The Role of Critical, Enabling and Empowering Pedagogies in the Field of Emotional and Social Learning in Schools

Abstract

Many systematic assessments and interventions dominate the field of emotional and social learning in schools. These include behavior-orientation, evidence based practices, and school-wide models based on a response-to-intervention structure, as well as data-driven instruction. Social technologies allow the management, control, and governance of large school systems. Yet, critical educators must also think about our idea of man, our concept and notion of society, and about the significance of freedom, autonomy, individuality, diversity, cultural sensitivity, and equality. Constricted by a control apparatus that becomes powerful and well-functioning, these values are often affected. Examination of the landscapes of education in theory and practice in North America provides us with critical, enabling, and empowering pedagogies. These approaches often focus on Student Participation, Student Voice, Teaching for Social Justice, Hip Hop and Rap Pedagogies, or Citizenship Education. These highly valued models and approaches impact the emotional and social learning in schools and the development of inclusive school cultures. The debate cannot only be about the effectiveness of our educational systems and the means and institutional functioning of our schools, but must include our educational and social ideals and utopias, especially those that center around equality , solidarity, social inclusion, cultural diversity, sustainability, and a just world worth living for everyone. Pro-social behaviors most naturally occur when learners participate together in developmentally appropriate positive environments that promote relevant activities reflecting life situations and recognizing cultural backgrounds. When students help craft the learning experiences and sense their value as individuals, they feel visible in their relationship with the global whole and many pro-social behaviors arise naturally.

Full text

The Role of Critical, Enabling and Empowering Pedagogies
in the Field of Emotional and Social Learning in Schools
Joachim Broecher 1, Janet F. Painter 2, and Julia M. Siebert 1
1 University of Flensburg, Flensburg, Germany; 2 Lenoir-Rhyne University, Hickory, NC, USA
Many systematic assessments and interventions dominate the field of emotio-
nal and social learning in schools. These include behavior-orientation, evi-
dence-based practices, and school-wide models based on a response-to-
intervention structure, as well as data-driven instruction. Social technologies
allow the management, control, and governance of large school systems. Yet,
critical educators must also think about our idea of man, our concept and noti-
on of society, and about the significance of freedom, autonomy, individuality,
diversity, cultural sensitivity, and equality. Constricted by a control apparatus
that becomes powerful and well-functioning, these values are often affected.
Examination of the landscapes of education in theory and practice in North
America provides us with critical, enabling, and empowering pedagogies. The-
se approaches often focus on Student Participation, Student Voice, Teaching
for Social Justice, Hip Hop and Rap Pedagogies, or Citizenship Education.
These highly valued models and approaches impact the emotional and social
learning in schools and the development of inclusive school cultures. The de-
bate cannot only be about the effectiveness of our educational systems and the
means and institutional functioning of our schools, but must include our edu-
cational and social ideals and utopias, especially those that center around equa-
lity, solidarity, social inclusion, cultural diversity, sustainability, and a just
world worth living for everyone. Pro-social behaviors most naturally occur
when learners participate together in developmentally appropriate positive en-
vironments that promote relevant activities reflecting life situations and recog-
nizing cultural backgrounds. When students help craft the learning experiences
and sense their value as individuals, they feel visible in their relationship with
the global whole and many pro-social behaviors arise naturally.
Participative projects at the former RAW-area in Berlin-Friedrichshain and at the former airport
Berlin-Tempelhof, Photos: J.B.
Literature on Student Voice and Student Participation
Batsleer, J. (2011). Voices from an edge. Unsettling the practices of youth voice and participation: Arts-based practice in The Blue Room. Man-
chester.
Pedagogy, Culture & Society,
19(3), 419-434
Beattie, H. (2012). Amplifying student voice: The missing link in school transformation.
Management in Education
, 26(3), 158-160
Busher, H. (2012). Students as expert witnesses of teaching and learning.
Management in Education
, 26(3), 113-119
Cody, J. L. and McGarry, L.S. (2012). Small voices, big impact: Preparing students for learning and citizenship.
Management in Education
, 26(3),
150-152
Cumings Mansfield, K. (2014). How listening to student voices informs and strengthens social justice research and practice.
Educational Admi-
nistration Quarterly,
50(3), 392-430
Davies, J. W. (2004). Voices from the margins: The perceptions of pupils with emotional and behavioural difficulties about their educational expe-
riences. In P. Clough et al. (Eds.),
Handbook of Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties
(pp. 299-316). New York: Sage
Davies, I., Flanagan, B., Hogarth, S., Mountford, P., and Philpott, J. (2009). Asking questions about participation.
Education, Citizenship and
Social Justice
, 4(1), 25-39
De Carvalho, R. (2012). Student participation in Brazil. The case of the ‚grêmio estudantil‘.
Management in Education
, 26(3), 155-157
Groom, B. and Rose, R. (2004). Involving students with emotional and behavioural difficulties in their own learning: A transnational perspective.
In P. Clough et al.,
Handbook of Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties
(pp. 317-326). New York: Sage
Hartas, D. and Lindsay, G. (2011). Young people‘s involvement in service evaluation and decision making.
Emotional and Behavioural Difficul-
ties
, 16(2), 129-143
Hulme, M., Mckinney, S., Hall, S., and Cross, B. (2011). Pupil participation in Scottish schools: How far have we come?
Improving Schools
, 14
(2), 130–144
Islam, A. (2012). Afterword. The space between? The value of student voice from a student‘s perspective.
Management in Education
, 26(3), 164
Jahnukainen, M. (2001). Experiencing special education.
Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties
, 6(3), 150-166
Jones, J. N. (2011). Narratives of student engagement in an alternative learning context.
Journal of Education for Students Placed at Risk
, 16(3),
219-236
Morcom, V. E. and MacCallum, J. A. (2012). Getting personal about values: Scaffolding student participation towards an inclusive classroom
community.
International Journal of Inclusive Education,
16(12), 1323-1334
Polat, F. and Farrell, P. (2002). What was it like for you? Former pupils‘ reflections on their placement at a residential school for pupils with emo-
tional and behavioural difficulties.
Emotional and Behavioural Difficulties
, 7(2), 97-108
Robinson, C. and Taylor, C. (2013). Student voice as a contested practice: Power and participation in two student voice projects.
Improving
Schools
, 16(1), 32–46
Scanlon, S. (2012). ‚Why didn‘t they ask me?‘: Student perspectives on a school improvement initiative.
Improving Schools
, 15(3), 185–197
Sellman, E. (2009). Lessons learned: Student voice at a school for pupils experiencing social, emotional and behavioural difficulties.
Emotional
and Behavioural Difficulties,
14(1), 33-48
Woolner, P., McCarter, S., Wall, K., and Higgins, S. (2012). Changed learning through changed space: When can a participatory approach to the
learning environment challenge preconceptions and alter practice?
Improving Schools
, 15(1), 45-60
Literature on Teaching for Social Justice, Social Cohesion, and Citizenship Education
Adams, M. and Bell, L.A. (Eds.) (2016).
Teaching for diversity and social justice
(3rd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge
Adams, M., Blumenfeld, W. J., Castaneda, C. R., Hackman, H. W., Peters, M., and Zuniga, X. (Eds.) (2013).
Readings for diversity and social jus-
tice
(3rd ed.). New York, London: Routledge
Apple, M. W. (2008). Can schooling contribute to a more just society?
Education, Citizenship and Social Justice
, 3(3), 239–261
Agarwal, R., Epstein, S., Oppenheim, R., Oyler, C., and Sonu, D. (2010). From ideal to practice and back again: Beginning teachers teaching for
social justice.
Journal of Teacher Education
, 61(3), 237-247
Armstrong, F. (2012). Landscapes, spatial justice and learning communities.
International Journal of Inclusive Education
, 16(5-6), 609-626
Ayers, W. C., Quinn, T. and Stovall, D. (Eds.) (2008).
Handbook of social justice in education
. New York, London: Routledge
Bigelow, B. and Peterson, B. (Eds.) (2002).
Rethinking globalization: Teaching for justice in an unjust world
. Milwaukee, WI: Rethinking Schools
Press
Bickford, D. M. (2008). Using testimonial novels to think about social justice.
Education, Citizenship and Social Justice
, 3(2), 131-146
Biesta, G., Lawy, R. and Kelly, N. (2009). Understanding young people‘s citizenship learning in everyday life: The role of contexts, relationships
and dispositions.
Education, Citizenship and Social Justice
, 4(1), 5-24
Bondy, E., Ross, D. D., Gallingane, C., and Hambacher, E. (2007). Creating Environments of Success and Resilience: Culturally Responsive
Classroom Management and More.
Urban Education
, 42(4), 326-348
Broecher, J. (2019). Maladjusted youth as sand in the gears? In J. Broecher (Ed.),
Creating learning spaces: Experiences from educational fields
(pp. 41-54). Bielefeld: Transcript, Download
Bullock, K., Muschamp, Y., Ridge, T., and Wikeley, F. (2010). Educational relationships in out-of-school-time activities: are children in poverty
missing out again?
Education, Citizenship and Social Justice
, 5(2), 103–116
Fairbrother, A. (2008). ‚They might need a little extra hand, you know.‘ Latino students in at-risk programs.
Urban Education
, 43(5), 587-611
Fenning, P., and Rose, J. (2007). Overrepresentation of African American students in exclusionary discipline. The role of school policy.
Urban
Education
, 42(6), 536-559
Frick, J. E. and Frick, W. C. (2010). An ethic of connectedness: enacting moral school leadership through people and programs.
Education, Citi-
zenship and Social Justice
, 5(2), 117–130
García, S. B. and Guerra, P. L. (2004). Deconstructing deficit thinking: Working with educators to create more equitable learning environments.
Education and Urban Society
, 36(2), 150-168
Jones, S. and Vagle, M. D. (2013). Living contradictions and working for change: Toward a theory of social class-sensitive pedagogy.
Educational
Researcher,
42(3), 129-141
Kaur, B. (2012). Equity and social justice in teaching and teacher education.
Teaching and Teacher Education
, 28(4), 485-492
Kelly-Jackson, C. (2015). Teaching for social justice and equity: The journey of a teacher educator.
The New Educator
, 11(3), 167-185
Le Fevre, D. M. (2011). Creating and facilitating a teacher education curriculum, using preservice teachers’ autobiographical stories.
Teaching and
Teacher Education,
27(4), 779-787
Lima, M. P., Rebelo, P. and Barreira, C. (2014). Teacher development: Contributions of educational biography and personality.
Journal of Adult
Development,
21(4), 216-224
Liu, L. and Milman, N. B. (2014). Developing glocally informed diversity and equity discourses: Examining inequity via autobiographical reflec-
tion.
Teacher Development
, 18(4), 546-561
Macartney, B. C. (2012). Teaching through an ethics of belonging, care and obligation as a critical approach to transforming education.
Internatio-
nal Journal of Inclusive Education
, 16(2), 171-183
McDonald, M. A. (2005). The integration of social justice in teacher education: Dimensions of prospective teachers‘ opportunities to learn.
Jour-
nal of Teacher Education
, 56 (5), 418-435
McMurray, A. and Niens, U. (2012). Building bridging social capital in a divided society: The role of participatory citizenship education.
Educati-
on, Citizenship and Social Justice
, 7(2) 207–221
Michie, G. (2009).
Holler if you hear me: The education of a teacher and his students
(2nd ed.). New York: Teachers College Press
Michie, G. (ed.) (2005).
See you when we get there: Teaching for change in urban schools
. New York: Teachers College Press
Nind, M., Boorman, G., and Clarke, G. (2012). Creating spaces to belong: listening to the voice of girls with behavioural, emotional and social
difficulties through digital visual and narrative methods.
International Journal of Inclusive Education
, 16(7), 643-656
Ochoa, T. A. and Eckes, S. E. (2005). Urban youth in correctional facilities: Segregation based on disability and race.
Education and Urban
Society,
38(1), 21-34
Sapphire (2009).
Push. A novel.
New York: Vintage Contemporaries
Stoltz, P. (2011). Canons and communities: children and social cohesion in Sweden and the Netherlands.
Education, Citizenship and Social Jus-
tice,
6(1), 39-52
Sundström, M. and Fernandez, C. (2013). Citizenship education and diversity in liberal societies: Theory and policy in a comparative perspective.
Education, Citizenship and Social Justice
, 8(2), 103-117
Tomlinson, S. (2013). Social justice and lower attainers in a global knowledge economy.
Social Inclusion
, 1(2), 102-113
Weiland, C. A., Murakami, E. T., Aguilera, E., and Richards, M. G. (2014). Advocates in odd places: Social justice for behaviorally challenged,
minority students in a large urban school district.
Education, Citizenship and Social Justice
, 9(2), 114–127
Whipp, J. L. (2013). Developing socially just teachers: The interaction of experiences before, during, and after teacher preparation in beginning
urban teachers.
Journal of Teacher Education
, 64(5), 454-467
Smyth, J. (2011).
Critical pedagogy for social justice
. New York, NY: Continuum
Zygmunt, E. and Clark, P. (2016).
Transforming teacher education for social justice
. New York, NY: Teachers College Press
Literature on Hip Hop and Rap Pedagogies
Alridge, D. P., Stewart, J. B. and Franklin, V. P. (Eds.) (2010).
Message into music: Hip Hop, history, and pedagogy
. Washington, DC: ASALH
Alvermann, D., Moon, J. and Hagood, M. (1999).
Popular culture in the classroom: Teaching and researching critical media literacy
. Newark, NJ:
International Reading Association and National Reading Conference
Broecher, J., Painter, J. F., Davis, J. H., and Williams, A. (2017). Professional growth through guided autobiographical reflection: A case study
from pre-service teacher education. In R. Nata (Ed.),
Progress in Education
, Vol. 43 (pp. 153-196). New York: Nova Science Publishers, Down-
load
Brown, E. L., Gorski, P. C. and Lazaridis, G. (2015).
Poverty, class, and schooling. Global perspectives on economic justice and educational equi-
ty.
Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing
Bukor, E. (2015). Exploring teacher identity from a holistic perspective: Reconstructing and reconnecting personal and professional selves.
Tea-
chers and Teaching: theory and practice
, 21(3), 305-327
Christensen, L. and Watson, D. (Eds.) (2015).
Rhythm and resistance. Teaching poetry for social justice
. Milwaukee, WI: Rethinking Schools
Dickens, L. and Lonie, D. (2013). Rap, rhythm and recognition: Lyrical practices and the politics of voice on a community music project for y-
oung people experiencing challenging circumstances.
Emotion, Space and Society
, 9, 59-71
Dimitriadis, G. (2009).
Performing identity/performing culture: Hip Hop as text, pedagogy, and lived practice
. New York, Frankfurt am Main: Pe-
ter Lang
Emdin, C. (2013). The Rap Cypher, the Battle, and Reality Pedagogy: Developing communication and argumentation in urban science education.
In M. L. Hill and E. Petchauer (Eds.),
Schooling Hip-Hop. Expanding Hip-Hop based education across the curriculum
(pp. 11-27). New York,
NY: Teachers College Press
Greenleaf, C., Hull, G. and Reilly, B. (1994). Learning from our diverse students: Helping teachers rethink problematic teaching and learning situ-
ations.
Teaching and Teacher Education
, 10(5), 521-541
Guillory, N. A. (2012). Talking back: Teaching and Learning through autobiographies in multicultural education.
Teaching Education
, 23(2), 153-
165
Hale, A., Snow-Gerono, J. and Morales, F. (2008). Transformative education for culturally diverse learners through narrative and ethnography.
Teaching and Teacher Education
, 24(6), 1413-1425
Hall, M. R. (2009). Hip-Hop education resources.
Equity & Excellence in Education
, 42(1), 86-94
Hanley, M. S., Noblit, G. W., Shepperd, G. L., and Barone, T. (Eds.) (2013).
Culturally relevant arts education for social justice. A way out of no
way.
New York, NY: Routledge
Hill, M. L. (2009).
Beats, rhymes, and classroom life. Hip-Hop pedagogy and the politics of identity
. New York, NY: Teachers College Press
Hill, M. L. and Petchauer, E. (2013).
Schooling Hip-Hop. Expanding Hip-Hop based education across the curriculum
. New York, NY: Teachers
College Press
Huq, R. (2006).
Beyond subculture. Pop, youth and identity in a postcolonial world
. New York, NY: Routledge
Kim, J. and Pulido, I. (2015). Examining Hip Hop as culturally relevant pedagogy.
Journal of Curriculum and Pedagogy
, 12(1), 17-35
Lam, K. D. (2015). Teaching for liberation: Critical reflections in teacher education.
Multicultural Perspectives
, 17(3), 157-162
Land, R. R. and Stovall, D. O. (2009). Hip Hop and social justice education.
Equity & Excellence in Education
, 42(1), 1-5
Low, B. E. (2010). The tale of the talent night rap: Hip-Hop culture in schools and the challenge of interpretation.
Urban Education
, 45(2), 194-
220
Low, B. E. (2011).
Slam school. Learning through conflict in the Hip-Hop and Spoken Word Curriculum
. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
Mahiri, J. (1996).
African American and youth culture as a bridge to writing development
. Berkeley, CA: National Center for the Study of Writing
and Literacy
Morrell, E. (2008).
Critical literacy and urban youth. Pedagogies of access, dissent, and liberation
. New York, London: Routledge
Noordhoff, K. & Kleinfeld, J. (1993). Preparing teachers for multicultural classrooms.
Teaching and Teacher Education
, 9(1), 27-39
North, C.E. (2009).
Teaching for social justice. Voices from the front lines
. Boulder, CO: Paradigm Publishers
Petchauer, E. (2012).
Hip-Hop culture in college student’s lives. Elements, embodiment, and higher edutainment.
New York, NY: Routledge
Porfilio, B. J. and Viola, M. J. (Eds.) (2012).
Hip-Hop’e’. The cultural practice and critical pedagogy of international Hip-Hop
. Frankfurt am
Main, Germany, New York, NY: Peter Lang
Prier, D. (2012).
Culturally relevant teaching. Hip-Hop pedagogy in urban schools
. New York, NY: Peter Lang