ArticlePDF Available

Technologies of Romance: Valentine from a Telegraph Clerk ? to a Telegraph Clerk ?: the material culture and standards of early electrical telegraphy

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

In 1860, renowned natural philosopher (now referred to as a ‘scientist’ or, more specifically in the case of Clerk Maxwell, a ‘physicist’) James Clerk Maxwell wrote ‘Valentine from a Telegraph Clerk ♂ [male] to a Telegraph Clerk ♀ [female]’ (Harman, 2001).[1] The short poem was a slightly tongue-in-cheek ode to the romance of the electric telegraph littered with references to manufacturers of batteries used in electrical telegraphy around this time such as John Daniell, Alfred Smee, and William Grove and electrical units (now SI derived units) such as Ohm, Weber, Farad and Volt (Mills, 1995). Although intended as slightly tongue-in-cheek, Maxwell’s short ode can be read as a state of play of electrical telegraphy as it stood in 1860 when Britain dominated the limited undersea electrical telegraph network as it existed at the time and continued to do so as the network expanded to a global interconnected electrical network by the end of the nineteenth century. Figure 1 Colour photograph of of a letter opener with a an 1894 calender and world map © Science Museum/Science & Society Picture Library Science Museum object 2004-162, Letter opener with 1894 calendar and map, made for the Eastern Telegraph Company, 1893–1894. Object is currently on display in cable section of the Information Age gallery at the Science Museum, London DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/012 full size print This sixteen-line poem was but one from a lifetime of poetry on the part of Clerk Maxwell – many exploring the wonders and romance of the new age of electrical telecommunications through which Clerk Maxwell lived and to which he actively contributed. Three years earlier in September 1857, Maxwell had also written a poem about the failed transatlantic telegraph cable, The song of the Atlantic Telegraph Co.[2] It would not be until 1866, nearly a decade after the failure of the initial 1857 transatlantic cable, that the first successful commercial transatlantic telegraph cable was laid and by the end of the nineteenth century a vast network of telegraph cables connected the furthest corners of the globe.[3] By this time, an extended telegraph network led to decreased costs and the telegraph became a more accessible and everyday form of communication. It was the romance, possibility, and personal use of the telegraph which caught the popular imagination, and these aspects began to be featured in popular literature in the late Victorian age – as they had been, in a more technical form, in Clerk Maxwell’s original 1860 poem above (Bruton, 2015). Below I have used artefacts from the Science Museum Group’s extensive holdings relating to the history of electrical telegraphy – many on display in the Information Age gallery at the Museum – to engage with both the technology and romance of the early years of electrical telegraphy.[4] In this article, I explore, situate and contextualise the technology – the material culture and early technical standards – as well as the human aspect – the romance and promise – of electrical telegraphy referred to in Clerk Maxwell’s poem above.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Science Museum Group Journal
Technologies of Romance: Valentine from a Telegraph Clerk to
a Telegraph Clerk : the material culture and standards of early
electrical telegraphy
Journa l IS SN nu mbe r: 2054-5770
Th i s a rti cle wa s wri tten by El iza be th B ruton
10-08-2019 Cite a s 10.15180; 191201 Di scus si on
Technologies of R omance : Va le nti ne from a Tel e graph Cl erk to a Te le gra ph Cl erk : the m ate ria l cul ture a nd s tand ard s of ea rly
el ectri cal tel e graphy
Publi s he d i n Autumn 2019, Is su e 12
Arti cle D OI : http://dx.doi .org/10.15180/191201
Keywords
electrical telegraphy, poetry, s cienti fic i nstr uments , James Clerk Ma xwell
Valentine from A Telegraph Clerk to a Telegraph Clerk , by JC Maxwell, 1860
The tendri l s of my s oul a re twi ned
With thine, though ma ny a mil e apart.
And thi ne in c l ose coi l ed ci rcuits wi nd
Around the needl e of my heart.
Cons ta nt as Da n i el l , s trong as Gr ove.
Ebullient throughout i ts depths l i ke Smee,
My hea rt puts forth i ts ti de of love,
And all i ts circuits clos e in thee.
O tell me, when along the line
From my ful l heart the mes sage flows ,
Wha t currents a re induc ed in thi ne?
On e click from thee wil l end my woes .
Through ma ny a n Ohm the Weber fl ew,
And clicked this a nswer b a ck to me;
I am thy Fara d s taun ch a nd true,
Charged to a Volt wi th love for thee
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/001
Introduction
In 1860 , renowned natural phi los opher (now referred to a s a ‘sc i enti st’ or, more s peci fic a l l y in the case of Cl erk Maxwell, a
‘phys i cist’) Ja mes Clerk Ma xwell wr ote ‘Valenti ne from a Telegraph Cl erk [ma le] to a Tel egraph Cl erk [female]’ (Harma n ,
2001).[1] The s hort poem wa s a sl ightly tongue-i n-cheek ode to the roma nce of the electri c telegraph littered wi th refer enc es to
manufa cturers of batteri es used in el ectri cal telegraphy a round thi s ti me such as Joh n Da niell, Alfred Smee, a nd W il l i am Grove
and electri cal units (now SI deri ved uni ts ) such as Ohm, Weber, Fa rad a nd Volt (Mills, 199 5).
Although i ntended a s s l ightly tongue-i n-cheek, Ma xwell ’s s hort ode can be read a s a sta te of play of el ectri cal tel egraphy as it
stood i n 18 60 when Bri tain domina ted the l imi ted u ndersea electri cal telegraph network a s i t exis ted at the ti me and conti nued
to do s o as the network expa nded to a globa l i nterconnected el ectri cal network by the end of the ni neteenth c entury.
Figure 1
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Scienc e Mus eum object 20 04-16 2, Letter o pener wi th 18 94 calendar a nd map, ma de
for the Eastern Tel egraph Company, 18 93–1894. O bjec t i s cur rentl y on di splay i n
ca ble secti on of the Information Age ga ll ery a t the Scienc e Mus eum, London
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /012
Thi s s ixteen-l i ne poem wa s but one from a lifeti me of poetry on the part of Cl erk Maxwell – ma ny expl ori ng the wonders a nd
roma nce of the new age of el ectri cal tel ecommunicatio ns thro ugh whi ch Clerk Ma xwel l l ived a nd to which he activel y
contri buted. Three yea rs earl ier i n September 185 7, Ma xwel l had a ls o wri tten a poem a bout the fa il ed tra nsatlanti c telegraph
ca ble, The song of the Atlantic Telegraph Co.[2]
It would not be unti l 1 866 , nearl y a dec a de after the failure of the ini tial 1857 trans atl a nti c cabl e, that the fi rst s ucc es s ful
commercial trans a tl a ntic telegra ph cabl e was laid and by the end of the nineteenth c entury a vast network of tel egraph cabl es
connected the furthest corners of the globe.[3] By this ti me, an extended tel egraph network l ed to decrea s ed costs a nd the
telegra ph beca me a mor e a cces si ble and ever yday form of c ommun i cation. It wa s the roma nce, pos si bil ity, and pers on a l use of
the tel egraph which c a ught the po pu l a r i ma gination, and thes e as pects bega n to be fea tured in popul ar l i terature in the l ate
Victorian a ge – as they had been, in a mor e techni cal form, in Cl erk Maxwell’s or i gi nal 1860 poem a bove (Bruton, 2 015). Below I
ha ve used artefa cts from the Sci ence M us eum Gr ou p’s extens ive holdi ngs relating to the hi stor y of electrical telegraphy – many
on di splay i n the I nfor ma tion Age gallery a t the Museum – to enga ge with both the tec hnology a nd romance of the earl y years of
electrical telegraphy.[4] In this a rticl e, I expl ore, s itua te and c ontextua l i se the technology – the ma terial cul ture a nd ea rly
techni cal s tand a rds – as well as the human aspect – the ro ma nce a nd promi s e – of el ectri cal telegraphy referred to in Clerk
Ma xwel l ’s poem above.
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/002
Needle
Figure 2
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Scienc e Mus eum object 19 83-47 8, Ørs ted Compa ss Needle, 182 8. Obj ect is currentl y
on di splay i n ca ble secti on of the Information Age gallery at the Science Mus eum,
London
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /013
In 1820 , Dani sh na tura l phi los opher Hans Christian Ør s ted publ is hed i n Lati n the r es ults of hi s experiments and demonstra tion
on the d i rect r el a ti ons hip between el ectri city a nd ma gnetism i n a report en titled Experimenta circa effectu m conflictus electrici in
acum magneticam (Ø rsted, 1 820 ). In the same year , a n Engl is h-language trans la ti on of Ø rsted’s paper wa s published as
‘Experi ments on the Effect of a Current of El ectri city on the Magneti c Needl e’ in Ann als o f P hilosophy (Ibi d, pp 273 277 ). Ø rsted’s
wor k conti nued to be of inter es t to telegraph engi neers more tha n fi fty yea rs later: i n 18 76, a sta tue was erected to the memory
of Ør s ted in Copenhagen and the Jou rna l of the Society o f Telegraph Eng ineers us ed thi s event to re-print Ø rsted’s ori ginal paper
in La tin alongs i de an En gl is h-langua ge tr a nslation by Reverent J E Kempe, Rector of St James ’s , Picca dil ly, London (Ør s ted, 1 876;
Ma dsen, 1 876 ).
Ør s ted ha d di scover ed tha t a ma gnetised c ompa s s needl e moved when brought near a wi re in whi ch el ectri c current wa s
flowing, and tha t the effect wa s i ncr ea s ed if the wi re wa s formed i nto a coi l. The Ørs ted Compa ss Needle shown above, c urrentl y
on di splay i n the I nfor ma tion Age gallery a t the Scienc e Mus eum, is believed to have been us ed at lecture demons trations in
London i n the 1 820 s – the same deca de of the publication in Lati n, English a nd other l a ngua ges of Ø rsted’s grou nd-brea king
res earch on el ectromagnetism. It wa s a l s o around this ti me that it bec ame a pparent that Ør s ted’s appa ratus had a ppl ication
far beyond s cienti fic researc h and demonstra tion a nd had i mmens e potential as a pra ctical form of long-distance el ectri cal
signa ll ing, also known a s el ectri cal telegraphy.
Figure 3
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Left: Scienc e Mus eum object 19 63-21 5, Large Cooke and W heatstone 5-needle
telegra ph, 1837 . O bjec t i s cur rentl y on di spl ay in the cabl e section of the
Information Age ga ll ery a t the Scienc e Mus eum, London
Ri ght: Scienc e Mus eum object 1876-12 72, Cooke and Whea tstone's ea rliest (fi ve-
needle) telegraph, England. Obj ect is currentl y on di splay i n the Maki ng the Modern
World gallery a t the Sci enc e Mus eum, London
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /014
On e of the earl ies t a nd best-kn own a ppl i cations of Ørs ted’s appa ratus a nd pri nci ples to a form of electri cal telegraphy wa s
Cooke and Whea tstone’s fi ve-needl e telegr a ph, patented by Wi l l i a m Fothergill Co oke a nd Cha rles Whea tstone i n 1837 (Li ffen
2010). Cons idered the first practica l el ectri cal tel egraph a ppara tus, a l etter of the a lphabet was communicated when any two of
the fi ve needles on the di al fa ce poi nted to a l etter. Thi s mea nt the s ystem coul d only c ommuni cate us ing twenty l etters of the
alphabet. Two Cooke a nd W heatstone five-needl e dials have s urvived: one on di splay i n the I nfor ma tion Age gallery a t the
Scienc e Mus eum (s hown a bove) a nd one a t the National Mus eum of Scotl and – the latter, as commu nica ted to me by John Liffen,
ha s s ome puzzl ing fea tur es wh i ch do not ma tch the Sc ienc e Mus eum exa mple but s ti l l s eems li kely to d a te fr om 183 7.
As di scus sed in more detai l i n John Liffen’s 20 10 j ourna l articl e, there a re also two o r three other more c ompl ete but l ater
wor ki ng model s of Co oke a nd W heats tone’s 1837 fi ve-needle di al tel egr a ph – one (also shown above) on di spl ay in the Maki ng
the Modern W orl d gallery a t the Scienc e Mus eum; one at the Museum fur Kommunika ti on i n Berlin; a nd a third example, also
bel i eved to da te fr om the same ti me, i n the P owerhous e Mus eum in Sydney (I bid). All three were working model s made i n 18 49–
50 to demonstra te i n a patent dispute.
An a rticl e in The Times (1839) des cri bed Cooke a nd W heats tone’s tel egraph s ystem as bei ng ‘du ring two months , constantl y
wor ked a t the pa ss i ng of ever y [Great Western Railway] tra in between Dr a yton, Ha nwell, a nd Paddington’ (The Times, 1839). The
arti cle went on to des cri be the ea rly – i f not earl ies t – tel egraphists employed on the l ine as bei ng ‘two of the boys fr om the Deaf
and Dumb Asyl um in the Kent-r oad have been at the Padd i ngton s tation for fi ve or s i x weeks , where they were ins tructed i n the
wor ki ng of the machi nery by Mr . Ralph Hutch i nson, and they a re now perfectl y competent to superi ntend the tel egraph a t a ny
one of the s tations ’, a n earl y exa mple of a new technol ogy enabl i ng acc essi bl e empl oyment opportuni ties for those previously
margina li s ed from mos t workpl aces.
Ba ck to top
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/003
Daniell
Figure 4
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Scienc e Mus eum object 19 23-23 2, Da niell cell us ed by Edward Da vy, 1836–183 9.
Ob ject is currentl y on di splay i n ca ble section of the I nfor ma tion Age gallery a t the
Scienc e Mus eum, London
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /015
In 1836 , Br i tis h na tur a l phi losopher a nd fi rst Profes s or of Chemi stry a t Univers i ty Col lege London, John Fr eder i c Da niell,
developed the Da niel l c el l . The Da niell cell wa s a n electroc hemical ba ttery contempo raneous ly r eferred to as a ‘doubl e flu i d
ba ttery’ which used c opper s ulpha te and zinc s ulphate fl uids and offered an i mprovement i n effi ciency over the Vol tai c cell
(Fa hie, 18 37, pp 216 –217 ). The Dani ell cell wa s mo re continuous and effici ent in operation, es peci al l y compared to the s ingle-
flui d ba ttery, but had a tendency to decl ine in effi ciency over ti me (ETHW ).
In 1837 , Dani ell received the Copley Meda l – the Roya l Soci ety’s oldes t a nd mos t pres tigi ous a ward, gra nted for outstanding
achievemen ts i n res earc h in a ny bra nch of science – for ‘hi s two pa pers on vol taic combina tions published i n the Philosophical
Transaction s for 183 6’ (Dani ell, 1836 ). These papers related to the electroc hemistry which underp i nned the Dani ell cell . ‘The fa r-
famed Da niel l c el l ’ (a s per contempora ry el ectri cal telegraphy hi s tor i an and Iri shman J J Fa hie) beca me one of the s tand a rd
prima ry batteri es fo r electri cal tel egraphy and remained s o into the mid-ni neteenth century when Cl erk Maxwell wrote the poem
quoted above (Fa hi e, 1837 ). It was the same J J Fa hie who discovered the Dani ell Cell s hown a bove – now on di s play i n the
Information Age ga ll ery – i n a fi eld in Somer s et i n 18 83 and i t i s believed to have been us ed and pos s ibl y made by chemi st
Edwa rd Davy, who a round 183 7–18 38 wa s a riva l to Cooke and Whea tstone i n developing a pr a ctic al el ectri c telegraph s ys tem.
[5] I n 183 8, Da vy emi grated to Aus tralia l ea vi ng behi nd his el ectri cal tel egraph a ppa ratus in s tor a ge with much bei ng destroyed
with the excep tion of a few Da niell cells.
Ba ck to top
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/004
Grove
Figure 5
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Left: Scienc e Mus eum object 19 80-51 7, Si r Wil l i a m Robert Grove (181 1–18 96):
Lithogra ph by Bos ley, a fter a daguerreotype by Claudet
Ri ght: Scienc e Mus eum object 1895-14 , Gr ove battery of fi ve cel ls , 1895
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /016
Another standard battery i nc orpo rated i nto use in electrical telegraphy i n the mi d-ni neteenth century was the Grove voltai c cell,
developed by W els h judge a nd natur a l phi los opher W il liam Grove. I nitially devel oped in 1 839 , the ba ttery continued to be us ed
througho ut the mi d-ni neteenth c entury a nd very pr oba bly beyond. In the mi d-ni neteenth c entury, the Grove cel l was fa voured by
the el ectri cal tel egraph i ndus try i n the US and Bri tain as i t had a higher output vol tage c ompa red to the ea rlier Da niell cells
menti oned previ ously. For example, the c ommerci al vers ion of the Grove cel l made i n 18 95 by the s cienti fic i nstr ument makers
Elliott Brothers s hown above was a battery of fi ve Grove cel ls with a total vol tage of 9 vo l ts s o about 1 .8 volts current output
per cell.[6] The Gr ove cell had el ectrodes made of pl ati num and zi nc with the electrol yte bei ng di lute sul phuri c acid a nd the
depol a ris er bei ng s trong nitri c acid.[7] However, the increased s cale and popul arity of the electri cal telegraph network i n the
late ni neteenth c entury l ed to the Grove cell fa l ling out of us e as , unl ike the Da niell cell, it did not p roduce a c on s ta nt voltage;
the platinum el ectrode was expens ive; an d fur thermore the battery di scha rged poisonous nitrogen di oxi de, whi ch was
ha zardous to hea l th.[8] As such the exa mple shown above may have b een a ra re s ur vivi ng commerc i a l vers i on of the Grove cell
from the l a te nineteenth c entury.
Ba ck to top
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/005
Smee
Figure 6
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Scienc e Mus eum object 18 95-13 , Smee cell, 189 5
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /017
In 1840 , s urgeon a nd l ater electro-chemi s t Al fr ed Smee devel oped a n improved vers i on of the single-fl uid battery cel l c a l l ed the
Smee c el l , for which he won the pr es ti gi ous Gol d Isis medal of the Soc i ety of Arts i n 18 41.[9] The Smee cel l wa s popul ar in both
the el ectri cal tel egraphy and pr i nting i ndustri es, i ncl udi ng the printi ng of ba nknotes . The latter was a family connecti on: Smee’s
father W i llia m Smee wa s Chi ef Accounta nt for the Ba nk of England (Mackenzie, 19 53).
Ba ck to top
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/006
Ohm
Figure 7
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Left: Scienc e Mus eum object 19 82-14 59/52 , Portra it, photogravure, Geor g Simon
Oh m
Ri ght: Scienc e Mus eum object 1980-34 , Stan dard resistor, 1 ohm, c 1883
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /018
In 1862 , the British Association for the Adva ncement of Sci enc e (BAAS) a ppoi nted the fi rst Commi ss ion to study el ectri c units
and standards of electri cal resistance. The commi ttee consis ted of experts in electr i cal engineeri ng and s cience cha ired by
William Thomson wi th members including Fl eemi ng Jenkin, James Pres cott Joul e, Clerk Ma xwell, and ma ny others. In 1 864, the
Oh ma d – na med after German phys i cist Georg Si mon O hm – wa s propos ed by the commi ttee to be the standard el ectri cal unit
(later SI deri ved un i t) for el ectri cal resistance; by 186 7, i t had been renamed the O hm, as i t is c urrentl y refer red to (Repo rt of the
Committee on Stan dards of Electrical Resistance, 1864 and 1 867 ).
At the 1 881 Congrès internationale des élec trici ens (Interna tion a l El ectri cal Congres s) a nd the rel ated 18 84 Interna ti ona l
Conferenc e for Determi nation of Electr i cal Units, the Ohm was defined in rel ation to the r es i s ta nce of a mercur y column of
specifi ed weight and length, wi th sli ghtly differ i ng l engths due to va riance between different na ti ona l s tand a rds of Ohm. In
addition, the i ncons is tenc y of the cros s -section of the glass tubi ng of the mercur y column meant repr od uci ng a physica l
standard Ohm wa s c hallengi ng. Ins tead other a ppa ratus s uch a s the standard one-o hm resistor (s hown above) wa s devel oped
to c i rcumvent this pr obl em a nd to bec ome a physica l a rtefact standard for the O hm.[10]
Ba ck to top
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/007
Weber
Figure 8
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Scienc e Mus eum object 19 32-39 0, W or king Reconstructi on of the Ga uss-Weber
(183 3) el ectromagnetic telegra ph a ppa ratus
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /019
In 1833 , direc tor of Gotti ngen O bser va tory Ca rl Friedrich Gaus s a nd his col lea gue W i l helm W eber i nvented on e of the fi rst
practica l el ectri cal tel egraph s ystems a nd used i t to communica te with ea ch o ther fr om the Phys ical Labora tory to the
Ob s erva tor y in Gotti ngen, Ger ma ny over a distance of about one ki lometre a nd to co or dina te thei r s tud y of geoma gnetism (s ee
Fi gure 8[11]). Gaus s a nd W eber l ater devel oped a telegraph code of thei r own ma kin g.
The Gaus s-W eber s ystem wa s the first to make use of the p rinci ple of self-i nduc ti on dis covered by Michael Fa rada y in 1831 a nd
the wo rki ng recons truction exampl e shown a bove was gi ven fi rst to the Ins tituti on of El ectri cal Engineers upon the centena ry of
Fa rada y’s d i s covery i n 19 31 by the Electrotec hni s cher Verein of Berl in.[12] Although most of thei r or i gi nal appa ratus has been
los t, there i s a lso a recons truction in the Deuts ches Mus eum, Muni ch.
In 1902 , the British Association for the Adva ncement of Sci enc e (BAAS) c ommi ttee on el ectri c units a nd s tandards of el ectri cal
res is ta nc e committee propos ed the SI derived uni t of ma gnetic flux be na med after Weber.[13]
Ba ck to top
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/008
Farad
Figure 9
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Left: Scienc e Mus eum object 19 78-44 6/4, Engra ved portra it of Michael Fa rada y
Ri ght: Scienc e Mus eum object 1914-89 7, Gl azed frame, containi ng ‘Del i neati on of
Lines of Magnetic Forc e by I ron fi lings’ pr epared by Mi cha el Fara day
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /020
Named after Mi cha el Fara day, the Fa rad i s the SI deri ved uni t of electri cal capa citanc e, a s decl ared a t the Congrès
interna tionale des électr i ciens (International El ectri cal Congres s) in 1 881 (The Electrician, 1881). The diagram s hown above,
whi ch some may r ecognis e fr om thei r s cience class es , wa s prepa red by Mi cha el Fa rada y an d ini tial l ed by hi m on the back.[14]
Using ma gnetic lines of forc e visua l ised by iron fil i ngs, i t demons trates the magneti c attra ction between the unlike pol es of two
adj a cent b a r ma gnets. Fa rada y’s work on electromagneti sm a nd el ectro-chemi stry wa s deepl y infl uenti a l on the devel op ment of
electrical telegraphy a nd l ater wireless telegraphy.
Ba ck to top
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/009
Volt
Figure 10
© Science Mus eum/Sc i enc e & Society Picture Libr a ry
Scienc e Mus eum object 19 15-36 3, Hi bbert standard one-vol t cell
DOI: http://dx .doi .or g/10.151 80/19 1201 /021
Thi s el ectri cal cell wa s designed a nd constructed by l ecturer on Ph ys ics a nd El ectro-Technol ogy W al ter Hi l lbert between 1 894
18 96 in order to produc e a c el l whi ch wo ul d gi ve an output vol tage of ex a ctly one vol t.[15] Li ttle i s known about this obj ect; it
may h a ve been us ed for tea chi ng while a l s o bei ng a physica l ma nifestation of el ectri cal s tand a rds at the time – i n pa rtic ula r
how they a ppl ied to both electri cal power a nd el ectri cal telegraphy i n the nineteenth c entury a nd beyond.
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/010
Conclusion
Wri tten in 1 860, Ja mes Cl erk Maxwell’s poem ‘Va lenti ne from A Telegraph Cl erk to a Telegr a ph Clerk ’ hi ghlighted the human
impul s e behi nd a nd r omanti c potenti a l of el ectri cal telegraphy i n the Vi ctorian Age. Cl erk Maxwell’s poem mi xed r omanti c
langua ge with s tandards of electri cal units a nd a ppa ratus (and the people behind them) to pa int an evoc a ti ve portrait of the
state of pl ay o f el ectri cal telegraphy a s i t stood in 1860. Through a clos e readi ng of the poem and a wi der ex pl ora tion of the
materi al c ulture represented through the Sci ence M useum c oll ections, I ha ve enga ged wi th both the technol ogy a nd roma nce of
the ea rly years of el ectri cal telegraphy.
Acknowledgements
Tha nks to: K a ty Barrett a nd La ura Humphreys , the edi tors of thi s Science Museum Grou p Journal spec i a l c ollecti on; my line
mana ger Ri cha rd Dunn a nd to the Science Museum Group Journal team es peci a l ly K a te Stein er for their support with thi s a rticl e;
and to the a nonymous revi ewer for their hel pful comments . Special tha nks go to Scienc e Mus eum Cura tor Emeri tus John Li ffen
for his helpful a nd detailed comments. All a nd a ny errors in the text are mine. Las t and not least, ma ny thanks go to my wife
Ca men Lei for her s upport and countl ess c ups of tea .
Com ponent D OI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15180/191201/011
Tags
Hi s tory of science
Hi s tory of technology
Museum collections
Scienc e a nd s oci ety
Scienc e communication
Publ ic engagement
Scienti fic i nstruments
Hi s tory of co mmuni cations
Publ ic hi story
Scienc e i n litera ture
Footnotes
1. There a re ma ny, s lightly varying versions of this poem s o I ha ve us ed the vers ion fr om the first (188 2) edi tion of Lewi s
Ca mpbel l a nd W i l l iam Garnett, The life of James C lerk Maxwell: with a selection from his correspo nden ce a nd occasiona l
writings an d a sketch of his co ntributions to science (London: Ma cmillan), pp 630–631. URL:
https://archive.org/deta i l s /lifeofjamesclerk00 campri ch/
2. See Burns , B, 18 57, History o f the A tlantic Cable & Und ersea Communications: The Song o f th e A tlantic Telegraph Compan y
by James Clerk Ma xwell. URL: https://a tl a ntic-ca ble.com/Arti cle/UnderTheSea/i ndex.htm
For further detai ls of Ja mes Clerk Ma xwell a nd a n appendix of h i s poetry, s ee Campbell , L a nd Ga rnett, W , 1 882 , Th e life
of James Clerk Maxwell: with a selection from his corresponden ce and o ccasional writings a nd a sketch of his contribution s to
science (London: Ma cmill a n) URL: https ://arc hi ve.or g/detai l s /l i feofj a mescl er k0 0campri ch/
3. Reformatted vers ion of a n arti cle by Rober t O W oods, Fel low ASME, tha t ori ginally a ppea red i n Mechanical En gineering ,
Jul y 2011. It c ontains addi tional ma terial from ‘From Gaini ng W eeks to Mi ll i s econds The Tra nsatlanti c Ca ble’, by Joh n
Vardala s , i niti al l y publ is hed i n IEEE-USA’s Toda y's Engineer, November 2010 .
URL: https ://ethw.or g/Tr a nsatlanti c _Ca ble
4. See Bl yth, T, 2 015 , ‘Informa tion a ge? The cha ll enges of displ ayi ng informa ti on a nd communication technol ogies’ i n
Scien ce Museum Group Journal, Spring. Ar ti cle DO I: http://dx.doi.or g/1 0.151 80/15 030 3
5. Homer, Ron, ‘Edward Davy, 18 06–1 855; O ttery’s Pioneer of the El ectri c Telegraph’, an unpubl ished paper i n T/192 3-23 2
Scienc e Mus eum Technica l File for: Dani ell cell used by Davy, 183 6/9, wi th spa re pot.
6. For further i nfor ma tion a bout the El li ott Brothers, s ee https ://www.mhs.ox.ac.uk/exhibi ts /elliott-brothers /
7. T/189 5-14 Scienc e Mus eum Technica l File for: Grove battery, fi ve cel ls , i n tra y
8. T/189 5-14 Scienc e Mus eum Technica l File for: Grove battery, fi ve cel ls , i n tra y and Mi ll s , Bob. 'Ea rly batteri es fo r
telegra ph, tel ephone a nd other us es', in A ustralasian Telephone Collectors So ciety Newsletter (January 199 5 and May
19 95). URL: http://tel ephonec ollecti ng.or g/arti cl es /batteri es .html
9. T/189 5-13 Scienc e Mus eum Technica l File for: Smee Cel l a nd Power , D’Arcy. ‘SMEE, ALFRED (181 8–1877)’, Di ctionary of
National Bi ogra phy, 18 85–1 900, Vol ume 52. URL: https://en.wiki s ource.org/wi ki/Smee,_Alfred_(DNB00)
10 . For further deta i ls, s ee Cha pter 2: 'Mean i ngs of Meas uremen t a nd Ac counts of Accu racy', i n Gooda y, G J N, 20 04, The
Morals of Measu rement: Accuracy, Irony, and Trust in Late Victorian Electrical Practice (Cambr i dge: Ca mbri dge Uni vers ity
Press ).
11 . As of Septemb er 20 19, this obj ect i s descri bed i n the Sci ence M useum’s col lections da tabase as a r epl ica but i n fact ma y
be a recons truc tion , a s discus s ed in c orrespondence wi th John Li ffen. He also di rected me to: Denni son, Mark and Tony
Ha l l -Patch, ‘“Repl i ca” s team l ocomoti ves, wha t purpose do they s erve?’, i n (ed) Ja rvi s, Adr i an, Replicas as Research Tools,
papers presented at a Research Day Sch ool Merseysid e Maritime Museum 10 February 1 996 which expl ai ns the differenc e
between a repl ica, recons truction, reproduction, a nd repr es entati on.
12 . T/19 32-39 0 Sc i enc e Mus eum Technica l File for: W orki ng Replica of the Gaus s-W eber (1 833) electr omagneti c telegraph
appara tus. (Exhi bited a t the Fa rada y Centenary Exhi biti on, September 1 931)
13 . See Gi orgi , Giovanni, ‘Ra ti ona l Units of Electromagnetism’ [unpubli s hed MS with handwritten notes by O l i ver Heavi s ide].
URL: https ://www.i ec.ch/a bout/hi s tory/documents /doc uments _gi ova nni.htm
14 . T/19 14-89 7 Sc i enc e Mus eum Technica l File for: Glazed fra me, conta i ning ‘Deli nea tion of Li nes of Ma gnetic For ce by Iron
fil i ngs’ prepared by Michael Fa rada y
15 . T/19 15-36 3 Sc i enc e Mus eum Technica l File for: Hibbert s tanda rd o ne-volt cell and W i ki source contr i butors , ‘Author :
Walter Hibbert’, Wiki s ource, https://en.wiki s ource.org/w/i ndex.php?title=Author:Walter_Hibbert&ol did=7 310 085
(acces sed 1 September 201 9)
References
1. Bruton, E, 2 015, ‘Love on the W ire: The Roma nce of Tel egraphy’, i n Viewpoint: the Mag azine of the British Society for th e
Histo ry o f Science 106 (February), 1 1. URL: http://www.bshs .org.uk/ca tegory/viewpoi nt
2. Da niell, J F, ‘X. O n Vol ta i c Co mbina tions . In a letter addres sed to Mich a el Fara day, D. C. L., F. R. S., Ful lerian Prof. Chem.
Royal Ins titution, Corr. Memb. Royal & Imp. Ac a dd. of Sci ence, Paris, Peters burgh, &c. By J. Frederi c Da niell, F. R. S., Prof.
Chem. in Ki ng's Col lege, Lon don’, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Vol ume 12 6 (1 836 ), 10 7-124 http://d oi .org/10.1 098/rs tl .1836 .001 2
and Da niell , John Frederi c. ‘XI . Addi tional obs ervations on vol taic combina tion s . I n a l etter addres sed to Micha el
Fa rada y, D. C. L. F. R. S., Full erian P rof. Chem. Roya l I nstituti on, Corr. Memb. Roya l & Imp. Aca dd. of Sc i ence, P a ris,
Petersburgh, & c. By J. Fr ederi c Dani el l , F. R. S., Pr of. Chem. i n Ki ng's Co l l ege, London’, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Vol ume 126
(1836), 125–129. http://doi .or g/10 .109 8/rstl.18 36.0013
3. Engi neeri ng and Technol ogy History W iki (ETHW ): Dani ell Cell. URL: https ://ethw.or g/Da niell_Cel l
4. Fa hie, 18 37, A history of electric telegraphy, to the year 183 7, 216–217
5. Ha rman, P M, 200 1, The Natu ral Philoso phy of James Clerk Maxwell (Ca mbri dge: Ca mbri dge Uni vers ity P ress)
6. Liffen, J, 201 0, ‘The In troduction of the Electri c Tel egraph i n Britain, a Rea ppraisal of the Work of Cooke a nd
Whea ts tone’, International Jo urnal fo r the History of Engin eerin g & Technology, Vol . 80 No. 2 (Jul y), 268 –299
7. Ma ckenzie, A D, 195 3, The Bank of England Note: A Histo ry of Its Printing. Ca mbridge: CUP Arc hi ve, 98
8. Ma dsen, C L, 187 6, ‘Ha ns Chri sti a n Ørs ted’ memoi r’, in Jou rna l of the Society o f Telegraph Eng ineers, vol . 5, no. 15.16, 469-
47 3. doi : 10.1 049 /js te-1.18 76.0034
URL: http://i eeexpl ore.i eee.org/stamp/stamp.js p ?tp=&a rnumber=5299 938 &isnumber=5299 867
9. Mi lls, B, 19 95, 'Early batteri es for telegraph, telephone and other us es', i n Australasian Telepho ne Collectors Society
Newsletter (Ja nua ry 1995 a nd May 1995). URL: http://tel ephonecol l ecting.org/a rticl es/batteri es.html See a ls o: Crowther, J
G, 201 3, British Scientists of the Nineteenth Century (Abi ngdon: Routl edge)
10 . Ørsted, H C, 18 20, Experimenta circa effectu m conflictus electrici in acum magneticam. Typi s Schul tzia nis URL:
https://li br a ry.s i .edu/d i gi ta l -library/book/experi mentaci r c00ors t
11 . Ørsted, J C, 1 876 , ‘Experiments on the effect of electr i c a ction on the ma gnetic needle’, Jou rnal of the Society of Telegraph
Engineers, vol . 5, no. 15.1 6, 459 –469 . doi : 10.1049/jste-1.1 876 .003 3
12 . Repo rt of the Committee o n Sta ndards of Electrical Resistance. Thirty-fourth Meeting of the British Asso ciation for the
Ad vancemen t of Science (London: John Mur ray) 18 64, and Rep ort of the Committee on Standards o f Electrical Resistan ce.
Thirty-seventh Meetin g of the British A ssociation fo r the Advancement of Scien ce (London: John Murra y) 18 67. URLs :
https://www.bi odi vers i tylibra ry.or g/item/930 72 and https ://www.bi odiversityl i bra r y.org/i tem/9 3115
13 . ‘The El ectri cal Congres s’, The Electrician, 7 (24 September 1881), 2 97
14 . ‘The El ectro-Magneti c Telegraph of the Grea t Wes tern Railwa y’, The Times, 5 December 1 839 , p 6 col 4
Author information
Dr El i za beth Bruton is Curator of Tech nol ogy a nd Engi neeri ng at the Science Mu s eum, London. She wa s previous l y Heritage
Offi cer at Jodrel l Bank Di scovery Centre, Uni vers ity of Manc hester; Co-c ura tor / Res ea rcher for the Harry's Story: Henry Moseley,
a scientist lost to war HLF-funded pro ject and exhi bition at the Hi s tory of Scienc e Mus eum, Oxford, a nd; pos tdoctoral researc her
for A HRC-fun ded project Innova ting in Combat: Telecommunications and intellectu al property in th e First W orld War, Univers i ty of
Leeds . Her res earch i nteres ts i ncl ude museums, commu nica tions history, military history, el ectri cal hi story, gend er, Victorian
technologies, and s cienti fic i nsti tutions .
Elizabeth Bruton
Curator of Enginee ring and Technology
Contact t his author >
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
William Fothergill Cooke and Charles Wheatstone patented the first practical electric telegraph system in 1837. Demonstrations using multi-needle instruments were given to the Directors of the London and Birmingham Railway (L&BR) at Euston and Camden Town later in 1837 but the electric telegraph was not adopted by the L&BR at this time. In 1839 Cooke installed a demonstration line alongside the Great Western Railway (GWR) between London Paddington and West Drayton using four-needle instruments. Although trials were successful the telegraph line was afterwards little used by the GWR and was abandoned within a year or so. Precise details of the equipment used on these demonstrations have always been unclear, leading to ambiguity in the identification of surviving instruments preserved in the Science Museum, London, and elsewhere. Recent close examination of these along with a new interpretation of contemporary documents shows that the widely held belief that five-needle instruments were used on the 1839 GWR installation is incorrect. It is also argued that the small five-needle instrument displayed at the Science Museum, London, and two similar specimens held elsewhere, are not the original instruments demonstrated in 1837 but working models made for a patent infringement trial in 1850. Conversely another five-needle dial owned by King's College London and on loan to the Science Museum can now be identified as almost certainly one of the original 1837 instruments.
Rational Units of Electromagnetism' [unpublished MS with handwritten notes by Oliver Heaviside
  • See Giorgi
See Giorgi, Giovanni, 'Rational Units of Electromagnetism' [unpublished MS with handwritten notes by Oliver Heaviside]. URL: https://www.iec.ch/about/history/documents/documents_giovanni.htm
Love on the Wire: The Romance of Telegraphy', in Viewpoint: the Magazine of the British Society for the History of
  • E Bruton
Bruton, E, 2015, 'Love on the Wire: The Romance of Telegraphy', in Viewpoint: the Magazine of the British Society for the History of Science 106 (February), 11. URL: http://www.bshs.org.uk/category/viewpoint
A history of electric telegraphy, to the year 1837
  • Fahie
Fahie, 1837, A history of electric telegraphy, to the year 1837, 216-217
Hans Christian Ørsted' memoir
  • C Madsen
Madsen, C L, 1876, 'Hans Christian Ørsted' memoir', in Journal of the Society of Telegraph Engineers, vol. 5, no. 15.16, 469-473. doi: 10.1049/jste-1.1876.0034 URL: http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=5299938&isnumber=5299867
Early batteries for telegraph, telephone and other uses
  • B Mills
Mills, B, 1995, 'Early batteries for telegraph, telephone and other uses', in Australasian Telephone Collectors Society Newsletter (January 1995 and May 1995). URL: http://telephonecollecting.org/articles/batteries.html See also: Crowther, J G, 2013, British Scientists of the Nineteenth Century (Abingdon: Routledge)
Experimenta circa effectum conflictus electrici in acum magneticam
  • H Ørsted
Ørsted, H C, 1820, Experimenta circa effectum conflictus electrici in acum magneticam. Typis Schultzianis URL: https://library.si.edu/digital-library/book/experimentacirc00orst