ArticlePDF Available

Becoming global talent? Taiwanese white-collar migrants in Japan

March 2020
Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 47(2):1-17

DOI:10.1080/1369183X.2020.1731986

Authors:

National Taiwan University

As more governments implement skill-based migration policies, understanding how policymakers, employers and migrants evaluate and interpret skills is of great importance. Based on a study of Taiwanese white-collar migrant workers in Japan, this article treats skills as socially constructed and offers an opportunity to investigate how skill is experienced across borders. This article makes contribution to skilled migration research by investigating the social contexts in which skills are categorised, evaluated, and developed, and how such experiences feed into migration decisions and adaptation outcomes. To many Taiwanese college-educated migrants, coming to work in Japan is a first step in being recognized as ‘global talent’. The initial successful migration outcome fails, however, to retain these new arrivals to corporate Japan. Taiwanese migrant professionals usually do not aspire to develop the firm-specific skills and in-house careers that Japanese-style training regimes offer.

Content uploaded by Yen-Fen Tseng

Content may be subject to copyright.

Content uploaded by Yen-Fen Tseng

Content may be subject to copyright.

Accepted version

(accepted version to be published by Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, online first

Tangled mobilities. Places, affects, and personhood across social spheres in Asian migration

Book

Full-text available

Jul 2022

The emotional, social, and economic challenges faced by migrants and their families are interconnected through complex decisions related to mobility. Tangled Mobilities examines the different crisscrossing and intersecting mobilities in the lives of Asian migrants, their family members across Asia and Europe, and the social spaces connecting these regions. In exploring how the migratory process unfolds in different stages of migrants’ lives, the chapters in this collected volume broaden perspectives on mobility, offering insights into the way places, affects, and personhood are shaped by and connected to it. OPEN ACCESS with support from Knowledge Unlatched: https://library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12657/57164/external_content.epub?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

What's Talent Got to Do with It? The Collective Labourer and the Rise of Barcelona's Digital Economy

Article

Full-text available

Sep 2023

This article explains the recent rise to prominence of Barcelona's digital economy, and, specifically, the role played by the city's “talent”. After developing a Marxian approach, we show how Barcelona's success rests upon a good supply of low‐cost, appropriately skilled labour fit for insertion into labour processes that can generally not be described as innovative or of high‐knowledge, high‐skill intensity. There is, in fact, a dearth of highly skilled labour‐power in the city, and inflows of foreign labour and outflows of freshly trained “talent” from the city's bootcamps are only swelling the ranks of a lower‐paid, moderately skilled knowledge workforce—many of whom work in low‐quality jobs. Finally, we show how leading startups in the digital economy are contributing to the expansion of “non‐standard” forms of precarious work. We conclude by highlighting the limits to the development and realisation of human productive subjectivity or talent under capital today, even in a widely hyped technopole such as Barcelona.

Immigration and labor shortages: Learning from Japan and the United Kingdom

Article

Full-text available

Jul 2023
ASIAN PAC MIGR J

Industrialized countries have increasingly used skill-based selective migration policies to reduce labor and skill shortages. But are these policies effective? This paper uses Japan and the United Kingdom to illustrate how immigration policy and employment, training and labor practices influence labor and skill supply. Until recently, these two countries had different migration policies and labor practices. Yet data shows similar patterns of labor and skill shortage profiles in both countries. This paper draws on empirical research to argue that such outcomes suggest that immigration policies will not alleviate labor and skill shortages unless accompanied by the transformation of employment and training practices.

Macro talent management: Literature review

Article

Jan 2022

This literature review is devoted to the analysis of the existing empirical studies in areas related to Macro Talent Management and its research directions. The study presents a systematic literature review of 150 empirical papers in peer-reviewed journals for the period from 2011 to 2021. Macro Talent Management is a complex phenomenon that combines different interrelated processes at country and organization levels. Socio-economic and cultural macro factors have a significant impact on human capital mobility, which can be represented as talent attraction and retention processes and, therefore, as a component of Macro Talent Management. At the same time, human capital mobility itself influences the indicators of countries and regions’ development at macro level. At country level, talent development requires joint actions of state institutions and organizations, while Macro Talent Management system can affect the countries’ economic indicators. However, it can be concluded that the literature lacks a sufficiently detailed consideration of the implementation of Macro Talent Management system; the impact of characteristics of political regimes and cultural characteristics on formation of Macro Talent Management in different countries is not fully described, as well as the influence of Macro Talent Management on innovative development at macro level is studied generally. This review allows researchers to clarify issues related to the subject of Macro Talent Management and the existing gaps in the literature. As a result of the analysis, we identified several areas for further research. First, it is important to study the mechanisms of inter-level interaction in talent management both in terms of human capital mobility and talent development within a country. It is also necessary to study in detail the influence of political and cultural characteristics in countries as conditions for the implementation of these activities by agents. Finally, the impact of talent management on innovation development at macro level has been studied rather generally, without considering the impact of specific processes on innovation activity of particular countries.

How does post‐study employment policy for international students create “skilled” migrants? The case of Japan

Article

Aug 2023

Yusuke Mazumi

The recent literature on skilled migration has addressed the socially constructed nature of the notion and category of “skilled” migrants, revealing the roles of the host state and its admission policy in shaping these migrants. This article adds to the literature by examining how the host state can also socially (or politically) create “skilled” migrants through policy that facilitates the post‐study employment of international students. The extant research on the social construction of skill and skilled migration informs the hypothesizing of three strategic ways in which host states seek to retain international students who may otherwise be excluded from the host labour market after graduation: (1) the creation of new work permits, (2) the discretionary relaxing of criteria for issuing work visas and (3) the provision of skilling support for finding employment. The case of Japan empirically validates all these strategies and indicates the particular significance of the second strategy.

Makro Yetenek Yönetimi Üzerine Bir Literatür TaramasıA Literature Review on Macro Talent Management

Article

May 2023

Olgun İrmak ÇETİN

Makro yetenek yönetimi kavramı, kamu kurumlarının ve diğer makro-ekonomik faktörlerin, yetenek yönetimi süreçleri üzerindeki etkisine odaklanmaktadır. Bu amaçla, önerilen literatür taraması, makro yetenek yönetimi alanında yapılan ampirik çalışmaların analizine dayanmaktadır. 2010-2021 yılları arasında hakemli dergilerde sunulan 155 ampirik makalede belirli araştırma alanları analiz edilmiştir. İlgili çalışmalarda, makro düzeyde yetenek yönetim sistemini oluşturan ana süreçlerin, beşeri sermaye hareketliliği üzerinde etkili olan sosyo-ekonomik ve kültürel makro faktörlerle ilişkili olduğu bulunmuştur. Aynı zamanda hareketliliğin, ülke ve bölgelerin gelişmişlik göstergelerini etkilediği de bulunan sonuçlar arasındadır. Ülkede yetenek gelişimi, kurumlar ve hükümet arasında işbirliğine dayalı çalışmalar gerektirmektedir. İnşa edilen sistem, ekonomik performansı etkileyebilmektedir. Analiz sonucunda, gelecekteki araştırmalar için bir dizi yön tespit edilmiştir. Birincisi, ülke içinde beşeri sermaye hareketliliği ve yeteneklerin gelişimi gibi konularda yetenek yönetimine ilişkin kurumlar arası etkileşimin önemli olduğudur. Uygulama için ülkenin siyasi ve kültürel özelliklerinin ayrıntılı bir çalışması yapılmalıdır. Son olarak, yetenek yönetiminin makro düzeyde inovasyon gelişimi üzerindeki etkisi, belirli süreçlerin tek tek ülkelerin inovasyon faaliyetleri üzerindeki etkisi dikkate alınmadan oldukça genel olarak incelendiği için yetersiz görünmektedir.

References

Chapter

Dec 2022

Helena Hof

Embedded Coexistence: Social Adaptation of Chinese Female White-Collar Workers in Japan

Article

Full-text available

Jan 2023

In Japan, Chinese female white-collar workers have emerged as a rapidly growing social group. Unlike traditional female migrants, high-skilled women exhibit more autonomy and strategy in their interactions with mainstream society. Traditional immigrant theories do not apply to their patterns of social adaptation. The paper draws on qualitative research with 38 Chinese female white-collar workers working in Tokyo after graduating from Japanese colleges. It illustrates their performance and strategies in adapting to Japanese society and explores how their decision-making process is shaped. The findings show that they exhibit a selective adaptation: They self-identify as “permanent sojourners”—they are eclectic, but inclined to maintain a cultural cognition ordered around their homeland culture, and they have multiple contacts across ethnic groups and reserve cultural differences in social interactions. Furthermore, this mode of adaptation results from the interaction of three factors: individual rational choice, the mutual pressure of the in-group and the out-group, and the national policies and historical issues between China and Japan. This paper argues that the migration patterns of different migrant groups should be interpreted in light of the subjectivity of migrants, taking into account their initiative, human capital, gender, and ethnicity. This study enriches the study of international female migration and adds to the practical research on social adaptation patterns among immigrants.

مقارنة منهجيات الكشف عن الطلاب الموهوبين في مجموعة من الدول الأجنبية (أمريكا ، بريطانيا ، فرنسا ، ألمانيا ، اليابان )

Article

Oct 2022

مشعل بن سعد السليمي الحربي

Brokerage in the Cross-border Labour Market: Recruitment and Training of Vietnamese IT Workers by Japanese Temporary Staffing Firms

Article

Aug 2022
Asian Stud Rev

Aimi Muranaka

Despite a declining population, the Japanese government has been reluctant to relax its immigration policy, which has forced private companies to seek their own ways of sourcing foreign labour. This article explores how Japanese temporary staffing firms (TSFs) have shaped the cross-border labour market for skilled labour candidates by developing their own educational programmes and networks in Japan and Vietnam. While existing research on the international migration industry and brokerage focuses on private brokers in the different stages of migration, this study examines the role of private actors in the migration process, from recruitment to training. The study is based on fieldwork, including interviews with staff of Japanese TSFs, their client companies and Vietnamese IT workers. The findings are twofold. First, through their own recruitment and training schemes, these TSFs provide Japanese language and culture training to Vietnamese skilled labour candidates on behalf of their clients. Second, such training is used to create ‘ideal’ migrant workers for Japanese employers. The study thus illustrates that intermediary actors are indispensable to the migration process, which creates mutual dependency between TSFs, Vietnamese workers and Japanese companies in the cross-border labour market.

Who are the fittest? The question of skills in national employment systems in an age of global labour mobility

Article

Full-text available

Mar 2020

Faced with demographic as well as economic changes, Germany and Japan have liberalised immigration controls for skilled migrants, set targets for foreign student enrolments in university, and introduced visa categories to enable foreign graduates to enter their labour markets. Yet a relatively modest share of foreign graduates actually receives jobs appropriate to their skill-level and remain in these labour markets. In this article, we focus on organisational recruitment and employment practices, especially those related to skill formation and the structuring of careers, as factors affecting the remain rates of foreign graduates. Our analysis shows that while obtaining the same educational credentials as native students, foreign graduates are disadvantaged because the employment systems of the host countries operate according to the logic of national labour markets, entailing institutionally and culturally specific skill expectations as well as formation processes. Consequently, foreign graduates either fail to enter the market, or are placed in lower or niche categories in a differentiated labour market.

Social construction of skill: an analytical approach toward the question of skill in cross-border labour mobilities

Article

Full-text available

Mar 2020

Selecting labour migrants based on skill has become a widely practised migration policy in many countries around the world. Since the late twentieth century, research on ‘skilled’ and ‘highly skilled’ migration has raised important questions about the value and ethics of skill-based labour mobility. More recent research has begun to question the concept of skill and skill categorisation in both government policy and academic research. Taking the view that migrants’ skill is socially constructed, we centre our discussion on three questions: Who are the arbitrators of skill? What constitutes skill? And how is skill constructed in the migration process and in turn, how does skill affect the mobility? We show that diverse actors are involved in the process of identifying, evaluating and shaping migrant skill. The interpretation of migrants’ skill is frequently distorted by their ascriptive characteristics such as race, ethnicity, gender and nationality, reflecting the influence of colonial legacy, global inequality as well as social stratification. Finally, this special issue emphasises the complex, and frequently reciprocal, relationship between skill and mobility.

Overcoming the Ethnocentric Firm?-Foreign Fresh University Graduate Employment in Japan as a New International Human Resource Development Method

Article

Full-text available

Apr 2017

This article analyses a new and, by international comparison, distinct recruitment trend – the systematic hiring of foreign fresh university graduates (FFGs) into Japanese multinational enterprises' (MNEs) operations in Japan. Our explorative research, which is based on interviews with HR managers and FFGs, offers three major findings related to international HR development methods. Firstly, the inpatriate literature has identified the roles of foreign (subsidiary) staff as knowledge conduits and boundary-spanners between headquarters and subsidiaries. While such objectives do not drive Japan's FFG hiring trend, we find similar challenges in terms of the absorptive capacities of headquarters. Secondly, following a Varieties-of-Capitalism perspective, we argue that FFG hiring is an institutional answer to the particularities of Japan's employment system. Aiming at internationalizing headquarters from within, it contributes to resolving the internationalization conundrum of Japanese MNEs, but rather than overcoming the existing ethnocentric HR model it accommodates this orientation. Thirdly, we advance the general HR literature by proposing a new framework that addresses the viability of international personnel development methods in dependence of the workforce diversity and distinctiveness of employment practices in headquarters. We locate FFG hiring, inpatriation and self-initiated assignments within this framework.

International human resource management of Japanese multinational corporations: Challenges and future directions

Article

Full-text available

Apr 2016

Japanese multinational corporations (MNCs) enjoyed global success until the early 1990s, but recent trends have presented many challenges, necessitating adaptations to international human resource management (IHRM) and other management practices. In reviewing recent changes in the IHRM of Japanese MNCs by focusing on 'internal internationalization' at headquarters and 'external internationalization' in foreign subsidiaries, we develop a framework that elucidates these processes through the characteristics of industries and Japanese MNCs. Moreover, we discuss future research avenues for a deeper understanding of Japanese IHRM and generating new knowledge in the IHRM field.

What's in a research agenda? An evaluation of research developments in the arena of skilled international migration

Article

Full-text available

Jan 2015

Research on skilled international migration has developed significantly in the last 25 years. This paper reviews progress in understanding the structuring power of transnational companies and international recruitment agencies in shaping global talent flows. It argues that four main strands in the research literature flow from this: work in international human resource management; analysis of the migration-development nexus; studies of city development associated with creative knowledge workers; and cultural geographies of expatriate identities. This paper interprets trends in research on these topics in relation to the wider issue of how some social scientists have become more reflexive about their engagement with research and thus have re-positioned the nature of what is considered to be the contemporary research agenda on skilled migration. This re-positioning is recognised to have strengths but also difficulties from a policy perspective.

Skilled or unskilled?: The reconfiguration of migration policies in Japan

Article

Jan 2021

Nana Oishi

While Japan has long been perceived as a country with restrictive immigration policies, it has been rapidly widening its immigration gates through various policy reforms in the past decade. The most prominent policy shift in Japan took place in 2018 when the government decided to officially open its labour market to migrants who work in 14 occupational sectors, including agriculture, elder care and construction, which used to be considered ‘unskilled’ and 'semi-skilled' in previous migration schemes. This study analyses how the major shifts in Japan’s migration policies have been introduced through the redefinition of ‘skills’ and ‘skilled migrants’. In doing so, it integrates the scholarly debates on immigration policymaking in Japan and the literature on the conceptualisation of skills. By reviewing the development of skilled migration policies and some impactful discourses driven by global, national and regional forces, this study argues that the ambiguous nature of ‘skills’ and the multi-level merits as outcomes have facilitated the major policy transformation in Japan.

A Closed Immigration Country: Revisiting Japan as a Negative Case

Article

Mar 2018

Ayako Komine

The Japanese government maintains that the country admits only skilled economic migrants. Its statistics tell a different story. Skilled and low-skilled economic migrants are admitted in equal measure. The aim of this article is to explain the dissonance between the government's policy rhetoric and policy outcome by turning to policy output. To this end, I quantitatively analyse immigration admission channels for economic migrants, using Ruhs' Openness and Rights Indicators (2013). The main findings not only go against much of what we believe about Japan but helps us reach a more nuanced understanding of its immigration policies. I demonstrate that Japanese immigration admission policies have become more open towards de facto low-skilled economic migrants over time and are more open to de facto low-skilled economic migrants than to de jure skilled economic migrants. Instead of openness, the gains made by certain groups of de jure skilled economic migrants have been exclusive immigration privileges related to permanent residence and family sponsorship.

Growing Restrictiveness or Changing Selection? The Nature and Evolution of Migration Policies

Article

Jul 2016
INT MIGR REV

This paper demonstrates that, since 1945, migration policies have overall become less restrictive. Challenging common assumptions, this long-term trend is robust across most of the 45 countries included in the DEMIG POLICY database. While the period after 1989 is characterized by a slowing down of the rapid post-WWII liberalization of migration policies, liberal policy changes have continued to outnumber restrictive policy changes until today. Yet policy developments differ across policy types and migrant categories: Entry and integration policies have become less restrictive, while border control and exit policies have become more restrictive. Also, while policies towards irregular migrants and family migrants have been tightened in recent years, less restrictive changes have dominated policies targeting high- and low-skilled workers, students, and refugees. The essence of modern migration policies is thus not their growing restriction, but their focus on migrant selection.

Migration, Whiteness, and Cosmopolitanism: Europeans in Japan

Book

Aug 2016

Milos Debnar

This book analyzes the increase in contemporary European migration to Japan, its causes and the lives of Europeans in Japan. Desconstructing the picture of highly skilled, privileged, cosmopolitan elites that has been frequently associated with white or Western migrants, it focuses on the case of Europeans rather than Westerners migrating to a highly developed, non-Western country as Japan, this book offers new insights on increasing diversity in migration and its outcomes for integration of migrants. The book is based on interviews with 57 subjects from various parts of Europe occupying various positions within Japanese society. What are the motivations for choosing Japan, how do white migrants enjoy the ‘privilege’ based on their race, what are its limits, and to what extent are the social worlds of such migrants characterized by cosmopolitanism rather than ethnicity? These are the main questions this book attempts to answer.

Immigrant Skill Utilization: Trends and Policy Issues

Article

Feb 2014

Since 1996, the problem of underutilization of immigrant skills in Canada has grown significantly. University-educated immigrants are more numerous, and census analysis shows their access to skilled occupations in the professions and management decline between 1996 and 2006. The decline in access since 2001 coincided with increased program efforts, including foreign credential assessment, bridge training, and others. Policy differences among provinces, or in occupational groups targeted, also have had little impact on aggregate trends. The value (in today’s dollars) of work lost to the Canadian economy grew from about $4.80 billion annually in 1996 to about $11.37 billion in 2006.

Becoming global talent? Taiwanese white-collar migrants in Japan

Abstract

Recommended publications

When "global talents" struggle to become local workers: The new face of skilled migration to corpora...

When “global talents” struggle to become local workers: The new face of skilled migration to corpora...

Skilled or unskilled?: The reconfiguration of migration policies in Japan

Transnationalization of a Recruitment Regime: Skilled Migration to Japan