Content uploaded by Michael Samers
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Michael Samers on Jul 09, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
Towards an economic geography of FinTech
!"#$%&%&Progress in Human Geography
I. Introduction
'!!(!)**&
++,-'.",.!
/0++-'+
%&)1!!
+-'
/2-'
3,.)*$1,.
%&)4/-'
+""++
!!/'
-'+!!+
!5
/
-'/-+
%&)&6!+%&)&%&)$!-'
!7)/$!784! %&)*/)-'!
!(2-9
++!+!
2-9/'-',.5
+
:!/-
)'-'/;
!//<%&)*/
)
-'inter alia !
+,./
2-'.3
+,-'9!.:
/0+
-'+3=!
+-',.
,.!/2+
-'/
II. Making sense of FinTech
0+
!" 2!
!/ -'+,
.!!+
!3,".!
!+
-%&&1/ /%&)8,-'.
)**&9",-'9.
%&)&/'-'>?
@/A/%&)4+-'>?+
@/18/,'.
,.+‘to
improve’.+
/'-B%&)C!-'>!
DE+!@/C/'
5+-'
!/-'!!
"!!
-'/'!
+-'!
%
+%&)C/-'
/
2!-'+
,-'9!.+
+
!-)/'5!
5!-'/F!!
5/0-'!
:-'
/-!!!!
!,!.<%<
+/-!"!
,!". 2,!./2
!"!//!
!
-'!//
G'!B
%&)C/;+
-'+,.9!!+
5/'++++
++:
+++/-+5
++!:/
HH-)II
III. Emerging academic literature on FinTech
;+-'+!
/'5longue durée +
-/ /%&)8!)*!
-'%&&$,-'A/&./2
A
!!J+not
!/5+
!!"
+""
!3!","!""
!.%&&$!/2B
""!//KB%&)$/
L!,!"".
!-!3"<F +
35
%&)%6!B%&)C/ -'!!
-%&)%/
- #%&)4!+
<F !!!,.
!/-
9%&)4:+-'"+
9.,./'+"
9++!
!:interessement!:/9%&)4+
-'3,"./2+
tabula rasa "+
5!
!++92
!" -/
"-'
//M/, %&)$6%&)46K'%&)C/5
-'"
+!+,!.
-"'",./-5M/%&)$
5"-',".
1
,!./'-'+
.!+!:-'
",.+!
!/
:5
%&)C!/ !!
/M+K'%&)C9
9B FN !!
!-'"!"3
"/
!/'
!%&)&
,!./ +!
59et al/%&)*60et al/%&)*6KB%&)*/
M+!/
0et al/%&)*!
=5!!:
/':
!+
"!/-
%&)C!
+!
5+
!/M+
:/
-'
"+:!
+ /%&)86%&)%6%&)46'<
%&)C/-+!!(
!
8
'<%&)C=)))/G9%&)4+
"%&&$="!
"/'+-'9
+9"!
-'+"
,."+
0O(9%&)8/
-'%)!!+
"! /%&)8/
2+
-'//M!/%&)*6M/%&)$6%&)C
/25+
!5+/
IV. Economic geographies of FinTech: two themes
-'!+
+
-)/'
++=!+
,./
G!+
-'++!
!+
++!:!!
!5+3+-'
/'-'+
!+<N!+
-N/
2++
+"/
4
-'!!
/'":
F
/'<%&)C5
+,".+"//
!!+!!+"
!"!/'+
!!F++
!!/;+
+F
!./F"
!3+P!!
(+ %&)C/'
!.++"
+
+L%&)4/
'!!+,.,.!+
+
/-5+.
"++"+
!'<%&)C/B
!+.!
-5!+
!3/-5.!"
"+!"!
/'B%B"
+-5+/
-'!+!+/G
+
!3+
C
+9L%&)8+
5/;
+!!:!
"+!B
%&)C6%&)*/ -55!
+,.+-'/0
+-'9!-)
/'!
+!
,".!+!
-5.+!++-5/
-'+:+
<N/
;+!!+-
!/'++
2
,.<N/-9."#/
+-''2"!
"
<%<+/B+
2!#
!C/9
:!
#'%&)$/'+! !!M
+ +!
!!. -+
!!.:9%&)$/
'-'
!++/
0!5-'!
!:
:/ ,."
$
!+
+!/'!!+
-' - -! :
B 'B !!'/'B'
:
5%&)46%&)C!/-
(!
:!!
/2
,.!!+
!!:!
+/95,.
-'+
!+:+
"5!
M!/%&)*/-
- B '"+:"5
/'
,.<N/
-'+
!!!!+/
2-N++=
/'
:-N+financial
+++-'/0
9/%&)1!//+
-N
-'/22-9(
+
+/G!M!/%&)*+
*
"!+-N
::
/B5-'++
++2-9
:3+++
-'/0
!
++90(%&)$6'%&)8
-':/G"
+9
%&)&6/%&)4/F-'
!!
6-'
+(2-9"/--'
+5
+-N/-B
!+-'!"
"+
+
/'+N-'!
,.+-'%&)4/'
+!B
-%&))6M/%&)1/
"(+
!
+/
!:-N5
0(9%&)86%&)$!
!-'+(
)&
!2-9+/-'
!!2-9N+L5!
M++!
+!!2-9/
-'!
,!5.!+-2
-';+
+5!-'%&)$/M
/%&)*!-'!2-9
/'B,-"'"
.+!+
B/0+
"B!
:-'/M!/%&)*++
55"!"
"!(
5+
!!/'!+N+L
-!"
"!!
/
;-N/9
::+-'
!:++
!+0O(%&)C/'
+!2'"
5+5:
+!/%&)$!"
-'!/'
!+
(/N+G<
))
<%F5-'
9%&)C/
!+!%&&$!
+!
3Bet al/%&)C/0-'5
!++0F-%&)C
!+!!!
++!5
!M/%&)*/'+
/':5
!!+
/'!-'+
/2!
:B'BB-'9!/'
+!+B'
-!.,!.9
!!9.+
+/'
+"! - "Q"!:9B '
B'!
9+
+9M+/'
+-'+
+
!+!+!+6
+)**&)**8!
M%&))
+%&&$9/%&)C/
0<N
5."
)%
+5
!+-'/0!!!+"
-'"5
!+"+
+/
-',.="R
2+55-)+!
-+-'/-"
!!!B%&&*/0
+=5+-,.
6++-,.
!(+,.!
/;++
!-
-!/0
,.,!.!!,!.
+(!+5+
/
->@
+'<%&)C=%6':%&&$6#
%&)1%&)46S"/%&)C6+// /
%&)C>?@
/%&)$=%&/'%&)4!,!
.,!.!!,.B%&)$6#
%&)1T+%&)%,+./ 0B
%&)C,.,.
!!+
+/+ / %&)C
-+"+3
/
)A
B+-5
+0B%&)C/9%&)4,.
!!6
++/,-.!
+!+/
+!(+
!!"!+
//!"
//0
B%&)C/,.5
formalB%&)$!
!+U/
%&)$!.
30B%&)C/
'5+0B.
%&)C,!-5.+,.)1&%/0
++!!"
,.-.!+
+/0+
3+3/ 0B
%&)Cis !!+!
/'!" +++
))V%&)1%)V%&)Cwithin =
!!)8V9 G!CAV
/G+
,".A N 0B%&)C/F
"!-'!,.!-K
'%&)C/2%)V++! !
%--// /%&)C6#%&)462G9%&)$62-%&)$6
/, %&)$6B%&)$6;/%&)C/'!
+ 0B%&)C!-5/
A +!,.,".
/'!
/
)1
++!"
0B%&)C/'!+
,.!5,!.
,.!,!!.<%&&4/'
3=5+-!!
,:.!,:./03
!3/
B"
+!+!*V
%&)C!/+!
+)AV
/',".+
0B%&)C/
-"
!!
1&VK!
/%&)C60B%&)C/2
+- /%&)C
!/9!-#
.%&)4<F ++-!)*1&&&
%V,5.>)$8&&&+
+!@/)%$*
!5B/%&)*/
B -9'!
"/1 !!'!!
,.!9!/'!
+'!+/2
+,.
!!+"
!//%&)$'!!!
1'"++59
/ 0B%&)C,9.
!!09+!+-+!
/
)8
+
+%&&&/
2-
N;"!
!/-!!+!+
B/%&)*6B%&)*%&)*!69 <%&)$6-%&)$/2
!!+
+!"/2"<F !+
."+.+
"<F +/ +!+7878&&!!
+B/%&)*/':
!+!"!)%VA)V
9 <%&)$/ %&V
)4V!+
!/
!!5
"3
!+"/93B/
%&)*!(!!:
:/
!9 <%&)$
3-/ !
+!+ %&)$/
!!5!"
+3!
++-
0;%&)$/2!!++
+5"!!P
+-!/M+
!-5!
+,./
)4
0P!
5-++/
-B%&)*!"-"
,".,!"./0
+!!
/M+
-providers!!,!.,."
3"/',!.
!+
+
5,!.,./,.
,.-/B
+strictly!(
,+.,.
5!!/G++
-+P"!5
-/ !%&)$>'
!!++!!!
@/%1$/95-++"
G9 +#%&)46
!%&)$/!"
!!<!
!+P,.
+/'
++,<!!.!
P"!!%&)$/'3!
-+
/2P
"+
!!3
)C
:-!
-/'3
!!/
0-+
!B%&)$6/%&)$6B%&)$6
%&)46K%&)$/!B%&)C+-!
!!>T
T-<5@/1%1/'+"
:-',.
B/%&)*6+%&)$6%&)*6:%&%&/'
!!++
+,".+%&)8"""+B%&)*
/ :+
;+T:
-'"+/9
5+/;
!,.3::
!+,./
!>+"@!
B%&)C=1%*++-'!+
+,.+!B
%&)8/'!B%&)C=><+"
@/1%1/',!.!(
!(/
!B.5!
3P,./'-
!,:.++ 2
5
/%&)$/2+!,.
-<%&&4:
)$
+::+5+
,./
;35+-+hegemonic
:+
+:/-:!
9%&)86M%&))6<<%&)&!+
-/.%&))-:>
++@/CC*
and groups/ +
!(R0-
+/<B%&)*+
+!!:!+
-'.5
++/
3+-
!//:<%&)46<%&)A+
, 9.//;
%&)C=8&1/G+"+
+!+!
-/-
5%&)C!
"+!2"+B"
Reuters%&)*/
'33-
!/!
!as defined by the World Bank
!/0!!,
.+':9++5!
P"3
!!!3/
Conclusions
)*
2+++5
-'/0!-' 2"
!!/0
,-'9!.+-'
/
0++-'=
!+
/-<N-N!"
-'/0!!!!+
/5
!+
+!
+++!+/
':
!5
+/;+<N
:+!platforms+"
!
!
R!!!!
+
M!/
%&)*6+%&%&6KB%&)$++
:/G+
2-9-'
++++
:
2-9/2((-N
-'!
"M!/%&)*/'+
%&
//++2'!
"!!
!!3</
%&)4/
2!
-
!0B/'
/M+3
Bet al%&)*3!+
+/0!
R2
!!!
+5
++
3-!+!
!/'-
+3!!+
::6!+
6+-"!!
, 9.!" 6+
-+!
/
0-',+.+
5!+-'
++++
-'(
/;-'P5
2<;!-00%&)$
3
,.
PKB%&)$/0
%)
!5+
!3!
-'!/2
+ -%&)*
/%&%&69%&)*
+-'"!
P5/
+-'!
++
+-'!
!+!,./N+
-'+
+!/
References
%&)* !%&)$+9
6B5!-!%8
=PP+//P+P!"""""%&)$"+"
"""""""""""""
!5"!/C#%&)*
G%&)C, .=9!/Competition & Change
%)1=%C1"A&&/
F 92<9M#%&)C'!
+"+"/2
G9;+92
=PP///PP<!P+P!P!P
A4**P/51%&%&
B< #G%&%& =<
‐‐!/Transactions of the Institute
of British Geographers18%=1%&"1AA/
%%
00B!#NBG<%&)8'F-'= N+<"9
<RM-+G<N/%&)8P&1C6
N0+G<N/%&)4T4%=PP/P!W%4C488A
)C %&%&/
#G:: %&)$RProgress in Human
Geography1%)=%8T1A/
B!N%&)*2+
R9#."<!
Science/Review of African Political Economy/14)4)=1$&"1*8/
BG%&)C,9!.BIS Quarterly Review/
!%&)CB2
=PP+++/!/P!P3PX3)C&*/)C-!%&%&/
B%&)*'R<
:/Review of International Political Economy%48=$)8"$A$/
B%&)*!'!=,-.
:/EPA: Economy and Space8)C=)11%")18*
B9/%&)8B5:
/Economy and Society111=84C"8*)
BG-%&))'
/Journal of Economic Geography))%=%*8TA&C/
B<' %&)C,-!
+!.NBFG0<%A%$$
=PP+++/!/PP+%A%$$8#%&)$/
B/%&)$U<,U./Economic Affairs/
A$A=1&4"1%)
9%&)CWorld Fintech Report 2017=PP+++//PP"
"+"""%&)CP8#%&)$/
9-'<9%&)* +!"!
=9Y/Telematics and Informatics
A4=88"$)/
%A
9L0O(F/%&)$International Financial Centers: After the Global
Financial Crisis and Brexit/;5=;5</
9 <%&)$ 9G=2B+':
2/;!!=PP+++//PPP"
""""":) %&%&/
9%&)4---=-9/Economic
Journal *A=%%8T%A*/
99%&)$ !!A&+MB(!"Alizila1#
=PP+++/:/P"""A&"+"""!(P) %&%&/
9B%&)8':. Dialogues in Human Geography8%=)$A"
%&&/
9B F%&)CMoney and Finance After the Crisis:
Critical Thinking for Uncertain Times/9=0"B+/
99%&)*</Review of
International Political Economy%48=$4A"$$8/
9N<L0(%&)12-!<
N+/Regional Studies1$8=C4)"CCC/
9NLM09%&)8Global production networks: Theorizing economic
development in an interconnected world/;5=;5</
9<9%&)&,F=G
"./2=BGGF/The Handbook of
Evolutionary Economic Geography/9=F+F/%A*"%4&/
S" %&)C-+=
+/<G0<$&1&
=PP+/+!/P!PP)&*$4P%41C*P0<$&1&/R
3W)C#%&)*/
99' %&)$- - !!.'!
"M+/2=GF
Handbook of Blockchain, Digital Finance, and Inclusion, Volume 1 Cryptocurrency,
FinTech, InsurTech, and Regulation.=FP </
%1
#':9 %&&$!!=
/Asian Journal of Communication)$1=A)$"AA%/
!GBG%&&*!<-
9=+/
Third World QuarterlyA&C=)%AC")%8$/
-/;%&)$":.
Reuters%8/
-%&)* ="
/Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space/F!)
%&)*/;2=)&/))CCP&A&$8)$Z)*$148)1/
- %&&1 '+R'+:
/Review of International Political Economy))%=%4A"%$$
- 0+'/%&))-:-:/
Progress in Human GeographyA84=C*$"$)*/
-B-!B%&)C-!-'
.%C#%&)C
=PP+++/!/P+"PPG%C&4)C/C#%&)*/
!B%&)C'=
/New Political Economy%%1=1%A"1A4/
!<#" %&)C--'=
/Journal of Business Economics/$C=8ACT8$&
!<G#<90!B0%&)$;-G=
2-2'-
/Journal of Management Information SystemsA8)=%%&"%48/
M!"!0O(%&)*
= !+/Geoforum)&4=)4C")$)/
M%&))2=9/
Progress in Human GeographyA8%=%A1T%18/
MG93<%&)1 FF
!F</Regional Studies1$C=)%*8")A&C/
%8
MGB%&)$' :=9
!.!-'/Finance and Society1%=)8*"$&/
MGB%&)*!+
=9-!/
Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space/F!))N!
%&)*/;2=)&/))CCP&A&$8)$Z)*$$C*4C
2-%&)$-=PP//PRWF89 BCF" 89 "1$*%" 4F "
8*$B814A A19) %&%&
2G9%&)$F5+/;+=2G9/
#0'%&)1G=.!
/American Economic Review)&1)=)$AT%%A/
#0'%&)4'"!/Science
A814A)C=)%$$")%*%/
#%&)49=!!
/Canadian Journal of Development StudiesAC)=$AT)&&/
KM#%&)$!
/Electronic Journal of Information Systems in Developing Countries$1=)"
)C/
F0O(%&)C=
+:/Regional Studies8))=))4")%C/
<%&)*The Pulse of FinTech 2018-!)A/<2/
=PP/P55PPPP%&)$P&CP""")"%&)$/
) %&%&/
N%&)C0!!!
RThird World QuarterlyA$$=)C)&")CA%/
!/%&)$>2+[@=/
Economic Anthropology8=%1CT%4&
<L%&)$=9 +!/2=9L
0O(F/International Financial Centres: After the Global Financial Crisis and
Brexit/;5=;5</)81")$)/
%4
<L%&)$! +T!
+/Dialogues in Human Geography$A=%$8T%$$/
<L-,-'='P"R.2=5"M#
0O(F/The Routledge Handbook of Financial Geography/=G/
%&)*B='
/Review of International Political Economy%48=C*&"
$)1/
< %&)C9:+='
+/Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space1*8=
)&)*")&A*/
< %&)C!<=:
/Finance and societyA)=))"A)/
BG%&)$M5!
G9RFinancial Innovation18=A")*/
)**82/Progress in Human Geography)*1=
8A)"81A/
' %&)40<)4A=!=!
!: /Afrobarometer/
:<G%&)4N!9R >
!!@ /2=#/The Postcolonial World/=
G/
B%&)%!=999<
/Journal of Development Studies 1$8=8$*T4&1/
+F%&)82=9
!+,N.,./Progress in Human Geography1))=)&$"))C/
+F%&)$22=-:/Progress in Human
Geography1%%=%41"%C1/
; %&)C',.=
/Review of African Political Economy11)8A=1**"
8&*/
; ;'0%&)C!=
!RReview of Development FinanceC=%*"A8/
%C
<-K0O(%&)4'9=
+/GeoforumC8=)1$")8$/
< <#%&)&F:/Economic Geography$4
)=%*"8)
<%&&4'!!! =G
!2-2!
=PP+++/+/PPPP""""!"
""!"!""""%&&4X&/) %&%&/
<N%&)AB\\!\/2=/<N
Neoliberalism Interrupted/=</
G%&)*\3 %/
+#%&%&'2=<N+G
9/Antipode8%%=84%"8$&/
)*$1Method in Social Science/=M/
<%&)4'B= -/Journal of Innovation
Management11=A%"81
G9:595F/%&)4Handbook on the geographies of
innovation/9=F+F/
LM%&)4 :9.-2< T
N+'/Telecommunications Policy1&=)4$T)$)/
#%&)$B!' /The New Times#)$/
#<%&)*%/&=
RReview of International Political Economy%48=$$4"*)&/
N%&)4Platform Capitalism/9!=</
:<L%&%&2!/2=
<K+NF/The Routledge International Handbook
of Financialization/=G/%$$"A&&/
' %&)$#/ !!/Marketing$
#=PP+++/"/P(""""""
""!!P) %&%&/
%$
'<#B%&)8World City Network: A Global Urban Analysis/%/
N+L=G/
'9M<#%&)C'-'G-G='9
;"9-/Asian Journal of Law and Society1=)&*")A%/
''%&)4'N++
!/Business Insider Nordic4!=PP/!/P"
"("""+"""!"%&)4")%) %&%&/
0LMMB"<%&)*!
=+/Supply Chain
Management%1)=4%"$1/
0O(9#%&)8,9.R9!!
-N+/Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers1&1=141T
1C$/
0B%&)CGlobal Findex Database.0=0B/
0F-%&)CBeyond Fintech: A pragmatic assessment of disruptive potential
in financial services%% =PP+++/+/PP!"""
"""""""%&-!
%&%&/
0;#%&)$+.!2>
G@/Information Technologies & International Development )1=
AAT1C/
LM%&)4Strategic Coupling: East Asian Industrial Transformation in the New Global
Economy/2=9</
K'%&)$B!!/Review of International Business and Strategy%$)=
)*"A1/
K''F%&)C'<-F=N/
Contemporary Economics))1=1)8"1A&/
K B#%&)$N+R'B
+/Geoforum*4=%1$"%88/
%*
Acknowledgements
F+8!9F
9,F<N+-.+!
!<N+9N<N]N
!N+--/0+
/0+
/ !/
A&
