ArticlePublisher preview available

Chloride diffusion and time to corrosion initiation of reinforced concrete structures

Emerald
Magazine of Concrete Research
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

The diffusion mechanism for chloride ions in concrete with varying water/cement ratio (w/c) is studied by chloride ion spray testing. A new model of chloride diffusion coefficient, which varies with the ingress depth of chloride ion and w/c, is developed. A spatial time-dependent reliability model of time to corrosion initiation (TCI) for reinforced concrete (RC) structures is developed, considering spatial variability of geometric, material and environmental parameters. The test results show that the chloride diffusion coefficient increases as w/c increases, and chloride diffusion velocity decreases as penetration depth increases. It is found that the probability of corrosion initiation considering spatial variability is 13.1–18.5% greater than that without consideration of spatial variability. This indicates that neglecting spatial variations in evaluating probability of corrosion initiation time overestimates the structural reliability. It is also found that the probability of corrosion initiation for future climate change is 9–11% higher than that obtained from constant temperature. The mean value of TCI based on a time-dependent chloride diffusion coefficient is 16.7% less than that obtained for a constant chloride diffusion coefficient. This suggests that it is more appropriate if penetration depth and w/c is considered when determining the time-dependent chloride diffusion coefficient.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Chloride diffusion and time to corrosion
initiation of reinforced concrete structures
Jianxin Peng
Professor, School of Civil Engineering, Changsha University of Science and
Technology, Changsha, Hunan, China
Huang Tang
Lecturer, School of Civil Engineering, Hunan City University, Yingyang,
Hunan, China; Industry Key Laboratory of Transportation Infrastructure
Security Risk Management of Changsha University of Science and
Technology, Changsha, Hunan, China (corresponding author:
tanghuang_123@163.com)
Linfa Xiao
PhD candidate, School of Civil Engineering, Changsha University of Science
and Technology, Changsha, Hunan, China
Xiaokang Cheng
Master, School of Civil Engineering, Changsha University of Science and
Technology, Changsha, Hunan, China
Jianren Zhang
Professor, School of Civil Engineering, Changsha University of Science
and Technology, Changsha, Hunan, China
The diffusion mechanism for chloride ions in concrete with varying water/cement ratio (w/c) is studied by chloride ion
spray testing. A new model of chloride diffusion coefficient, which varies with the ingress depth of chloride ion and
w/c, is developed. A spatial time-dependent reliability model of time to corrosion initiation (T
CI
) for reinforced concrete
(RC) structures is developed, considering spatial variability of geometric, material and environmental parameters. The
test results show that the chloride diffusion coefficient increases as w/cincreases, and chloride diffusion velocity
decreases as penetration depth increases. It is found that the probability of corrosion initiation considering spatial
variability is 13.118.5% greater than that without consideration of spatial variability. This indicates that neglecting
spatial variations in evaluating probability of corrosion initiation time overestimates the structural reliability. It is also
found that the probability of corrosion initiation for future climate change is 911% higher than that obtained from
constant temperature. The mean value of T
CI
based on a time-dependent chloride diffusion coefficient is 16.7% less
than that obtained for a constant chloride diffusion coefficient. This suggests that it is more appropriate if penetration
depth and w/cis considered when determining the time-dependent chloride diffusion coefficient.
Notation
Cchloride concentration
C
cr
critical chloride concentration
C
cr(i)
threshold of chloride concentration of element i
C
i
chloride concentration of element i
C
s
surface chloride concentration
C
s(i)
surface chloride content of element i
C(x,t) chloride content at time tof exposure, and at depth x
from the surface of the concrete
C
0
initial chloride concentration inside the
concrete structure
C
0(i)
initial concentration of chloride ions in concrete of
element i
Dchloride diffusion coefficient
D
exp
experimental chloride diffusion coefficient
D
real
chloride diffusion coefficient for real structure
D
real(i)
real diffusion coefficient of element i
d
x
model parameter (correlation lengths) for a
two-dimensional (2D) random field in xdirection
d
y
model parameter (correlation lengths) for a 2D random
field in ydirection
E
c
cover thickness
erf error function
F
c
specified concrete compressive strength
f
age
time correction factor
fTbtemperature correction coefficient
GCL;ipowerful function
mexperimental parameter
p
ci
probability of initiation of chloride-induced corrosion
for each element
p
r
probable symbol
Rgas constant
R
2
correlation coefficient
Sspatial segment at random field
Treal temperature where the assessed structure is located
T
b
average absolute temperature related to calculation
T
CI
time to corrosion initiation
T
0
temperature in the year 2000
T
28
absolute temperature corresponding to a curing of
28 days
tcalculated time
t
build
construction completion time of structure
t
exp
tested time
Uactivated energy during the diffusion process of
chloride ion in concrete
w/bwater/binder ratio
w/cwater/cement ratio
X(s) random field
xdepth from the surface of the concrete
γ(S) variance function
757
Cite this article
Peng J, Tang H, Xiao L, Cheng X and Zhang J (2021)
Chloride diffusion and time to corrosion initiation of reinforced concrete structures.
Magazine of Concrete Research 73(15): 757770,
https://doi.org/10.1680/jmacr.19.00276
Magazine of Concrete Research
Research Article
Paper 1900276
Received 04/06/2019; Revised 19/05/2020;
Accepted 27/05/2020;
Published online 03/07/2020
ICE Publishing: All rights reserved
Keywords: compressive strength/
durability-related properties/modelling
... When water and oxygen penetrated into concrete [4][5][6] and reached the surface of steel, corrosion of steel could happen [7,8], and this process will be accelerated in the presence of chloride ions [9][10][11][12]. In the environments with abundant chloride ions, such as marine environment and where the deicing salts are used, chloride ingress into steel-reinforced concrete needs to be strictly controlled, because chloride-induced corrosion is the main reason for steel corrosion in chloride laden environments [13][14][15][16][17][18][19]. Concrete could crack because of the accumulated pressure caused by the increasing corrosion products in the interface between the steel and concrete, and the structure could even fail because of the severe corrosion of steel [20,21]. ...
... By comparing Eq. (11) and Eq. (16), the relationship between D ss and k can be obtained as in Eq. (17). ...
... The theoretical model between D ss and d pore is reported in Eq. (16). In order to verify this equation, similar like the above discussion, the d c and d a results were reported. ...
Article
Chloride diffusion coefficient of concrete is a critical parameter indicating a durability property of steel-reinforced concrete elements in chloride-laden environments. However, chloride diffusion tests of concrete could take months or even years to finish in order to obtain the steady state chloride diffusion coefficient (Dss). Most engineers have to take a rapid chloride migration test to get a chloride migration coefficient, which could still take one or a few days to finish. In contrast, a water permeability test could be finished within only a few hours, and a steady state water permeability coefficient (k) can be obtained. This study aims to build a theoretical model between Dss and k, and the model has been validated by experimental work. The obtained model shows that relationship between Dss (in m²/s) and k (in m²) can be simply described using a formula Dss/k = 32Daq/d²pore, where Daq (in m²/s) is the chloride diffusion coefficient in free solution, and dpore (in m) is the equivalent pore diameter. The experimental validation work showed that the model is in good agreement with the measured data, and dpore in the formula can be replaced with the average pore diameter da. Applying this model in engineering projects could aid to predict the difficult-to-get Dss of cementitious materials through the rapid measurements of k and da.
... Under highly alkaline concrete conditions, the chemical environment passivates the steel reinforcement. It keeps it from rusting by forming a long-lasting oxide coating on the steel surface (Al-Saleh, 2015;Peng et al., 2021). The elimination of passivity is possible by the absorption of chloride ions. ...
Article
Full-text available
Numerous research has investigated the effects of blast furnace slag as a cementitious or substitute cementing material on the characteristics of concrete. Blast furnace slag cement (BFSC) shows promise in the concrete permeability domain, where this extra cementing ingredient enhances the chloride attack resistance of concrete. Four mixtures of BFSC concrete made with 0.5, and 0.6 water-to-cement ratios (w/c) were studied. The effect of using an air-entraining agent (AEA) and a change in the surface of tested samples (top, bottom, and side) on the chloride penetration and its diffusion coefficient has been investigated. The properties of fresh and hardened concrete were determined. This research has its novelty for the first time, where the chloride contents were determined through specimens' top, bottom, and side surfaces using potentiometric titration. The results indicated that the air-entraining agent and w/c ratio had inversely affected the invested concrete properties. The measured total and soluble chloride content at a depth of 20~30 mm is less than the limits of the corrosion threshold for the three studied surfaces. Also, changes in the w/c ratio, cement content, and AEA affect the diffusion coefficient. Keywords: Air entraining agent; Blast-furnace slag cement; Concrete; Potentiometric titration; Chloride permeability; Total chloride; Soluble chloride; Diffusion coefficient.
... The chloride diffusion coefficient should also consider the temperature effect, which can be presented as [47]: ...
Article
Full-text available
High performance concrete (HPC) is a kind of concrete with mineral admixtures, which has better resistance ability to chloride ions diffusion than ordinary concrete. In the present study, the authors carried out a chloride ion diffusion experiment for the HPC with fly ash and silica fume. The influence of the water–binder ratio (W/B), binary (Portland cement–Fly ash (PC-FS) and Portland cement–Silica fume (PC-SF) and ternary (Portland cement–Fly ash–Silica fume (PC-FA-SF)) combinations on the concrete compressive strength and chloride ion diffusion was investigated. It was found that the compressive strength of normal concrete and HPC increase with the decrease in the W/B, the ratio of W/B deceasing value to strength increasing value for normal concrete is 0.74, and for the HPC is 0.20, so the influence of the W/B on the concrete strength for normal concrete was obviously more than the HPC. The influence of the contents of the SF or FA on developing the concrete strength was limited. The concrete compressive strength of ternary combination specimens decreases with the increase in FA or SF when the content of the other mineral admixture SF or FA remained unchanged. The ternary combination was more efficient in prohibiting chlorides ingress insider the specimens than the binary combination. The mesoscopic simulation and the tested value of the chloride ion under the same depth was close, the average ratio of simulation value to tested value was 0.91. The aggregate shape and distribution also had a negligible influence on chloride diffusivity in the HPC, but the chloride ion concentration increased with the increase in aggregate size.
... In experimental research, realization of reinforcement's corrosion was carried out through a method of accelerating corrosion by electricity [9]. Many research studies related to corrosion were based on this method [10][11][12]. ...
Article
Full-text available
In order to study the influence of corrosion rate and shear span ratio on reinforced concrete beam, a numerical analysis method of corroded reinforced concrete beam was put forward. Bond-slip relationship formula between reinforcement and concrete was suggested. A three-dimensional finite element model of corroded reinforced concrete beam was established. Calculation method of ultimate bearing capacity for reinforced concrete beam was suggested. Ultimate bearing capacity experiment on 14 corroded reinforced concrete beams with different corrosion rates and shear span ratios was carried out. Numerical analysis results and experimental results were compared and analyzed. The results show that, for reinforced concrete beams with different corrosion rates and shear span ratios, load-deflection curve can be divided into elasticity stage and plasticity stage. With the increase of corrosion rate and shear span ratio, ultimate bearing capacity of corroded reinforced concrete beam decreased. When shear span ratio was 3.0, if corrosion rate increased by 1%, experimental value of ultimate bearing capacity decreased by 1.002 kN. When shear span ratio was 2.4, if corrosion rate increased by 1%, experimental value of ultimate bearing capacity decreased by 1.849 kN. The numerical analysis method put forward in this paper was feasible, and the suggested ultimate bearing capacity calculation method for reinforced concrete beam has a high accuracy.
Article
For marine reinforced concrete (RC) structures under chloride-attack, the risks of member surface damage can be evaluated using random field analysis method, considering the spatial variations of durability parameters. However, the random field analysis method requires high computational cost and advanced skills, and is not feasible for engineering practice. Recognizing this difficulty, a simplified method is proposed in this paper based on the statistical characteristics of time to corrosion initiation and surface damage. The new method establishes the mappings between the probabilities of member surface damage and the probability (or reliability index) of corrosion initiation at the same age. Thus, engineers and decision-makers can estimate the risk of surface damage through reliability index of corrosion initiation, with the latter can be obtained relatively easily. Probabilistic analysis for the durability performance of a RC slab serviced in marine environment is performed to demonstrate the method. The accuracy of the proposed method is examined through the comparison with the random field simulation method and experimental results in literature.
Article
Full-text available
Concrete cracking induced by strand corrosion can degrade bond strength and lead to prestress loss. A novel model is proposed to predict corrosion-induced prestress loss in pretensioned concrete structures. The coupling effects of concrete cracking and bond degradation are incorporated into the model. An experimental study is conducted to evaluate the effective prestress in eight corroded pretensioned concrete beams under various stress levels. Experimental results are employed to validate the proposed model. Results demonstrate that the proposed model can accurately predict prestress loss in corroded pretensioned concrete structures. Prestress loss depends on the corrosion degree. Corrosion-induced concrete cracking may not degrade bond strength and effective prestress unless corrosion loss exceeds 6.6%. As corrosion further progresses, bond strength and effective prestress decrease monotonically and then reduce to zero when corrosion loss reaches 34.0%.
Article
This paper presents the results of an experimental study investigating the mechanical behavior of corroded beams strengthened by three different strengthening schemes, and the influence of further corrosion on the structural performance of strengthened corroded beams. Eight rectangular reinforced-concrete (RC) beams were tested through a three-point bending system. The experimental results showed that the failure modes of the strengthened corroded beams were diagonal tensile failure, flexural failure, and support crush failure, respectively. The increases in ultimate load capacity and rigidity of the corroded beams strengthened with combined strengthening were up to 39.44% and 127.57%, respectively, compared with those of the corroded beams. The ductility of the tested beams strengthened with a single U-shaped steel strip was 16.97% greater than that of the corroded beams, while the ductility of the corroded beams strengthened with flexure strengthening and combined strengthening was, respectively, 4.6% and 28.8% lower than that of the corroded beams due to brittle failure. Compared with the strengthened corroded beams, the ductility and ultimate load capacity of all strengthened beams subjected to further corrosion (5% average corrosion loss of the cross section of the tensile steel bar) increased from 53.14% to 73.39% and from 37.37% to 53.13%, respectively. It was found that further corrosion had a small influence on the rigidity of tested beams strengthened by flexure strengthening and combined strengthening as opposed to the beams strengthened by shear strengthening.
Article
An experimental study was conducted to compare the deterioration of mechanical properties of HPS specimens subjected to electrochemical corrosion and neutral salt spray accelerated corrosion. Twenty seven 460D steel specimens were designed and subjected to these two kinds of corrosion. The geometric features of the specimens were evaluated by using 3D scanning technology. Mechanical properties and corrosion damage were discussed after tensile tests. FEM was developed to investigate the effects of different corroded cross sections and their spacing on the degradation of mechanical properties. Experimental results show that specimens subjected to the electrochemical accelerated corrosion have more obvious non-uniformity. Shape of big pits in terms of the electrochemical accelerated corrosion can be regarded as a flat semi-ellipsoid, and part of a full semi-ellipsoid for salt spray accelerated corrosion, and cone for the small pits. Corrosion method has an effect on the ductility, strength, and failure behaviors. Compared with thickness loss, width loss has a greater impact on structural strength and stiffness.
Article
This paper investigates the corrosion fatigue mechanism and crack growth behavior of HRB400 steel bar in corrosive environment. Fatigue crack growth (FCG) test is conducted under different fatigue loading types, environments and stress ratios. The fatigue loading type includes constant and stepwise decreasing load amplitude. The environment involves air, distilled water, 3.5% NaCl solution and artificially accelerated corrosive environment. The stress ratio ranges from 0.1 to 0.7. The threshold stress intensity factor range and FCG rate under various test conditions are obtained. The FCG path and fracture morphology are examined by optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopic, respectively. Following this, the threshold stress intensity factor ranges, FCG rates, FCG paths and fracture features under different conditions are compared. Then, the corrosion fatigue mechanism of HRB400 steel bar under the test environments are quantitatively analyzed. The results show that the hydrogen embrittlement plays a predominant role in the corrosion fatigue process of HRB400 steel bar. The contribution of anodic dissolution to the FCG rate increases as the aggressiveness level increases. The contribution of hydrogen embrittlement to the FCG rate increases with increasing stress ratio and stress intensity factor range.
Article
To study the erosion degradation rule of the concrete member under different chloride ion erosion conditions, the chloride ion immersion tests for the flexural-tensile concrete member and salt spray tests for non-stress concrete member were carried out. Based on the test results of chloride mass fraction, flexural-tensile strength and flexural-tensile strain of concrete member, the effects of erosion time, environmental temperature, stress level, environmental chloride ion mass fraction and erosion pattern on the diffusion rule of chloride ion and flexural-tensile strength of concrete members were studied. The results show that, the chloride ion mass fraction in soaking environment is higher than that in salt spray environment; the chloride ion mass fraction increases with the erosion time, environmental temperature, chloride ion concentration and stress level; the diffusion coefficient increases with the increasing of the stress level and temperature; under the condition of lower stress level, lower temperature and shorter erosion time, the ultimate flexural-tensile strength of concrete members has a slight upward trend, and then it decreases with erosion time; the ultimate flexural-tensile strain of concrete members decreases while the influence factors increase. The results provide a theoretical base for the durability assessment and design for concrete member under chloride ion erosion environmental and have some practical values. © 2016, Editorial Board of Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology. All right reserved.
Article
Random field discrimination was used to analyze stochastic structures with spatially random properties. For criteria were considered in the choice of the random field discrimination method. A systematic method based on linear regression theory was chosen which minimized the error of the discredited field relative to its real field for non-Gaussian fields. The random field discrimination process can be done independently from the finite element discrimination process. Examples show that this method is more efficient and flexible than other discrimination methods for finite element reliability analyses.