ArticlePDF Available

Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera

Authors:
Article

Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera

Abstract and Figures

This article conducts a comparative analysis of the Egyptian webcomic superhero, Qahera with Marvel’s X-Men superhero, Dust by analysing the symbolic meaning of the veil in their storylines. By applying existing research from both comic scholars and postcolonial feminist researchers, this article illustrates how the veil can be used as a tool to perpetuate colonial prejudices as we see with Dust - or subvert them in the case of Qahera. Through both humour and political allegory, Qahera the Superhero has created a sensitive narrative for the veiled superheroine which speaks to the everyday life of a veiled Muslim woman in Egypt.
Content may be subject to copyright.
1 PhD candidate in the joint program in Communication and Culture at Ryerson University and York University in Toronto,
CANADA
*Corresponding Author: safiyya.hosein@ryerson.ca
INTRODUCTION
In recent years, webcomics have enjoyed a surge in popularity with Muslim women creators such as Huda
Fahmy and Sanya Anwar making comics that destabilise orientalist constructions of Muslim women through
humour and insight. For many years, the depiction of Muslim women in comics was dependent on industry
gatekeepers such as Marvel and DC who often characterised them as either oppressed or in the case of belly
dancers hypersexualised. In this article, I will compare two veiled Muslim superheroes Marvel’s X-Men
superhero, Dust and the Egyptian webcomic superhero, Qahera. The purpose is to illustrate how the medium of
webcomics is a powerful tool that makes Muslim women from the Global South active agents in shaping their own
narratives. By illustrating how gatekeepers construct veiled Muslim women, this comparison will reveal how the
webcomic Qahera the Superhero provides a counter-narrative to popular conceptions of veiled Muslim women as
exoticised and oppressed. As a result, webcomics are significant in destabilising orientalist narratives about Muslim
women by including their voices into media discourses and are thus a powerful social justice tool of representation.
THEORISING THE MUSLIM SUPERHERO
Muslim characters have been a part of comics for decades but have only taken on deeper significance in the
post 9/11 era with Muslim superheroes such as Ms. Marvel’s Kamala Khan and the Green Lantern’s Simon Baz.
While representation has come a long way for the depiction of Muslims in comic books, there is still room for
improvement. Before the surge in popularity of Muslim superheroes, Jack Shaheen brought attention to the
depiction of Muslims in American comic books in the 1990s. In his article Arab images in American comic books’,
Shaheen discusses a typology of Arab Muslim representation that mostly prioritises Muslim and Arab masculine
constructions. However, his analysis of Arab gender roles included the depiction of Arab Muslim women whom
he described as beingdoomed to one of two illustrations, either a scantily-clad or salivated-upon belly dancer, or
a faceless housewife, whose thick-set form is bundled up in dark robes(Shaheen, 1994: 129). The latter
construction of the faceless housewife is undoubtedly descriptive of the stereotype of the veiled Muslim woman.
Shaheen described the faceless housewife as inconsequential to the plot whose main purpose is served beingpart
of the setting’, never to be spoken to or to speak, and thus being devoid of personality’ (Shaheen, 1994: 129).
Therefore, veiled Muslim women in a pre-9/11 context in North American comic books continues to perpetuate
the stereotypical construction of being oppressed and lacked any real significance in the narrative.
Feminist Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in
Culture and Politics, 4(1), 09
ISSN: 2542-4920
Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera
Safiyya Hosein 1*
Published: April 11, 2020
ABSTRACT
This
article conducts a comparative analysis of the Egyptian webcomic superhero, Qahera with Marvel’s X
-
Men
superhero, Dust by analysing the symbolic meaning of the veil in their storylines. By applying
existing
research
from both comic scholars and postcolonial feminist researchers, this article illustrates how the
veil
can
be used as a tool to perpetuate colonial prejudices as we see with Dust - or subvert them in the case
of
Qahera.
Through both humour and political allegory, Qahera the Superhero has created a sensitive
narrative
for
the veiled superheroine which speaks to the everyday life of a veiled Muslim woman in Egypt.
Keywords:
Qahera the superhero, webcomics, veiling, Sooraya Qadir, Dust, Muslim superheroes, colonial
feminism
Hosein /Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera
2 / 12 © 2020 by Author/s
However, after 9/11, Muslim women seemed to take on new significance for the American comic book
publishers Marvel and DC, who sought to capitalise on the wider media sensationalism of Muslims by including
them in their superhero lexicon. The earliest of this inclusion was the X-Men Sooraya Qadir, codenamed Dust. As
a niqabi superhero, who flayed her opponents alive with lethal sand particles, the faceless housewife was reinvented
with a personality and an orientalist superpower, making her far more relevant to the genre of comics than before.
Furthermore, whenever she transformed from being fully veiled and robed in her human form into a naked sand
form when she used her superpower, her characterisation seemed to merge with Shaheen’s belly dancer type. Julie
Davis and Robert Westerfelhaus analysed Dust’s representation somewhat imperfectly in their short essayFinding
a place for a Muslimah heroine in the Post-9/11 Marvel Universe: New X-Men’s Dust’, which paid much attention
to the superheroine from a gendered perspective but failed to engage with any of the substantial issues regarding
the representation of her race/ethnicity. After pointing out how Dust’s religion has been used more as a tool for
sensationalism, it didn’t engage with the character’s orientalist construction. For example, the authors justify her
demeaning superhero name as a connection to the arid sands of the Arabian and Saharan deserts’, when both her
name and the superpower itself relied too much on a stereotypical perception of the Middle East as an uncivilised
desert region (Davis and Westerfelhaus, 2013: 804). When it came to engaging with her deeply sexualised imagery,
the article merely dismissed her naked sand form as reminiscent of pornography, when it was in fact more
reminiscent of eighteenth and nineteenth century harem paintings. The article concluded that she was marginalised
in comics simply because she was a woman as opposed to being a woman of colour, the authors being seemingly
unaware of the fact that non-white female superheroes have historically been given much less of a symbolic
presence in comics than their white counterparts.
However, it is worth pointing out that the veiled Muslim woman has been sensitively constructed most notably
(perhaps unsurprisingly) in Middle Eastern superhero comics. The 99 is a Kuwaiti comic that was inspired by the
powerful characters of DC and Marvel comics. Its characters are young men and women gifted with superpowers
that personify the 99 attributes of God1 (an Islamic scriptural concept) and are in a perpetual battle with the
comic’s chief villain named Rughal. By blending Islamic mythology with actual historical knowledge of the
Mongols, The 99 series has gained a cult-like following in North America. Shirin Edwin’s article, Islam’s Trojan
horse: Battling perceptions of Muslim women in The 99’, analysed the Muslim female superheroes from the series,
describing the text as a ‘polemic on Islam and Islamic feminism, in particular’ (Edwin, 2012: 171). Edwin’s article
looked at multiple female characterssome veiled, others non-religious, and from a variety of backgrounds. Her
essay primarily focused on their body language, dress code and personalities. One of her most interesting analyses
was of the veiled superhero Batina, whose power is the ability to hide and move undetected through surveillance.
The character’s natural inclination is to stay hidden but because of herNoor stone2 she is compelled to became
visible. Edwin surmises that:
Significantly, Batina’s powers, and her own personal struggles, powerfully reflect the choice of Muslim
women behind the veil who nevertheless make consistent, if unacknowledged, contributions to society.
(Edwin, 2012: 182)
The implication that a Muslim female superhero would be empowered by her faith is predictable here since the
series originated from the religious and culturally conservative Middle Eastern Gulf state, Kuwait. But what was
notable about Edwin’s observation, was her connection between the character and her veil. It can be argued that
Batina’s veil was allegorical to her shy personality, which often motivated her to stay hidden. Given that her
superpower was based on faith (the Noor stone is an allusion to Islamic mythology), her storyline thus rounds her
characterisation off appropriately with that the Noor stone is symbolically compelling her to be brave and thus be
seen.
No article on the Muslim superhero would be complete without a discussion of the rebooted Ms. Marvel, the
Pakistani-American teen Kamala Khan, who debuted to much fanfare in October 2014 and remains one of
Marvel’s most popular superheroesa heartening fact when one considers that the character is far more sensitively
told than the orientalised Dust (Diamond, 2014). Arguably, the figure of Kamala Khan is a giant step forward from
the faceless housewife and the belly dancer construction of traditional Muslim representations in comics. However,
despite her more sensitive construction, scholars have discussed some problematic aspects of the Ms. Marvel comic
series. InComics as public pedagogy: Reading Muslim masculinities through Muslim femininities in Ms. Marvel’,
Shenila S. Khoja-Moolji and Alyssa D. Niccolini pointed to one panel in Issue #1 that depicted the new Captain
Marvel, Carol Danvers, passing on theMs. Marvelmantel to Kamala in the form of a ‘celestialbeing, which they
concluded can be interpreted as a subtle reinforcement of the white saviour complex (Khoja-Moolji and Niccolini,
1 Usually referred to asThe 99 Names of Allahbut Allah is the Arabic word for Godand is used by Muslims and Arabic-
speaking Christians.
2 The superheroes in The 99 receive their superpowers from a fictional artifact called theNoor stone’.
Feminist Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in Culture and Politics, 4(1), 09
© 2020 by Author/s 3 / 12
2015: 29). The visual panel in question depicts Captain America, Iron Man, and Carol Danvers, descending from
above in a cloud of smoke with their hands in the air (Iron Man’s is folded to his chest) in front of a mesmerised
Kamala, which tends to confirm Khoja-Moolji’s and Niccolini’s analysis. This same visual panel was further
analysed in Sarah Gibbonss article, ‘I don’t exactly have quiet, pretty powers’: Flexibility and alterity in Ms. Marvel’,
for its celestial connotations, which aptly connects it to the kind of Christian iconography found in Raphael’s
painting The Transfiguration (1520). While both articles do speak of the mostly positive representation of Kamala,
their point about the white saviour complex depicted in the panel, as well as Khoja-Moolji’s and Niccolini’s
observations aboutnormality’ in the comic beinginvisibly marked by Christianity’ provides salient contributions
(Gibbons, 2017: 28). I would argue that an improvement on orientalist representations in superhero comics does
not equate to an unproblematic Muslim representation. Since the debut of Dust, in which white saviourism was
more overt, the subtle use of imagery that depicts white superheroes as saviours appears to have become a worrying
trend in Muslim superhero representation.
THE VEILED AMERICAN SUPERHERO: AN ANALYSIS OF DUST
At the beginning of the USA War on Terror, Marvel Comics introduced Dust in December 2002 in the New
X-Men series, Issue #133. Dressed in a traditional abaya (a Middle Eastern style of dress), Dust is predominantly
portrayed as veiled. Despite this veiled representation, she is not an asexual character, devoid of any desirable gaze.
On the contrary, her abaya is form-fitting to imply ample cleavage and curves beneath her garment, and her eyes
are well-defined as the only facial feature that the audience is afforded (in Middle Eastern cultures where the female
is veiled, or scarfed, eyes can carry a significant sexual power). A key element of her character’s costume is wearing
the niqab as a protection from prurient gaze. When a superhero colleague searches for her in a post-battle scene in
a later issue, she is reluctant to go back into human-form because shehas no clothesand therefore cannot make
it back to the X-Men school dormitory fully veiled. In yet another scene, she defends her choice to eat alone, stating
it is becauseit requires me to take off my hood’ (Davis and Westerfelhaus, 2013: 804). Her portrayal as a Muslim
superheroine does not appear to be so much a benevolent move of diverse inclusion bestowed by Marvel, rather
the figure is a trope that continues to reinforce blatant orientalist stereotypes that produces the age-old clash-of-
civilisations binary.
Figure 1. Henry, C. (2005). Dust on the cover of New X-Men: Hellions Vol.1, August 2005. © C. Henry.
Hosein /Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera
4 / 12 © 2020 by Author/s
It is important to consider the context of production and the possible intention in creating Muslim superheroes.
The reader may wonder why superhero comics are so eager to make a Muslim character a goodone (and more
so a superhero fighting in the name of freedom) in an age of western tension with the Islamic world? One
possibility could be best explained through Gayatri Spivak’s work on thedomesticated Otherand theimperialist
self’. In Three women’s texts and a critique of imperialism’, Spivak examines the works of authors Charlotte
Brontë, Jean Rhys, and Mary Shelley to deconstruct the imperialist undertones in their feminist works. She states:
No perspective critical of imperialism can turn the Other into a self, because the project of imperialism
has always already historically refracted what might have been the absolutely Other into a domesticated
Other that consolidates the imperialist self. (Spivak, 1985: 253)
Dust can best be described as an epitome of Spivak’s ‘domesticated Otherconsolidated for theimperialist self’.
Spivak referenced this binary when exploring imperialism and feminism in her analysis of the works of the three
White female authors she examined. Throughout her essay, she expresses wariness of the limitation of feminist
individualism when analysing western literature that alludes to the Third world and its diasporas. In many ways, a
veiled Muslim superheroine like Dust represents the same type of binary as thedomesticated Otheron one end,
and theimperialist selfon the other end. In his book Understanding Comics, Scott McCloud details the power of
drawing in comics in which he argues that the purpose of cartooning lies in itsamplification through simplification’
format. In his chapter,The vocabulary of comicshe refers to icons before discussing images and states thatby
stripping down an image to its essential meaning’, an artist can amplify that meaning in a way that realistic art
can’t(McCloud, 1994: 30). If we combine both McCloud’s and Spivak’s observations, then the domesticated
Other’ is amplified as Islam through its orientalist, veiled character and the imperialist self’ is the western audience
that the character is created for.
The impulse to domesticate the Oriental subject has far-reaching, arguably racist and gendered implications. In
her article, Do Muslim women need saving? Anthropological reflections on cultural representations and its others’,
the anthropologist and scholar Lila Abu-Lughod, mentions a 19th century conference proceedings book by
Christian missionary women entitled A Cry of Need from the Lands of Darkness Interpreted by Those who Heard it. Citing
the need to save their veiled counterparts ʻwho will never cry for themselves, for they are down under the yoke of
oppressionʼ, Abu-Lughod questions exactly why it is necessary to save these women, and for what reason? (Abu-
Lughod, 2002: 789) The clear implication is that we are saving them from Muslim menan archetype of orientalist
masculinity that has too often endured racist stereotypes as savage, oversexed and uncivilised. It is thus no
coincidence that our first introduction to an ostensibly powerful Muslim female superhero like Dust is presented
as incapacitated in her first scene while she is rescued by the white hyper-masculine ex-soldier superhero Wolverine,
who saves her from none other than these uncivilised Brown men who dare to unveil her and thus strip her of her
modesty. Ironically, these Brown men are members of the Taliban, a group of religious fanatics who have
notoriously mandated veiling in territories in Afghanistan that they control, a fact completely ignored. After Issue
#133 opens with Wolverine valiantly fighting off several Taliban members somewhere in Afghanistan, the reader
is privy to him walking into a tent only to find an unconscious Dust in the arms of a French thief Fantomex, who
is about to sell her into the mutant3 slave trade. After remarking on the deplorable treatment of women in the
Taliban-era Afghanistan, Wolverine expresses incredulity that Fantomex would exploit their vulnerability
(Morrison, Van Sciver and Rapmund, 2002). The politics of the scene is ripe with meaning when one considers
that around the same time that the comic was written, the French had rebuffed the USA in their recruitment of
western allies to join them in the invasion of Iraq. Therefore, the opening scene seems to be a mouthpiece for the
writer Grant Morrison’s political views, and the text infers that the artist disapproved of the French government’s
choice during that time. The incapacitated Dust is first seen in the arms of Fantomex before the last panel shows
her in the arms of Wolverine. Such an example of rescue by a white male from first the Taliban and then the
Frenchman not only positions Wolverine as a white male saviour but lays thewhite man’s burden’ squarely on an
American. And whilst Wolverine was born in Canada, his prior US Army service and his current home combines
a form of American nationalism with white masculinity.
It is important to discuss the cover of Issue #133 which was the issue that marked Dust’s debut. Her veiled
face appears on the front cover which is all black except for a slit of skin, revealing alarmed green eyes and dark
eyebrows, reminiscent of the iconic 1980s National Geographic cover of a startled green-eyed Afghan girl (McCurry,
1985). In a disappointing turn, the issue that introduces her depicts her from the start as marginalised by placing
her on the periphery of the main storyline where the primary focus is the rescue of Professor Xavier, which seems
at odds with her feminine and coquettish eyes which make the cover. Most troublingly, she is devoid of any
dialogue in this issue save for one Arabic word, toorab [dust], that she repeatedly utters in the ending, after being
coaxed to come out of her sand-form by Jean Grey. The scene in question is troublesome when one considers the
3 Mutants are superheroes in the X-Men series.
Feminist Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in Culture and Politics, 4(1), 09
© 2020 by Author/s 5 / 12
fact that Dust we learn, is a mutant with particularly strong powers. While the X-Men regroup in their Mumbai
headquarters, the red-headed American superheroine Jean Grey uses the mutant-location device cerebro4 to try to
locate Dust who is described earlier on as simply a ʻmutant refugeeʼ (Morrison, van Sciver and Rapmund, 2002).
While the X-Men gabber on in lively conversation, they notice the dust that is settling around a sleeping Wolverine.
Jean Grey soon announces that the mutant is in the room but just not in human form and begins to talk to Sooraya,
coaxing her into showing herself by reminding her that they were the ones who rescued her. This is shocking when
one considers that earlier on Dust was powerful enough to flay thirteen Taliban members alive in her superpower
form. The idea of a mutant that powerful being scared to appear in front of the others is a puzzling
disempowerment. The scene also juxtaposes Dust with another female character the brave, jeans-clad white
American woman, Jean Grey, who is also positioned as a saviour’ who seemingly conjures her up, thus reinforcing
Spivak’s observations of the domesticated Other.
Dust’s transformation from sand to human form is the most telling in terms of her sexual objectification since
there is a clear imprint of her undressed body in sand-form before we see her appear veiled as a human being, in
a form-fitting abaya with a curvaceous silhouette and the same alarmed eyes. It is worth noting that the first image
we see of her transformation in Issue #133 was less sexualised and slightly morbid with her ribcage featured in
one panel. However, later transformations became more overtly sexualised with her naked body more clearly
illustrated in sand form. Dust, the implied radical that cannot eat in front of others because she must first remove
ʻher hoodʼ and the defender of the niqab, becomes domesticated by the male gaze. Her lack of dialogue implies
that she is there for us to watch, objectified, and her non-existent English-speaking abilities only serves to
accentuate her exoticism. In Estranging the familiar: Eastand westin Satrapi’s Persepolis’, Nima Naghibi and
Andrew O’Malley describe the veil in terms of a ʻradical othernessʼ:
As Gayatri Spivak has famously argued, the project of imperialism has historically been to transform the
radically other into the domesticated other in a way that consolidates the (western) self. (Naghibi and
O’Malley, 2005: 226)
In their argument, the veil is the icon that amplifies the character’s construction and simplifies her as a
representative of a foreign civilisation. Already marginalised as a secondary character, Dust is reduced to being a
talking niqab. This comic symbol of ʻradicalised othernessʼ requires domestification, her purpose is to render an
idealised version of the radicalised Other that is domesticated by the western/American subject. She is non-
threatening and marginalised and the object of the male gaze.
The Islamic feminist Leila Ahmed has noted the hypocrisy of western colonisers who were obsessed with
emancipating Muslim women while also opposing women’s own emancipation campaigns in their home countries
(Ahmed, 1993: 152). Having coined the term ʻcolonial feminismʼ, Ahmed stated that during Lord Cromer’s
governorship in Egypt, he made de-veiling his mission while simultaneously opposing the Suffragist movement in
his native country, Britain (Ahmed, 1993: 151). She points out that the Suffragist movement challenged Victorian
norms and social mores which Cromer defended. In her book Rethinking Orientalism: Women, travel and the Ottoman
empire, Reina Lewis says of the harem:
There is no denying itas a topic, the harem sold books Publishers knew it, booksellers knew it,
readers knew it and authors knew it. (Lewis, 2005: 12)
Lewis argument speaks to the power of the veil in popular culture which is an artefact often conjured up in
conjunction with the western image of the harem and repeated in mainstream comics. Because Dust is depicted as
naked in her superpower form and only returns to her veiled self when she is human, she evokes the harem painting
and its mystical sexuality. But in depictions outside the harem, Muslim women were often veiled. Harem paintings,
veils and white saviours typically reinforce colonial prejudices which can be emboldened in the form of symbolic
archetypes deployed in contemporary comments.
THE VEILED EGYPTIAN SUPERHERO: AN ANALYSIS OF QAHERA
In July 2013, a previously unknown Egyptian illustrator named Deena Mohammed created a witty comic on
Tumblr meant to be a joke to her friends and poke fun at a misogynistic cleric in Egypt. The comic made a light-
hearted point about misogyny on Egyptian TV, and became a sensation on Tumblr. It soon ballooned into a bigger
project entitled Qahera the superhero and became a fan favourite online (Mohammed, 2013). The veiled superhero
has a mission to fight misogyny at home while fighting Islamophobia abroad. The webcomic’s cult-like following
4 Cerebro is a fictional device that locates mutants in the X-Men series. It was invented by two of the seriesmost important
characters, Professor Xavier and Magneto.
Hosein /Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera
6 / 12 © 2020 by Author/s
and clever social justice messages soon attracted attention in western media outlets such as the BBC, Foreign Policy,
The Washington Post, and Vice. Qahera the superhero’s playful style has helped make the comic an attraction, in its ironic
and boldly honest take on being a Muslim woman.
The construction of the character is notably different to Dust. Qahera is also dressed in an abaya but vacillates
between wearing a hijab and covering her face with a veil at other times. But she is never seen nude, and her looser-
fitting costume follows the Islamic requirements for modesty. By being a superhero that defends many different
types of Egyptians, Qahera makes it clear that she is not bogged down by the constraints of patriarchal
interpretations of religious scripture. In her comic On Basic Equality and Such, Qahera is seen saving Egyptian dogs,
Copts, partying women, street thugs, and families much to the chagrin of a judgmental male bystander who chides
her for ʻnot rescuing menʼ (Mohammed, 2019). Despite the character’s admonishment, she continues to rescue
people he disapproves of. InBeyond the veil: Graphic representation of Islamic women’, Jackie Duncan does a
comparative analysis of Qahera with Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis (2004) by analysing the use of the veil in both those
texts. She acknowledges that the veil ʻhas long been stigmatised as a form of oppression(Duncan, 2015: 1) and
determines that representations of the veil in Qahera as well as the graphic novel Persepolis illustrate multi-
dimensional complexity. She surmises that the veiled superhero in Qahera ʻis imbued with superpowers to become
a visible symbol of power under a veilʼ thus embracing her veil and using it as a source of power (Duncan, 2015:
2). She states that in Persepolis the main character ʻuses her rebellious spirit to approach the issueʼ and consistently
rebels against the suffocating limitations of an Islamist Iran (Duncan, 2015: 2). Thus the freedom to choose
whether to practice veiling or not is what both texts are essentially referring to(Duncan, 2015: 2). Duncan’s essay
concludes that:
Both interpretations offer an understanding for a more complex interpretation of the Islamic women
through their perceptions of the veil. A complexity that is compounded by veiling being stamped as an
inherent symbol of otherness. (Duncan, 2015: 3)
Duncan is not the only scholar to note the uniqueness of comics in deconstructing the veil, and
orientalism/Islamophobia. Gillian Whitlock also discusses veiling when she analyses Persepolis in her chapter
ʻAutographicsʼ in her book Soft weapons (2007). When examining the use of the veil in Satrapi’s schoolyard
playground, Whitlock remarks on its triviality to young Muslim girls when Satrapi and her peers use it as a toy to
play skipping, rather seeing it as a ʻpiece of cloth, and its fetishization by adults can seem strangeʼ (Whitlock, 2007:
190). This kind of critical intervention is novel for it treats the veil as an insignificant artefact of no real importance
which is a perspective that is rarely ever communicated in popular culture. Similarly, Qahera seems to reduce this
over-worked cultural symbol, as to her it is only useful in the superhero wardrobe. The costume does not wear the
character but rather the other way around, unlike the case with Dust.
Figure 2. Mohammed, D. (2013). Qahera the Superhero, Egypt, Tumblr, June 30
th
, 2013. © D. Mohammed.
Feminist Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in Culture and Politics, 4(1), 09
© 2020 by Author/s 7 / 12
Qahera is an allegory that synchronises the hybridity of text and images closely together. In ʻPart 1: Brainstormʼ,
the comic starts off with the veiled superheroine denoting ʻmisogynistic trashʼ with her supersonic ears before a
comic panel cuts to a cleric telling a group of men that the best wife is an obedient wife (Mohammed, 2013). Soon
after Qahera attacks the surprised cleric and hangs him on a clothesline with two laundry clips before telling him
that he’s right that ʻhousework is women’s work absolutelyʼ (Mohammed, 2013). As noted in ʻPart 10: On basic
equality and suchʼ, she pokes fun at an ignorant bystander who insults her incessantly. It ends with her saving
someone who looks like him with him finally giving his nod of approval. The point of the comic is to make jest
out of conservative Muslim masculinity. Qahera is often regarded as satirical for this reason.
Figure 3. Mohammed, D. (2013). Qahera the Superhero, Egypt, Tumblr, June 30
th
, 2013. © D. Mohammed.
Qahera the Superhero is very much a polemic on inclusive feminism. The character openly assists marginalised
members of society like refugees while standing up for Egyptian women during the Arab Spring protests in Tahrir
Square, and she has tackled everything from classism to racism in her statements. One of the earlier comics on the
European feminist group, FEMEN5 attracted criticism because of its purported violence which is surprising when
one considers the fact that Qahera the superhero is a humorous superhero comic. The Qahera artist has discussed the
criticisms in her interview with Disorient magazine (Kleer and Taxis, 2019) as well as another one where she went
into even more detail (Aleya, 2018). When FEMEN protested in front of a Swedish mosque in June 2013, perhaps
they and western audiences in general were not prepared for counter-narratives from Muslim artists to fight for
women’s rights. The comic illustrates an annoyed Qahera staring at her computer screen while FEMEN members
protest bare-breasted in front of the Swedish mosque. During the protest, Qahera veils herself before she confronts
them. After the FEMEN protestors make condescending remarks about needing to ʻsaveʼ her, she uses her sash
as a lasso to capture them, before she transports them to a far-off location to dangle them over a cliff stating,Hey
so, feel free to rescue me anytime… the question is who’s going to rescue you?(Mohammed, 2013). According to
the online news portal The Huffington Post, the real-life protest in Sweden only saw three FEMEN protestors who
described themselves as ʻsextremistsʼ and were subsequently arrested for their protest (Bennett-Smith, 2013). In
an interview with Disorient magazine online, Mohammed responded to some of the criticism of the FEMEN comic
by stating that:
The problem is to define feminism through gender issues only, without taking anything else into account.
You can’t be a feminist if you are oppressing other women. You can’t be a feminist if you are classist or
racist. A lot of people in Egypt tend to disrespect feminism because they are very familiar with a very
bourgeois type of feminism that is aligned with the state. People offend your intellect when you are
expected to believe a feminism that claims to fight for women’s rights but disrespects other human
rights. (Kleer and Taxis, 2019)
In referring to FEMEN’s Islamophobic views on veiling as a form of oppression the counter-argument by Islamic
and/or Muslim feminists is posed of Muslim women’s agency when it comes to choosing to veil.
5 A European feminist group who refer to themselves assextremists’. They include atheism in their ideology and protest
topless.
Hosein /Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera
8 / 12 © 2020 by Author/s
Figure 4. Mohammed, D. (2013). Qahera the Superhero, Egypt, Tumblr, July 20
th
, 2013. © D. Mohammed.
In the FEMEN comic the creator appears to draw a direct allusion to Wonder Woman, a feminist superhero
who has also faced criticism for being too sexualised, as indicated in the UN’s brief choice for Wonder Woman as
an ambassador for the empowerment of women and girls for which they faced intense backlash for choosing an
icon that was decidedly too sexualised. After protests and an online petition was launched, the decision to use her
as an icon was rescinded (Ross, 2016). A hallmark weapon of Wonder Woman is her magic lasso, so when in the
FEMEN comic Qahera uses her sash as a make-do lasso to capture the FEMEN protestors, this allusion appears
deliberately intertextual. Another interpretation of Qahera’s ad-hoc lasso can be to suggest a sense of solidarity
with other iconic female superheroes and an attempt to indigenise the superheroine trope to an Egyptian Muslim
audience. From this angle, the comic can be read as one that builds solidarity with feminist allies. (It is also quite
possible that the comic was providing commentary on the policing of women’s choices in dress as well.)
Figure 5. Mohammed, D. (2013). Qahera the Superhero, Egypt, Tumblr, July 20th, 2013. © D. Mohammed.
Figure 6. Mohammed, D. (2013). Qahera the Superhero, Egypt, Tumblr, July 20
th
, 2013. © D. Mohammed.
Feminist Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in Culture and Politics, 4(1), 09
© 2020 by Author/s 9 / 12
In Women and Gender in Islam, Leila Ahmed tackles the arguments of two Arab men during the colonial era
Qassim Amin (known as the ʻFather of Arab Feminismʼ) and Talat Harb, a hardline Islamist, arguing that Amin’s
perspectives are a reinscription of colonial discourses about Islam’s inferiority and the ʻbackwardnessʼ of the veil.
His proposals, which included a ban on veiling and segregation, was later espoused by the middle classes and Arab
feminists. When coupled with other male thinkers of his time who held his same contempt for the veil, Ahmed
concluded that their ʻtrue motivationʼ was in fact that:
(…) they are men of the classes assimilating to European ways and smarting under the humiliation of
being described as uncivilized becausetheirwomen are veiled, and they are determined to eradicate the
practice. (Ahmed, 1993: 165)
Ahmed illustrates how Harb asserted patriarchy like Cromer and Amin, but this time through a reversal. On the
debates between both Amin and Harb, she stated that:
(…) the argument between Harb and Amin centered not on feminism versus antifeminism but on
Western versus indigenous ways. For neither side was male dominance ever in question. (Ahmed, 1993:
163)
This trope is concretely applicable to Qahera in the ʻPart 7: On women’s choicesʼ comic which starts off with
Qahera and her unveiled friend walking into a restaurant where two men begin to discuss them. One of them terms
the veil as ʻa shame to seeʼ and surmises that it is oppressive (Mohammed, 2015), arguing that a progressive society
would not have so many veiled women and advocates policies that support de-veiling. The other man begins to
defend the veil and connects it quickly to ʻprotectionʼ and states a much-repeated folk analogy about the veil being
like candy wrapper. Qahera notices that her friend looks uncomfortable and she disrupts both men, slamming her
fists on the table. She begins to yell at them that women are human beings and that ʻwomen’s lives are not for you
to prove a pointʼ before she storms off (Mohammed, 2015). Interestingly, this comic does not show her using any
of her superpowers thus reframing her as an ordinary human being to possibly drive the point home that ordinary
feminists can take such action.
The subtleties and nuance of the comic can also be described through other choices on Mohammed’s part for
drawing a Muslim superhero in hijab. Making it clear that the comic is specifically about commentary on Egyptian
life and politics, she states to Disorient:
First, I just thought it would be interesting to have a superhero that doesn’t look like the other ones.
Second, I like things that represent reality and I wanted her to look like most Egyptian women, to
represent them... Also, from a character design perspective it’s just nice to draw someone that looks
different to stereotypical designs of female superheroes. I would think about how she would fly and
what that would look like. And in Egypt a veil [is] such a practical costume. You can just pull up the
niqab and you are unrecognized. It’s a character that feels bothdifferent and familiar. (Kleer and Taxis,
2019)
We see the practicality of the costume in detail in her comic, ʻPart 9: On Things We have to Worry Aboutʼ where
Qahera addresses the everyday lives of Egyptians and the things they need to worry about such as traffic and the
economy. A few panels into the comic, we see the character alternating between being veiled and unveiled at times.
For instance, in the panel with her addressing a crowd about ʻcontroversial political opinionsʼ she is veiled
(Mohammed, 2019). In the panel after that, she is unveiled when speaking to an elderly woman about gender roles.
When the costume calls for anonymity such as addressing a crowd on controversial politics, she is veiled. When
she is not in the spotlight but addressing someone else’s point of view, she chooses to not be veiled. A few panels
later, she is seen veiled in a mob fighting back armed men. The veil is seen as practical, it provides anonymity
which serves her strategy when fighting off enemies, so they have a harder time identifying her.
In contrast to the western representation of Dust, this type of comic and character is ground-breaking. When
the veil is represented for practicality, and not for any orientalist uses the image is not exploitative. Mohammed’s
superhero is made for an Egyptian audience while American superhero comics are made for western audiences
but of course Muslims, people of colour, and marginalised groups form part of western audiences too.
Mohammed’s work does cater to an Egyptian audience, but she makes it clear that while she primarily draws for
the audience, she also draws for western ones as well. She cited the FEMEN comic as an example and admits that
she did not translate it in Arabic because of its lack of relevance to Egyptians (Kleer and Taxis, 2019). This recalls
Leah Misemer (2017), who discusses webcomics as a space for community-building and solidarity. Misemer points
out that webcomics often address multiple audiences, making them a space that serves multiple purposes (Misemer,
2017: 5). By addressing a non-Muslim western audience, Qahera is not only a counter-narrative to popular
Hosein /Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera
10 / 12 © 2020 by Author/s
misconceptions of the veil and Muslim women’s representation but also potentially a learning space for them. For
Muslim audiences in the west, it can function more as a space for solidarity. And for Egyptian audiences, it can
function as a space for both familiarity and solidarity for specific political themes such as the refugee crisis in 2015.
Figure 7. Mohammed, D. (2013). Qahera the Superhero, Egypt, Tumblr, June 30
th
, 2013. © D. Mohammed.
While Dust is veiled, she is still sexualised with the form-fitting abaya and niqab with coquettish and startled
eyes when viewed up close. Mohammed’s character on the other hand is not sexualised and not subject to the male
gaze. Panels of the superheroine’s eyes betray expressions of anger and frustration when she hears for example the
misogynistic cleric. When one considers the cover of New X-Men #133 where Dust’s alluring green eyes and startled
expression stares back at the reader, one can’t help but think that they were drawn to accentuate her ʻexoticismʼ
as opposed to reveal anything substantial about the inner character. With that said, perhaps the one ground-
breaking aspect of Dust lies in the fact that she was the first Muslim superhero in the post-9/11 era and it is
possible that her representation as a Muslim superhero inspired the later Muslim superheroes in comics such as
Kamala Khan, and the characters in The 99. From that aspect, her representation was necessary in its own way.
Figure 8. Mohammed, D. (2013). Qahera the Superhero, Egypt, Tumblr, July 20
th
, 2013. © D. Mohammed.
Keeping these perspectives in mind, Qahera is representative of Spivak’s ʻabsolutely Otherʼ as opposed to the
ʻdomesticated Otherʼ. And in this construction, we see a revolutionary tactic in Qahera as representing the
resistance of theimperialist selfrather than a consolidation of it. The ʻabsolutely Otherʼ can therefore be deduced
as a holistic representation of the Other not refracted through the imperialist self and therefore can be best
described as a decolonised representation of a veiled Muslim superhero. Technically the ʻradical Othernessʼ in
Qahera is instead a radical resistance to colonial biases told through veiling and intersectional feminism.
CONCLUSION
The growing popularity of webcomics is a testament to the eagerness of members of marginalised groups to
speak with their own voices and under their own terms. Whether most creators intend it or not, their work can be
a resistance to popular misconceptions and biases found in mainstream publications and their representations of
marginalised groups. Mohammed has made it clear that she is intentionally political in her outlooks on class and
misogyny, which is apparent through reading her comic. Ironically, while Islamophobia is not an existential threat
to her, she does admit that her first encounter with it was through the comments about Qahera in a BBC online
article (Kleer and Taxis, 2019). But as a well-informed and passionate creator taking on such political issues, she
Feminist Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in Culture and Politics, 4(1), 09
© 2020 by Author/s 11 / 12
was aware of the growing threat of Islamophobia and has sought to challenge stereotypes of Muslim women
through her drawing of Qahera. With comic characters such as Dust still a reality in superhero comics and a lot of
marginalised issues being funneled into autobiographical comics, she has made an effective choice in creating a
webcomic about a Muslim superhero. By creating a veiled Muslim superhero, she adds a rich and challenging
dimension in this increasingly popular archetype.
REFERENCES
About Us - FEMEN. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://femen.org/about-us/ (Accessed 28 December 2019).
Abu-Lughod, L. (2002). Do Muslim women really need saving? Anthropological reflections on cultural relativism
and its others. American Anthropologist, 104(3), 783-790.
Ahmed, L. (1993). Women and Gender in Islam: Historical roots of a modern debate. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Aleya, S. (2018). Interview Deena Mohammed. Available at: http://www.tarshi.net/inplainspeak/interview-
deena-mohamed-qahera/ (Accessed 28 December 2019).
Bennett-Smith, M. (2013). Topless FEMEN activists protest In Swedish mosque, allegedly calledwhores from
hell (NSFW, video). Available at: https://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2013/07/01/femen-protest-mosque-
sweden-whores_n_3530171.html (Accessed 3 August 2019).
Davis, J. and Westerfelhaus, R. (2013). Finding a place for a Muslimah heroine in the post-9/11 Marvel Universe:
New X-Men’s Dust. Feminist Media Studies, 13(5), 800-809.
Duncan, J. (2015, April). Beyond the veil: Graphic representation of Islamic women. The Compass, 1(2), 1-9.
Top 100 Graphic Novels: October 2014. (2014, October). Available at:
https://www.diamondcomics.com/Home/1/1/3/237?articleID=156090 (Accessed 3 August 2019).
Edwin, S. (2012, December). Islam’s Trojan horse: Battling perceptions of Muslim women in The 99. Journal of
Graphic Novels and Comics, 3(2), 171-1999.
Gibbons, S. (2017). ‘I don’t exactly have quiet, pretty powers’: Flexibility and alterity in Ms. Marvel. Journal of Graphic
Novels and Comics, 8(5), 450-463.
Kent, M. (2015). Unveiling marvels: Ms. Marvel and the reception of the new Muslim superheroine. Feminist Media
Studies, 15(3), 522-538.
Khoja-Moolji, S. and Niccolini, A.D. (2015). Comics as public pedagogy: Reading Muslim masculinities through
Muslim femininities in Ms. Marvel. Girlhood Studies, 8(3), 23-39.
Kleer, L. and Taxis, C. (2019). You can’t be a feminist if you are oppressing other womenan interview with Egyptian artist
Deena Mohamed. Available at: https://www.disorient.de/blog/you-cant-be-feminist-if-you-are-oppressing-
other-women-interview-egyptian-artist-deena-mohamed?fbclid=IwAR38JbXMIKqZkSDCJzdhgwZyM2iGq
URXrGCapU8mdNCPdAoVHNpTIrg17dU (Accessed 3 August 2019).
Lewis, R. (2005). Rethinking Orientalism: Women, travel and the Ottoman harem. London: I.B. Tauris.
McCurry, S. (1985, June). Afghan girl. National Geographic.
McCloud, S. (1994). Understanding Comics: The invisible art. New York: Harper Perennial.
Misemer, L. Webcomics building communities: Depression and visibility in Hyperbole and a half. Comics and
Medicine Conference, Seattle, WA, June 2017.
Mohammed, D. (2013, June 30). Part 1: Brainstorm. Available at: https://qaherathesuperhero.com/post/
64031330049 (Accessed April 25th, 2019).
Mohammed, D. (2015, July 28). Part 7: On women’s choices. Available at: https://qaherathesuperhero.com/post/
125314061196 (Accessed April 25th, 2019).
Mohammed, D. (2019, April 10). On basic equality and such. Available at: https://qaherathesuperhero.com/post/
184095849551 (Accessed April 25th, 2019).
Mohammed, D. (2019, February 18). Part 9: Things we have to worry about. Available at:
https://qaherathesuperhero.com/post/182896728481 (Accessed April 25th, 2019).
Morrison, G., Van Sciver, E. and Rapmund, N. (2002). New X-Men: Issue #133 [Comic] (Vol. 1). New York, NY:
Marvel.
Naghibi, N. and O’Malley, A. (2005). Estranging the familiar: Eastand Westin Satrapi’s Persepolis. English Studies
in Canada, 31(2-3), 223-247.
Ross, A. (2016). One less woman in politics: Wonder Woman loses job as UN ambassador. The Guardian. Available
at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/dec/12/wonder-woman-un-ambassador-gender-equality
(Accessed 3 August 2019).
Said, E. W. (1979). Orientalism. New York: Vintage Books.
Satrapi, M. (2004). Persepolis. New York City, NY: Pantheon.
Shaheen, J. G. (1994). Arab images in American comic books. Journal of Popular Culture, 28(1), 123-133.
Shaheen, J. (1991). The comic book Arab. The Link, 24(5), 1-11.
Hosein /Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera
12 / 12 © 2020 by Author/s
Spivak, G. C. (1985). Three women’s texts and a critique of imperialism. Critical Inquiry, 12(1), 243-261.
Weir, C., de Felippis, N. and Henry, C. (2005). New X-Men: Hellions (Vol. 1). New York City, NY: Marvel Worldwide
Inc.
Whitlock, G. (2007). Soft Weapons: Autobiography in transit. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Citation: Hosein, S. (2020). Veiling the Superhero: A Comparative Analysis of Dust and Qahera. Feminist
Encounters: A Journal of Critical Studies in Culture and Politics, 4(1), 09. https://doi.org/10.20897/femenc/7913
Copyright © 2020 by Author/s and Licensed by Lectito BV, Netherlands. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons
Attribution License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
In this article we examine the production and operation of the character, Kamala Khan, a Muslim American-Pakistani superheroine of the Ms. Marvel comic series, to glean what this reveals about Islam and Muslims, with particular attention to representations of Muslim masculinities. We argue that Ms. Marvel's invitation to visualize Muslim girls as superheroes is framed by a desire to interrupt rampant Islamophobia and xenophobia, yet, in order to produce such a disruption it relies on, and (re)produces, stereotypical conceptualizations of Muslim masculinities as mirrored in men who are conservative, prone to irrational rage, pre-modern, anachronistic, and even bestial. However, as the series progresses we notice the emergence of representations of complex and complicated Muslim masculinities that cast doubt on these tired, hackneyed ones, thus making way for a comic to undertake the pedagogical work of resistance. We see this graphic novel, like the shape-shifting Kamala herself, as wielding potentially dynamic and transformative power in social imaginaries.
Article
The new Ms. Marvel series featuring Kamala Khan has been tremendously popular, having garnered significant media attention since its launch in 2014. This article analyses the representation of freaked and Othered bodies in the series. It suggests that the visual representation of Kamala’s extraordinary flexibility parallels thematic concerns surrounding the figurative flexibility to crises demanded of the characters who share her home in Jersey City; the body in this series is a site for the negotiation of and resistance to neoliberal ideologies. While Kamala’s literal flexibility is her greatest power, her visual non-conformity suggests that she is an admirable hero because she refuses to subscribe to a contemporary economic narrative that requires individuals to be flexible to unreasonable bodily demands.
Article
Soon after the attacks on the US on September 11, 2001, Marvel Comics introduced Dust, an observant Sunni Muslim, as a member of the New X-Men. In this study, we point out how the focus upon her Islamic faith departs from conventional depictions of superheroes in American popular media. Additionally, we discuss how her religious beliefs and practices define her as different, and thus sets her apart, from other superheroes. We also examine how, in keeping with the American monomyth metanarrative that informs the superhero genre, Dust functions as a liminal character, one who bridges the worlds of Islam and the West. The paper concludes by noting that Dust, in common with other superheroines, is relegated to the periphery of Marvel's narratives primarily because she is female.
Article
The September 11 attacks intensified media and scholarly attention on Muslim women, occasioning controversial debates and discussions ranging from curious questions about Muslim women's lives to eager clarifications on their status in Islamic societies. While numerous responses contributed to clearing space for the inclusion of Muslim women's issues in international fora, these well-meaning efforts ended up reinforcing pre-9/11 beliefs about their oppression and subordination in Islamic societies, and ironically narrowed the dialectic of feminism in Islam to a struggle between women and religious fundamentalism. It was to widen this dialectic, among other things, and to expand the normative boundaries of feminist critique of Islam that Naif Al-Mutawa responded with his comic book The 99 by presenting Muslim women as superheroes. However, as this paper will argue, it is not in the unilateral representation of women as villain-bashing superheroes in direct contrast to their portrayal as defenseless victims of violence but to unravel the complex dimensions of feminisms in Islam that also include women's weaknesses, struggles and problems, that The 99 visualizes a timely response to the ongoing polemic on Islam and Islamic feminism, in particular.
Article
This article explores the ethics of the current "War on Terrorism, asking whether anthropology, the discipline devoted to understanding and dealing with cultural difference, can provide us with critical purchase on the justifications made for American intervention in Afghanistan in terms of liberating, or saving, Afghan women. I look first at the dangers of reifying culture, apparent in the tendencies to plaster neat cultural icons like the Muslim woman over messy historical and political dynamics. Then, calling attention to the resonances of contemporary discourses on equality, freedom, and rights with earlier colonial and missionary rhetoric on Muslim women, I argue that we need to develop, instead, a serious appreciation of differences among women in the world—as products of different histories, expressions of different circumstances, and manifestations of differently structured desires. Further, I argue that rather than seeking to "save" others (with the superiority it implies and the violences it would entail) we might better think in terms of (1) working with them in situations that we recognize as always subject to historical transformation and (2) considering our own larger responsibilities to address the forms of global injustice that are powerful shapers of the worlds in which they find themselves. I develop many of these arguments about the limits of "cultural relativism" through a consideration of the burqa and the many meanings of veiling in the Muslim world. [Keywords: cultural relativism, Muslim women, Afghanistan war, freedom, global injustice, colonialism]
Article
El autor ofrece un acercamiento al mundo de las historietas desde el punto de vista de que se trata de un medio de comunicación con una estructura y un lenguaje propio. Analizan los diversos elementos de las historietas, desde el vocabulario hasta su diseño y su retórica.