ArticlePublisher preview available

Economic Complexity and Income Inequality: Does Country Risk Matter?

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

This research sets out to determine the nexus among economic complexity (ECI; which reflects a country’s productivity), income inequality, and country risk and whether country risk affects the complexity-inequality nexus. By applying balanced panel data of 43 countries from 1991 to 2016 to a data-driven econometric methodology-finite mixture model, we provide fresh insight into this relationship from the perspective of country risk. The results indicate that the two-group finite mixture model is able to best fit our data, and that increasing economic complexity has no impact on income inequality in group A, whereas improving the structure of productivity mitigates the income gap in group B. Furthermore, country risk and the subcomponents of the former (i.e., economic risk, financial risk, and political risk) all exert effects on the complexity-inequality nexus. Specifically speaking, an increase in ECI is associated with more equal income distribution in a country with low country risk, while the improvement in productive structure cannot improve an unequal income distribution in countries under high country risk. Finally, it is noteworthy that the finite mixture model also captures information about the transformation of this nexus, with evidence demonstrating that 5 countries experience a variation in their complexity-inequality relationship over the sample period.
Vol.:(0123456789)
Social Indicators Research (2021) 154:35–60
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11205-020-02543-0
1 3
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Economic Complexity andIncome Inequality: Does Country
Risk Matter?
Chien‑ChiangLee1,2· En‑ZeWang3
Accepted: 1 November 2020 / Published online: 9 November 2020
© Springer Nature B.V. 2020
Abstract
This research sets out to determine the nexus among economic complexity (ECI; which
reflects a country’s productivity), income inequality, and country risk and whether country
risk affects the complexity-inequality nexus. By applying balanced panel data of 43 coun-
tries from 1991 to 2016 to a data-driven econometric methodology-finite mixture model,
we provide fresh insight into this relationship from the perspective of country risk. The
results indicate that the two-group finite mixture model is able to best fit our data, and that
increasing economic complexity has no impact on income inequality in group A, whereas
improving the structure of productivity mitigates the income gap in group B. Furthermore,
country risk and the subcomponents of the former (i.e., economic risk, financial risk, and
political risk) all exert effects on the complexity-inequality nexus. Specifically speaking,
an increase in ECI is associated with more equal income distribution in a country with low
country risk, while the improvement in productive structure cannot improve an unequal
income distribution in countries under high country risk. Finally, it is noteworthy that the
finite mixture model also captures information about the transformation of this nexus, with
evidence demonstrating that 5 countries experience a variation in their complexity-inequal-
ity relationship over the sample period.
Keywords Income inequality· Economic complexity· Country risk· Finite-mixture
model· Heterogeneity
JEL classification O15· O4· G00· G51
The authors are listed in alphabetical order and share first authorship. This paper is supported by the
National Science Foundation of Jiangxi Province of China [20202BAB201006] and the 2020 Jiangxi
Humanities and Social Sciences Project of University.
* En-Ze Wang
enzewang2008@gmail.com
Chien-Chiang Lee
cclee6101@gmail.com
1 Research Center oftheCentral China forEconomic andSocial Development, Nanchang
University, Nanchang, China
2 School ofEconomics andManagement, Nanchang University, Nanchang, China
3 Economics andManagement School, Wuhan University, Wuhan, Hubei,
People’sRepublicofChina
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... However, widening income inequality will be a quite serious problem. In fact, income inequality is an important concern for the economy (Lee & Wang, 2021). ...
... In addition, another study applying SYS-GMM estimates based on data from 88 countries in 2002-2007 revealed that the economic complexity index is associated with higher income inequality (Chu & Hoang, 2020). Another study using mixed models in 43 countries over the period 1991-2016 also reported a positive influence of the economic complexity index on income inequality (Lee & Wang, 2021). ...
... These findings align with the studies conducted by Lee & Wang (2021) and Hartmann et al. (2017). The economic complexity index has the potential to reduce income inequality by improving the employment structure, expanding employment and educational prospects, and producing high-value products (Lee & Wang, 2021). ...
Article
Full-text available
This research examines the influence of the economic complexity index, GDP per capita, gross higher education participation ratio, government spending on education, and fertility rates on income inequality in G20 Forum member countries from 2010 to 2019. The dynamic panel data regression method with the two-step System Generalized Method of Moments (SYS-GMM) estimation technique is used to analyze the data in this study. The findings reveal that the economic complexity index, GDP per capita squared, government spending on education, and fertility levels have a negative and significant effect on income inequality. Meanwhile, GDP per capita and gross enrollment rates in tertiary education have a significant positive effect on income inequality. This study shows that the economic complexity index and the quality of human resources can reduce income inequality. Therefore, policies that focus on improving the quality of human resources need to be considered to encourage innovation, increase GDP per capita, and ultimately reduce income inequality.
... In the income inequality cluster, researchers mainly studied the impact of economic complexity on reducing inequality from various angles (Hartmann et al., 2017;Sbardella et al., 2017;Lee & Wang, 2021a, 2021b and mitigating greenhouse gas emissions (Boleti et al., 2021;Neagu & Teodoru, 2019;Romero & Gramkow, 2021;Shahzad et al., 2021). In addition, a few studies examined the role of technological innovation (Yu et al., 2022), financial stability (Ashraf, 2022), and globalization (Nan et al., 2022) on CO 2 emissions. ...
... For instance, Nguyen C.P. published papers related to "Economic growth" (Nguyen, 2021(Nguyen, , 2022Nguyen et al., 2021) and "Diversification" (Nguyen & Schinckus, 2022). In addition, Lee C.-C. published papers related to "Ecological footprint" You et al., 2022) and "Income inequality (Lee & Wang, 2021a, 2021b. Lapatinas A. published papers related to "Diversification" (Adam et al., 2023;Lapatinas, 2019), "Ecological footprint" , and "Income inequality" . ...
... reveals that the publications of each country are related to different clusters. For instance, in China, the publications are related to "Ecological footprint" (such as Numan et al., 2022;Shahzad et al., 2023), "Income inequality" (such as Lee & Wang, 2021a, 2021bLi et al., 2023), "Economic growth" (such as Tabash et al., 2022;Zhu & Li, 2017), and "Diversification" (such as Gao et al., 2021;Shou et al., 2017). Similarly, in the United States, the publications are related to different clusters including "Ecological footprint" (such as Additionally, a co-authored country analysis was applied to identify the main country groups that have contributed to the publication on economic complexity. ...
Article
Full-text available
The growing literature on the issues of economic complexity makes it challenging to achieve a comprehensive multidimensional picture of the current problem for beneficiaries, policymakers, and future research. Therefore, this study aims to conduct a bibliometric analysis of 272 documents published in the field of economic complexity since 2007 and extracted from the Scopus database. Results are presented through figures, tables, maps of past trends and research directions using keyword analysis, global citation analysis of authors, organizations, countries, journals, articles, references, content analysis, and other bibliometric analysis via VOSviewer, CiteSpace, and WordStat software. A bibliometric review was applied to identify four clusters: Economic Growth, Diversification, Income Inequality, and Ecological Footprint. Finally, the state of the art in economic complexity research is discussed, and directions for future research are provided.
... Finally, concerning point (iv), Lee and Wang (2021) provide econometric evidence that the ECI-inequality nexus depends on country risk. According to the authors, country risk can negatively and positively affect the ECI-inequality relationship, depending on whether economic, financial and political risk-as the three main elements of country risk-affect the diversity or the exclusivity (i.e. ...
... To attract, coordinate and remunerate networks of qualified workers, high-quality and inclusive institutions are also required. In this respect, the scope for future research is still large: understanding which specific types of institutions, either formal or informal, shape the Non-linear and significant relation between ECI and income inequality, but only in urban and high-GDP states Lee and Wang (2021) 43 countries, 1991-2016 Two-group finite mixture model Negative relationship between ECI and income inequality only in low-risk countries, no relation in high-risk countries Source: author's elaborations complexity-inequality relationship is still subject to anecdotal and case-based evidence instead of being based on solid empirical evidence. Identifying true causal linkages is another issue that needs to be properly addressed, using not only instrumental variable techniques but also more recent approaches in the field of quasi-natural experiments, counterfactual analyses, difference-in-differences regressions or even machine learning algorithms. ...
... Tracking the progress and the determinants of economic complexity has attracted great attention among policymakers and academia. An extensive body of the existing literature was concerned with the key determinants of the economic complexity: Foreign direct investment (Sadeghi et al., 2020;Antonietti and Franco, 2021;Saqib and Dinca, 2023); institutional governance (Hartmann et al., 2017); human capital accumulation (Shahbaz et al., 2019), income inequality (Hartmann et al., 2017;Lee and Wang, 2021), gender equality found to serve as key drivers of economic complexity. However, less attention has been paid to global risk factors such as geopolitical risk, oil price volatilities, and global economic policy uncertainties as potential determinants of economic complexity. ...
... The interactions among geopolitical risk, economic uncertainty, and economic complexity have become a central issue for academics, scholars, and policymakers investigations. Studies for instance, Lee and Wang (2021) assessed the impact of country risk on the economic complexity-income inequality for panel data of 43 countries from 1991 to 2016 using the finitemixture model. The authors uncover that upgrading economic complexity positively correlates to low uncertainty and equal income distribution. ...
Article
Full-text available
Enhancing future economic growth through higher economic complexity is vital for sustainable growth strategies. Even though most studies are concerned with the key factors governing the economic complexity process, there needs to be more studies about the impact of risk factors on economic sophistication evolvement, particularly for oil-rentier economies. The present paper intends to delve into the dynamic connectedness between some risk factors, such as economic, political, and geopolitical risks and oil price volatility and the progress of economic complexity. We utilized quarterly data (1995Q1-2021Q4) for Saudi Arabia as a heavy oil-rich economy. As the first study to delve into the short-long term connections at various time scales and frequencies within a multivariable setting, we contribute to the literature by offering a spotless picture of economic complexity risk factors. In doing so, we resort to a novel wavelet local multiple correlation method, which can explore the varying patterns of time periods in the interconnections between the variables. Our findings disclose that oil volatility, geopolitical risk, and global uncertainties are positively connected to economic complexity over the long run. In contrast, their short-term effect is weak and mostly insignificant. These results indicate the resiliency of the Saudi economy to external to oil volatility shocks and intensification of global and local uncertainties. These outcomes offer policymakers new insights and prominent policy recommendations when designing economic strategies to achieve higher economic sophistication and sustainable growth.
... Finally, concerning point (iv), Lee and Wang (2021) provide econometric evidence that the ECI-inequality nexus depends on country risk. According to the authors, country risk can negatively and positively affect the ECI-inequality relationship, depending on whether economic, financial and political risk-as the three main elements of country risk-affect the diversity or the exclusivity (i.e. ...
... To attract, coordinate and remunerate networks of qualified workers, high-quality and inclusive institutions are also required. In this respect, the scope for future research is still large: understanding which specific types of institutions, either formal or informal, shape the Non-linear and significant relation between ECI and income inequality, but only in urban and high-GDP states Lee and Wang (2021) 43 countries, 1991-2016 Two-group finite mixture model Negative relationship between ECI and income inequality only in low-risk countries, no relation in high-risk countries Source: author's elaborations complexity-inequality relationship is still subject to anecdotal and case-based evidence instead of being based on solid empirical evidence. Identifying true causal linkages is another issue that needs to be properly addressed, using not only instrumental variable techniques but also more recent approaches in the field of quasi-natural experiments, counterfactual analyses, difference-in-differences regressions or even machine learning algorithms. ...
... We therefore apply FMMs to estimate the relationship between elections and military expenditures. This estimation technique is a semi-parametric method for modeling unobserved heterogeneity in the sample that allows us to relax the assumption of one data-generating process as parameters may vary across groups of observations, which makes it possible to determine the conditions under which competing theories apply (see also Bagozzi et al., 2014;Lee & Wang, 2021;Wang & Lee, 2021). Mixture models generate endogenous group membership and permit explaining group membership with several concomitant variables (Van Horn et al., 2015). ...
... We therefore apply FMMs to estimate the relationship between elections and military expenditures. This estimation technique is a semi-parametric method for modeling unobserved heterogeneity in the sample that allows us to relax the assumption of one data-generating process as parameters may vary across groups of observations, which makes it possible to determine the conditions under which competing theories apply (see also Bagozzi et al., 2014;Lee & Wang, 2021;Wang & Lee, 2021). Mixture models generate endogenous group membership and permit explaining group membership with several concomitant variables (Van Horn et al., 2015). ...
Article
This study explores whether the level of military expenditures is affected by the occurrence of elections. From a theoretical perspective, it is not immediately clear whether, and if so, in which direction, upcoming elections shift military expenditures. On the one hand, the incumbent may try to enhance the likelihood of being re-elected by supporting the domestic defense industry. On the other hand, it might be more attractive to cut defense spending and increase non-defense spending. It is also possible that both effects coexist. We therefore apply the finite mixture model (FMM), which is able to test competing hypotheses. Our results, based on a panel of 93 democratic countries between 1980 and 2018 and Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) data on military spending, yield support for both hypotheses. Countries facing security risks or having a significant defense industry are most likely to expand their defense spending in an election year, while other countries are more likely to reduce their defense expenditure.
... However, farmer participation in agribusiness institutions' activities has mostly been limited to production activities, and it has not been fully optimized [4]. The agricultural sector is essential in economic development, particularly in developing countries [5], where it is a priority [3] and an essential part of domestic economies [6], as well as a strategic sector at the national and regional levels [7]. Furthermore, the sector is strategically responsible for accomplishing the first Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), which aim to eradicate extreme poverty and hunger [8]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The objective of this research was to examine the determinants of farmer participation and shallot-farming development in search of effective farm management practices. The study used structural equation modeling data analysis. The primary data were collected from direct structural interviews with 150 randomly chosen shallot farmers in Bantaeng Regency, Indonesia. It was found that the latent variables of Physical Aspects of Land, System of Economy Peasant Society, and System of Political Peasant Society were fundamental factors that exerted a positive and significant influence on the latent variable of Farmer Participation. Therefore, improvements in the physical aspects of the land, the economic framework, and the political structure of agricultural communities could promote farmer participation. Furthermore, the latent variable of Farmer Participation and System of Political Peasant Society had a positive and significant impact on shallot-farming development. Thus, by increasing the influence of government officials and community leaders, shallot farming can be promoted. The farmers can then enhance their participation in shallot-farming plan formulation and implementation, providing the continued development of shallot farming. The findings of this study contribute significantly to the body of knowledge by validating previous research and proposing different ways to improve effective farm management practices in shallot farming.
... Based on endogenous growth theory which taking knowledge and technology as key economic drivers, economic complexity is proposed to reversely estimating the production capacity of an economy with exporting products information as carrier, which has more effectiveness of predicting economic growth than classical indicators in traditional political economy (Hidalgo, 2021), and has been successfully used in research on economic development . Ma et al. 2022;Britto et al. 2019;Sepehrdoust et al. 2019), green economy (Mealy and Teytelboym 2022;Rafique et al. 2021;Neagu 2019;Pérez-Hernández et al. 2021), social inequality (Hartmann et al. 2017;Chu and Hoang 2020;Lee and Wang 2021;Sepehrdoust et al. 2022), to provide information about the current state of economic development. In the realm of economic complexity, the primary models for assessing the state of economic development include classic measurement methods such as the economic complexity index (ECI) and the product complexity index (PCI) based on Method of Reflections (the following abbreviation "MR"), as well as fitness complexity index (FCI) and product complexity index (FPI) (Hidalgo 2021). ...
Article
Full-text available
Selecting suitable trading partners in the globalized trade landscape remains critical. Traditional selection processes driven by factors like comparative advantage and trade costs are cumbersome and incomplete. Economic complexity offers a more precise measure of a country’s economic development and product capacity, facilitating future-oriented choices. Leveraging international trade data from 2001 to 2015, this paper employs economic complexity theories to analyze Chinese and the US’ trade networks in the global market. It explores multi-level considerations for exporting countries’ partner selection, revealing varying product diversification challenges and market clustering tendencies. China shows increasing overall product proximity relationships, specifically notable in textile-related products, while the US exhibits decreasing product proximities. Additionally, trading positions and product dependencies vary across markets. Some countries, like Japan and Germany, maintain stable positions, while others fluctuate. Notably, countries like Nigeria, Bangladesh, and Cambodia have higher positions in the Chinese market, suggesting promising long-term trade partnerships. Conversely, countries like Yemen, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, and Sudan have higher positions in the US market, indicating significant disparities. Products that are needed in the Chinese market and occupy higher complexity positions are primarily concentrated in the field of non-ferrous metals, while the US market relies more on raw materials. This highlights distinct market dynamics, particularly pronounced in the US market. Hence, there is a greater likelihood of obtaining better economic benefits by trading these products in their respective markets.
... However, farmers' participation in agribusiness institutions' activities has mostly been limited to production activities, and it has not been fully optimized [5]. The agricultural sector is essential in economic development, particularly in developing countries [4,6] a priority [3], and an essential part of domestic economies [7] as well as a strategic sector at the national and regional levels [8,9]. Furthermore, the sector is strategically responsible for accomplishing the first MDGs, which aim to eradicate extreme poverty and hunger [10]. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
The objective of the research was to examine the determinants that determine farmer participation and shallot farming development in search of effective farm management practices. The study used Structural Equation Modeling data analysis. The primary data was collected from direct-structural interviews with 150 randomly chosen shallot farmers in Bantaeng Regency, Indonesia. It was found that the physical attributes of the land, the economic framework of the community, and the political system of the agricultural community were fundamental factors that exerted a positive and significant influence on farmer participation. Therefore, improvements in the physical aspects of land, the economic framework, and the political structure of agricultural communities could promote farmer participation. Furthermore, the farmers’ participation and the political structure of agricultural communities have a positive and significant impact on the development of shallot farming. Thus, by increasing the influence of government officials and community leaders, shallot farming can be promoted. The farmers can then enhance their participation in the shallot farming plan's formulation and implementation, providing the continued development of shallot farming. The findings of this study contribute significantly to the body of knowledge by validating previous research and proposing different ways to improve effective farm management practices in shallot farming.
Article
Inclusive green growth offers countries seeking new sources of growth an optimistic and realistic alternative that makes economic, environmental and social sense. Existing studies examine the moderating role of various factors in the relationship between economic complexity and certain components of green and inclusive growth, but the role of education is less well known. Therefore, the objective of this study is to examine the moderating role of public expenditure of education in the relationship between economic complexity and inclusive green growth, for the period 2000–2020. On this basis, the study uses several empirical methods to examine the effect of economic complexity on inclusive green growth, as a function of public expenditure of education. The results indicate that economic complexity has a positive effect on inclusive green growth and that positive effect is strengthened when economic complexity interacts with public expenditure of education. The results also show that internet access, industrial employment, female labour force participation, trade openness, institutional quality, household consumption and natural resource rents are important determinants of inclusive green growth. Furthermore, when disaggregating inclusive green growth, the results obtained show that public spending on education essentially play a moderating role in the relationship between economic complexity and inclusive growth. Heterogeneity analysis suggests that the moderating role of public expenditure in the relationship between economic complexity and inclusive green growth is more important in developing countries of Asia and the Middle East, followed by those of Latin America. The results of the study have important policy implications for policy makers in developing countries in promoting inclusive and green growth.
Article
Full-text available
Recent research on the effects of the productive structure of an economy has turned to examining whether economic complexity is associated with lower income inequality. In contrast to the commonly adopted approach that estimates the impact of economic complexity in a cross-country setting, we use panel data for Brazilian states to identify the relationship between economic complexity and income inequality at the sub-national level. Our findings show that the relationship between economic complexity and income inequality has an inverted U-shape, indicating that growing levels of complexity first worsen and then improve the income distribution in Brazilian states. Our findings also show that this relationship is particularly prominent in those states that have relatively high levels of urbanization and overall development. Furthermore, we identify separate effects on income inequality from the degree to which regional productive structures are characterised by diversity in terms of industries and occupations. These effects are particularly pronounced in less developed states with a more rural character. In combination, these findings confirm the important role that the productive structure plays in processes that drive improvements in income distributions and suggest that more research on this impact is warranted at the regional level.
Article
Full-text available
This paper analyses the impact of economic complexity on the labour market using annual data on OECD countries for the period 1985–2008 and averaged data over the period 1990–2010 for 70 developed and developing countries with a large number of controls. We show that moving to higher levels of economic sophistication of exported goods leads to less unemployment and more employment, revealing that economic complexity does not induce job loss. Our findings remain robust across alternative econometric specifications. Furthermore, we place the spotlight on the link between products' embodied knowledge (sophistication) and labour market outcomes at the micro-level. We build a product-level index that attaches a product to the average level of unemployment (or employment) in the countries that export it. With this index, we illustrate how the development of sophisticated products is associated with changes in the labour market and show that the economic sophistication of exported goods captures information about the economy's job creation and destruction.
Article
This study explores the impacts of country risks on the relationship between energy consumption and financial development for 79 countries. By using the panel smooth transition regression model, this study finds non-linear relationships between variables - that is, the relationships differ in higher and lower risk environments. We show that banking sector development has larger impacts on energy consumption than does stock market development. The results of the full sample show under the stable country risk environments that financial development could help to reduce energy consumptions. Lastly, the results offer that different types of financial development and country risk environments have varying impacts on energy consumption in OECD and non-OECD countries.
Article
Objective This article documents wide‐ranging revisions to the Standardized World Income Inequality Database (SWIID), which seeks to maximize the comparability of income inequality estimates for the broadest possible coverage of countries and years. Methods Two k‐fold cross‐validations, by observation and by country, are used to evaluate the SWIID's success in predicting the Luxembourg Income Study (LIS), recognized in the field as setting the standard for comparability. Results The cross‐validations indicate that the new SWIID's estimates and their uncertainty are even more accurate than previous versions, extending its advantage in comparability over alternate income inequality data sets. Conclusion Given its superior coverage and comparability, the SWIID remains the optimum source of data for broadly cross‐national research on income inequality.
Article
This paper investigates the relationship between economic complexity, a measure of economic structures, and income inequality. Using cross-country OLS regression analysis, we show that countries with economic structures geared toward complex products have less inequality. Human capital is found to magnify this correlation but with subtle interaction effects. Concerns about endogeneity bias in the OLS estimates stemming from reverse causality motivate us to estimate a dynamic panel data model, using a system GMM estimator. From the system GMM estimates we find that an increase in economic complexity provokes higher inequality, not less.
Article
This paper examines whether U.S. and home country geopolitical risks (GPRs) and disasters matter for the returns from cross-border trading of country exchange-traded funds (ETFs) by employing a quantile regression approach. Using monthly returns of 125 country-specific ETFs traded in the U.S. from 38 countries over the period 2004–2018, we find that the highest averages of total deaths, total damage values, total affected, and GPRs are all in developing countries. United States disasters have comparatively more significant impacts than home country disasters on ETF returns as does the salient influences of U.S. investor sentiments, supporting the market sentiment hypothesis. Moreover, U.S. and home country GPRs and disasters also have predictive power on returns. The contemptuous effects and predictive powers of GPRs and disasters are asymmetric across quantiles. The influences of home country GPRs are more salient than the GRPS of U.S., implying that ETFs can be a safe haven during U.S. geopolitical risks. Additionally, our results show that the impacts of disasters on returns can be negative and/or positive, implying the possibility of disasters exuding an impetus and/or risk to country ETFs.
Article
This study explores the non-linear effects of both finance development and country risks on income inequality when countries’ risk changes through a broad sample of 59 countries over the period 1985–2015. Using the panel smooth transition regression model, our results present evidence of the different relationships among income inequality, finance development, and country risks under different degrees of country risk. For the full sample, we find evidence of the inequality-widening hypothesis under unstable economic, stable financial, and stable political environments. For the sub-samples, under stable economic and financial environments, high-income countries’ income inequality can be improved through financial development. Moreover, we find a positive relationship between financial development and income inequality for low-income countries.