ArticlePDF Available

Effect of Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) on Academic Performance: Evidence from Students Of Science VI

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This study was conducted in Doos Sur Elementary School, Hindang, Leyte, Philippines within the school year 2017-2018 to assess the effectiveness of Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) on academic performance in science among grade VI students. It utilized the pretest-posttest quasi-experimental design. The SIM used as a treatment of the study covered one of the least mastered skills in the Science VI, that is, describing the appearance and uses of homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures. The study employed 20 students for control group and 20 students for experimental group enrolled in Science VI during the first quarter. Control group was taught with conventional teaching method and the experimental group was taught with SIM. Through hypothesis testing, this study determined the significant effect of SIM to students' academic performance. Results of the study showed that the use of SIM is effective in terms of improving students' performance particularly on the topic pertaining to the least mastered skills in Science VI. This implies that SIM can be utilized as instructional materials during learning process as effective teaching tool.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Review of Socio-Economic Research and Development Studies 2020
Volume 4 No. 1, 20-32
EFFECT OF STRATEGIC INTERVENTION
MATERIAL (SIM) ON ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE:
EVIDENCE FROM STUDENTS OF SCIENCE VI
Michael G. Suarez1 and Leomarich F. Casinillo2
*
1Doos Sur Elementary School, Hindang Leyte, Philippines
2Visayas State University, Visca, Baybay City, Leyte, Philippines
This study was conducted in Doos Sur Elementary School, Hindang, Leyte,
Philippines within the school year 2017-2018 to assess the effectiveness of Strategic
Intervention Material (SIM) on academic performance in science among grade VI students.
It utilized the pretest-posttest quasi-experimental design. The SIM used as a treatment of
the study covered one of the least mastered skills in the Science VI, that is, describing the
appearance and uses of homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures. The study employed
20 students for control group and 20 students for experimental group enrolled in Science
VI during the first quarter. Control group was taught with conventional teaching method
and the experimental group was taught with SIM. Through hypothesis testing, this study
determined the significant effect of SIM to students’ academic performance. Results of the
study showed that the use of SIM is effective in terms of improving students’ performance
particularly on the topic pertaining to the least mastered skills in Science VI. This implies
that SIM can be utilized as instructional materials during learning process as effective
teaching tool.
Keywords: Strategic Intervention Materials, quasi-experimental design, Academic
Performance, Science VI
1. INTRODUCTION
Teaching at any level requires that the students be exposed to some form
of stimulation or intervention to improve learners’ academic achievement (Abad,
2005; Abdo & Semela, 2010; Adewale, 2014; Ogbondah, 2008). Okobia (2011) noted
that teaching resources means anything that can assist the teacher in promoting
*
Corresponding author: Leomarich F. Casinillo, Visayas State University, Visca, Baybay City, Leyte,
Philippines. Email: leomarich_casinillo@yahoo.com
EFFECT OF STRATEGIC INVERVENTION MATERIAL ON ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
21
teaching and learning. When the students are given the chance to learn through
more senses than one, they can learn faster and easier. This was in contrast with
current setting in Doos Sur Elementary School (DSES), Hindang Leyte, Philippines
wherein students had difficulty in understanding the concepts and low
performance was visualized and least mastered competencies were visible.
According to Casinillo (2019) and Casinillo et al. (2020), there are some factors
affecting their learning experiences that leads to low academic performance. In
the study of Govindaraju and Venkatesan (2010), poor teaching strategy,
difficulties in learning and low performance results to school drop-outs. Hence,
strategic intervention must be implemented to develop students’ interest and
progress their level of achievement.
This study was conducted in DSES, an elementary public school of
Department of Education (DepEd), Leyte Division. In DSES, intermediate science
teachers found it demanding to understand pupils not to grasp the lesson and
incapable to master the competency being taught. As related by some Science
teachers in this institution, they would no longer provide further activities since
many students had failed to absorb the lesson all the time even if they prepared
ample of drills and activities to elevate its academic success yet it was far from
reality. Dr. Frank Yui as cited by Barredo and Joan (2014) in a speech once said
“Rich countries are science-rich and poor countries are science-poor.” This
statement posed a challenge to all educators to improve the teaching-learning
process especially in science. Furthermore, science is the backbone of the
development of a country and a country with a majority of science illiterates is a
poor country (Abdo & Semela, 2010).
Arisi (1998) and Bunagan (2012) defined Strategic Intervention Material as
meant to re-teach the concepts and skills (least mastered). It is a material given to
students to help them master competency -based skills which they were not able
to develop during a regular classroom teaching. It consists of both learning
strategies (for students) and content enhancement (for teachers). It is a
multifaceted approach to help students to become independent and successful
learners (Jotia & Matlale, 2011; Okobia, 2011). This intervention material focuses
on the skill not mastered by the students during regular class. It does not involve
pretest and posttest, however it includes fun activities. Module, on the other hand,
contained different topics included in a given chapter and intended for regular
classroom teaching and distance learning. Module requires pretest and posttest,
and also includes fun activities.
Seeing that these students faced a much more different learning activities
in primary grades and yet achieved below from what was expected of them, they
MICHAEL G. SUAREZ and LEOMARICH F. CASINILLO
22
should be given proper intervention and strategy to address these perennial
problems. Subsequently it is the teachers’ accountability to give enhancement to
such insufficiency, they should find means to recuperate the least mastered skills
committed by pupils so that they can become adequately prepared for national-
building (Okobia, 2011). Hence, SIM is intended as intervention in a regular class
to facilitate the least mastered topics in Science class.
At present, in the Philippine education system, intervention materials are
highly regarded as tools for remediating poor achievements of the learners. SIM
or Strategic Intervention Material refers to a teaching aid introduced into the
teaching methods to stimulate the activity of the students and thereby increased
their level of understanding (Dy, 2011). It is strategically prepared and designed
for teaching remediation for low achievers in the subject. It is given after the
regular classroom instruction to students who were not able to grasp the concepts
of the subject matter.
The Trends in Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) revealed
unsatisfactory results, the Philippines ranked 41st in Math and 42nd in Science out
of 47 countries that were tested for grade 8 students (Gonzales et al., 2003). This
proved that vast majority of Filipino students have performed way below par in
all national achievement tests, and below the levels of most students from other
countries in the international tests. Thus, education managers must focus on
reforming and delivering quality instruction so that the Basic Education
Curriculum will not be overwhelmed by the crisis. Students must be provided
with maximum opportunities to become functionally literate in science through
strategic intervention. The Department of Education as noted by Luz (2017) data
showed that for every 100 children who enter Grade 1, close or about 15 do not
make it into Grade 2, and roughly one-quarter (24 percent) have dropped out
before Grade 6. It is for these reasons that the researcher embarks on developing
strategic intervention materials in Science for Grade 6 students that enhanced
learning and remedy the least mastered skills of the students, thus attain growth
in their academic performance.
Strategic Intervention Material, an instructional material for remediation
purposes is one of the solutions employed by the Department of Education
(DepEd) to enhance academic achievements of students performing low in the
field of science and technology. DepEd Memorandum No. 117 section 2005 stated
that the National Training on Strategic Intervention Materials (SIM) Development
in summer 2005 was implemented (Abad, 2005). The training workshop aimed to
enhance teachers’ skill in test analysis and interpretation and capacitate them in
developing various intervention materials for remediation and enrichment of
EFFECT OF STRATEGIC INVERVENTION MATERIAL ON ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
23
learning. As part of intensifying and developing strategic intervention materials
as tool for remediating poor performance in Science. The Department of Education
included the SIM making as one of the contests during science fairs in school,
division, regional, and national level competitions. This is supported in a studies
of Jotia and Matlale (2011) and Popoola (1990) who investigated the effect of
instructional resources on the academic achievements of students. It is found out
that inadequate material resources have negative effect on the academic
performance of the students on how well a student is accomplishing his or her task
and studies, it also determines the level and quality of students.
Innumerable strategies had been developed in the past to solve problem
in academic performance in Science, however the problems still exist at present.
This study, therefore hoped to contribute knowledge in relation to students poor
academic status by trying the effect of Strategic Intervention Materials to enhance
and give remedy on the least mastered skills. Being the center on the teaching-
learning process, science teachers must equip every pupil with the necessary
scientific skills that helped them perform in the different learning areas in the
curriculum. Effective and efficient instruction benefited all pupils but it’s
imperative for teachers to use sound strategies that enhanced the scientific
competence of learners. These were the very reasons why the researcher ventured
in this study. The researcher chose grade 6 students among the other grade levels
because they were supposed to be armed with the necessary skills to become
successful in school and in preparation for their academic and scientific activities
in higher grades. Grade 6 students were viewed to be in a better position as
participants considering the range of experience they have taken and their level of
maturity compared to lower years. Furthermore, these students were also
expected to participate more seriously.
Research Questions
This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of Strategic Intervention
Material (SIM) in improving the academic performance of students in Science VI.
Specifically, the study attempted to answer the following questions:
1. What is the level of students’ academic performance on the topic
describing the appearance and uses of homogeneous and heterogeneous
mixtures on the control and experimental groups before and after the
utilization of SIM?
2. Is there a significant mean difference between the students’ academic
performance on the topic describing the appearance and uses of
MICHAEL G. SUAREZ and LEOMARICH F. CASINILLO
24
homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures on the control and
experimental groups before and after the utilization of SIM?
Statement of Hypothesis
𝐻𝑜: There is no significant mean difference between the class without and with
SIM.
𝐻𝑎: There is a significant mean difference between the class without and with SIM.
2. METHODOLOGY
The Respondents and Ethical Procedure
Prior to the conduct of the study, the permission of the school principal of
Doos Sur Elementary School (DSES) was asked through a formal letter. Next, the
permission of the two science teacher was also asked to cooperate in the said study.
This study was conducted after the first grading period of school year 2017-2018.
Currently, there are only two sections of grade six students in DSES. Hence, by
complete enumeration, this study utilized 40 grade six students who enrolled in
DSES in order to gather richer information. In this manner, Grade Six under of
Science Teacher A would be the experimental group composed of 20 students
taught with SIM while Grade Six under the Science Teacher B would be the control
group composed of 20 students taught in traditional instruction. Table 1 shows the
distribution of participants and its gender.
Table 1. Distribution of Participants
Sections
No. of
Males
No. of
Females
Total
Teaching
Method Used
Experimental Group
13
7
20
With SIM
Control group
11
9
20
Without SIM
This research study was purely academic in nature and no sensitive
information was gathered from the students, hence, parents’ consent was not
needed. However, the participation of this study was voluntary. Furthermore,
before the conduct of the study, teachers and students were assured that all
information gathered were treated with confidentiality and solely used for this
study only.
EFFECT OF STRATEGIC INVERVENTION MATERIAL ON ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
25
Data Collection Procedure
The pretest-posttest quasi-experimental design was employed to carry out
this study. Classes were grouped into two such as the experimental and control
group. After the conduct of first quarterly test and identification of least mastered
competencies, pre-test was administered. Subsequently, item analysis was done in
order to determine what competencies were the least mastered. The least mastered
competencies were used as bases for constructing the SIM as an intervention
material, that is, the topic describing the appearance and uses of homogeneous
and heterogeneous mixtures.” The construction of SIM is grounded on the study
of Abad (2005) and Luz (2017). In ensuring the appropriateness of SIM, there were
three kinds of content validity executed: the Guide on Reviewing or Judging the
SIM, the Learning Resources Management and Development System (LRMDS)
educational soundness general evaluation checklists and LRMDS specification
and guidelines for intellectual property rights management. Master Teachers in
DSES validated the content if it anchored on the DepEd’s guidelines on reviewing
the SIM. The LRMDS district coordinators which comprised of principals with the
help of LRMDS division coordinator and its technical working group gave content
validity of the SIM. Thereafter was the conduct of SIM for two weeks in a 50-
minute intensive intervention for experimental group. The students were properly
guided on how to use the said materials during lectures. On the other hand, 50-
minute conventional or traditional way of teaching was implemented for control
group daily. After the treatment, both sections were given posttest. This was the
basis in determining the academic performance of the students.
Data Analysis
The data gathered in this study were tabulated, treated, analyzed and
used as bases for interpretation. Standard statistical procedures and formula were
used to arrive at a reliable conclusion. The researcher used Mean, Standard
deviation, Minimum, Maximum value, Mean Percentage Score (MPS) as statistical
treatment to process the data and to arrive at descriptive interpretation of each
item in the instrument. Paired t-test and Independent t-test was employed to
compare the two mean scores after the implementation of SIM. Table 2
summarizes the research questions and data analysis of this research study.
MICHAEL G. SUAREZ and LEOMARICH F. CASINILLO
26
Table 2. Research Questions and Data Analysis
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
This presents, analyzes and interprets the data gathered by the researcher
from the responses of the questionnaires distributed to the research subjects and
from the result of examinations conducted. These include the following:
1. The level of pupils’ academic performance on the topic describing the
appearance and uses of homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures on the
control and experimental groups before and after the utilization of SIM.
2. The significant mean difference between the pupils’ academic
performance on the topic describing the appearance and uses of
homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures on the control and
experimental groups before and after the utilization of SIM.
The data gathered were organized and statistically treated to answer the
specific questions of this study. These were presented in series of tables sequenced
according to specific questions raised in this research. Discussion include the
description, analysis and interpretation of data.
Descriptive Analysis of Academic Performance
Table 3 presents the statistical data on the level of achievement before the
integration of SIM. These data provide the mean score and MPS of the learners in
the class who had individually undertaken the pretest intended to measure their
academic achievements in Science. From the above data, respondents in Grade Six-
Teacher A registered an MPS of 32% while Grade Six- Teacher B had an MPS of
Research Questions
1. What is the level of students’ academic performance on the
topic describing the appearance and uses of homogeneous and
heterogeneous mixtures on the control and experimental
groups before and after the utilization of SIM?
2. Is there a significant mean difference between the students’
academic performance on the topic describing the appearance
and uses of homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures
experimental groups before and after the utilization of SIM?
3. Is there a significant mean difference between the students’
academic performance on the topic “describing the appearance
and uses of homogeneous and heterogeneous mixtures” on the
control and experimental groups after the utilization of SIM?
EFFECT OF STRATEGIC INVERVENTION MATERIAL ON ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
27
23.25% which did not meet the national standard of 75% proficiency level
attributed to any of the subject areas. On the average, Grade Six-Teacher A scored
better compared to Grade Six-Teacher B hence Teacher A had a mean score of 6.40
compared to Teacher B which registered to 4.65. Section Teacher A recorded a
standard deviation at 2.26 while section Teacher B posted 1.98 which implies that
Teacher B had more consistent scores compared to Teacher A. Generally, both
sections got alarming results thus, intervention was needed to uplift its academic
performance. The findings were supported in a studies of Jotia and Matlale (2011)
and Popoola (1990) who found out that inadequate material resources have
negative effect on the academic performance of the pupils on how well a student
is accomplishing his or her task and studies, it also determines the level and
quality of students.
Table 3. The level of students’ academic performance on the control and
experimental groups before the utilization of SIM.
Note: Total item score is 20.
From the presented data, respondents in Section Teacher A had the
highest score of 20 while Section Teacher B is 12 (Table 4). Standard deviation
shows that the scores in the posttest are more scattered around its respective mean
from the posttest in both sections of (Teacher A: 2.26; Teacher B: 1.66). Respondents
in Section Teacher A got an MPS of 92.25% (mean: 18.45) compared to Section
Teacher B posted an MPS of 51.50 (mean: 10.30). This infers that Section Teacher A
which used strategic intervention materials had a higher MPS compared to Section
Teacher B which did not use strategic intervention materials. With the
implementation of SIM, the MPS of the respondents exposed to it had greatly
improved while those who were not had a slight increase in their MPS. This means
that students taught with SIM performed better and scored higher than those
taught without SIM. Findings of this study confirm in the studies conducted by
Inyang-Abia (1992), Özdem Yilmaz et al., (2017) and Dy (2011) that strategic
intervention materials are highly regarded as tools for remediating poor
achievements of the learners. SIM or Strategic Intervention Material refers to a
teaching aid introduced into the teaching methods to stimulate the activity of the
Section
Pre-test
N
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Minimum
Score
Maximum
Score
MPS
(%)
Teacher
A
Experimental
20
6.40
2.26
2
9
32%
Teacher
B
Control
20
4.65
1.98
1
8
23.25%
MICHAEL G. SUAREZ and LEOMARICH F. CASINILLO
28
students and thereby increased their level of understanding. Bunagan (2012) also
supported the findings which defined SIM as meant to re-teach the concepts and
skills (least mastered). It is a material given to students to help them master
competency-based skills which they were not able to develop during a regular
classroom teaching.
Table 4. The level of pupils’ academic performance on the control and
experimental groups after the utilization of SIM.
Note: Total item score is 20.
Effectiveness of Strategic Intervention Material (SIM)
The statistical computation of data as presented in Table 5 exposed the
significance of results of the pretest and posttest undertaken by the grade 6 classes
with the implementation of SIM. Also, it presents the significant difference
between the control and experimental group. The computation result indicated the
t-test for paired samples results to a t-value of Section Teacher A posted 21.18 and
a p-value of <0.001 (Table 5). This means that the difference between the posttest
and pretest is significant and implies that SIM is effective tool in teaching. In the
same table, it is also shown that the computed t-value and p-value of experimental
and control group after implementation of SIM are 11.98 and 0.001, respectively,
using independent T-test (Table 5). The p-value is less than the level of significance
(p<0.01), therefore, the difference between the mean scores in the experimental
post-test and control post-test is highly significant (Table 5). It follows that the
mean score in the experimental group is significantly larger compared to the
control group. The result is parallel to the existing studies in literature (Arisi, 1998;
Barredo & Joan, 2014; Bunagan, 2012; Jotia & Matlale, 2011; Popoola, 1990). It
implies that the implementation of SIM is effective at 1% level of significance. This
further means that the performance of the students positively responds to the
utilization of SIM. This is supported to the study of Bete (2020) that using SIM can
elevate the science instruction and students’ academic performances
Section
Posttest
N
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Minimum
Score
Maximum
Score
MPS
(%)
Teacher
A
Experimental
20
18.45
2.26
16
20
92.25%
Teacher
B
Control
20
10.30
1.66
6
12
51.50%
EFFECT OF STRATEGIC INVERVENTION MATERIAL ON ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
29
Table 5: T-test for pretest and posttest score of students in the utilization of SIM
under the experimental and control group.
Variables
Independent T-test
(Computed Value)
df
p-value
Experimental Group
(Pretest vs Posttest)
21.18**
19
<0.001
Control vs Experimental Group
(Posttest vs Posttest)
11.98**
19
<0.001
Note: ** - highly significant at 1% level.
4. CONCLUSION
This study was conducted to evaluate the effect of Strategic Intervention
Material (SIM) to pupil’s academic performance in Doos Sur Elementary School,
Hindang, Leyte, Philippines within the school year 2017-2018. Results showed that
experimental group performs better than control group based on their post-test
results. Hence, it is concluded that SIM is effective teaching strategy to improve
the level of achievement of students on the least mastered topics in Science.
Conclusively, SIM should be used in teaching Science subject to increase the
academic performance and address the studentsdifficult topics to be mastered.
Apparently, SIM assists students to develop the fundamental knowledge, skills
and understanding in least mastered topics in science and effective aid in
imparting information to students. It is also concluded that by the implementation
of SIM, the school administration and teachers should able to maintain and enrich
the provision of activities so that the students will have the chance to learn new
ideas in harnessing their scientific skills. Thus, teachers should be given room for
improvement and further elevate to a higher level of SIM implementation to
further meet the desired instructional objectives.
It is highly recommended that science teachers can use strategic
intervention materials made by the researcher to re-teach the concepts and skills
and help the pupils master the competency-based skill. Generally, the Department
of Education should include the Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) in the
teaching of Science concepts and principles as part of the Science curriculum in all
levels of basic education and same innovative teaching strategy should be adopted
in all subjects. Curriculum planners should develop SIM based on the sequence of
competencies of the curriculum and ensure that these are provided to all schools
in all subjects. While implementing the SIM, the teachers should conduct item
analysis in every quarterly test so that the teachers can identify the most-learned
and the least-learned skills of the students. One of the limitation of this study is
MICHAEL G. SUAREZ and LEOMARICH F. CASINILLO
30
the small sample size which leads to the possibility that T-test result will be
insignificant. Hence, further studies on the use of SIM as aids in teaching should
be conducted with a large sample size of students. Furthermore, seminars and in-
service trainings should be conducted in the division level regarding development
and implementation of the SIMs which were not included in the researchers’ SIM.
5. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors would like to acknowledge the reviewers for the rigorous
review, suggestions and comments for the improvement of this paper.
6. REFERENCES
Abad, F. B. (2005). Training Workshop on Strategic Interventions for Succesful Learning.
Department of Education. Retrieved July 11, 2017, from
http://nlpdl.nlp.gov.ph:81/DE02/Memoranda/DE00M2005/DE02M020050
117.pdf
Abdo, M. and Semela, T. (2010). Teachers of poor communities: The tale of
instructional media in primary schools of Gedeo zone, Southern Ethiopia.
Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 35(7), 78-92.
Adewale, O. S. (2014). Instructional Improvement of Secondary School Teachers
through Effective Academic Supervision by the Vice-Principals. Journal of
Education and Human Development, 3(2), 607-617.
Arisi, R. O. (1998). The use of instructional materials by Social Studies teachers in
secondary schools in Oredo local government area of Edo State. Journal of
Social Studies, 1(1), 76.
Barredo, K., & Joan, K. (2014). Development on academic performance in science using
strategic intervention material. Retrieved from
http://www.classroom20.com/profiles/blogs/strategic-intervention-
materials-in-science
Bete, A. O. (2020). Students’ knowledge and process skills in learning grade-8
chemistry. Journal of Research, Policy & Practice of Teachers and Teacher
Education, 10(1), 1-13.
Bunagan, F. (2012). Strategic Intervention Material. Retrieved June 12, 2017, from
https://www.slideshare.net/felixbunagan/strategic-intervention-aterial
Casinillo, L. F. (2019). Factors affecting the failure rate in mathematics: the case of
Visayas State University (VSU). Review of Socio-Economic Research and
Development Studies, 3(1), 1-18.
EFFECT OF STRATEGIC INVERVENTION MATERIAL ON ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
31
Casinillo, L. F., Camulte, M. C. G., Raagas, D. L. & Riña, T. S. (2020). Cultural
factors in learning mathematics: the case on achievement level among
Badjao students. International Journal of Indonesian Education and Teaching,
4(1), 71-81.
Conroy, R. (2015). Sample size: A rough guide. Retreived from
http://www.beaumontethics. ie/docs/application/samplesizecalculation.
Dumigsi, M. P. & Cabrella, J. B. B. (2019). Effectiveness of Strategic Intervention
Material in Mathematics as Remediation for Grade 9 Students in Solving
Problems Involving Quadratic Functions. Asian Journal of Education and
Social Studies, 5(1), 1-10.
Dy L. (2011). Teaching mathematics through Strategic Intervention Materials (SIM).
Retrieved from http://jhody.hubpages.coom/hub/
Gonzales, P., Guzmán, J.C., Partelow, L., Pahlke, E., Jocelyn, L., Kastberg, D., and
Williams, T. (2004). Highlights from the Trends in International Mathematics
and Science Study (TIMSS) 2003 (NCES 2005-005). U.S. Department of
Education. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics.
Retrieved from https://nces.ed.gov/timss/pdf/naep_timss_pisa_comp.pdf
Govindaraju, R. & Venkatesan, S. (2010). A study on school drop-outs in rural
settings. Journal of Psychology, 1(1), 47-53.
Inyang-Abia, M. E. (1992). Cultural dimension in curriculum materials: A study of
longman Social Studies series for junior secondary classes. Nigerian journal
of Social Studies review, 1, 96 103.
Jotia, A. L. and Matlale, O. J. (2011). Use of instructional materials in social studies:
Impact on students’ performance in primary school leaving certificate
examinations in Botswana. European Journal of Educational Studies, 3(1),
111-122.
Luz, J. M. (2017). Brigada Eskwela: Essays on Philippine Education. Anvil Publishing,
Inc. Philippines.
Ogbondah, L. (2008). An appraisal of instructional materials used to educate
Migrant Fishermen’s children in Rivers State, Nigeria. International Journal
of Scientific Research in Education, 1(1), 13-25.
Okobia, E. O. (2011). Availability and teachers' use of instructional materials and
resources in the implementation of social studies in junior secondary
schools in Edo State, Nigeria. Rev. Eur. Stud., 3(2), 90-97.
Özdem Yilmaz, Y., Cakiroglu, J., Ertepinar, H., & Erduran, S. (2017). The pedagogy
of argumentation in science education: science teachers’ instructional
practices. International Journal of Science Education, 39(11), 1443-1464.
MICHAEL G. SUAREZ and LEOMARICH F. CASINILLO
32
Popoola,T. A. (1990). An investigation into the relationship between instructional
resources and students’ academic performance in secondary schools in Abeokuta,
Ogun State, Nigeria. An unpublished MEd Thesis.
... SIMs have shown success in improving student learning across various subjects, enhancing comprehension, retention, and academic performance. For example, Lazo and de Guzman (2021) and Suarez and Casinillo (2020) found SIMs beneficial in diverse educational contexts, while Cagape et al. (2023) and Calaranan & Corpuz (2023) demonstrated their positive impact on learning outcomes in subjects like science and social studies. These findings highlight the adaptability and efficacy of SIMs in addressing educational challenges. ...
... denoting excellence in clarity and logical structure, which are essential for effective learning. The thoughtful presentation and organization of the SIM contribute significantly to its effectiveness as a teaching tool, enhancing students' learning experiences (Suarez & Casinillo, 2020). Finally, in terms of accuracy and up-to-datedness, the SIM obtained a mean score of 4.57 (SD=0.626), ...
Article
Full-text available
Calculus is a foundational discipline critical for both academic and professional growth. This study, conducted at a state college in Davao de Oro, Philippines, sought to develop Strategic Intervention Materials (SIMs) to address key challenges in Calculus I. Utilizing a developmental research design, the study followed a modified ADD model comprising three stages: analysis, design, and development. Participants included 44 prospective mathematics teachers, selected through random sampling, and five experts in mathematics education and instructional material development. Data collection involved a survey to identify the least mastered topics and validation sheets. The study identified specific areas of difficulty, including Maxima and Minima, Derivatives of Logarithmic and Exponential Functions, Functions with Arguments Approaching Infinity, Derivatives of Inverse Trigonometric Functions, Antiderivatives of Algebraic Functions, and the Constant of Integration. The resulting SIMs were evaluated and demonstrated outstanding content validity, face validity, clarity of presentation, logical organization, accuracy, and relevance. Calculus instructors are encouraged to integrate these SIMs into their curriculum to enhance student understanding in these challenging areas. The study further recommends that calculus teachers employ varied, research-based methodologies to effectively bridge learning gaps in calculus, ultimately fostering a more comprehensive grasp of fundamental calculus concepts.
... Research on SIMs suggests their effectiveness in improving student performance in mathematics. For instance, studies have shown that SIMs can significantly enhance students' understanding and retention of complex topics such as fractions, a crucial area often utilized in higher mathematics (Suarez et al., 2020). ...
... It implies that the null hypothesis was rejected and there was a significant difference between the pretest and posttest mean score of the experimental group in Logic. The results were supported by Suarez et al., (2020), that SIM was effective in terms of improving students' performance particularly on the topic pertaining to the least mastered skills. SIM can be utilized as instructional materials during the learning process as an effective teaching tool. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study aims to develop a SIM (Strategic Intervention Material) using problem-based learning or approach in improving least mastered mathematical skills of tertiary education students in Mathematics in the Modern World. This study also aims to prove that using SIM in teaching is more effective than the traditional way of teaching. This study made use of True Experimental Design. A total of 95 students of Camarines Sur Polytechnic Colleges who were enrolled in Mathematics in the Modern World served as the respondents of the study. Percentage, mean and t-tests were used as tools in the Analysis of data.
... To ensure the effective utilization of the developed SIMs, schools must prioritize providing teachers with adequate training and support. This aligns with the findings of Casinillo [15], who emphasizes the crucial role of teacher training in maximizing the impact of SIMs. At the individual level, teachers can leverage the SIMs to target identified learning gaps and address specific student needs. ...
... Adapting and modifying the SIMs to fit their teaching style and classroom context further personalizes the learning experience. Finally, continuous monitoring of student progress and adjustments to instructional strategies as needed allow teachers to optimize the use of the SIMs for improved student outcomes [15]. Table 2 presents the validation of the experts on the content of the SIM for two (2) try outs. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study aimed to address the persistent challenges of low student mastery in Grade 7 Biology by constructing and validating a Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) titled "Mission poCELLble" – Cellular Structure and Function. The development process was driven by the urgency to provide targeted support for students struggling with key concepts in cellular biology. A Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) for grade seven biology was the main objective of this study. The SIM was meticulously crafted based on the identified least mastered skills and the Department of Education's standard criteria for SIM construction. This research followed the input-process-output model of developing instructional material, utilizing two sets of questionnaires: one set for five identified experts and one for teacher and student users, each containing 19 statements tailored to their respective roles. Data analysis informed the construction of the SIMs, including identifying least mastered skills, assessing student-teacher agreement with the Kappa Measure, and measuring expert and readability levels with Cronbach's alpha and Flesh-Kincaid Reading Ease.The results revealed that the SIM content, pedagogical and technical aspects were “very evident” as rated by the experts. The internal consistency between responses are rated as “good”. These findings suggest the potential of the "Mission poCELLble" SIM as a valuable tool for intervention purposes in Grade 7 Biology classrooms. Further research is recommended to assess the SIM's effectiveness in improving student learning outcomes.
... The findings of Suarez and Casinillo (2020) are similarly disconcerting. Hence, the intervention material was required to improve the students' academic performance. ...
... Students' performance improves when SIM is used, according to Suarez and Casinillo (2020). Results from studies by Diaz and Dio (2017) and Lazaro (2018) show that using a SIM improves students' performance compared to using a conventional textbook. ...
Article
Full-text available
In response to the pressing need for innovative educational approaches, this research investigates the implementation of SIMULE to evaluate its impact on the conceptual understanding and procedural fluency of Grade 7 students. This study focused on utilizing SIMULE as an instructional resource in improving the conceptual understanding and procedural fluency of Grade 7 students at Lambayong National High School, School Year 2023-2024. A total of 89 students were the respondents of the study. Respondents were selected through purposive sampling and grouped using simple random sampling. This study employed a quasi-experimental design. The data were gathered using the researcher-made pretest and posttest. Mean and standard deviation determined the student's concept fluency level and procedural understanding. T-test was used to determine the significant difference between the two groups' pretest and posttest scores and the mean gain scores. The study revealed that both groups had little mastery of the topics before the conduct of the study. In the posttest, both groups improved their conceptual understanding and procedural fluency. It revealed that using SIMULE and conventional teaching can help students improve their conceptual understanding and procedural fluency. However, students exposed to SIMULE performed better than those exposed to traditional teaching. Further, the learning gains were significantly higher in favor of the students exposed to SIMULE. Thus, the study recommended using SIMULE as an intervention material to improve students' conceptual understanding and procedural fluency.
... Designed to reteach and reinforce concepts that students find difficult, SIMs are tailored resources that address individual learning needs, fostering independent and successful learning (Peñaflor, 2019;Jotia & Matlale, 2011;Bunagan, 2012). Research has consistently shown the effectiveness of SIMs in improving academic performance, conceptual understanding, and scientific attitudes (Bastida & Bastida, 2022;Suarez & Casinillo, 2020;Zahara et al., 2018). Additionally, incorporating real-world applications into SIMs enhances student engagement by making lessons more relevant and meaningful, as supported by studies emphasising the benefits of contextualised and interactive learning experiences (Hulleman & Harackiewicz, 2009;Semilarski et al., 2021). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study used a quasi-experimental pretest-posttest design with non-equivalent groups to assess the effectiveness of a Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) incorporating interactive real-world scenarios on secondary school chemistry performance. Eighth-grade students from a rural public secondary school in southern Nueva Vizcaya, Philippines, participated, with the experimental group receiving the SIM intervention and the control group receiving traditional classroom instruction. The findings demonstrated significant improvement in posttest scores among students exposed to SIM integrated with real-world scenarios, contrasting with minimal gains observed in students taught through conventional methods. These results highlight the effectiveness of integrating real-world contexts into educational materials to enhance student engagement and comprehension of complex chemistry concepts. The findings underscore the importance of incorporating real-world scenarios into educational strategies to optimise learning outcomes in secondary school chemistry. Educators are encouraged to adopt innovative teaching approaches that stimulate active engagement and practical and contextualised application of knowledge to enhance student academic achievement.
... Additionally, statistical knowledge is essential in research and public discussions, where it is used to bolster arguments or counter certain issues (Allchin & Zemplén, 2020). The teaching and learning of probability and statistics have gained increasing importance in higher education institutions due to the current demand for welltrained professionals (Suarez & Casinillo, 2020). While statistics and mathematics share similarities, they involve different cognitive processes. ...
Article
Full-text available
Statistics and probability enabled students to better understand, process, and evaluate massive amounts of quantitative data that existed and had a probabilistic sense in uncertain situations. The research article aimed to elucidate the performance and self-efficacy as predictors of students' achievement in the statistics and probability courses. The study utilized a descriptive-predictive research method and was conducted at Sto. Tomas National High School, involving a sample of 263 grade 11 senior high school students. The gathered data were analyzed using descriptive measures and multiple regression analysis. The study's results revealed that the performance in General Mathematics was very satisfactory, while self-efficacy was high. Moreover, the level of achievement in Statistics and Probability was very satisfactory. It was also revealed that both General Mathematics performance and self-efficacy had a positive and significant relationship with Statistics and Probability achievement. Through regression analysis, it was discovered that General Mathematics performance was the strongest predictor that influenced achievement in Statistics and Probability. The study identified a significant predictive model for Statistics and Probability achievement. These findings could provide valuable guidance to teachers in enhancing the achievement of senior high school students in Statistics and Probability.
... Teachers may give students Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) materials to assist them in mastering competency-based skills that they were not able to acquire during scheduled classroom instruction. These materials include content enhancement for teachers as well as learning strategies for students (Suarez & Casinillo, 2020). It is a comprehensive strategy to assist students in becoming successful and self-sufficient. ...
Article
Full-text available
The research examines how Strategic Intervention Material affects the Academic Achievement of Biology Students in Senior Secondary Schools within Epe Local Government Area, Lagos state. The study uses a pre-test, post-test control group quasi-experimental design with a 2x2 factorial matrix. The sample size consists of 239 SSII students from public co-education secondary schools in the study area. Four schools were randomly selected, with two schools each assigned to the experimental and control groups. The research instruments include the Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) in biology, a lesson plan, and a 20-item multiple-choice biology achievement test (BAT), which was subjected to thorough face and content validity and had a reliability coefficient of 0.82 using the Kuder-Richardson 21 formula. Three hypotheses were formulated to guide the study and were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics of the t-test. The study found a significant main effect of the strategy on the academic achievement of biology students. Students who were exposed to the use of the strategic intervention material package obtained significantly higher mean scores than their counterparts in the conventional group. The study also found no significant difference between the mean achievement scores of male and female students exposed to the SIM package. It is recommended that SIM should be incorporated into teacher education programs in tertiary institutions to educate teachers in training about its importance and use, and seminars, conferences, and workshops should be organized for in-service secondary school teachers to train them in the knowledge and skills of its effective use to enhance student academic achievement in biology.
... The experimental group received a targeted intervention. Perhaps this intervention was effective but not dramatically so, resulting in only a slight improvement [9]. Table 5 shows the mean gain scores of the control and experimental group. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study investigates the effectiveness of laboratory-based instruction in conveying fundamental concepts related to the relative density and buoyancy of liquids within a secondary laboratory science program at a leading university in Mindanao. Despite the challenges posed by digital technology and remote learning, traditional laboratory experiments remain integral to science education, providing active, hands-on learning experiences. The primary focus is to assess the impact of laboratory instruction on student performance according to these principles. Our findings reveal a significant improvement in the performance of students in the experimental group. Notable enhancements were observed between pre-tests and post-tests, with statistical significance established at α = 0.05. This underscores the substantial role of laboratory-based instruction in augmenting student performance. Additionally, when comparing final grades as an independent variable, we find that the laboratory teaching method significantly contributes to overall effectiveness in student learning. Furthermore, students’ positive perceptions of the subject and their attitudes toward both the laboratory and the subject matter emerged as significant contributors to performance improvements. Consequently, this enhanced likelihood of achieving better grades in physics highlights the broader impact of laboratory-based instruction on student academic outcomes.
Article
Despite the growing integration of digital learning tools in science education, research on their comparative impact remains limited. The quasi-experimental design involved 32 Grade 9 students from Candaping National High School, Candaping B, Maria, Siquijor, who were grouped based on their prior Science performance. Participants were divided into two groups: one receiving CAI-based instruction and the other utilizing SIMs. Pre-test and post-test scores were analyzed using mean, standard deviation, and t-tests for dependent and independent data to measure learning gains. Results indicate that students exposed to CAI demonstrated a 14.00% improvement, while those using SIMs showed a 12.33% increase. Statistical analysis revealed a significant difference (p < 0.05), suggesting that CAI was more effective in fostering conceptual understanding. These findings demonstrate the potential of CAI to transform science education by utilizing technology to enhance learning outcomes in complex topics like photosynthesis and cellular respiration while highlighting the effectiveness of both CAI and SIMs in bridging learning gaps, offering educators practical and flexible tools to improve student performance.
Conference Paper
Purpose: The purpose of the study is to assess the impact of utilizing Pocket Science Magazine as a strategic intervention material for least mastered competencies. Moreover it is an intervention and innovation rolled into one strategic material. Design/Methodology/Approach: Using total enumeration sampling technique, the participants of the study were identified based on the result of the summative test (pretest), those struggling students will undergo an intervention program through the utilization of this pocket science magazine. Moreover, posttest will be given to them right after the intervention. Findings: Findings reveal that the participants mastery level have improved from 2.87 to 8.46 from the Intervention program using the pocket science magazine. Based on the t-test calculation, the result is significant at p < .05. Therefore, the utilization of pocket science magazine has a significant effect and indeed effective as a strategic intervention material.
Article
Full-text available
Determining the knowledge and skills of students are identified as aspects in enhancing the students’ academic performance in sciences. Using the research instrument composed of test items and process skills checklist, data were gathered from 332 grade 8 students from the seven (7) public high schools in the Division of Santiago City, Philippines to assess their knowledge and science process skills in learning grade 8-Chemistry. Standard score (z-score) and descriptive statistics were used to analyzed the data. It was revealed that the student-respondents’ knowledge belongs to “developing proficiency level” while their process skills were rated as poor in their grade 8-Chemistry subject. In using the z-scores, most of the respondents are partially proficient in their scientific knowledge and skills. Based from the result, specific topics in grade 8 chemistry that needs an intervention material were identified. These intervention materials will be subjected to validation and further assessment. In improving the level of process skills and knowledge, students are encouraged to participate in different chemistry activities and for the teachers to elevate their science instruction and students’ academic performances.
Article
Full-text available
In teaching and learning mathematics, there are shortcomings and negative factors that result in the failure of students. Hence, this study was conducted to explain the main factors affecting the failure rate in mathematics courses at Visayas State University (VSU). This study uses a random sample of 151 students who failed mathematics courses such as College Algebra, Trigonometry, and Calculus. The different factors affecting the failure rate in mathematics were identified using a structured questionnaire. The students' perception of learning mathematics and the students' perception of a mathematics teacher were measured using a developed students' perception questionnaire. Median and quartile variation were used to summarize the perception scores. Chi-square goodness of fit was used to describe the different factors if it follows a uniform distribution. The Chi-square test for independence was also used to determine the relationship between student's perceptions and the factors affecting the failure rate. Results revealed that there were five main factors affecting the failure rate in mathematics that does not follow a uniform distribution namely: poor study habits (51%), negative learning attitudes (22.5%), social environment (13.9%), emotional problem (7.3%) and financial problem (5.3%). The study shows that these students were interested in learning mathematics, but the quartile variation reveals that these responses were not consistent. On average, their mathematics teacher was rated as very satisfactory in terms of teaching strategies and the result was consistent with the quartile variation. Furthermore, results show that there is no relationship between the factors affecting the failure rate and students' perception of learning mathematics. Also, no relationship is found between factors affecting the failure rate and students' perception of a mathematics teacher.
Article
Full-text available
This study focused mainly on the cultural factors such as beliefs, value practices and exposure to technology-related instructional materials in learning mathematics in regards to their level of achievement among Badjao students. At present, there are limited studies on the learning factors in regards to the level of achievement in mathematics among Badjao students in Bato, Leyte, Philippines. The study employed 71 Badjao elementary and high school students in four selected schools in the municipality of Bato, Leyte using a complete enumeration. Descriptive statistics and Chi-square Contingency Coefficient were used to characterize the variables of interest and to capture its relationships, respectively. Result reveals that the belief of Badjao students is high which indicates that mathematics is important to their daily lives and well-being. However, when it comes to their value practices, Badjao students rated average, which implies that they have mediocre study habits towards mathematics. Findings revealed that almost all of the Badjao students are beginners in their proficiency level in learning mathematics. Result shows that there is a significant relationship between mathematics achievement of the Badjao students and their beliefs about mathematics as well as their value practices in learning mathematics. Furthermore, their level of achievement in mathematics and level of exposure to technology-related instructional materials has no relationships.
Article
Full-text available
This study aimed to investigate the effectiveness of Strategic Intervention Material (SIM) in Mathematics as remediation for Grade 9 students in solving problems involving quadratic functions. The SIM was designed as a remediation tool for students in teaching one of the least learned competencies. It was personally conducted by the researcher in Digos City NHS – Igpit HS Annex, Igpit, Digos City, Davao del Sur, Philippines during the School Year 2016-2017. A total of 16 Grade 9 students were the respondents of the study. Quasi-experimental design was used. The data were gathered using the researcher-made pretest and posttest. Frequency, relative frequency, mean and standard deviation were used to describe the academic achievement of students in problem solving involving quadratic functions. One-way analysis of co-variance (ANCOVA) was utilized to test if the significant difference existed between the experimental and the control groups. Findings revealed that the proficiency level of Grade 9 students in the posttest when remediated using the SIM was “satisfactory”; while the students remediated with the Grade 9 Learner’s Material was described as “did not meet expectations.” A significant difference in the academic achievement of students on the topic in favor of the experimental group was noted; hence, the Strategic Intervention Material in Mathematics was found effective as a remediation tool for Grade 9 students in solving problems involving quadratic functions. Recommendations were offered.
Article
Full-text available
A study of Longman Social Studies Series for junior secondary classes. Nigeria journal of social studies review 1(1), 96 – 104.
Article
Full-text available
This study investigated the effect of instructional materials on the teaching and learning of social studies in secondary schools in Oju with four purposes, four research questions and hypothesis. Survey design was adopted and both students and teachers constituted the population for study. A sample of hundred subjects was drawn from five schools and was administered questionnaires. Data collected was analyzed using simple percentage (%) for research question and chi square for hypothesis. However, the four hypothesis were tested at 0.05 level of significance and were all rejecte relevant instructional materials, availability and ability of the teacher to improve all had significant relationship with the teaching and learning of social studies in Oju local government area. The research recomm instructional materials in secondary schools. Copyright©2016, Ogaga et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Att distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Article
Full-text available
Social studies is a core subject offered in the junior secondary school educational system. This study is designed to assess the availability and teachers' use of instructional materials and resources in the implementation of junior secondary school social studies curriculum in Edo state. Three research questions were raised and one hypothesis was formulated. A sample of fifty social studies teachers were randomly selected from fifty junior secondary schools in five local government areas of Edo State. Data analysis was carried out using t-test for the hypothesis and simple percentages for questions one and two. The results showed that instructional materials and resources available were grossly inadequate. It was also observed that there was no difference in the use of instructional materials between specialist social studies teachers and non-specialist teachers. It is therefore recommended that instructional materials and resources be made available for the teaching of social studies.
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of working conditions at school on teachers’ level of instructional media use in the primary school system of Gedeo Zone, southern Ethiopia. The survey was made on a sample of 139 (24.4 % female and male 75.6 %) teachers who were randomly drawn from 9 primary schools (four rural and five urban primary schools). The instruments used to generate data were self-reported questionnaires tapping the level of instructional media use and the associated school-level environmental factors. The findings based on Factor Analysis revealed three independent dimensions of school environment factors related to the use of instructional media by teachers. It is further disclosed that the level of use of instructional media is low with an average frequency of use swinging between once in two weeks to twice in three weeks during four weeks of instruction. The implications of the findings related to pre-service and in-service teacher training are also discussed.
Article
Argumentation has been a prominent concern in science education research and a common goal in science curriculum in many countries over the past decade. With reference to this goal, policy documents burden responsibilities on science teachers, such as involving students in dialogues and being guides in students’ spoken or written argumentation. Consequently, teachers’ pedagogical practices regarding argumentation gain importance due to their impact on how they incorporate this practice into their classrooms. In this study, therefore, we investigated the instructional strategies adopted by science teachers for their argumentation-based science teaching. Participants were one elementary science teacher, two chemistry teachers, and four graduate students, who have a background in science education. The study took place during a graduate course, which was aimed at developing science teachers’ theory and pedagogy of argumentation. Data sources included the participants’ video-recorded classroom practices, audio-recorded reflections, post-interviews, and participants’ written materials. The findings revealed three typologies of instructional strategies towards argumentation. They are named as Basic Instructional Strategies for Argumentation, Meta-level Instructional ‌St‌‌rategies for ‌Argumentation, and Meta-strategic Instructional ‌St‌‌rategies for ‌Argumentation. In conclusion, the study provided a detailed coding framework for the exploration of science teachers’ instructional practices while they are implementing argumentation-based lessons.
Article
This study evaluated the instructional materials in the effective implementation of migrant fishermen's children education programme in Rivers state of Nigeria. The population for the study was made up of all the teachers and the pupils. All the 179 teachers constituted a sample for the study and 590 primary six pupils were selected from 59 schools through a simple random sampling technique (10 pupils from each school). The researcher designed a migrant fishermen education questionnaire (MFEQ) for teachers and a written achievement test for pupils (WATP) to gather data for the study. The questionnaire consisted of Likert-type items to elicit information. The written achievement test for pupils was made up of 50 questions, 20 from English language, 20 from mathematics and 10 from social studies. The reliability coefficient of the instruments were ascertained using Pearson Product Moment Correlation which gave the value of 0.87 and 0.90 respectively two research question guided the study and two null hypotheses were formulated and tested for statistical significance at .05 alpha levels using chi-square (x 2). The findings show that there is a significant relationship between the available instructional materials and effective implementation of migrant fishermen's children education. Based on these findings, recommendations were proffered.