Available via license: CC BY 3.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science
PAPER • OPEN ACCESS
Toxicity and Effect of Chemicals in Skin Care Products on Human Health
To cite this article: Wenxin Liang 2020 IOP Conf. Ser.: Earth Environ. Sci. 512 012081
View the article online for updates and enhancements.
This content was downloaded from IP address 181.214.191.193 on 18/06/2020 at 18:08
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution
of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
1
Toxicity and Effect of Chemicals in Skin Care Products on
Human Health
Wenxin Liang1, *
1Faculty of Science, Hong Kong University, Hong Kong 999077, China
* Corresponding author: 1109037678@qq.com
Abstract: Chemicals in skincare products are very critical because they not only have an
influence on the safety of cosmetics but also on all aspects of the human body and life. For
sensitive skin, a particular type of skin that should avoid cosmetics containing harmful
chemicals, it is significant to evaluate the toxic and protective mechanism of products by using
scientific methods. Besides, using the experimental data to explore the protective and toxic
effects of functional skincare products on sensitive skin is more clear to clarify the
pathophysiology, biochemical changes and particular clinical manifestations of skin diseases.
These phenomena occur after the skin contact with chemical substances, and the dynamic
process of the chemicals damages the skin barrier and percutaneous absorption. By observing
the performance and improvement of sensitive skin protection before and after the experiment,
the research evaluates the toxicity of the different chemical substances in skincare products on
sensitive skin. The research in this article is also helpful for people to use skin care products
reasonably and promote skin health.
1. Introduction of sensitive skin and cosmetics
Sensitive skin is a kind of skin with extraordinarily sensitizing and highly intolerant to any slight
external irritation and is prone to itching, tingling, burning, and tightness. The clinical manifestations
of sensitive skin are mainly subjective sensory abnormality, lack or slight objective symptoms, high
sensitivity, poor tolerance, and strong responsiveness [1].
With the widespread use of cosmetics, various problems have also appeared, such as low quality of
cosmetics, excessive levels of toxic substances, the addition of glucocorticoid-prohibited drugs, and
consumers' failure to choose cosmetics based on their skin type. Hospital visits make the appearance
of cosmetic dermatitis endless in the crowd. Cosmetic toxicity, in the broad sense, refers to abnormal
changes in the physiological state of the skin caused by the use of cosmetics. It mainly manifests as
cosmetic photodermatitis, irritating cosmetic dermatitis, cosmetic allergic contact dermatitis, cosmetic
hormone-dependent dermatitis, and cosmetic pigments. Also, cosmetics may cause abnormal
dermatitis and hair damage. The narrow sense of cosmetic dermatitis refers only to cosmetic allergic
contact dermatitis and cosmetic irritant dermatitis [2].
In future research, there will be more studies about the pathogenesis of sensitive skin and the
ingredients in cosmetics that cause the formation of sensitive skin, providing compelling evidence for
the development of more sensitive cosmetics for sensitive skin.
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
2
2. Recognition of sensitive skin
2.1 Concept of sensitive skin
Sensitive skin refers to a state of skin hypersensitivity that occurs under physiological or pathological
conditions. It is common in young and middle-aged people, and the disease site is mainly the face.
Common symptoms of sensitive skin include flushing, erythema, itching, tingling, irritation, dryness
and discomfort, desquamation, palate, fine pimples, and exudation. Patients often show heat sensitivity,
sometimes even simple skincare products and water cannot tolerate, rash repeatedly and challenging to
cure so that many patients show anxiety and anxiety.
The epidermis of sensitive skin is very fragile and inelastic. Although the appearance looks white
and tender, it is susceptible. This kind of inherited skin is sensitive to fragrance, and many cosmetics
cannot be rubbed. When the skin exposes to wind and sun, clothes are too tight, friction, impermeable
substances, alcohol, the perfume will make a sensitive situation more dangerous.
2.2 Causes for sensitive skin
This hypersensitivity of the skin results from a decrease in its tolerance threshold [3]. At present, the
cause is not clear, so that it may be a widespread phenomenon caused by various factors such as
internal and external causes. Different factors can explain it:
- An inflammatory reaction develops when skin contact with irritating chemicals such as soaps,
household detergents, or pollution.
- The altered barrier function of the epidermis. This phenomenon then promotes dehydration of the
skin and especially the penetration of potentially irritating agents.
- Psychological factors like stress.
- Hormonal factors (menstrual cycle, menopause).
- Physical factors: sun, temperature changes (hot/cold), wind, air conditioning, heating, hard water.
3. The Judgment of sensitive skin
The judgment of sensitive skin can divide into subjective judgment, Semi-subjective judgment, and
objective judgment according to its mechanism [4].
3.1 Subjective judgment
Subjective judgment mainly takes the form of a questionnaire. Its accuracy is affected by the design of
the interviewer and the interviewee. The questionnaire should contain any information that may be
relevant, such as slight damage (roughness) of the skin to dry and cold weather, sunlight, sweat,
skincare products, housekeeping products, jewelry, fabrics, wool. If the facial skin is prone to redness,
dryness, tingling, burning, itching, and discomfort; if people have a history of adverse cosmetic
reactions, a history of dermatitis and eczema, a history of asthma or hay fever; investigators must be
fully trained to master the investigation skill.
3.2 Semi-subjective judgment
The methods used for semi-subjective evaluation are skin chemical probe tests, including lactic acid
test, chloroform-methanol mixed solution test, dimethyl sulfoxide test, and skin response test. There
are two representative methods for testing lactic acid. In the first method, researchers apply aqueous
lactate solution to the cheek and wipe with a cotton swab on the face with room temperature. In the
second method, the researcher makes the subject sweat in a room with low relative humidity and then
apply aqueous lactic acid to the wrinkles and nose, lips, and cheeks. Finally, researchers use
sub-methods to assess the tingling of the sum. It may sound subjective, but the results are very similar
to reality. It is considered highly reproducible. The test response of lactic acid is closely related to the
season. For example, it is more severe in winter in summer, which indicates that the increase in skin
tingling may cause by dry skin in winter. However, in winter, dry skin may lead to increased skin
tingling and impaired barrier function, and highly sensitive nerve sensory signals.
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
3
3.3 Objective judgment
Objective judgment is to use biomedical engineering technology to evaluate subtle changes in the skin
through non-invasive techniques. For example, the experimenter can use the water vaporizer to
measure the water loss of the skin, measure the biophysical parameters of the skin, and use the
ultrasonic scanner to check the thickness of the epidermis, dermis and subcutaneous tissue. In fact,
measuring skin transepidermal water loss is the most classic indicator.
It is common to use human skin testing. However, other methods are also useful, Including patch
test, light patch test, forearm control use test, tape test, repeated stimulation patch test, cumulative
stimulation test, chamber scratch test, and improved soap chamber test. The experimenter can use
different methods according to different experimental purposes. For example, complete and
standardized test patches help diagnose and distinguish between allergic contact dermatitis and mild
irritation. Furthermore, in addition to "irritating responses," key forearm-controlled trials are useful.
Besides, in vitro tests such as collagen edema tests, elevation tests and tests have positive clinical
significance in assessing chemical irritation.
4. Explore the protective effect of functional cosmetics on sensitive skin
4.1 Observation objects and groups
The observation objects were 114 patients who were diagnosed with facial allergic skin disease in the
outpatient department of Renmin Hospital of Wuhan University from July 2008 to May 2009, all of
whom were female [5].
Group A: purely topical functional cosmetics, 31 cases-group A: Apply functional products every
morning and evening after cleansing. Using Avene Water Spray (150ml Avene Shu Spring Water
Spray) to spray the surface and pat gently for absorption continuously. Then experimenters applied
Avene Moisturizing Toner (200ml Avene Moisturizing Toner 200ml) with a cotton pad (Avene Fine
Pressed Cotton Pad (50 pieces)) on the face, and applied Avene Living Spring Repair Moisturizing
Cream (Avene Living Spring Repair Moisturizer Cream 40m1) spreading on the face;
Group B: pure external topical non-hormonal drugs (Shu Fulin Ointment (butylated
hydroxybenzoic acid)), 37 cases, Shu Fulin ointment was applied topically after cleansing, once every
morning and evening;
Group C: 46 cases of topical non-hormonal drugs combined with functional cosmetics, based on
group A plus Shu Fulin ointment for external use, once a day in the morning and evening.
4.2 Statistical methods
Statistical methods: SPSS13.0 statistical software use for analysis. Counting data compare using the
X² test. Measurement data were analyzed by using t-test. P <0.05 was considered a significant
difference.
4.3 Observation indicators and judgment standards
4.3.1 Observation indicators
The clinician evaluated observation indicators before treatment, 24 hours, seven days, and 14 days
after treatment. Actual index evaluation content: erythema, edema, dryness, desquamation. Subjective
index evaluation content: itching, tightness, tingling, burning.
The index was evaluated by a semi-quantitative grading method: 0 points: none; 1 point: mild; 2
points: moderate; 3 points: severe Symptoms and signs improvement index (SSRI) = (points before
treatment - points after treatment) / points before treatment × 100%. The scores of various indicators
add to the disease score. Efficacy index = (pre-treatment disease point - post-treatment disease point) /
pre-treatment disease point × 100%.
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
4
4.3.2 Evaluation criteria of curative effect:
Clinical cure: efficacy index> 90%;
Significant effect: The efficacy index is 60% ~ 90%;
Improvement: curative effect index 20% ~ 59%;
Ineffective: efficacy index <20%. The curative effect is mainly a clinical cure, and the curative
effect is significant.
4.4 Treatment results
Table 1 shows the improvement of the SSRI scores of the individual symptoms and signs in the
functional cosmetic group and the non-hormonal group alone.
The results in Table 1 suggest that the dryness, tightness, and burning of the face in the pure topical
functional cosmetic group were significantly better than those in the non-hormonal drug group alone
(P <0.05); the facial edema and erythema in the non-hormonal drug group alone were improved. The
improvement of desquamation signs and tingling sensations was significantly better than that of the
pure topical functional cosmetics group (P <0.05); there was no significant statistical difference in the
improvement of pruritus symptoms between the two groups.
Table 1. symptoms and signs SSRI scores after treatment in 2 groups of patients
The use of functional cosmetics can significantly improve the therapeutic effect and speed of
symptom relief of non-hormonal drugs alone and can be promoted and applied clinically, becoming a
safe and reliable auxiliary treatment method. Moreover, most of its active ingredients are highly safe
and have no toxic side effects. Not only can it alleviate the symptoms of the disease, but it can also
effectively restore the skin's water and oil balance, improving the appearance of the skin, maintaining
the health of the skin, and improving the quality of life. For healthy skin, it can reduce irritation,
maintain natural skin barrier and balance, and resist external stimuli; for sensitive skin and problem
skin, it can reduce skin sensitivity, play an auxiliary drug treatment, and reduce the use of drugs for
disease outbreaks.
5. Toxicity analysis and recognition of chemicals in common skincare products
In the past, people's skincare mainly used natural raw materials (such as plant and rock ingredients). However,
since the 20th century, the petroleum industry has greatly developed, and petrochemical raw materials used
widely in our daily life, for example, most cosmetics and daily necessities are made from petrochemical raw
materials.
Hazardous substances in cosmetics mainly come from chemical raw materials and excessively added banned
restricted chemical substances. In fact, some manufacturers did not strictly implement the requirements of the
Cosmetics Hygiene Regulations, resulting in some unqualified cosmetics entering the market. After using these
unqualified products, the light ones will cause skin irritation, erythema, and edema, which will cause obvious
damage to the skin and mucous membranes, and the serious ones will cause teratogenesis and cancer. China's
"The Cosmetics Hygiene Regulations" stipulates lead content ≤40 mg / kg; mercury content ≤1 mg / kg; arsenic
content ≤10 mg / kg.
The fact is that the ingredients in cosmetics are straightforward to get into the skin and blood. Once these
substances enter the body, they can damage the endocrine and nervous system and may cause reproductive,
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
5
reproductive and developmental problems. The following are common chemicals in daily personal care and
hygiene products, to understand their toxicity to human health.
5.1 Sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) and sodium lauryl ether sulfate (SLES)
SLS and SELS are surfactants. Twelve sodium alkyl sulfate (SLS) is also a strong ionic sulfate surfactant. It has
excellent detergency and is found in many foam cosmetics in shower and bathtub, using as a foaming cleaner in
industrial cleaning products [6]. Sodium dodecyl sulfate is an anionic surfactant used in cosmetics with detergent
properties. Therefore, it is very common in body wash and shampoo. However, it is produced by ethoxylation
from sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS), which is a very polluting chemical transformation. Furthermore, sodium lauryl
sulfate is less irritating than sodium lauryl sulfate. Although the latter is more natural and recognized in the field
of biotechnology., it is possible to soften and increase its foaming ability due to chemical conversion.
Sodium dodecyl sulfate, being harmful to the liver, can be absorbed by the skin maintaining in the body.
However, its carcinogenic effect has not been confirmed.
Overdose can cause difficulty breathing, and when swallowed, sodium lauryl sulfate can cause nausea,
vomiting, diarrhea, and oesophageal irritation.
5.2 Phthalates
Phthalates are used widely in nail polishes, hair sprays, perfumes, lotions, deodorants, and humectants. For
example, they are used as plasticizers (thinners and softeners). In addition, they have many other uses, such as
retaining color, making nail polish brittle and preventing fixative from making hair too hard. However, people do
not always find them on labels.
In 2002, three American Consumer Associations issued an alert: many cosmetics contain phthalates.
Therefore, these potentially toxic substances have been banned from using in toys since 1999. However, these
harmful health chemicals have been found in dozens of deodorants, shampoos, varnishes, and other moisturizers.
When Phthalates are ingested during pregnancy, it is very harmful to the development of the male reproductive
system.
5.3 Fragrances
Fragrances often add to the daily deodorants, perfumes, and colognes that people usually contact. Furthermore, it
finds in almost all personal care products, including soaps, shower gels, shampoos, creams, lotions, and
humectants. Therefore, fragrances are essential additives. This chemical is contained even in products labeled as
odorless or fragrance-free.
One reason why it is more difficult to know exactly what the chemicals contain is that cosmetic
manufacturers have so-called "rights" to protect their trade secrets, which gives them the right not to disclose the
full list of ingredients, so consumers sometimes do not know what they are buying. Does the cosmetic contain
fragrance? However, usually, these chemicals are not tested for toxicity individually or in combination.
Studies have shown that skin irritation, and runny nose is often associated with the use of fragrances.
Perfume is one of the main allergens in the eyes of the chemist. Maybe not everyone knows how harmful
fragrance is to skin. The essence itself is a mixture consisting of artificial or natural spices which are also a
variety of chemical components, and some of them are mainly allergens and even carcinogenic.
5.4 Mineral oil
Mineral oil is a highly hydrophobic and occlusive fatty substance (waterproof) derived from hydrocarbons (coal
or petroleum distillates). Because it prevents water from evaporating, it moisturizes by indirect action. It is
widely used in a variety of skin creams and moisturizers, as well as in hair care products. However, mineral oils
are often susceptible to contamination by polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (HPA). Long-term exposure to these
substances’ links to cancer. What is more, HPA can also cause allergies and skin irritation. There is a standard
for acceptable daily intake's mineral hydrogen carbon. For lip products, people should use no more than an
acceptable daily intake (ADI). Eating natural mineral oil is toxic because it settles and accumulates in the user's
stomach. People need to avoid using all kinds of balsam and lipstick whose ingredient is mineral oil. Therefore,
breastfeeding women should avoid using all the cream on their chest when they are in oral contact with the baby.
5.5 Lead
Lead and its compounds are prohibited substances in cosmetic components. As impurities, the content
of lead in cosmetics must not exceed 40 mg/kg (based on lead). However, except for hair dyes
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
6
containing lead acetate, the content must be less than 0.6% (Pb) in hair dye products. Lead can
increase the whiteness of the skin in cosmetics, so the lead generally adds to whitening and whitening
cosmetics.
Lead is toxic to all living things and its compounds and itself are harmful to human health through
skin absorption. They mainly affect the hematopoietic system, nervous system, kidney, gastrointestinal
tract, reproductive function, cardiovascular, immune and endocrine systems, especially fetal health.
The main clinical manifestation is neurasthenia syndrome caused by central nervous system
dysfunction. According to the Safe Cosmetics Campaign, lead can cause learning and behavior
problems, reduce male fertility, cause hormonal imbalances, delay the onset of puberty in girls, and
late development of testicles in boys. In fact, most lipsticks contain lead. It should note that there are
no safe levels of lead in the blood, and even low concentrations can cause damage.
5.6 Formaldehyde
Formaldehyde, this dehydrogenated alcohol is an antibacterial preservative, and it is also the first
group of substances classified by the International Cancer Research Agency as carcinogens for
humans, especially the respiratory tract. For the respiratory tract, the residual effects of formaldehyde
in the human body are acute and chronic exposures, which have irritating effects on the eyes and
respiratory tract. Formaldehyde is also a source of nasopharyngeal carcinoma, a strong skin irritant,
and allergic compound, often associated with adverse reactions (contact dermatitis or asthma).
Except for uses that are still very common in nail hardeners, it scarcely uses in cosmetics. Our daily
formaldehyde content is shallow, so the formaldehyde-releasing agent content is different. If the
content of formaldehyde in cosmetics is more significant than 0.05% in finished products, it must
clearly state on the label.
6. Effects of skincare products on sensitive skin
6.1 Harm of cosmetics to sensitive skin
Cosmetics induce the formation of sensitive skin. With the widespread application of cosmetics,
various problems have also appeared. For instance, people may face the risk of buying the low quality
of cosmetics with excessive levels of toxic substances. After people use it, the main negative effects
are cosmetic photodermatitis, irritative cosmetic dermatitis, cosmetic allergic contact dermatitis,
cosmetic hormone dependent dermatitis, and cosmetic pigment. Abnormal dermatitis and hair damage
caused by cosmetics. Various factors cause skin sensitivity, and their clinical manifestations are also
different, most of which are subjective sensory abnormalities [7]. For example, the most common
subjective feelings are itching, burning, tingling and dryness. Although different individuals have
different manifestations and different degrees, most people will have corresponding skin discomfort or
skin intolerance after using cosmetics.
People with sensitive skin will have more or less skin burning, itching, tingling, or tightness when using any
cosmetics, which is intolerance to cosmetics. "Cosmetic intolerance" is considered as an extreme manifestation
of sensitive skin. These patients show the corresponding discomfort after being slightly stimulated by cosmetics.
At present, there are many reasons for cosmetic intolerance, mainly due to the combined effect of exogenous and
endogenous factors. Exogenous factors can include subjective or objective stimuli, including potential allergic
contact dermatitis and irritating dermatitis syndrome; endogenous factors include facial seborrheic dermatitis,
rosacea, psoriasis disease, acne, neuropathy, and phobia of skin diseases.
For example, polyethylene glycol (PEG) is a suitable and stable oil dissolving encapsulant. Polyethylene
glycol is used in detergents to dissolve oil and increase the viscosity of the product. Due to its significant
effectiveness, polyethylene glycols are often used in corrosive oven cleaning sprays, but they find in many
skincare products. However, scientific experiments have proven that some people are allergic to polyethylene
glycols and that they have potential carcinogenic risk for degradation products of polyethylene glycol (PEG).
Also, polyethylene glycol can cause the skin's natural moisturizing ingredients to peel off, leaving the immune
system vulnerable.
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
7
6.2 Cosmetics improve the health condition of sensitive skin
With the change of social and economic level and the complexity of cosmetics types and ingredients,
the possibility of sensitive skin appearing and being stimulated increases. Also, people's awareness of
skin health and aesthetic standards has been improved. Therefore, people's attention to sensitive skin is
gradually increasing. The cosmetics industry will put more and more important products on sensitive
skin and develop anti-allergic ingredients of active substances for various reasons and manifestations
of sensitive skin. According to the existing market research, except for some makeup brands, almost
all makeup brands have launched a specific number and different types of products for sensitive skin.
In these "Shumin" cosmetics, some anti-allergy and anti-stimulation plant extracts will be added with
purslane, chamomile, tea polyphenol, artichoke oil which have anti-allergic and anti-irritant properties.
Inflammation and anti-external stimulation can alleviate skin allergy, provide a natural protective
barrier for skin, effectively repair damaged skin, stimulate cell biochemical synthesis and cell
regeneration, and reconstruct skin immune system.
7. Conclusion
The exact meaning of sensitive skin has not yet agreed. Some scholars have defined sensitive skin as
reduced tolerance to cosmetics and toiletries or environmental factors (compared to the average
population). In other words, they cannot tolerate products or environmental factors that ordinary
people can tolerate. The skin (especially the face) is highly sensitive, and the incidence of adverse
reactions to cosmetics and toiletries is high. The symptoms can be visible irritations such as erythema
and desquamation and also be subjective discomforts such as tingling, burning, itching, and tightness.
Some scholars believe that this hyperresponsiveness of sensitive skin is a non-immune-mediated
inflammation. The causes of sensitive skin are also related to various factors such as race, age, gender,
and cosmetic irritation. The pathogenesis is complex, and there are great difficulties in treatment.
Cosmetics can induce the formation of sensitive skin. It is common to see the widespread use of
cosmetics with harmful chemicals leads to the impairment of the epidermal barrier, resulting in
sensitive skin [8]. Many people have to endure the negative effects of skin sensitivity. People ignore
the corresponding symptoms or can't use the corresponding skincare products correctly, which
aggravates the facial disease. However, hazardous substances in cosmetics mainly come from adding
banned chemicals and excessive use of restricted chemical substances. This is because the merchant
wants to let the user see the effect of the product in a short time. Furthermore, some manufacturers do
not strictly implement the requirements of the "Cosmetic Hygiene Regulations", some unqualified
cosmetics have flowed into the market. In order to strengthen the management and supervision of
unqualified cosmetics, consumers should report when they buy unqualified products. People should
use cosmetics produced by regular manufacturers to avoid being harmed by unqualified cosmetics.
All in all, skincare products have benefits and protective effects on people and also come with
health risks. A correct evaluation of sensitive skin and products' chemical ingredients are essential to
prevent and treat facial skin diseases.
Acknowledgement:
The assistance provided by Mr Liang was greatly appreciated.
References
[1] Z. Keyuan, research progress on the correlation between cosmetics and sensitive skin, Chinese
Journal of Aesthetic Medicine. Vol.25. No.12. (2016)
[2] S. Watkins, J. Zippin. Allergic contact dermatitis and cosmetics[J]. 90(4):201-204. (2012)
[3] L. Misery, E. Myon, N. Martin, F. Verriere, T. Nocera, and C. Taieb, Sensitive skin in France:
An epidemiological approach, Ann.Dermatol. Venereol, 132(5), 425–429. (2005)
[4] W. Xuemin, understanding sensitive skin and how to assess it, Journal of Clinical Dermatology
Vol. 32 Number 11. (2003)
AESEE 2020
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 512 (2020) 012081
IOP Publishing
doi:10.1088/1755-1315/512/1/012081
8
[5] S. Wang, H. Liang, Protective effect of functional cosmetics on sensitive skin, Chinese Journal of
Aesthetic Medicine, Vo1 18. No 10. (2009)
[6] H. Loffler, R. Happle, Profile of irritant patch testing with detergents: Sodium lauryl sulfate,
sodium laureth sulfate and alkyl polyglucoside. Contact Dermatitis, 48 (1), pp. 26-32. (2003)
[7] C. Lu, G. Cheng, L. Shen, et al. Designing a new model for cosmetic adverse reaction monitoring
in China[J]. Contact Dermatitis, 73(1):29-35. (2015)
[8] A. Fauger, A. Lhoste, M. Chavagnac-Bonneville, et al. Effects of a new topical combination on
sensitive skin[J]. 66(2):79-86. (2014)