ArticlePublisher preview available

The 2015 eruption of Gamalama volcano (Ternate Island–Indonesia): precursor, crisis management, and community response

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Gamalama is an active stratovolcano on Ternate, a small volcanic island in Maluku Utara, Indonesia. Since 1510, a total of 77 eruptions have been recorded, with various impacts on the population and environment on the island and its surroundings. In July 2015, Gamalama erupted after < 24 h of precursor signs. The seismic activity continued to increase until September 2015, as marked by three sudden eruptions that were not preceded by significant volcanic and tremor earthquakes. This research was intended to understand the chronology and impact of the 2015 Gamalama eruption, which is categorically unusual, and to learn how the government conducted relevant crisis management and in what manners the community affected by ejected materials reacted to it. The former was achieved by analyzing the data provided by the Gamalama volcano observatory. As for the latter, interviews with key stakeholders in volcanic disaster management and a questionnaire-based survey involving 85 respondents in the most affected areas were conducted. The results showed that despite the relatively small Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI = 2), the 2015 eruption was rather unexpected to many parties because it began with a short-term precursor sign (less than a day). The impact included tephra deposits as thick as 2–6 mm was in the Loto, Togafo, and Takome Villages. A total of 1791 people was recorded evacuating to several locations, such as Afe Taduma village, the SMKN 2 camp, the SKB camp, and the Naval Base camp. After a rapid impact assessment and coordination with the Center for Volcanology and Geological Hazard Mitigation (CVGHM), the government issued a status of emergency and evacuation orders. In cases when eruptions are initiated with a short-term precursor, the large population size and geographic condition of Ternate Island create a particular challenge in the resultant evacuation. Nevertheless, with prior mitigation measures and evacuation drills in hazard zones, evacuation can be carried out effectively. Even when a large-scale Gamalama eruption requires an evacuation to neighboring islands, a properly implemented mitigation such as the establishment of sister islands can substantially facilitate volcanic crisis management activities on small islands.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
The 2015 eruption of Gamalama volcano (Ternate Island–
Indonesia): precursor, crisis management, and community
response
Agung Hidayat .Muh Aris Marfai .Danang Sri Hadmoko
Published online: 6 June 2020
ÓSpringer Nature B.V. 2020
Abstract Gamalama is an active stratovolcano on
Ternate, a small volcanic island in Maluku Utara,
Indonesia. Since 1510, a total of 77 eruptions have
been recorded, with various impacts on the population
and environment on the island and its surroundings. In
July 2015, Gamalama erupted after \24 h of precur-
sor signs. The seismic activity continued to increase
until September 2015, as marked by three sudden
eruptions that were not preceded by significant
volcanic and tremor earthquakes. This research was
intended to understand the chronology and impact of
the 2015 Gamalama eruption, which is categorically
unusual, and to learn how the government conducted
relevant crisis management and in what manners the
community affected by ejected materials reacted to it.
The former was achieved by analyzing the data
provided by the Gamalama volcano observatory. As
for the latter, interviews with key stakeholders in
volcanic disaster management and a questionnaire-
based survey involving 85 respondents in the most
affected areas were conducted. The results showed
that despite the relatively small Volcanic Explosivity
Index (VEI = 2), the 2015 eruption was rather unex-
pected to many parties because it began with a short-
term precursor sign (less than a day). The impact
included tephra deposits as thick as 2–6 mm was in the
Loto, Togafo, and Takome Villages. A total of 1791
people was recorded evacuating to several locations,
such as Afe Taduma village, the SMKN 2 camp, the
SKB camp, and the Naval Base camp. After a rapid
impact assessment and coordination with the Center
for Volcanology and Geological Hazard Mitigation
(CVGHM), the government issued a status of emer-
gency and evacuation orders. In cases when eruptions
are initiated with a short-term precursor, the large
population size and geographic condition of Ternate
Island create a particular challenge in the resultant
evacuation. Nevertheless, with prior mitigation mea-
sures and evacuation drills in hazard zones, evacuation
can be carried out effectively. Even when a large-scale
Gamalama eruption requires an evacuation to neigh-
boring islands, a properly implemented mitigation
such as the establishment of sister islands can
substantially facilitate volcanic crisis management
activities on small islands.
Keywords Crisis management Volcanic island
Gamalama volcano Ternate Island Indonesia
A. Hidayat
Department of Geography, Faculty of Geography,
Universitas Gadjah Mada, Sekip Utara, Bulaksumur,
Yogyakarta 55281, Indonesia
M. A. Marfai (&)D. S. Hadmoko
Department of Environmental Geography, Faculty of
Geography, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Sekip Utara,
Bulaksumur, Yogyakarta 55281, Indonesia
e-mail: arismarfai@ugm.ac.id
123
GeoJournal (2022) 87:1–20
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10708-020-10237-w(0123456789().,-volV)(0123456789().,-volV)
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... The small island community in Ternate offers fascinating subjects to study: the adaptive capacity to deal with disasters to survive in dangerous locations (Rampengan et al., 2014;Reenberg et al., 2008). Gamalama activities were first recorded in 1510, and since then, at least there have been 77 eruptions with widely differing physical and social impacts (Hidayat et al., 2022). In addition, several unrecorded eruptions of Gamalama with enormous consequences have also been recently revealed by Faral et al. (2022). ...
... On Ternate Island, eruptions are often followed by volcanic ashfall with varying intensities depending on the duration and magnitude of the eruption (Faral et al., 2022). Heavy ashfall occurred after the 1980 Gamalama eruption, resulting in the evacuation of as many as 40,000 people to the neighboring islands, i.e., Tidore, Hiri, and Halmahera (Hidayat et al., 2020a(Hidayat et al., , 2020b(Hidayat et al., , 2022. Also, the 2015 Gamalama eruption produced ashfall that forced the evacuation of 1791 people (Hidayat et al., 2022). ...
... Heavy ashfall occurred after the 1980 Gamalama eruption, resulting in the evacuation of as many as 40,000 people to the neighboring islands, i.e., Tidore, Hiri, and Halmahera (Hidayat et al., 2020a(Hidayat et al., , 2020b(Hidayat et al., , 2022. Also, the 2015 Gamalama eruption produced ashfall that forced the evacuation of 1791 people (Hidayat et al., 2022). In addition to ashfall, the small island community of Ternate also experienced lahar induced by torrential rains within a few hours after the 2011 eruption (BPBD Badan Penanggulangan Bencana Daerah, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
A study of volcanic hazard knowledge and preparedness of communities living on the flanks of Gamalama Volcano, on the small island Ternate, was conducted in January–February 2019. A total of 1265 respondents participated in a questionnaire-based survey using 42 questions to inquire about community knowledge of natural disasters and volcanic hazards, community preparedness, and the correlation between community knowledge and preparedness. The results showed that the majority of respondents selected from the small island community had good knowledge of natural disasters and volcanic hazards and were also well-prepared. There are positive correlations between knowledge of natural disasters and volcanic hazards; the latter is also positively linked to preparedness. Long experience in dealing with the eruptions of Gamalama in the past has raised local people’s awareness of volcanic hazards, which in turn increases their preparedness. Such understanding and preparedness are inseparable from the abundant dissemination channels of details on eruption threats and risks on Ternate Island, including televisions, the internet, radios, government officials, and non-governmental organizations.
... Gamalama, located in the Maluku Islands, is one of the most active volcanoes in Indonesia having erupted 6 times since 2010 (GVP, 2013b). The decrease in duration of seismic precursors before recent eruptions (Hidayat et al., 2020;Kunrat et al., 2020) poses an increasing risk to the growing population on the island as warning alerts may not give sufficient time for evacuation (Hidayat et al., 2020). MODVOLC detected a thermal anomaly in 2003 (Wright and Pilger, 2008a). ...
... Gamalama, located in the Maluku Islands, is one of the most active volcanoes in Indonesia having erupted 6 times since 2010 (GVP, 2013b). The decrease in duration of seismic precursors before recent eruptions (Hidayat et al., 2020;Kunrat et al., 2020) poses an increasing risk to the growing population on the island as warning alerts may not give sufficient time for evacuation (Hidayat et al., 2020). MODVOLC detected a thermal anomaly in 2003 (Wright and Pilger, 2008a). ...
Article
Routine analysis and detection of volcanic thermal features (VTFs) are available globally for low spatial resolution (>1 km/pixel) thermal infrared (TIR) sensors. However, medium resolution (90 m/pixel) ASTER (Advanced Spaceborne Thermal Emission and Reflection Radiometer) TIR data, which is sensitive to smaller and cooler VTFs, have yet to be systematically examined at all active Indonesian volcanoes. We manually examined cloud-free nighttime images at 136 potentially active volcanoes from 2000 to 2020 CE and found at least 71 volcanoes with VTFs, despite the low proportion (26.5%) of cloud-free images. Of these, 34 volcanoes have VTF detections from space published for the first time (to our knowledge) and at least 44 volcanoes have non-eruptive VTFs (fumaroles, heated volcanic lakes and open vent systems). The inclusion of hotspots detected by ASTER in this study increases the percentage of Indonesian volcanoes with recorded satellite-detectable thermal features from 27% to 52%, larger than in Latin America (27%) and the US (33%) which were surveyed in the same way and is possibly due to a higher frequency of eruptions in Indonesia. The distribution of VTFs across sub-regions in Indonesia is not uniform but may be correlated with the number of volcanoes with eruptions. This multi-decadal country-wide survey highlights the potential of TIR monitoring and detection of low-temperature volcanic features that may be eruption precursors, but also the limits of the available datasets since many volcanoes only have a few cloud-free nighttime images per year.
... The sister village concept was implemented in the aftermath of the 2010 Merapi eruption as a mitigation measure against the next eruption [102]. Sister island in Indonesia has been developed technically in Ternate island threatened by Gamalama volcano by involving neighboring islands: Tidore, Hiri, and Halmahera, both for temporary and permanents displaced population [101,103]. The mapping phase is helpful for selecting the proper sister village and sister island. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper discusses the relations between the impacts of volcanic eruptions at multiple-scales and the related-issues of disaster-risk reduction (DRR). The review is structured around local and global impacts of volcanic eruptions, which have not been widely discussed in the literature, in terms of DRR issues. We classify the impacts at local scale on four different geographical features: impacts on the drainage system, on the structural morphology, on the water bodies, and the impact on societies and the environment. It has been demonstrated that information on local impacts can be integrated into four phases of the DRR, i.e., monitoring, mapping, emergency, and recovery. In contrast, information on the global impacts (e.g., global disruption on climate and air traffic) only fits the first DRR phase. We have emphasized the fact that global impacts are almost forgotten in the DRR programs. For this review, we have extracted case studies from Indonesia, and compared them to those of other regions, because Indonesia is home to >130 volcanoes and experienced several latest volcanic eruptions with VEI > 5.
Article
Investigating past eruptions gives a unique opportunity to understand volcanic hazards, particularly in Indonesia, where volcanic eruptions occur frequently. Here, we present the first reconstruction of the eruptive history of the Ternate and Tidore Islands (North Maluku, Indonesia) over the past 22,000 years cal. BP, based on a new identification and characterization of past volcanic events methodological approach. This multidisciplinary study (geomorphology, tephrochronology, sedimentology, geochronology, geochemistry) constitutes the first stratigraphic and chronological continuum from volcanic deposits found in a set of fifteen sections established in Ternate, Tidore, and Maitara Islands. Sedimentological and geochemical data from tephrostratigraphy studies and radiocarbon dating suggest that these islands experienced at least four major explosive events from c. 22,000 to 740 years cal. BP. The oldest event recorded is a Plinian eruption associated with a caldera-forming eruption of Telaga volcano on Tidore Island at c. 22,000–17,500 cal. BP. A second pumiceous eruption dated at c. 18,000 cal. BP is attributed to the last Plinian eruption of Gamalama volcano on Ternate, whose current eruptive activity is mainly strombolian or phreatomagmatic. A succession of pyroclastic deposits of phreatomagmatic origin is related to the Ngade maar formation on Ternate Island, and the abundant deposits of scoria, pumice, and ash found in all sites probably occurred c. 14,500–13,000 cal. BP. No eruptions of the Kie Matubu volcano on Tidore Island have been reported by human beings since their presence in the region from the 16th century, but this study highlights two late Holocene eruptions, c. 2500 cal. BP and 740 cal. BP. This first chronostratigraphic framework from the late Pleistocene to recent eruptions in this region, sheds new light concerning the management of prediction and warning information about potential eruptions that may occur on these small volcanic islands in the future.
Article
Full-text available
This article presents the characteristics of the small islands of Tidore and Hiri, which are vulnerable to the dangers of volcanic eruptions in Indonesia. The physical condition of the area is very important for carrying out a sustainable disaster risk reduction analysis; therefore, climate and topographic data are important to know. The limited availability of data in the study area causes climate data to be obtained from NASA’s Earth Science Data Systems (ESDS) and regional topographical presentation of Indonesia’s national DEM data. The results show that in the period 2004 to 2014, the temperature in the study area ranged from 292 K to 309 K. The islands of Tidore and Hiri have monthly precipitation between 50 mm to 500 mm.
Article
Full-text available
The daily media is filled with images of catastrophic events which seem increasingly frequent and violent. In parallel there are a large range of scientific studies, debates in the policy arena, and a growing number of international institutions focused on disaster reduction. But a paradox remains that despite advances in technology, disasters continue to increase, affecting many individuals in rich as well as poor countries.
Article
Full-text available
Indonesia merupakan salah satu negara yang dilalui oleh Cincin Api Pasifik. Lebih dari 400 gunungapi berada pada jalur tersebut dan 130 diantaranya masih aktif hingga sekarang. Erupsi gunungapi menghasikan material dari ukuran kecil (abu, pasir, kerikil) hingga ukuran besar (bongkah). Material – material yang keluar dari vent, sebagian akan diendapkan di dekat vent dan perlahan akan membentuk kerucut gunungapi. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk memetakan pulau vulkanik kecil di Indonesia yang memiliki gunungapi aktif sejak era Holosen. Selain itu juga untuk menganalisis jumlah penduduk yang berada di pulau vulkanik dan sekitarnya untuk melihat jumlah orang yang potensial terdampak erupsi. Identifikasi pulau vulkanik dilakukan dengan interpretasi visual citra satelit yang diverifikasi dengan database gunungapi pada pulau vulkanik yang dipetakan. Hasil identifikasi menunjukkan ada 22 pulau vulkanik dengan catatan erupsi sejak era Holosen. Sebanyak 16 pulau teridentifikasi masih terdapat gunungapi aktif dan sebanyak 6 pulau teridentifikasi terdapat gunungapi dalam masa istirahat. Potensi penduduk terpapar bahaya erupsi pada radius 5 kilometer dari pusat eruspi sebanyak 180.434 orang, radius 10 kilometer dari pusat erupsi sebanyak 373.286 orang, dan radius 30 kilometer dari pusat erupsi sebanyak 1.471.995 orang. Ada kebutuhan yang nyata untuk melakukan kajian tentang bahaya erupsi di pulau vulkanik di Indonesia, dimana penduduk dan kegiatan ekonominya terus mengalami perkembangan, sehingga berpotensi tinggi terpapar bahaya erupsi. Untuk menyusun strategi pengurangan risiko bencana di pulau vulkanik diperlukan pemahaman tentang wilayah bahaya dan kejadian – kejadian erupsi serta dampaknya pada pulau vulkanik Indonesia dimasa lalu.
Article
Full-text available
In August 2010, Mt. Sinabung in North Sumatera erupted for the very first time in 400 years; until that moment the volcano had been declared as dormant. In contrast to the communities living around Mt. Merapi in Java, the Mt. Sinabung communities had little to no preparation when faced with the sudden volcanic eruption. The Sinabung eruption caused disturbances as it ruined the farmlands and community's sources of livelihood, especially since most of the community members are farmers. Most of the time, these farmlands are located not far from their house, so displacing them means moving them away from their main source of income. This makes some of the displaced keep moving back to their old villages to farm even though they are putting themselves in danger by doing so. This condition motivated the community to initiate Beidar, an organization to monitor volcanic activities and give out early warnings to villagers nearby and within the hazard zone to evacuate. This paper will study Beidar's involvement with the community and the government, how they operate, and how they impact the community members living near the volcano. This data used in this study are primarily from interviews with Beidar members and organizers, volcanic monitoring posts, and the local disaster management. A thematic analysis of the interviews shows the history of Beidar's development as an organization proudly independent of the government; the "recruitment" of members; the important roles in the community including mediating between government and other local organizations (e.g., volcano monitoring station); specific monitoring; communication and evacuation activities (e.g., including search activities after eruptions and lahars); contacts and sharing of experience with similar groups in Indonesia; and identifying the limits of their influence in preventing local people from returning to the red zone. This research concludes that Beidar was officially acknowledged as an organization in March 2014 under the wing of the Volcanology Agency, which needed help to disseminate the volcano status information to the community. Recruiting local youth is seen as a better alternative since the communities — especially the internally displaced community members — have little trust in the government due to the crisis and deemed them 'incompetent'. Beidar, as a community-based organization, can fill the gap between the community and the government in terms of information dissemination, especially because they are local and are acknowledged as a trusted part of the community. However, this dynamic has a side effect of the villagers' feeling of security with Beidar 'watching over them'. This lowers their risk perception of the volcano, leading them to endanger themselves more by crossing over the hazard area to conducting their day-to-day activity.
Article
Full-text available
Volcanoes can produce far-reaching hazards that extend distances of tens or hundreds of kilometres in large eruptions, or in certain conditions for smaller eruptions. About a tenth of the world’s population lives within the potential footprint of volcanic hazards and lives are regularly lost through volcanic activity: volcanic fatalities were recorded in 18 of the last 20 years. This paper identifies the distance and distribution of fatalities around volcanoes and the activities of the victims at the time of impact, sourced from an extensive search of academic and grey literature, including media and official reports. We update and expand a volcano fatality database to include all data from 1500 AD to 2017. This database contains 635 records of 278,368 fatalities. Each record contains information on the number of fatalities, fatal cause, incident date and the fatality location in terms of distance from the volcano. Distance data were previously available in just 5% of fatal incidents: these data have been significantly increased to 72% (456/635) of fatal incidents, with fatalities recorded from inside the crater to more than 100 km from the summit. Local residents are the most frequently killed, but tourists, volcanologists and members of the media are also identified as common victims. These latter groups and residents of small islands dominate the proximal fatality record up to 5 km from the volcano. Though normally accounting for small numbers of fatalities, ballistics are the most common cause of fatal incidents at this distance. Pyroclastic density currents are the dominant fatal cause at 5 to 15 km. Lahars, tsunami and tephra dominate the record after about 15 km. The new location data are used to characterise volcanic threat with distance, as a function of eruption size and hazard type, and to understand how certain activities increase exposure and the likelihood of death. These findings support assessment of volcanic threat, population exposure and vulnerabilities related to occupation or activity.
Article
One of the most powerful eruptions of the Holocene, known as the Samalas eruption, had a VEI of 7 and took place on Lombok, eastern Indonesia in 1257 CE. Thick tephra fall covered the entire island, and pyroclastic density currents (PDCs) up to 50 m thick buried almost half of Lombok. Until now, there has been no detailed study of the geomorphological evolution of Lombok related to this eruption, especially for the eastern part of Lombok. The main goal of this paper is therefore to reconstruct the paleo-topography on the eastern part of Lombok before the eruption of the Samalas volcano in 1257 CE, and to analyse the subsequent landscape evolution following this eruption. Data were collected from more than 1300 points in order to gather geomorphological, geological, and geochemical information for the eastern part of Lombok over the last millennium. Data were obtained from wells (which are widespread in the studied area), natural outcrops (mainly cliffs along the shoreline and the rivers), and human-made outcrops in quarries, as well as from the two-dimensional resistivity profiling (Dipole-dipole array) carried out on eastern Lombok in 2016 and 2017. We estimate that 4435 ± 5.5 × 106 m3 of pumice-rich PDC, over a surface of 171 km2, buried the eastern part of Lombok in the aftermath of the 1257 CE eruption, and as a result of this rapid pumice-rich PDC deposition there has been some aggradation of the shoreline at some points, resulting in most of the pre-1257 coral reef being buried. After several intense rainfall events, the deposited volcanic material was probably eroded during the first decades following the 1257 CE eruption by mountain streams, producing lahars. We estimate that the remaining volume of pumice-rich PDC deposits following this erosion is 625 ± 5.5 × 106 m3 over a surface of 89 km2, which is equivalent to 14% of the initial volume.
Article
The products of explosive activity of La Soufrière volcano on the island of St Vincent over the last 1000 years are described. Dates for the different eruptions were determined using information from contemporary accounts, fieldwork and radiocarbon dating. Scoria-flow type pyroclastic density currents (PDCs) dominate the products of both the historical eruptions (1979, 1902–03, 1718/1812 CE) and prehistoric eruptions (~1580 and 1440 CE) with subordinate fallout components associated with several eruptions. Radiocarbon dating shows that these six eruptions define a crude cyclicity with repose periods ranging between 77 and ~140 years and systematically decreasing in more recent times. Two prehistoric eruptions, in ~1440 and 1580 CE respectively, both produced magmatic lapilli fallout and PDCs, and were fed by slightly more evolved magmas than the historical eruptions. The eruptions in 1902 and 1812 CE had ash-rich, possible phreatomagmatic activity at their onset. The iconic 1902–03 CE eruption generated radial distributed PDCs, which were responsible for the deaths of ~1500 people. However, only small remnants of these deposits remain and the original distribution cannot be determined from the preserved geology, which has important implications for hazard studies. Petrochemical work has shown that magmas involved in the explosive eruptions were quite narrow in compositional range, mainly comprising basaltic andesites. The 1902–03 eruption involved a late stage basaltic component in March 1903. However, activity in the last 1000 years generated notably more homogeneous magmas with a narrower range than the older eruptive periods previously reported in the literature, suggesting a significant variation in the magmatic reservoir feeding system with time.
Article
Retrospective analysis of the contemporary colonial and scientific records of a major explosive eruption of the Soufrière of St Vincent from 1902 to 1903 reveals how this significant and prolonged event presented challenges to the authorities charged with managing the crisis and its aftermath. In a small-island setting vulnerable to multiple hazards, the spatial footprint of the volcanic hazard and the nature and intensity of the hazard effects were rather different to those of other recurrent hazards such as hurricanes. The eruption affected the same parts of the island that had been impacted by prior explosive eruptions in 1718 and 1812, and hurricanes in 1831 and 1898, with consequences that disproportionately affected those working in and around the large sugar estates. The official response to the eruption, both in terms of short-term relief and remediation, was significantly accelerated by the existence of mature plans for land-reform following the collapse of the sugar market, and ongoing plans for rebuilding in the aftermath of the destructive hurricane of 1898. The picture that this analysis helps to illuminate provides insights both into the nature of the particular eruptive episode, and the human and social response to that episode. This not only informs discussion and planning for future explosive eruptions on St Vincent, but provides important empirical evidence for building effective responses in similar multihazard contexts.