ArticlePDF AvailableLiterature Review

Persistence and Fade-Out of Educational-Intervention Effects: Mechanisms and Potential Solutions

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Some environmental influences, including intentional interventions, have shown persistent effects on psychological characteristics and other socially important outcomes years and even decades later. At the same time, it is common to find that the effects of life events or interventions diminish and even disappear completely, a phenomenon known as fadeout. We review the evidence for persistence and fadeout, drawing primarily on evidence from educational interventions. We conclude that 1) fadeout is widespread, and often co-exists with persistence; 2) fadeout is a substantive phenomenon, not merely a measurement artefact; and 3) persistence depends on the types of skills targeted, the institutional constraints and opportunities within the social context, and complementarities between interventions and subsequent environmental affordances. We discuss the implications of these conclusions for research and policy.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... As the threshold to adulthood, adolescence plays a pivotal role in shaping individuals' interactions with the world. The psychological and social impacts of this stage vary widely among individuals, underscoring the need for timely and tailored interventions [4]. Adolescence is considered a period of heightened risk due to the multitude of factors that can contribute to psychological and social issues, thus raising concerns among parents and professionals about the vulnerability of teenagers during this crucial time [2]. ...
... Financial investments, on the other hand, have been shown to have a linear relationship with children's educational outcomes. For instance, a hundred-dollar increase in investment is associated with a measurable improvement in children's outcomes, a trend that persists across the funding spectrum (Bailey et al., 2020). In addition, it underscores the importance of providing students with a forum to share their specific, personal perspectives on their first year as a means of improving higher education outcomes (Daniels & MacNeela, 2021). ...
... adapted fromBailey et al. (2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
In this review, we argue that the role of causally informative evaluations of interventions within developmental psychology should be elevated. Causally informative research on the effects of intervention inputs on medium- and long-term outcomes are sufficiently relevant to developmental psychology to inform or even constrain our theories and to inspire future developmental research. We review several examples of research that yielded developmental insights from such work and discuss a broad theoretical framework for using developmental theory to reason about the effects of interventions and vice versa. Finally, we discuss potential challenges that have inhibited the role of causally informative research on interventions in developmental psychology along with actionable steps researchers can take to integrate such work more deeply into the field.
... The academic performance of students is a complex phenomenon influenced by multiple factors, including demographic characteristics, family background, and school-related factors [1]- [3]. Understanding these influences is crucial for developing effective educational interventions [4]. Despite considerable research efforts, the relationship between student performance and these multifaceted factors remains a topic of debate [5]. ...
Article
This study aims to predict student performance using deep learning models, including Multilayer Perceptron (MLP), Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN), Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory (BiLSTM), and Long Short-Term Memory with Attention (LSTM with Attention). The dataset comprises student demographic and educational factors, and the models are evaluated using metrics such as MAE, RMSE, R², MSLE, and MAPE. The results show that the CNN model outperforms other models, achieving the highest accuracy in predicting student test scores. The MLP model also performs well, while the BiLSTM and LSTM with Attention models exhibit lower predictive performance. High MAPE values across models suggest a need for alternative metrics in future research. This study highlights the importance of selecting suitable model architectures for predictive tasks in education, emphasizing the effectiveness of convolutional layers in capturing complex patterns.
... Guidelines for developing surgical simulation curricula have occasionally omitted such considerations [37]. Even when initially based on a robust understanding of educational theory, simulation implementation may lose some of its efficacy over time as the enthusiasm spurring initial curricular development fades [38,39]. Educators have highlighted issues around simulation implementation and retention as major barriers in surgical training [40]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Simulation curricula continue to struggle with adequately preparing trainees for the operating room. One reason for this phenomenon may be the lack of application and enactment of learning and instructional theories into simulation curricular design and practice. Few educators have taken a reflective approach to understand how surgical simulation succeeds and fails to incorporate best practices for learning based on theory. As such, this study aims to examine simulation sessions to identify gaps in practice by nesting two key frameworks from general education into surgical simulation: learning integration and the cognitive apprenticeship model. We conducted an observational qualitative study in which we recorded simulation sessions with fifteen trainees and surgeons and deductively applied components of the above frameworks to transcripts. Subsequently, we analyzed gaps in the transcripts with regard to the application of these frameworks as theoretical concepts informing the analysis and interpretation. We organized results around the four fundamental tenets of learning integration, with principles of the cognitive apprenticeship model explored to provide further units of analysis. In doing so, we identified that simulation instructors adequately modeled, coached, and scaffolded to enable early phases of learning integration. However, instructors less aptly enabled reflection and self-guided exploration, which are critical components of learning integration. We found areas in which instruction diverged from ideal standards as informed by our theoretical frameworks, thus highlighting the importance of regular simulation review to ensure that well-designed and intentioned simulation curricula continue to reflect the best educational principles when enacted in practice.
... For instance, in some circumstances, it is argued that an intervention that affects outcomes in the short-term could lose its effect in the long-term (Stern et al., 2012;Forss 2020;David, 2023). This phenomenon is known as fade-out or the abatement of effects (Bailey et al., 2020). This might be caused by a variety of issues, such as skill decay or other experiences which override early impacts (Green 2020;Schneider 2020;Blattman et al., 2014). ...
Article
Preschool has direct effects on attendees, but less is known about how public preschool expansions targeted to low-income children affect early educational experiences and school readiness in a broader community. We use Virginia administrative data (~630,000 students) and a discrete increase in targeted public pre-K (Virginia Preschool Initiative Plus [VPI+]) to estimate the effects of means-tested pre-K expansion on preschool participation patterns and school readiness. VPI+ expansion decreased the probability that children spend no time in licensed settings (6–7 percentage points), increasing the probability for public pre-K and private centers (5–8 and 2–3 percentage points, respectively). Kindergarten literacy skills improve (5%–6% of SD). Effects are larger among the target population but shared broadly (perhaps through private centers). These previously unmeasured benefits inform future policy and research.
Chapter
Higher-order learning (HOL) is essential for mastering knowledge and is particularly relevant in today's rapidly changing job market where critical thinking, problem-solving and decision-making are highly valued. Especially in a modern artificial intelligence (AI) age, the value of isolated knowledge (lower-order learning) is rapidly diminishing. In a technologically evolving world, HOL helps learners become more resourceful and targeted in their learning approach. As a result, learners can navigate the rapidly changing demands of both their academic training and their future workplace more confidently. However, traditional curricula have historically underemphasized HOL development or viewed it from a primarily pedagogical lens, resulting in learners struggling to engage in HOL. This book chapter explores the crucial role of self-regulation in successfully promoting higher-order learning (HOL), regardless of pedagogy. The chapter outlines critical components and pragmatic solutions for facilitating HOL and self-regulation, as well as the implications of HOL and self-regulation on employability in an AI landscape.
Article
Full-text available
In a quantitative meta-analysis, the effects of phonological awareness training on reading were shown. In a homogeneous set of U.S. studies with a randomized or matched design, the combined effect sizes for phonological awareness and reading were d = 0.73 (r = .34, N = 739) and d = 0.70 (r = .33, N = 745), respectively. Thus, experimentally manipulated phonological awareness explains about 12% of the variance in word-identification skills. The combined effect size for long-term studies of the influence of phonological awareness training on reading was much smaller, d = 0.16 (r = .08, N = 1,180). Programs combining a phonological and a letter training were more effective than a purely phonological training. Furthermore, training effects were stronger with posttests assessing simple decoding skills than with real-word-identification tests. In sum, phonological awareness is an important but not a sufficient condition for early reading.
Article
Environmental disasters have increased in frequency and intensity as a result of climate change. Can timely intervention help protect against the health impacts of these disasters? We study this question by leveraging data from a double-blind cluster-randomized controlled trial of at-birth vitamin A supplementation, which boosts immune system functioning, in Bangladesh. During the trial, a large tornado swept through the study area, affecting both treatment and control clusters. Tornado exposure in infancy decreased physical growth and increased the incidence of severe fevers. But infants who received supplementation were protected from these negative effects.
Poster
There is current research that suggests preschool educators do not have the phonemic awareness (PA) for ensuring the development of young children’s early literacy skills. This exploratory study examined the relationship between preschool teachers’ content knowledge in early literacy, education level, and years of teaching experience to emergent literacy assessment; and if differences in students’ emergent literacy assessment varied across preschool program settings. Results from a multiple regression analysis indicated the findings were not significant; however, in conducting simple linear regression analyses, preschool teachers’ content knowledge in early literacy had a predictive relationship with students’ emergent literacy skills. Results from a one-way ANOVA found emergent literacy assessment, PALS-K scores for the pre-kindergarten group as significant from the Head Start group.on
Article
Over 9 months, structured clinical interviews with 17 kindergartners were used to study (a) the learning of a concrete counting strategy for addition, (b) the transition from concrete to mental counting strategies, and (c) the role of the commutativity principle in developing more economical counting strategies. Kindergartners appear to differ in their readiness to use a concrete strategy. Many children persisted in counting all with objects. The most common sequence of mental counting strategies was counting all starting with the first addend, counting all starting with the larger addend, and then counting on from the larger addend. A knowledge of commutativity does not appear to be necessary to invent counting strategies that disregard addend order.
Article
We study the impact of preschool targeted at children from low-income families over the life cycle and across generations, and examine its interaction with an infant health intervention. Using Danish administrative data with variation in the timing of program implementation over the period 1933–1960, we find lasting benefits of access to preschool on adult educational attainment, earnings, and survival beyond age 65. We also show that children of women exposed to pre-school obtain more education by age 25. However, exposure to a nurse home visiting program in infancy reduces the added value of preschool, implying that the programs serve as partial substitutes. (JEL I12, I18, I21, I26, J13, J24, J31)
Article
In the current article, we examine the long-run school selection patterns of children randomly assigned to the Chicago School Readiness Project, an early childhood educational (ECE) intervention that aimed to improve the quality of Head Start classrooms serving low-income communities. Analyses suggest that adolescents who participated in the program were more likely to opt out of their assigned neighborhood school and attend schools with better indicators of academic performance. Further analyses suggested that these selection patterns began in elementary school, although elementary school quality explained only a small portion of the effect on high school selection. Results suggest that intensive ECE interventions could have lasting effects on children’s patterns of selection into later educational environments.