Content uploaded by Suniya S. Luthar
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Suniya S. Luthar on Jan 02, 2020
Content may be subject to copyright.
!
"#$"%&'()$#(
'
%$
'*%
'+', +',
nicolezillmer@gmail.com
Acknowledgements: Support for this work was provided by Authentic Connections Co. The article
was prepared while Suniya Luthar was on the faculty at Arizona State University (ASU). For their
many contributions to this program of research, the authors are grateful to graduate students and
postdocs from Luthar’s laboratories at ASU and prior to that, at Columbia University’s Teachers
College.
'
%-,
--.
/0'12.3
0'-2
,45-
'6
*--
--
-7-
-6
2
Educators in high-achieving settings
5-56
3
0'.
4--
46
0'-55
-
-
4
-50'
-5
5894
/66:;
9<8=1-6/39<8>,
3:39<8?,0:@9<8?1A
-B0/B01
-4
-/3(:#
9<8=1'A.
6/
&6C:B9<8=1
6-6-
-D6EF5
/0'19<8=#3C;
-5-
4G
/@*:69<8=1
'$:B/'$B9<8H1526
0'--
56
3
Educators in high-achieving settings
73-
-B0
0'6
---6
6
0'2-
--
4 589
4/9<8=81
D-
E4
A
/9<8=1
-'-6
(&%53B:3/9<8=1
4
45
3
-
-I
7--*
6-2
/ 3:39<8?1A
/B01
B0,
A--4*
4
Educators in high-achieving settings
3:/9<8J8??12
D-5
A
A
56-E(
2-4
/ : 9<<J1-
/B0'9<8J1
&B0A
4-#
/9<8=1*B0
K-
,-"
4
4--
-
5
-*
(/9<8=14*-
-L
55--
64
4*
@&M-
A
-6-
!"
'.-
/0'1--I
3
5
Educators in high-achieving settings
0'
/: 9<8=,@*:69<8=1
-G/
&:9<8=, :!1
-*4
AB
-
IA0'6
425
#/8HHN1
5-5
0'A
6--,I!!
!-
0'
-
9<<</:&69<891-
*0'A
.
8<58?
#$%
--
255
-9<8?9<8H
-A
%$A
-,2
8-
'2
/$5&958O-
-9<8O1
6
Educators in high-achieving settings
-
'
@H589-42/3558?1-
8<589OOH=
555585555
3
-8'*
4
'-86'
9<8=/"9<8H1B88=<
8>H<-O9H=
-8N9<==
;-0'/:&69<891
-F#/F#,':#
9<<81-*
4*'4573-5
7#5&6
'F#2-
2/O<1-
9P
3
-?
=H=?A-
(=8--=<HO,--O?--OJ
O=
&
'-
'
-7
5
I-6
%
-8##6/'9<8?1
7
Educators in high-achieving settings
2F#
/9P18-
-"9<8H
2'45-O,
8>PO</M971
'0'
/:9<8O1"-
A2
/#;:&69<<H1'-##6/##1
-82-
,"6I##
62!Q<<8,!Q<8
!Q<?
@0'55
4L-4-
4-
-
/1'-82
-'453-5
-2!Q<<8##/-
1-><58<N/O<1?H58>8/OO1(
-2##8O5==/J<1
-2$558=-##8=5
O?/NJ1
(4*###56'-
2,995ON/N?1
9<5JN/N?1$-2?=-##
<?59=/991'-
2
'
(-
-2
*2-
'453-5,
6-#(
8
Educators in high-achieving settings
4*-#5
6'
2*
6*4*
62*
64/303)7:C5#
9<<O1-
-*-
/3):9<8=1'
-6
/39<8=8?J1';0-
!65'*/9<8=N?O1
RDKE
---
34
I-
40'-5
.0'%$4
*$%&'4/7*5-
9<8O1$(/':
@9<8=)/#9<8?1
-6-0'
4-
-D3
/--1&-
-E
70'--
--A
2F#
8HHH9??8/':#9<<81
-6-
35&4/ 9<8H1--
8<<<<%
2
9
Educators in high-achieving settings
-/
: 9<8=1
()&)&
.6"
5-6
A5
/: 9<8=1
".A
/B@6:@9<8H1
A-
-
25/3
@*: 9<8O1
'
-5
4-6S
4-A,-I
5DE
-26
/-1A/(9<8=1'
40'-
44-6
'(/9<8=1
---6
.&
I-
10
Educators in high-achieving settings
-DE/3:
9<8>1
DE.
.
-5--
---
-4
/9<<N13
--5-
6-G
*0'
-6
-4
--
&-
45-5
--/1
"/"1/1/16
"-I
6
20--
--HJPO=
I
#NN-69</
-1=/--
1=?DE"-6-
-ONP,89P,HP,
>P,SNPO?
?H8JO8/H>OP1-6-
-8N58=,8H/9?NP1-J58955/8NP1-
J
"#F
11
Educators in high-achieving settings
"I--992/
91"-6---6
--55-56'
8N6"-
/91T8>6
-H(H
25/<5895N>5JO5
=H58<1--6
'-4-
99'4-
U7SU#S9-
555595555
99-6"
2
/1--5
/1--5
/1-,/1
/1--'
"-6
--4
I
%
-
-7S
#S-
-5.#-2A
36*VOO+/>8J91V?ONNQ<<<8-5
/'()'1-I/1
A'2A-7S
---A*/,91NJ
-4A
2#'()'-A
12
Educators in high-achieving settings
IA-,9
/N1(A--
-'5
-5-6
'
--6-
/1-5/1
'
-
W-6W
--D-E
-6
;G--5
W-5W6
'
---5-
556-
'-
-
/:BX*9<89,06:9<<H1
-
/8HH91(/9<8O1
D
Y-6
E
B-6
L*55
/1
-
$
--
13
Educators in high-achieving settings
5I'(
/9<8=1-
*'
7--A
B00'2
-6'-6
Z-/39<8=166-
6
.
A/39<8=1
2*
6-0'
26
66-
4-4*'
/9<8=1
0';
/9<8=14A
-6-
-6-4
-*-
-
/;9<8=1
3-
46-
#*
'5/1
3B/9<8H1-D-
ED-
14
Educators in high-achieving settings
-6
.4
B
-I
3-
E6
-
+"!
7-
0'655L
-'#/9<8H1
-
&6C:B/9<8=1
-5A
-4
I
.
6
(/9<8O165
30/'1-8889
*)($DY-
A4-A-
AK--6
E"A
-A
,-
3)($*5
--
-6-4
(--
-
15
Educators in high-achieving settings
D-E-
-6'--5
--
K
-D4E'0'6
6-5,
60'
--
6
,!"
B00'
6--5
%--6
K4/
76: 9<8O10-
/@&-:'9<8J142
B*D8J4-6-4
.'E/#
9<8=1
(
4/@9<8J, 9<8<,
C:@9<<H1
6/"6:
39<8=1
--.
/-)-7;:"6
1;-'3
/9<8=1-6',
*6
-6-
16
Educators in high-achieving settings
)
$A
6-
(I-
A-
/39<8=1'-DE
-I
/: 9<8=1
'
-6
--6-0'--6
--
;6
5DE
5-
/ 3:
09<8=126
2---42-
D""-6-L6
-66E
-5,4
/:$9<8O,B9<8H,3:
B9<8H1'3/9<8=1
A*
-/;0:(*
9<<O,9<8=1
;/A154
17
Educators in high-achieving settings
'@/$:
9<8O155-6-
--L
655-A-63
*/$:
9<8O1-4A/ :&
1-
HS8<5(
0'25
A
4
--
'-0'-
4'
6*0'
--
-I
6L
-'
L5L-
D-6E/
9<8=1A--5
L6--
#
'B:#'/9<<8./ ))
!#&)%)#
F:;
'/9<8?1%6
'012=?O5=J8
7: 0/9<8=1&#-
18
Educators in high-achieving settings
'370K6@;
/$1 /885N81
"-*
7*5-&/9<8O13'A
4[#
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/11/magazine/why-are-more-american-
teenagers-than-ever-su$ering-from-severe-anxiety.html
;007:(*'/9<<O17-5
['*A5
''34/J1H8J5HN>
;@0-":!65'*C/9<8=1
K%
'370K6@;/$1
/N?O5N=81
"-*
@*B&:6B/9<8=1)560!
+7!!(--6)8(!/
S----.S
SSSS\S9<8=S-.>>?HN?SS-.>>?HN?\8
@B&-C:'#B/9<8J1'
9--#$&"
"#"%
06$B&/9<<H1"'I
)-::;8H?L99?8<8<=JS?H?JJ?
0B :@'$/9<8J10
#-F6-F6
C"':@B/9<<H1
(%(-1</81>H85?9?
8<N8<9S<<N>J?>N<=N9?JHN
BC: 3C/9<<J1(-
(-(@
19
Educators in high-achieving settings
BCB�:/9<8=1%6
6-'5
=!!-4>-8==H58H<J
SSS8<8<8OS<H?>?OH>8=<<88>8
/9<8H135&4'
%B''
33F:/9<8J1B"
'0-2:/N18?>58?=
33F:0B/9<8=1
4['370K6@;
/$1 /=N58<81
"-*
33F:3B/$1/9<8?16
?!!/%"
/9<8<17
(%-;4/819O5N?8<8<=<S<<8N8H8<89<<NNJ9=
':B*)/9<891UF
K-
-@;9<8598=8<88OOS<<N=<><O88>N?=??
'3K670:;@/9<8H1
"-*
7;76: B/9<8O1'
-5'.5
7!34/919J9L9OO
SSS8<8<NOS<<<<<O<
/9<<N1G"-
0=!1A8?=858?HN
/9<8O173
[!-:3-88?N588?=
7(8<88OOS8O>?JH8J8OO9O=JN
:&60/9<891'GD6E[)
=!!-
3A->9H5>>H
'C$C:B/9<8O1
20
Educators in high-achieving settings
;D'
@E5B/
7(SS4S8<8<8JS.-9<8O<9<<O
:$/9<8O1#56
0-4*0
=!-@@-NNOLN>H
: /9<8=1F5
5'3
7066@;
6)+%/>>85>?=1-F6
:!/9<8H10'
26"
)/(2
S8<8<NOS<<<<??J
B'@6B:@'5B/9<8H1
"$#/#$%#1@6
B
B0'/9<8J1A:6#
!!/#
SS---SS52
'$B/9<8H1C
6)-!-!D/
SS4S8<8O99JS9?>JJ
(B&3'%53CB$:3B7/9<8=1
3-65['37
0K6@;/$1
/NN5>H1"-*
(7/9<8O1KG#
---S*S5S59<8OS5K55G5
55S[
\V-:\V:\V:\V
"6C7''@:3B/9<8=1$
21
Educators in high-achieving settings
A
'370K6@;/$1
/8=?58HO1
"-*
"/9<8H10'"-'9<8J9<8O9<8=
9<8H# https://blog.prepscholar.com/historical-percentiles-new-
sat.
# /9<8=1U-6.
-6'#
https://time.com/longform/teaching-in-america/.
#C$:7/8HHN1 '%= (60-
!-!/7
"??59H/
#0 '3'6B5'B$#:"5
6C/9<8H1B
''370K6@;
/$1 /89O58>91
"-*
#0/9<8?1)#
SS---S*SS9<8?S89S555
S>8N8><S]5
#CC;B&:&67/9<<H106"B
'"'
7'/9<8=./="65!
%/0$"
#&/8HH91G(&C7"-67C:
-(3/$1!%6)!
!!/9JH59==137'"
'
0&60C':B/9<8=1&(*
5-
'370K6@;/$1
/J?5=81"
-*
22
Educators in high-achieving settings
3#'7/9<8>16
!%3>:A/#SS6-S-5
SS9<8?S<?S9<8?56-55
)-C77;'B:"6C0/1$5
#*#"
4=!/
3B7@*' : 7/9<8O1)
!!!E.6
0!-0
!!E+79!
-F//=!./$(#%
("
3(:#/9<8=1F4'3
70K6@;/$1
/8<?589J1"
-*
3CC7)C/9<8=1"
'5
'370K6@;/$1
/8>N58J?1
"-*
3C00)$30)7#':C5#B/9<<O1
0-3</91H?58<O
37":BB@/9<8H1#
#SS---S*S5
S59<8HS55-5S
8#6#/1
2F#/^O<1
0((S
S
/9<8=5
9<8H1
B
0
)
B
;
'
B
P
'45
7
3-
5
7
#5
&6
'
B ; B ; B ; B ; B ;
3558? 98< H=P _8H<<
<5 5 HO O9 5 >= 9> 5 99 5 N= 5
35"5
8J
8ON
==<P 5 _>OO
_H9 == >< H8 >J JO 8O NJ 9H 9> 99 8?
$5&95
8O J<N H?P _>9<<
<
5 5 H? JO ?H NH NJ J< NJ >> 8J NO <J
$5"58O 88>
O=JP 5 _=89
_8=<
=> 8<
NHO ?> ?H == >? ON 9N JN 8N
$5&85
8= J<> HNP _>?<<
<
5 5 =H =? =8 ?< >J =9 N< >> 9= 9> 8?
B3558= O9> HJP _8OJ>
<5 5 => JH ?H ?8 N8 >= 9O N? 8< 9< <J
3558= >J8 H=P _>8<<
<H8 O< 8>
8>9 ?< JJ O? N? 9< N? 8J
$558= >>9 HJP _N9<<
<5 5 H8 ?O O9 >> JH >< 8= N9 <? 99 <?
35"58H 8=J
H==P 5 _9=N
_H8 O9
O< O< O9 ?9 OO >J ?O 9? >H 8N
($*-#6#2A'
-*-!Q<<86!Q<8!Q<?,5
2-42-'*-
24
Educators in high-achieving settings
#6#$,3-B3
B-,B3-3,"",&&('OOH=
9
+68%B(!6)
- ))./0/
1/ ! "2
')3
) 43-))
=' 5$67 5<8?
88-" 5$68 5<N<
N7" 5$69 5<N8
9" 5$6( <<8
>$ 5$6# <<<
8N'-" 5$86 5<NO
J#" 5$85 5<N<
?-" <98 5$6:
89"-" 5<8< 5$68
8#/"1 5<9O 5$6;
O" 5<88 5$67
H"" 5<NO 5$87
:>/)!% >/44 >/A:
#;$<=
>
1- 5$6; 5<8>
1-5 5$88 <<9
1I 5$89 <<H
1 5$85 5<8=
1- 5$;7 5<8J
1 5<88 5$67
25
Educators in high-achieving settings
1 <<H 5$66
.% >/>A >/>1
.!!)= ! >/31 >/AA
$-
N
0!!B!B!B6
8D9
"
A
T
A
- B 0
B
= B
= B = + ,3+,3
7S 9O9 <J
J
9H9 <J? NN> <O
9
NJ=J
``` <N> <HJ <<8
(S NO? <J
NNH< <?< NON <J
<8NN <<9 8>> <<9
") +,3+,3
;-
9N= <H
=N<9 <HN N<? 8<
9
8O<>
``` <8H 8<=O`` <8N
N8< 8<
<9H9 <H> N99 89
99N9 <<N 89O8`` <8?
- 8?9 <O
O8OH <H> 99H 8N
=
8==>
``` <9< 9O>` <<>
26
Educators in high-achieving settings
"6- NN8 88
?N>N <=O N89 8<
><NH <<8 8>? <<9
8HN 8<
O9N> <HN 9?J 8<
O
8>H>``
`<8O 9H9` <<>
$/`!Q<8,``!Q<<8GHHH!I<<<8,3<N8<N<A*