written communication as
being cathartic, reducing avoidance and feeling more legitimate for
students engaging with cyber counselling. The cathartic quality of
writing was similarly reported in two of the other studies (2,4). Some
students appear to feel greater confidence t yping or writing, rather
than verbalising their feelings and experience (1).
instead of just writing into a journal where no one
would see it, it's like now someone is reading this and
responding in a way that's really good.
(Mishna et al., 2013, p.174)
3.3.8 | Anonymity
There is a level of safety and comfor t reported in the findings of
studies within the review (1,2,4,6). Clients reported being hidden or
concealed in this way of working. In some cases, a desire for ano-
nymity in counselling was repor ted, described in Dunn's (2012) find-
ings as being similar to a confessional. The desire for, and comfort
with, being detached or hidden is connected intrapersonally for cli-
ents with other subthemes of isolation and autonomy.
I was hoping to remain totally anonymous even to
you, my councillor.
(Fang et al., 2018, p.1780)
3.3.9 | Social support
Walsh and Richards' (2017) study repor ted on students engaging in a
programme of online therapy that also offered community support.
Findings in th is stu dy sugges t that stud en ts expe ri en ce d re assuran ce ,
support, validation and a sense of community whilst maintaining a
sense of anonymity. This helped student s to feel less alone and more
motivated to engage with the platform. As only one study offered
this type of suppor t, the significance of this cannot be extended too
far. Further studies exploring the helpfulness of community support
alongside online therapy could therefore be investigated.
it was good to like, know that other people were ac-
cessing it and have a sense of like community and
know that like you weren't alone it.
(Walsh & Richards, 2017, p.25)
3.4 | Demotivating factors
It is clear from synthesis of the findings of the papers that there
are factors that demotivate individuals from engaging with online
  
|
 9
HANLE Y ANd W YATT
therapy. Four subordinate themes were identified. These were as
follows: (a) time challenges, (b) technology challenges, (c) experi-
encing stigma, and (d) writing difficulty. It is critical to gain a clear
understanding of the factors demotivating clients from sustained
engagement with online therapy in order to improve services
and meet the demands of students experiencing psychological
difficulty.
3.4.1 | Time challenges
Findings in three of the studies reviewed (2,4,6) suggest that stu-
dents underestimate the commitment of time and effor t required
to engage with online therapy, perhaps mistaking it for a ‘quick
fix’. However, once they engage with the process, those involved
in the studies reported gaining a clearer understanding of what is
involved and what is expected. This process can lead to high rates
of dropout. Conflicts with other priorities such as educational de-
mands and pressure also result in dropping out of the online pro-
cess (4). Findings in two of the studies reported frustration with
the time needed in online therapy, the involvement of a lot of work
and resistance to do the work due to the time commitment re-
quired (2,6).
It seems to require a lot more effort than a session
in person.
(Fang et al., 2018, p.1783)
3.4.2 | Technology challenges
Two out of six studies found technology to be a demotivating factor
relating to engagement in online therapy. The key issues reported
related to the difficulty of navigating support online, administration
issues (such as difficulty logging in or being disconnected), bounda-
ries being interrupted by technology, and confusion and frustration
navigating the nuances of online communication (2,5).
I hit the wrong button and saved a draft instead of
sending out the email! It seems that technical difficul-
ties keep happening to me.
(Fang et al., 2018, p.1782)
3.4.3 | Experiencing stigma
Individuals continue to experience stigma regarding seeking psycho-
logical help and support. Students reported feelings of shame and
fear of judgement for needing counselling and fear of exposure or
wasting the counsellors' time (1,2,4).
I do feel that people generally look shamefully on
people who need counselling, like they can't deal
with their problems on their own. And prior to signing
up..there was an element of shame in myself, for this
same reason.
(Dunn, 2012, p.322)
3.4.4 | Writing difficulty
One of the studies in the review highlighted that writing may be a
challenge for some individuals and bec ause online therapy is heavily
dependent on the client communicating their feelings and experi-
ences by writing, students may be more inclined to dropout for this
reason. The key challenges reported relating to writing difficulty
were frustration with the difficulty experienced trying to commu-
nicate, a lack of guidance with the writing process, uncertainty and
self-doubt about writing ability and being overwhelmed with the ef-
fort needed to engage by writing (2).
I felt a little frustrated with myself. I think it is difficult
for me within this email format to actually reflect on
what I am saying, even if I revise it.
(Fang et al., 2018, p.1782)
3.5 | Unique factors
During the synthesis process, it was evident that certain factors
were impacting levels of engagement both positively and negatively
that were specific to the individual or the design/t ype of online
therapy. The three subordinate themes identified were programme
content and design, individual beliefs and values, and online suppor t
and provision.
3.5.1 | Programme content and design
This subtheme comprised 26 of the coding references across three
out of the six papers. It is clear from the data that how individuals ac-
cess, navigate and engage with online therapy programmes, whether
self-administered or facilitated by a therapist, can encourage or de-
motivate clients to maintain their engagement. Factors such as hav-
ing the ability to track achievement , monitor progress and gain new
information and skills (e.g. relaxation techniques) proved important.
Other factors such as difficulty navigating online platforms, an over-
whelming design, being tex t heavy, disengaging content and lack of
identification with programme features (e.g. unrealistic examples
and complicated programme structures) negatively impacted en-
gagement (4–6).
When an item I'd completed was ticked of f of my to
do list, it provided me with a sense of accomplishment
and motivation.
(Walsh & Richards, 2017, p.22)
10 
|
   HANLEY ANd W YAT T
3.5.2 | Individual beliefs and values
Walsh and Richards (2017) reported that successful maintained en-
gagement in online therapy depended upon personal characteristics
such as how self-motivated the individual is. Findings in their study
were supported by Fang et al.'s (2018) study repor ting that individu-
als who are conscientious, goal-driven and self-motivated, with a
high level of self-efficacy, found engaging with online therapy more
comfortable and helpful.
I wanted to use the programme to gain the relevant
skills and strategies to tackle my personal issues.
(Walsh & Richards, 2017, p.25)
3.5.3 | Online support and provision
Differences in the counsellor response method and structure of
therapeutic interventions online can facilitate or interrupt the thera-
peutic relationship and therapeutic process (1). In Dunn's (2012)
findings, individuals reported the importance of consideration of
language and tex t formatting in online therapy. Adapting language,
text format and st yle to meet the needs of clients may help them to
feel heard and understood.
the way [my counsellor] responded to my emails was
perfect. She wrote between my paragraphs, address-
ing each issue as I had raised it, then I could do the
same for my reply. It helped to see clearly as issues
were addressed and clarified.
(Dunn, 2012, p.322)
4 | DISCUSSION
The findings of this study can help to guide services and improve the
effective provision of psychological support to potentially vulnerable
HE students. Within the three main strands highlighted in the analysis
(motivating factors, demotivating factors and unique factors), 16 sub-
ordinate themes were identified offering further insight and provid-
ing answers to the research question, ‘What factor s serve to influence
higher education students’ levels of engagement with online therapy?'
In summary, these highlight that the students in the studies were rela-
tively positive towards online therapy. They found the flexible nature
of the resources being offered helpful and this appeared to increase
the likelihood that they would engage with therapy. In contrast, how-
ever, the nascent development of online services also came through
in the reports from those in the studies. Technological limitations and
personal concerns about engaging with mental health and well-being
services were not always overcome by the mediated services on offer.
Below, we discuss these elements in more det ail.
Six out of the nine subthemes generated under the main theme
‘motivating factors’ relate to the value of humanising the clients'
experience of online therapy. Clients are motivated to engage with
online therapy when their experience is personalised, and they re-
ceive understanding, acknowledgement, caring and support from an-
other human being in addition to clear boundaries, consistency and
non-judgement. Providing online support services that embrace the
value of the therapeutic relationship is therefore critical, particularly
during extended periods of isolation. Equally, the research indicated
that the support of others experiencing psychological difficulties,
shared vi a fo ru ms or online comm unit ies, offered individuals a sense of
reassurance, validation, belonging and greater motivation to maintain
engagement. Such a finding is echoed in studies of students seeking
psychological support through similar means (e.g. Hanley et al., 2019;
Hyperoptic, 2019). The experience of communicating via technology
for HE students is arguably more normalised and comfortable for this
population. Considerable efforts and inroads have been made to cou-
ple this prolific use of technology with the increased demand for psy-
chological support. Stand-alone online therapeutic programmes have
become more prevalent, and in the effor t to expedite these services
swiftly, coupled with finite human resources (before the COVID-19
pandemic), the importance and significance of the human fac tor in the
online therapeutic arena is arguably in jeopardy of being lost. Such a
shift in therapeutic provision would contrast many of the engaging
factors noted in this synthesis. As such, this could have serious impli-
cations for the provision of self-administered online therapy and online
therapy facilitated by an untrained online supporter.
The studies also reflected that online therapy can mitigate initial
difficulties with direct interpersonal contact. For instance, Dunn's
(2012) paper reports that face-to-face therapy can be intimidating,
with some individuals fearing being analysed and judged by the ther-
apist and thus feeling overly self-conscious and finding themselves
unable to form the words to communicate. These findings are con-
sistent with studies such as Hanley et al.'s (2019) study exploring
how young people use online forums for support. Online therapy
therefore has the potential to offer psychological support to HE stu-
dents that is within their locus of control and level of tolerance.
Higher education students can experience greater agency in
online therapy. They can choose how and when they engage, fac-
tors that are often motivated by the perception of privacy and an-
onymity. Further, some students reported utilising online therapy
as a tool for the present and future (notably returning to therapeu-
tic interchanges that had been stored). Bohart and Tallman (2010)
describe client agency as critical in the therapeutic process in con-
tributing towards a successful outcome. Findings in Hanley's (2009,
2012) work examining the quality of the working alliance in online
therapy with young people similarly indicate the impor tance of cli-
ent agency when working therapeutically online. This is concordant
with Chickering's (1969) ‘seven vectors’ theory of identity, particu-
larly managing emotional well-being and moving through autonomy.
Accordingly, the wide provision of an online therapeutic resource
has the potential to offer ongoing suppor t in the psychological de-
velopment of young adults.
Significant factors demotivating HE student's engagement in
online therapy relate to the limited perception, expectation and
  
|
 11
HANLE Y ANd W YATT
understanding of the work and time required to engage with the
online therapeutic process. As such, it is arguably the responsibil-
ity of therapists to find ways to inform, educate and raise aware-
ness of the therapeutic process, a factor that is not different with
face-to-face therapy but needs to be tailored to account for the
different media it is offered in. Technolog y removes many of the
physical barriers that traditional therapy can encounter; for in-
stance, it can increase accessibility to support by providing time
and space (Harris & Birnbaum, 2015; Pattison et al., 2015). Where
one bar ri er ma y be rem oved howeve r, pra c ti c al tech nol og ica l cha l-
lenges emerge in their place and can negatively impact upon levels
of engagement. The research informs us that some HE students
disengage from the online therapy process due to individual diffi-
culties and challenges with the process of writing itself. Findings
in King et al.'s (2007) study, focusing upon the motives and ex-
periences of young people who choose Internet instead of face-
to-face counselling, are consistent with this. They highlight the
challenge and concern that feelings may be lost in text or not fully
understood by the therapist.
Counsellors, psychotherapists and psychologists are well posi-
tioned to further develop and communicate standards and policies
for online therapeutic practice to therapists and client s. Similarly, as
stigma continues to be a factor affec ting individuals' engagement
with online therapy, it is arguably the responsibility of professionals
in these fields to continue raising awareness about mental health
and well-being so as to destigmatise the seeking of psychological
help and support. A s such, this review contributes to the idea that
the role of therapists, and thus the training of therapists, stretches
beyond the therapy room itself.
4.1 | Strengths, Limitations and Future Research
This systematic review is the first to bring together the literature
focusing upon how HE students experience engagement with on-
line therapy. The hope is that findings inform future research and
development of online services and better support the increasing
numbers of HE students experiencing psychological difficulty. There
are limitations to this study, however, which must be highlighted and
considered. Firstly, the limited capacity of the paper only permitted
a broad thematic synthesis of the data, which with more time and
resources could be deepened and potentially investigated further. A
thorough search was conducted of the library databases; however,
unpublished and grey literature was not included in the search strat-
egy, which may have limited the final ar ticles selected.
The work highlights numerous gaps in the understanding of on-
line work. For instance, further development of strategies to support
individuals who may find writing more arduous will help increase the
accessibility of online therapy. Similarly, future research and analy-
sis of existing online therapy platforms and programme content and
design may fur ther aid our un der st a nd in g of what str uct ure s, moda l-
ities and content HE students find helpful or unhelpful. Explorations
into these arenas will help inform the shaping of existing platforms
and design of new platforms to better meet the needs of users and
expectantly reduce attrition rates of such services.
In addition to the above, future re search should consider th e les-
sons learnt from the expedited transition of therapeutic face-to-face
services to online during the COVID-19 global pandemic. In particu-
lar, topics such as how services have evolved or been experienced as
helpful, unhelpful or differently to previous online provisions would
further the understanding of how HE students engage with online
therapeutic resources.
5 | CONCLUSION
This paper set out to review the existing literature exploring how
HE students engage with online therapy. Doing so has highlighted a
series of fa ctors that are likely to both motiv ate an d de mo ti vate ind i-
viduals from such engagement. Specifically, students appear to view
online therapy positively, but they can be inhibited by both personal
issues, such as the stigma associated with seeking help for issues
related to their mental health and well-being, and practical issues,
such as technological failures. Therapeutic services therefore need
to ensure that information about the work they offer online is clear
and transparent and that the platforms they work on are secure and
stable. These findings resonate with the findings exploring online
work with other groups, such as younger populations, and highlight
the need for more research focusing upon this growing arena. Online
therapy is moving at such a pace, particularly given the impac t of
changes to modes of delivery during the COVID-19 pandemic, that
research needs to keep abreast of these changes to support the de-
velopment and reflect upon the appropriateness of such changes.
Student populations are ‘digital natives’, and the expectation that
therapeutic support is provided online is only likely to grow.
ORCID
Terry Hanley https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5861-9170
Claire Wyatt https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0538-3608
REFERENCES
Bohart, A. C., & Tallman, K. (2010). Clients: The neglected common fac-
tor in psychotherapy. In B. L . Duncan, S. D. Miller, B. E. Wampold
& M . A. Hubble (Eds.), The heart and soul of change: Delivering what
works in therapy (pp. 83–111). American Psychological Association.
htt ps://doi.org/10.10 37/12075 -00 3
Broglia, E., Miling s, A., & Barkham, M. (2017). Challenges to address-
ing student mental health in embedded counselling services: A
survey of UK higher and further education institutions. British
Journal of Guidance and Counselling, 46(4), 441–455. https://doi.
org/10.1080/03069 885.2017.1370695
Chickering, A. (1969). Seven vectors. http://www.cabri ni.edu/commu
nicat ions/ProfD ev/carde vChic kering.html
Clarke, A. M., Kuosmanen, T., & Barry, M. M. (2014). A systematic re-
view of online youth mental health promotion and prevention in-
terventions. Journal of Youth Adolescence, 44, 90–113. https://doi.
org/10.1007/s1096 4-014-0165-0
Clear y, M., Walter, G., & Jackson, D. (2011). “Not always sm ooth sailing”:
Mental health issues associated with the transition from high school
12 
|
   HANLEY ANd W YAT T
to college. Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 32(4), 250–254. https://
doi.org/10.10 37/0002-9432.77.4.53 4
Conley, C. S., Kirsch, A. C., Dickson, D. A ., & Bryant, F. B. (2014).
Negotiating the transition to college: Developmental trajectories and
gender differences in psychological functioning, cognitive-affective
strategies, and social well-being. Emerging Adulthood, 2(3), 195–210.
https://doi.org/10.1177/21676 96814 521808
Deasy, C., Coughlan, B., Pironom, J., Journdan, D., & Mannix-McNamara,
P. (2014). Psychological distress and coping amongst higher educa-
tion students: A mixed method enquiry. PLoS One, 9(12), https://doi.
org/10.1371/journ al.pone.0115193
Dempster, M . (2011). A research guide for health and clinical psychology.
Palgrave Macmillan.
Dunn, K. (2012). A qualitative investigation into the online ther-
apy relationship: To meet or not to meet, that is the question.
Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 12(4), 316–326. https://doi.
org /10.1080/14733 145 .2 012 .6 69772
Eisenberg, D., G ollust, S. E., Golberstein, E., & Hefner, J. L. (20 07).
Prevalence and correlates of depression, anxiety and suicidalit y
among university students. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,
77(4), 534–542. https://doi.org/10.1037/0002-9432.77.4.534
Ersahin, Z. (2014). Online youth counselling and therapy: A systematic re-
view of individual synchronous interventions. Univer sity of Manches ter.
Unpublished.
Ersahin, Z., & Hanley, T. (2017). Using text-based synchronous chat to
offer therapeutic support to students: a systematic review of the re-
search literature. Health Education Journal, 76 (5), 531–543. https://
doi .or g/10 .1177/0 0178 96917 70 4675
European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) (2020).
Event background COVID-19. https://www.ecdc.europa.eu/en/novel
- c o r o n a v i r u s / e v e n t - b a c k g r o u n d - 2 0 1 9 o n 3 0 / 0 3 / 2 0
Fa ng, L., Tar shi s, S., Mc I nr oy, L ., & Mi s hna , F. (20 18 ). Un d erg rad uat e s tu-
dent experiences with tex t-based online therapy. British Journal of
Social Work, 48, 1774–1790. ht tps://doi.org/10.1093/bjsw/bcx111
Flemming, K., Booth, A., Garside, R., Tuncalp, O., & Noyes, J. (2019).
Qualitative evidence synthesis for complex interventions and
guideline development: Clarification of the purpose, designs and
relevant methods. BMJ Global Health, 4(e00 0882), 1–9. https://doi.
org/10.1136/bmjgh -2018-000882
Hanley, T. (200 9). The working alliance in on li ne the rapy wit h yo un g pe o-
ple: Preliminary findings. British Journal of Guidan ce and Counselling,
37(3), 257–269. ht tps://doi.org/10.1080/03069 88090 2956991
Hanley, T. (2012). Understanding the online therapeutic alliance through
the eyes of adolescent service users. Counselling and Psychotherapy
Research, 12(1), 35–43 . https://doi.or g/10 .108 0/14733 145. 2011 .
560273
Hanley, T., & Cutts, L. A. (2013). What is a systematic review? Counselling
Psychology Review, 28(4), 3–6.
Hanley, T., Daru, S., Wyatt, C., & Xiromeriti, S. (2020). The use of com-
puter-mediated technolog y to suppor t students’ mental health and well-
being in Higher Education settings. Society for Research into Higher
Education. https://www.srhe.ac.uk/downl oads/repor ts-2018/
H A N L E Y T e r r y R e p o r t . p d f
Hanley, T., Prescott , J., & Ujhelyi Gomez, K. (2019). A systematic review
exploring how young people use online forums for support around
mental health issues. Journal of Mental Health, 28(5), 566–576.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09638 237.2019.1630725
Hanley, T., & Reynolds, D. J. (2009). Counselling psychology and the in-
ternet: A review of the quantitative research into online outcomes
and alliances within text-based therapy. Counselling Psychology
Review, 24(2), 4–13.
Harris, B., & Birnbaum, R . (2015). Ethical and legal implications on
the use of technology in counselling. Clinical Social Work Journal, 43,
133141. https://doi.org/10.1007/s1061 5-014-0515-0
Health and Care Professions Council (2012). Standards of Proficiency
for Practitioners Psychologists. http://www.hpcuk.org/asset s/docum
ents/10002 963SOP_Pract ition er_psych ologi sts.pdf
Hubble, S., & Bolton, P. (2019). Support for students with mental health
issues in higher education in England. House of Commons Library.
https://resea rchbr iefin gs.files.parli ament.uk/docum ents/CBP-
8593/CBP-8593.pdf
Hyperoptic (2019). Connectivity is king for students, but they are easily
distracted. https://www.hyper optic.com/press/ posts/ conne ctivi ty-
is-king-for-stude nts-but-they-are-easil y-distr acted
Inglis, B., & Cathcart, K. (2018). O nline counselling support in austra-
lian and new zealand universities. Journal of the Australian and New
Zealand Student Services Association, 26(2), 99–112.
King, R., Bambling, M., Lloyd, C., Gomurra, R., Smith, S., Reid, W., &
Wenger, K. (2007). Online therapy: The motives and experiences
of young people who choose the internet instead of face to face or
telephone counselling. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 6(3),
169–174. htt ps://doi.org /10.108 0/14733 1406 0 0848179
Mair, D. (2016). Short-term counselling in higher education: Context, theory
and practice. Oxon: Routledge.
Mishna, F., Bogo, M., & Sawyer, J. (2013). Cyber counselling: Illuminating
benefits and challenges. Clinical Social Work Journal, 43, 169–178.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s1061 5-013-0470-1
Musiat, P., Conrod, P., Treasure, J., Tylee, A., Williams, C., & Schmidt, U.
(2014). Targeted prevention of common mental health disorders in
university students: Randomised controlled trial of a transdiagnostic
trait-focused web-based intervention. PLoS One, 9(4), 1–10. https://
doi.org/10.1371/journ al.pone.0093621
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) (2009). The
Guidelines Manual. London, UK: National Institute for Health and
Clinical Excellence. http://www.nice.org.uk /about nice/howwe
work/devel oping nicec linic algui delin es/clini calgu ideli nedev elopm
entme thods/ Guide lines Manua l2009.jsp
Office for Students (2019). Summary of equality and diversity data.
h t t p s : // w w w . o f f i c e f o r s t u d e n t s . o r g . u k / d a t a - a n d - a n a l y s i s / e q u a l i t y -
and-diver sity/
Ostrowski, J., & Collins, T. P. (2016). A comparison of telemental health
terminology used across mental health state licensure boards. T he
Professional Counselor, 6(4), 387–396. https://doi.org/10.15241/
jo.6.4.387
Pattison, S., Hanley, T., Pykhtina , O., & Ersahin, Z. (2015). Extending
practice: New horizons and contexts. In M. Robson, S. Pat tison & A.
Benyon (Eds.), The sage handbook for counselling children and young
people (pp. 427–441). Sage.
Richards, D., & Timulak, L. (2012). Client-identified helpful and hin-
dering events in therapist-delivered vs. self-administered online
cognitive-behavioural treatments for depression in college stu-
dents. Counselling Psychology Quarterly, 25(3), 251–262. https://doi.
org /10.1080/09515 070. 2012.70 3129
Sahu, P. (2020). Closure of universities due to coronavirus disease 2019
(COVID-19): Impact on education and mental health of students and
academic staff. Cureus, 12(4), E75 41. ht tps://doi.o rg/10.7759/cureus
Santucci, L. C., McHugh, R. K., Elkins, R . M., Schechter, B., Ross, M . S.,
Landa, C . E ., Eisen, S., & Barlow, D. H. (2013). Pilot implementation
of computerized cognitive behavioural ther apy in a universit y health
setting. Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 41, 514–521.
htt ps://doi.org/10.10 07/s10 48 8-0 13-04 88-2
Stallman, H. M. (2011). University counselling services in australia activ-
ities, changes, and challenges. Australian Psychologist, 47, 249–253.
https ://doi.or g/10.1111/ j.1742-954 4. 2011.00 02 3. x
Sweeney, G . M., Donovan, C. L., March, S., & Forbes , Y. (2019). Logging
into therapy: Adolescent perceptions of online therapies for men-
tal health problems. Internet Interventions, 15, 93–99. ht tps://doi.
org/10.1016/j.invent.2016.12.001
  
|
 13
HANLE Y ANd W YATT
The British Psychological Society (2014). Code of human research ethics.
http://www.bps.org.uk/syste m/files/ Publi c%20fil es/inf180_web.
pdf
The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (2012). Methods
for the development of NICE public health guidance (3rd rd.). https://
www.nice.org.uk/artic le/pmg4/chapt er/appen dix-h-quali ty-appra
i s a l c h e c k l i s t - q u a l i t a t i v e - s t u d i e s
Thomas, J., & Harden, A. (2008). Methods for the thematic syn-
thesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews. BMC
Medical Research Methodology, 8(45), 1–10. https://doi.
org /10.1186/1471-228 8-8-45
Thorley, C. (2017). Not by degrees: Improving student mental health in the
UK’s universities. Institute for Public Policy Research. https://www.
ippr.org/files/ 2017-09/15046 45674_not-by-degre es-170905.pdf
Thurber, C ., & Walton, M. D. (2012). Homesickness and adjustment in
university students. Journal of American College Health, 60(5), 415–
419. https://doi.o rg/10.108 0/0744 8 4 81. 2012.673520
Vazquez, F. L., Torres, A., Otero, P., & Diaz, O. (2011). Prevalence, co-
morbidity and correlates of DSM-I V axis: Mental disorders among fe-
male university students. The Journal of Nervous and Mental D isease,
199(6), 379–383. https://doi.org/10.1097/NMD.0b013 e3182 1cd29c
Walsh, A., & Richards, D. (2017). Experiences and engagement with the
design features and strategies of an internet-delivered treatment
programme for generalised anxiety disorder: A service-based evalua-
tion. British Journal of Guidance and Co unselling, 45(1), 16–31. https://
doi.org/10.1080/03069 885.2016.1153039
How to cite this article: Hanley T, Wyatt C . A systematic
review of higher education students' experiences of engaging
with online therapy. Couns Psychother Res. 2020;00:1–13.
https://doi.org/10.1002/capr.12371
... These services have become popular and, although pose many ethical and practical challenges, can arguably meet demands that traditional in-person services cannot always meet (Stoll et al., 2020). For instance, it is notable that web-based services are more appealing for some younger people and student populations (Hanley and Wyatt, 2021), the Internet making the access of services easier and increasing the anonymity of individuals while using them. Such benefits have particularly come to the fore during the recent pandemic, with web-based services reporting large increases in their service usage as a consequence of national policies such as school closures and social distancing measures (Inkster and Digital Mental Health Data Insights Group, 2021). ...
... These include static resources that provide information and more dynamic resources, such as online therapy (Hanley, 2020). As noted above, web-based services prove a popular idea with student populations (Hanley and Wyatt, 2021). Despite this, research also suggests that engagement with such services might be relatively limited (Musiat et al., 2014;Santucci et al., 2014). ...
... The 17% of students identifying in this way does however prove higher than the 10% prevalence reported in (Frith, 2017). Such an increase may be attributed to comforting elements such as the perceived safety provided by the anonymous communication allowed online (Hanley and Wyatt, 2021). When considering the types of goals that individuals set, it is notable that these are wide ranging. ...
Full-text available
Article
The interest in student mental health and wellbeing has increased in recent years. Additionally, there is a rising volume of students seeking support. Numerous online resources have been developed to meet this need, including anonymous web-based therapy. To date, there has been little focus upon how students may utilise such a service, and this study examines routine evaluation data (solicited from a Goal-based Outcome Measure) from a United Kingdom based service provider. Over the course of one academic year (2018–2019), 211 students articulated therapeutic goals within Kooth Student , a web-based therapy and support service for individuals in higher education. These goals were examined for key trends. The students identified a total of 625 goals to work on in therapy, with individuals setting an average of three goals each. The most common goals focused upon obtaining additional support within the service and exploring their emotions. The results suggested that female students were more likely to move towards achieving their goals, with goals that did move shifting an average of 7.74 on a 10-point scale. Practical goals that focused upon getting more help, both inside and outside the service, were most likely to be achieved. In contrast, self-help/self-care goals were less likely to be achieved. These results provide a helpful insight into how students made use of therapy and highlight the importance of the interaction that web-based services have with other provision (web-based and in-person). They also demonstrate the challenge of capturing meaningful outcome data in anonymous services.
... However, this doesn't mean people don't need to be supported to complement their efforts but rather they don't want to live or work under dictatorship or imposition of any kind. Being in control of one's affairs is mentally and physically relaxing for it allows one to think deeply and willingly mobilize all the required energy not only to failed but recover if in difficult circumstances while empowering oneself (UNDESA, n.d.), concurring with e-therapy is motivating because it enhances the building of the therapeutic relationship, autonomy of clienteles in the sense that they are somehow in control of the sessions, processes, avoid face-to-face support, allows additional time for thinking, in most cases, it is a therapy tool box, reduces isolation and psychosocial pressure, increases the value of therapeutic writing as everything is written, anonymity and client concealment; and increases the needed social support since the platform is some sort of a community (Hanley & Wyatt, 2020). Students preferred e-counselling for many reasons such as it facilitates the building of therapeutic relationship, increases independence and autonomy during work; and reduces the anxiety in face-to-face counselling (Hanley & Wyatt, 2020). ...
... Being in control of one's affairs is mentally and physically relaxing for it allows one to think deeply and willingly mobilize all the required energy not only to failed but recover if in difficult circumstances while empowering oneself (UNDESA, n.d.), concurring with e-therapy is motivating because it enhances the building of the therapeutic relationship, autonomy of clienteles in the sense that they are somehow in control of the sessions, processes, avoid face-to-face support, allows additional time for thinking, in most cases, it is a therapy tool box, reduces isolation and psychosocial pressure, increases the value of therapeutic writing as everything is written, anonymity and client concealment; and increases the needed social support since the platform is some sort of a community (Hanley & Wyatt, 2020). Students preferred e-counselling for many reasons such as it facilitates the building of therapeutic relationship, increases independence and autonomy during work; and reduces the anxiety in face-to-face counselling (Hanley & Wyatt, 2020). ...
... Additionally, etherapy requires both clienteles and counsellors to be conversant with the internet and above all, being extremely careful with portal, emails and avoid wrongly sending messages to wrong persons (Abbott et al., 2008). To some extent, e-counselling can be challenging for some clienteles due to lack of time, technological complications, being exposed to additional stigma such as being afraid because of the feeling of wasting counsellor time especially if one is slow in thinking and composing messages, feeling shame to login; and difficulties in writing short and concise messages (Hanley & Wyatt, 2020). ...
Full-text available
Article
Daily, in almost every part of the world, series of maltreatment are meted on the children. Because of their vulnerability, the time has come to take serious actions and unreserved measures to end this inhumane treatment and support the victims and their communities. Children are innocent beings and are the last hope of every community and nation and deserve a decent and safe environment to grow to the fullest. This is a fundamental human right as capsulated in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), an international legal instrument of universal significance. A systematic review of the works of literature using information collected from different sources was actuated. Google search engine, google scholar, web of science, and Scopus database were used to search for these articles. During the search, combinations of words and phrases were used to ensure articles reflected the most current knowledge and scholarly works. The systematic searches beget varied and voluminous articles that had to be sieved not only to meet the inclusion and exclusion criteria but also to ensure the fundamental objectives of the study are wrangled. In summary, the potentials of web-counseling include but are not restricted to unlimited access and improved seeking behavior, affordability, convenience, limited pressure, permanent record availability, anonymity, independence and autonomy, empowerment, geographical barriers elimination, less feeling shy, freedom of expression, confidentiality, and privacy, efficiency and effectiveness improvement, all-time access to multiple therapists, resources with no transport cost and hassle, and client-driven therapy sessions
... Furthermore, the colonisation of work into private spaces and free time has also been associated with the neglect of social lives and hobbies (Cannito and Scavarda, 2020). However, use of technology, especially the provision of telehealth and online services, can also be considered to mitigate against some of the physical barriers -such as distance or time -which may have traditionally limited access to services for people from less advantaged circumstances (Hanley and Wyatt, 2020). The traditional power differentials associated with healthcare between practitioner and service user may be re-shaped using technology. ...
... For example, there was evidence in a recent systematic review of higher education students' access to talking therapies online that clients felt the online medium gave them greater access to steer the conversation and to work at their own desired pace. In addition, it was observed that some students were storing written exchanges with their therapist online to revisit at a later juncture, which the authors credit with fostering the client's own sense of agency, in turn associated with better therapeutic outcomes (Hanley and Wyatt, 2020). More generally, the expansion of information technology may be seen to empower individuals from marginalised groups, not least through the sharing of information directly relating to their health, or participation in society, or indeed through greater connectivity -the capacity to discover and meet with potential collaborators at geographical distance (Bach, Wolfson and Crowell, 2018). ...
... Several themes have emerged in COVID-19 research between 2020-2022, these are not limited to technology, remote education learning, emergency remote education, digitalization, student experiences, administration challenges and educational outcomes. [7][8][9][10][11] While some areas have been widely researched, others have not received the same attention. Understanding faculty experiences may enable researchers to gain important information on how individuals respond, future course design, institutional responses, support structure and technological needs. ...
Article
Objective: The COVID-19 pandemic led to a rapid transition in operations for higher education institutions. The delivery of traditional teaching methods shifted to online instruction. Much of the research has explored student experiences during COVID-19 pandemic. The purpose of this project was to explore faculty experiences with COVID-19 in a Midwest state within the United States.Methods: The team utilized a convenience sample of faculty employed at colleges and universities in a Midwest state that taught in the spring of 2020. An email was sent to the faculty, informing them about the nature and purpose of the study and the criteria for participation along with a link to the survey. The survey was a 33-item online survey utilizing Qualtrics®.Results: The sample size for this study was N = 329. Majority of respondents (n = 89) felt that the transition to online learning was difficult. Lastly, common challenges reported were communication with students and peers and isolation.Conclusions: Understanding faculty experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic is essential to future teaching curriculum. The majority of faculty felt that transition to online learning was difficult and affected their mental wellbeing. Communication with students was identified as the biggest challenge for faculty. Yet, faculty felt as though student grades were not affected. As future curriculum and faculty experiences are explored, an emphasis on improving student-faculty communication must be priority. Exploration regarding mental wellness services and resources should be considered for faculty within higher education institutions.
... Initially it was intended that students would be able to tick off completed activities, and this history would be available at the next login. This feature provides a sense of accomplishment, and allows participants to self-monitor their progress in healthrelated online interventions and therapies (Mehra et al., 2020;Hanley and Wyatt, 2021). Additionally, this would provide more specific and detailed LMS log data. ...
Full-text available
Article
The efficacy of mindfulness-based interventions in randomised-controlled trials and large experimental studies has been demonstrated in university student populations. Whilst these investigations have provided insight into the nature of the delivery of mindfulness-based practices, there has been little research in the implementation of self-managed online student wellbeing and mindfulness programs at university. This ecological validation study conducted in 2020 evaluated a real-world implementation of a large, university-wide, online mindfulness-based program that was accessible fully online via the tertiary institutions’ Learning Management System (LMS) student orientation site. The total sample included 833 participants from a range of disciplines and faculties at Monash University, Australia. At the end of the study, 236 (28.3%) participants were retained and completed the follow-up survey. Participants had the option to engage with the fully self-managed online mindfulness program for a 12-week semester. The mindfulness practices were pre-recorded, audio-guided sessions, and 10–15 min in length. Baseline and end of semester questionnaires included the 14-item Warwick-Edinburgh Mental Wellbeing Scale, 10-item Perceived Stress Scale and the 18-item Five Facet Mindfulness Questionnaire. Participants who engaged with the mindfulness program over 3 or more weeks showed significant improvements in all three outcome measures, and all participants showed significant improvements in wellbeing at the end of semester. Learning analytics obtained via the LMS revealed that 58.6% (n = 489) had not logged into the mindfulness program at all, almost a third (31.0%, n = 259) logged into the program materials once or twice, and 10.2% (n = 85) of the whole sample engaged with the program actively, having logged in three or more times. The total number of student logins peaked in week 2, reduced between week 2 and week 7 and thereafter activity remained stable until the end of the semester. We hypothesise that the changes in wellbeing, stress and mindfulness at the end of the semester seen in the low engagement participants may partly be explained by the circumstances of COVID-19 restrictions improving. This study has revealed and discusses the complexities of student behaviour and implications for implementing an online mindfulness program in the real- world setting of a university.
... The physical distancing requirements in response to the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in an en masse transition from in-person psychotherapy to online psychotherapy delivered remotely. Online psychotherapy may reflect both synchronous and asynchronous online interventions, as well as online self-help programs, and telepsychotherapy (Hanley & Wyatt, 2021;Machluf et al., 2021;Nadan et al., 2020;Nuttman-Schwartz & Shaul, 2021). ...
Article
Objective We aimed to develop a self-report measure of therapist acceptance of telepsychotherapy based on the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) framework. Methods Using a cross-sectional survey design, 1265 therapists completed the UTAUT-T, as well as additional questions. Results Confirmatory analysis indicated that the original UTAUT model did not fit the therapist context well. Exploratory factor analysis specified a better-fitting five-factor model, which showed good internal validity fit (χ² = 17,753.36, RMSEA = 0.063, TLI = 0.886, SRMSR = 0.04). The five UTAUT-T subscales showed high internal consistency (Cronbach's α = 0.86) and together predicted the intention to use online therapy in the future (R² = 0.42, F(5, 1259) = 181.9, p < 0.001). Conclusion The 21-item UTAUT-T offers a promising self-report measure of therapist acceptance of telepsychotherapy and intention towards using it in the future. Future studies on the convergent and predictive validity of the UTAUT-T are warranted.
... Further elaborations on the potential benefits (and challenges) of online therapy can be found in numerous papers (e.g. Cooper et al., 2019;Hanley & Wyatt, 2020;Mallen et al., 2005;Rochlen et al., 2004) and within the chapters of each of the books referred to below. Such views, despite acknowledging the complexity of the context, challenge the notion that it is impossible to create therapeutic relationships online. ...
... Since these initial projects, looking at online working, I have been involved in a series of systematic reviews examining the literature around online therapeutic practices. This has included pulling together studies examining therapeutic work with young people , higher education students (Hanley & Wyatt, 2020) and the literature around the way that young people make use of online mental health and well-being forums . Each of these pieces has striking similarities. ...
Full-text available
Article
This paper reflects upon the history of online counselling and psychotherapy research. It provides a reflection upon the growing body of research in this field and discusses the impact of the recent global COVID‐19 pandemic upon it. It specifically argues that the pandemic has been an evolutionary catalyst for developments in online therapy. Therapeutic practices, and attitudes towards them, have changed in ways that will alter the shape and form of therapies in the future. As a consequence, research into online therapeutic work needs to be responsive and adapt to this changing world. Counselling and psychotherapy researchers therefore have to situate themselves in a way that allows them to keep one foot in the present and one foot in the future to stay abreast of technological developments. There may be a reluctance to do so from some areas in the therapeutic profession, but their presence might prove vital in ensuring that ethical sensitivity, which acknowledges and values the complexity of the human experience, remains at the foreground of psychological support.
Article
Based on an integrative review of the relevant literature in and on person‐centred and experiential (PCE) therapy, this study identifies and discusses the findings of 13 articles on the delivery of individual video counselling and psychotherapy. Six overarching themes were identified: the discrepancy of the experiences of clients and practitioners; the possibility of good‐quality PCE therapy (psychotherapy and/or counselling); “doing” PCE therapy online; “being” online; the role of technology; and implications for training and practice. It is suggested that all these have implications for ongoing practice and education/training, and need to be considered by practitioners, educators/trainers, and professional bodies.
Article
During the global pandemic, therapists have offered distance-based approaches to counseling and psychotherapy, often online. Although online therapy is not a new phenomenon, until recently it was offered by a minority of practitioners. Now, following the changes imposed by the pandemic, it is familiar to the majority. Therapists and clients have met and worked together in separate spaces in new ways mediated by digital technology following rapidly changing regulations and these changes have had an impact on resulting therapeutic work. This article explores ways in which individuals may respond uniquely and collectively to changing contexts and offers possible explanations for these responses, drawn from existing psychotherapeutic research and leading to recommendations that additional assessment and monitoring procedures should be used with hybrid or blended approaches.
Full-text available
Article
The novel coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), originated in Wuhan city of China, has spread rapidly around the world, sending billions of people into lockdown. The World Health Organization (WHO) declared the coronavirus epidemic a pandemic. In light of rising concern about the current COVID-19 pandemic, a growing number of universities across the world have either postponed or canceled all campus events such as workshops, conferences, sports, and other activities. Universities are taking intensive measures to prevent and protect all students and staff members from the highly infectious disease. Faculty members are already in the process of transitioning to online teaching platforms. In this review, the author will highlight the potential impact of the terrible COVID-19 outbreak on the education and mental health of students and academic staff.
Full-text available
Article
This paper is one of a series exploring the implications of complexity for systematic reviews and guideline development, commissioned by the WHO. The paper specifically explores the role of qualitative evidence synthesis. Qualitative evidence synthesis is the broad term for the group of methods used to undertake systematic reviews of qualitative research evidence. As an approach, qualitative evidence synthesis is increasingly recognised as having a key role to play in addressing questions relating to intervention or system complexity, and guideline development processes. This is due to the unique role qualitative research can play in establishing the relative importance of outcomes, the acceptability, fidelity and reach of interventions, their feasibility in different settings and potential consequences on equity across populations. This paper outlines the purpose of qualitative evidence synthesis, provides detail of how qualitative evidence syntheses can help establish understanding and explanation of the complexity that can occur in relation to both interventions and systems, and how qualitative evidence syntheses can contribute to evidence to decision frameworks. It provides guidance for the choice of qualitative evidence synthesis methods in the context of guideline development for complex interventions, giving ‘real life’ examples of where this has occurred. Information to support decision-making around choice qualitative evidence synthesis methods in the context of guideline development is provided. Approaches for reporting qualitative evidence syntheses are discussed alongside mechanisms for assessing confidence in the findings of a review.
Full-text available
Article
Background: with reports continually demonstrating increased demand and severity of student mental health needs, it is important to gain a fuller understanding of the impact on embedded student counselling services. Aims: to identify (1) service similarities; (2) factors which impact on services; (3) characteristics of service users; and (4) identify the use of therapeutic technology (e.g. online self-help). Methods: an online survey was completed by 113 heads of UK student counselling services across Higher Education (HE), Further Education (FE), and Sixth Form Colleges (SFCs), to capture service data from the academic year 2013/14. Results: students predominantly received high-intensity support (e.g. Counselling) and referrals increased over 3-years. Conclusion: challenges to embedded counselling services and their implications for development are discussed.
Full-text available
Article
Objectives This study describes adolescent attitudes towards online therapies and explores the factors that predict these attitudes. Method Australian adolescents (N = 217) were surveyed on their knowledge of, attitudes towards (including perceived problems, perceived benefits, and perceived helpfulness), recommended availability of, and intentions to use online therapies. In addition, demographic and clinical factors, factors relating to technology use, adolescents' mental health attitudes, and personality traits were also measured. Results The findings suggested that 72.0% of adolescents would access an online therapy if they experienced a mental health problem and 31.9% would choose an online therapy over traditional face-to-face support. The most valued benefits of these programs included alleviation of stigma and increased accessibility. Knowledge of online therapies was found to positively predict perceived helpfulness and intended uptake. Conclusions This study provides insight into adolescent attitudes towards online therapies and highlights the need to investigate strategies for increasing uptake.
Article
Background: Young people increasingly look towards the Internet for support. Online forums have been developed to provide mental health support, but they have received little attention in the research to date. Aims: To summarise the existing literature examining how individuals use online forums to obtain support for mental health difficulties. Methods: A systematic review of electronic databases was conducted to identify empirical literature in this area. The papers that met the inclusion criteria and satisfied quality assessment review were analysed for key themes. Results: Twenty-one papers were found. Three common themes in the papers were associated with opportunities of the technology: (1) Providing stand alone or complementary informal support, (2) Providing informational, emotional and infomotional support, and (3) Making use of the specific practical opportunities afforded by forum technology. A further three themes were associated with challenges: (1) Managing the expectations of forum users, (2) Ensuring service user safety, and (3) Navigating the technical challenges associated with forums. Conclusions: The paper highlights the potential for individuals to access dynamic and responsive support within online forums. Additionally, it reflects upon the major areas that mental health professionals need to be aware of when entering into this arena.
Article
The higher education sector is currently undergoing a major shift towards increasing the amount of courses that are taught online, hence there is also a growing need to provide support services for online students. This paper reports on the results of a survey that aimed to gather information on the online presence of counselling services across Australian and New Zealand higher education facilities. It indicates that movement towards offering online counselling support for students is slow, with services and professionals showing some resistance to, and anxiety around, moving into this sphere. Where services have been offered, there is little consistency across the sector. A number of challenges around engagement, marketing, technology and clinician anxiety have hampered successful outcomes. There have been notable exceptions to this, with a few universities trialling different online platforms and engagement strategies with students, with varying levels of success. Overall there appears to be a need for counsellors to be offered training in providing online services to students; not only to increase their confidence in providing these services, but also to help to change attitudes about online mental health services. There is also a need for more research into the efficacy of those models which are operating successfully, in order to encourage change in clinician attitudes, which in turn may lead to further adoption of online services across the sector. © 2018, Australian and New Zealand Student Services Association. All rights reserved.
Article
Online counselling is gaining momentum in the field of social work. The aim of this study was to understand the benefits, challenges and user experiences of a text-based online counselling programme for undergraduate students. Hosted by a social work school in a large, urban university in Canada, the counselling programme trains Master of Social Work (MSW) student counsellors to provide service online as well as offline. Qualitative content analysis was employed to analyse transcripts of 385 e-mail sessions and eighty-five chat exchanges between twenty-two MSW student counsellors and thirty-three undergraduate clients. Analysis identified advantages (increased accessibility, flexibility and immediacy; allowing room for reflections; increased sense of safety) and disadvantages (technical difficulties and increasing ‘work-load’). This study provides evidence of the unique benefits and challenges of online counselling with undergraduate clients and illuminates user experiences that illustrate the uniqueness of online counselling practice.
Article
Objective Counselling within educational settings has now become commonplace. As with the advent of the use of new technologies in teaching, such developments are also impacting the broader support structures available to students. One development is the move of schools to offer pupils access to online counselling services. To date, such practices have received little attention, and this paper synthesises the existing empirical research literature in this area. Design A systematic review of the literature was conducted which focused upon synchronous chat counselling for 11- to 25-year-olds. Method Key bibliographic databases were searched for relevant papers. These were assessed for relevance and quality prior to being included into the analysis. The final selection of studies was analysed for key themes. Results In all, 19 papers met the inclusion criteria. The thematic synthesis identified four higher order themes: (1) developing safe and youth-friendly online services, (2) online client characteristics, (3) in-session online processes and (4) session alliance and outcome. Conclusion These themes outline the varied challenges and opportunities present within this developing practice. Each is initially discussed alongside existing literature related to online counselling before the implications for educational providers are explicitly considered. Ultimately, it is concluded that online counselling for students has much potential, however, those commissioning such services need to be mindful of common pitfalls.