Content uploaded by Brian Dixon
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Brian Dixon on Mar 06, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
Scoping a Justicatory Narrative for Design Practice in Research:
Some Epistemological Intersections in Dewey, Wittgenstein and
Heidegger
!
"
#$
%&'
$()
'!
*+*+,-
./The Routledge
Companion to Design Research, 0123
4%!.1567879:5
)%
9(
99
'
(
"
;<$
<$=
5
=!>=
?@
$
5A+1,
/Design IssuesBC45668.?95?+1
,'/Design IssuesD54EE58.795
F2G"+21H
A'Design Research Through Practice: – From the Lab,
Field, and Showroom4+*%.*F568
?
*5
!A*IJKL-A
AM0A*"The New Mode of Knowledge
Production4K.AEEC8"'
2Mapping Design ResearchAI'2
4+.+N5658
M
A
<$
C%(
A
L
(#
7L
"
==
#
#
C@2,O!
/=C
7A*+,-.
/
L
L$
%!=
=
&"
"(
48
#
#
9P2
K'*LO
=
=
M
@
!"=$
AH$>:
'$FF$
BL$"@$
D
!
.KE
*906M150?*FC%
L
+
'L"
:AHThe Re$ective Practitioner4-3.++ED?8
BFF#The Semantic Turn: A New Foundation for Design
4+1@K.J1J0566:8
DA"@Design as Politics4K.+5668
EACristiano Storni, “Notes on ANT for designers: ontological,
methodological and epistemological turn in collaborative design.” CoDesign 11, no.
3-4 (2015): 166-178; andBjögvinsson, Erling, Pelle Ehn, and Per-Anders Hillgren.
"Design things and design thinking: Contemporary participatory design
challenges." Design Issues 28, no. 3 (2012): 101-116.
6A0Where the action is 4J*%.*"0
5668
A+*2+Deluze and Design
4O.;O05678
5I*,%O0(0
*0%1/%5
4566D8.?=
?ANorbert Roozenburg, "On the pattern of reasoning in innovative
design." Design Studies 14, no. 1 (1993): 4-18.
CARichard Buchanan. “Worlds in the making: design, management, and
the reform of organizational culture.” She Ji: The Journal of Design, Economics, and
Innovation 1, no. 1 (2015): 5-21.
4
87
"
!
"
'L
48
K
+#"
!'
L:1
71$Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature
M
A11Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature
40.0;0EBE8
:$".
$
L$'$
$
L$E?6 @
1QAMartin Heidegger: Between Good and Evil
O(
$
#
9
Dewey, Wittgenstein and Heidegger
"24D7E=E758K
'4DDE=E78*L4DDE=EB:8
@
#
;A'%4
%9L8O
!-'L
IB"48
$
'$L$
'
O4J*%.L;0EEE8
BO(
#L
$'
'1I$
!( -
AL$E??
D
48
=
@
P'L=
$E56
$!5
I$P
'L
=M
"
D+
!
E@'
L0*K,'1L
L1'."K+'/
Beyond the Analytic-Continental Divide: Pluralist Philosophy in the Twenty-
First Century2#%+%J0*
K4%!.156:8555=5CD
56@L$0
Hans-JoachimDahms. “Pragmatism in the Third Reich.
Heidegger and the Baumgarten Case.” European Journal of Pragmatism and
American Philosophy 11, no. XI-1 (2019), 1–25.
5'
4(+18
L$
MJI
AL+"
MAJ+I
Heidegger and the Problem of Knowledge4-.L
0JED?8
-#
0
;J
J-3L
J
E6C55%
$
4I
L8!
'25?L
48
(
5C%Logic: A Theory of Inquiry25
55@$2
*The Education of John Dewey: A Biography 4-3.J
;056658
5?A2,@%O!/John Dewey,
The Later Works, 1925–1953, vol. 5 1929–1930, 2%+
4JK.A;0EDC8CB=:6
5C'!$
#1IA1
IJohn Dewey's Quest for Unity: The Journey of a Promethean Mystic
4-3.0+5668
572, The Later Works, 1925–1953, vol. 12 1929–1930, Logic:
The Theory of Inqiury, 2%+ 4JK.A
;0EDB8
Experience and Nature26!
"#
(4!
8%(
J
!O!-
!
!
'
1+1$The Principles of
Mathematics27
(%
L
Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus5D
9
5:2, The Later Works, 1925–1953, vol. 1 1929–1930,
Experience and Nature, 2%+ 4JK.A
;0EDC8
5B+1The Principles of Mathematics, Vol. 14J.
J;0E6?8
5DK'Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus4K.F
0E558
9"
"
!Philosophical Investigations,29
<$
"
<$
(=
$
'
9
context
usedL
=!
A#
?6
K'L
"
5EK'Philosophical Investigations, I
OM*%4!.++E:?RE7DS8
?6
'$.1
*Ludwig Wittgenstein: The Duty of Genius4K.T+
EE68
O@M+O
L(
=9
ML$
Being and Time?
#Dasein=
<$
Dasein’s!
=L
was;'
1
<$
(
!
?5"(
"Enframing
<$??
?*LBeing and Time2A4%.
A;-30566RE5BS8
?5Being and Time!1
E?6
@
L$AMartin
Heidegger: Between Good and Evil
??*LPoetry, Language, Thought%L
4-3.LJ5668?7
<$?C
<$?7
%
?:!
!?B
?D'$!
M?E
C6'L$
M
C>
C5
?C*L,K<L$/@%JMM
Pathmarks'*-4J.J;0
EED85?E
?7LPoetry, Language, Thought56B
?:%AH+1,'
/
?BA0'2*J"O!
4J*%.*"0566C8
?DA"%4"+I*0O
I20K'8Design Things4J*%.
*"0568
?E%F#$0OWork-Orientated
Design of Computer Artifacts4A.%EDD8
C6A21HMaking Design Theory4J*%.*"
056B8
CAWhere the action is"'
@@@;.%
4--2.+ED:8
C5%"@$J",
)/0
05?4566C8.BB9E7
1
A(4
(8#
"#
(9
%
C?
K$'L
#
-
%#
C?A1+,"%.%L
0/0"OA
E%* 4%.O566E8.C6E=7?*A
UJ9 (UDesign Issues
5E5456?8.:95D0,O
O.%00/40%
.%;566E8
Some Areas of Intersection
%&
CCLM
".
!4
848
<$
<$
<9$.
!999"
L
!
!9
CCJI$L$
LAIHeidegger
and the Problem of Knowledge
O!$
L$4'
8$!
E57!Experience and Nature.O!
!
<!$484$
8O!=
M! @
!C7
L!!
<$
$!=
=A
JL
C7@
1AThe Necessity of Pragmatism, John Dewey’s Conception of
Philosophy 4-LJ".3;0ED:8
+!,O!O!."%
12V0/Design Issues
?75456E8.79:
C:%9
23<+$+"+
9 <$
CB"
=+=
(!48
;L'
!%
1
!
"
!
9
+
@
'
"
C:L<9999
9
taking care $ALBeing and TimeD:RE?S
CB*LThe Question Concerning Technology and Other
Essays,'K4-3.LW10EBB8
CC
L
<$
The Blue BookThe Brown Book48
Philosophical Investigations"
("
>48
<$
!9
CE*
!
"9
'$9>
!L
!!76'
!
CDK'Preliminary Studies for the “Philosophical
Investigations”: The Blue and Brown Books 4!.++E7D8
CE'Philosophical Investigation5:
76?DRD69DS
'
<$7
#
<$75=
7?
K'!%
(
"
(meaningfully
<$
=!7C
L
0K
L'+L<
$48is
7R55S
75The Later Works, vol. 1,C:
7? CC
7C?:
4$77%
L#
7:
'9!"
%
! 9
!9
9
(
(9(
"
(X
F(7B
#
@
77Lawrence J. Hatab and William Brenner, “Heidegger and Wittgenstein on
Language and Mystery.” International Studies in Philosophy 15, no. 3 (1983): 25–43.
7:ALPoetry, Language, ThoughtD7=56D+
AThe Later Works, vol. 1,CB
7BAThe Later Works, vol. 12, 67=55
(7D
'9L
On
Certainty,59
"#
'taught
%(
:6"<
$:
"
(
:5
L
7D6D
7EK'On CertaintyIOM*
%ILT'0I
OM*%4!.'9+EERE:ES8K
Philosophical Investigations!9
=(#
:6'On Certainty5RC69CS
:5RD59D?S
:5CCR?C9?C?S
J
@L
<
4 84 8$1
<
$:?(
:C
%>
4
!98
1> !
X
1
=!
'L%
@
!9(9
@'
:?LBeing and Time56R5ES
:CA*LThe Essence of Truth: On Plato's Cave Allegory
and Theaetetus 4K.J56658
@L
"<$
1
!M
!'
!
Towards a Justicatory Narrative
"
K$9(
'$L$9
9!
"
"
""
&
M'
-
A
"
9
3(
(
9
"
(
contribution#
!
"
L
!
MM)
'!
)
"'L
%#
"
@
@
(
@'
(
@L$
M
""
L$%
(
"
L>
L>