ArticlePublisher preview available

Running Head: A Pilot Study Comparing Tele-Therapy and In-Person Therapy: Perspectives from Parent- Mediated Intervention for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Conclusions about the efficacy of tele-therapy for parent-mediated intervention for children with Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD) are limited, due to the shortage of direct comparisons between tele-therapy and traditional face-to-face therapy. In this study, we implemented a parent training program, which targeted on language facilitating intervention strategies. Fifteen parents of children with ASD participated in person, and 15 participated via online video conferencing. We measured parents' intervention fidelity and children's initiations, responses, lexical diversity and morphosyntactic complexity. Results indicated significant improvements in parents' fidelity and children's lexical diversity and morphosyntactic complexity. No significant differences were detected between the two therapy delivery groups on any outcome measures. Finally, children's progress on morphosyntactic complexity was significantly correlated with parents' improvement on fidelity. 3
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
1 3
Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders (2021) 51:129–143
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10803-020-04439-x
ORIGINAL PAPER
A Pilot Study Comparing Tele‑therapy andIn‑Person Therapy:
Perspectives fromParent‑Mediated Intervention forChildren
withAutism Spectrum Disorders
YingHao1,2· JessicaH.Franco2· MadhuSundarrajan2,3· YaoChen2
Published online: 6 May 2020
© This is a U.S. Government work and not under copyright protection in the US; foreign copyright protection may apply 2020
Abstract
Conclusions about the efficacy of tele-therapy for parent-mediated intervention for children with Autism Spectrum Disorders
(ASD) are limited, due to the shortage of direct comparisons between tele-therapy and traditional face-to-face therapy. In
this study, we implemented a parent training program, which targeted on language facilitating intervention strategies. Fif-
teen parents of children with ASD participated in person, and 15 participated via online video conferencing. We measured
parents’ intervention fidelity and childrens initiations, responses, lexical diversity and morphosyntactic complexity. Results
indicated significant improvements in parents’ fidelity and children’s lexical diversity and morphosyntactic complexity. No
significant differences were detected between the two therapy delivery groups on any outcome measures. Finally, children’s
progress on morphosyntactic complexity was significantly correlated with parents’ improvement on fidelity.
Keywords Tele-health· In-person therapy· Parent training· Children with ASD
Introduction
Parent training has been found to yield improved linguistic
skills in children with Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD)
(e.g., Gengoux etal. 2015). However, barriers like the geo-
graphical distance between specialists and patients restrict
service delivery to many families that are in need of help
(Boisvert etal. 2010). Tele-therapy takes advantage of com-
puter and Internet-based technologies, and potentially over-
comes the barriers (Pickard etal. 2016). Previous studies
have demonstrated the initial efficacy of tele-therapy (e.g.,
Ingersoll etal. 2016). However, as there is a shortage of
direct comparisons between tele-therapy and traditional
onsite therapy for parent training in children with ASD,
conclusions about the efficacy of tele-therapy in this area
are limited (Boisvert etal. 2010; Boisvert and Hall 2014).
To address the gap, in this study, we compared the efficacy
of parent training for children with ASD that were delivered
in clinic and via Internet. In the following, we firstly con-
sidered significant areas of deficits in children with ASD to
specify focuses in our comparisons. We then reviewed the
extant literature of parent training and preliminary findings
of tele-therapy for parent-mediated intervention for children
with ASD before discussing the gap and raising our research
questions.
Significant Areas ofDeficit
Language remains a major deficit for an overwhelming
majority of children with ASD (Kasari etal. 2008), even
though it has been removed from the defining criteria for
the diagnosis of ASD (American Psychiatric Association
2013). Children with ASD demonstrate reduced language
usage, which is associated with reduced social interactions
(Deitchman etal. 2010). Early language development has
been widely found to predict future social functioning, and
inversely relate to atypical behaviors among children with
ASD (Barokova and Tager-Flusberg 2018; Howlin etal.
2004; Lord etal. 2004). Therefore, language is still a major
* Ying Hao
yinghao@olemiss.edu
1 Department ofCommunication Sciences andDisorders,
School ofApplied Sciences, University ofMississippi, 2301
South Lamar, NE, Suite 1200, Oxford, MS38655, USA
2 Department ofCommunication Sciences andDisorders,
University ofTexas atAustin, Austin, USA
3 Department ofSpeech-Language Pathology, University
ofthePacific, Stockton, USA
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... The larger magnitude observed in these meta-analyses could be due to delivery of the intervention in-person, or to sample differences (autism only vs. broad DD). Results of the few clinical trials that have directly compared in-person to telehealth models have been mixed, with some finding similar effects across in-person versus telehealth modalities (Hao et al., 2021;Peskin et al., 2024) and others finding mixed effects depending on outcome (Agazzi et al., 2021). For example, Agazzi et al. (2021) found similar effects of in-person vs. telehealth parent training on child disruptive behavior, but higher parent satisfaction for the in-person model. ...
Article
Full-text available
Children with developmental disabilities (DD) exhibit an increased rate of challenging behaviors; however, parents experience significant barriers to accessing mental health services. This meta-analysis evaluated the efficacy of telehealth parent training for challenging behaviors among children with DD on child and parent outcomes. Sixteen clinical trials were included. Results indicated a significant positive effect on parent report of reduction of challenging behaviors (g = 0.28). Furthermore, small to moderate significant improvements were found for parent distress (g = 0.39) and positive parenting practices (g = 0.36), and parent self-efficacy (g = 0.36). Telehealth delivery format (synchronous vs. asynchronous) did not moderate any outcomes. Implications of findings, limitations, and recommendations for future research are discussed.
... We ensured an equal number of participants were tested via Zoom in both clinical groups (autism and non-autism). Previous studies have shown a correlation between telehealth and face-to-face assessment scores (Sutherland et al., 2019;Hao et al., 2021). Face-to-face meetings were primarily conducted in the children's homes or educational settings. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study is one of the few research efforts investigating unexpected non-interactive foreign language acquisition in children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Participants included 46 English-Hebrew-speaking children (ages 4;10 to 12;0): 14 autistic children who acquired English via non-interactive input (ASD-NI); 12 autistic children (ASD-Nat), and 20 non-autistic children with typical language development (TLD-Nat) who acquired English and Hebrew naturalistically. Morpho-syntactic abilities were assessed using Sentence Repetition tasks in both languages. The results showed no group differences for morpho-syntax in English; in Hebrew, the ASD-NI group scored similarly to the ASD-Nat group but lower than the TLD-Nat group. Individual performance differences between Hebrew and English were observed across all groups. Additionally, correlations between exposure and SRep scores were found in both groups for Hebrew but not English. These findings highlight diverse paths to language acquisition in ASD, with children acquiring foreign languages via both naturalistic and non-interactive input.
... 24 A comparison of the effectiveness of communitybased PT versus clinical-based PT and an investigation of factors influencing efficacy would provide valuable insights. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic has increased interest in online PT, [25][26][27][28][29] and recent legal amendments in Japan now permit online family support. 24 Given the potential for online PT to be integrated into future care models, pilot studies demonstrating its outcomes are essential. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Parent training (PT) is an effective program for improving the parenting skills and mental health of parents of children with developmental disabilities (DD) and for improving children’s behavioral problems. However, studies must substantiate the effectiveness of PT for the parents of adolescents with DD in improving parental mental health and children’s problem behaviors with ample scientific evidence. This study is a retrospective observational study and has two objectives. The first is to examine the effectiveness of online adolescent PT (ON-APT), in which lectures on counseling skills are incorporated for the parents of adolescents with DD. The second aim is to examine the effects of different delivery conditions on community- and clinical-based ON-APT. Methods Data from seven parents and children who participated in community-based ON-APT and 14 parents and 12 children who participated in clinical-based ON-APT were included in the analysis. Prior to the intervention (pre-test) and after the intervention (post-test), paired t-tests were conducted using the CBCL, BDI-II, and PATS scores to demonstrate the effectiveness of the ON-APT program. Second, a two-way repeated measures analysis of variance with aligned rank transform was conducted to assess the impact of varying ON-APT delivery conditions (clinical- versus community-based ON-APT) and time (pre- and post-tests) on the outcome variables. Results ON-APT resulted in significant improvements in some children’s problem behaviors (withdrawal). Community-based ON-APT resulted in improvements in some children’s problem behaviors (total score, withdrawal, and social problems scales) compared with clinical-based ON-APT. Conclusion This study shows the potential effectiveness of ON-APT, in which lectures on counseling skills are incorporated for parents of adolescents with DD. Further, a comparison between clinical-based and community-based ON-APT showed that integrating face-to-face consultations into ON-APT may improve children’s problem behaviors. However, this study provides preliminary evidence for its potential efficacy, and future studies should demonstrate this efficacy through a validation design.
... Empowering parents to change their child's behaviour leads to more positive parent-child interactions and a better quality of life for the family (Hao et al., 2021;Kunze et al., 2021). If parents are unable to access treatment regularly or find it too burdensome to implement outpatient treatment in their daily lives, they will not use these techniques when they are alone, let alone be highly compliant with the implementation of the techniques (Vismara et al., 2012). ...
Article
Purpose The purpose of this study is to analyse recent empirical research that has explored the field of telepractice in early intervention for families of children with autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Design/methodology/approach The systematic review included 16 studies from 2012 and 2022 that examined the field of telepractice in early intervention for families of children with ASD. Analyses focused on the accessibility of telepractice and comparison with traditional treatment, the effectiveness of telepractice for parents in learning strategies in the home environment and the effectiveness of telepractice for children with ASD. What are the differences related to formats of telepractice and whether telepractice presents some technical challenges for families? Findings The results indicate that telepractice can make an important contribution to more intensive and better quality treatment. The review of studies shows positive effects in terms of parental satisfaction and the effectiveness of telecare interventions for children. Some early intervention telepractice programmes also report improvements in parents’ use of strategies, communication skills, imitation skills and interaction with children. Research limitations/implications The studies reviewed were conducted on relatively small samples. Many of them did not include a control group. Only three studies compared traditional formats with distance treatments. Some studies did not include professional support for parents. Some studies had shorter time periods of distance treatment. Some studies had a high lack of feedback from parents on the use of telepractice. In the future, more randomized controlled trials should be conducted in the field of telepractice in early intervention, based on larger samples and including a control group. It would be advisable to compare the different types of distance treatments with each other and with the traditional face-to-face format. Further research should examine the impact of participant characteristics, socioeconomic status and participant demographics, together with individual needs, perceptions and treatment responses to telepractice. Given the mixed results regarding the impact of early distance treatment in reducing stress in parents, further research in this area is recommended. Practical implications From this systematic review, the authors can conclude that the optimal early intervention would be a hybrid training, i.e. the implementation of both approaches so that the family has the opportunity to have a traditional contact with a specialist and the use of telepractice, which can increase the number of treatments and reduce costs. The authors suggest that parents and telepractice providers be educated about the safe and appropriate use of telepractice. Professionals should also have coaching skills to conduct telepractice and adapt some strategies (such as prompting and modelling) taking into account the specific needs of parents and children and be frequently available to the family. There should also be higher levels of support for parents’ well-being. Social implications Policy proposals include raising the level of early intervention for children with ASD, as this can have more lasting effects for families of children with ASD. This may have an impact by reducing the costs of support for families later on. Funding is recommended for developers of online platforms that create a safe and effective basis for telecoaching practice, for appropriate technical equipment for professionals and families and for education for professionals in the use of telepractice. Originality/value Based on the analysis of the recent research, suggestions and guidelines for the effective use of telepractice in early intervention for children with ASD and their families are presented.
... The COVID-19 pandemic has increased expectations for online PT (ON-PT) as an adaptation of traditional face-to-face PT (F2F-PT) [10]. ON-PT is particularly valuable for families with limited access to traditional F2F-PT [11]. Therefore, ON-PT is an important method for delivering PT to a broader range of areas. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Parent training (PT) is an effective intervention for improving children's behavioral problems and enhancing parental mental health in those caring for children with developmental disabilities (DD). Recent studies report the effectiveness of online PT (ON-PT). ON-PT encompasses both the on-demand type and the real-time type, which involves real-time online group PT delivered through web conferencing systems. However, the efficacy of the on-demand type has been established through comparisons with face-to-face PT (F2F-PT), whereas the real-time type of ON-PT has been assessed exclusively in single-arm studies, underscoring the need for comparative analyses with F2F-PT to validate its effectiveness. This study aims to compare the effectiveness of the real-time type of ON-PT and F2F-PT for parents of children with DD using a retrospective study design. Methods: The analysis included data from 13 parent-child pairs in the F2F-PT and 27 parent-child pairs in the ON-PT. Assessment scales included parental depression and stress, evaluated using the Beck Depression Inventory-Second Edition (BDI-II) and Parenting Stress Index (PSI), respectively, as well as children's behavioral problems, measured with the Eyberg Child Behavior Inventory (ECBI). A two-way repeated-measures ANOVA assessed the impact of different PT delivery methods and time on the outcome variables. Results: Attendance and dropout rates were similar between ON-PT (82%, 18.7%) and F2F-PT (80.3%, 18.1%). A two-way repeated-measures ANOVA showed that the interaction effect was marginally significant for PSI (p = 0.066) and statistically significant for both the child domain of PSI (p = 0.049) and ECBI (p = 0.013). Simple main effects analysis indicated that pre-test mean scores for PSI (p < 0.001), the child domain of PSI (p = 0.001), and ECBI (p = 0.002) were significantly higher than post-test scores in the ON-PT compared with the F2F-PT. Furthermore, although a higher proportion of participants in the ON-PT were within the clinical range of ECBI at the pre-test (70.4%) compared to the F2F-PT, this proportion decreased to 44.4% at the post-test. Conclusion: This study suggests that ON-PT may be as effective as or potentially more effective than F2F-PT. The adoption of online formats should be considered for families facing challenges, as ON-PT may improve children's behavioral problems and reduce parental stress. Nonetheless, the retrospective study design warrants caution in interpreting the findings, and a future study with a prospective, rigorous validation design will be essential to effectively compare the effectiveness of ON-PT and F2F-PT.
... The effectiveness of online therapy has been a budding subject of research though there continues to be a lack of published literature for Luxembourg residents. Studies conducted in other parts of the world during the first two years of the global pandemic indicated that the outcomes of online therapy did not differ compared to face-to-face therapy (Hao et al., 2021;Lin et al., 2022). Virtual therapy also offers support to patients who face barriers in care, such as traveling (Alleman, 2002). ...
Article
Full-text available
Mental health care in high-income countries can have various rates of usage due to differences in accessibility, modality of psychotherapy, and potential stigma surrounding mental health (Alonso et al., 2004). This study aimed to explore perceptions of mental health and mental health care, stigma for mental illness, and perceived change in mental health due to COVID − 19 pandemic in a high-income country with relatively easy access to basic mental health care. An anonymous survey was sent to individuals who are 18 years and older and resident of Luxembourg, a small country in Europe (N = 56). Participants were asked a series of open-ended and forced choice questions. Descriptive statistics were calculated for forced-choice questions and inductive content analysis was used to analyze the open-ended responses. Participants defined mental health in a variety of different ways, and a majority reported receiving mental health services. There was no significant difference in participants’ ratings of mental health before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. Mental health professionals were relatively easy to find and were considered somewhat helpful, though participants also reported some stigma towards mental illness. Benefits and challenges of in-person and virtual therapy showed points of crossover and potential for further research. The current findings inform the broader literature on mental healthcare with implications for improving care in high-income countries.
Article
Full-text available
Caregivers are generally children’s primary communication partners; therefore, their ability to support their child’s use of augmentative and alternative communication systems, such as the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS; Frost & Bondy, 2006), is critical. However, few studies explore systematic approaches to PECS caregiver training and little is known about how to efficiently and effectively support caregivers’ PECS implementation. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the feasibility and preliminary effectiveness of a 2-week telehealth training package using behavior skills training and general case training to teach caregivers to implement PECS (i.e., the PECSperts Caregiver Training Package). Six caregivers of children on the autism spectrum participated in the study, four mothers and two fathers. Feasibility was evaluated across the areas of acceptability, service demand, community implementation, practicality, and limited effectiveness testing (Bowen et al., 2009). The training was evaluated using a modified concurrent multiple probe across behaviors research design. Caregivers reported a high degree of satisfaction with the training, and high rates of session attendance and study engagement were observed. Caregivers achieved high levels of PECS teaching accuracy for all the phases of PECS targeted in the training (i.e., phases 1 to 3b). Results persisted at 1- and 2-month follow up probes. The results indicate that a brief telehealth model may be an effective approach to PECS caregiver training and may be feasibly implemented in community settings. The results support the need for future research exploring the effectiveness of the training on children’s PECS use.
Chapter
Project ImPACT is a parent-implemented intervention, focused on teaching social communication to toddlers and preschoolers with autism. The program can be used in an individual, group, or telehealth version and uses a blend of developmental and behavioral techniques. We found sufficient evidence to consider the original Project ImPACT as an established evidence-based intervention and to rate the telehealth version as promising. Parental satisfaction is consistently high in studies on the program. Several studies also reported a decrease in parental stress. The four main intervention targets of Project ImPACT are social engagement, communication, imitation, and play. The effect on the language and communication of young children with autism is the most robust. There is also some evidence for an effect on social engagement, imitation, play, and social skills in general. However, these findings are more mixed, possibly related to child characteristics, treatment fidelity, and differences in outcome measures. Given the large variability in outcomes, sample characteristics, and adaptations to the original intervention, more research is needed to further guide practical decisions.
Article
Full-text available
The role of language in autism spectrum disorder (ASD), more specifically, its function in social communication and strong predictive power on future outcomes, warrants language assessments that have good psychometric properties that capture the heterogeneity of language ability found among diagnosed individuals. Given the rapid growth in intervention and treatment research, there is an urgent need for the development and implementation of outcome measures that are easily obtained and sensitive to change. In this commentary, we argue for the use of natural language samples as measures of expressive language and communication for this purpose and review the literature on their implementation in ASD research. Conceptual and measurement issues are discussed and future developments are outlined.
Article
Full-text available
Problem/condition: Autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Period covered: 2014. Description of system: The Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring (ADDM) Network is an active surveillance system that provides estimates of the prevalence of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) among children aged 8 years whose parents or guardians reside within 11 ADDM sites in the United States (Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Georgia, Maryland, Minnesota, Missouri, New Jersey, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Wisconsin). ADDM surveillance is conducted in two phases. The first phase involves review and abstraction of comprehensive evaluations that were completed by professional service providers in the community. Staff completing record review and abstraction receive extensive training and supervision and are evaluated according to strict reliability standards to certify effective initial training, identify ongoing training needs, and ensure adherence to the prescribed methodology. Record review and abstraction occurs in a variety of data sources ranging from general pediatric health clinics to specialized programs serving children with developmental disabilities. In addition, most of the ADDM sites also review records for children who have received special education services in public schools. In the second phase of the study, all abstracted information is reviewed systematically by experienced clinicians to determine ASD case status. A child is considered to meet the surveillance case definition for ASD if he or she displays behaviors, as described on one or more comprehensive evaluations completed by community-based professional providers, consistent with the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) diagnostic criteria for autistic disorder; pervasive developmental disorder-not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS, including atypical autism); or Asperger disorder. This report provides updated ASD prevalence estimates for children aged 8 years during the 2014 surveillance year, on the basis of DSM-IV-TR criteria, and describes characteristics of the population of children with ASD. In 2013, the American Psychiatric Association published the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5), which made considerable changes to ASD diagnostic criteria. The change in ASD diagnostic criteria might influence ADDM ASD prevalence estimates; therefore, most (85%) of the records used to determine prevalence estimates based on DSM-IV-TR criteria underwent additional review under a newly operationalized surveillance case definition for ASD consistent with the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria. Children meeting this new surveillance case definition could qualify on the basis of one or both of the following criteria, as documented in abstracted comprehensive evaluations: 1) behaviors consistent with the DSM-5 diagnostic features; and/or 2) an ASD diagnosis, whether based on DSM-IV-TR or DSM-5 diagnostic criteria. Stratified comparisons of the number of children meeting either of these two case definitions also are reported. Results: For 2014, the overall prevalence of ASD among the 11 ADDM sites was 16.8 per 1,000 (one in 59) children aged 8 years. Overall ASD prevalence estimates varied among sites, from 13.1-29.3 per 1,000 children aged 8 years. ASD prevalence estimates also varied by sex and race/ethnicity. Males were four times more likely than females to be identified with ASD. Prevalence estimates were higher for non-Hispanic white (henceforth, white) children compared with non-Hispanic black (henceforth, black) children, and both groups were more likely to be identified with ASD compared with Hispanic children. Among the nine sites with sufficient data on intellectual ability, 31% of children with ASD were classified in the range of intellectual disability (intelligence quotient [IQ] <70), 25% were in the borderline range (IQ 71-85), and 44% had IQ scores in the average to above average range (i.e., IQ >85). The distribution of intellectual ability varied by sex and race/ethnicity. Although mention of developmental concerns by age 36 months was documented for 85% of children with ASD, only 42% had a comprehensive evaluation on record by age 36 months. The median age of earliest known ASD diagnosis was 52 months and did not differ significantly by sex or race/ethnicity. For the targeted comparison of DSM-IV-TR and DSM-5 results, the number and characteristics of children meeting the newly operationalized DSM-5 case definition for ASD were similar to those meeting the DSM-IV-TR case definition, with DSM-IV-TR case counts exceeding DSM-5 counts by less than 5% and approximately 86% overlap between the two case definitions (kappa = 0.85). Interpretation: Findings from the ADDM Network, on the basis of 2014 data reported from 11 sites, provide updated population-based estimates of the prevalence of ASD among children aged 8 years in multiple communities in the United States. The overall ASD prevalence estimate of 16.8 per 1,000 children aged 8 years in 2014 is higher than previously reported estimates from the ADDM Network. Because the ADDM sites do not provide a representative sample of the entire United States, the combined prevalence estimates presented in this report cannot be generalized to all children aged 8 years in the United States. Consistent with reports from previous ADDM surveillance years, findings from 2014 were marked by variation in ASD prevalence when stratified by geographic area, sex, and level of intellectual ability. Differences in prevalence estimates between black and white children have diminished in most sites, but remained notable for Hispanic children. For 2014, results from application of the DSM-IV-TR and DSM-5 case definitions were similar, overall and when stratified by sex, race/ethnicity, DSM-IV-TR diagnostic subtype, or level of intellectual ability. Public health action: Beginning with surveillance year 2016, the DSM-5 case definition will serve as the basis for ADDM estimates of ASD prevalence in future surveillance reports. Although the DSM-IV-TR case definition will eventually be phased out, it will be applied in a limited geographic area to offer additional data for comparison. Future analyses will examine trends in the continued use of DSM-IV-TR diagnoses, such as autistic disorder, PDD-NOS, and Asperger disorder in health and education records, documentation of symptoms consistent with DSM-5 terminology, and how these trends might influence estimates of ASD prevalence over time. The latest findings from the ADDM Network provide evidence that the prevalence of ASD is higher than previously reported estimates and continues to vary among certain racial/ethnic groups and communities. With prevalence of ASD ranging from 13.1 to 29.3 per 1,000 children aged 8 years in different communities throughout the United States, the need for behavioral, educational, residential, and occupational services remains high, as does the need for increased research on both genetic and nongenetic risk factors for ASD.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose We aimed to study narrative skills in Mandarin-speaking children with language impairment (LI) to compare with children with LI speaking Indo-European languages. Method Eighteen Mandarin-speaking children with LI (mean age 6;2 [years;months]) and 18 typically developing (TD) age controls told 3 stories elicited using the Mandarin Expressive Narrative Test (de Villiers & Liu, 2014). We compared macrostructure-evaluating descriptions of characters, settings, initiating events, internal responses,plans, actions, and consequences. We also studied general microstructure, including productivity, lexical diversity, syntactic complexity, and grammaticality. In addition, we compared the use of 6 fine-grained microstructure elements that evaluate particular Mandarin linguistic features. Results Children with LI exhibited weaknesses in 5 macrostructure elements, lexical diversity, syntactic complexity, and 3 Mandarin-specific, fine-grained microstructure elements. Children with LI and TD controls demonstrated comparable performance on 2 macrostructure elements, productivity, grammaticality, and the remaining 3 fine-grained microstructure features. Conclusions Similarities and differences are noted in narrative profiles of children with LI who speak Mandarin versus those who speak Indo-European languages. The results are consistent with the view that profiles of linguistic deficits are shaped by the ambient language. Clinical implications are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
Background There is a significant need for strategies to increase access to evidence-based interventions for children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD). One novel approach is to train parents to use evidence-based interventions for their child with ASD via telehealth. Pilot work examining the efficacy of one such program, ImPACT Online, demonstrated a high rate of parent program engagement, low attrition, and associated gains in parent learning and child social communication. Objective The objective of this study was to conduct an open trial of ImPACT Online to better understand its dissemination potential. Methods We examined the reach and representativeness of families who registered (n=36) compared to families who were referred (n=139) to the open trial for one referral site. We then compared the demographics of all families who enrolled in the open trial (n=112) to families who enrolled in one of two controlled trials of the same program (n=50). We also examined metrics of program engagement for the open and controlled trials, the relationship between program engagement and changes in parents’ intervention knowledge, and program evaluation for the participants in the open trial. Results In total, 25.8% (36/139) of the parents who were given information about the program at their child’s diagnostic feedback session registered with the program. The parents who enrolled in the open (OT) and controlled trials (CT), respectively, were similar in gender (OT: 84.8% (95/112); CT: 88% (44/50), female), marital status (OT: 80.4% (90/112) ; CT: 69.6% (32/46), married), education (OT: 58.0% (65/112); CT: 54.0% (27/50), college degree or higher), and employment status (OT: 58.0% (65/112); CT: 65.3% (32/49), employed outside the home). The child participants were similar in terms of gender (OT: 83.0% (93/112); CT: 76.0% (38/50), male) and race and ethnicity (OT: 38.4% (43/112); CT: 24.0% (12/50), minority). However, the mean chronological age of the child participants in the open trial group was significantly higher (Mean=60.0 months) than in the controlled trial group (Mean=43.0 months), with t160=5.22, P<.001. Parents in the open trial engaged with the program at a significantly lower rate than the controlled trial, F3,81=21.14, P<.001. Program engagement was significantly associated with gains in parent intervention knowledge across both the groups, beta=.41, t=2.43, P=.02. Participants in the open access trial evaluated the program highly, but several barriers were noted. Conclusions These data suggest that additional strategies may need to be developed to support families in using telehealth-based parent-mediated intervention in community settings.
Article
Full-text available
Objective: This study examined the impact of parent training on adaptive behavior in children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and disruptive behavior. Methods: This was a 24-week, 6-site, randomized trial of parent training versus parent education in 180 children with ASD (aged 3-7 years; 158 boys and 22 girls) and moderate or greater behavioral problems. Parent training included specific strategies to manage disruptive behavior over 11 to 13 sessions, 2 telephone boosters, and 2 home visits. Parent education provided useful information about autism but no behavior management strategies over 12 core sessions and 1 home visit. In a previous report, we showed that parent training was superior to parent education in reducing disruptive behavior in young children with ASD. Here, we test whether parent training is superior to parent education in improving daily living skills as measured by the parent-rated Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales II. The long-term impact of parent training on adaptive functioning is also presented. Results: At week 24, the parent training group showed a 5.7-point improvement from baseline on the Daily Living domain compared to no change in parent education (p = .004; effect size = 0.36). On the Socialization domain, there was a 5.9-point improvement in parent training versus a 3.1-point improvement in parent education (p = .11; effect size = 0.29). Gains in the Communication domain were similar across treatment groups. The gain in Daily Living was greater in children with IQ of >70. However, the interaction of treatment-by-IQ was not significant. Gains in Daily Living at week 24 were maintained upon re-evaluation at 24 weeks posttreatment. Conclusion: These results support the model that reduction in disruptive behavior can lead to improvement in activities of daily living. By contrast, the expected trajectory for adaptive behavior in children with ASD is often flat and predictably declines in children with intellectual disability. In the parent training group, higher-functioning children achieved significant gains in daily living skills. Children with intellectual disability kept pace with time. Clinical trial registration information-Randomized Trial of Parent Training for Young Children With Autism (RUBI); http://clinicaltrials.gov/; NCT01233414.
Article
Both naturalistic communication and parent-implemented interventions are evidence-based practices for young children with disabilities, but demonstrations of effective methods for teaching parents to implement naturalistic interventions successfully with their children are still warranted. The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of a training and coaching program on parent implementation of naturalistic teaching strategies and on concomitant child communication skills using a telepractice service-delivery model (i.e., Internet-Based Parent-Implemented Communication Strategies [i-PiCS]). We found that parents learned to implement the targeted naturalistic teaching strategies with fidelity when, and only when, they were provided with training and coaching over the Internet. The parents’ implementation of these strategies also corresponded with positive changes in their children’s communication skills. The limitations and implications of this investigation are discussed.