ChapterPDF Available

VICTORIA: An Interactive Online Tool for the VIrtual Neck Curve and True Ostium Reconstruction of Intracranial Aneurysms

Authors:
A2822
VICTORIA
An interactive online tool for the VIrtual neck Curve and
True Ostium Reconstruction of Intracranial Aneurysms
Benjamin Behrendt1, Samuel Voss2,3, Oliver Beuing4, Bernhard Preim1,
Philipp Berg2,3, Sylvia Saalfeld1,3
1Department of Simulation and Graphics, University of Magdeburg, Germany
2Department of Fluid & Technical Flows, University of Magdeburg, Germany
3Forschungscampus STIMULATE, University of Magdeburg, Germany
4Institute of Neuroradiology, University Hospital of Magdeburg, Germany
sylvia.saalfeld@ovgu.de
Abstract. For the characterization of intracranial aneurysms, morpho-
logical and hemodynamic parameters provide valuable information. To
evaluate these quantities, the separation of the aneurysm from its parent
vessel is required by defining a neck curve and the corresponding ostium.
A fundamental problem of this concept is the missing ground truth. Re-
cent studies report strong variations for this procedure between medical
experts yielding increased interobserver variability for subsequent eval-
uations. To make further steps towards consensus, we present a web
application solution, combining a client based on HTML and JavaScript
and a server part utilizing PHP and the Matlab Runtime environment.
Within this study, participants are requested to identify the neck curve of
five virtual aneurysm models. Furthermore, they can manipulate the os-
tium surface to model the original parent artery. Our application is now
available online and easily accessible for medical experts just requiring
an internet browser.
1 Introduction
The assessment of intracranial aneurysm (IA) rupture risk increasingly depends
on morphological as well as hemodynamic parameters that are calculated based
on the aneurysm sac [1,2]. Furthermore, therapy planning requires a detailed
knowledge of the individual IA neck size to select an appropriate treatment
strategy and device, respectively [3]. In addition, a virtual separation of the
IA from the parent vessel allows for the extraction of parameters from a 3D
model rather than 2D projected images in the clinical routine that suffer from
increased user- as well as image (i.e. the viewing angle of the 2D projections)
dependency [4].
However, the separation between parent vessel and aneurysm sac (i.e. the
ostium) strongly varies, which might lead to insufficient analyses and in conse-
2 Behrendt et al.
quence to unreliable conclusions. The separation of the IA from the healthy par-
ent vessel is often realized using a (planar) cut-plane [5,6], which might be error-
prone for complex IA shapes. In previous work, we developed a semi-automatic
extraction of an anatomical, bent neck curve [7], but the question about the
correct neck curve remains unanswered.
Therefore, VICTORIA (VIrtual neck Curve and True Ostium Reconstruc-
tion of Intracranial Aneurysms) aims at a standardization of IA neck curve and
ostium reconstruction. For the definition of these neck curves and ostia, highly
experienced physicians are required. Since their availability for user studies is
limited due to the clinical work load, we developed an easy accessable frame-
work solely requiring a web browser. Thus, we can gather expert-knowledge
from physicians as well as biomedical engineers. The study has been successfully
launched at https://VICTORIA.cs.ovgu.de/.
2 Materials and methods
Within the VICTORIA study, participants are requested to identify the neck
curve of patient-specific IA models extracted from 3D digital subtraction data.
The extraction of surface models is described in our previous work [8].
2.1 VICTORIA web application
The study is conducted using a specialized web application, consisting of two
parts: a client part (written in HTML and JavaScript), and a server part (written
in PHP and using Matlab runtime environment). The VICTORIA study can be
accessed via the internet using a web browser. Between client and server, the
data is exchanged in the JSON format. The server stores user-submitted data
in a relational database, thus allowing for easy sorting and filtering of the data,
see Figure 1.
In order to keep the motivation to participate high, the user is directly pre-
sented with five datasets and two tasks, respectively. For both tasks, a surface
Fig. 1. Illustration of the different parts of the VICTORIA web application
VICTORIA 3
mesh of an IA and its parent vessel is shown. The rendering is performed using
the WebGL2 API, thus allowing it to run in most current desktop browsers. The
mesh is illuminated using the Phong lighting model to increase shape percep-
tion. The user has limited control over the camera (rotation, zoom and panning),
ensuring that the neck region is always visible and centered in the image.
2.2 Neck curve definition
First, the user draws a neck curve onto the vessel mesh by selecting surface
vertices, see Figure 2. To connect the selected vertices into a circular path, the
surface triangle mesh is interpreted as a bidirectional graph. The shortest paths
between the selected points are then calculated using the A* algorithm by Hart
et al. [9]. However, the A* algorithm is only designed to find the shortest path
between two points, not the shortest path connecting a list of unordered points.
To prevent having to force users to select the points in order and thus sacrificing
usability, the list of points has to be sorted automatically. Here, a distance matrix
stores the length of the shortest path between all points. Whenever a new point
is added to the matrix, the distances to all other points are determined using
A*. To sort the list of points, we begin with a list containing only one randomly
chosen point. As long as there are points that have not been added to the list,
we take the last entry, look up the closest point (based on the distance matrix)
Fig. 2. The different steps of the ostium definition. (A) 3D visualization of the
surface model with WebGL. (B) The user can interactively select points on the
aneurysm surface. The points are automatically selected (see also inlay). (C) If
the points are close to each other, the neck curve is automatically closed. (D) In
the second step, an automatic ostium triangulation is provided. (E) The user can
hover over the points and the active point is highlighted. (F) the point can be
moved (including a reduced movement of its neighbors) until the user is satisfied
with the ostium shape.
4 Behrendt et al.
that has not been added yet, and add it to the back of the list. After all points
have been processed, the resulting list contains the shortest path connecting all
neck points selected by the user. The last and first point in the list will only
be connected if their distance is shorter than the longest path between any of
the other adjacent points in the list. This prevents the neck curve from closing
before the user has finished adding all desired points. In case the resulting neck
curve does not match the users’ expectation additional points can be added.
The sorting and path finding algorithm are implemented in JavaScript and
are performed entirely on the client side. Even on less powerful devices, they run
interactively without any noticeable delay.
2.3 Ostium creation and manipulation
After submitting the neck curve, the server calculates the associated ostium sur-
face mesh. This step is implemented in Matlab, motivated by previous work [7] as
well as to provide additional geometric functionalities and to spare the client’s
PC performance. To ensure the general applicability, we use the Matlab run-
time environment and provide it at our linux server. The Matlab script receives
the previously selected surface meshes and downsamples them to a predefined
threshold. The process is illustrated in Figure 3. For the illustration, the neck
curve points are resampled to 32 points. The ostium triangulation is analytically
defined and centered around the origin (z-coordinates equal 0). Next, the ana-
lytically defined border points are replaced by the neck curve points and simple
Laplacian smoothing (50 iterations, σ= 1.0) is applied to all vertices except the
border points, resulting in the smooth ostium surface (Fig. 3).
The second task consists of the adjustment of the previously calculated os-
tium surface. This is important to better approximate the inflow area for further
postprocessing steps in order to better approximate the parent vessel’s original
geometry. During this task, only the backfaces of the vessel are rendered to reveal
the ostium. The user can grab and drag any vertex of the ostium surface that is
not part of its border. To keep the interaction as simple and straight-forward as
possible, the vertices can only be moved in the direction of the average surface
Fig. 3. Illustration of the ostium triangulation. The neck points are resampled
to 32, p1-p32 (left). The pre-defined triangulation is centered around 0 with
border points q1-q32 (center). Next, q1-q32 are replaced by p1-p32 and all
points undergo Laplacian smoothing yielding the triangulated ostium surface.
VICTORIA 5
normal of the ostium. As moving one vertex at a time would be tedious, dragging
one vertex by a distance of valso moves the surrounding vertices by a distance of
vnbased on their normalized Euclidean distance dnto the original vertex. The
parameter acontrols the size of the affected area. We empirically determined a
value of 1
3to result in an interaction that feels natural.
vn=v·(max(0, dn(1 a)) a1)0.75
The second task can be considered optional, as it is possible for the user to
directly accept and submit the ostium surface generated by the server without
performing any modifications.
Finally, we implemented a registration form combined with a questionnaire.
Users enter their name, e-mail address, occupation and employer, as well as
answer questions about their experience with IAs. Thus, an examination of dif-
ferences between user groups (e.g., physicians vs. engineers) can be conducted
in the future.
3 Results
The VICTORIA study was implemented at the Otto-von-Guericke University,
Magdeburg, Germany, and can be easily assessed at https://VICTORIA.cs.
ovgu.de/. We tested this interactive survey sucessfully with three medical coop-
eration partners. They requested more hints and icons regarding the controlling
of the application which we included. The neck curve definition requires ap-
proximately two minutes per case and less than ten minutes overall. The study
requires the use of Mozilla Firefox or Google Chrome. Other, less commonly used
browsers, such as Apple Safari or Microsoft Edge do not support the required
WebGL technologies. The evaluation of the submitted ostia segmentations is not
part of this work but ongoing research. In this work, the implementation of the
web-based study is presented and the prototype does fulfill its purpose.
4 Discussion
Currently no ostium ground truth is available, yet it is required for many post-
processing steps of IA models. We presented an approach that allows for an easy
participation of international field experts and physicians by utilizing a combi-
nation of JavaScript, PHP and Matlab-programs, including 3D visualizations,
editing and modification options.
Based on a ground truth ostium definition, a precise morphological evalu-
ation of the 3D IA shape is further promoted, and it is highly beneficial for
the quantification of hemodynamic flow simulations [10]. Furthermore, a 3D
neck curve determination and subsequent parameter evaluation is superior to 2D
analysis [4]. Particularly, since relevant blood flow parameters that are associ-
ated with rupture (e.g., normalized wall shear stress, shear concentration index,
oscillatory shear index [11]) need to be calculated with high accuracy, wrong
6 Behrendt et al.
aneurysm-vessel-separation or high user-dependency can lead to clear variations
regarding the analysis.
Furthermore, we expect our survey results to be utilized as ground truth
data for deep learning-based ostium extraction approaches, e.g. similar to the
MeshCNN network [12]. Finally, our architecture can be easily adapted to other
medical image processing questions that require 3D models and user interaction.
Acknowledgement. This study was funded by the Federal Ministry of Ed-
ucation and Research in Germany within the Forschungscampus STIMULATE
(grant number 13GW0095A) and the German Research Foundation (grant num-
ber SA 3461/2-1, BE 6230/2-1).
References
1. Detmer FJ, Chung BJ, Jimenez C, et al. Associations of hemodynamics, mor-
phology, and patient characteristics with aneurysm rupture stratified by aneurysm
location. Neuroradiology. 2019;61(3):275–284.
2. Niemann U, Berg P, Niemann A, et al. Rupture Status Classification of Intracranial
Aneurysms Using Morphological Parameters. In: Proc. of IEEE Symposium on
Computer-Based Medical Systems (CBMS); 2018. p. 48–53.
3. Paliwal N, Tutino V, Shallwani H, et al. Ostium ratio and neck ratio could pre-
dict the outcome of sidewall intracranial aneurysms treated with flow diverters.
American Journal of Neuroradiology. 2019;40(2):288–294.
4. Wong SC, Nawawi O, Ramli N, et al. Benefits of 3D rotational DSA compared with
2D DSA in the evaluation of intracranial aneurysm. Acad Radiol. 2012;19(6):701–
707.
5. Lauric A, Baharoglu MI, Malek AM. Ruptured status discrimination perfor-
mance of aspect ratio, height/width, and bottleneck factor is highly dependent
on aneurysm sizing methodology. Neurosurgery. 2012;71(1):38–46.
6. Xiang J, Natarajan SK, Tremmel M, et al. Hemodynamic–morphologic discrimi-
nants for intracranial aneurysm rupture. Stroke. 2011;42(1):144–152.
7. Saalfeld S, Berg P, Niemann A, et al. Semiautomatic neck curve reconstruction for
intracranial aneurysm rupture risk assessment based on morphological parameters.
Int J Comput Assist Radiol Surg. 2018;13(11):1781–1793.
8. Glaßer S, Berg P, Neugebauer M, et al. Reconstruction of 3D Surface Meshes for
Bood Flow Simulations of Intracranial Aneurysms. In: Proc. of the Annual Meeting
of the German Society of Computer- and Robot-Assisted Surgery (CURAC); 2015.
p. 163–168.
9. Hart PE, Nilsson NJ, Raphael B. A formal basis for the heuristic determination
of minimum cost paths. IEEE transactions on Systems Science and Cybernetics.
1968;4(2):100–107.
10. Berg P, Beuing O. Multiple intracranial aneurysms: a direct hemodynamic com-
parison between ruptured and unruptured vessel malformations. Int J Comput
Assist Radiol Surg. 2018;13(1):83–93.
11. Cebral JR, Mut F, Weir J, et al. Quantitative characterization of the hemody-
namic environment in ruptured and unruptured brain aneurysms. AJNR Am J
Neuroradiol. 2011;32(1):145–151.
12. Hanocka R, Hertz A, Fish N, et al. MeshCNN: A Network with an Edge. ACM
Trans Graph. 2019;38(4):90:1–90:12.
E2822
Article
Full-text available
Purpose For the status evaluation of intracranial aneurysms (IAs), morphological and hemodynamic parameters can provide valuable information. For their extraction, a separation of the aneurysm sac from its parent vessel is required that yields the neck curve and the ostium. However, manual and subjective neck curve and ostium definitions might lead to inaccurate IA assessments. Methods The research project VICTORIA was initiated, allowing users to interactively define the neck curve of five segmented IA models using a web application. The submitted results were qualitatively and quantitatively compared to identify the minimum, median and maximum aneurysm surface area. Finally, image-based blood flow simulations were carried out to assess the effect of variable neck curve definitions on relevant flow- and shear-related parameters. Results In total, 55 participants (20 physicians) from 18 countries participated in VICTORIA. For relatively simple aneurysms, a good agreement with respect to the neck curve definition was found. However, differences among the participants increased with increasing complexity of the aneurysm. Furthermore, it was observed that the majority of participants excluded any small arteries occurring in the vicinity of an aneurysm. This can lead to non-negligible deviations among the flow- and shear-related parameters, which need to be carefully evaluated, if quantitative analysis is desired. Finally, no differences between participants with medical and non-medical background could be observed. Conclusions VICTORIAs findings reveal the complexity of aneurysm neck curve definition, especially for bifurcation aneurysms. Standardization appears to be mandatory for future sac-vessel-separations. For hemodynamic simulations a careful neck curve definition is crucial to avoid inaccuracies during the quantitative flow analysis.
Article
Full-text available
Background and purpose: Incompletely occluded flow diverter treated aneurysms remain at risk of rupture and thromboembolic complications. Our aim was to identify the potential for incomplete occlusion of intracranial aneurysms treated by flow diverters. We investigated whether aneurysm ostium size in relation to parent artery size affects angiographic outcomes of flow diverter-treated sidewall aneurysms. Materials and methods: Flow diverter-treated sidewall aneurysms were divided into "occluded" and "residual" (incomplete occlusion) groups based on 6-month angiographic follow-up. We calculated the ostium ratio, a new parameter defined as the aneurysm ostium surface area versus the circumferential surface area of the parent artery. We also calculated the neck ratio, defined as clinical aneurysm neck diameter versus parent artery diameter from pretreatment 2D DSA, as a 2D surrogate. We compared the performance of these ratios with existing aneurysm morphometrics (size, neck diameter, volume, aspect ratio, size ratio, undulation index, nonsphericity index, ellipticity index, bottleneck factor, aneurysm angle, and parent vessel angle) and flow diverter-related parameters (metal coverage rate and pore density). Statistical tests and receiver operating characteristic analyses were performed to identify significantly different parameters between the 2 groups and test their predictive performances. Results: We included 63 flow diverter-treated aneurysms, 46 occluded and 17 residual. The ostium ratio and neck ratio were significantly higher in the residual group than in the occluded group (P < .001 and P = .02, respectively), whereas all other parameters showed no statistical difference. As discriminating parameters for occlusion, ostium ratio and neck ratio achieved areas under the curve of 0.912 (95% CI, 0.838-0.985) and 0.707 (95% CI, 0.558-0.856), respectively. Conclusions: High ostium ratios and neck ratios could predict incomplete occlusion of flow diverter-treated sidewall aneurysms. Neck ratio can be easily calculated by interventionists to predict flow-diverter treatment outcomes.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The mechanisms of cerebral aneurysm rupture are not fully understood. We analyzed the associations of hemodynamics, morphology, and patient age and gender with aneurysm rupture stratifying by location. Methods Using image-based models, 20 hemodynamic and 17 morphological parameters were compared in 1931 ruptured and unruptured aneurysms with univariate logistic regression. Rupture rates were compared between males and females as well as younger and older patients and bifurcation versus sidewall aneurysms for different aneurysm locations. Subsequently, associations between hemodynamics and morphology and patient as well as aneurysm characteristics were analyzed for aneurysms at five locations. Results Compared to unruptured aneurysms, ruptured aneurysms were characterized by a more irregular shape and were exposed to a more adverse hemodynamic environment described by faster flow, higher wall shear stress, more oscillatory shear, and more unstable and complex flows. These associations with rupture status were consistent for different aneurysm locations. Rupture rates were significantly higher in males at the internal carotid artery (ICA) bifurcation, ophthalmic ICA, and the middle cerebral artery (MCA) bifurcation. At the anterior communicating artery (ACOM) and MCA bifurcation, they were significantly higher for younger patients. Bifurcation aneurysms had significantly larger rupture rates at the MCA and posterior communicating artery (PCOM). In these groups with higher rupture rates, aneurysms were characterized by adverse hemodynamics and more complex shapes. Conclusion Hemodynamic and morphological differences between ruptured and unruptured aneurysms are consistent across locations. Adverse morphology and hemodynamics are related to rupture as well as younger age, male gender, and bifurcation aneurysms.
Article
Full-text available
PurposeMorphological parameters of intracranial aneurysms (IAs) are well established for rupture risk assessment. However, a manual measurement is error-prone, not reproducible and cumbersome. For an automatic extraction of morphological parameters, a 3D neck curve reconstruction approach to delineate the aneurysm from the parent vessel is required. Methods We present a 3D semiautomatic aneurysm neck curve reconstruction for the automatic extraction of morphological parameters which was developed and evaluated with an experienced neuroradiologist. We calculate common parameters from the literature and include two novel angle-based parameters: the characteristic dome point angle and the angle difference of base points. ResultsWe applied our method to 100 IAs acquired with rotational angiography in clinical routine. For validation, we compared our approach to manual segmentations yielding highly significant correlations. We analyzed 95 of these datasets regarding rupture state. Statistically significant differences were found in ruptured and unruptured groups for maximum diameter, maximum height, aspect ratio and the characteristic dome point angle. These parameters were also found to statistically significantly correlate with each other. Conclusions The new 3D neck curve reconstruction provides robust results for all datasets. The reproducibility depends on the vessel tree centerline and the user input for the initial dome point and parameters characterizing the aneurysm neck region. The characteristic dome point angle as a new metric regarding rupture risk assessment can be extracted. It requires less computational effort than the complete neck curve reconstruction.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this study was to compare conventional two-dimensional (2D) digital subtraction angiography (DSA) with three-dimensional (3D) rotational DSA in the investigation of intracranial aneurysm in terms of detection, size measurement, neck diameter, neck delineation, and relationship with surrounding vessels. A further aim was to compare radiation dose, contrast volume, and procedural time between the two protocols. Thirty-five patients who presented with subarachnoid bleeds on computed tomography and were suspected of having intracranial aneurysms underwent conventional 2D DSA followed by 3D DSA. The 3D digital subtraction angiographic images were displayed as surface shaded display images. Aneurysm detection, sac size, neck diameter, neck delineation, and relationship of aneurysm to the surrounding vessels analyzed from the two protocols were compared. Radiation dose, contrast volume, and procedural time for both examinations were also compared. Three-dimensional DSA detected 44 aneurysms in 31 patients, with negative findings seen in four patients. A false-negative detection rate of 6.8% (three of 44) for 2D DSA was noted. There was no significant difference in aneurysm size between 3D and 2D DSA. The sizes of aneurysm necks were found to be significantly larger in 3D DSA than on 2D DSA. The aneurysm neck and relationship to surrounding vessels were significantly better demonstrated on 3D DSA than on 2D DSA. Radiation dose (entrance surface dose), contrast use, and procedural time with 3D DSA were significantly less than with 2D DSA. Three-dimensional DSA improves the detection and delineation of intracranial aneurysms, with lower radiation dose, less contrast use, and shorter procedural time compared to 2D DSA. The size of the aneurysm neck on 3D DSA tended to be larger than on 2D DSA.
Article
Full-text available
Hemodynamics are thought to play an important role in the mechanisms of aneurysm pathogenesis, progression, and rupture. The purpose of this study was to define quantitative measures related to qualitative flow characteristics previously analyzed and to investigate their relationship to aneurysm rupture. The hemodynamic environments in 210 cerebral aneurysms were analyzed by using image-based CFD under different flow conditions. Quantitative hemodynamic variables were defined and extracted from the simulation results. A statistical analysis of the relationship to the previous history of aneurysm rupture was performed, and the variability with flow conditions was assessed. Ruptured aneurysms were more likely to have larger inflow concentrations, larger MWSS, larger shear concentrations, and lower viscous dissipation ratios than unruptured aneurysms. Areas under low WSS and measures of abnormally low shear force distributions of ruptured and unruptured aneurysms were not statistically different. Although the values of hemodynamic quantities changed with different flow conditions, the statistical differences or ratios between their mean values over the ruptured and unruptured groups were maintained, for both pulsatile and steady flows. Concentrated inflow streams and WSS distributions with elevated levels of MWSS and low aneurysmal viscous dissipation are statistically associated with a clinical history of prior aneurysm rupture. In contrast, the area and total viscous shear force applied in the aneurysm region subjected to abnormally low WSS levels are not. This study highlights the potential for image-based CFD for investigating aneurysm-evolution mechanisms and for clinical assessment of aneurysm risks.
Article
Polygonal meshes provide an efficient representation for 3D shapes. They explicitly captureboth shape surface and topology, and leverage non-uniformity to represent large flat regions as well as sharp, intricate features. This non-uniformity and irregularity, however, inhibits mesh analysis efforts using neural networks that combine convolution and pooling operations. In this paper, we utilize the unique properties of the mesh for a direct analysis of 3D shapes using MeshCNN, a convolutional neural network designed specifically for triangular meshes. Analogous to classic CNNs, MeshCNN combines specialized convolution and pooling layers that operate on the mesh edges, by leveraging their intrinsic geodesic connections. Convolutions are applied on edges and the four edges of their incident triangles, and pooling is applied via an edge collapse operation that retains surface topology, thereby, generating new mesh connectivity for the subsequent convolutions. MeshCNN learns which edges to collapse, thus forming a task-driven process where the network exposes and expands the important features while discarding the redundant ones. We demonstrate the effectiveness of MeshCNN on various learning tasks applied to 3D meshes.
Article
Purpose: Despite numerous studies addressing the rupture risk of intracranial aneurysms that have been published, the assessment thereof still remains challenging. Image-based simulations enable a precise prediction of patient-specific blood flow information. However, those approaches normally consider only small segments of the complete cerebral vasculature. Methods: To test the validity of the consideration of single aneurysms in one computational setup, domains of the complete anterior and posterior circulations with multiple intracranial aneurysms (MIA) were simulated. Six patients with MIA were investigated, while 3D surfaces of eleven unruptured and six ruptured aneurysms were segmented. The segmentations were used for the determination of morphological parameters and also for image-based blood flow simulations used to characterize the hemodynamic properties of each aneurysm. Results: In the geometric comparison, neck aspect ratios of unruptured and ruptured aneurysms did not differ significantly. In contrast, size ratios, aspect ratios, surface areas, volumes, and non-sphericity indices were significantly higher in the ruptured cases. The analysis of hemodynamic parameters demonstrated that in each patient, the ruptured aneurysm exhibited the lowest averaged wall shear stresses and highest oscillatory shears. Unstable flow was also detected in ruptured aneurysms based on increased oscillatory velocity. Conclusion: In this small study involving patients with MIA, different morphologies and flow patterns were observed between ruptured and unruptured aneurysms. The analysis of the hemodynamics in such patients revealed a good agreement with studies that only considered single malformations. Additionally, complex flow patterns are detected in ruptured cases, which require deeper investigation.
Article
Numerous size and shape parameters have historically been used to describe cerebral aneurysms and to correlate rupture status. These parameters are often inconsistently defined. To evaluate the impact of definition variation on rupture status detection performance. Catheter rotational angiographic data sets of 134 consecutive aneurysms (60 ruptured) were automatically measured in 3 dimensions with a validated algorithm. According to the literature, aneurysm height was assessed as both maximal and orthogonal distances from dome to neck. Maximal and orthogonal widths were defined perpendicular to height definitions. Neck size was evaluated as minimum, maximum, and average diameter of the neck plane. Aspect ratio (AR; height/neck), height/width ratio (HW), and bottleneck factor (BNF; width/neck) were evaluated for alternative definitions of each size variable. Univariate statistics were used to identify significant features and to compute the area under the curve (AUC) of the receiver-operating characteristic. The AR, HW, and BNF showed significant dependence on parameter definition. Statistical significance and performance varied widely, depending on alternative definitions: AR, AUC range of 0.59 to 0.75; HW, AUC range of 0.48 to 0.72; and BNF, AUC range of 0.57 to 0.72. Using maximal height, orthogonal width, and minimum neck resulted in the best AR, HW, and BNF performances. Compared with HW, AR and BNF were less sensitive to alternative definitions. Alternative aneurysm size definitions have a significant impact on prediction performance and optimal threshold values. Adoption of standard methodology and sizing nomenclature appears critical to ensure rupture detection performance and reproducibility across studies.