ArticlePDF Available

THE CONTAMINANTS OF THE BEE COLONY

Authors:
  • Bee Product Science

Abstract

The contamination sources of the bee colony can roughly be divided into environmental and apicul-tural ones. The environmental sources can be further divided in agricultural and non-agricultural ones. The following environmental sources were examined: heavy metals, radioactivity and pesticides. The contamination of bee products by these sources is relatively small and the levels found are non-toxic for humans. The bees seem to have a filtering effect, leaving honey relatively free of toxic contaminants. The contamination of pollen, wax and propolis is greater than that of honey. Pollen quality is mostly endangered by pesticides. The apicultural sources include varroacides, antibiotics, paradichlorobenzene etc. Synthetic varro-acides are the most important sources for contamination, as they have to be used for long-term varroa control. The acaricide levels, found in the different products after treatment with the different acar-icides, decrease in the following order: brood combs > honey combs » sugar feed ~ honey. The contamination level of the brood combs, found in our study, is: bromopropylate > coumaphos and fluvalinate. Non toxic acaricides as organic acids and thymol will not endanger honey quality, if applied after the prescriptions. During honey control activities of the Swiss Canton Laboratories, residues of antibiotics, used for the control of American foul brood were found. The measurements in 1999 to 200 1 showed that one third of the imported honey contained antibiotics, while 6 to 9 % of the Swiss honeys were contaminated, mostly by sulfathiazole. Some beekeepers use paradichlorobenzene (PDCB) for the control of wax moth. This substance was found in about 30 % of all analysed Swiss honeys. Residues coming from wood protectants of bee hive, honey harvest and storage are also dis. cussed. The results show that the main contamination danger for bee products originates in a lesser extent from the environment, than from the apicultural practice. Antibiotics are the most likely contaminants of honey. Acaricides are the most important contaminants of wax and propolis.
Bulgarian Journal of Veterinary Medicine (2003), 6, No 2, 59-70
THE CONTAMINANTS OF THE BEE COLONY
S. BOGDANOV, A. IMDORF, V. KILCHENMANN,
J. D. CHARRIERE & P. FLURI
Swiss Bee Research Centre, Federal Dairy Research Station,
Bem; Switzerland
Summary
Bogdanov, S., A. Imdorf, v. Kilchenmann, J. D. Charriere and P. Fluri, 2003. The contami- nants of the
bee colony. Bulg. J. Vet. Med., 6, No 2,59 -70.
The contamination sources of the bee colony can roughly be divided into environmental and apicul- tural ones.
The environmental sources can be further divided in agricultural and non-agricultural ones. The following
environmental sources were examined: heavy metals, radioactivity and pesti- cides. The contamination of bee
p
roducts by these sources is relatively small and the levels found are non-toxic for humans. The bees seem to have
a filtering effect, leaving honey relatively free of toxic contaminants. The contamination of pollen, wax and
p
ropolis is greater than that of honey. Pollen quality is mostly endangered by pesticides.
The apicultural sources include varroacides, antibiotics, paradichlorobenzene etc. Synthetic varro- acides are
the most important sources for contamination, as they have to be used for long-term varroa control. The acaricide
levels, found in the different products after treatment with the different acar- icides, decrease in the following
order: brood combs > honey combs » sugar feed ~ honey. The contamination level of the brood combs, found in
our study, is: bromopropylate > coumaphos and fluvalinate. Non toxic acaricides as organic acids and thymol will
not endanger honey quality, if ap- plied after the prescriptions. During honey control activities of the Swiss Canton
Laboratories, resi- dues of antibiotics, used for the control of American foul brood were found. The measurements
in 1999 to 200 1 showed that one third of the imported honey contained antibiotics, while 6 to 9 % of the Swiss
honeys were contaminated, mostly by sulfathiazole. Some beekeepers use paradichlorobenzene (PDCB) for the
control of wax moth. This substance was found in about 30 % of all analysed Swiss honeys. Residues coming
from wood protectants of bee hive, honey harvest and storage are also dis. cussed. The results show that the main
contamination danger for bee products originates in a lesser extent from the environment, than from the apicultural
p
ractice. Antibiotics are the most likely con- taminants of honey. Acaricides are the most important contaminants
of wax and propolis.
Key words: bee products, beeswax, honey quality, contamination, pollution, propolis, resi- dues
INTRODUCTION
Contamination of honey and other bee products
has placed the beekeepers in the situation of
Hamlet and they lead a "to bee or not bee" fight
against the sea of troubles arising from the
contamination sources of bee products. In order
to win this struggle, the beekeepers should un-
derstand the importance of the different
contamination sources. In this short re- view it
will be attempted to discuss the relative
importance of the different con- tamination
sources.
The contamination sources can roughly be
divided into environmental (heavy metals,
pesticides, bacteria, GM plants) and apicultural
ones (Varroacides,
The contaminants of the bee colony
Pharn-Delegue, Taylor & Francis,
London and New York, 12-41.
Swiss Cantonal laboratories, 2002 (per-
sonal communication).
Wallner, K., 1991. Das Wachsmotten-
bekiimpfungsmittel Paradichlorbenzol.
Schweizerische Bienen-Zeitung, 116,
582-587.
Wallner, K., 1997. Bericht der LA fUr
Bienenkunde d. Universitiit Hohen-
heim, 1996,ADIZ, 31, S.XV.
Wallner, K., 1999. Varroacides and their
residues in bee products. Apidologie,
30, 235-248.
Wenk, P., 2002 (personal communica-
tion).
Williams, I. H., 2002. The EU regulatory
framework for OM crops in relation to
bees. Bee World, 83, 24-35.
Paper received 20.02.2003; accepted for
publication 07.05.2003
Kubik, M., J. Nowacki, A. Pidek, Z.
Warakomska, J. Michalczuk, W.
Goszczynski and B. Dwuznik, 2000.
Residues of captan (Contact) and dife-
noconazole (Systemic) fungicides in
bee products from an apple orchard.
Apidologie, 31,531-541.
Menkissoglu-Spiroudi, U., A. D. Tsigouri,
G. C. Diamantidis and A. T. Thra-
syvoulou, 2001. Residues in honey
and beeswax caused by beekeeping
treatments. Fresenius Environmental
Bulletin, 10, 445-450.
Milani, N., 1999. The resistance of Var-
roa jacobsoni Oud. to acaricides. Api-
dologie, 30, 229-234.
Porcini, C., S. Ghini, S. Girotti, A. G.
Sabatini, E. Gattavecchia, and G.
Celli, 2002. Use of honey bees as
bioindicators of environmental pollu-
tion in Italy. In: Honey Bees: Esti-
mating the Environmental Impact of
Chemicals, eds J. Devillers and M. H.
Pham-Delegue, Taylor & Francis,
London and New York, pp. 186-247.
Snowdon, J. A. and D. 0. Cliver, 1996.
Microorganisms in honey. Interna-
tional Journal of Food Microbiology,
31, 1-26.
Snowdon, J. A., 1999 The microbiology
of honey. American Bee Journal, 139,
51-60.
Smith, G., J. Bromenshenk, D. Jones and
G. Alnasser, 2002. Volatile and semi-
volatile organic compounds in beehive
a!:Inospheres. In: Honey Bees: Estima-
ting the Environmental Impact of
Chemicals, eds J. Devillers and M. H.
Correspondence:
Dr. S. Bogdanov,
Swiss Bee Research Centre,
Federal Dairy Research Station,
3003, Bern, Switzerland
www .apis.admin.ch
stefan. bo gdano v @ fam. admin. ch
BNM,6,No2
70
... Metal contamination of food is a problem of major concern. In order to protect public health, a limit of 1 and 0.1 mg kg -1 for Pb and Cd respectively in honey has been proposed to the European Community (Bal-Prylypko et al., 2018;Bogdanov et al., 2003). On 2015, the European Community, set a limit of 0.1 mg kg -1 for Pb for honey consumption by children and persons with specific dietary needs (Commission Regulation (EU), 2015), while there is no specification about the maximum acceptable limit for Arsenic (Bal-Prylypko et al., 2018). ...
... All the minerals and heavy metals identified in honey samples are listed in Table 5. The mean mineral concentrations in the different honey groups were expressed by mg kg -1 for Cr, Mn, Fe, Ni, Cu, and Zn and by µg kg -1 for As, Pb, and Cd, the concentrations of the two later were compared to the maximum allowable contaminant levels established by the Commission Regulation (EU) (2015) and proposed by Bogdanov et al. (2003). ...
... The Codex Alimentarius (2001) stipulates that "honey should only contain heavy metals at levels that do not pose a risk to human health". The European Union proposed limits of 1.0 and 0.1 mg kg -1 for Pb and Cd respectively (Bogdanov et al., 2003). ...
Article
Full-text available
The quality of twenty Algerian honeys was assessed based on their palynological and physicochemical properties, and their trace and toxic elements composition. A qualitative pollen analysis was conducted to estimate the botanical origin. The physicochemical analyses included moisture content, pH, electrical conductivity, 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF), colour, and the content of 3 sugars (fructose, glucose, and sucrose). The analysis of mineral and heavy metals included Zn, Mn, Fe, Cu, Cr, Ni, Pb, Cd, and As. The pollen spectrum showed a great diversity with 60 taxa identified. The palynological analyses revealed the presence of 15 honeys with pollen dominance (unifloral): Citrus sp., Eucalyptus sp., Ziziphus lotus (L.) Lam., Sinapis arvensis L., Dorycnium sp., Bupleurum sp., Echium sp., Lotus sp., and 5 honeys without pollen dominance (polyfloral). The physicochemical results showed that the samples conform to international quality standards, with few exceptions related to HMF, mainly due to beekeeping practices. The colour was from water white to dark amber. Pb and Cd concentrations were found to be below the maximum residue limits set by the European Directive with which the toxic elements were compared. These results would contribute to the assessment of Algerian honey and provide a database for the regulation of honey trade and consumer protection.
... The differences between the values in this study and the values obtained in previous investigations could be attributed to a variety of factors, including botanical origin, geographical origin, irrigation water, soil type, and pollution level (Dima et al., 2012;Taha et al., 2017;Spulber et al., 2018). Previous studies have shown that trace elements are highly present in hive products in heavy-traffic areas and industrial centers in Switzerland (Bogdanov et al., 2003) and Saudi Arabia (Taha et al., 2017). The concentrations of the determined elements in forager bees differed significantly (P < 0.05) depending on the geographical origin. ...
... Research by Leita et al. [179] demonstrates this phenomenon, highlighting a positive correlation between the Cd content in honey and the Cd levels found in Trifolium pratense L. flowers foraged by bees near a heavily trafficked highway. Studies conducted in Switzerland [101,180] have revealed a descending trend in the level of contamination across various bee products: bees > propolis > comb > wax > honey. This phenomenon is likely attributed to the filtering process employed by bees during honey production. ...
... Research by Leita et al. [179] demonstrates this phenomenon, highlighting a positive correlation between the Cd content in honey and the Cd levels found in Trifolium pratense L. flowers foraged by bees near a heavily trafficked highway. Studies conducted in Switzerland [101,180] have revealed a descending trend in the level of contamination across various bee products: bees > propolis > comb > wax > honey. This phenomenon is likely attributed to the filtering process employed by bees during honey production. ...
... Además, su cuerpo cubierto de pelos, retiene algunas sustancias que entran en contacto con ellas y, en consecuencia, las almacena en sus colmenas. Estas características las convierten a ellas y a sus productos en potenciales bioindicadores de contaminación ambiental (Bogdanov et al., 2003;Celli & Maccagnani, 2003;Porrini et al., 2003;Wakgari & Yigezu, 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
En este trabajo se estudió el uso de colonias de abejas (Apis mellifera) como biomonitores de contaminación ambiental por metales pesados. Para ello se evaluó la concentración de Cd (cadmio), Cr (cromo), Ni (níquel), Pb (plomo) y Zn (cinc) en abejas, polen y miel colectadas en apiarios ubicados en tres zonas con diferentes fuentes de contaminación. Los muestreos para la determinación de metales pesados se realizaron en cada apiario una vez al mes, durante doce meses. Las muestras de abejas y polen fueron procesadas mediante digestión ácida y las soluciones resultantes fueron analizadas mediante espectrofotometría de absorción atómica. En tanto que las muestras de miel se procesaron por digestión en microondas y la detección fue realizada en espectrómetro de fluorescencia de rayos X por reflexión total. Las concentraciones de cada uno de los metales fueron determinadas en relación al peso seco de las muestras. Los datos obtenidos indicaron que los cinco metales pudieron ser detectados en abeja y polen y solo pudo ser determinado el cinc en las muestras de miel. La matriz que mejor resulto como biomonitor de contaminación por metales pesados resulto ser la abeja.
... Feeding honeybees with syrups and industrial sugars after the broods have been naturally available is known as an indirect form of adulteration which is very difficult to detect. Feeding low quality honey to honeybees is also reported [38][39][40][41]. Different confectionary and bakery products are sweetened with Acesulfame-K and Aspartame [42,43]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Food adulteration refers to the alteration of food quality that takes place deliberately. It includes the addition of ingredients to modify different properties of food products for economic advantage. Color, appearance, taste, weight, volume, and shelf life are such food properties. Substitution of food or its nutritional content is also accomplished to spark the apparent quality. Substitution with species, protein content, fat content, or plant ingredients are major forms of food substitution. Origin misrepresentation of food is often practiced to increase the market demand of food. Organic and synthetic compounds are added to ensure a rapid effect on the human body. Adulterated food products are responsible for mild to severe health impacts as well as financial damage. Diarrhea, nausea, allergic reaction, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, etc., are frequently observed illnesses upon consumption of adulterated food. Some adulterants have shown carcinogenic, clastogenic, and genotoxic properties. This review article discusses different forms of food adulteration. The health impacts also have been documented in brief.
... Včely medonosné a ich produkty môžu byť kontaminované nielen nepriamou cestou, teda škodlivinami z poľnohospodárskych postupov (resp. vo všeobecnosti z prostredia), ale aj priamou cestou, teda kontaminantami pochádzajúcimi z včelárskej praxe (Bogdanov et al. 2003 Original article Biodiversity & Environment, 2022 Vol. 14, No. 1, 4-9 Med sa stal dôležitou súčasťou ľudského jedálnička. ...
Article
Full-text available
The content of potentially toxic elements in the bee-honey Honeybees are considered the most important and at the same time the most numerous pollinators. Bee products are currently an important part of the cosmetics or healing industries. Rapid anthropogenic changes in the environment of the local honeybee population are declining worldwide. In our study, bee honey was used for environmental quality monitoring in various areas of Slovakia. The number of hives, altitude and the secondary landscape structure were recorded in each locality, which was subsequently evaluated using landscape-ecological coefficients and indices. The content of potentially toxic elements (Cu, Fe, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) in the honey samples was evaluated using the ICP-OES (optical emission spectrometry) method. The health risks resulting from the consumption of honey using the hazard quotient (HQ) was also assessed. The results showed that the content of potentially toxic elements in honey is greatly affected by the place, where the hives are stored. At the same time, their potentially toxic element content in the honey samples is related to a number of hives in the area and altitude. With the consumption of honey, a risk was identified in only one locality in Slovakia and was related to exceeded value of lead.
... Since it is widely used for both nutritional and medicinal purposes (Abeshu and Geleta 2016), honey should be free from any contamination (Jakšić et al. 2018). Honey contamination is promoted by collection of nectar from a polluted environment and management of honeybee colonies during honey production and after honey collection (Bogdanov et al. 2003;Bogdanov 2006). ...
Article
Full-text available
We examined the residues of 13 elements in soil, plant parts, nectar, bee heads, thorax, and abdomens, feces from bee guts, and bee products sampled from two Polish cities (Lublin and Poznań). Our findings indicated that bees have an extraordinary ability to remove metals from nectar when converting nectar into honey. Compared to nectar, honey contained 40-fold lower Fe, 26-fold lower Zn, and eightfold lower Cu and Cd levels, indicating removal of these elements via nectar processing, during which water is evaporated and complex sugars are decomposed into simple ones. The amount of Pb remained unchanged; however, it can also be regarded as a fourfold decrease due to water evaporation from honey, compared to nectar. Some portion of the ingested Fe, Cu, and Zn was used by bees, and the excess amounts were excreted in feces. All analyzed elements were present as biocomplexes transported from the alimentary tract through the abdomen to the thorax and head. Elements transferred in the alimentary tract were partially immobilized/metabolized in the bee fat body, and their residues were excreted with feces from the gut. We postulate that honey is not a good indicator of environmental pollution, as a high amount of elements is removed by bees from their bodies.
Article
Full-text available
Infections in honey bees affect both young and adult bees. Most of these infections are of bacterial origin. In this study, it was aimed to determine whether hive tool, beekeeper smooker, gloves, feeder and beekeeper suit used in the same colonies with clinical signs of foulbrood in apiaries are a reservoir source in terms of microbial infections. For this purpose, samples were collected from 29 different apiaries in the Southern Marmara region. The samples were brought to the laboratory under appropriate conditions, and agent isolation and identification were performed. Different microorganisms were isolated from feeder, hive tool, beekeeper smoker, gloves and beekeeper suit samples collected from each apiary. Bacteria isolated from the samples taken from the hives with clinical signs of foulbrood and from the samples taken from the tools and equipment were isolated as the same species or as a mixture. As a result, an intense presence of microorganisms was detected in the feeder, hive tool, beekeeper smoker, gloves and beekeeper suit used by beekeepers, and it was determined that these materials used in beekeeping were a source of microbial reservoirs.
Article
Bee can be categorised as either honeybee or a stingless bee. Both produce honey, which is beneficial for human consumption because it is rich in nutrients. However, there is no study done on its quality affected by packaging materials during storage. This study evaluated the physicochemical properties of stingless bee honey (Heterotrigona itama) when stored in different packaging materials, clear and amber glass bottles, and clear and amber plastic bottles, stored at room temperature for three months. Honey was harvested from the pots to test its quality after some time. The physicochemical analyses were colour L*, a* and b*, pH value, total titratable acidity, antioxidant activity, ashes, moisture content and water activity. During three months of storage, none of the storage materials showed a significant difference from each other. If the honey storage is extended, honey stored in amber glass will give better quality at the end of the storage day due to the consistent parameter such as antioxidant activity, which is considered one of the valuable components in stingless bee honey.
Article
Full-text available
The presence of residues in bee products results mainly from treatments of colonies with protection agents including acaricides and antibacterials. Lipophilic active ingredients are present in honey at very low amounts, but accumulate at ppm levels as residues in beeswax with years of treatments. Thus, beeswax could become over rime a source of residues for honey. A review of the residues found in honey and beeswax in Greece and other European countries is given and acaricides' stability in honey and wax is discussed. Also, results of the effect of different treatment procedures on the presence of fluvalinate residues in honey and wax are presented.
Article
Full-text available
Ten bee colonies were placed in the middle of a ten-hectare-apple orchard at about 10% in bloom. The orchard was sprayed with a mixture of a contact fungicide, Captan 50WP (active ingredient captan) and a systemic fungicide, Score 250 EC (active ingredient difenoconazole). The residues of fungicides in honey, pollen, and bee bread were then measured by gas chromatography. Honey had very low contamination - 0.0006 mg·kg-1 of difenoconazole and 0.009 mg·kg-1 of captan. Contamination of pollen was much higher - about 0.043 and 2.99 mg·kg-1 of difenoconazole and captan, respectively. The most contaminated was bee bread, 0.27 and 6.39 mg·kg-1 of difenoconazole and captan, respectively. This finding may be due to some chemical reactions between difenoconazole and some plant metabolites taking place in pollen and bee bread. Difenoconazole, a systemic fungicide, penetrates about 1.66 and 1.16 times more efficiently into honey and bee bread, respectively, than the contact fungicide captan. But in pollen pellets from apple, the penetration coefficient was lower than 1. This observation corroborates the suggestion that in fresh pollen some fungicides may be fixed by sugars, aminoacids, or even proteins.
Article
Full-text available
In general, the use of varroacides in bee colonies leaves residues in various bee products. Among the variety of available varroacides, three ingredients are commonly detectable in honey and beeswax: bromopropylate (Folbex VA Neu), coumaphos (Perizin, Asuntol) and fluvalinate (Apistan, Klartan, Mavrik). These chemicals are fat-soluble and non-volatile, and thus they accumulate in ppm levels as residues in beeswax with years of treatment. Through the process of diffusion, these ingredients migrate from the wax comb into the stored honey. In German honey, the most frequently found varroacide is coumaphos (28 %). Bromopropylate is detectable but with decreasing frequency (11 %). Because of its high binding strength in beeswax, fluvalinate detection is relatively rare in honey (1 %). All residues were found with low ppb levels. Other ingredients with similar chemical behaviour presently play an unimportant role as residues in honey, beeswax and propolis owing to the very low amount of ingredients used (acrinathrine, flumethrine) or instability (amitraz). © Inra/DIB/AGIB/Elsevier, Paris
Article
There is increased interest in the numbers and types of microbes (also called microorganisms) in honey when honey is used as an ingredient in food or as part of a drug or cosmetic. The microbiological content of ingredients affects the shelf-stability and safety of the final product. Hence, purchasing specifications for honey are being set that include counts for microbes. Thus, the honey industry needs to know what microbes are present, where they are coming from, and how to control them. This need for knowledge is likely to increase as the diverse industrial markets for honey increase. Honey is a product with minimal types and level of microbes; this is attributable to the natural properties of honey and control measures in the honey industry. However, honey can carry spores of yeast, mold and bacteria and all food, including honey, can be inadvertently inoculated with undesirable microbes during processing. Although these microbes (except some yeast and perhaps mold) cannot grow in honey, they can persist in honey, be carried into a new product in which honey is used as an ingredient and grow in and spoil the new product. Spores are present everywhere, they may even be found in honey in the hive and could come from primary sources such as pollen, the digestive tracts of honey bees, air, earth, and nectar. It is difficult to control the entry of microbes from these sources. Other kinds of microbes, particularly those in the vegetative form as opposed to the spore form, can be added any time after the honey is harvested. Although these microbes cannot grow in honey, it is possible that they persist for a matter of weeks. These postharvest sources of microbes can include air, food handlers, cross contamination, equipment and buildings. These sources of contamination are controlled by good manufacturing practices (e.g., honey house sanitation) and heat treatment. More work will be needed to explain what influences the types and levels of microbes in honey particularly during harvesting, processing, storage and use as an ingredient.
Article
The past five years has seen the commercialization of the first GM crops and their products in Europe. The next five years may well see their more widespread cultivation and use. Some of these crops, particularly GM oilseed rape and GM maize, are or will be visited by bees. This will have implications for beekeepers harvesting and marketing honey and other bee products from these crops, for the bees themselves as they feed on nectar and pollen from the crops and for other crops or wild plants that the bees may spread GM pollen too. This is the first of a series of articles that explore the interactions of bees with GM crops, the regulatory framework that aims to ensure the safety of the crops to human health and the environment, the wider issues that risk assessments must now consider before marketing consents are issued, and the farm scale evaluations of crops being undertaken prior to more extensive cultivation.
Article
A serious problem in the control of the mite Varroa jacobsoni Oudemans is the selection of acaricide-resistant strains. Increased tolerance of this mite to several active substances (acrinathrin, amitraz, bromopropylate, chlordimeform, coumaphos, flumethrin, fluvalinate) was determined with laboratory assays or presumed as the most likely explanation of decreased field efficacy. Resistance to fluvalinate in Italy and later in other countries caused heavy damage to beekeeping. Early detection of the presence of resistant Varroa mites was crucial to reduce losses. Regarding resistance management tactics, 'moderation tactics' seem to be more suitable than 'high dose tactics' to delay the selection of resistant Varroa strains. © Inra/DIB/AGIB/Elsevier, Paris
Bericht der LA fUr Bienenkunde d. Universitiit Hohenheim
  • K Wallner
Wallner, K., 1997. Bericht der LA fUr Bienenkunde d. Universitiit Hohenheim, 1996,ADIZ, 31, S.XV.
Volatile and semivolatile organic compounds in beehive a!:Inospheres. In: Honey Bees: Estimating the Environmental Impact of Chemicals
  • G Smith
  • J Bromenshenk
  • D Jones
  • G Alnasser
Smith, G., J. Bromenshenk, D. Jones and G. Alnasser, 2002. Volatile and semivolatile organic compounds in beehive a!:Inospheres. In: Honey Bees: Estimating the Environmental Impact of Chemicals, eds J. Devillers and M. H. Correspondence: Dr. S. Bogdanov, Swiss Bee Research Centre, Federal Dairy Research Station, 3003, Bern, Switzerland www.apis.admin.ch stefan. bo gdano v @ fam. admin. ch BNM,6,No2