Content uploaded by Gilbert Matthews
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Gilbert Matthews on Mar 08, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
䉰ϓ䃰ќ
" 1 1 3 " * 4 " - + 0 6 3 / " - 0 ' $ ) * / "
ప䉱ϔ䃱ѝࡼчߋ
ჇФ喟 ٰ
$IJOB"QQSBJTBM4PDJFUZ
*44/$/'
ă
㾵ۻը
$&0
㫖䚘
ᑍᔄ㏏
ȟᑍ
ȟ૨
ദκู➕ᱯὍಷ⮰
111
䶥ⰚУը䃰ќ
ᒚ
ȟ䔗
ȟ䘚ࡃ᳄
ژ٭ᘻ㻭哔ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭∁Ꮩᘻ㻭哕➥៵ࡺጊ⮰䃰ќ∁℀䒯
(*-#&35&."55)&84
⼺ݹោ⣜⢳ࣶ⼺ោ⣜⢳㔱ڟ㈧⮰ᵴҷⵀ⾢
↗⇔⊤
ȟক
ȟ䊷
ឬᵤᓯܶ喋4喌
Ϧц႒㐨䃰У ".* ផᆁܶ
ȧ႒ᱛܶᒝ৹ఌၼᎠ៑Ȩ㐋䃍⎼ܶ喋-:ÿ;$1(喌
Ꭰ じ 喋ᕧじ 喌
Ꭰ ᰴ ᬑܦ❴
ネࢁѹ ࡺϦℽڝস䉎ᩫ䘔
ߊࢁѹ 䉰ϓ䃰ќࡻц
㑂䒽ܦ❴ȧ䉰ϓ䃰ќȨ㑂䒽䘔
㑂 ᑌᰠࡺ
ន㵸㑂 ᲔᲪമ
ޛ 㑂 ы
䉏Ч㑂䒽 ᱺ
㑂 䒽 ы ⢷ⷶ䧒
Ȟᱺ
㠝Ⱊᒁ ᱺȞ ы
㒺ᱛ㑂䒽 ࢃࢆࡂ
࢜ ݣ 卫ࢆᬶ๕ឬᰵ䭼ژ
ܶ *44/
$/'
У ٯ
౬ ࡃϘጮ㺫ࡦ䛸⇟䌛
๓࣒ ᅮ
䗚 㑂
⩡ 䄉喋喌喋ᒭ䃎ࣽ㵸喌
喋喌喋㑂䒽喌
េ⽫䗚ポ FEJU!DBTPSHDO
᱘ܶผᬺ
᱙ܷጟߍڒȨప႓ᱜܷ喍ٶ
Ⰵ ❵喎ȩ হĄ ప ܷ 㑾 ą喍IUUQ喟
XXXDIJOBKPVSOBMOFUDO喎Ƞᢛÿÿ
ႄࡃܷ㓑喍పᵥᓰܷ喍䖡䔶喎
ᢛᏀ喎ࣷĄ䊲ᭌܷഌܧ❵Ꭰąȡ
҉㔲㦄҉ᱰҬ⩕䉦᱙ܷ⽬䚙⁎ᕔЅ
㐆ȡຯ҉㔲ᘼᄳ」㑃ڒᢛᏀ喑
䄤ౕᲒ⽬ᬣฝᬻ喑᱙ܷᄳ҉䔯ᒀั⤳ȡ
⁎䓺ڟ∔䉰ϓ䃰ќࡻцჄᓚԍ
⁎䓺ڟ∔䉰ϓ䃰ќࡻц㑽々 XXXDBTPSHDO
Ⱋᒂ
$"5"-0(6&
ጒ҉ⵁ⾣
ИϬʹ㺭ڟ∔ネ⤲ᅮ䶰≷㘩߇
ȟ ᇠԛȟ݅▬▬ȟᒽᬻ⦉ȟ侙ȟ䊲
ڟκ䶰ᩢ䉥ㆧЭ۬⣜䛽≭䃍ッ∁⮰ᣎ䃔 ᳄⺃⺼
㾵ۻը $&0 㫖䚘 ᑍᔄ㏏ȟᑍȟ૨
倄ᵍ䲊㏻㥑ᕓᰵ䉰ϓネ⤲⣜⟢ȟ࣋ఌࣶᄥも ⿓ཌ
ڣЃ䉱ϔ䃱ѝ
ࡂ㏻≺႒㻲㻾Џ⢵䰁㞦ᱛ৭Уը䃰ќѿ㈧ᲰᐦᏀ⩔ⵀ⾢
ȟ ক䔗ᮕ
ദκู➕ᱯὍಷ⮰ 111 䶥ⰚУը䃰ќ ᒚȟ䔗ȟ䘚ࡃ᳄
ప䭲㻳䛻
ژ٭ᘻ㻭ȟტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭∁Ꮩᘻ㻭喝➥៵ࡺጊ⮰䃰ќ∁℀䒯
ȟ(*-#&35&."55)&84
䃱ѝᵵҸ
⼺ݹោ⣜⢳ࣶ⼺ោ⣜⢳㔱ڟ㈧⮰ᵴҷⵀ⾢ ↗⇔⊤ȟকȟ䊷
"QQSBJTBM+PVSOBMPG$IJOB 41
International View 䭱㻲䛺
ȟ㺭䛳⩔⮰䃰ќ∁
ᄥ1998 Ꭰ㜟϶ᝬᰵ⮰➥៵ࡺጊ䃰ќᵴҷ⮰ⵀ
⾢ࣽ⣜ژ٭ᘻ㻭喋fairness opinion喌፤⩔⮰䃰
ќ∁ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭喋expert witness喌স㶍∁
䮎喋Court of Chancery喌ᘻ㻭⮰䔵⩔∁ᰵ᭪㦃
Ƞ᱘喏Иᄲⵀ⾢㒺䃭ݤϐᬿༀц
喋SE C 喌ำᵴТβៗ䱞ژ٭ᘻ㻭⮰ᝬᰵ➥៵ࡺ
ጊ䃰ќᘻ㻭ȠИ⮰ⵀ⾢ᄥ䆍࠱᠘∁Ꮩ㷭۟
ៗ䱞βژ٭ᘻ㻭ᝂќըⰤڟԍᖛ⮰䲊ጮژ䃰ќ
ᵴҷȠ
㶔ᵨ 1ⅳᕧβេ㵸ܲጴȟ࣋স㷗⮰
ტ䃭ϦБࣶ∁Ꮩ㺭䛳⩔⮰䃰ќ∁喋℀ژ
∁喋comparable comanies喌1喏℀ϐᬿ∁喋comparable
transactions喌স⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁喋discounted cash flow喌Ƞ
䮐䔜∁โ喏ϐᬿУᵨ喋transaction price喌χ
䦴ᄥ⠘⿷ژϐᬿ喋armăs length deal喌ᵴҷ⮰∁Ꮩ
ᘻ㻭স㷗⮰ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭䔵⩔䃰ќ∁喋⩝κ
ϐᬿУᵨ᭛ژ٭ᘻ㻭⮰ܲᄥ䆍喏ఌₐᬺ᭪ᬌ∁҈
ژ٭ᘻ㻭⮰䃰ќ∁Ƞ⤲喏ϐᬿУᵨ҈㷗䉔⪽
⮰ᄥ䆍喏ᬌ∁࣋⮰ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭҈䃰ќ⮰
࣮㔯∁喌Ƞ
䃰ќ∁⮰䔵᠕⮰ᰬ๓κఇܲ
ͷ⮰ژ٭ᘻ㻭স䃰ќᘻ㻭喋ᓱ♢ϐᬿࣽ⩋ͷݹ
҈ܦ喌স 40⮰ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭䛳⩔β℀ژ∁
䔇㵸ќը喏㔸ϱᰵ 20⮰∁Ꮩᘻ㻭䛳⩔β䄑∁Ƞ
㶍 ∁Ꮩ䒯 䓽 ⮰۟ Ჭᄽ 䛳⩔ ℀ژ ∁喏
ఌₐტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭䒯ᄽ䛳⩔Ƞ
ᄥ℀ϐᬿ∁⮰䔵⩔ႄㆧѨ⮰⟢ۡȠ䊱䓳
60⮰ژ٭ᘻ㻭স䃰ќᘻ㻭স 25⮰ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭
䛳⩔℀ϐᬿ∁喏Ѳϱᰵ䊱䓳 10⮰∁Ꮩᘻ㻭䔵
⩔䄑∁Ƞ⩝κ℀ϐᬿ⮰ϐᬿУᵨ፤፤࠱᠘➥
៵ࡺጊ䃰ќᓱ䶧ހ䮐⮰ࡻᩴᏀ喏㶍∁Ꮩ፤፤
䃰ќ㏿᱖ހ䮐ࡻᩴᏀᄥϐᬿУᵨ⮰ᒝ৹⮰ᗱۡ
㐉䛳⩔℀ϐᬿ∁䔇㵸ќըȠ
Ⱔࣹ⮰᭛喏ᩢ⯶∁喏ᅐڢ᭛⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁喏܌
ͺᝬᰵ⮰ژ٭ᘻ㻭স䃰ќᘻ㻭ȟᝬᰵ⮰ტ䃭Ϧ
ᘻ㻭㷗䛳⩔喏܌ͺᝬᰵ⮰ڟ㖀ϐᬿᵴҷ
㑂㔱ᠵȞ᱙࣌ᬕ᭜В㒻పڙ∂ᰭࣾ䓫⮱➦៶ࡻጋ⮱䃱ѝ㐌䃎ⵁ⾣ᄦ䆎喑ϻθܧᏚუ䃮ϧ⮱䃱
ѝϧঅӈᐧ䃛ȡᄦλప䄨㔲㔹㼭喑ₑ᭜䓾ᎡᲒ䯫ᓄ⮱ᰶڠ㒻ప䃱ѝ䌢∂⮱䃮ܳᲽ」喑ڕ䲏
ރᲽγ䃱ѝߎ⮱Ҁᄦ䃱ѝ∂⮱ⰸ∂হ䔶᠖ ➦ݘ᭜В㔁⮱ᢛϻ䃱ѝߎӈ㔲喍უᘼ
㻮ܧڤ㔲Ƞ࣌ᝃ㷘⮱უ䃮ϧ喎⮱㻿Ꮣࣷ䃱ѝߎҬ⩕㔲喍∂Ꮪ喎⮱㻿ᏓᄦⰥڠ䃱ѝ∂⮱Ҭ⩕䔈㵹γ㐀
ᕔܳᲽȡթᓄЙ䛺◦ڠ∕⮱᭜ڣ∂Ꮪ҉䃱ѝᘼ㻮Ҭ⩕㔲ౕ䃱ѝߎ㐀⮱Ҭ⩕䓴⼸ᠮᰶ⮱Ⱕᒀ⤳
ᕔȠⰥᒀ⮱㻯◦喑ҸຯĄౕڙٮᘼ㻮ᓲ䶨ᄳࡼ᩵Ꮑށ䮑ąȠĄڠ∕䓀ڒթᄦ %$' 㐀⮱ᒞ৺ąȠĄВ
℁ڙⰛᴴڙ⮱ጛᐯ⩞㐊Ҭ⩕ጯ౧∂ąぶ喑Ҁ⣝γ⤳ᕔ䃱ѝᘼ㻮Ҭ⩕㔲ᄦ䃱ѝߎ⮱⤳ᕔҬ⩕喑㔹
᭜ᄦ䃱ѝᘼ㻮⮱キࢂȠιٰᐼ⮱Ҭ⩕ȡ҉㔲ᄦ %$' ㏵թহ䶱≸⮱ⰸ∂喑Вࣷᄦ็䃱ѝ∂Ҭ⩕⮱ᑧ
䄰喑Όₒࣺγ㒻ప㵹ౕⰥڠ䬛䷅⮱㻯◦ȡ䔆ψᄦλ⌞ڒγ㼐㒻ప䃱ѝ䌢Ƞᄦ℁㒻䃱ѝߎȠ
Ჱᐧప⤳ᕔ⮱䃱ѝߎጯ౧䘪ᰶ䛺㺮⮱Ռ䞡Фթȡ喍$7* ◦䃱喎
ژ٭ᘻ㻭ȟტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭∁Ꮩᘻ㻭
úúྲઢӨࢷᄊកவขඋᣗ
ȋ (*-#&35&."55)&84
42 䉰ϓ䃰ќ Ꭱす
䭱㻲䛺 International View
㷗㶍∁Ꮩ䛳⩔Ƞ
⠘⿷ژϐᬿ⮰ᵴҷ喏∁Ꮩ䕆፤䃐ϐᬿ
Уᵨ喋䕆፤ጞ㏻䄯᪠βࡻᩴᏀ⮰ᒝ৹喌᭛⤲⮰У
ըᅦᏒ喏Ꭲχᵴҷ喏Б⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁҈侸
䃭ϐᬿУᵨ⤲ᕓ⮰䃰ќ∁Ƞ
㜖2013 ᎠБᲑ喏䓳ࡶ⮰ᘻ㻭БϐᬿУᵨ҈
УըᅦᏒ喏࣋ఌκᎢ䉙ݕ喋me rger a rb itrage喌
්ߌβᄥ⠘⿷ژϐᬿ⮰䃰ќ䰬Ⅾ喞 19982004
Ꭰস 20052012 Ꭰᬢ䬠喏ϱᰵ 2ҷ⠘⿷ژ
ϐᬿ⮰䃰ќᵴҷ喏㔸 20132018 Ꭰ䬠喏19 䃰
ќᵴҷ⮰ 13 ⠘⿷ژϐᬿ⮰䃰ќᵴҷȠ
θȟ㏴ը喋ĄUFSNJOBMWBMVFą喌⮰䃍ッ
И㻮ᄋβژ٭ᘻ㻭স䃰ќᘻ㻭ܦڣ㔱ȟ
㶔1 ➥៵ࡺጊ䃰ќᵴҷ⮰∁䔵⩔
ќը䛻 ℀ژ ℀ϐᬿ ⣜䛽≭ោ⣜ᝂڢ
Ђ喋∔䛶 B喌 ϐᬿУᵨ
ژ٭ᘻ㻭ᝂќը
19982004 8 7060100NA
20052012 9 555591NA
20132018 23喋∔䛶 b喌9170100NA
ᕧ䃍 40 776498
࣋⮰ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭
19982004 10 8040100NA
20052012 11 363682NA
20132018 19 1616100NA
ᕧ䃍 40 382895
㷗⮰ტ䃭Ϧᘻ㻭
19982004 8喋∔䛶 c喌60259013
20052012 11 5536910
20132018 19 2616955
ᕧ䃍 38 4323935
㶍∁Ꮩᘻ㻭
19982004 10 40108010
20052012 11 2718919
20132018 19 505363
ᕧ䃍 40 2087035
∕䛷喟
B ౕϑᭀ喑䛴⩕γⰡᣒ䉱᱙ࡃ∂喍DBQJUBMJ[BUJPOPGFBSOJOHT喎ȡ
C ϑᭀᰶ ڙٮᘼ㻮ȡ
D 㷘ӊ䊃λᘼ㻮ӈ㔲⮱ѝթȡ
"QQSBJTBM+PVSOBMPG$IJOB 43
International View 䭱㻲䛺
ტ䃭Ϧস∁Ꮩ⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁⮰㏴ը⮰䃍ッ∁Ƞ
⮰㶔ᵨ 2ⅳᕧβⰤڟᢚ喋ᬢ䬠ᢚᬌ᭪
㦃ጚᐮ喌Ƞᅩネ㏒ࡶ⮰ژ٭ᘻ㻭ܲ䛳⩔΄喋䕆
፤䛳⩔ᖛ⼺ោᬓ䨬ݹݕ⋒喋EBITDA喌䃍ッ㏴ը喏
ტ䃭Ϧস∁Ꮩ㺭䛳⩔Ⱔᄥ႒ᱛ⮰්䪫Ὅಷ䃍ッ
㏴ըȠ⩝κ΄䕆፤ᵥᢚ℀ژস℀ϐᬿ䃍ッ喏
∁Ꮩ⮰㏴ը䃍ッ∁ڢ䕆፤䛳⩔ጮ౦∁⮰⿷౦
᭛㜠⮰Ƞ
㶔 Ȟ㏴ը⮰䃍ッ
΄ ්䪫⢳
ژ٭ᘻ㻭ᝂќը 5347
࣋ტ䃭Ϧ 1684
㷗ტ䃭Ϧ 1189
∁Ꮩ 991
ȟ∁Ꮩᘻ㻭ᄥ⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁⮰Ӊ䊂
㶍∁Ꮩ 19 97 Ꭰ䄠ᬺĄ⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁䊶Ბ
䊶ๆ⮰᱘∁Ꮩᘻ㻭䛳⩔⮰䃰ќὍಷą喏ₐᎠ
Ꮢ喏∁ᏙБ⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁҈۟ژ٭Уը⮰㺭
∁Ƞᅐڢ᭛㜖 2012 БᲑ喏㶍∁Ꮩ܌䃰ќ
ᵴҷБ⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁҈⮰䃰ќ∁Ƞ
㶍∁Ꮩ፤፤ᠳ䉏࣋ტ䃭Ϧস㷗ტ
䃭Ϧ⮰⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁䃰ќ㏿ͷ䬠⮰ጔ๓ጚᐮȠ䔅
χጚᐮ⎼㜖κ䒿ڑը⮰喝䉎ߍ䶰≷⮰ȟោ
⣜⢳⮰স්䪫⢳⮰ふఌ㉌Ƞ∁Ꮩᘻ䃲ݜ⣜
䛽≭ោ⣜∁Ą⮰䲌⼷ᏒふκڢӉᢚ⮰䒿ڑը⮰
䲌 ᕓস䒿 ڑըӉ ᢚ⮰ճ 䃪⮰ 䲌ᕓąȠ ຮᰬ倄 ∁
䮎 䓽ᝬ 䔜喝Ą⣜ 䛽≭ោ ⣜∁⮰ 䃰ќ࠱ ᠘ᒴๆ 䒿
ڑըÿÿ㷗ᩢڑ㤞ȟผโ⮰䃰ќტ䉔
⪽ÿÿ㔸䔅χ䒿ڑը⮰ᓚᄻߔᄲᄨ㜠ќը㏿
⮰ጔ๓ጚᐮąȠ
䉎ߍ䶰≷܌ͺⅤ䔈⣜䔼Ꭰࡳ䊷߫喏㏴ը
䕆፤ദκ䶰≷⮰じπᎠ䶰≷䃍ッȠБ҈㔱 50 ҅Ꭰ
⮰េ㵸ܲጴϺ㏻侸喏๓ๆژᬌ∁䓪ႯИ
⮰5Ꭰ䉎ߍ䶰≷ȠᎢ喏්䪫Ὅಷճ䃪⮰᭛ᠭ㐙⮰
්䪫喏Ꭲ᱖㔯㭽Э⮰⩋ঔ⮰䷺䮕Ƞ⣜䛽≭ោ
⣜∁᭛䃰ќጴ⮰ᰵ⩔ڣ喏Ѳ᭛۲⮰ڣȠ
⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁᭛۲⮰䃰ќ∁喏䰬㺭㷗ڢЂ
∁喋ຮ℀ژ∁ )侸䃭Ƞ
ఇȟ∁Ꮩᄥκ℀ژ∁⮰ᘻ㻭
∁Ꮩ㏻፤Б℀ژⰚᴳژ⮰ጚᐮ⩝
㐉䛳⩔℀ژ∁Ƞ℀ژ∁ఌ㷗࣋ఌ㷗
䛳⩔喏ҷຮ喏℀ژᵣ᱘䛻๖ᄽ喏℀ژ⮰
㻰Ὅ᭪㦃๓κⰚᴳژ㻰Ὅ喏℀ژⰚᴳژ
⮰㥑ߍᰵጚᐮ喏℀ژⰚᴳژ⮰ࣽ
ᆁݹᮛᰵᝬふふȠڟκژ㻰Ὅ⮰喏∁Ꮩ
∔ᘻݜ喝
Ą∁Ꮩ㘩ఌᝬ䄿⮰℀ژ㷗䃰ќژژ
㻰Ὅ⮰᭪㦃ጚᐮ㔸ᐯ⩔℀ژ∁⮰䃰ќćć
ᅩネദκژ㻰Ὅ䃰ݐ℀ژ⮰℀ᕓ㘩㑦ᄽ
⤲䃦Ӊᢚ喏Ѳႄ⣜⮰ᩛᠭӉᢚ喏Ꭲఌₐ䌡
স᱘∁Ꮩᘻ㻭㷗፤፤䛳⩔Ƞą
2012 Ꭰ⮰∁Ꮩᘻ㻭㏲㜠䭴䔜β∁Ꮩ⮰⿷౦喝
Ą᭪㔸ᬿ㻭⮰᭛喏䛳⩔ጮ౦∁⮰ݹ᭛ႄⰚᴳژ
䋟๋℀⮰℀ژ喏ఌ㔸℀ژ⮰ϐᬿ΄
БⰚᴳژ⮰ࣽᆁݹᮛӇⰤڟ⮰ȠຮⰤ
Ѩ㵸ڱႄ䃤ๆⰤξ《ε⮰Э喏݅℀ژ⮰
∁ქᬿ㷗䲌⮰䛳⩔Ƞҷຮ喏ᔗ丼Ꮓȟ䨢㵸
স↩䒒ݢ䕌㵸Б㷗䃐᭛ᰵ䃤ๆⴑ࣮㔱
ጮ౦《ε⮰㵸Ƞ䕆䓳䃲ݗ㏰ф䉔⮰
℀ژ喏Б㣣ጮ౦ᄥ䄑㵸᱖Ბࣽᆁݹᮛ⮰ᘻ
㻭喏Ꭲఌₐ䛳⩔㣣ᓃ⮰㵸ጮ౦΄Ⱊᴳژ
㜖䏗ըᄥⰚᴳژ⮰Уը䔇㵸ݐȠą
♢㔸喏䯪Б㣣Ⱊᴳژ䔇㵸ᵣߍ⮰
℀ژᬢ喏℀ژ∁݅䒯䲌Ƞᑿᝬ䄿⮰
℀ژⰚᴳژᰵ᭪㦃⮰ϓ৭ᝂߍ㏫ᬢᝂ
ᰵ᭪㦃⮰ጮ౦΄ᬢ喏䛳⩔℀ژ∁ᝂ℀
ϐᬿ∁᭛䔮⮰ȠĄᬢݧ喏ጚᐮ๓ݜҫ⩔
℀ژ∁ᄥ䃰ќጞ㏻⇍ᰵᘻ͵Ƞą
∁Ꮩ䃐䔵⩔⮰℀ژⰚᴳژ䋟๋
℀喏㷗ტ䃭Ϧ⮰䃭䃹ᩛᠭ⮰ᗱۡ喏ᘻҫ⩔
℀ژ∁ќը喝
Ą䃭ᬺќը䛳⩔⮰℀ژ䭱℀⮰
҈Ꮐ⩝ጸ᱇䛳⩔℀ژ∁⮰ឫ៱Ƞ䔵⩔⮰
℀ژᓱ᭛ⰚᴳژႸڔⰤ⮰Ⴘ㒺℀ژȠ
Ѳ᭛喏ຮ㺭ҫ⩔℀ژ∁喏݅ᓱ䶧ᰵ㏰Ą䋟๋
44 䉰ϓ䃰ќ Ꭱす
䭱㻲䛺 International View
℀⮰℀ژᵣ᱘ąȠą
20 11 Ꭰ㜟϶ᰵ 20 ژᐬៗ䱞 ⮰ژ٭ᘻ㻭䃰ќ
ᵴҷȠڢ⮰ 19 ᵴҷ喏䛳⩔β℀ژ∁҈䃰
ќ∁ͷȠڢ⮰ 11 ᵴҷ喏ᰵტ䃭Ϧ
喋㷗ᝂ࣋喌䛳⩔β℀ژ∁Ƞ♢㔸喏∁Ꮩ
ϱ 1ᵴҷ喋DFC Global喌䛳⩔β℀ژ∁ᓃ
ܦ∁Ꮩᘻ㻭Ƞᅩネຮₐ喏∁Ꮩᰵᬢцᐯ⩔℀ژ
∁⮰ᬢ䛳⩔℀ژ䔇㵸䉉⮰䃍ッ喏䄑ᗱᒎ
ᰬ䓽⁍ࣽ⩋ 2018 Ꭰ7ᰴȠ
℀ژ∁᭛䃰ќጴ⮰ᰵᩴڣͷȠ➥៵ࡺ
ጊ䃰ќᄥ䄑∁䊶Ბ䊶ᄽ⮰Ꮐ⩔⼷ᏒࣹᏀ
βტ䃭Ϧᄥ䄑∁⮰䒯ᄽ䛳⩔Ƞტ䃭Ϧժκ
⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁᭛ఌ∁Ꮩᘻ㻭ѿ⣜βᄥ⣜䛽≭ោ
⣜∁⮰Ꮐ⩔সᄥ℀ژ∁⮰ᐯ⩔Ƞᅩネຮₐ喏
℀ژ∁េ㵸ܲጴ⮰ژ٭ᘻ㻭⮰ᠭ㐙ҫ⩔ѿ
⣜βេ䉰⩸ᄥ䄑∁⮰Ꭻ∇ᣑȠ
ᅩネᄥ℀ژ∁⮰ҫ⩔ᰵᝬԉ⪅喏㶍∁Ꮩ
ᠳܦ ќը 䛳⩔ Б ⮰䃰 ќ∁ ᭛ᰵ⩔ ⮰Ƞ
㶍∁Ꮩᰪ 2010 Ꭰܦڢᄥ㔯㭽ๆ䃰ќ∁⮰
ᘻ㻭喝
Ą℗ᬌ⪽䬚⮰᭛喏➥៵ࡺጊ⮰∁ᒷᎢ᱖㻰ژ
Уը䃰ќႄ⮰ф䔵⮰ᝂ᭛ᣑ⮰䃰ќ
∁喏Ѳ᭛ႄๆ㷗Ꭻ∇ᣑ⮰ȟ䅔ᙺ⮰䃰ќጴ
Ꮐ㔯㭽⮰䃰ќ∁喏ๆ∁Ꮐᑿᥙ䙹ҫ⩔喏ѿ⣜
∁ќը⮰䲌ᕓȠຮ⣜䛽≭ោ⣜∁⮰䃰ќ
㏿℀ژᝂ℀ϐᬿ⮰ܲ㏿䒯ᣑ䓽喏
ᰠߌⰤԍ∁䘩⮰䃰ќβ䔅ژȠą
2013 Ꭰ喏∁Ꮩ䄠ᬺ喝䕆፤㔸㼬喏ĄᏀᑿ䛳
⩔ᰠߌ䲌⮰∁喏䔵ๆќըឬᱛÿÿҷຮ⣜
䛽≭ោ⣜∁ȟ℀ϐᬿ∁喋࣮㔯䓳ᒬϐᬿ⮰ϐᬿ΄
喌ȟস℀ژ∁喋࣮㔯ጮϐᬿژ⮰℀ژস
΄喌喏ᒎ∁⮰ќը㠯ఠ喏ఌ∁
ᰵ⮰䭼ݢᕓą12Ƞ
ტᏀܳ㔯㭽䃰ќ䛳⩔⮰℀ژ喏۲ำ
ຩ ∁Ꮩ㼏 䛶䔵⩔ ℀ژ ⮰ ℀ᕓȠ 䲎喏
ЂИᏀ㘩๋∁Ꮩ㼏䛶䔵⩔℀ژ∁⮰࣋ఌ
喋ᅐڢ᭛ຮⰤᏀ⮰ژ٭ᘻ㻭䛳⩔β℀ژ∁喌Ƞ
ტБ䃭ᬺ䃰ќܲ䛳⩔βĄ䋟๋℀⮰
℀ژąᬢ喏㶍∁Ꮩᰠ㘩䛳⩔䔅ᰵ⩔㷗Ꭻ
∇ᣑ⮰䃰ќ∁Ƞ
喍᱙⩞䊢ᮕ㔨䃾喎
ͻᏨ እ ͺ Ꮷ ( *- #& 35 & . "5 5)& 84 Ўၶ උˉ ֺ
ܷߥ֖ ඊ ܷߥὋ ௦Ꮎڍ ᛠˉᠪ ຆܢ Ὃઝ 46 55&3
4&$63*5*&4 */$ ᕥ˞֖ࣝᰳጞᛠᗈὋڙઅᛠᮖ۪థ ܲ
ࣱ҅NjϘNjࣲ᠓ኍࢹͺᄉፂᰍὋ˃МЉNjМՂϘNj
ឃϘNjࣲ᠓NjѫઞNjԣݝஎᐦాஅ᠓Nj҅Мˀ᭣МԦ
ᛠNjвᚷᠪNjᆠNj᠈ҫ᧗ጷԢڍᬄኍᮖ۪nj.BUUIFXT Ўၶڙᐎ
ᥧNjڠழกయઝ˃ࠑὋڙϘNj҅ழ᭦థᣖܲᗂᤗὋઝ
Ꮎڍ࣍Ө"4"Ὀ#VTJOFTT 7BMVBUJPO 3FWJFX ᄉᎃށտὋ
ࣲѢڍᬄэѶူ*74$ὈМЉϘࢹͺጷᄉտnj