ArticlePDF Available

Professional School Counseling in Vietnam Public Schools

Authors:
Professional School Counselin
g
in Vietnam
Public Schools
Anh K. Pham1
Patrick Akos2
3)
Journal of Asia Pacific Counseling
2020 The Korean Couns eling Association
www.japconline.org
2020, Vol. 10, No.2, 37- 49
Doi : 10 .18401/2020.10.2.6
Abstract
School counseling as a profession is in its embryonic stage in Vietnam. National education reform initiatives have
focused on curricula, standardized tests and textbooks, yet have essentially ignored problems of violence and students’
mental health. The American School Counseling Association model can serve as a guide for a culturally appropriate
school counseling model for Vietnam. We explore the Vietnam educat ion context and the existing practice of school
counseling and make recommendations for professional school counseling in Vietnam.
K
eywords: professional school counseling, Vietnam, culture, ASCA
Comprehensive school counseling programs have grown rapidly worldwide. The Psychotherapy and
Counseling Federation of Australia (PACFA) in Australia, the Child and Adolescent Mental Health (CAMH)
model in the United Kingdom, the American School Counselor Association (ASCA Model) in the United
States, Perkama Counseling Association in Malaysia, and Pastoral Care and Career Guidance (PCCG) in
Singapore are but a few examples of programs representative of school counseling models (Alli, 2015;
ASCA, 2004, 2019; Lohia & Singh, 2013; Low, 2014; Martin, Lauterbach, & Carey, 2015). These models
are designed to fit the unique cultural context and education system of each country.
Despite more push for nationwide education reform initiatives from pre-school to higher education in
Vietnam, the development of a national comprehensive model of school counseling in Vietnam through the
Vietnam Ministry of Education and Training (MoET) has been slow to develop (Le et al., 2016; Nguyen, H.
T., 2014; Nguyen, T. T., 2016; Nguyen, H. T., 2014; MoET, 2005; 2015; 2017). To date, only the public
schools in some urban and more populated areas of Vietnam have successfully implemented school
counseling activities to support students with psychological development issues. We summarize the unique
and impactful historical and cultural developments, in addition to the current practice of professional school
1Education Services International
2University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Corresponding Author
Anh K. Pham, Education Services International, 20 Street 8, Binh An Ward, District 2, Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.
Email: steve.pham@esi.com.vn
Regular Article
38 PHAM, AKOS
counseling in Vietnam. We also propose possible reforms toward a fundamental framework for developing a
national model of school counseling for Vietnamese public schools.
Historical Influences on Education and Counseling in Vietnam
Vietnam has a long and distinct history of seeking peace and establishing a socialist nation. The influences
on its education history can be summarized as feudalism with the dramatic influence of Chinese
Confucianism, French colonialism, American imperialism, to the modern period of Reconstruction and Reform
(Bui, M. H., 2014; Han, V. X., 2008; MoET, 2014; Taylor, 2013; The Government of S.R Vietnam, 2005,
2009; Tran, K., 2016; World Bank, 2011). At the end of the nineteenth century and early twentieth century,
Vietnam’s traditional Confucian-oriented education system was dramatically destructed and replaced by
French-colonial education. The French colonial apparatus attempted to create an education system using only
the French language as the national language in all schools and daily lives. Among many Vietnam
educational pioneers (e.g., Dong Du in 1905, Dong Kinh Nghia Thuc movement in 1907, Phan Chu Trinh’s
Reformism movement in 1906), Nguyen Ai Quoc led the most the most influenced movement against the
French colonial education system (Bui, M. H., 2014; Taylor, 2013).
In the 1920s and 1930s, Nguyen Ai Quoc and many Vietnamese patriots under the Indochina Communist
Party took enormous efforts to launch several educational movements, such as Turning Prisons into Schools,
Widely Disseminating the National Vietnamese Language, to develop a Vietnam education system that would
depend on the ideology of Marxist-Leninist philosophy, with the emphasis of nation-wide universalization of
public education and Vietnamese National Language (Bui, M. H., 2014; World Bank, 2011).
The August Revolution and the Declaration of Victory in August 1945 formally marked the end of both
feudalism and the French colonialism over thousand of years in Vietnam and the beginning of Vietnamese
national independence with a Communist-oriented democratic republic (Bui, M. H., 2014; Huynh, K. K.,
1971). The establishment of the democratic republic government led by President Ho Chi Minh and the
anti-illiteracy movement across the nation marked the formation of the Vietnam education system with two
legal documents Decrees No. 146-SL and No. 147-SL in 1946 (Bui, M. H., 2014). However, the French
invaded Vietnam again in 1946, dramatically influencing the education system by French-colonial education
during the war resistance from 1946 to 1954 (Bui, M. H., 2014).
In 1950, the Democratic Republic Government of Vietnam officially passed the first national education
reform project to ensure that the Vietnamese language would be taught in all schools during 1950-1955.
Additional educational initiatives included the establishment of a “complementary” education system to
provide educational opportunities to all Vietnamese people, including the establishment of School Steering
Committee to enhance the collaboration of teachers and parents in developing and implementing academic
policies, the establishment of preschool education, while many national education leaders went to study in the
Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR), China, and the German Democratic Republic (Bui, M. H., 2014;
Taylor, 2013; World Bank, 2011).
During the period of Vietnam’s North-South Separation from 1955 to 1975, there were two different
COUNSELING IN VIETNAM 39
education systems. In the North, the government implemented the second education reform once peace was
achieved in 1955 continuously building the socialist education system that emphasized the importance of
collaboration between teachers and students, linkages between theory and practice, in addition to school and
social life. Officially adopted in 1955, a 10-year duration that included 4 years for elementary education, 3
years for lower secondary education, and 3 years for upper secondary education was created. However, most
of the schools at all levels had to be evacuated, since the teaching and learning activities were dramatically
influenced during the U.S. air-force attacks on the North from 1965 to 1972. In the South during this period,
the European and French-influenced education system was gradually replaced by the U.S. education system
with a 12-year duration: 5 years for elementary or primary education, 4 years for middle school or lower
secondary education, and 4 years for high school or upper secondary education (Bui, M. H., 2014; Huynh,
K. K., 1971).
The Vietnamese education reform entered a new era in 1976, the year the reunification government issued
Resolution No. 14-ND-TW, which initiated the third education reform throughout the whole country. Literacy
was still the major focus for all improvement activities (Bui, M. H., 2014; Han, V. X., 2008). Specifically,
the Vietnam Ministry of Education and Training (MoET) developed a new 12-year curriculum, which was
implemented in all schools across the country with new textbooks and re-trained teachers. However, the third
education reform during the period from 1976 to 1985 faced many challenges due to the collective economy,
a serious shortage of financial and teachers’ resources, and less autonomy for professors working under a
heavily bureaucratic system of governmental centralization.
In 1986, the remarkable national renovation “Doi Moi” was established, to move from the centralized
planning system to a socialist-oriented market mechanism, whichled to another transformation of the
education system in Vietnam. Efforts toward democratization, diversification, and mobilization of social
resources for a better educational quality and efficiency occurred at all levels (Bui, M. H., 2014). The
enormous efforts put forth from “Doi Moi” significantly improved Vietnam’s education quality at all levels
to meet the country’s national substantial goals, ensuring that every child has equal opportunity in education
(Bui, M. H., 2014; MoET, 2014; Taylor, 2013). This nation-wide reform influenced all areas of Vietnamese
society and economy, leading to the adoption of Vietnam Education Law 1998 (later replaced by the
Education Law 2005). Four years later, the Education Law Amendment 2009 created a dramatic trend of
privatization and liberalization at all levels of education in Vietnam (Bui, M. H., 2014, MoET, 2005).
These education reforms resonated with a contemporary school counseling focus. National education
systems encouraged students to acquire knowledge and skills for vocational career or higher education.
Instructional or teaching methods could help students develop their consciousness, initiative, and creativeness,
fostering a self-study spirit and an eagerness to learn (MoET, 2005).
Contemporary Reform in Education and School Counseling
These educational movements have put Vietnam’s education system towards a very positive course by
providing a variety of education options for every student. To achieve the Millennium Development Goals in
40 PHAM, AKOS
education, the Vietnam government has adopted a new Vietnam Education Law for K-12 education that
provides high quality and equality of educational opportunity for every student (The Government of S.R
Vietnam, 2019). Indeed, the Vietnam Education Law 2019 affirmed the importance of career education where
the lower and upper secondary students are provided comprehensive career guidance relevant to their ages
and psychological status. The career guidance program could be integrated into mainstream and
extra-curricular activities to help students gain the knowledge necessary about different occupations and
awareness of their abilities, in addition to skills for their future career and social lives. Nevertheless,
professional school counseling, by title, did not appear in this important education legislation.
Findings from a study conducted by Nguyen Hong Thuan (2014) highlighted that most public schools in
Vietnam adopted the specific guidelines from the OL No. 9971/BGDDT-HSSV and the National Standards
for Secondary Schools Assessment in developing a school counseling program for their students. In primary
and secondary public schools in Vietnam, school principals can appoint some senior teachers with leadership
and classroom administrative skills, knowledge about students’ disciplines, and counseling skills to play the
role of homeroom teachers. As homeroom teachers, they can appoint one or two communist youth specialists
commonly outstanding students or model students in their peers’ view, in terms of academic achievement and
personal moraleto help them in their additional duty of classroom administration, students’ discipline and
counseling (HCM YPO, 2018; HCM CYU, 2019). As a result of the lack of professional school counselors,
the counseling programs in public schools solely aimed at supporting students in their career planning and job
seeking rather than helping them with students’ mental health and personal/emotional development. Moreover,
many homeroom teachers and psychology teachers in the role of the counselor lack the appropriate training,
professional counseling knowledge or skills (Le et al., 2016; Nguyen, H. T., 2014). Very little research is
known about the actual number of school counselors, what counseling model or standards are used, or the
effectiveness of school counseling programs.
Most public schools in Vietnam have continuously proposed for more effective programs of school
counseling to reduce school violence, bullying and improve students’ mental health and social/personal
development. A recent study conducted by Son, Vu, Thien, Luong, and Hoi (2019) on high school students’
(grades 6 to 12) stress suggested a range of issues and variance in coping related to grade levels and learning
environment, family and living conditions, personality and life-skills. Another research study (Hoi, Son, My,
& Vu, 2019) on children under 16 years old with incomplete-family (divorced parents, single mothers,
orphans) circumstance found that nearly a quarter of these participating children had psychological trauma.
This study highlighted that the factor of domestic violence could be considered to be one of the key factors
of psychological traumas in young children, followed with external local community or living environment.
These studies proposed urgent development of appropriate school counseling programs to help Vietnamese
high school students reduce their mental health problems and improve their academic achievement and
personal/emotional development.
COUNSELING IN VIETNAM 41
Unique Vietnamese Cultural Issues in School Counseling
The historical background of Vietnam education was influenced by both traditional Eastern Confucianism
and Western contemporary liberation education from France and the United States. Over several decades of
peace-seeking and nation restructuring, Vietnam has successfully established its education system for all levels
from early years or pre-school education to higher education with the emphasis on students’ personal and
social development (Bui, M. H., 2014; Han, V. X., 2008; The Government of S.R Vietnam, 2005, 2009;
MoET, 2014, 2017; Tran, K. 2016; Tran, K., Nguyen, X. T., 2015; World Bank, 2011).
School counseling did not emerge in the education literature until the late 1970s and 1980s, originating
with career guidance for secondary students in only a few public schools (Le et al., 2016; Nguyen, H. T.,
2014; Nguyen, T. H., 2005). In 1991, MoET established the Center of Labor and Career Guidance, which
published the first legislation of counseling Career Guidance for Secondary Students and provided training
courses of career guidance for school administrators at public secondary schools. Since then, a growing
number of career guidance centers established across the country provides secondary students guidance about
necessary vocational skills for their future careers (Le et al., 2016).
However, school counseling has never gained appropriate consideration from educational policymakers and
educators. Consequently, the concept of professional school counseling has not been clearly defined in any
educational legislation, neither in the Education Law 2005 or 2009 or in the recent Education Law 2019.
Rather, the Official Letter(OL) No.9971/BGDDT-HSSV Implementing School Counseling for General
Students and Higher Education Students, issued by the MoET in October 2005, is still seen as formal
guidance about professional school counseling from the government. This document describes school
counseling for secondary students as providing “some certain analysis, realistic advice to help students
release mental stress and feel more stable, and confident, and then they will be able to resolve their
problems in a positive way (MoET, 2005, p. 1). This document also provides generic guidance that schools
can employ, assigning psychology teachers or members from Communist Youth Associates to periodically
provide school counseling for all upper secondary students (grade 10 to 12), and to those enrolled at
vocational schools, colleges, and universities. Further, the guidelines note that a particular school’s counseling
program should focus on major matters such as, career guidance, career choice and higher education
information; love, gender and different gender relationship; interpersonal relationship with family members,
teachers and peers; learning methods; social community activities, and the arts. In 2012, the MoET published
the National Standards for Secondary Schools Assessment, which reaffirmed that secondary students should
be taught about “social life skills” through mainstream curricular and extracurricular activities, for the purpose
of enhancing their skills of communication, self-awareness, decision-making, critical thinking and
problem-solving, goals setting, resilience, and teamwork. More importantly, they should be provided
comprehensive counseling about physical and mental health, gender, love, marriage, and other family matters.
42 PHAM, AKOS
Movement toward a Vietnamese School Counseling Model (VSCM)
In December 2017, the MoET published Guidance (Circular No. 31/2017/TT-BGDDT) on Implementing
School Psychology Counseling in 1-12 Schools in response to school bullying and violence (Le, M. C., 2016;
Nguyen, H. T., 2014; Nguyen, T. H. H., 2016; Tran, A. T., 2016). This was the first official legislation that
provided a clear definition of school psychology counseling in all public schools in Vietnam. This document
proposed a comprehensive program of school psychology counseling that should focus on the following major
areas: age, gender, marriage, adolescent reproductive health matters; behaviors, violence and sexual abuse;
interpersonal relationships between family members, teachers, friends and other social communities; effective
learning methods and career orientation (MoET, 2017). Through intervention and appropriate resolutions,
including the utilization of external psychosocial counseling agencies and experts, the psychological
counseling program should effectively offer assistance for students with serious psychological problems such
as mental disorders.
This official guidance of school psychological counseling was the result from many education reforms and
initiatives from the government, educators, and educational scholars. The OL No. 9971/BGDDT-HSSV 2005,
together with this guidance, could be considered as official legislation for defining the profession of school
(psychological) counseling, as well as for developing a fundamental framework of the Vietnam School
Counseling Model (VSCM). We provide a general comparison of these parameters next to the ASCA
National Model in Appendix 1.
Our recent research on an effective model of school counseling for public secondary schools in Vietnam
(Pham, K. A., 2019) used a questionnaire, interviews and focus group protocols to explore the existing
practices of school counseling and the perspectives of school administrators, teachers, and school counselors
on professional school counseling. The questionnaire focused on perspectives on school counseling, school
counseling practices and recommendations for a comprehensive school counseling program data. We collected
data from 158 educators (including 10 school leaders, 129 teachers, and 19 school counselors or personnel
assigned to act as school counselors) from ten public schools in the southern region of Vietnam on this issue.
In our research, we discovered that homeroom teachers were primarily assigned to the counselor role in
most public schools in Vietnam. Interestingly, those homeroom teachers were unable to clearly define the
responsibilities of a school counselor, as attention is not always placed on supporting a student’s academic,
social/emotional, and career development needs. Further, those assigned to school counseling do not use data
to monitor a student’s progress nor to assess the effectiveness of their counseling program. In Vietnam, it
appears that the complex and unique education system puts a burden on the multifaceted role of homeroom
teachers and the specific role of communist youth specialists in public schools. Therefore, the MoET should
urgently provide clarification on school counseling skills for homeroom teachers, as well as identify
professional standards, professional development and assessment tools for professional school counselors’
performance.
Nonetheless, despite limitations or appropriate guidance, a senior homeroom teacher may have the best
opportunity to establish rapport with students, and may be in the best position to help students in school
counseling and career guidance by providing early interventions for students with mental and health matters,
COUNSELING IN VIETNAM 43
as well as offering useful information about college and career opportunities that align with students’
individual goals and personal aspirations (Thuan, 2014; Thuong, 2016). With a shortage of professional
school counselors, homeroom teachers need to collaborate closely with the communist youth specialists who
can assist school administrators in resolving students’ matters, such as fighting, truancy, tardiness, and in
organizing school events and activities (Le, M. C., 2016; Nguyen, H. T., 2014; Nguyen, T. H. H., 2016). The
high rating of school communist youth specialists as the important stakeholders and homeroom teachers as the
immediate key contact in providing school counseling for students affirmed the very specific and complex
practices of school counseling in Vietnam.
Perhaps unique to other national models, and in particular the United States, there were no significant
differences in perceptions of the effective model and comprehensive programs of school counseling between
school administrators, counselors, and teachers, although they had different levels of demographic
characteristics and professional qualifications. Further, administrators more adequately perceived the practices
of school counseling than school counselors (and those assigned to act as school counselors) and teachers.
Even as the data suggests that school counseling has been increasingly recognized as a nationwide emerging
educational issue in public schools, distinct differences still exist in urban, suburban and rural regions
(perhaps due to the lack of legislation and funding).
Studies from other developed countries can be utilized as an influence on curricula and best practice
(ASCA, 2004; Low, 2014; Martin et al., 2015). Some studies have examined several challenges that Vietnam
public schools are facing now, such as a lack of comprehensive standards of professional school counseling,
shortage of professional school counselors, lack of collaboration between school leaders, administrators and
teachers in developing and implementing effective school counseling programs, lack of training programs for
school counselors, and the different perceptions of educators, parents, and students about school counseling
(Le et al., 2016; Nguyen, H. T., 2014). Given the growing awareness of personal and social development
problems among secondary students, students’ depression and trauma, in particular (Hoi, D. D., et. al., 2019;
Le, T. K. D., La, T. B., & Dinh, D. H., 2007; Son, H. V., et. al., 2019), the Vietnam government and educational
scholars in Vietnam should further the development of a VSCM to meet the growth of students’ needs. An
effective model of school counseling would enable students to thrive, both on an academic and social basis
(DeSimone & Roberts, 2016; Le et al., 2016; Martin & Carey, 2014; Nguyen, H. T., 2014; Sciffer, 2015).
The Future of School Counseling in Vietnam
We come short of providing a full VSCM as we believe this must come internally in Vietnam and through
collaboration of all stakeholders. However, based on the historical and cultural review of the education
system and preliminary findings of the contemporary state of school counseling in Vietnam, we would like
to share the following perspectives that we believe may positively impact the developing field of professional
school counseling in Vietnam. Most of the suggestions we present aim toward building a national model of
school counseling and offer a clear identity of school counseling profession.
44 PHAM, AKOS
Key Advocator, a Crucial Role of MoET
MoET has a crucial role in the development and implementation of all education policies, including
national education workforce planning and assignments. MoET considers national models (such as the ASCA
National Model of the United States) to be a template for important milestones in the development of school
counseling in Vietnam. To do so, the MoET should consider the establishment of the Vietnam Association
of School Counselors (VASC), to ensure and provide oversight on the certification and licensure of school
counselors. These organizations and associations can also work closely with universities and all counselors by
training institutions to develop formal curricula for professional school counselors, including upholding
minimum standards of qualifications and accreditation to ensure the effectiveness of school counseling
programs delivered to students in public schools in Vietnam.
In addition to utilizing legislation to formulate the VSCM, the MoET may clarify students’ and
professional standards, program assessment and school counselor assessment, in addition to appraisal based in
research. Further, clarity on the preparation and role of professional school counselors is needed. The MoET
requires the establishment of a school counseling department, with a department head representative from the
school board, school administrator, teachers with psychology training credentials, clinic nurse, communist
youth specialist, parents’ association representative, and some outstanding students (class or/and communist
youth leaders). This collective approach is culturally appropriate, since it will diffuse the responsibility of
leadership of professional school counseling. Moreover, all the structural guidance on Vietnamese school
counseling emanates from legislation rather than research on best practice in Vietnam.
The formulation of these administrative organizations and a Vietnam School Counseling Model (VSCM)
will be an impetus to encourage public schools across the country to develop and implement a comprehensive
program of school counseling that focuses on improving students’ academic, career, and social/emotional
development. MoET also has a responsibility to develop formal curricula for professional school counselors
and help public schools streamline professional development programs for school counselors by providing
additional training for psychology counselors and social workers, to transfer them to professional school
counselor programs for public schools when necessary. Finally, MoET can either provide professional school
counselors or funds for public schools through hiring professional counselors to ensure that every public
school establishes a department of school counseling that operates under an appropriate ratio of professional
school counselors to students, once the national model of school counseling is enacted.
Strong Collaboration between School Administrators, Teachers, School Counselors, Communist
Youth Special ists, Parents, Students, and Local Communitie s
A Vietnam School Counseling Model could be formed once the standards of professional school
counseling and a school counselor’s role is concisely clarified, as well as the effectiveness of school
counseling programs (including the collaboration between all school stakeholders and parents and students)
and the performance of school counselors is properly assessed (Gysbers & Henderson, 2001; 2005; 2006;
Gysbers & Lapan, 2003). School administrators always play an especially critical role in the delivery of
COUNSELING IN VIETNAM 45
comprehensive programs of school counseling and the assessment of school counselors’ performance in public
schools. Research has proved that the positive support of school principals correlates to the development and
implementation of a comprehensive counseling program (Camelford, 2014; Hepp, 2013; Lashley & Stickl,
2016). To effectively develop and implement a comprehensive program of school counseling, school
administrators should collaborate with stakeholders to clarify the role, responsibility and accountability of
every school stakeholder. Within the historical and cultural context of Vietnam’s education system, it is
necessary that various school stakeholders be involved in providing school counseling in Vietnam public
schools. Therefore, MoET should develop and provide appropriate professional development of school
counseling for not only the school administrators but also other school stakeholders, including parents, to
ensure everyone clearly understands the importance of school counseling and can positively collaborate in
providing school counseling services for their students.
The lack of national standards for professional school counseling and the misunderstanding of school
administrators about the roles of school counselors contribute to the specific concept called “ambiguity” in
school counseling practice in Vietnam (Cao, T. T. X. & Truong, T. T. T., 2016; Nguyen, H. T., 2014;
Nguyen, T. M., 2008). Public school principals should clearly understand that a school counseling program
is integral to mainstream instructional programs that demonstrate students’ academic, career, and
social/emotional development, rather than extracurricular activities related to psychological counseling for
students with mental and health problems. Since the fundamental factors of a clear identity of school
counseling profession, an on-going professional development of professional school counseling plus a highly
level of strong collaboration between all school stakeholders put together that will foster an outstanding
program of school counseling for the best benefits of students.
Conclusion
The authors found very little research on school counseling in Vietnam. Like many countries in the region,
the field of school counseling in Vietnam is in its nascent stage and the role of professional school
counselors is still ambiguous. Though it make take several years, the empirical agenda for MoET and
Vietnam educators and scholars are the formulation of an official national model of school counseling and
standards of school counselors. In addition, with the increase of school violence, student’s mental and health
have become a serious alert in Vietnam schools and families. Therefore, the majority of public schools have
urged MoET to provide immediate solutions: workforce policy of professional school counselors, adequate
funds to establish counseling offices, and professional training for school counselors, homeroom teachers, and
communist youth specialists. A formal national model of school counseling and standards of professional
counselors will ensure that Vietnam has more well-prepared school counselors, to improve the quality and
effectiveness of school counseling for the success of all students.
46 PHAM, AKOS
References
Alli, R. (2015). Implementation of the American School Counselor Association (ASCA) national model: A
framework for school counseling programs by high school principals in their schools (Order No.
3726698). Available from ProQuest Central. (1717897882). Retrieved from https://search.proquest.com/
docview/1717897882?accountid=34574
American School Counselor Association. (2019). The ASCA National Model: A Framework for School
Counseling Programs (4th ed.). Alexandria, VA: Author.
American School Counselor Association. (2016). The ASCA National Model: Implementation Guide:
Foundation, Management, and Accountability. Alexandria, VA: Author.
American School Counselor Association. (2016). Ethical standards for school counselors. Retrieved March
10, 2018, from https://www.schoolcounselor.org/asca/media/asca/Ethics/EthicalStandards2016.pdf
American School Counselor Association. (2012). The ASCA national model: A framework for school
counseling programs (3rd ed.). Alexandria, VA: Author.
American School Counselor Association. (2012). School counselor competencies. Retrieved March 10, 2018,
from https://www.schoolcounselor.org/asca/media/asca/home/SCCompetencies.pdf
Bui, M. H. (2014). History of Vietnam Education (3rded.). Hanoi University of EducationEducational
Leadership and Learning. University of Education Publishing House.
Camelford, K. G. (2014). The relationship between the implementation of the American school counselor
association national model and professional secondary school counselor burnout (Order No. 3583628).
Available from ProQuest Central. (1572226545). Retrieved from https://search.proquest.com/docview/
1572226545?accountid=34574
Cao, T. T. X., & Truong, T. T. T. (2016). Application of model theory in the establishment of a school
counseling organization in high schools. Innovative Education and Development of Trans-cultural
Workforce - Science Seminars Yearbook, 315-322. Ho Chi Minh National Universities Publications.
Carey, J. C., & Dimmitt, C. (2012). School counseling and student outcomes: Summary of six Statewide
studies. Professional School Counseling, 16(2), 146-153.
DeSimone, J. R., & Roberts, L. A. (2016). Fostering collaboration between pre-service educational
leadership and school counseling graduate candidates. Journal of Counselor Preparation and
Supervision, 8(2) doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.7729/82.1081
Do, V. B. (2006). The reality of counseling services in Ho Chi Minh City. Proceedings of the Conference
on Building and Developing a School Counseling Network (pp. 70-73). Hanoi, Vietnam: Ministry of
Education and Training.
Gysbers, N. C., & Henderson, P. (2001). Comprehensive guidance and counseling programs: A rich history
and a bright future. Professional School Counseling, 4, 246-256.
Gysbers, N. C., & Henderson, P. (2005). Designing, implementing and managing a comprehensive school
guidance and counseling program. In C.A. Sink (Ed.), Contemporary school counseling (pp. 151-188).
Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Gysbers, N. C., & Henderson, P. (2006). Developing & managing your school guidance and counseling
COUNSELING IN VIETNAM 47
program (4th ed.). Alexandria, VA: American Counseling Association.
Gysbers, N. C., & Lapan, R. T. (2003). The implementation and evaluation of comprehensive school
counseling programs in the United States: Prospects and problems. Professional School Counseling, 6,
222-227.
Han, V. X. (2008). Vietnam in 2007: A profile in economic and socio-political dynamism. Asian Survey,
48(1), 29-37. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1525/as.2008.48.1.29
Hepp, E. C. (2013). The secondary school counselor and principal preferences regarding key school
counselor roles (Order No. 3667105). Available from ProQuest Central. (1641140732). Retrieved from
https://search.proquest.com/docview/1641140732?accountid=34574
Ho Chi Minh Communist Youth Union (HCM CYU). (2019). The Resolution No. 04-NQ/TWĐTN-VP.
Retrieved from http://doanthanhnien.vn/tai-lieu/chi-tiet/1698
Ho Chi Minh Young Pioneer Organization (HCM YPO). (2018). The Resolution No. 04-NQ/TWĐTN-VP.
Retrieved from http://www.thieunhivietnam.vn/dieu-le-doi-tntp-ho-chi-minh-khoa-viii-giai-doan-2018-
2023-n504.html
Hoi, D. D., Son, H. V., My, N. T. D., & Vu, G. T. (2019). Factors affected the psychological trauma of
children living in incomplete families - The concern in Vietnamese school counseling. European
Journal of Educational Research, 8(4), 955-963. http://doi.org/10.12973/eu-jer.8.4.955
Huynh, K. K., (1971). Vietnamese August Revolution Reinterpreted. Journal of Asian Studies 30, 4. pp.
761-82.
Lashley, C. A., & Stickl, J. (2016). Counselors and principals: Collaborating to improve instructional
equity. Journal of Organizational and Educational Leadership, 2(1), 0_1, 1-24. Retrieved from
https://search.proquest.com/docview/1840949178?accountid=34574
Le, S., Le, H. M., & Nguyen, T. T. (2016). School Counseling: Fundamental Issues. Thanh Nien
Publishing House.
Le, M. C. (2016). Operational Model of School Psychology in 1-12 schools. Innovative Education and
Development of Trans-cultural Workforce - Science Seminars Yearbook, 221-231. Ho Chi Minh
National Universities Publications.
Le, T. K. D., La, T. B., & Dinh, D. H. (2007). Study of some factors that affect middle school students’
mental health. Proceedings of the Conference on Mental Health Prevention and Interventions for
Weinomese Children (pp. 35-42). Hanoi, Vietnam: Vietnam National University.
Lohia, A. R., & Singh, R. (2013). School counseling: A necessity in modern education. Indian Journal of
Health and Wellbeing, 4(5), 1212-1213. Retrieved from https://search.proquest.com/docview/
1615264150?accountid=34574
Low, P. K. (2014). Looking in from the outside: community counselors’ opinions and attitudes to school
counseling in Singapore. Pastoral Care in Education, 32(4), 295-305. doi:10.1080/02643944.
2014.974663
Martin, I., & Carey, J. (2014). Development of a logic model to guide evaluations of the ASCA national
model for school counseling programs. The Professional Counselor, 4(5), 455-466. doi:http://
dx.doi.org/10.15241/im.4.5.455
48 PHAM, AKOS
Martin, I., Lauterbach, A., & Carey, J. (2015). The identification of factors affecting the development and
practice of school-based counseling in different national contexts: A grounded theory study using a
worldwide sample of descriptive journal articles and book chapters. International Journal for the
Advancement of Counseling, 37(4), 305-318. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10447-015-9245-4
Ministry of Education and Training (2017). The Circular No. 31/2017/TT-BGDĐT guidance of school
psychology counseling programs for students in 1-12 schools. Retrieved from http://MoET.
gov.vn/van-ban/vanban/Pages/chi-tiet-van-ban.aspx?ItemID=1269
Ministry of Education and Training (2015). The result of the nation-wide conference regarding the
development of psychological counseling in 1-12 educational settings and collaboration between schools,
families, and society. Retrieved from http://pbc.MoET.gov.vn/?page=12.4&view=1091&opt=brpage
Ministry of Education and Training (2014). Enhancing the effectiveness of education quality for all levels
of students in national educational settings and vocational schools. Retrieved from http://www.
MoET.gov.vn/tintuc/Pages/tin-tong-hop.aspx?ItemID=4300
Ministry of Education and Training (2005). Official Letter No. 9971/BGD-DT-HSSV regarding the
implementation of school counseling programs for all levels of students. Retrieved from
http://www.MoET.gov.vn/tintuc/Pages/tin-tong-hop.aspx?ItemID=4300
Nguyen, H. T. (2014). The suggestions for developing a model of school counseling in middle schools. The
Vietnam Institute of Educational Sciences (VNIES).
Nguyen, T. H. (2005). Solutions for managing school counseling in middle schools in Binh Thanh District,
Ho Chi Minh City. The Vietnam Institute of Educational Sciences (VNIES).
Nguyen, T. H. H. (2016). School counseling at high schools in Ho Chi Minh City. Innovative Education
and Development of Trans-cultural Workforce - Science Seminars Yearbook, 232-243. Ho Chi Minh
National Universities Publications.
Nguyen, T. M. (2009). Building model of school counseling department in high schools. The Ministry of
Education and Training: Hanoi National University of Education (HNUE).
Pham, K. A. (2019). The Effective Model of School Counseling Recommended for Public Secondary
Schools in Vietnam (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Aspen University, Colorado, the United States.
Sciffer, M. (2015). The threat to the quality of school counseling service. Education Retrieved from
https://search.proquest.com/docview/1717033707?accountid=34574
Son, H. V., Vu, G. T., Thien, D. T., Luong, T., & Hoi, D. D. (2019). The stress problems and the needs
for stress counseling of high school students in Vietnam. European Journal of Educational Research,
8(4), 1053-1061. http://doi.org/10.12973/eu-jer.8.4.1053
Sink, C. A., Akos, P., Turnbull, R. J., & Mvududu, N. (2008). An investigation of comprehensive school
counseling programs and academic achievement in Washington State middle schools. Professional
School Counseling, 12, 43-53.
Sink, C. (2005). Comprehensive school counseling programs and academic achievement- a rejoinder to
Brown and Trusty. Professional School Counseling, 9, 9-12.
Taylor, W. K., (2013). A History of the Vietnamese. The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK:
Cambridge university press.
Received March 24, 2020
Revision received June 25, 2020
Accepted August 7, 2020
COUNSELING IN VIETNAM 49
The Government of S.R Vietnam (2019). Education Law No. 43/2019/QH14. Retrieved from
http://vanban.chinhphu.vn/portal/page/portal/chinhphu/hethongvanban?class_id=1&_page=1&mode=detail
&document_id=197310
The Government of S.R Vietnam (2009). The Annexation No. 44/2009/QH12 to the Education Law No.
38/2005/QH11. Retrieved from http://vanban.chinhphu.vn/portal/page/portal/chinhphu/hethongvanban?
class_id=1&mode=detail&document_id=92515
The Government of S.R Vietnam (2005). Education Law No. 38/2005/QH11. Retrieved from
http://vanban.chinhphu.vn/portal/page/portal/chinhphu/hethongvanban?class_id=1&_page=1&mode=detail
&document_id=14756
Tran, A. T. (2016). The Training Model of master’s degree for School Counselors in Vietnam: Real
Situation and Solutions. Research Journal of Hanoi National University: Educational Research No. 2,
83-95.
Tran, A. T. (2016). Career Guidance Counselors: Reality and Need. Innovative Education and Development
of Trans-cultural Workforce - Science Seminars Yearbook, 288-295. Ho Chi Minh National
Universities Publications.
Tran, K. (2016). Fundamental Issues of Educational Leadership and Learning (8thEd). Hanoi University of
Education Educational Leadership and Learning. University of Education Publishing House.
... Teachers and youth union workers do not have an educational background in health sciences, and school health workers are mostly doctors' assistants and nurses with intermediate and associate degrees (Viet Nam MOH and MOET 2017). Studies show that teachers and staff who are assigned to the counselor role cannot clearly define the responsibilities of a school counselor and have not been adequately trained in some specific skills, such as substance use, HIV/AIDS counseling, crisis intervention, and grief and loss counseling (Pham 2021). Many school health workers do not know the names of specific mental illnesses, although they can recognize signs of abnormal mental health in their students. ...
... In-school resources for psychology counseling are limited, and collaboration with external partners needs to be improved. 4 Furthermore, lack of recognition from parents and students is cited as another barrier to effective counseling service delivery (Pham 2021). ...
... There are, however, encouraging signs that such culture-specific frameworks are being developed. For example, the preliminary Vietnamese School Counselling Model (Nguyen, 2014(Nguyen, , 2017Pham & Akos, 2020) takes the cultural, historical and legislative history of Vietnam into account. There also exists a three-tiered counselling system in Singapore schools, which takes the cultural setting into account . ...
Article
Background School counselling in the Asia Pacific region has experienced enormous development in the last few decades but faces many serious challenges as counsellors seek to respond to the needs of young people in a complex and fast-changing environment. Aims This article aimed to explore the challenges school counsellors face in finding a clear identity and sense of purpose. Discussion We outline the antecedents and consequences of a weak counsellor identity. We suggest that the future development of school counselling in the region rests on responding to the challenge of school counsellors finding a clear and robust identity by (1) adopting an ecological perspective and (2) developing culture-specific, indigenous ways of counselling. Conclusion Given that the development of school counselling in this region has a long way to go, we briefly sketch some research priorities for the years ahead, which may contribute to the realisation and articulation of a stronger professional identity for school counsellors.
... The suggested lever F9 refers to the expressed need for more school counsellors in general to help students with their issues. These include the need for more school counsellors specifically in schools in rural areas as opposed to schools in urban areas (Pham & Akos, 2020) or at specific school levels such as primary schools (Harris, 2013). The suggested lever F10 refers to issues of professional motivation and retention, namely making sure the school counselling profession is attractive enough to encourage students to pursue this career, such as by providing a competitive salary, and to avoid school counsellors leaving the profession because of low job satisfaction. ...
... Furthermore, it should serve different age groups and take into account all talented categories. As well, more efforts must also be made to rehabilitate and train teachers and administrators who work with the gifted and talented (Elton, 2023;Krishan & Al-rsa'i, 2023;LeBlanc & Borders, 2021;Pham & Akos, 2020) whether before or during service which will improve the identification process by connecting and providing care programs and locations, allowing them to achieve privacy, and removing them from the decision-making process. on the methods of identifying the gifted and talented and provide them with all knowledge and practical experiences needed. ...
Article
Full-text available
Identifying gifted and talented students is one of the biggest challenges that face those working with them. As a result, the purpose of this research was to investigate the most effective methods of identifying gifted and talented students. Furthermore, the study employed both quantitative and qualitative methods. The study's sample size was 465 teachers and administrators, and the results revealed that the level of effective identification methods for gifted and talented students from the teachers' and administrators' point of view who work with them was moderate. As well, the findings showed statistically significant differences due to the gender variable in favor of males and due to the experience variable in favor of those with more than 10 years of experience. Furthermore, the study recommended using new technologies to identify gifted and talented students, as well as rehabilitating and training teachers and administrators on methods of identifying gifted and talented students, whether before or during their service, and providing them with all the necessary knowledge and practical experiences.
... School counselling is a growing service across many developing countries (Harris, 2013;Pham & Akos, 2020). Previous local and overseas studies have examined students, school counsellors, teachers, and education administrators' perceptions of school counselling services (Alghamdi & Riddick, 2011;Aluede & Egbochuku, 2009;Chen & Kok, 2015;Hamilton-Roberts, 2012;Harris, 2009;Khansa, 2015;Lau, 2009;Low, 2014Low, , 2015aLow, , 2015bQuinn & Chan, 2009). ...
Article
School counselling is not an isolated school-based intervention but rather as part of a more holistic social wellbeing system where there are many stakeholders. Studies have examined students’, school counsellors’, teachers’, and administrators’ perceptions of school counselling. Research that focuses on the perceptions of community counsellors of school counselling is rare. This paper reports on a quantitative survey study of community counsellors’ perceptions in Singapore. Findings indicate some expectations such as school counsellors could offer some family counselling and perceptions such as confidentiality could be strengthened in schools, were widely held among community counsellors. Findings also suggest deeper understanding of both school and community counsellors’ perceptions is needed to strengthen collaboration for better mental health support for children and youths.
... Though debate about school counselor role continues, the United States has a relatively well-established, standardized set of training expectations, especially when compared to other countries (Köse, 2017;Nguyen-Thi et al., 2020;Shi, 2018). Most scholarship suggest school counseling is a more emergent profession internationally (e.g., India, Israel, Vietnam; Akos et al., 2014;Heled & Davidovitch, 2020;Pham & Akos, 2020). International counselor educators looking to establish more consistency in training programs may consider CACREP or the new ASCA standards as a possible template to inform their country's own standards when coupled with a country's norms, values, and role expectations. ...
Article
Full-text available
Counseling and educational reform have been responsive to major societal change. This evolution is also reflected in counselor preparation. We examined changes in the Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs (CACREP) school counselor preparation standards over four decades in the United States. Constant comparative analysis revealed substantial increases in school counselor preparation demands from 1982 to 2016. Data suggest persistent increases in the array and breadth of competency-based standards, including emergent foci (e.g., crisis response, addiction). Future considerations around school counselor identity, expectations and professional collaboration in school counselor preparation are considered.
Article
Full-text available
School counselling has the potential to deliver significant support for the wellbeing of children. However, much of the research on school counsellors has been conducted in developed Western countries, with very limited research into factors influencing the effectiveness of counsellors in lower middle-income countries or in Asia. The aim of this qualitative study was to investigate the perceptions of Filipino counsellors about their roles, and factors that supported or impeded their effectiveness. Seventeen school counsellors in the Philippines were interviewed, and the data were analysed thematically. Our findings suggest that Filipino school counsellors often carry out dual roles, experience a lack of role clarity, and are systemically disempowered in their schools. Relationships with school principals have a significant influence on counsellors’ roles and positioning in schools, and therefore on their effectiveness. The ability of principals to foster a school ethos supportive of counselling is essential in enabling counsellors to leverage the multifunctional nature of their work, become embedded and centrally positioned in the school community, and enhance their effectiveness. Doing so can enable counselling to be more culturally accessible to young people.
Article
Full-text available
Domestic violence, separation and divorce are becoming increasingly common and leaving psychological traumas that are not easily healed for family members, especially for children in Vietnamese incomplete family. In this article, we identify the factors affecting the psychological trauma of children in the incomplete families by using Achenbach T. M's Children Behavior Checklist (CBCL). We design 2 experiments and 3 steps to filter the main factor affected the psychological trauma of children living in incomplete families. In results, we found out that up to 46.42% of children had psychological traumas when living in incomplete family with an extremely high level of 8.16% and an average of 57.14%. The results showed not only by living in incomplete family but also other factors such as the pressure from public opinion and community affected the children psychological trauma. It is necessary to minimize the effect of psychological trauma of children in Vietnamese families.
Article
Full-text available
The correlation between the stress problems and the needs for high school students' stress counseling in Vietnam is an unspecified issue that deserves attention. This study was conducted to test the hypothesis that there was no correlation between the stress problems and the needs for counseling of high school students in Vietnam. Survey of 1,200 high school students in Vietnam from grades 6 to 12 with questionnaires, the results show that the mean score of stress problems in high school students is 2.67-corresponding to moderate level. Different levels of learning and living conditions are encountered in different student's stress problems. The mean score for high school students' stress needs of counseling is 3.18-corresponding to the optional level. Different levels of education have different needs for stress counseling. There is a strong correlation between high school students' problems and needs for stress counseling. The more problematic high school students experience in stress, the more they need to be counseled on this issue.
Article
Full-text available
A grounded theory methodology was used to analyze articles and book chapters describing the development and practice of school-based counseling in 25 different countries in order to identify the factors that affect development and practice. An 11-factor analytic framework was developed. Factors include: Cultural Factors, National Needs, Larger Societal Movements, Models of School Counseling, Laws and Educational Policy, Characteristics of the Public Education System, The Counseling Profession, Research and Evaluation, Related Professions, Community Organizations or NGO Coalitions, and Local Stakeholder Perceptions. The utility of this analytic framework in promoting understanding of the development and practice of school-based counseling in individual countries and in facilitating comparative analyses across countries is illustrated.
Article
Data utilization is a key component of school improvement as data can be used to enhance student achievement both systematically and on an individual student level. Through systemically analyzing multiple sources of data, educators can make informed and knowledgeable school improvement decisions. In order to effectively make data-drive decisions that enhance student success, a promising strategy is the partnership, collaboration, and shared decision making between the school counselor and principal (Finkelstein, 2009). This relationship can help advance the effective utilization of data for school improvement, as both professionals utilize leadership skills in order to foster student growth and performance. In this article, the authors address aspects of the partnership principals and school counselors could form to develop the school's data utilization practices and thus enhance the capacity of teachers and other school personnel to improve the performance of students in the classroom and on standardized tests. The article begins with a discussion of the current interest in principal instructional leadership as a factor in school improvement. The authors then turn to the capabilities of school counselors and the roles they might play in collecting, analyzing, and interpreting student data as well as more effectively utilizing their knowledge and skills to work with teachers, other school personnel, students, parents, and community members. Next, they offer recommendations for creating a collaborative working relationship between principals and counselors to use data more effectively to improve classroom planning, instruction, and assessment; motivation and classroom management; and school climate and behavior management. Journal of Organizational & Educational Leadership, 2(1), Article 6 http://digitalcommons.gardner-webb.edu/joel/vol2/iss1/6
Article
In this brief article, the author responds to Brown and Trusty's assertion that based on the deficiencies of existing comprehensive school counseling program (CSCP) research, school counselors need not focus their time and effort on showing causal connections between their programs and measures of student academic achievement. Rather than defending the specific merits of the CSCP research, this rejoinder article addresses (a) the larger issue of whether Brown and Trusty have mischaracterized a key underlying results-based assumption of CSCPs, as well as (b) the value of multiple research paradigms in CSCP evaluation studies, and (c) the importance of systemic thinking and collaboration within CSCP research.