Content uploaded by Ehsan Abdi
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Ehsan Abdi on Apr 29, 2021
Content may be subject to copyright.
Φ
Φ
'*(!(( $*!- #
,) '!!)- # '$*() ()'*)*' "$#()')(
$""'! # )#! +#)( $) ( #')$' #
"$)$' $' +'! (% %%!)$#( ( #')$' ) (
%')*!'!- ))')+ )$ *( # $($' ,# )*'#(
,''!!)-"%'$+"#)#"#)##$() '*)$#
' ) - )$'( # "' ) '$,) ( "$)$' ) "-
*)!.$'*()! (% '+( # )( ()*-$#)#*$*(
,+!) )'#($'" )#&* *(# ,+!)(
$%)+!)' (#%'$%$( $')*!)))$#
( #')$' $%')# # ,# )*'# ' '#)
#')$')-%*!)(#"!- '$)$' )$'&* %')*')$# '$)$'
'$ #'#'$+'+$!)*!)(+#$#(')$
(((()%')!)-$ )%'$%$( )#&* ()*-(
#%'$'"$#
'*(!(( $*!- #
$#)#*$*(+!) '#($'"$#)$# $#)$'#
*!)#$(($)$''$ #'$'&*')*')$#
$*(%+*%$
%5.@/22;.1?.:.A606;0?2.@26; A52 @6G2 <3 D6;1
AB?/6;2@ 3?<: 8* B= A< !*#C2? A52 =.@A
F2.?@ ,- '< 1.A2 @2C2?.9 42;2?.A<? 0<;02=A@ 5.C2 /22;
0<;@612?21 3<? <33@5<?2 D6;1 D52?2 A52?2 6@ . 4?2.A D6;1
=<D2??2@<B?02.;152;02@64;6360.;A3BAB?2:.?82A4?<DA56@
2E=20A21 '52@2 .?2 =2?:.;2;A :.4;2A 42;2?.A<?@ 1<B/9F
321 6;1B0A6<; 42;2?.A<?@ @B=2?0<;1B0A6;4 42;2?.A<?@ .;1
5645C<9A.4242;2?.A<?@,-'<?21B02A520<@A<32;2?4F
3?<: D6;1 AB?/6;2@ A52?2 6@ . ;221 A< 6:=?<C2 .C.69./696AF
.;1 ?21B02 <=2?.A6<;.9 .;1 :.6;A2;.;02 0<@A@ ?B@592@@
<B/9F21!.056;2@!@.?2.;.AA?.0A6C2@<9BA6<;3<?
D6;1 =<D2? 42;2?.A6<; .@ A52F <332? =?<:6@6;4 12@64;
32.AB?2@ .;1 =2?3<?:.;02 05.?.0A2?6@A60@ @B05 .@ /?B@592@@
<=2?.A6<; @96=?6;4 296:6;.A6<; 3?.0A6<;.99F ?.A21 =<D2?
2920A?<;600<;C2?A2? .;1 :216B:@=221 <=2?.A6<;,- #A52?
.==960.A6<;@ 5.C2 .9@< /22; ?2=<?A21 3<? A52 ! 3<?
2E.:=92 6; . 39FD5229 2;2?4F @A<?.42 @F@A2: ,- .;1 .@ .
@56=42;2?.A<?,-
'52!0<;@6@A@<3AD<@A.A<?D6;16;4@12@64;21D6A5
16332?2;A=<92=.6?;B:/2?@<;26@0<;;20A2116?20A9FA<A52
)46;;EI;F:F:7 )5:AA> A8@9;@77D;@9 +@;H7DE;FK A83EF@9>;3
+$ADI;5:+!7?3;>E346;<3>74;G7335G=
#*3F>AI ;EI;F:#5"3D7@*75:@A>A9K 7@FD7 )GDD7K +!7?3;>
?3D=F3F>AI?5>3D7@5A?
46;;EI;F:-;@6*75:@A>A9;7E";?;F76 )F A:@OE@@AH3F;A@
7@FD73?4D;697+!7?3;>7:E3@346;I;@6F75:@A>A9;7E5A?
(#5#3:A@;EI;F:-3DI;5=#3@G835FGD;@9DAGB-#-3DI;5=
+@;H7DE;FKAH7@FDK+!7?3;>D?5?3:A@I3DI;5=35G=
)?;DF;EI;F:F:7 35G>FK A8@9;@77D;@9 AH7@FDK +@;H7DE;FK
AH7@FDK+!7?3;>365AH7@FDK35G=
4?61 0.9921 A52 $<D2? *6;16;4 $* .;1 A52 <A52? 6@
@B==9621 A5?<B45 . C.?6./92C<9A.42 C.?6./923?2>B2;0F
0<;C2?A2?0.9921A52 <;A?<9 *6;16;4 * @052:.A60<3
A52!4?610<;;20A6<;6@@5<D;6;64'52$*.;1
*=<92=.6?;B:/2?@.?205<@2;6;@B05.D.FA<296:6;.A2
16?20A :.4;2A60 0<B=96;4 /2AD22; A52 AD< D6;16;4@ '52
6;16?20A 0<B=96;4 6@ 2;./921 B@6;4 . @=206.9 ?<A<? @A?B0AB?2
0.9921 A52 ;2@A219<<= ?<A<? ;2@A219<<= ?<A<?
0<;364B?.A6<;3<?A52!6@@5<D;6; 64'52 ;B:/2?
<3;2@A@?2>B6?213<?A52?<A<?0.;/2</A.6;213?<:
&$
D52?2 .;1 .?2$* .;1 * =<92=.6? ;B:/2?@
?2@=20A6C29F
'52 ! 0.; <=2?.A2 6; A5?22 16@A6;0A :<12@ <3
<=2?.A6<;6;09B16;46;1B0A6<;0.@0.121.;1@F;05?<;<B@;
.99:<12@ A52$*6@16?20A9F 0<;;20A21 A<A52@B==9FD5692
A52 * 6@ <=2;21 6; A52 6;1B0A6<; :<12 @5<?A2;21 6; A52
0.@0.121 :<12 .;1 @B==9621 A5?<B45 . 3?.0A6<;.99F ?.A21
0<;C2?A<? 6; A52 @F;05?<;<B@ :<12 '52 ! ?<A.A6<;.9
@=2210.;/20.90B9.A213?<:
#&#$#
$
D52?2 # .;1 #.?2$* .;1 * @B==9F .;4B9.?
3?2>B2;062@?2@=20A6C29F
;9E5:7?3F;5A8F:7#9D;65A@@75F;A@
;9*:7@7EF76>AABDAFADEFDG5FGD7
l-)))
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON. Downloaded on April 29,2021 at 13:20:39 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
@6123?<: 12C29<=6;4 :<?2 .1C.;021D6;1AB?/6;2@.;1
42;2?.A<? A205;<9<462@ A< 6:=?<C2 .C.69./696AF .; 23320A6C2
D.FA<.0562C2A526:=?<C2:2;A6@A<.==9F?296./92.;10<@A
23320A6C2 0<;16A6<; :<;6A<?6;4 ,- '52 D6;1 6;1B@A?F
0B??2;A9FB@2@0<;16A6<;:<;6A<?6;4 @F@A2:@!&@@B05.@
C6/?.A6<;A2:=2?.AB?29B/?60.A6;4 <69 .;1 42;2?.A<? 0B??2;A
.;.9F@6@ 12C29<=21 3?<: <A52? ?<A.A6;4 :.056;2 =<D2?
42;2?.A6<;6;1B@A?62@,- D52?2 A52F 5.C2.0562C21@B002@@
<D2C2? A52@2 A205;6>B2@ 5.C2 ;<A F2A =?<C2; 23320A6C2 6;
D6;1AB?/6;2@ D5605 .?2 <=2?.A21 .A@9<D @=221 .;1 D6A5 .
?.=619F C.?F6;4 A<?>B2 <::2?06.9 D6;1 AB?/6;2 !&@
:<@A9F 2:=9<F C6/?.A6<;/.@21 A205;6>B2@ B@6;4
.00292?<:2A2?@ D5605 .?2 @<=56@A60.A21 .;1 2E=2;@6C2
B/?60.A6<; <69 .;.9F@6@ 6@ /20<:6;4 :<?2 0<::<; 3<?
12A20A6;4 42.?/<E A<<A5 .;1 /2.?6;4 D2.? /BA 0.;;<A 12A20A
3.69B?2@<BA@612A52 42.?/<E ,- !<?2 .1C.;021 A205;6>B2@
@B05.@<=A60.9@A?.6;:2.@B?2:2;A@5.C2/22;12C29<=213<?
:<;6A<?6;4 /9.12 6;A24?6AF <D2C2? A52@2 .?2 .9@<
2E=2;@6C2.;1?202;A?296./696AF @B?C2F@,-5.C2@5<D;A5.A
A52 2920A?60.9 @F@A2:@ 5.C2 . 56452? 3.69B?2 ?.A2 A5.; A52
:205.;60.9@F@A2:@
'52?2.?2 <;9F 32D @AB162@ 0.??621<BA <; 3.B9A 16.4;<@6@
<3 A52 ! :<@A9F <; C6/?.A6<; .;.9F@6@ .;1 :6A64.A6<;
<4.;2A.9,-12?6C212>B.A6<;@3<?C6/?.A6<;0<:=<;2;A@
:.4;6AB12@42;2?.A21/FA52$*.;1*:.4;2A6036291@.@
3B;0A6<;@<3 .6?4.=39BE12;@6AF=<92 ;B:/2?@ .;1:.056;2
16:2;@6<;@ /16 2A .9 6; ,- =?<=<@21 . ;2D =.?.9929
D6;16;4 12@64; 3<? A52 @A.A<? $* .;1 * A< :6A64.A2 A52
C6/?.A6<; 92C29 6; A52 =?2@2;02 <3 ?<A<? 2002;A?606AF <??299
2A .9 6; ,- =?<=<@21 . ;B:/2? <3 ?<A<? 12@64;@ D6A5
@B6A./92@A.A<?=<92=.6?0<:/6;.A6<;@6;<?12?A<6:=?<C2A52
! 12@64; /F ?21B06;4 A52 B;/.9.;021 :.4;2A60 =B99
(!$ 3@5.? 2A .9 6; ,- ?202;A9F =?<=<@21 . ;2D 3.B9A
12A20A6<;A205;6>B2/.@21<;A52:.056;2I@0B??2;A@64;.AB?2
.;.9F@6@ A< 12A20A ?<A<? 2002;A?606AF 3.B9A@ 6; A52 ! ;
,-.;2D:2A5<1D.@=?<=<@216;<?12?A<12A20AA52@A.A<?
D6;16;4 @5<?A 06?0B6A 3.B9A@ 6; A52 ! /F .;.9F@6;4 A52
;2@A21 9<<= ?<A<? @9<A 5.?:<;60@ @22; 6; A52 @A.A<? 0B??2;A@
;,-.;.;.9FA60.9:2A5<1<3A52!D6A5/?<82;?<A<?
9<<=@.;12;1?6;4@D.@ =?2@2;A21 "2C2?A5292@@ 6; ;<;2 <3
A52./<C2D<?8D.@.42;2?60A205;6>B23<?12A20A6;4C.?6<B@
AF=2@ <3 3.B9A@ 6; A52 ! .@ . D6;1 AB?/6;2 42;2?.A<?
=?<=<@21
*.A@<;2A .9 ,- 5.C2=?<=<@21 ;<C29 !&A205;6>B2@
/.@21 <; A52 0<;A6;B<B@ D.C292A A?.;@3<?: *' <3 A52
42;2?.A<?I@ 2920A?60.9 =<D2? @64;.9 A< 12A20A 6;16C61B.9
C6/?.A6<; 3.B9A@ A5.A <00B? 6; 2.05 :205.;60.9 0<:=<;2;A
D6A5 /<A5 3?2>B2;0F .;1 A6:2 1B?.A6<; F 0<:=.?6;4 A52
?2.9A6:2C6/?.A6<;D.C23<?:@</A.6;213?<:A52 *' D6A5
. =?2C6<B@ 0.90B9.A6<; A52 3.B9A .;1 6A@ @=206360 3?2>B2;0F
:.F/2 12A20A21 '56@A205;6>B26@@A699 6; A52?2@2.?05@A.42
.;1 5.@ <;9F /22; .==9621 A< 42;2?.A<?@ 6; . 9./<?.A<?F
2;C6?<;:2;A/BA6A1<2@.==2.?A<<332?@64;6360.;A.1C.;A.42@
0<:=.?21 A< A?.16A6<;.9 A205;6>B2@ <? 6;@A.;02 6A B@2@
2E6@A6;4 @2;@<?@ .C.69./92 6; :<@A 42;2?.A<? @F@A2:@ A<
:2.@B?2 2920A?60.9 @64;.9@ '52?23<?2 6A D<B91 /2 . ;<;
6;A?B@6C2:2A5<1D6A52.@F6:=92:2;A.A6<;.;1;<.116A6<;.9
0<@A@ ; .116A6<; A52 @=206360 3?2>B2;062@ .@@<06.A21 A< A52
3.B9A .@ D299 .@ A52 A6:2 A5.A A52 3.B9A <00B?@ 0.; /2
612;A63621 '56@ 529=@ 12A2?:6;2 A52 9<0.A6<; .;1 ?2.@<; <3
A52 3.B9A '52 *' .9@< 5.@ A52 ./696AF A< 12A20A /<A5
2920A?60.9 .;1 :205.;60.9 3.B9A@ <00B??21 6; . D6;1 AB?/6;2
9A5<B45A52 B@2 <3 D.C292A A?.;@3<?: :2A5<16;12A20A6;4
C.?6<B@3<?:@ <33.B9A@6; D6;1AB?/6;242;2?.A<?@ 5.C2/22;
D6129F @AB1621 , - A< A52 /2@A <3 A52 .BA5<?@I
8;<D92142 ;< D<?8 5.@ /22; ?2=<?A21 6; .==9F6;4 A56@
A205;6>B2A<A52!
; A56@ =.=2? A52 =?.0A60.96AF <3 A52 *' :2A5<1 6;
12A20A6;4 C.?6<B@ 3.B9A@ 6; A52 ! 6@ .@@2@@21
@6:B9.A6<; :<129 6@ 12C29<=21 6; !' &6:B96;8 3<? .
=?<A<AF=2 8*! .;1 6A@ .00B?.0F 6;
=?2160A6;4 A52 :.056;2I@ =2?3<?:.;02 .A 16332?2;A <=2?.A6;4
0<;16A6<;@ 6@ C.961.A21 B@6;4 2E=2?6:2;A.9 A2@A@ D.C292A
/.@21 .1<=A6C2 369A2? 6@ 12@64;21 .;1 6:=92:2;A21 <; A52
@6:B9.A6<;:<129@6;<?12?A<?21B02A520<:=BA.A6<;.9A6:2
'5?22 16332?2;A 3.B9A AF=2@ ;.:29F A52 A<?>B2 =2?AB?/.A6<;
?<A<? /?<82; /.? .;1 4?61 <C2?C<9A.42 3.B9A@ .?2 /26;4
0<;@612?216;A56@D<?86;<?12?A<.@@2@@A52=?.0A60.96AF<3
A52=?<=<@21*':2A5<1
%$*$+%+)*,"*'($)%(#*'!*%
&$%$
&6:69.? A< A52 <B?62? '?.;@3<?: A52 *' B@2@ 6;;2?
=?<1B0A@ A< :2.@B?2 A52 @6:69.?6AF /2AD22; . @64;.9 .;1 .;
.;.9F@6;43B;0A6<;,-; A52 *' A52 .;.9F@6;4 3B;0A6<;
6@ . D.C292A '52 *' 0<:=.?2@ A52 @64;.9 D6A5 . @563A21
.;10<:=?2@@21<?@A?2A0521C2?@6<;<3.D.C292A&A?2A056;4
<? 0<:=?2@@6;4 . 3B;0A6<; 6@ ?232??21 A< .@ H@0.96;4I F
0<:=.?6;4 A52 @64;.9 A< A52 D.C292A .A C.?6<B@ @0.92@ .;1
=<@6A6<;@ . 3B;0A6<; <3 AD< C.?6./92@ 6@ </A.6;21 3 A52
@64;.9 6@ ?2.9C.9B21 A52 *' 6@ . ?2.9C.9B21 3B;0A6<; <3
@0.92.;1=<@6A6<;'52*'<3.?2.9A6:2@64;.9($0.;/2
1236;21.@,-
01&
/
01",%
.
D52?2
ψ
$6@A52:<A52?D.C292A.;10.;/22E=?2@@21.@
"01&
",%
.'
D52?2.;1?2=?2@2;A A52 =.?.:2A2?@ <3 A52 D.C292A @0.92
.;1 A6:2@563A ?2@=20A6C29F '52 .@A2?6@8 6@ B@21 3<?
0<:=92E0<;7B4.A2
'52 D.C292A A?.;@3<?: ?2@B9A@ 6; 0<2336062;A@ D5605
?23920A A52 0<??29.A6<; /2AD22; A52 @64;.9 .;1 A52 @2920A21
D.C292A 3B;0A6<; '< 6;0?2.@2 A52 0<2336062;A .:=96AB12@
42;2?.A21 /F . 46C2; 3.B9A .;1 52;02 2;5.;02 A52 3.B9A
12A20A6<; =?<02@@ A52 D.C292A 3B;0A6<; @5<B91 /2 @2920A21
/.@21 <; A52 3.B9A ?2@=<;@2 '52?2 .?2 :.;F 16332?2;A
D.C292A@ A5.A 0.; /2 B@21 6; A52 *' 2=2;16;4 <; A52
3.B9A AF=2 A52?2 6@ . 124?22 <3 3?221<: A< @2920A . D.C292A
3B;0A6<;<?2E.:=92 63 A52 23320A <3 . 3.B9A6@4<6;4A< /2
?23920A21 .@ <@0699.A6<; 6; A52 :2.@B?21 @64;.9 . D.C292A
3B;0A6<; A5.A :<?2 09<@29F :.A052@ <@0699.A6<; /25.C6<B?
:B@A /2 05<@2; '52 !<?92A D.C292A 3B;0A6<; 5.@ /22;
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON. Downloaded on April 29,2021 at 13:20:39 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
@5<D; A< /2 .; .==?<=?6.A2 05<602 3<? A52 2920A?60.9 .;1
:205.;60.9 3.B9A@ <00B??21 6; . D6;1 AB?/6;2 .;1 A52?23<?2
0.;/2B@216;3.B9A12A20A6<;<3A52!6;D6;1AB?/6;2
<=2?.A6;40<;16A6<;@,-'52!<?92AD.C292A6@1236;21.@
"01&!
0#1
#&$# $&$"
&6:69.? A< A52 0<;02=A <3 3?2>B2;0F @0.92 6@ .;<A52?
B@23B9=?<=2?AF <3@64;.9@6;D.C292A A?.;@3<?::2A5<1,-
'5205<602<3@0.923.0A<?6@12=2;12;A<;A523?2>B2;0F<3
6;A2?2@A '52 @:.992? A52 @0.92 3.0A<? A52 :<?2 0<:=?2@@21
A52D.C292A9@<A529.?42?A52@0.92A52:<?2@A?2A0521A52
D.C292A;.116A6<;A52?26@.; 6;C2?@2?29.A6<;@56=/2AD22;
@0.92 .;1 3?2>B2;0F '52 56452? @0.92@ 0<??2@=<;1 A< A52
:<?2@A?2A0521D.C292A@'52:<?2@A?2A0521A52D.C292AA52
9<;42? A52 =<?A6<; <3 A52 @64;.9 D6A5 D5605 6A 6@ /26;4
0<:=.?21 .;1 A52?23<?2 A52 0<.?@2? A52 @64;.9 32.AB?2@
:2.@B?21/FA52D.C292A0<2336062;A@
'52 0<;C2;A6<;.9 .==?<.05 A< A52 B@2 <3 *' 6@ A<
.;.9F@2 A52 0<:=92A2 /.;1D61A5 <3 A52 @64;.9 92.16;4 A< .
0<:=BA.A6<;.99F 6;A2;@6C2 =?<02@@ D52?2.@ :.;F <3 A52
0.90B9.A6<;@ .?2 B;;202@@.?F 3<? .; 2920A?60.9 :.056;2
0<;16A6<; :<;6A<?6;4 ,- '56@ 6@ /20.B@2 A52 3.B9A?29.A21
3?2>B2;062@.?232D.;18;<D;.;1<A52?3?2>B2;0F/.;1@1<
;<A ?2>B6?2 .;.9F@6@ +.;4 2A .9 ,- 5.@ =?<=<@21 . :<?2
2336062;A .1.=A6C2 *'/.@21 369A2? 3<? B@2 6; ?2.9A6:2
0<;16A6<; :<;6A<?6;4 D52?2 A52 =?<02@@6;4 A6:2 6@ 82F ;
A56@ .==?<.05 <;9F 2;2?4F .A 8;<D; 3.B9A 3?2>B2;062@ 6@
2EA?.0A21 .;1 <A52? B;?29.A21 3?2>B2;062@ .?2 923A
B;=?<02@@21 '56@ 92.1@ A52 0.90B9.A6<; A6:2 A< /2
@64;6360.;A9F @5<?A2; 6; 0<:=.?2 D6A5 . 0<;C2;A6<;.9 *'
'52 :2A5<1 6@ 52;02 .==9621 A< A52 ! *' 0<;16A6<;
:<;6A<?6;46;A56@.;.9F@6@
; .1.=A6C2 AD<16:2;@6<;.9 A6:23?2>B2;0F @9616;4
D6;1<D @5<D; 6; 64 6@ B@21 6; A56@ =.=2? A@ 02;A?.9
3?2>B2;0F 6@ A52 :2.; 3?2>B2;0F 1B?6;4 A52 A6:2
6;A2?C.9 <3 A52 =?2@0?6/21 3.B9A?29.A21 3?2>B2;0F /.;1
'52B==2?.;19<D2?0BA<333?2>B2;062@ # .;1 #
.?2 .1.=A21 A< A52 39B0AB.A6<; <3 A52 42;2?.A<? ?<A.A6<;.9
@=221#6;A526;A2?C.9
*#&#$#
(
#&#%#
(
#& #01
<? . D6;1 AB?/6;2 # 6@ 6;A?6;@60.99F 12=2;12;A <; A52
39B0AB.A6<; <3 D6;1 @=221
η
'52 ?29.A6<;@56= /2AD22;
3?2>B2;0F
ω
.;1D.C292A@0.926@
&#
#01
*6A5 A52 .61 <3 .;1 A52 D.C292A @0.92@ 3<?
0<;1B0A6;4/.;1=.@@369A2?6;40.;/212A2?:6;21/F
2301
D52?2
*&#
#
&#
#01
&B/@2>B2;A9F/F=2?3<?:6;4A52*'9<0.99F6;A52@0.92
?.;421236;21/F.:.A?6E<3D.C292A0<2336062;A@0.;/2
</A.6;21'522;2?4F <3 A52 3?2>B2;0F <36;A2?2@A1B?6;4
A52=2?6<16@05.?.0A2?6G21/F
+$
(-
&0011)23
2$301
'52 @9616;4 D6;1<D 6@ A52; :<C21 .9<;4 A52 @64;.9 A52
:.E6:B: .;1 :6;6:B: D.C292A @0.92@ 6; /26;4
?21236;21 D6A56; 2.05 A6:2 6;A2?C.9 .00<?16;4 A< A52
42;2?.A<??<A.A6<;.9 @=221 #.;1 '52 2;2?4F6;A52
3.B9A?29.A21 3?2>B2;0F /.;1 6@ 0.90B9.A21 6; 2.05 A6:2
6;A2?C.9 B@6;4 .;1 '52@2 0.90B9.A6<;@ .?2 ?2=2.A21
B;A69A52D5<92@64;.9 5.@ /22; =?<02@@21 6;.99F . =9<A <3
A52 2;2?4F C.?6.A6<; 6; A52 3.B9A?29.A21 3?2>B2;0F /.;1 6@
</A.6;21 D6A5 ?2@=20A A< A6:2 C.?6.A6<; .;1 A52 05.;42@ 6;
A52?B;;6;40<;16A6<;@<3A52*'0.;/2.@@2@@21
;9*:7 E>;6;@9I;@6AIBDABAE768ADF:7 I3H7>7F43E76363BF;H7
8;>F7D
'" "!%)
;,- A52 1?6C2 A?.6;0<:=<;2;A@D5605.?2 :<@A =?<;2
A<3.69B?2 6; . 42.?21D6;1 AB?/6;2 D2?2 12A2?:6;21'52@2
.?2 A52 /9.12@ :.6; /2.?6;4 @5.3A 42.?/<E .;1 42;2?.A<?
'52 3?2>B2;0F ?.;42@ D52?2 A52 3.B9A @64;.AB?2 3?2>B2;062@
.?2 =9.021 .?2 =?2@2;A21 6; './92 ,- '< 12A20A . D6;1
AB?/6;23.B9AA52 *' 6@ .==9621A<A52<BA=BA=<D2? @64;.9
<3 A52 42;2?.A<? '52 @.:=96;4 3?2>B2;0F @5<B91 /2 05<@2;
A< /2 AD602 A52 56452@A 3.B9A 3?2>B2;0F A5.A A52 @F@A2: 6@
2E=20A21A<12A20A .00<?16;4 A<A52"F>B6@A0?6A2?6<;,- A
6@A52?23<?2</@2?C213?<:'./92A5.A.@.:=96;4 3?2>B2;0F
<3G:B@A/2B@216;A52*':2A5<1
$(%*%*/&!*!
'52@=206360.A6<;@ <3 A528* !.?2@5<D;
6;'./92'52!D.@0<;@A?B0A21.@ .@A2==6;4
@A<;2 A<D.?1 . !*@0.92 D6;1 AB?/6;2 42;2?.A<? 6;
.:/?6142 D6A5 A52 @A.08 92;4A5 <3 :: '52 @A.A<?
D6;16;4@ D2?2 3<?:D<B;1 3?<: 0<==2? @A?6=@ '52 =<D2?
D6;16;4D.@?.A21.A).AG.;1A520<;A?<9
ω
ω
ω
ω
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON. Downloaded on April 29,2021 at 13:20:39 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
D6;16;4D.@12@64;213<?).AG.;1?.A21.A
<A5 @A.A<? D6;16;4@ D2?2 0<;;20A21 6; 129A. '52 ?<A<?
0<:=?6@2@ @6E @2A@ <3 ;2@A@ 2.05 0<;@6@A6;4 <3 . ;B:/2? <3
0<;02;A?60 9<<=@ A52 0<;1B0A<?@ /26;4 @<961 /.?@ D6A5 <;2
0<::<; 2;1 ?6;4 ,- '52 ! <; . A2@A /21 6@
@5<D;6;64
*"
(#-*
$ "
±L 7@7D3FADEF3FAD3@69D;6;?43>3@5783G>FE
±L 3G>FEA55GDD;@9;@F:7I:A>7-*6D;H7FD3;@
ML #75:3@;53>83G>FE53GE764KG@43>3@5764>367E3@6AD
E:38F
ML >75FD;53>83G>FE53GE764K97@7D3FADDAFADI;@6;@9
83G>FADDAFAD7557@FD;5;FK
ML 3G>FE3EEA5;3F76I;F:I;@6FGD4;@74>367EADE>AI
EB776E:38F
;9=-#A@F:7F7EF476
*"
!)-#
D3?7E;L7
)B776D3@97 DB?±
(3F76FADCG7 $?
(3F76BAI7D=-3FDB?
&-BA>7@G?47D
&-D3F76HA>F397 ,L67>F3
&-D3F765GDD7@F>;@7
-BA>7@G?47D
-D3F76HA>F397 ,L67>F3
-D3F765GDD7@F>;@7
&6:B96;8 :<129D.@12C29<=213<?A528*!
0<B=921 A< . 42.?/<E D6A5 . ?.A6< <3 .;1 A5?22 /9.121
D6;1AB?/6;2 D6A5 ./9.12?.16B@ :'52A<?>B2.==9621
A<A5242;2?.A<?D.@0<;A?<9921@B05A5.A :.E6:B:=<D2?6@
2EA?.0A213?<:A52D6;1A56@0<??2@=<;1@A<.A6=@=221?.A6<
λ<3 .;1.=<D2?0<2336062;AA2?:<3,-'52
42;2?.A<? @=221 A<?>B2 C<9A.42 0B??2;A .;1 $* <BA=BA
=<D2?D2?29<4421B@6;4.@.:=96;43?2>B2;0F<3G
(@6;4 A52 &6:B96;8 :<129 A52 @A2.1F @A.A2 =2?3<?:.;02
<3A52 ! 0.; /2</A.6;21 6;09B16;4 @A.A<? C<9A.42@.;1
0B??2;A@ .@ D299 .@ A52 :.056;2I@ A<?>B2 .;1 .0A6C2 .;1
?2.0A6C2 =<D2? '52 :.056;2I@ =2?3<?:.;02 </A.6;21 3?<:
@6:B9.A6<; .A ?.A21 <=2?.A6;4 0<;16A6<;@ .?2 0<:=.?21 D6A5
2E=2?6:2;A.9 A2@A ?2@B9A@ 6; './92 9<@2 .4?22:2;A
/2AD22; @6:B9.A6<; .;1 A2@A ?2@B9A@ 0<;36?: A52 C.9616AF <3
A52 :<129@ 12C29<=21 3<? A52 =?<A<AF=2 ! '52
<=2?.A6;4 =.?.:2A2?@ </A.6;21 3?<: A52 @6:B9.A6<; 0.;
A52?23<?2 /2 B@21 6; *' 3.B9A 12A20A6<; <3 A52 =?<A<AF=2
:.056;2
*"
)))*(
#
#
)B776D7H?;@
*ADCG7$?
&-HA>F397,
-HA>F397,
&-5GDD7@F
-5GDD7@F
(73>BAI7D=-
&-(735F;H7BAI7D=,D
88;5;7@5K
)+"***%$$*!
"!%"$%"$%$
'5?22 @6;B@<61.9 A<?>B2 =2?AB?/.A6<; 3.B9A@ D6A5 16332?2;A
3?2>B2;062@ D2?2 .==9621 A< A52 ! 6; &6:B96;8 .A
16332?2;AA6:26;A2?C.9@.@@A.A216;'./92)
*",
*&&#
)#
! $
M)75L $?
M)75L $?
M)75L $?
64 @5<D@ A52 A<?>B2 @=221 .;1 <BA=BA =<D2? <3 A52
!D52;A523.B9A@.?2.==9621@0.;/2@22;A523.B9A
=2?AB?/.A6<;@ .?2 2C612;A 6; A52 42;2?.A<? A<?>B2 @64;.9 F
0<;A?.@A A52 $* <BA=BA =<D2? @5<D21 <;9F . @9645A
<@0699.A6<;1B?6;4A52 3.B9A .@A <B?62? '?.;@3<?: '
D.@ =2?3<?:21 <; A52 $* =<D2? @64;.9 6; .; .AA2:=A A<
612;A63F 82F 3.B9A 3?2>B2;062@ .;1 A52 ?2@B9A@ .?2 @5<D; 6;
64 @ 0.; /2 @22; A52 3.B9A 3?2>B2;062@ 0.;;<A /2
2E=9606A9F 612;A63621 .:<;4 A52 <A52? 3?2>B2;062@ 6; A52
=<D2? @=20A?B: '52@2 3?2>B2;062@ .?2 42;2?.99F .@@<06.A21
D6A5 A52 D6;1 AB?/6;2 :205.;60.9 =.?A@ .@ D299 .@ A52
42;2?.A<? 2@=206.99F .A 9<D 3?2>B2;062@ D52?2 A52 =<D2? 6@
05.;4211B2 A<D6;1@=221 C.?6.A6<;@A6@ .9@<6:=<?A.;AA<
;<A2A5.AA52'6@;<AA6:212=2;12;A.;1@< 612;A63F6;4.
05.;426;3?2>B2;0F.@@<06.A21D6A5.3.B9A6@163360B9A
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON. Downloaded on April 29,2021 at 13:20:39 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
;9)B776FADCG73@6&-AGFBGFBAI7DE;9@3>EI:7@FADCG7B7DFGD43F;A@
83G>FE3D73BB>;76
;9*3@3>KE;EA8F:7&-AGFBGFBAI7DE;9@3;@F:7BD7E7@57A8F:7
FADCG7B7DFGD43F;A@83G>FE
'52*'.;.9F@6@12@0?6/216;&20A6<;6@.==9621A<A52
$* <BA=BA =<D2? @64;.9 6; A52 =?2@2;02 <3 A52 A<?>B2
=2?AB?/.A6<;3.B9A@'52=9<A<32;2?4FC.?6.A6<;6@@5<D;6;
64'52@.:2=9<A6@:.4;636213<?9<D3?2>B2;062@6;64
'52364B?2@092.?9F@5<D/<A5A52=?2@2;02.;11B?.A6<;<3
A52 A5?22 A<?>B2 =2?AB?/.A6<; 3.B9A@ D6A5 .;1 G
3?2>B2;062@ <00B??21 6; A52 ! .A A52 A6:2 6;A2?C.9@
@A.A21 6; './92 ) A @5<B91 /2 ;<A21 A5.A A52 <A52? 9<D
3?2>B2;062@=?2@2;A6;A52*'.?21B2A<A52@9<D9FC.?F6;4
G <BA=BA =<D2? 6; ?2@=<;@2 A< 05.;42@ 6; A52 D6;1
@=221
$"""%$
; A56@ @20A6<; . ?<A<? 3.B9A D.@ @6:B9.A21 3?<: $
@20 D52?2 A52 ?2@6@A.;02 <3 A52 A56?1 /.? 6; A52 ;2@A219<<=
?<A<?,-D.@6;0?2.@21A<@6:B9.A2./?<82;/.?.@@5<D;6;
64'520B??2;A@6;A526;16C61B.9?<A<?/.?@.?2@5<D;6;
64"<A602A5.AA520B??2;A6;/.?6@G2?<3?<: $
@ D5692 A52 0B??2;A 6; <A52? ?<A<? /.?@ .?2 6;0?2.@21 1B?6;4
A52@.:2=2?6<1?23920A6;4A5223320A<3A52/?<82;?<A<?/.?
'52*' .;.9F@6@3<?A52/?<82;/.?3.B9A6@ =?2@2;A21D6A5
A524?61<C2?C<9A.423.B9A6;A52;2EA@20A6<;
;9-* A8&-AGFBGFBAI7DE;9@3> ;@F:7 BD7E7@57 A8F:7 FADCG7
B7DFGD43F;A@83G>FE
;9-*A8&-AGFBGFBAI7DE;9@3>7J3?;@;@9F:7>AI8D7CG7@5;7E
Fig. 9. The nested loop rotor configuration showing the broken bar.
Fig. 10. Rotor bar currents at the event of rotor broken bar fault shown in
Fig. 9.
15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
600
610
620
630
640
Speed (rev/min)
15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
-4
-3.5
-3
Torque (kNm)
15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
Time (s)
160
180
200
220
P output power (kW)
Fault # 3
Fault # 2
Fault # 1
0 1020304050607080
Frequency (Hz)
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
|Y(f)|
10 Hz fault
50 Hz fault
Broken bar
Normal nested -loop Nested-loop wit h broken bar
15 20 25 30 35 40
-500
0
500
Rotor Bar 1
15 20 25 30 35 40
-500
0
500
Rotor Bar 2
15 20 25 30 35 40
-500
0
500
Current (A)
Rotor Bar 3
15 20 25 30 35 40
-500
0
500
Rotor Bar 4
15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (s)
-500
0
500
Rotor Bar 5
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON. Downloaded on April 29,2021 at 13:20:39 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
$$""&"&$%$
?<: $ # . 4?61 3.B9A D.@ @6:B9.A21 D52?2 A52
.:=96AB12<3<;2<3A52=5.@2@<3A52)$*C<9A.42D.@
6;0?2.@21 /F '52 42;2?.A<? @=221 A<?>B2 .;1 $*
<BA=BA=<D2?.?2@5<D;6;64D52;A52/?<82;?<A<?/.?
3.B9A 6@ <00B??21 1B?6;4 $ .;1 A52 4?61 <C2?C<9A.42
3.B9A6@ <00B??21 1B?6;4$ '52 *' :2A5<1 .==9621
A<A52$*<BA=BA=<D2?@64;.9.?2@5<D;6;64
'52 <00B??2;02 .;1 1B?.A6<; <3 A52 ?<A<? .;1 4?61 3.B9A@
.?2 2C612;A 6; 64B?2 @5<D6;4 A52 82F 3?2>B2;0F
.@@<06.A21D6A52.053.B9A?<:'./926A6@2E=20A21A<@22
.3.B9A3?2>B2;0F/2AD22;G0<??2@=<;16;4A<A52?<A<?
/?<82;/.? 3.B9A D5692 . 3.B9A 3?2>B2;0F09<@2A< G 6@
2E=20A213<?A524?61C<9A.423.B9A'56@6@6;.4?22:2;AD6A5
A52?2@B9A@<364D52?2G.;1G3?2>B2;062@.?2
</@2?C21 3<? A52 1B?.A6<;@ <3 # .;1 #
?2@=20A6C29F
;9*:7 #EB776 FADCG7 3@6&-AGFBGFBAI7DI:7@9D;6
AH7DHA>F39783G>F;E3BB>;76
)%$"+)%$)
'52 ! 6@ .; .AA?.0A6C2 42;2?.A<? @F@A2: 3<? B@2 6;
D6;1=<D2?42;2?.A6<;=.?A60B9.?9F<33@5<?26;@A.99.A6<;@.@6A
<332?@ @64;6360.;A ?296./696AF 6:=?<C2:2;A .@ D299 .@ 0<@A
?21B0A6<; D52; A52 <C2?.99 D6;1 AB?/6;2 1?6C2 A?.6; 6@
0<;@612?21 ; A56@ @AB1F . 0<;A6;B<B@ D.C292A A?.;@3<?:
*' A205;6>B2 B@6;4 . D.C292A/.@21 .1.=A6C2 369A2? 5.@
/22; =?<=<@21 3<? A52 3.B9A 12A20A6<; 6; . ! D6;1
AB?/6;2 '5?22 16332?2;A 3.B9A@ ;.:29F ?<A<? A<?>B2
=2?AB?/.A6<; ?<A<? /?<82; /.? .;1 4?61 <C2?C<9A.42 3.B9A@
5.C2/22;0<;@612?216;<?12?A<.@@2@@A52=?.0A60.96AF<3A52
=?<=<@21:2A5<1 8*!5.@ /22; 0<;@612?21.@
A52=?<A<AF=2:.056;26;A52@AB1F
A 5.@ /22; @5<D; A5.A A52 *' A205;6>B2 6@ 0.=./92 <3
12A20A6;4 .99 A52 3.B9A@ .==9621 A< A52 :.056;2 /F 092.?9F
612;A63F6;4 A52 .@@<06.A21 3.B9A 3?2>B2;062@ .;1 1B?.A6<; A
5.@.9@</22;@5<D;A5.A/F12@64;6;4A52.1.=A6C2369A2?A52
=?<02@@6;4 A6:2 6@ 0<;@612?./9F ?21B021 :.86;4 A52 *'
.;.9F@6@ . @B6A./92 A205;6>B2 3<? ?2.9A6:2 0<;16A6<;
:<;6A<?6;4<3A52! <;@2>B2;A9F6;0<:=.?6@<;D6A5
0<;C2;A6<;.9 C6/?.A6<; .;1 A2:=2?.AB?2 :2.@B?2:2;A@ .;1
9B/?60.A6<; <69 .;.9F@6@ A205;6>B2@ 0B??2;A9F /26;4 B@21 /F
A52 6;1B@A?F A52 =?<=<@21 *' A205;6>B2 6@ . 9<D0<@A
.9A2?;.A6C2A< 12A20A /<A5 2920A?60.9 .;1:205.;60.9 3.B9A@ 6;
A52!
3
4
;9-* A8&-AGFBGFBAI7DI:7@DAFAD4DA=7@43DFE3@6
9D;6HA>F39783G>FEFE3D73BB>;763G@?39@;8;764?39@;8;76
)%($)
12>A43> -;@6@7D9K AG@5;> >A43> -;@6(7BADF-
BB
1200:3@9#3FH77H($;>EE7@ $KEH77@ NDA@>7EE&7D?3@7@F
#39@7F7@7D3FADE8AD%88E:AD7 -;@6*GD4;@7EO *'+,$('+
(''-+,*0))%$,$('+,A> G@7BB
12(#5#3:A@.-3@946; 3>74;& *3H@7D&(A47DFE#
39;7>3N*:7468?3E397@7D3FAD;@I;@6FGD4;@7EO(/ *% ,*('$+
'(,$('(',*(%('! * ' &&#
@F7D@3F;A@3>BBM
127DD7;D3 (#)F7B:3@ #D3G<A NA?B7@E3F;@9
5:3D35F7D;EF;5EA834DGE:>7EE6AG4>K876?35:;@7O', *',$('%
0&)(+$-&(''-+,*$%% ,*('$+HA>BBM
12.;A@9.-3@9N7E;9@3@6B7D8AD?3@57 3@3>KE;EA834DGE:>7EE
6AG4>K876?35:;@7 8ADEF3@63>A@7 E:;BE:38F97@7D3FADEKEF7?EO
', *',$('%('! * ' ('% ,*$%'(',*(%'"$' *$'"
BBM
12 $;>EEA@ "7DF>;@9 N#3;@F7@3@57 ?3@397?7@FA8I;@6BAI7D
EKEF7?EGE;@95A@6;F;A@?A@;FAD;@9EKEF7?EM>;87 5K5>7 5AEF3@3>KE;E
8ADFIA53E7EFG6;7EO*'+,$('+('' *"0('. *+$(' HA>
@A#3D5:BB
12& *3H@7D N(7H;7I A85A@6;F;A@?A@;FAD;@9A8DAF3F;@97>75FD;53>
?35:;@7EO% ,*$(/ *))%$,$('+HA> @A G>K
BB
12"-3@900:3@9"A@9 .G (";GN-;@6*GD4;@773D4AJ
3;>GD7 67@F;8;53F;A@-;F:77B$7GD3> $7FIAD=EO
*'+,$('+(''-+,*$%'!(*&,$+,A> G@7BB
12)B;@3FA& *3H@7D,3@GEE7>!AGFAG>3=AEN(7>;34;>;FKA8
I;@6FGD4;@7 EG43EE7?4>;7EO ' /% (/ * ' *,$(' HA>
@A757?47DBB
12*"A93@ (#5#3:A@ !)7887@ N$A;E7 3@6H;4D3F;A@;@4DGE:>7EE
6AG4>K876?35:;@73@64DGE:>7EE6AG4>K876D7>G5F3@57?35:;@7O
% ,*$(/ *))%$,$('+HA>BBM
15 20 25 30 35 40
150
200
150
200
Speed (rev/min)
15 20 25 30 35 40
150
200
150
200
Torque (kNm)
15 20 25 30 35 40
Time (s)
160
180
200
P1 output power (kW)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON. Downloaded on April 29,2021 at 13:20:39 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
12)46; 46; (#5#3:A@ N )FG6K A8+@43>3@576#39@7F;5
&G>> ;@DGE:>7EEAG4>K 76#35:;@7EO *'+,$('+('
' *"0('. *+$('HA>BBM
12ADD7>> !@;9:F (7FL NEEG7EI;F:F:7 67E;9@A84DGE:>7EE
6AG4>K876D7>G5F3@57?35:;@7EG@43>3@576?39@7F;5BG>>E=7I3@6
;DA@>AEE7EO ',% ,*$#$' +'*$. +('!
BBM
12#8E:3D )46; #4D3:;?; )#ADF3L3H;L367: N)F3F;5
557@FD;5;FK 3G>F7F75F;A@;@DGE:>7EEAG4>K76@6G5F;A@
#35:;@7E43E76A@#AFADGDD7@F);9@3FGD7 @3>KE;EO ''-%
('! * ' (! ,# $'-+,*$% % ,*('$++($ ,0 %5FA47D
";E4A@BB
12#8E:3D *347E: #4D3:;?; )!:3<7:A66;@ N)F3FADE:ADF
5;D5G;F83G>F67F75F;A@3@6>A53F;A@?7F:A6E8AD4DGE:>7EE#EGE;@9
@7EF76>AABDAFADE>AF:3D?A@;5EO *'+,$('+ (' (/ *
% ,*('$+ & *%*&"
12 3@69:; AD9;@BAGD #)3=7F %D377 #:?36;3@
%D377NEGDH7KA@DAFAD83G>FE;@4DGE:>7EE6AG4>K876?35:;@7EO
', *',$('%(-,#('! * ' ('' *" ,$+&ADFG93>
12)-3FEA@ .;3@9 -/3@9 &*3H@7D D34FD77 NA@6;F;A@
?A@;FAD;@9A8F:7 BAI7DAGFBGFA8I;@6FGD4;@7 97@7D3FADEGE;@9
I3H7>7FEO *'+,$('+('' *"0('. *+$(' HA> @A
)7BFBB
12(4D3:;? )-3FEA@ )<GDAH;5 D34FD77 N@8875F;H7
BBDA35:8AD(AFAD>75FD;53>EK??7FDK7F75F;A@;@-;@6*GD4;@7
EO*'+,$('+(''-+,*$%% ,*('$+,A>$A
$AH7?47DBB
12 :7@ &3@ 0"; /0; .:7@ N7@7D3FAD473D;@983G>F
6;39@AE;E8ADI;@6FGD4;@7 H;37?B;D;53> I3H7>7FFD3@E8AD?GE;@9
?73EGD76H;4D3F;A@E;9@3>EO%+ .$ * ' /% ' *"0(-*'%,A>
BD;>BB
12*3@9 -";G *)A@9 N-;@6FGD4;@7 83G>F6;39@AE;E43E76A@
#AD>7FI3H7>7FFD3@E8AD?3F;A@3@6-;9@7D,;>>76;EFD;4GF;A@O%+ .$ *
' /% ' *"0(-*'%,A>BB
12-/3@9 &*3H@7D D34FD77 #-;>=;@EA@ NAEF78875F;H7
5A@6;F;A@?A@;FAD;@98ADI;@6FGD4;@7EO *'+,$('+('
'-+,*$%% ,*('$+HA>@A 3@BB
12 (;4D3@F"7DF>;@9N)GDH7KA883;>GD7E;@I;@6BAI7DEKEF7?EI;F:
8A5GEA@)I76;E:I;@6BAI7DB>3@FE6GD;@9O
*'+,$('+('' *"0('. *+$(' HA> @A #3D5: BB
12-/3@9 &*3H@7D D34FD77 N@;@F7>>;97@F3BBDA35:FAF:7
5A@6;F;A@?A@;FAD;@9A8>3D97E53>7 I;@6FGD4;@7EO -*() '$'
' *"0++($,$('('! * ' D3@57
12(#5#3:A@ &*3H@7D 46; >>;43@6 3D=7D
N:3D35F7D;E;@94DGE:>7EE6AG4>K 876?35:;@7 DAFADEO % ,*$
(/ *))%$,$('HA>BBM
12">3@A#*3F>AI(#5#3:A@NA@FDA>3>9AD;F:?E8ADB7D?3@7@F
?39@7F97@7D3FADE7H3>G3F76A@3I;@6FGD4;@7 7?G>3FADF7EFD;9O ,#
', *',$('%('! * ' ('(/ *% ,*('$+#$' +'
*$. +BD;>BB
12(#5#3:A@ &*3H@7D 46; >>;43@6 3D=7D
N:3D35F7D;E;@94DGE:>7EE6AG4>K 876?35:;@7 DAFADEO % ,*$
(/ *))%$,$('+HA>@AG9BB
)%(&)
D757;H76F:7 )5679D77 8DA?7D6AIE;+@;H7DE;FK
#3E::36D3@;@3@6F:7#)5679D778DA?F:7):3D;8+@;H7DE;FKA8
*75:@A>A9K *7:D3@ D3@ ;@ 4AF:;@7>75FD;53> 7@9;@77D;@97F:7@
5A?B>7F76F:7&:679D77;@7>75FD;53>?35:;@7E67E;9@3@6?A67>;@98DA?
3?4D;697 +@;H7DE;FK 3?4D;697 +! ;@7;E5GDD7@F>K 3@
EE;EF3@F&DA87EEAD;@>75FD;53> @9;@77D;@93FF:7 +@;H7DE;FK A83EF
@9>;3+$ADI;5: +!;E?3;@D7E73D5:;@F7D7EFE;@5>G677>75FD;53>
?35:;@7E3@66D;H7E8ADD7@7I34>7 BAI7D97@7D3F;A@3@63GFA?AF;H7
3BB>;53F;A@E
%D757;H76F:7)5679D778DA?F:7 ):3D;8+@;H7DE;FK
A8*75:@A>A9K *7:D3@ D3@ ;@ 3@6F:7 #&:;>3@6&:679D77E
8DA?3?4D;697 +@;H7DE;FK 3?4D;697 +! ;@3@6
D7EB75F;H7>K 3>> ;@7>75FD;53> 7@9;@77D;@97;E5GDD7@F>K F:7 #3@39;@9
;D75FADA8-;@6*75:@A>A9;7E"F6 3?4D;697 I:7D7 :7 :3E477@
;@HA>H76I;F:5A??7D5;3>7JB>A;F3F;A@A8F:74DGE:>7EE6AG4>K876;@6G5F;A@
97@7D3FADF75:@A>A9K 8ADI;@6BAI7D3BB>;53F;A@E74753?7 3)7@;AD
#7?47DA8F:7;@;E?3;@D7E73D5:;@F7D7EFE;@5>G677>75FD;53>
?35:;@7E3@66D;H7E D7@7I34>7 BAI7D97@7D3F;A@ 3@67>75FD;53>
?73EGD7?7@FE3@6;@EFDG?7@F3F;A@
D757;H76F:7679D77 ;@7>75FD;53>E5;7@57E3@6F:7
&:679D778DA?F:7 +@;H7DE;FK A83?4D;6973?4D;697+!;@
3@6 D7EB75F;H7>KA>>AI;@9BAEF6A5FAD3> IAD=A@E7?;5A@6G5FAD
67H;57BDA57EE;@9:74753?73+@;H7DE;FK"75FGD7D;@7>75FD;53>7@9;@77D;@9
;@I;F:F:7@9;@77D;@97B3DF?7@F+@;H7DE;FKA83?4D;697I:7D7
:7 I3E3)7@;AD"75FGD7D;@@ :7 I3EI;F:F:7 -3DI;5=
#3@G835FGD;@9DAGB +@;H7DE;FK A8-3DI;5= AH7@FDK +! 3E3
&DA87EEADA8BAI7D7>75FDA@;5E;E5GDD7@FD7E73D5:;@F7D7EFE;@5>G67
7>75FD;53>6D;H7EBAI7D7>75FDA@;5E3@6E7?;5A@6G5FAD?3F7D;3>E
D757;H76:;E)5679D77 ;@)A8FI3D7 @9;@77D;@98DA?L36
+@;H7DE;FK *7:D3@ D3@ ;@7>3F7DD757;H76:;E#)5679D77 ;@
?476676)KEF7?E8DA?#3E3DK=+@;H7DE;FK D@A L75:(7BG4>;5 ;@
3@6:;E&:679D77 ;@>75FD;53> @9;@77D;@98DA?F:7 E3?7
;@EF;FGF;A@;@7F:7@5A@F;@G763E3(7E73D5:7D3F'G77@OE+@;H7DE;FK
7>83EF;@3@6>3F7D3F+@;H7DE;FKA8D;EFA>;@7;E
5GDD7@F>K 3"75FGD7D;@@3>A9G7 3@6;9;F3> >75FDA@;5E3FAH7@FDK
+@;H7DE;FK AH7@FDK +!;E?3;@D7E73D5:;@F7D7EFE;@5>G67 :3D6I3D7
67E;9@7?476676EKEF7?E3@6E;9@3>3@6;?397BDA57EE;@9
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON. Downloaded on April 29,2021 at 13:20:39 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.