ArticlePDF Available

Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media Sponsored Advertising Eficacia del marketing influyente Vs la publicidad patrocinada por medios sociales

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This study aims to assess the efficacy of social media advertising and influencer marketing, using sales, page engagement, brand perceptions and buying intentions as the dependent variables. To achieve the objectives of this study, the researchers ran six advertisements and opted to make use of the same adverts for both the influencer marketing and social media advertising campaigns. The findings of this study indicate that sponsored advertisements are more effective in generating post engagements than influencer marketing posts. Moreover, the study shows that social media users tend to save sponsored advertisements more than they save advertisements by influencers.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana publica bajo licencia Creative Commons Atribución-No Comercial-Compartir Igual 4.0 Internacional
(CC BY-NC-SA 4.0). Más información en https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
ARTÍCULOS
UTOPÍA Y PRAXIS LATINO AMERICANA. AÑO: 25 , EXTRA 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
REVISTA INTERNACIONAL DE FILOSOFÍA Y TEORÍA SOC IAL
CESA-FCES -UNIVERSIDAD DEL ZULIA. MA RACAIBO-VENEZ UELA
ISSN 1316-5216 / ISSN-e: 247 7-9555
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
Sponsored Advertising
Eficacia del marketing influyente Vs la publicidad patrocinada por medios sociales
YOSRA JARRAR
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1595-0933
yjarrar@aud.edu
American University in Dubai, EAU
AYODEJI OLALEKAN AWOBAMISE
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1474-3553
Ayodeji.awobamise@kiu.ac.ug
Kampala International University, Uganda
ADEBOLA ADEWUNMI ADERIBIGBE
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-00541-2932
adebola.aderibigbe@bowenuniversity.edu.ng
Bowen University, Iwo, Nigeria
Este trabajo está depositado en Zenodo:
DOI: http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4280084
ABSTRACT
This study aims to assess the efficacy of social media
advertising and influencer marketing, using sales, page
engagement, brand perceptions and buying intentions as the
dependent variables. To achieve the objectives of this study,
the researchers ran six advertisements and opted to make use
of the same adverts for both the influencer marketing and social
media advertising campaigns. The findings of this study indicate
that sponsored advertisements are more effective in generating
post engagements than influencer marketing posts. Moreover,
the study shows that social media users tend to save sponsored
advertisements more than they save advertisements by
influencers.
Keywords: Brand loyalty, brand perception, buying intention,
influencer marketing, sponsored ads.
RESUMEN
Este estudio tiene como objetivo evaluar la eficacia de la
publicidad en redes sociales y el marketing influyente,
utilizando las ventas, participación de la página, las
percepciones de la marca y las intenciones de compra como
variables dependientes. Para lograr los objetivos de este
estudio, los investigadores ejecutaron 6 anuncios y optaron por
hacer uso de los mismos anuncios tanto para el marketing
influyente como para las campañas publicitarias en redes
sociales. Los hallazgos de este estudio indican que los
anuncios patrocinados son más efectivos para generar
interacciones con publicaciones que las propias publicaciones
de mark eting influyente. Además, el estudio muestra que los
usuarios de las redes sociales tienden a guardar más los
anuncios patrocinados que los anuncios provenientes de
influyentes.
Palabras clave: Anuncios patrocinados, fidelidad de marca,
intención de compra, marketing influyente, percepción de
marca.
Recibido: 19-09-2020 Aceptado: 10-11-2020
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana; ISSN 1316-5216; ISSN-e 2477-9555
Año 25, n° extra 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
41
INTRODUCTION
Influencer marketing focuses on using social media influencers to drive a brand’s message and reach a
target market. Influencers are those individuals who have built a large social media following and who are
perceived as trusted and influential in one or several niche markets (Sudha& Sheena: 2017, pp.14-30). The
spread of the internet and the rise of social media users worldwide have made influencer marketing the logical
next step of digital marketing. Approximately, a third of the world’s population is connected to the internet and
makes use of social media on a daily basis which has led to a change in consumer behaviour
(Zahoor&Quereshi: 2017, pp.47-64; Awobamise: 2018, pp.40-55). These changes manifest in the way
customers shop and seek out information on what to buy. As a result, there has been a growing consensus
on the need to change the way marketing is carried out. More specifically, traditional media and even
traditional digital marketing including sponsored posts, pop-up ads and so on need to be augmented with
influencer marketing if they are to achieve their desired results in this significantly evolving digital marketplace
(Khamis et al.: 2017, pp.191-208; Awobamise: 2018, pp.40-55).
Today, social media influencer marketing has become a major marketing tool for brands all over the world.
This was enabled by the popularity and wide acceptance of platforms like Instagram, Facebook and YouTube,
which enabled ordinary, everyday people to become social media influencers (Khamis et al.: 2017, pp.191-
208). As the internet becomes more ubiquitous, influencer marketing will not only survive but may become a
very lucrative alternative to traditional advertisements and even traditional social media or internet advertising.
The endorsement has always been a formidable marketing tool used to sway public opinion; politicians
make use of celebrities in political agenda-setting and advertisers use them to promote goods and services
(Awobamise&Jarrar: 2018). The idea has always been that people tend to see these celebrities and public
officials as role models and are more likely to believe them and support their agenda. Endorsements help
companies develop and cultivate good reputations and are, in many cases, considered cost-efficient and
effective (Taleverna: 2015; Harrison: 2017; Awobamise&Jarrar: 2018). Therefore, as the popularity of the
internet has brought about a new class of ‘celebrities’ or influencers, marketers need to seize this new
opportunity or adapt to this new reality.
Because of the reach and influence, these influencers wield when they review products, brands or just
talk about a service or a product, and it is becoming increasingly clear that this new breed of ‘celebrities’ have
the power to influence consumer opinion, hence the growth of influencer marketing (Booth &Matic: 2011,
99.184-191). Influencer marketing has become so pervasive that one can hardly scroll through an Instagram
page without coming across some sort of such marketing. This is also the reality in even developing nations
like Uganda, Nigeria and Kenya.
According to De Veirman, et al. (De Veirman et al.: 2017, pp.798-828), the general goal of any form of
marketing is to increase sales, build brand awareness, grow market share, launch a new product/service,
target new customers, improve stakeholder relations, enhance customer relations, and increase profit
amongst others. If examined critically, one can categorize the goals of marketing into two broad categories:
1) Increasing market share (which involves increasing sales and breaking into new markets) 2) Improving
stakeholder relations (which includes improving brand awareness, creating a positive perception about the
brand, customer relations, and targeting new customers amongst others). Therefore, it is reasonable to
measure the effectiveness of influencer marketing based on these two goals.
Nigeria has fully embraced social media influencers and celebrity endorsement (two terms that will be
used interchangeably in the course of this study). Some of the top influencers in Nigeria are Ebuka Obi-
Uchendu, OloriSupergirl, Noble Igwe, TundeEdnut, KayodeAbass, Omojuwa, just to name a few. These
influencers have built a large and loyal following on social media and are now leveraging on their platforms to
promote brands, causes and ideologies to their thousands of loyal and dedicated followers.
Sponsored posts or social media advertising allow advertisers to make promotional messages that are
shown on the target customers’ or audiences’ timelines. Social media advertising has been proven effective
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
42
in improving sales and creating awareness. However, there is a steady increase in the use of social media
influencer marketing which begs the question of which is the most effective of the two. This study, therefore,
seeks to compare the effectiveness of social media advertising and social media influencers’ posts on two of
the most popular social media platforms in Nigeria- Instagram and Facebook.
Conceptual perspective
In the course of this study,the sponsored post shall be used interchangeably with social media marketing
where a marketer makes use of advertising tools on social media platforms like Facebook, YouTube,
Instagram and Twitter. These tools usually allow the marketer to select a specific audience based on age,
gender, hobbies, location and so on, and ensure that only the selected demographics get to see the marketing
or advertising messages.
Influencer marketing, on the other hand, refers to marketing that involves leveraging on the popularity of
social media influence of an individual to market products or services or advance a cause. This involves
contacting a social media personality or a page that advertisers think is relevant to their products or services
and negotiate a term that allows influencers to promote products or services to their thousands or millions of
followers (Bolarinwa: 2015, pp.195-201).
This study posits that there is a significant difference in post engagement, sales, and buying intentions
between consumers exposed to social media advertising and those exposed to influencers’ promotional
messages as shown in Figure (1) below:
Figure 1.Conceptual framework
Theoretical perspective
This study made use of two theories; the technological determinism theory and social learning theory.
Technological determinism is a reductionist theory which at its core posits that the development of any
society and its cultural values are driven by that society’s technological development and
progression.Technological determinists believe that particular communication technologies, media or even
technology, in general, are the sole causes of change in society (Ray: 2013).
This theory is particularly important to this study because it helps understand how technology in this
case, social media (which influencer marketing is a result of) is changing consumer buying behaviour.
Social learning theory was propounded by Bandura in 1963 (Bandura & Walters: 1963) and has been
widely used in the field of communication and advertising (Bush et al.:1999, pp.13-24). The theory posits that
people learn by observing others. It promotes the idea that individuals are motivated to behave in a certain
way based on direct or indirect social interactions (Moschis& Churchill: 1978, pp.599-609; Subramanian &
H3
H2
Marketing
Communication
Influencer marketing
Social media marketing
Page engagement
Sales
Buying Intention
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana; ISSN 1316-5216; ISSN-e 2477-9555
Año 25, n° extra 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
43
Subramanian: 1995, pp.14-18). Previous studies in marketing have made use of this theory to understand
how consumer consumption behaviour is influenced by socialization agents like family, peers and celebrities
(Martin & Bush: 2000, pp.441-453). Social learning theory is proposed in this study as a contextual foundation
in understanding how social media influencers shape buyers’ behaviour and perception, and how this
influence impacts sales.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Social media influencers (SMIs) according to Freberg et al. (Freberg et al.: 2010) “represent a new type
of independent third-party endorsers who shape audience attitudes through blogs, tweets, and the use of other
social media”. As mentioned before, influencer marketing is gaining momentum and popularity in developing
countries and is fast becoming an alternative to traditional forms of marketing communication (Booth &Matic:
2011, pp.184-191, Chan et al.: 2013, pp.167-179).
De Veirman, Cauberghe and Hudders (De Veirman et al.: 2017, pp.798-828) pointed out that influencer
marketing is very effective in ensuring a positive eWOM (electronic word of mouth). The effectiveness of
influencer marketing was further supported by studies by Sudha and Sheena (Sudha& Sheena: 2017, pp.14-
30) who found out that influencer marketing promotes a level of credibility that traditional marketing
communication usually finds difficult to achieve.
According to Influicity- a tech company that develops applications and solutions to help marketers,
agencies and publishers to manage their influencer operations- influencer marketing is effective in creating
awareness for a brand or a product. They argued that 93% of marketers state that influencer endorsements
increase their brand awareness and help them attract new customers. They also explained that consumers
place a lot of trust in influencers and 82% of consumers are likely to purchase a product that is endorsed by
an influencer while 31% of consumers in North America make a purchase based on the recommendations of
an influencer. Furthermore, they claimed that social media influencers help in ensuring brand loyalty by
consumers. While the previous studies showed that social media influencer marketing is effective in improving
brand awareness, sales and retention, the fact remains that the majority of these studies were conducted in
North America and Europe. There is, therefore, a need to find out if this remains true in an African context.
Are influencers relevant enough in Nigeria to influence consumer buying decisions?
This study, therefore, seeks to test the following hypotheses:
Hypothesis 1 (H1): Influencer marketing posts generate more post engagements than sponsored posts.
Hypothesis 2 (H2): Influencer marketing posts generate more sales than sponsored posts.
There is, however, evidence that sponsored posts or social media advertising are effective in getting
people to purchase a product or make use of a service. Dahlen, Lange and Rosengren (Dahlen et al.: 2009)
argued that no matter how limited the exposure is on social media, it usually has a strong impact on users’
purchase behaviour. Bang and Lee (Bang & Lee: 2016, pp.1-14) in their study on the effectiveness of paid or
sponsored posts proved that social media users generally do not trust this type of advertising. This position is
supported by studies by Van Reijmersdal et al. (Van Reijmersdal et al.: 2016, pp.1458-1474) who stated that
consumers who discover that a post is sponsored or is an advertisement usually react with a decreased buying
intention. Evans et al. (Evans et al.: 2017, pp.138-149) also supported this position as they concluded that
posts with the term “paid ad’ or ‘sponsored’ have fewer engagements than those without.
A study conducted by Putter (Putter: 2017, pp.7-13) on the impact of social media on consumer buying
intention stated that when used properly, social media can be a great tool to develop and maintain a
competitive advantage. He found out that companies that make use of social media in their marketing efforts
tend to have a more significant advantage over those that do not. He implied that there is a direct relationship
between increased buying intention and social media advertising, a relationship this study hopes to explore.
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
44
One of the earliest studies on social media advertising and brand perception was conducted by Rahman
and Rashid (Rahman and Rashid: 2018). They posited that social media advertising has become more popular
because of the array of options the internet and social media have made available to the general public.
People now have options to choose from. Therefore, the simple act of choosing has become quite laborious.
Similarly, according to Khalid (Khalid: 2016), there is a significant positive relationship between social media
advertising and brand trust, brand equity and brand loyalty. A study by Ali et al. (Ali et al.: 2016, pp.69-77) on
the impact of social media marketing on consumers’ perception of brands found out that social media
marketing has a significant impact on brand perception. In their study, they compared social media marketing,
promotional marketing and door-to-door marketing, and the findings showed that social media marketing has
a significant advantage over the other forms of marketing when it comes to influencing consumer perception.
One obvious limitation of most of the studies conducted to ascertain the relationship between social media
marketing and brand perception is the fact that they lumped all forms of social media marketing into one,
which muddies the waters and makes it difficult to understand how different forms of social media marketing
might influence brand perception by consumers (Gorry& Westbrook: 2009, pp.195-203).
From the foregoing, it appears that the literature supports the fact that sponsored or paid advertisements
are not very effective. However, a media user cannot usually go on any social media platform without
stumbling upon a sponsored post. The signs point to the fact that marketers and advertisers still see ‘traditional
social media advertisements’ as effective and spend a lot of money on such advertisements. There is also a
distinct lack of literature comparing the effectiveness of sponsored posts vis-à-vis influencer marketing posts.
It is based on this premise that the researchers seek to test the following hypothesis:
Hypothesis 3 (H3): There is a significant difference in the buying intention of consumers exposed to
sponsored advertisements and those exposed to marketing messages from social media influencers.
METHODOLOGY
}
This study aims to assess the effectiveness of social media advertising and influencer marketing using
sales, page engagement, brand perceptions and buying intentions as the dependent variables. Due to the
nature of the research, the entire process of data collection was carried out online.
To achieve the objectives of this study, the researchers ran six different advertisements. The table below
shows the breakdown of the advertisements that were used in this study.
S/N
Product/Service
Types Of
Advertisement
Value
Target
Audience
Social
Media
Potential
Reach
1
Hair and Make-up
products by
Beamzmakeover
Influencer
Marketing by
Glowville
700
USD
(one the
page for
a week)
Females
between the
ages of 18-
35
Facebook
and
Instagram
20720
(combined
followers)
2
Mobile phones by 1989
technologies
3
Sexual Enhancement
products by
Purixxx2020
4
Hair and Make-up
products by
Beamzmakeover
Social media
advertisement
100
USD (for
one
week)
Females
between the
ages of 18-
35 and have
shown an
Facebook
and
Instagram
35,000
potential
reach
(combined)
5
Electronics products by
1989 technologies
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana; ISSN 1316-5216; ISSN-e 2477-9555
Año 25, n° extra 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
45
6
Sexual Enhancement
products by
Purixxx2020
interest in
Beauty
products
Table 1.Social and influencer marketing breakdown
The three categories of products Beauty and make-up, electronics and sexual enhancement - were
selected because they are the most popular advertisements and paid posts on social media in Nigeria
according to Glowville Communications- an online marketing company based in Lagos, Nigeria.
Due to funding limitations, the researchers opted to make use of OlumideGlowville, a social media
influencer who is popular in Nigeria. MrOlumide of Glowville Communications agreed to give the researchers
access to their social media analytics so we could confirm page and post engagements for free. All the posts
were shared on social media within two months, with a week interval between each post. The researchers
measured post engagement and sales for two weeks immediately after posting.
For social media advertisements, the researchers ran the adverts for the same products and made them
as targeted as possible (see Table 1).
To ensure that there was no bias, the researchers opted to make use of the same adverts (image) for
both the influencer marketing and social media advertising. The only difference was that the accompanying
messages on both were different. Below is a sample of a makeup tutorial advert that was used for social media
advertising and influencer marketing.
Figure 2. Sample advert used for the study. Created using Canva free software
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
46
For the social media influencer marketing, Glowville developed a sales copy that accompanied the advert.
The sales copy used as the accompanying text to the advertisement above. The text is shown below:
How have you been spending your Coronavirus lockdown? Have you learnt a new skill, or improved
on an existing skill? Acquiring new knowledge and skills might be just what you need to survive post-
COVID 19. So yesterday, I was chatting with a good friend of mine, and she told me how she
graduated with a first-class but looked for a job for years without any. She then decided to put into
use the skill she learnt while in NYSC. Today she makes an average of 150,000 a week and employs
three full-time staff. She is a make-up artist. Because she’s my padi, I asked her to teach some of my
Facebook family some makeup skills, and she agreed. For a paltry 7500 Naira, you can finally learn
how to make-up like a pro. I have enrolled Damilola for the class and thought to extend this opportunity
to my followers. Please do not miss out as slots are very limited. Do not worry, and the class is going
to be completely online, so you can still learn while keeping your social distance. Call Bimbo on
+2348033457298 to register, and if you mention my name, you get a 25% discount!!
All the advertisements used in this study made use of a ‘Call-to-Action’ – in this case, it was ‘call
+2348033457298, +2348038380552’ for the sponsored posts and +2348089194939, +2348023173982 for
the influencer marketing- that required potential customers to call a particular number. The number was used
exclusively for this campaign, so any call that came through must have come from someone who had seen
the campaign. This ensured that we could confirm the effectiveness of both the social media influencers’
messages and social media advertisements as well as to measure and confirm buyers’ intention.
An online questionnaire was developed and distributed through Facebook, and the post was sponsored
to boost the reach of the post linking to the online questionnaire. This was to ensure the maximum and most
targeted reach possible for the questionnaire. The questionnaire was targeted (using the Facebook audience
insight application) to the same demographic of customers the social media advertisements were targeted at,
thereby ensuring that the majority of the respondents who filled the questionnaire were exposed to either the
sponsored posts or the influencer’s posts. To encourage people to fill the questionnaire, a reward system was
introduced, promising a chance for respondents to win a prize if they fill and submit the online questionnaire.
By the end of the campaign period, 1272 people completed the online questionnaire, but only 1136 were used
for the study.
Experimental Conditions
Because this study was conducted exclusively online, a controlled environment was not possible.
However, two broad groups of respondents were identified, those who were exposed exclusively to the
influencer marketing (influencer’s followers) and those who were exposed to the paid social media advertising
(targeted audience).
The social media influencer had 20,720 followers as at the time of this writing, while Facebook and
Instagram gave a combined possible reach of 35,000. The table below shows the actual number of users who
interacted with, saw or engaged with the posts during the campaign period.
S/N
Advertising
method/platform
Product/brand promoted
Total number of
engagements
1
OlumideGlowville Facebook
page (social media influencer)
Hair and Make-up products
(training) by Beamzmakeover
21,235
Sexual enhancement products by
Purixxx2020
17,525
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana; ISSN 1316-5216; ISSN-e 2477-9555
Año 25, n° extra 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
47
Mobile phone shop (1989
technologies)
15,668
2
OlumideGlowvilleInstagram
Page
Mobile phones by 1989
technologies
2346
Sexual Enhancement products by
Purixxx2020
4532
Hair and Make-up products
(training) by Beamzmakeover
1750
3
Sponsored Post from official
pages of brands and products
advertised (Facebook)
Electronics products by 1989
technologies
17500
Sexual Enhancement products by
Purixxx2020
25248
Hair and Make-up products
(training) by Beamzmakeover
18858
4
Sponsored Post from official
pages of brands and products
advertised (Instagram)
Electronics products by 1989
technologies
25023
Sexual Enhancement products by
Purixxx2020
21214
Hair and Make-up products by
Beamzmakeover
22048
Table 2.Total number of engagements
RESULTS
Hypothesis 1 (H1): influencer marketing posts generate more post engagements than sponsored posts.
To test this hypothesis, the data analytics on Facebook and Instagram for both the influencer marketing
and sponsored posts were collected and presented in the table below:
Product/Brand
Influencer marketing
(Facebook and Instagram post
engagements)
Sponsored advertisement
(Facebook and Instagram post
engagements)
Hair and Make-up products
(training) by Beamzmakeover
22985
40906
Sexual Enhancement products
by Purixxx2020
18014
42523
Electronics products by 1989
technologies
22057
46462
Total
63056
129891
Table 3.Data analytics on Facebook and Instagram for both the influencer marketing and the sponsored
posts
The table above shows that sponsored advertisements provided over 100% more engagements than
influencer marketing. It should be noted that engagements here include: post likes, comments, and shares.
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
48
The findings showed that the sponsored posts on Facebook and Instagram provided 129891 engagements
representing 67.3% of total engagements, while influencer marketing provided 63056 total engagements
representing 32.7% of total engagements.
It should be noted that the cost of a post on Olumide (Glowville) page is usually between 200 dollars for
a single image post and 500 dollars for a post accompanied by a story/write-up (the one used in this study).
In contrast, the cost of the sponsored post used in this study was 100 USD per post, bringing the total cost for
sponsored posts to 300 USD and the influencer marketing to 1500USD. At just 1/5 of the total cost, a
sponsored post was still more effective in improving engagement than influencer marketing. Therefore,
Hypothesis 1 is rejected.
Hypothesis 2 (H2): Influencer marketing posts generate more sales than sponsored posts
To measure the sales of the products, two approaches were used, namely; 1) The researchers measured
how many phone calls were made daily for a period of two weeks from the day the post was shared on social
media. Each social media post (for both influencer marketing and sponsored posts) had a unique phone
number that all potential customers were required to call. 2) The total number of people who actually paid for
the service within two weeks of when the post was shared was also collected. The table below details the
number of sales and calls for each product category used in this study.
Marketing type
Product/brand
Calls/WhatsApp
messages
Total
sales
Influencer
marketing
Hair and Make-up products (training) by
Beamzmakeover
1523
301
Sexual Enhancement products by Purixxx2020
1891
378
Electronics products by 1989 technologies
890
57
Sponsored
posts
Hair and Make-up products (training) by
Beamzmakeover
1200
98
Sexual Enhancement products by Purixxx2020
766
211
Electronic products by 1989 technologies
1200
23
Table 4.The number of sales and calls for each product category
The table shows that influencer marketing is more effective at getting people to call and even buy a
product or use a service than a sponsored post. The findings show that the three products categories got a
total of 1, 068. Seven hundred thirty-six sales representing 68.9% of the total sales and sponsored posts could
only generate 332 sales representing 31.1% of the total sales.
A daily chart below shows the daily sales and calls/WhatsApp for a period of two weeks of post-advert
placement.
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana; ISSN 1316-5216; ISSN-e 2477-9555
Año 25, n° extra 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
49
Figure 3. Sales vs. calls for influencer marketing
Figure 4. Sales vs. Calls for sponsored advertisements
The charts above show that influencer marketing brought in more total sales than sponsored posts.
Another observation is that sales appear to be almost constant throughout the period under review for
sponsored posts. This can be explained in light of the fact that Facebook and Instagram show an advert to an
almost equal number of people per day, therefore, making the exposure almost equal throughout the period
set by the marketer. Influencer marketers mostly post the advert message once, so there is a lot of
engagement on the first day, after which engagement and sales significantly drop for the product.
Based on the above findings, it is clear that influencer marketing is more effective in generating more calls
and sales than the sponsored post. Therefore, hypothesis 2 is accepted.
Hypothesis 3 (H3): there is a significant difference in the buying intention of consumers exposed to
sponsored advertisements and those exposed to marketing messages from social media influencers.
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
day 1 day 2 day 3 day 4 day 5 day 6 day 7 day 8 day 9 day
10
day
11
day
12
day
13
day
14
sales calls
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Day 6 Day 7 Day 8 Day 9 Day
10
Day
11
Day
12
Day
13
Day
14
Sales Calls
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
50
After the online campaign was carried out, and the responses/engagement data was collected over a
period of two weeks after the campaign, a follow up questionnaire was also distributed online. The
questionnaire sought to measure two things; the buying intention of users who saw the adverts (from either
the social media influencer page or the sponsored posts) and the brand perception of the buyers.
The researchers also collected data on the number of people who saved the posts on Instagram and
Facebook. It is the assumption of the researchers that the only reason why a post like the ones used in this
study will be saved is if the user intends to revisit the post in the future in order to make a purchase. The
findings of the study showed that a combined number of 2,304 people saved the post on both the Facebook
and Instagram pages of the social media influencer’s handle. While, 3401, people saved the page on the
sponsored posts. The chart below depicts these findings:
Figure 5. Post saves on Facebook and Instagram (influencer marketing and sponsored post)
From the foregoing, social media users who were exposed to the sponsored posts tended to have a higher
level of buying intention than those exposed to the social media influencer’s message. This may suggest that
users will save a post from a page they do not follow if they find that post interesting. While they might not
save a post from an influencer’s page, they already follow since they can always go back to the page and find
the particular post. This, however, is worthy of a different and more elaborate study to find out what influences
social media users to save posts and what kind of posts are most likely to be saved. From the findings of this
study, we can conclude that there is a significant difference in the buying intentions of social media users
exposed to advertising messages from a sponsored post and those exposed to advertising messages from a
social media influencer. Therefore, hypothesis 3 is accepted.
Findings from the questionnaire also showed that of the 1,272 total respondents, 435 stated that they saw
the influencer’s posts, 701 said that they saw the sponsored post and 136 said that they saw both adverts.
Since the purpose of the questionnaire was to compare the buying intention of users exposed to influencer
marketing messages and sponsored posts, only 1136 questionnaires were used in the study.
The findings showed that 422 respondents of the total respondents confirmed that they saved at least
one of the advertising posts. When asked why they saved the posts, 82% of the respondents stated that they
saved the post in order to be able to easily find it when they decide to purchase the product in the future.
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
influencer
(Instagram)
Influencer
(Facebook)
Sponsored post
(Facebook)
Sponsored post
(Instagram)
Post Saves (Beamzmakeover) Post saves (Obiwezy) Post saves (Eunicelane)
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana; ISSN 1316-5216; ISSN-e 2477-9555
Año 25, n° extra 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
51
The findings also show that 56% of those who were exposed to the social media influencer advertising
message stated that they intend to purchase at least one of the products in the near future or as soon as they
can afford it, while only 32% of those who saw the sponsored post stated that they would be purchasing at
least one of the products they saw in the near future.
DISCUSSION
The findings of this study indicate that sponsored advertisements are more effective in generating post
engagements than influencer marketing posts. This can be explained by the fact that sponsored posts have a
wider and more targeted reach than influencer marketing posts. It should be noted that influencers can only
share a post with their already existing followers which limits their reach to the number of people who follow
them. In contrast, sponsored posts can be configured to reach as many people as you want in any particular
location, which makes a sponsored post unlimited in its reach. The reach alone can account for the reason
why sponsored posts generate more engagements than influencer marketing. It should, however, be noted
that engagements do not necessarily translate to more sales. The findings of this study show that while
sponsored posts generate more engagement, influencer marketing generates more sales. Sudha and Sheena
(Sudha& Sheena: 2017, pp.14-30) assert that influencer marketing promotes a level of credibility that
traditional marketing communication will find difficult to achieve.
It is also well established in the literature that people follow influencers because they have a genuine
interest or trust in what they promote or represent. This probably explains why people are more likely to buy
a product or pay for a service that is promoted by an influencer they follow than from a sponsored post. This
also lends credence to the social learning theory as propounded by Bandura in 1963 (Bandura & Walters:
1963), which posits that people learn by observing others. In this case, people are not just learning the
importance or credibility of a product, but because someone they trust (influencer) endorses or supports the
brand, they tend to do likewise and support the same brands.
Buying intention was measured by the number of people who have indicated an interest in purchasing a
product through calls or WhatsApp or by saving the advertising message. The findings show that social media
users tend to save sponsored advertisements more than they save advertisements by influencers. The
researchers posit that this happens because followers of influencers can always go back to the page and
check for the advert, but since the majority of those exposed to sponsored posts do not follow the advertisers’
pages, they tend to save the posts since they might never come across that particular post again. The positive
brand perception was higher among users exposed to advertisements by social media influencers than those
exposed to the sponsored posts on social media. The reason for this is because social media users tend to
trust the influencers they follow. This trust often leads to followers supporting and trusting the brands their
‘mentors’ also trust and support.
CONCLUSION
As social media and the internet become ubiquitous, the creation of social media celebrities (often referred
to as influencers) become more commonplace. Africa in general and Nigeria in particular, is not so far behind
in the development of new online ‘celebrities. Brands and advertisers are increasingly making use of social
media influencers as brand influencers, and it has, therefore become imperative to confirm the efficacy of
influencer marketing as a means of brand and sales promotion. Findings from this study show that influencer
marketing while very effective in promoting some immediate sales is not very effective in increasing post
engagement which is helpful in ensuring consumers interaction with advertisers in order to get pertinent
information that informs their decision to buy. The researchers, therefore, recommend further studies to
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
52
consider looking into the effectiveness of social media influencers in encouraging brand loyalty and ensuring
return purchase. Without brand loyalty and return purchase, the ability of brands to remain competitive and
profitable is very slim.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Mr Olumide Lawrence, the CEO, Glowville Communications Ltd and a social media
influencer, who allowed us access to his past database and also helped us to post the advertisements for free
on his social media accounts for the purpose of this research.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ALI, Z, SHABBIR, MA, RAUF, M & HUSSAIN, A (2016)."To assess the impact of social media marketing on
consumer perception."International Journal of Academic Research in Accounting, Finance and Management
Sciences, 6(3), pp.69-77.
AWOBAMISE, AO (2018). "Increased Consumerism in a Networked-Nigeria: A Study on the Effect of E-Malls
and Social Media on Youth Spending." Journal of Digital Media & Interaction, 1(2), pp.40-55.
AWOBAMISE, AO& JARRAR, Y (2018). "Celebrity Endorsement and Its Impact on Consumer Perception: A
Study of Globacom Nigeria Limited."The Online Journal of Communication and Media, 4(2).
BANDURA, A & WALTERS, RH (1963)."Social learning and personality development."New York: Rinehart
and Winston.
BANG, HJ & LEE, WN (2016). "Consumer response to Ads in social network sites: an exploration into the role
of Ad location and path." Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising, 37(1), 1-14.
BOLARINWA, OA (2015). "Principles and methods of validity and reliability testing of questionnaires used in
social and health science researches."Niger Postgrad Med Journal, 22(14), pp.195-201
BOOTH, N & MATIC, JA (2011). "Mapping and leveraging influencers in social media to shape corporate
brand perceptions."Corporate Communications: An International Journal, 16(19),pp.184191.
BUSH, AJ, SMITH, R & MARTIN, C (1999)."The influence of consumer socialization variables on attitude
toward advertising: A comparison of African-Americans and Caucasians."Journal of Advertising, 28(3),pp.13-
24.
CHAN, K, LEUNG NGY & LUK, EK (2013)."Impact of celebrity endorsement in advertising on brand image
among Chinese adolescents."Young Consumers, 14(2), pp.167-179.
DAHLÉN, M, LANGE, F & ROSENGREN, S (2009).Optimal marknadskommunikation, Malmö: Liber.
DE VEIRMAN, M, CAUBERGHE, V & HUDDERS, L (2017)."Marketing through Instagram influencers: The
impact of number of followers and product divergence on brand attitude."International Journal of Advertising,
Utopía y Praxis Latinoamericana; ISSN 1316-5216; ISSN-e 2477-9555
Año 25, n° extra 12, 2020, pp. 40-54
53
36(5), pp.798-828.
EVANS, NJ, PHUA, J, LIM, J & JUN, H (2017)."Disclosing Instagram influencer advertising: The effects of
disclosure language on advertising recognition, attitudes, and behavioral intent." Journal of Interactive
Advertising, 17(2), pp.138-149.
FREBERG, K, GRAHAM, K, MCGAUGHEY, K & FREBERG, LA (2010). "Who are the social media
infleuncers? A study of public perceptions of personality."Public Relations Review.
GORRY, GA & WESTBROOK, RA (2009)."Winning the internet confidence game."Corporate Reputation
Review, 12(3), pp.195203.
HARRISON, K (2017). Top 10 trends that will transform digital marketing in 2017.
KHALID, R (2016). Firm-created social media communication and consumer brand perceptions. Proceedings
of Academic World 18th International Conference, Boston, USA.
KHAMIS, S, ANG, L & WELLING, R (2017). "Self-branding, ‘micro-celebrity’ and the rise of Social Media
Influencers."Celebrity Studies, 8(2), pp.191-208.
MARTIN, CA & BUSH, AJ (2000)."Do role models influence teenagers’ purchase intentions and behavior?"
Journal of Consumer Marketing, 17(5),pp.441-453.
MOSCHIS, GP & CHURCHILL JR, GA (1978). "Consumer socialization: A theoretical and empirical
analysis."Journal of Marketing Research, 15(4),pp.599-609.
PUTTER, M (2017)."The impact of social media marketing on consumer buying intention."Journal of
International Business Research and Marketing, 3(1), pp.7-13.
RAHMAN, MM & RASHID, MM (2018). Social media advertising response and its effectiveness: Case of South
Asian teenage customers. Global Journal of Management And Business Research.
RAY, A (2013). Brief Introduction to Technological Determinism.
SUBRAMANIAN, S & SUBRAMANIAN, A (1995)."Reference Group Influence on Innovation Adoption
Behaviour: Incorporating Comparative and Normative Referents."European Advances in Consumer
Research, 2(16),pp.14-18.
SUDHA, M & SHEENA K (2017)."Impact of Influencers in Consumer Decision Process: the Fashion
Industry."SCMS Journal of Indian Management, pp.14-30.
VAN REIJMERSDAL, EA, FRANSEN, ML, VAN NOORT, G, OPREE, SJ, VANDEBERG, L, REUSCH, S &
BOERMAN, SC (2016). "Effects of disclosing sponsored content in blogs: How the use of resistance strategies
mediates effects on persuasion." American Behavioral Scientist, 60(12), pp.1458-1474.
ZAHOOR, SZ & QURESHI, IH (2017)."Social Media Marketing and Brand Equity: A Literature Review."The
IUP Journal of Marketing Management, 17(4), pp.47-64.
Effectiveness of Influencer Marketing vs Social Media
54
BIODATA
Y JARRAR earned her Ph.D. in Communication and Media Management at the American University of
Cyprus. Currently she is an Assistant Professor of Communication and Information Studies at the American
University in Dubai. Her research interests lie within the field of news media, media ethics, media effects, and
public relations.
A.O AWOBAMISE PhD, is an Associate Professor in the Department of Journalism and Media Studies and
also the Associate Dean (Research) of the College of Humanities and Social Sciences at Kampala
International University. Apart from university activities, Dr. Ayodeji also provides digital marketing solutions
and teaches short courses on digital and social media marketing. He is also the founder and director of
Technocast Nigeria limited- a digital and proximity marketing company based in Lagos, Nigeria. His research
areas include, digital marketing, public relations, advertising, new media and semiotics.
A.A ADERIBIGBE is a Senior Lecturer in the College of Computing and Communication Studies, Bowen
University where he has been lecturing for almost a decade. He holds a PhD in Applied/Developmental Mass
Communication. He is the Director of Student Support Services in Bowen University, Nigeria.
... The study also highlights an influencer priming effect. Users tend to be put off by the interruption of TV, Facebook, and YouTube ads (Jarrar, 2020), but if they have seen an influencer post from the same campaign beforehand, they are more ready to watch the TV ad and not dismiss it out of hand. The research was conducted by using the eye tracker model Gazepoint GP3HD, with a 150 Hz sampling rate, and a GSR model Gazepoint Biometrics, integrated for data collection in Gazepoint Analysis UX Edition software, v.5.3.0. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The family as a social unit significantly influences the behaviour of all individuals within it, as well as the behaviour of individuals as consumers. When observing consumer behaviour, the influence of family is viewed through two aspects: its influence on the personal characteristics, attitudes, values, and other characteristics of an individual, and its influence on the consumer purchasing process. Households can influence consumers either directly or indirectly. They could be intermediaries between larger social systems and indirectly influence the formation of thought processes, consumer desires, attitudes, and motivations. The family directly influences certain stages of the purchasing process, as well as on purchase of the product itself. The most important role of family is raising children. As mediators in the transferring of social value, families have an important societal position. The most significant changes that have happened within families are the changing traditional roles of women in families and households. The role of women in contemporary times has become increasingly important when compared to the past. »Modern women« build their own careers, but they also want their opinions and decisions to be respected, and they are also active decision- makers in their family circle. Therefore, the goal of this study to determine the role of women as decision-makers in the family, with an emphasis on the purchase decisions.
... The study also highlights an influencer priming effect. Users tend to be put off by the interruption of TV, Facebook, and YouTube ads (Jarrar, 2020), but if they have seen an influencer post from the same campaign beforehand, they are more ready to watch the TV ad and not dismiss it out of hand. The research was conducted by using the eye tracker model Gazepoint GP3HD, with a 150 Hz sampling rate, and a GSR model Gazepoint Biometrics, integrated for data collection in Gazepoint Analysis UX Edition software, v.5.3.0. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The purpose of this research is to analyze the influence on consumer perception through neuromarketing methods as well as to analyze the influence of two-step flow theory supported by neuromarketing methods. The choice of different forms of neuromarketing, the popularity of influencers and their opinion leadership has resulted in the convergence of the promotion of products and brands. By considering neuromarketing methods and techniques, the research objective is to determine the cognitive perception that customers have of the stimuli transmitted by influencers. The two-step theory proposes that influencers as opinion leaders have a stronger effect on the public than the media to a sense of trust and the virtual relationship people have with them. To fulfil the research objective set, the authors used description, analysis, synthesis, and inductive and deductive research methods as the research technique to measure the cognitive processing of stimuli published by social media influencers.
... In addition to this, it is stated that the influencers successfully transfer the information about a specific product or service, and they increase brand awareness. Jarrar et al. (2020) state that influencer marketing is very effective on immediate sales. ...
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effects of the influencers' perceived characteristics (informativeness, perceived ease of use, and admiration) on purchase intention and purchase behavior. The main population of this research is people who use social media and follow at least one influencer. IBM SPSS 20 and SmartPLS 3.3.3 package programs were used in the analysis. In the study, confirmatory factor analysis and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) analysis were performed to test the relationships in the proposed research model, respectively. As a result of the structural equation modeling analysis, it was found that informativeness, perceived ease of use, and admiration have significant and positive direct effects on purchase intention. In addition, informativeness, perceived ease of use, and admiration have significant and positive indirect effects on purchase behavior. The main contribution of this study to the literature is not only to explain the effects of informativeness, perceived ease of use, and admiration on purchase intention but also to comprehensively reveal the effects of these variables on both purchase intention and purchase behavior by considering them together in the context of influencer marketing.
Article
Full-text available
This article aims to identify and assess the factors that representatives of Generation Z in Poznań believe determine their entrepreneurial attitudes. Using a combination of literature analysis and a diagnostic survey of students at Poznań University of Economics, the study reveals how local socio-economic conditions and educational opportunities affect entrepreneurial aspirations. The results underscore the importance of tailoring educational and policy initiatives to the specific needs of young entrepreneurs in Poznań, emphasizing practical education, support for local business initiatives and the city's entrepreneurial heritage. The results provide deeper insight into the relationship between generational characteristics and the local context, while suggesting directions for further research, such as comparative analyses with other Polish cities to examine regional differences in entrepreneurial attitudes.
Article
Full-text available
Social media, a new dimension of marketing promotion mix, has made it possible for users to express their views about the companies, as well as their advertising. The purpose of this study was to test four hypotheses regarding the effects of young social media users’ attitude, behavioral response, and purchasing intention toward social media advertising in South Asian perspective. The study selected four popular social networking sites such as Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Google Plus which indicated the highest Asian visitor and surveyed with a structured questionnaire, asking respondents to mention their attitudinal views and responses about social media and social media advertising. The result identifies variation in predictors of users’ buying decision and provides some indications for using and developing social media platform for advertisement in the developing country and describes how to reach more user response in a regular time frame with the ultimate success of purchasing goal.
Article
Full-text available
The importance of measuring the accuracy and consistency of research instruments (especially questionnaires) known as validity and reliability, respectively, have been documented in several studies, but their measure is not commonly carried out among health and social science researchers in developing countries. This has been linked to the dearth of knowledge of these tests. This is a review article which comprehensively explores and describes the validity and reliability of a research instrument (with special reference to questionnaire). It further discusses various forms of validity and reliability tests with concise examples and finally explains various methods of analysing these tests with scientific principles guiding such analysis.
Book
We should always keep in mind that both technology experts and business managers are part of the society. Without understanding society, we cannot understand our clients and customers. But if a professional does not know that exactly how technology is related to the society and vice versa, he/she cannot devise technological systems that would benefit the society in the long run. Apparently, study of society and social sciences is not an imperative for a technical or management trainee. But in the age of social networks like Facebook and with increased public focus on topics like corporate social responsibility (CSR), it is not a good idea to neglect the social influence and importance of technology as a whole. Technological determinism can amply help us in developing an understanding on how society and technology interact. The basic framework of this theoretical paradigm has been constructed on the basis of Thorstein B. Veblen’s works. Although a strictly deterministic approach might damage the very target of this book, I have focused on the philosophical side of determinism. This has been done to provide a wholesome view of the debates that frequently arise while analyzing the relationships between technology and society. Although this book is primarily meant for sociology students, I have adopted an interdisciplinary approach. If a manager or technology expert wishes to work on socio-technical projects, this book can be helpful for them as well.
Article
Using the theory of consumer socialization, the authors explore factors that might shape attitudes toward advertising for African-American and Caucasian young adults. Though the African-American market is growing in importance to advertisers, little if any research has explored African-American perceptions of advertising. The theory of consumer socialization provides a conceptual framework for investigating variables that might influence attitudes toward advertising. African-American and Caucasian young adults were surveyed on various consumer socialization variables. Parental communication, peer communication, mass media, gender, and race were found to be related significantly to attitudes toward advertising. African-Americans watched more TV and had more positive attitudes toward advertising than their Caucasian counterparts.
Article
Attempts to determine which individual, or group of individuals, has the strongest influence on adolescent consumer purchase intentions and purchase behavior. By introducing the concepts of direct (fathers and mothers) and vicarious (favorite entertainers and favorite athletes) role models into the consumer behavior literature, the study allows greater understanding of the socialization patterns of young adult consumers. Results from this study provide significant contributions for marketing and advertising managers seeking to improve their understanding of the ever-growing adolescent consumer market.
Article
Purpose – The emerging new influencer community is wielding significant power over the perceptions of brands and companies, largely driven by the rapid expansion of social media channels through which influencers communicate. The “nobodies” of the past are now the new “somebodies” demanding the attention of communication professionals who seek continuous engagement with targeted consumers throughout the various channels of the social web. The purpose of this paper is to present a means of identifying these new “somebodies”. Design/methodology/approach – This paper reviews a customizable valuation algorithm created to identify the “new somebodies” who are the influencers creating a revitalized level of brand awareness for companies. The index valuation algorithm measures a cross‐section of variables that numerically rate influencers in the social media conversation about a particular company, product or service. Findings – This information helps us understand how these “somebodies” influence traditional target audiences, and help communications professionals establish effective outreach strategies. Integrating the influencer index data into a holistic social media strategy provides a comprehensive social media approach for optimizing brand equity. Originality/value – The index identifies the “conversation points” that should guide engagement with each individual influencer, determining aspects such as subject and tone, and identifies these influencers.
Increased Consumerism in a Networked-Nigeria: A Study on the Effect of E-Malls and Social Media on Youth Spending
  • A O Awobamise
AWOBAMISE, AO (2018). "Increased Consumerism in a Networked-Nigeria: A Study on the Effect of E-Malls and Social Media on Youth Spending." Journal of Digital Media & Interaction, 1(2), pp.40-55.
Top 10 trends that will transform digital
  • K Harrison
HARRISON, K (2017). Top 10 trends that will transform digital marketing in 2017.