Conference PaperPDF Available

Combined distribution of ice thickness and speed based on local measurements at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse 2000-2003

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Fatigue caused by ice-induced vibrations (IIV) is an important design consideration for offshore structures exposed to drifting sea ice. The occurrence of IIV is promoted by, but not limited to, certain combinations of ice thickness and ice drift speed, which makes them fundamental input parameters for structure fatigue life estimation. To that end, this work identifies and analyses the frequency of combined ice thicknesses and ice drift speeds during all recorded ice-structure interaction events at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse during 2000-2003. The ice drift speed measurements were performed manually at the lighthouse, leading to bias towards multiples of 0.05 m/s. The ice thickness measurements by EM antenna underestimates ridge keel depth. The current approach gave a total of above 25 days of ice condition measurements. The cumulative distributions for ice thickness and speed were estimated. Given drifting ice conditions, the probability of encountering ice thicker than 0.8 m was 0.34, i.e. the probability of encountering thicker ice than most of the level ice in the area. A relatively frequent combination of ice conditions was ice thickness between 0.1 and 0.6 m and ice drift speed between 0.05 and 0.15 m/s, occurring with a probability of 0.29.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Combined distribution of ice thickness and speed based on local
measurements at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse 2000-2003
Vegard Hornnes1, Knut Vilhelm Høyland1, Joshua Dennis Turner1, Ersegun Deniz
Gedikli1,2, Morten Bjerkås3
1 Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Norwegian University of Science and
Technology,
Høgskoleringen 7A, 7491 Trondheim, Norway
vegard.hornnes@ntnu.no
2 Department of Ocean and Resources Engineering, University of Hawaii at Manoa,
Honolulu, USA
3 DIMB Consult AS,
Ellefsens vei 3, 7020 Trondheim, Norway
Fatigue caused by ice-induced vibrations (IIV) is an important design consideration for
offshore structures exposed to drifting sea ice. The occurrence of IIV is promoted by, but not
limited to, certain combinations of ice thickness and ice drift speed, which makes them
fundamental input parameters for structure fatigue life estimation. To that end, this work
identifies and analyses the frequency of combined ice thicknesses and ice drift speeds during
all recorded ice-structure interaction events at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse during 2000
2003. The ice drift speed measurements were performed manually at the lighthouse, leading to
bias towards multiples of 0.05 m/s. The ice thickness measurements by EM antenna
underestimates ridge keel depth. The current approach gave a total of above 25 days of ice
condition measurements. The cumulative distributions for ice thickness and speed were
estimated. Given drifting ice conditions, the probability of encountering ice thicker than 0.8 m
was 0.34, i.e. the probability of encountering thicker ice than most of the level ice in the area.
A relatively frequent combination of ice conditions was ice thickness between 0.1 and 0.6 m
and ice drift speed between 0.05 and 0.15 m/s, occurring with a probability of 0.29.
25th IAHR International Symposium on Ice
Trondheim, 23 - 25 November 2020
1. Introduction
Drifting sea ice can cause severe IIVs of offshore structures. One example is the Kemi-I
lighthouse situated in the Bay of Bothnia, which eventually collapsed after a period of heavy
vibrations caused by ice actions during the winter of 1973/74 (Määttänen, 1975). To ensure
safe and reliable structures, the potential IIVs caused by ice conditions in an area must therefore
be considered during design (ISO, 2019). IIVs can be divided into three regimes: intermittent
crushing, frequency lock-in and continuous brittle crushing (ISO, 2019). The occurrence of
each type of IIV will depend on the local ice conditions as well as parameters such as the
structural flexibility (Hendrikse and Nord, 2019). Notably, frequency lock-in can lead to
significant vibrations close to the natural frequencies of the structure and is therefore a concern
when it comes to structural fatigue (Hendrikse and Koot, 2019).
For offshore wind turbines, fatigue load caused by wind and waves is a major design concern
(Igwemezie et al., 2019), making it important to consider the addition of possible fatigue loads
from ice. Different models have been developed to understand the impact of IIVs on structural
fatigue, such as by Hendrikse and Nord (2019). The application of the model for an offshore
wind project is described by Hendrikse and Koot (2019). In short, the model attempts to find
the combinations of ice drift speed and ice thickness that lead to frequency lock-in for a
structure. Then, the probability of occurrence of the relevant ice conditions can be used to
determine the vibration cycles and the contribution to fatigue. A parallel can be drawn to
structural reliability analyses based on wave conditions, which rely on simultaneous
distributions of significant wave height and wave period (Vanem, 2016). Consequently,
accurate statistics of local ice conditions in an area are necessary in order to determine the
fatigue contribution from ice interactions.
A relevant source of statistics on local ice conditions were recorded through the ‘Low Level
Ice Forces’ (LOLEIF) and the ‘Measurements on Structures in Ice’ (STRICE) projects. During
the years 2000 2003, extensive full-scale measurements of ice thickness and ice drift speed
were carried out at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse (Haas and Jochmann, 2003).
Norströmsgrund is located in the Bay of Bothnia in the Northern Baltic sea (N65°6.6′
E22°19.3′), in a transition zone between land-fast and drift ice (Bjerkås, 2006, Ervik et al.,
2019). The ice condition measurements at Norströmsgrund are advantageous in that they
provide a temporal distribution of the conditions experienced by the structure, and that possible
influences from the structure on the ice speed are included. The probability of occurrence of
ice conditions at Norströmsgrund can thus be used as input for fatigue modelling. In addition,
the statistics can provide a starting point for connecting local ice conditions and met-ocean
data, in order to predict local ice conditions in other areas (Bjerkås and Gedikli, 2019, Turner
et al., 2020).
2. Data and data analysis
The following outlines how the local measurements of ice thickness and speed were carried
out during the LOLEIF/STRICE projects.
2.1. Ice drift speed
The ice drift velocity was estimated manually by the personnel stationed on the lighthouse
during ice-structure interactions (Fransson, 2008). A video screen showing the ice was marked
corresponding to a 10x10 m2 grid, and the ice speed and direction was estimated by tracking
distinct ice features through the grid. The manual measurement method resulted in a discrete
distribution of speed values with at most two significant digits per value. The measurements
were performed infrequently and irregularly, with gaps in time between measurements ranging
from minutes to hours. No clear pattern in the timing of the measurements was observed. A
measurement was often made when the load recording started and after significant shifts in
speed, but this was not always the case, see Samardžija (2018) and Ervik et al. (2019).
2.2. Ice thickness
The ice thickness measurements at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse were carried out with
several different combination of instruments during the four-year period (Haas and Jochmann,
2003). An upward-looking sonar (ULS) as well as a Geonics EM31 electromagnetic ice
thickness sensor (EM) was employed in 2000 to measure the subsurface profile of the ice, while
a laser distance meter measured the elevation above the surface. The laser distance meter was
replaced by a sonic distance meter in 2003. The ULS was placed 6 7 m below mean water
level, about 5 m southeast of the lighthouse. The EM sensor and laser distance meter were
mounted on a rig extending 10 m away from the lighthouse, approximately 2 m above the mean
water level. The ice thickness measurement frequency varied between 0.1 1 Hz. Note that the
ice thickness was not always recorded due to instrument issues.
The EM measurements averaged the ice thickness over a certain footprint of some metres in
diameter (Haas and Jochmann, 2003). For ridges, the EM most probably measured the
thickness of the consolidated layer and some part of the rubble depending on their
conductivities, which is affected by their salinities and the macroporosity (Ervik et al., 2019).
As a result, the EM measurements underestimated the ridge keel depth. In contrast, the ULS
always measured the deepest point on the ice keel, making it more accurate for ridge thickness.
Haas and Jochmann (2003) found that EM measurements underestimated the keel depth by as
much as 50%, but that EM and ULS measurements agreed well for level ice. Bjerkås (2006)
multiplied the EM keel depths with 3.16 in order to reach similar values as measured by ULS.
In what follows, no correction will be made for possible underestimation of keel depth by EM.
In order to maintain a consistent measurement method between 2000 2003, this work focuses
on the ice thickness measured through EM only.
2.3. Data structure
Measurements of loads, ice thickness, speed and other parameters were recorded and saved in
a total of 519 time series known as events, with durations ranging from 10 minutes to 24 hours.
Importantly, the measurements of ice speed were only recorded simultaneously with load
measurements, primarily during ice-structure interactions. The loads were recorded when
observers noticed interesting ice interactions with the lighthouse (Bjerkås et al., 2003). That is,
the ice-structure interactions governed the collection of ice condition data. As such, the
selection of recorded ice conditions during events will be inherently skewed towards conditions
which produce ice-structure interactions.
2.4. Data analysis
A MATLAB routine was used to search through and extract recorded measurements from the
519 events. Errors in the dataset were removed. Subsequently, the collected data were
processed as outlined in the following.
2.4.1. Stepwise interpolation
Because of variations in the measurement frequency of ice thickness and speed and the poor
temporal resolution of the speed measurements, the parameters were interpolated as illustrated
in Figure 1 within each event. The interpolation was not carried out outside the duration of the
events. Stepwise interpolation schemes were preferred over alternatives like linear
interpolation in order to avoid generating thickness and speed values that did not necessarily
occur. The values were interpolated every second, effectively standardizing the measurement
frequency to 1 Hz. Additionally, a comparison between the previous neighbour interpolation
and nearest neighbour interpolation was carried out in order to investigate the resulting speed
frequency distributions.
Figure 1. Example of a speed time series, showing measured speeds (crosses) along with
stepwise interpolation methods (lines) between measurements.
2.4.2. Parameter constraints
To focus the analysis on conditions which may contribute to structural fatigue, only drifting
ice with a certain ice thickness is considered. Static ice with a drift speed of 0 m/s is removed,
as well as ice thinner than 0.1 m. The purpose of setting an ice thickness criterion is to eliminate
false positives from open water, which restricts the analysis to conditions where sea ice has
been confirmed to occur. Only common measurements that fulfil both parameter constraints
simultaneously are considered for the analysis.
3. Results
Figure 2 shows the frequency of all local ice thickness and ice speed values that were recorded
during the interaction events of the LOLEIF/STRICE campaigns, without interpolation and
parameter constraints. A mean thickness of 0.86 m was measured during events, with a
standard deviation of 0.77 m and where the most frequently measured thicknesses were in the
interval 0.05 0.10 m. The frequency distribution shows a decreasing trend for thicknesses
above 0.4 m, with the exception of local peaks at 0.7 m, 1.4 m and 1.9 m. The measurements
contained fluctuations on the order of ± 0.05 m for level ice, giving a baseline uncertainty.
The measured speed shown in Figure 2 has a mean of 0.12 ± 0.09 m/s, with a mode of 0.1 m/s.
The values contain at most two significant digits, and only 48 unique speed values were
recorded in total. The frequency distribution contains prominent peaks for multiples of 0.1 m/s,
with less prominent peaks at values such as 0.15 and 0.25 m/s. These peaks point to a
significant underlying bias in the speed measurements towards multiples of 0.05 m/s. Although
they follow the underlying trend of decreasing frequency with increasing speed, the
prominence of the peaks are large outliers from the apparent underlying distribution.
Figure 2. The frequency of measured ice thickness values (left, bin width 0.05 m) and non-
zero ice speed values (right, bin width 0.01 m/s) recorded during the events of the
LOLEIF/STRICE campaigns.
The previous neighbour and nearest neighbour interpolation methods result in similar speed
frequency distributions. The relative difference between the two interpolation methods is below
± 0.1 for the most frequently occurring intervals. Because of the overall small difference in the
resulting distribution for speed, the previous neighbour interpolation was utilized for the
combined distribution for consistency.
Implementing previous neighbour interpolation and the parameter constraints results in the
frequency distributions of ice thickness and speed shown in Figure 3. The mean thickness is
0.76 ± 0.70 m with a mode in the interval 0.10 0.15 m. Compared to the frequency distribution
of the measured results (cf. Figure 2), the ice thickness has notably less prominent peaks at
higher thicknesses, and the distribution is more evenly decreasing.
Figure 3. The frequency of interpolated ice thickness values (left, bin width 0.05 m) and ice
speed values (right, bin width 0.01 m/s) that simultaneously fulfil the parameter constraints.
The mean speed after interpolation is 0.10 ± 0.08 m/s, and the mode is in the interval 0.10
0.11 m/s. The bias in the speed data is still present, although occurrences of 0.15 m/s and 0.25
m/s are relatively less frequent.
After interpolation, the frequency distribution of thickness and speed can be considered an
estimate of the occurrence of each parameter in seconds, as the measurement frequency is
standardized to 1 Hz. The result is thickness and speed data within the parameter constraints
for a total of about 25 days and 5 hours between 2000 2003. In comparison, the total event
duration is about 94 days and 16 hours across the four years. Most of the removed data was
static ice, making up a total duration of above 52 days. Interpolation results in about 79 days
of ice thickness measurements during events, where the ice was thicker than 0.1 m for roughly
67 days and 18 hours.
Figure 4 shows the interpolated thickness distribution per year, while Table 1 summarizes the
mean, standard deviation and mode per year. 2003 is an outlier, with a large mean thickness
and a frequency distribution skewed towards thicker ice compared to other years. This is,
however, not reflected in the modes, as 2003 also contains a significant number of
measurements between 0.10 0.15 m. These measurements were primarily recorded during
the final weeks of the measurement campaign in April. If the final full week of measurements
is not included, the mean thickness for 2003 is 1.23 ± 0.85 m with a mode between 0.45 0.50
m.
Figure 4. Interpolated ice thickness distributions per year for drifting ice, with bin widths 0.1
m. The bin heights are normalized by probability, summing to 1.
Table 1. Ice thickness means, standard deviations, and modes in total and per year for measured
and interpolated ice thickness distributions with parameter constraints. The modes are the most
frequent interval with interval widths of 0.05 m.
Year
Measured ice thickness
Interpolated ice thickness
Mean ± st. dev. [m]
Mean ± st. dev. [m]
Mode [m]
Total
0.86 ± 0.77
0.76 ± 0.70
0.10-0.15
2000
0.69 ± 0.57
0.84 ± 0.62
0.25-0.30
2001
0.57 ± 0.51
0.46 ± 0.45
0.15-0.20
2002
0.67 ± 0.62
0.70 ± 0.59
0.30-0.35
2003
1.03 ± 0.85
1.06 ± 0.87
0.10-0.15
3.1. Combined distribution
The combined distribution of drifting ice thickness and speed is illustrated in Figure 5. The
biased speed distribution affects the combined distribution, resulting in separate thickness
distributions for certain speed values. The most frequently occurring combination is between
0.15 0.20 m and 0.03 0.04 m/s. The joint cumulative histogram of the ice thickness and
speed is shown in Figure 5c, and can be used to estimate the probability of certain ice
conditions. The most frequent combinations occurred for ice thicknesses in the interval 0.1
0.6 m and speeds in the interval 0.05 0.15 m/s with a total probability of 0.29. The thickness
distribution had a long tail, resulting in a 0.34 probability of encountering ice thicker than 0.8
m. Multiplying the probabilities from the cumulative histogram with the total duration of 25
days and 5 hours gives approximate time durations that the conditions in question were
encountered at the lighthouse. For example, drifting ice thicker than 0.8 m was encountered an
estimated total duration of 8 days and 20 hours between 2000 2003.
(a)
(b) (c)
Figure 5. Figures showing the combined distribution of ice thickness and ice drift speed. (a)
shows a bivariate frequency distribution of the two parameters with bin widths of 0.05 m x
0.01 m/s. (b) shows a heatmap of the frequency distribution in (a), where the colour of each
field shows the probability of each combination of parameters, normalized over the visible
bins. The heatmap has bin widths of 0.2 m x 0.02 m/s. (c) shows the same distribution as a joint
cumulative histogram, with bin widths of 0.1 m x 0.02 m/s.
4. Discussion
After interpolation, the frequency distributions of ice thickness and speed can be interpreted as
temporal distributions of ice conditions at the lighthouse, because the parameters are
interpolated to every second. The frequency of a given combination of ice thickness and speed
will equal an estimate of its total duration. The duration can then be divided by the total
measurement time over four years to find the probability of occurrence of the conditions in
question. Note that the durations will be a lower bound estimate, as the measurements and
interpolation are limited only to the recorded events, with a total duration of 94 days and 16
hours over the four years. Despite this, much of the drifting ice encountered during the
campaign periods are likely recorded in events. Drifting ice often caused ice-structure
interactions, and recording these interactions was the focus of the campaign.
The significant bias in the speed data towards multiples of 0.05 m/s is likely caused by rounding
to one or two significant figures, as the speed was manually estimated. Some information is
lost when the values are rounded, which makes it difficult to recover the underlying
distribution. The bias makes the combined distribution less accurate for small speed intervals,
effectively reducing the resolution from which useful data can be extracted.
Some relevant ice thickness measurements by EM of drifting ice in the Bay of Bothnia are
summarized by Ronkainen et al. (2018) and can be used for comparison to the measurements
at Norströmsgrund. In 2003, several ice thickness measurement campaigns were carried out by
using a helicopter-borne EM instrument (HEM), described by Haas (2004). The analysis of the
dataset done by Ronkainen et al. (2018) focused on drifting ice, where they found a mean ice
thickness of 1.39 m and a mode of 0.5 0.6 m on the 21st of February, east in the Bay of
Bothnia. They also found that 63.1% of the drift ice was deformed. Haas et al. (2009) found a
generally good agreement between HEM measurements and ground-based measurements
using a Geonics EM31 instrument, which was also used at Norströmsgrund.
Except for the large mode at 0.1 0.2 m, the ice thickness distribution at Norströmsgrund
follows a similar trend as the HEM measurements in 2003, with a local peak at 0.5 0.6 m and
a gradual decline with a very long tail in the distribution. Importantly, the seasonal
development of ice thickness will impact the Norströmsgrund statistics, as these were recorded
over more than two months, while the HEM data is from a single day. Excluding the thin ice
during the last week of measurements in April, the mean thickness at Norströmsgrund (1.23
m) is close to the mean thickness through HEM (1.39 m). Additionally, Ronkainen et al. (2018)
writes that there was less ice in the west side of the Bay and a greater presence of coastal leads,
which will reduce the mean ice thickness at Norströmsgrund compared to the helicopter
measurements. Note that the frequency distribution of ice thickness at Norströmsgrund will
depend on the ice speed, while the ice can be assumed static relative to the helicopter during
HEM measurements.
Drift ice thicker than 0.8 m was encountered 35% of the time during events at Norströmsgrund,
much of which was deformed ice. According to Määttänen and Kärnä (2011), the level ice
thickness was less than 0.6 m in the area during the measurement years. Li et al. (2016) found
a mean annual maximum ice thickness of 0.61 m between 2000 2003 based on Freezing
Degree Days calculations, with 2003 being the most severe year with 0.71 m. The severity of
the winter in 2003 is reflected in the long tail of the thickness distribution that year (see Figure
4d). Ronkainen et al. (2018) points out that 2003 was very windy, which likely contributed to
the large amount of ridging.
Note that the temporal distribution of ice thickness at Norströmsgrund may be affected by the
structure itself, but the magnitude of this effect is unknown. For example, when the driving
forces on an ice floe are insufficient for limit stress failure to occur, the floe may get stuck on
the lighthouse. The thickness of the stuck floe will continue to be measured for some time,
increasing its relative frequency in the data.
5. Conclusions
The recorded ice thicknesses and ice drift speeds at Norströmsgrund during the
LOLEIF/STRICE campaigns in the years 2000 2003 were extracted and analysed. By
interpolating per second, the varying measurement frequencies were corrected, and a joint
temporal frequency distribution of drift ice at the lighthouse was estimated. The joint
distribution can provide input to fatigue modelling and as a basis for transferring local ice
conditions to other areas. However, ridge keel depth was underestimated by EM measurements.
In addition, the accuracy of the combined distribution was affected by significant underlying
bias in the ice speed data. Establishing a more accurate local speed distribution is a target for
further research.
The drift ice thickness distribution in 2003 followed a similar trend to helicopter EM
measurements that year, with the addition of a large mode for thin ice measured late in the
season. A significant fraction of the drift ice encountered was thicker than level ice, which is
important to consider for distributions of local ice thickness. The influence of the structure on
the local ice drift and resulting thickness distribution was not quantified but is highly relevant
for fatigue simulations based on local ice conditions and should be investigated further.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to extend their gratitude to Ilija Samardžija, Torodd S. Nord, Hayo Hendrikse,
and other partners on the FATICE project who provided helpful feedback on the methods and
findings in this work.
The authors also wish to acknowledge the support to the FATICE project from the
MarTERA partners, the Research Council of Norway (RCN), German Federal Ministry of
Economic Affairs and Energy (BMWi), the European Union through European Union’s
Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 728053-
MarTERA and the support of the FATICE partners.
References
Bjerkås, M., and Gedikli, E. D., 2019. A method to find intervals with probability of harsh ice
induced vibrations. Proc. 25th International Conference on Port and Ocean engineering
under Arctic Conditions, Delft, The Netherlands.
Bjerkås, M., Ivanova, A., Bonnemaire, B., and Jochmann, P., 2003. Magnitudes of global and
local ice loads on the lighthouse Norströmsgrund winter 2002. Report, Norwegian
University of Science and Technology.
Bjerkås, M., 2006. Ice Actions on Offshore StructuresWith Applications of Continuous
Wavelet Transforms on Ice Load Signals. PhD thesis, NTNU.
Ervik, Å., Nord, T. S., Høyland, K. V., Samardžija, I., and Li, H., 2019. Ice-ridge interactions
with the Norströmsgrund lighthouse: Global forces and interaction modes. Cold
Regions Science and Technology 158, 195220.
Fransson, L., 2008. Ice mechanics and shipping in ice-infested waters. Research report no 65,
Finnish Transport Safety Agency.
Haas, C., and Jochmann, P., 2003. Continuous EM and ULS thickness profiling in support of
ice force measurements. Proc. 17th International Conference on Port and Ocean
Engineering Under Arctic Conditions, Trondheim, Norway.
Haas, C., 2004. Airborne EM sea-ice thickness profiling over brackish Baltic Sea water. Proc.
17th IAHR International Symposium on Ice, St. Petersburg, Russia, 12-17.
Haas, C., Lobach, J., Hendricks, S., Rabenstein, L., and Pfaffling, A., 2009. Helicopter-borne
measurements of sea ice thickness, using a small and lightweight, digital EM system.
Journal of Applied Geophysics 67(3), 234-241.
Hendrikse, H., and Nord, T. S., 2019. Dynamic response of an offshore structure interacting
with an ice floe failing in crushing. Marine Structures 65, 271-290.
Hendrikse, H., and Koot, J., 2019. Consideration of ice drift in determining the contribution
of ice-induced vibrations to structural fatigue. Proc. 25th International Conference on
Port and Ocean engineering under Arctic Conditions, Delft, The Netherlands.
Igwemezie, V., Mehmanparast, A., and Kolios, A., 2019. Current trend in offshore wind energy
sector and material requirements for fatigue resistance improvement in large wind
turbine support structures A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 101,
181-196.
ISO19906, 2019. Petroleum and natural gas industries Arctic offshore structures.
International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Li, H., Bjerkås, M., Høyland, K. V. and Nord, T. S., 2016. Panel loads and weather conditions
at Norströmsgrund lighthouse 2000-2003. Proc. 23rd IAHR International Symposium
on Ice, Ann Arbor, Michigan USA.
Määttänen, M., 1975. Experiences of ice forces against a steel lighthouse mounted on the
seabed, and proposed constructional refinements. Proc. 3rd International Conference on
Port and Ocean Engineering Under Arctic Conditions, Fairbanks, Alaska, 857871.
Määttänen, M., and Kärnä, T., 2011. ISO 19906 ice crushing load design extension for narrow
structures. Proc. 21st International Conference on Port and Ocean Engineering Under
Arctic Conditions, Montréal, Canada.
Milaković, A.-S., Braun, M., Willems, T., Hendrikse, H., Fischer, C., and Ehlers, S., 2019.
Methodology for estimating offshore wind turbine fatigue life under combined loads of
wind, waves and ice at sub-zero temperatures. Proc. International Conference on Ships
and Offshore Structures ICSOS 2019, Florida, USA.
Nord, T. S., Samardžija, I., Hendrikse, H., Bjerkås, M., Høyland, K. V., and Li, H., 2018. Ice-
induced vibrations of the Norströmsgrund lighthouse. Cold Regions Science and
Technology 155, 237251.
Ronkainen, I., Lehtiranta, J., Lensu, M., Rinne, E., Haapala, J., and Haas, C., 2018. Interannual
sea ice thickness variability in the Bay of Bothnia. The Cryosphere 12, 3459-3476.
Samardžija, I., 2018. Two applications of a cross-correlation based ice drift tracking algorithm;
ship-based marine radar images and camera images from a fixed structure. Proc. 24th
IAHR International Symposium on Ice, Vladivostok, Russia, 141- 151.
Turner, J., Høyland, K. V., Hornnes, V., and Gedikli, E. D., 2020. Comparison of in-situ
measurements from the Norströmsgrund lighthouse to Copernicus reanalysis products.
Proc. 25th IAHR International Symposium on Ice, Trondheim, Norway.
Vanem, E., 2016. Joint statistical models for significant wave height and wave period in a
changing climate. Marine Structures 49, 180-205.
... Simultaneous load and environmental data from the campaigns were collated and cleaned of errors. Like in Hornnes et al. (2020), the recorded environmental data were interpolated using a previous neighbor interpolation routine. Further, to find brittle crushing events, the following selection criteria were applied to the time series: ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The design of flexible vertical offshore structures exposed to crushing ice, such as offshore wind turbines, can become governed by ice loads and the structural response associated with low relative speeds between ice and structure. Low ice speeds can cause significant loads due to pressure synchronization and/or increase in contact, potentially larger than those observed at high ice speeds, which is often referred to as the velocity effect. In this study, the dataset from the full-scale measurement campaign at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse is reanalyzed. Several instances of ice load amplification are identified and presented, to confirm that synchronization and the velocity effect developed. The increase in ice load is quantified and discussed in the context of a theoretical framework, and model-and full-scale observations of the velocity effect on other structures. Then several events of high-speed crushing are investigated and the potential global pressures at low speeds for those events are estimated based on the theoretical framework. These estimates are compared to typical high-speed global crushing pressures used to define the ice strength coefficient R for the Baltic Sea. It is found that the velocity effect may produce global pressures equivalent to a R factor above 0.9 MPa. The results provide a theoretical substantiation for inclusion of the velocity effect and a possible physical interpretation of the recommended value of 1.8 MPa in the ISO 19906 design standard.
... This factor ignores the presence of wind farms, which may significantly affect the ice drift. Ice thickness distributions were estimated for each region based on research in the Danish Straits and the Bay of Bothnia (Hornnes et al., 2022;Hornnes et al, 2020;Ronkainen et al. 2018). The number of ice interaction days, ice , was estimated based on the probability of ice occurrence at the coast, a correction for ice formation offshore, and an ice drift factor based on experiments at the Noströmsgrund Lighthouse. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
For the design of offshore foundations in regions such as the Baltic Sea, it is paramount that ice-structure interaction is appropriately considered. For the monopile, a common foundation for offshore wind turbines, challenges with ice-induced vibrations and high ridge loads may require ice-mitigating measures to be included in the design. A 'feasibility map' showing the necessity for such ice-mitigating measures in the entire Baltic region has been developed for monopiles. The feasibility was considered in technical terms by imposing design, installation, and fabrication constraints, and in economic terms, expressed in weight increase of monopiles when compared to an 'ice-free' design. A design assessment of offshore wind turbines across the Baltic Sea was conducted by optimizing foundation designs for the IEA 15 MW reference turbine for nine identified characteristic regions of the Baltic Sea. The assessment was performed via the in-house foundation design software MORPHEUS by Wood Thilsted. MORPHEUS has been coupled to the phenomenological ice model "VANILLA" to capture the dynamic ice-structure interaction for level ice. From the assessment, the following regions are deemed feasible for monopiles without ice-mitigating measures: the Danish Straits, the Baltic Proper South, the Baltic Proper North, the Gulf of Riga and the Archipelago Sea. The Bothnian Sea North and the Bay of Bothnia are deemed infeasible without mitigating measures. For the Bothnian Sea South and the Gulf of Finland, no conclusive answer was found as more research into the cost competitiveness of alternative options is required. The increase in fatigue resulting from ice loading was found to be the main cause for foundation weight increase of monopiles compared to monopiles designed for ice-free waters.
... It is frequently used in cold regions for safe navigation, to inform ice-structure interaction modeling, and decision making, among other things. However, while much research is done for the Baltic Sea [2][3] [4] [5] and the Northern Sea Route, little research is done for Alaskan waters. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Climate change is affecting global weather patterns, but nowhere is this more apparent than in the Arctic. The Arctic is an extreme environment going through rapid climate change, resulting in the opening of new shipping lanes and leading to less multiyear ice formation. This increases the risk of collision with the sea ice making it difficult to make long term voyage plans based on sea ice predictions. The Automatic Identification System (AIS) provides important services for marine domain awareness. For safe and effective ship traffic management and the development of new artificial intelligence (AI) marine algorithms, precise AIS readings for hull size and type are typically required. In this paper, we provide a summary of ship activities as well as relevant ice information in Alaskan waters that may result in ice-ship interactions and discuss them. AIS ship data was used to determine the ship speed distribution in different areas in the Alaskan waters. Ship movement in ice infested regions was compared with sea ice data from the Copernicus Reanalysis Products and sea ice thickness was estimated using empirical equations to identify potential ship-sea ice interactions. Data from 2015 to 2020 was analyzed to determine if there is an increase in maritime activity that can be linked to a decline in sea ice extent in Alaskan waters. The AIS data was also sorted by ship hull types to see how the different sectors of the Alaskan maritime industry are changing over time in ice-covered areas.
... This factor ignores the presence of wind farms, which may significantly affect the ice drift. Ice thickness distributions were estimated for each region based on research in the Danish Straits and the Bay of Bothnia (Hornnes et al., 2022;Hornnes et al, 2020;Ronkainen et al. 2018). The number of ice interaction days, ice , was estimated based on the probability of ice occurrence at the coast, a correction for ice formation offshore, and an ice drift factor based on experiments at the Noströmsgrund Lighthouse. ...
... It is found that the correlation coefficient between the ice thickness and the ice drift speed has a negative value as shown in Fig. 12. Furthermore, Hornnes et al. (2020) has studied the joint distribution of the ice thickness and the ice drift speed for the purpose of fatigue assessment at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse in the bay of Bothnia. They found that thicker sea ice tends to drift with a lower speed. ...
Article
The purpose of the present paper is to investigate the viability of the so-called ice rose diagram, which is a graphic tool to provide a succinct view of the ice drift information such as speed and direction of ice drift events in terms of their relative distribution at a local observation station to support the dynamic ice-structure interaction in cold regions. The ice drift data is collected by using local subsurface measurements based on acoustic Doppler current profilers (ADCP) in the Beaufort Sea during 2006–2017. Probabilistic analyses are performed in order to characterize the time-series data from these ADCP measurements. Both the ice drift speed and direction are treated as random variables for which analytical probability density functions are fitted. It is found that sea ice in the Beaufort Sea tends to drift at a lower speed during the winter season (i.e. the growth season) than during the summer season (i.e. the melting season). The Weibull distribution provides the most appropriate fit to the data of ice drift speeds during the growth season. For the melting season, a mixed distribution provides the most appropriate fit for the drift speed. Regarding directionality of the ice drift, a mixed Von Mises distribution is applied in order to represent its statistical properties. In this work, the relationship between ice drift speed and wind speed is also studied. It is found that the magnitude of the ice drift speed is approximately 2.5% of the wind speed during the winter season.
... However, to identify all combinations of conditions that could result in any significant structural loads, a complete analysis of all recorded ice conditions is required. To accomplish this, Hornnes et al. (2020) extracted and summarized all ice conditions that were recorded at the lighthouse during the campaigns. They found that 34% of the ice encountered at the lighthouse was thicker than the level ice in the region, signifying the importance of considering deformed ice in severe ice conditions. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
In the FATICE project we have addressed the fatigue damage on fixed offshore structures exposed to drifting ice. This is an important challenge in the development of energy production from offshore wind in the Baltic and involves at least five element: a) define ice statistics, b) predict the structural response (ice-structure interaction simulations), c) estimate the fatigue damage and d) carry out scale-model tests. We have used the Copernicus database and simple analytical equations to define the large-scale ice statistics and studied down-scaling to structural scale by comparing with ice load data on the Norströmsgrund lighthouse (LOLEIF and STRICE data). The VANILLA model allows for ice-structure interaction simulations and has been validated against the full-scale LOLEIF and STRICE data and against the model-scale ice in HSVA. The fully coupled and the traditional methods are compared. In the fatigue estimations studies the assumption of linear damage accumulation is challenged and load combinations from wave, wind and ice studied by assessing simulated time-series of the different loads. The main results is that sea ice cause the higher loads than wind and waves do , but the cumulative frequency of ice loads is much smaller than for wind and waves. The traditional model-scale ice tends to be too soft and/or too viscous so that a realistic breaking pattern combined with realistic force-time series is not been obtained for large aspect ratios. HVA has developed a crushing model ice (ICMI) in which the ice crystals are larger and the texture more uniform
... Of particular note is the method with which ice drift was measured; cameras were used to manually measure ice velocity by tracking conspicuous ice features across a 10 m x 10 m grid displayed on a screen (Jochmann and Schwarz, 2000b). Measurements were sporadic and heavily biased; see Hornnes et al. (2020) for further discussion and a detailed description of the steps necessary to prepare the sea ice velocity and thickness data for analysis. Ice loads were measured directly by nine panels covering 162 deg of the perimeter. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Here, we aim to extend the full-scale data measurements of ice conditions and the resulting structure behaviour at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse to other locations in the Baltic Sea via comparison to the met-ocean conditions from Copernicus reanalysis products. The sea ice velocity produced by the global reanalysis product of the Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service compares favourably to the measurements taken at Norströmsgrund, producing a skewed lognormal similar to the distribution observed during the measurement campaigns. The sea ice thickness from the reanalysis is less applicable; the inspected model produces estimates of level ice thickness near Norströmsgrund over an area of approximately 9.3 km x 3.9 km, averaging out the effect of ridges and leads. A transformation from level ice statistics to first year ice statistics is thus required for application to other locations in the Baltic Sea. Atmospheric reanalysis of air temperature, barometric pressure, wind speed, and wind direction match perfectly over a much larger area (approximately 83 km x 35 km near the Norströmsgrund lighthouse). Comparison to met-ocean conditions both on-site and via Copernicus reanalysis products show some evidence that frequency lock-in events are connected to changes in local conditions; further analysis is required for confirmation.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Here, we aim to extend the full-scale data measurements of ice conditions and the resulting structure behaviour at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse to other locations in the Baltic Sea via comparison to the met-ocean conditions from Copernicus reanalysis products. The sea ice velocity produced by the global reanalysis product of the Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service compares favourably to the measurements taken at Norströmsgrund, producing a skewed lognormal similar to the distribution observed during the measurement campaigns. The sea ice thickness from the reanalysis is less applicable; the inspected model produces estimates of level ice thickness near Norströmsgrund over an area of approximately 9.3 km x 3.9 km, averaging out the effect of ridges and leads. A transformation from level ice statistics to first year ice statistics is thus required for application to other locations in the Baltic Sea. Atmospheric reanalysis of air temperature, barometric pressure, wind speed, and wind direction match perfectly over a much larger area (approximately 83 km x 35 km near the Norströmsgrund lighthouse). Comparison to met-ocean conditions both on-site and via Copernicus reanalysis products show some evidence that frequency lock-in events are connected to changes in local conditions; further analysis is required for confirmation.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Ice-induced vibrations have to be considered in the design of vertically sided offshore structures which may encounter drifting sea or lake ice during their lifetime. One particular aspect is the contribution of ice-induced vibrations to the fatigue of such structures. Estimation of the duration of events is often difficult, due to limited available data on ice drift, leading to conservative assumptions. In this paper, the approach followed for assessing the fatigue resulting from frequency lock-in vibrations in the design stage of a recent offshore wind project is presented. The project concerned offshore wind turbines with jacket support structures consisting partly of vertical structural members. The severity of ice-induced vibrations for the structures is first assessed using a simulation model. Following this, ice drift is included in the assessment to obtain an estimate of the number of cycles of frequency lock-in over the lifetime of the structure. Results show that site-specific combinations of ice floe size and driving forces significantly influence the expected number of cycles of frequency lock-in. It is concluded that for this project limited conditions exist in which sustained vibrations can develop and that the contribution of frequency lock-in to structural fatigue is therefore limited as well.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
A method is proposed to estimate when harsh ice induced vibrations could be expected at an offshore site in an ice-infested region. The method aims to come up with specific estimates based on input parameters that are easily accessible. Therefore, the proposed method uses measured air temperatures, wind speeds, wind directions and ice concentrations, where some other relevant parameters such as ice thickness and ice drift speed could be calculated from these measured parameters. Test runs have been performed from a database with 60years of environmental data. However, because global sea ice concentration climate data record was only available between the years of 1979 and 2015 in EUMETSAT OSI SAF 1 , database of input parameters were adjusted covering this period. Further comparisons with historical observations as well as the full-scale data sets from the LOLEIF and STRICE projects have been utilized. The early results of this model show that including ice thickness, air temperature, ice drift speed, wind direction and ice concentration, time periods of the year with high probability of ice induced vibrations could be hindcasted. These findings have been proved against three seasons of registered vibration events at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse.
Article
Full-text available
Interaction of sea or lake ice with vertically sided offshore structures may result in severe structural vibrations commonly referred to as ice-induced vibrations. With the surge in offshore wind developments in sub-arctic regions this problem has received increased attention over the last decade, whereas traditionally the topic has been mainly associated with lighthouses and structures for hydrocarbon extraction. It is important for the safe design of these offshore structures to have the ability to predict the interaction between ice and structure in an expected scenario. A model for simulation of the interaction between a drifting ice floe and a vertically sided offshore structure is presented. The nonlinear speed dependent ductile and brittle deformation and local crushing of ice are considered phenomenologically. A one-dimensional sea ice dynamics model is applied to incorporate the effects of floe size, wind and current. The structure is modelled by incorporating its modal properties obtained from a general-purpose finite element software package. Alternatively, the model can be coupled to in-house design software for fully coupled simulations. Examples of application of the model to simulate dynamic ice-structure interaction are provided. Simulation results are validated with public data from forced vibration experiments, small-scale intermittent crushing and frequency lock-in, and full-scale interaction with the Norströmsgrund lighthouse. Effects of floe size and environmental driving forces on the development of ice-induced vibrations in full-scale are studied. It is shown that sustained frequency lock-in vibrations of the structure can only develop for very specific combinations of environmental driving forces and ice floe size. In all other cases, the ice floe slows down and comes to a stop, or accelerates to a drift speed which exceeds the range where frequency lock-in develops. This results in only a few cycles of vibration per interaction event, such as observed for the Norströmsgrund lighthouse in the Baltic Sea.
Article
Full-text available
While variations of Baltic Sea ice extent and thickness have been extensively studied, there is little information about drift ice thickness, distribution, and its variability. In our study, we quantify the interannual variability of sea ice thickness in the Bay of Bothnia during the years 2003–2016. We use various different data sets: official ice charts, drilling data from the regular monitoring stations in the coastal fast ice zone, and helicopter and shipborne electromagnetic soundings. We analyze the different data sets and compare them to each other to characterize the interannual variability, to discuss the ratio of level and deformed ice, and to derive ice thickness distributions in the drift ice zone. In the fast ice zone the average ice thickness is 0.58±0.13 m. Deformed ice increases the variability of ice conditions in the drift ice zone, where the average ice thickness is 0.92±0.33 m. On average, the fraction of deformed ice is 50 % to 70 % of the total volume. In heavily ridged ice regions near the coast, mean ice thickness is approximately half a meter thicker than that of pure thermodynamically grown fast ice. Drift ice exhibits larger interannual variability than fast ice.
Article
Full-text available
The signatures in force and response time series from ice-ridge interactions on vertically sided structures are not described in standards and are among the least understood types of ice-structure interactions. In this paper, we identified 35 high global-force ridge events at the Norströmsgrund lighthouse in the winters of 1999/2000 to 2002/2003. During these events, load panels rendered global forces in excess of 3 MN, where the highest global force measured was approximately 6 MN. The type of ice-ridge interaction mode was further classified based on the signatures in force and the response time series as well as video records. The classified ice-ridge interactions included 1) limit-force stalling, 2) limit-stress ductile failure and 3) limit-stress brittle failure. Based on the suggested format of classification, recommendations for future instrumentation are proposed.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Cross-correlation function can be used to estimate the sea ice drift velocity from a pair of sequential images of an ice surface. The approach is established in scientific literature and mostly used for calculating the velocity field of ice drift from satellite imagery. Traditionally, disadvantages of the approach are large computational requirements and inability to account for the rotational motion of the ice field. When used on a smaller spatial and temporal scale to estimate the global ice drift, inability to capture the rotational motion is not crucial since the assumption of translational motion of the ice field does not impair the estimate of the global ice drift. This paper presents an ice drift tracking algorithm that is based on cross-correlation between subsequent marine radar frames that captures ice features surrounding a ship. Computational requirements are not an issue in this use and few days of ice drift is calculated in matters of minutes. The algorithm can produce a real-time ice drift measurements that are valuable information in ice management operations. One potential usage of the results is shown where using the estimated ice drift velocity, the drift of the channels produced in ice management operations is estimated. The same cross-correlation approach can be implemented on camera images. An example of ice drift estimate using the camera images from Norströmsgrund lighthouse is given.
Article
Full-text available
The signature and occurrence of frequency lock-in (FLI) vibrations of full-scale offshore structures are not well understood. Although several structures have experienced FLI, limited amounts of time histories of the responses alongside measured met-ocean data are available in the literature. This paper presents an analysis of 61 measured events of resonant vibrations of the Norströmsgrund lighthouse from 2001 until 2003. The vibrations of most of these events did not reach a steady state; thus, they violate an often-quoted criterion for frequency lock-in vibrations and remain outside any modes of ice-induced vibrations suggested in standards. Met-ocean data from both in situ measurements and from the Copernicus marine service information database are further used to better understand the occurrence of resonant ice-induced vibrations. All events between 2001 and 2003 occurred during days with ice concentrations of 8–10/10, closely packed consolidated drift ice. The locally measured ice velocity and thickness ranged from 0.023 to 0.075 m s⁻¹ and from 0.26 to 1.9 m, respectively. These measurements included level ice, rafted ice and ridged ice. The events of resonant vibrations are further compared with measurements from the same structure between 1979 and 1988. Most events of resonant vibrations were recorded in the winter of 1988, followed by the winters of 2003 and 1980. The winter of 1988 had fewer freezing degree days (FDD) than the 65-year average, whereas the winters of 2003 and 1980 had more FDD than the 65-year average.
Conference Paper
Due to increasing trend of building offshore wind turbines (OWTs) in seas at high latitudes where seasonal sea ice occurs, novel methods for design of such structures are needed. Specifically, the effect of ice-induced vibrations (IIVs) on fatigue life of the structures is currently poorly understood. Therefore, the goal of this paper is to analyze the current state-of-the-art approach for estimating the ice loads contribution to the fatigue life of OWTs and identify the current knowledge gaps. Moreover, the paper proposes a methodology for developing a combined load spectrum of wind, waves and ice using numerical simulations, with an ultimate goal to develop applicable Gaßner curves characterizing the variable-amplitude nature of the loading pattern. Finally, the use of small-scale fatigue tests under sub-zero temperatures in order to develop the appropriate S-N and Gaßner curves is discussed.