Content uploaded by Victoria Modupe Philips
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Victoria Modupe Philips on Aug 19, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
SOCIOLOGY DEPARTMENT
HONOURS
RESEARCH PROJECT
SOC 8X01
(2017)
INCLUSION AND EXCLUSION IN HIGHER EDUCATION
Title: What are the factors influencing discrimination against
International students in South Africa?
Prepared by: VICTORIA MODUPE OLABOYE (217066651)
SUPERVISED BY: DR KEZIA BATISAI
|
|
Acknowledgements
!!
"#!!$%
&&&
'$()
*(!()+(!
, |
TABLE OF CONTENTS
,
-
'.
/0
'1
&+23
.24
.24
&2,
#25
- |
/26
$43
44
41
-2
'-,
#--
.-5
1 .Introduction
&211-!&)!.
!
) & "432278%! 6333
&)!!-333/!
5 |
! "4334%!
!
9+
&)
!
"4334%&))
:);
)!
)
#"2184%<&"4324%!
+)
: "4334%!
)
9 * !
' . "4330%! 9
= ! +
!>!+)?
.)!)!$@')
+ ) ' .!
6 |
A'A"4330%!>&;
B &+ )
AAC"4330%+
))C
)A"4330%!/'"211-%!('"4336%!
9 ! =
=D>
! "4336% "A < "4330%!
!!
D> "4336%
= )/9
"4336%+
!
2 Problem Statement
&))+;
."4322%!/!
7>
#">&)%!#!E!&;'!
0 |
+ ! FF
!+F."4322%
)
"21807-12%! # !
+! !!!
#!
!
!"*
%
) "2180G-12%!!
!
!;!!!:;
9:<
A < 'A "4330%! "/ < '% "211-%! ' "4333%! # < & "2112%
)
!!
!!;!
>H">H%
>H
>!=
)
8 |
>!
&)
>H
>H
&)
=F&)I9
,Literature Review
3.1 Definition of Discrimination
'9F9)&"2114%!
9 C
!!
/!
3.2 International Students
*!&)!:
(@# "432472%
/ "433172-%
1 |
&)!&
)+
3.3 Historical overview of discrimination against International students in higher education
&F83!+!
* "2183*< 2186%!+
F#9B$!
C ! "43387 2-6% J
!;
;))!
.!!<!"432,%'!#!<!"4323%.<K!"432,%
+!>&!/!
9F9F!9;9
!!
:
?)
).!"4332%;
:
)$C"433-%! $"433-%!$"4323%! "H433-%!
K!)!H)*
."4336%H!/ C"4330%
9 !; 9
23 |
>+++.
A'A"4330%'."4333%+
!
& )
!+&)
) "4323%4323%!;
2113!&)+)
&!:#
"4333%$!&)))"4322%$"2118%
#"2118%!$&):
)$ "4333%!
!!
? $9 "4332% 9
;
)
; ! K! $A=! . #
"$2118G.A "4333%
) J@ "4338% . $# &#
@/@!
+!+!+=$!&
22 |
) ) >
>! "4323%!>&)+
3.4 Sex and Discrimination
.;
;(
=*+!L'"4336%!
/"4333%!H
H*!
+!H!
$"2115%!+
9#=!H
!
)) "2118%!
>E!!
< (!$
+ )
! !
:
"432,%!$=
!=
24 |
+ + (
+ < : <
; L < ' "4336%!
!"2111%! E< "433,%! *+! >E
+ + ! ! ! ; =
!!!
&! );
) + ) (
!#!
"E< !433,%&!H
+ + CH
"/!4333%!!=
"!433-!$!2115%+
! !
::
+&
+ >& * !
+ "*! 4332%
&! "'! 2114% + !
2, |
:"'4331%!
"/!210-%
3.5 Race and Discrimination
)!&)
&)$
"4335G23%!&)
#"#%"4322G26%!A>
;
==*!
&)!
&)"4335G-21%!
*!H"211-744,%+
&);!J)J
3.6 Religiosity and Discrimination
<9H/"433,%!
+45M
.("4335%+
7+9
2- |
.G.G'
G 9 G ) ;
*! ( "4335%!
"2111%! >&
7JBG
F9G ) !
$!9"4334%
* C
9+!(!"4335%!+<
7 . " #! 2165%G
. ! 4 G
. " *! 2180 ! 2108%G &
G&
"/!2108%G$
"$!4334%
3.7 Languages and Discrimination
E"4335%
E"4335%!/<'"211-%
$ "4332%
9+/<
25 |
' "211-% $ "4332%
+D>"4336%
!/!E"4335%
C#"433,%,04
@!
>&!)!#!;&!
& ) " 24 ; < : *
+!; !!
!
=&)
3.8 Socioeconomic factors and Discrimination
) 9 )) "4332%!
!
B C !
= ! = (! &/ "216-%!
!
N E
=9
')"433-%;
) !
26 |
;<+;
+ < *A
"4323%! ; A
+;)!+
! )!
9
!*!
:
9
A;C&"4333%!!
/ )
! )
+ ! =
;+
:
3.9 Conclusion
)+&)!
+
20 |
O=)!
!
+ $ !
!
.>&!!A
>&A>
&!$;&!!&!'!
&!P=!#!!
>&!!>&;
"!#!*4320%+
!
= ) +
! +
!9+
! +! ! ! 9
!!+!;
Q&)!
:=
28 |
4 Hypotheses
1 Sex is an independent variable and discrimination of International students in South Africa is a dependent
variable.
+&)
4 Race is an independent variable and discrimination of International students in South Africa is a dependent
variable.
&)
,&)
Religiosity is an independent variable and discrimination of International students in South Africa is a dependent
variable.
- &
)
Language is an independent variable and discrimination of International students in South Africa is a dependent
variable.
5 There&
)
21 |
Socioeconomic is an independent variable and discrimination of International students in South Africa is a
dependent variable.
5Research Design and Methodology
52Study Design
+ = >H
9L
!
" <$!4331740,% $
+
>H/!
>H ) E
"&!432574%)
*!
7+!!;!"%"
%
) ) =
==
43 |
"<*A!43247,83%)=
;== ; '
7+!++
>H
&&
&4-"&&&4-%
5.2 Ethical issues
.9
"<*A!43247232%!9
!
$ !
"<*A!4324723
42 |
6Profile information
2&+
44 |
&+
Image 1 Q
6626M,,8-MQ!
>H&Q=Q
+
4, |
4.
Image 2 ) )
8,28M015M#553M
O) 3,2M ! >H & 9
)=
4- |
,important of religious belief
Image 3
Image 3 -8,4M!4328M
248-M03,M!
!1-8M
-/'
45 |
Image 4 !
,138M&
,2,8M!@2085M!R-,2M
!,38M!)
314M
&
46 |
Image 5 Socioeconomic status
Image 5 $ = ,538M !
,3-6M
O9
2-00M9
285M!)314M
+3,4M
7 Hypothesis Testing
40 |
*!>H9
&)=46
= + 4 9
!!
>H9
)!
+! !"%!;
;=! !E; .!
7.1 Sex and UJ undergraduate sociology students’ perception towards factors influencing discrimination of
international students in South Africa.
/ 2 + >H
&)
:=+!+
L4"+%=462"&)+
%
/7 9 +
&)
/7 9 +
&)
48 |
/2#;&=A
+
=462"&)+%!
';=
"@ <>!432076,%A+
>H2
+ = 462 " & ) +
%
Sex * Use of South African languages excludes international students
Crosstabulation
>&)+
+
+
+
+
+
&+ $ # 26 ,3 ,4 25 20 223
M&+ 2-5M 40,M 412M 2,6M 255M 2333M
* # ,, ,5 82 ,6 ,2 426
M&+ 25,M 264M ,05M 260M 2--M 2333M
# -1 65 22, 52 -8 ,46
M&+ 253M 211M ,-0M 256M 2-0M 2333M
41 |
) 2 "S,46 = & ) +
S426 S223412M9
+,-0M+
Table 2
Chi-Square Tests
D
)
& "4;
%
#;&= 6-83- 266
'. 6,41 - 206
';;'
)
524 2 -0-
D# ,46
3 "33M% + 5
+2643
)4;;=3266T335we do not reject
!9+
&)
7.2 Race and UJ undergraduate Sociology students’ perception towards factors influencing discrimination of
international students
,3 |
/47 >H
&) This hypothesis was tested using chi –square because race is a nominal
category, which means that it mutually exclusive. Queson 2 (indicate your race) and queson 26.2 (There is signi"cant "nancial support
available for internaonal students) was used to test this hypothesis.
/7 9 &
)
/7
&)
/4;=+
;=43M!,,M!;
= +43M!"@<>!4320765%
=4)),
=464 "
%
,2 |
Race1 * There is financial support for foreign students (eg: bursary) Crosstabulation
"7%
+
+
+
+
+
.2 ) # ,- -1 85 63 -2 461
M.2 246M 284M ,26M 44,M 254M 2333M
) # - 23 4, 2, , 5,
M
.2
05M 281M -,-M 4-5M 50M 2333M
# ,8 51 238 0, -- ,44
M.2 228M 28,M ,,5M 440M 2,0M 2333M
,7#
),!S,44!S461) S5,O)!
C ,,5M +
!))
-Chi-square tests
Chi-Square Tests
D
)
& "4;
%
#;&= 5814- 430
'. 650- - 263
';;') 203 2 683
D# ,44
3 "33M% + 5
+645
; ;= 430 T 335 we do not reject
!
&)!>H
,4 |
7.3 . >H 9
Hypothesis 3: There is a relationship between religious affiliation of the undergraduate students, Sociology
students at UJ and factors influencing discrimination of international students.
/7 9
&)
/7 9
&)
/,; = A
"%=46,"
%!';=
A
! = =46,
/+;=43M
,,M!;=+43M!
"@<>!4320765%#
;#
,, |
5
Religious Afiliation * I am open to being friends with foreign students Crosstabulation
+ +
+ +
+
.) ;# # - - 1 26 48 62
M.) 66M 66M 2-8M 464M -51M 2333M
# # 26 4, -, 86 16 46-
M.) 62M 80M 26,M ,46M ,6-M 2333M
# 43 40 54 234 24- ,45
M.) 64M 8,M 263M ,2-M ,84M 2333M
# ; #
;# "-51M% ! #
,46M!
;#
#
6
Chi-Square Tests
,- |
Chi-Square Tests
D
)
&"4;
%
#;&= 4280- 032
'. 4201 - 03,
';;') 606 2 -22
D# ,45
2"233M%+5
+,05
6;==46,"
;;=032T335
! the null hypothesis is not;335!
9
&)!=46,"
%
Hypothesis 4 / >H
!;=
,5 |
/,
;
=A
"%=46-
&)%!';=
A
! = =46-
/+;=43M
,,M!;=+43M!
"@ < >!4320765% / @ !
))
,6 |
/79
&)!
/7 9
&)
)
+
+
+
+
+
/ @ # 48 2, 24 4 , 58
M/ -8,M 44-M 430M ,-M 54M 2333M
) # 2 , - , 3 22
M/ 12M 40,M ,6-M 40,M 33M 2333M
!!!
R
# 02 02 56 40 40 454
M/ 484M 484M 444M 230M 230M 2333M
# 233 80 04 ,4 ,3 ,42
M/ ,24M 402M 44-M 233M 1,M 2333M
0>H
!!-88M@
,0 |
&)!,24M)
&)
Chi-Square Tests
D
)
&"4;
%
#;&= 283-38 342
'. 28836 8 326
';;') 0333 2 338
D# ,42
5"2,,M%+5
+23,
6;==46-"
&)%;;=
342T335!we do not reject the null hypotheses ;
335! 9
&)!
=46,"
Hypotheses 5: >H
&)
/7 9 ;
,8 |
&)
/7 9
&)!
Correlations
* ;
ENU * ;
## 2333 314V
&"4;% 3-6
,45 ,42
## 314V2333
&"4;% 3-6
,42 ,4,
,1 |
&N * ;
## 2333 22-V
&"4;% 3-4
,45 ,42
## 22-V2333
&"4;% 3-4
,42 ,4,
V#335"4;%
&9 E9; ;2W2! ;2
W2 3 !
&9 "3-6% E9 ; "3-4%
"%!;2!
;E9;3-63-4&9. ;E9
;&.35!reject!
"% >H 9
! 9
&)&>HI
8Interpretations of the findings
+>H9
C "432,%!
-3 |
$ =
!=+
+(
+<:<;
)+2=
+!
&)
!!
! 9
);)9)
*!;E
9
!'!)"433-%;
)!
; <
+ ; + <
*!E"4335%!/<'"211-%
$ "4332%
9+/<
' "211-% $ "4332%
+D>"4336%
!
+!!!!
&)
23Limitation of the study
-2 |
>H
)>H
C9!+
9>H&
!!!!
=!
=!
=! $!
!
=!
23 Recommendation
>H
99!
!!
=
===!
22 Conclusion
>H">H%!
!!
$+ >&)
>&$+
>H!!>H9
&)/!&
-4 |
) A ; $!
+ +! A !
+
!
! +!!;'
;!!=
=>H9)
+!!!
&)
References
)!&)H.4332#Quality in Higher Education0"2%755:6,
)! ! !#4322R79
Politikon ,8"2%751:8,
)!2110#Canadian Journal of Counseling ,2"-%7451:40-
)!#G!@G<!'"433-%>I)$
"$%+>Australian
Journal of Education!-8"2%!-0;6,
-, |
!&4323The challenges of transformation in higher education and training institutions in South Africa$7
&)
! 432,F 97>E
Journal of Studies in International Education 20"2%75:28
!HC!E!>!$! !<$!"2180%# International Migration
Review, 21!-12;522
! "4334%F)7>&9!International Educator, 11",%!24:20
!)4323I>K&)Sociology --"4%74,,:
453
AA!#PHC4330H9+!!
College Student Journal -2",%76,2:6,1
/.C2118Prohibited person: Abuse of undocumented migrants, asylum seekers and refugees in South
AfricaP7/.C
!)433-H!I#
Chronicle of Higher Education 53",8%7),0
-- |
!)$433-K7 International Education
Journal 5"-%75-3:552
#! / < &! $ "2112% ) Journal of Multicultural Counseling and
Development, 21"-%!20,;282
#!H'E21119 Journal
of Travel Research ,0",%7456:466
#!)2184&Psychological Bulletin 12",%75-3:504
#! H 4333 7 $! + & ) International
Migration ,8"6%723,:2,,
!.)$4332C+7;&)
Africa Today -8"4%7225:2,0
@4332National Plan for Higher Education7@
!.HA4335*7@!
Africa Insight ,5",%721
-5 |
!@H*4322/+&)7)&>
South African Journal of Higher Education 45",%7-63:-05
*! "4332% * &N +
>")@.
)!&!C)!)23;2-
*!H.<@!'"2183%7$!!!+Annual Review of Sociology!
6!2;43
*!''.4336&)@)9!!
=AJournal of MulticulturalCounseling and Development ,-"-%7438:444
*! !<!)"2118%!7CI
E)*<$ "@%!Teaching and learning in thecollege classroom "5;20%>&.!H7
#
/!./ "210-% &@+# #
&&)
/! & "4336% ! ! 7
Journal of Studies in International Education!44"2%!0;22
-6 |
/!.'!<'!/."211-%#)7Journal
of Multicultural Counseling and Development, 22!0:26
/! #HG#!'.G*!'$!4331& !!
=@H@=D&!41"23%7021;04-
/.CQC.Q211874,2;481
@4324 Open doors 2012: Report on International educational exchangeC!
#7@
H!@!$'/ #C43309;
>&7)!
!!International Journal of Intercultural Relations ,2"5%7635:64-
E4334>@*;*$2,
EX! !#)!H*$E/4335
>EBritish Journal of Psychology 16",%7
'!)"4333%@.#!,-"2%!48;-5
-0 |
'! # / H *A 433- ) 7 Higher
Education Research and Development 4,"4%728,:218
'!HH!<.!#"4330%C)I Higher Education,
53",%!,82;-31
'! *!<#!@ "2116%# <H"@%! Counseling
across cultures(!#)7&
'!!#!C!<!H"4323%97)
#Journal ofStudies in International Education, 14"-%!,81;-35
$C! 433-*>Chronicle of Higher Education 53",6%7)-5
$!&!#!@&/*;$4323International student security#7#
>
$! .! ! $! ) C . 4333 & )
On borders: Perspectives on International migration inSouthern Africa!216:428P7&$9
-8 |
$!)2118F()97# H
Ethnic and Racial Studies 42"6%72226:22,6
(@#"4323%Education at a glance 2010: OECD indicators(@#
(!$<'!#"4336%>7C
Journal of Instructional Psychology, 33",%!420;444
A!&$'A4330)+7)
)Journal ofPsychology 2-2",%746,:483
.!$!$'!&H&4333!
7)= Higher Education Research and Development
21"2%781:234
. !.!Q4322#7'@;4@#!
&C'++
&! .! <Q! & "2114% )
;7H7H#02"2%75,;51Q
-1 |
!)433,*7Journal of Studies
in International Education 0"-%7,01:-3,
D>C"4336%7!7>
4332(K$@
C#! !&!<*!)"4332%The psychology of culture shock "4%'7.
53 |