Content uploaded by Grant Silva
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Grant Silva on Jun 22, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 1/9
Public Philosophy The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order
Public Philosophy
The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order
by Grant J. Silva
June 8, 2020 0
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 2/9
George Floyd’s murder at the hands of the Minneapolis Police Department has ignited nationwide protests against
police violence. Within these protests, the movement for black lives (#BlackLivesMatter) plays a central role. Much like
the protests themselves, to assert that “Black lives matter” is an act of defiance against our nation’s history of white
supremacy and the blatant disregard of black lives by law enforcement. Police violence visited upon black bodies
remains a central component of this nation’s unjust law and white supremacist order. One need only reflect on the
numerous black people that have had their rights denied, been murdered, beat, and disproportionately incarcerated,
to realize that there has been no greater acolyte to white supremacy than law enforcement.
The slogan “Black lives matter” is an ontological, moral, and political exclamation that humanity happens in black. From
this point of view, to treat black people as expendable objects that feel no pain and lack reason; to ignore their cries for
their children and mothers as their airways are closed and blood flow restricted; or to shoot them multiple times for
taking a jog or while sitting in their home, is a crime against humanity. While it might seem odd to need reminding that
humanity happens in black, the vociferous criticism of this movement, which takes shape in the counter-slogan “all
lives matter,” demonstrates that our nation is unaccustomed to recognizing, and indeed many refuse to acknowledge,
humanity in nonwhite terms.
Many who reject “Black lives matter” also assert that “Blue lives [i.e., law enforcement personnel] matter.” This should not
come as a surprise. The lives and, more importantly, livelihoods of law enforcement agents owe a great deal to white
supremacy. The imbrication and codependency of blue and white lives was laid bare in W. E. B. Du Bois’s important work
Black Reconstruction in America (1935). In the second chapter, while examining the material conditions that allowed
chattel slavery to flourish in the southern United States, Du Bois juxtaposes Southern slavery to that in the Caribbean. In
comparison to Haiti, why didn’t the United States experience more widespread slave rebellions? In “the West Indies,” Du
Bois explains, “the power over the slave was held by the whites and carried out by them and such Negroes as they
could trust.” In the South, by contrast, “the great planters formed proportionately quite as small a class [as in the
Caribbean] but they had singularly enough at their command some five million poor whites; that is, there were actually
more white people to police the slaves than there were slaves.” This additional five million poor whites differentiated
slavery in the South by providing the enforcement mechanisms that prevented widespread slave revolt. As Du Bois
puts it, slavery was “held stable and intact by the poor white.”
Given that poor white labor was often pitted against slave labor, one might think that impoverished whites would resist
lending a hand to the cause of slavery. However, Du Bois reminds us, some whites actually came to benefit from this
situation, both economically and socially, as an instrument helping to keep slave rebellion in check. By protecting and
serving plantation owners, poor whites acquired jobs and a sense of superiority “as overseer, slave driver, and member
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 3/9
of the patrol system.” These support roles bolstered the vanity and esteem of impoverished whites, not to mention their
pocketbooks, by associating them and their interests with the slave-master class. This superiority and esteem
contributed to the primitive accumulation of value that remains invested in whiteness today—an investment kept alive
in appeals to Southern “heritage,” “tradition,” and other dog whistles for white supremacy—as well as in the phrase “all
lives matter.”
The value of blue lives remains roughly in the same derivative state today. The importance attached to blue lives is an
extension of the pre-existing value ascribed to the prevailing social order, which is predicated on white supremacy. As
agents of “the law,” which itself harbors ideological proportions (Du Bois offers the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 as example
but one can easily add the Black Codes and Jim Crow), blue lives remain committed to keeping wealth and property in
the hands of those who have it and protecting it from the hands of those who do not. One need only consider law
professor Cheryl I. Harris’s important 1993 essay “Whiteness as Property” together with the protection of private property
as one of the central purposes of government in order to discern the role of law enforcement within the racial state.
If, as Michelle Alexander writes in The New Jim Crow, there are more black people in jail and prisons today than there
were slaves during the height of chattel slavery, then law enforcement is the middle term that unites the formal end of
slavery with the emergence of a racialized carceral system that preys on people of color. This truth, in so many words,
is what the protests we are witnessing today cry out against.
Insofar as blue lives gain value relative to the prevailing social order of white supremacy, then police officers are used
in similar fashion as poor whites were during slavery. In arguing this, I am not offering a victim narrative for blue lives.
Instead, I seek to critique the social conditions leading to the devaluation of black lives, especially at the hands of law
enforcement. If, as the protestors remind us, police violence against blacks is the problem, then philosophers and social
theorists must examine why people become cops in the first place. Is it akin to the poverty draft—the claim that poor
people enlist in the military because of limited economic opportunities? Are working-class and poor people, white and
nonwhite, lured into careers in law enforcement by decent salaries and benefits, augmented by overtime pay? Like the
Southern poor white who garnered a sense of self-worth and stock in whiteness by serving in a slave patrol, what
psychological propensities (I am tempted to say “pathologies”) incline recruits to a career in law enforcement as it
happens in our racialized setting today? What makes an adult want to join the force today, knowing full well how it
takes part in the oppression of racialized communities? We need answers to these questions.
To change this dynamic, law enforcement agencies must move away from policing communities to building
community—an abandonment of domination for a democratic sharing of power. But the inertia of the prevailing social
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 4/9
order and its investments in black criminality makes this shift difficult. In Black Reconstruction, Du Bois notes that as
vagabond or thief, a “negro” threatened society. Whites tolerated this threat, however, because it reinforced the
patronizing dimensions of slavery. As “an educated property owner, successful mechanic, or even professional man,” a
free black person contradicted and undermined the institution of slavery. Such an individual was proof that slavery
rested on a noble lie. Underscoring the importance of black lives by shouting “Black lives matter” is an affirmation of
humanity that runs counter to the narrative and value hierarchy of the unjust prevailing social order—not to mention
the enforcement system that it depends upon.
To be fair, we must not place the full burden of racial injustice upon blue lives. As Plato identified in The Republic, justice
at the macro or political level manifests in the justice of individuals, the micro level. The same is true of injustice. If our
polis and the work of its guardians are built upon racist foundations, we will also see that racism manifest in the actions
of its individuals. One telling example is the intentional sublimation of any talk of lives mattering away from a particular
referent (in this case “black”) by substituting a generic “all.” When has someone ever uttered “all lives matter” in a non-
reactionary way? Is it not always a response to the attempt to underscore the value of black lives? By striving to
undermine a claim for basic recognition and minimal levels of respect, does this not make “all lives matter” a not-so-
silent accomplice in our society’s current value hierarchy?
Many people object to the movement for black lives because it expresses value for black people in a way that is not
contingent upon and does not first pay homage to white life (this is not to say it devalues white life!). Even the phrase
“Black lives matter, too,” I argue, betrays the central premise of this movement since it renders the value of black lives
an afterthought or addendum. The radicalness of “Black lives matter” is that it transcends the economy of value that
has undergirded race relations in the United States.
By “economy of value,” I mean a system operating according to a zero-sum game, a situation where the elevation of
some requires the denigration of others. For instance, while some might respond to this blog post by saying that police
violence has also targeted Irish, Italian, and Eastern European immigrants, once the preservation of the prevailing
power dynamic required their incorporation into the category “white”—as Khalil Gibran Muhammad outlines in his 2011
essay “Where Did All the White Criminals Go?”—these groups too were able to climb the social ladder on the backs of
black people. This is to say, while many people are comfortable talking about social value abstractly, it has never been
anything but concrete. The history of citizenship law and immigration policy, racial segregation and Jim Crow, racial
covenant clauses on deeds of homeownership, disparities in terms of salary and wage earnings, employment rates
and opportunities, health care and general wellbeing, access to nutritious food and education, disproportionate
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 5/9
incarceration rates, life expectancy, and more, all speak to the value historically invested in white lives. Value that
required the exclusion and domination of others.
For those who have been taught to see race from within this particular value system, “Black lives matter” cannot be
interpreted as anything other than a threat to the status quo. They cannot see race without a racial hierarchy that
favors white lives. Enamored by the “all” and cognizant of the economy of value that has given shape to our nation’s
moral arc, those who refuse to say “Black lives matter” know that value is meaningless when it lacks a particular
referent. Their logic then becomes, “If I [whiteness] cannot have it, then nobody can.” “All lives matter” cannot be excised
from white racial normativity, the type of which mistakes itself for all of humanity.
Race relations in the United States did not have to unfold in a zero-sum manner—indeed, I often challenge my students
to imagine race in a different way. Is it possible to see race outside the optics of white supremacy? I also ask them to
imagine policing and law enforcement divorced from its investments in black criminality (not to mention Latinx illegality
—but that is a whole other issue). Given the historical modalities through which it has taken place, could policing
without racism occur in the United States? Perhaps most important of all, as the increasingly desperate responses to
the George Floyd protests make clear, might militarized police violence be the wake-up call many (sadly not all) whites
need in order to see that this system predicated on the devaluation of black lives will quickly turn on them too if they
choose to unite their interests to the wellbeing of black people? Perhaps the structure that should be burned down next
is the corrupt social one that gives value and takes it away in order to keep itself alive.
Photo: George Floyd protests in Washington DC’s Lafayette Square on May 30, 2020 (Rosa Pineda, via Wikimedia
Commons)
Grant J. Silva
Grant J. Silva is associate professor of philosophy at Marquette University. You can find him on Twitter
@elprofesorsilva.
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 6/9
TAGS Black Lives Matter Editor: David V. Johnson George Floyd Grant J. Silva justice law Michelle Alexander Plato police race racism
Republic slavery W.E.B. Du Bois
PREVIOUS ARTICLE NEXT ARTICLE
RELATED ARTICLES
Public Philosophy Public Philosophy
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 7/9
Public Philosophy COVID-19
COVID-19 Public Philosophy
TOPICS
APA
Black Issues in Philosophy
Blog Announcements
COVID-19
Diversity and Inclusiveness
Graduate Student Council (GSC)
Issues in Philosophy
Member Interviews
Philosophy in the Contemporary World
Public Philosophy
Recently Published Book Spotlight
6/8/2020 The Lives that Matter in the Prevailing Social Order | Blog of the APA
https://blog.apaonline.org/2020/06/08/the-lives-that-matter-in-the-prevailing-social-order/ 8/9
Research
Service
Teaching
Teaching and Learning Video Series
Women in Philosophy
Work/Life Balance
Search
Advanced search
POSTS YOU MAY ENJOY
Student Snapshot: Cappagnia-
Lynne Chase
Cappagnia-Lynne Chase is an Oneonta native.
She is majoring in Theatre and minoring in both
dance and philosophy at SUNY Oneonta. She is
also...
Member Interviews
Elyse Purcell & Sean Petersen -June 5, 2020
Why We Shouldn’t Shrink
Our PhD Programs
Issues in Philosophy June 4, 2020
Mitigating the Harms:
Policy Possibilities under
the New Title IX Rule