ArticlePDF Available

ACHIEVING HAIR SALON COMPETITIVENESS THROUGH RELATIONSHIP MARKETING MODEL: A CASE OF HAIR SALONS IN THE FREE STATE PROVINCE IN SOUTH AFRICA

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This paper is based on research on growing competition within hair salons. The study found evidence of such competition and identified relationship marketing (RM) as a tool to support competitive strategy. Hair salons are regarded as emerging small, medium and micro enterprises (SMMEs)-a status achieved due to participation in competitive social-economic activities. This paper presents a RM model compatible with the requirements of emerging SMMEs. It is hoped that this model will promote hair salons' competitive strategy, thus contributing to South African socioeconomic mantra. There is a perceived lack of relationship marketing by SMMEs, particularly for emerging SMMEs like the hair salons. This perception amplifies the importance of strategic tools to support competitive strategy for successful competition. A survey data collection method was used to collect quantitative and qualitative data from 145 respondents, randomly selected owner/managers of hair salons and customers. These responses were supported with personal interviews to improve generalizability. The evidence of lack of awareness and the importance of RM activities was found. This finding supports the need for RM model presentation and hair salon competitiveness and emphasises the requirements for hair salons as emerging SMMEs.
Content may be subject to copyright.
ACHIEVING HAIR SALON COMPETITIVENESS THROUGH
RELATIONSHIP MARKETING MODEL: A CASE OF HAIR
SALONS IN THE FREE STATE PROVINCE IN SOUTH
AFRICA
Dr Francis Okyere
Department of Business and Management Development
National University of Lesotho
Dr Edmund Owusu Amoakoh
Department of Business Management
Central University of Technology, Free State Province, South Africa
Abstract
This paper is based on research on growing competition within hair salons. The study found
evidence of such competition and identified relationship marketing (RM) as a tool to support
competitive strategy. Hair salons are regarded as emerging small, medium and micro
enterprises (SMMEs) a status achieved due to participation in competitive social-economic
activities. This paper presents a RM model compatible with the requirements of emerging
SMMEs. It is hoped that this model will promote hair salons competitive strategy, thus
contributing to South African socio-economic mantra. There is a perceived lack of
relationship marketing by SMMEs, particularly for emerging SMMEs like the hair salons.
This perception amplifies the importance of strategic tools to support competitive strategy for
successful competition. A survey data collection method was used to collect quantitative and
qualitative data from 145 respondents, randomly selected owner/managers of hair salons and
customers. These responses were supported with personal interviews to improve
generalizability. The evidence of lack of awareness and the importance of RM activities was
found. This finding supports the need for RM model presentation and hair salon
competitiveness and emphasises the requirements for hair salons as emerging SMMEs.
Keywords: Relationship marketing, Competitiveness, Competitive strategy, Free State
Province, Relationship management, SMMEs
Introduction
The growing competition within hair salons in the Free State, a province of South Africa, has
necessitated the identification of relationship marketing (RM) as a tool to support competitive
strategy. Hair salons are seen to be emerging small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in the
province a status achieved due to participation in competitive socio.-economic activities.
Currently the problem of unemployment facing the youth and the low-cost start-ups has led to
the proliferation of hair salons, creating fierce completion among them. Thus, they are
uncompetitive, which has caused many of them to fold. Therefore, a RM model has been
suggested as a marketing strategy that should be used to build, develop, and maintain a
successful relational exchange for competitiveness (Po-Tsang Chen and Hsin-Hui Hu, 2010).
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
396
It can be assumed that with an increased consumer appetite for service quality and pressure of
increased profit and market share, hair salons would benefit from the application of RM to
build a customer base. This assumption relates to the domain of both RM strategies and the
services hair salons provide to achieve favourable interaction with customers. With
determination, the interactions should enable hair salons to engage, network, and collaborate
with customers for improved services.
Previous study by Che, Binti, and Jamil (2009) on RM suggests that the primary focus of
interaction is to understand customer preference, taste and lifestyle and use this
understanding to build closer relationships for competitiveness. The authors argue that to
achieve a sustained competitiveness, the quality of interaction with the understanding of
customer’s taste, preference and lifestyle is vital for customized service, customer attraction
and retention. This argument is supported and expanded by Cosic and Djuric (2010) who
include business development strategy through network-interaction concepts. In the context
of the hair salon industry the network-interaction concept is related to the achievement of a
RM strategy that is highly competitive. It is suggested that success of the model would be
realised by the utilization of relational exchange theory which is a source of business
partnerships; based on buyer-seller relationships (Kanagal, 2010).
Theoretical and conceptual frameworks
This study was underpinned by relational exchange theory, which relates to a long-term
relationship between the business and customers. According to Jham and Khan (2008),
building relationships requires customer satisfaction as a pre-requisite to meeting customers’
expectations. Khan (2012) also states that the continuity of the business relations between the
customer and the business is dependent on customer retention. Therefore, the study considers
customer satisfaction and retention as critical to relationship building between the customer
and the business.
Conceptually, it was assumed in this study that the application of RM components such as
trust/confidence, communication, responsiveness, tangibility, complaints handling and
empathy ((Deng, Wei and Zhang, 2010; Anabila, Narteh and Tweneboah-Kodua, 2012;
Rezvani et al., 2011; Kassim and Abdulla, 2010; Pournaserani, and Mousavian, 2011) serve
as independent variables and could lead to service quality, customer satisfaction and retention
as dependent variables for a business to achieve competitiveness and growth. This could
make RM theoretically appealing for hair salons.
METHODOLOGY
Research design
The research design was exploratory research. The study was exploratory because it
investigated how RM can be used and what impact it has on hair salon competitiveness,
which is a virgin area. The importance of hair salon competitiveness provided the rationale
for the development of the RM model. The exploratory design is selected for its quantitative
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
397
relevance to contextual interplay of data collection and analysis. It employs both descriptive
and quantitative research approaches
Population and sampling
The target population for this study were the owners and customers of the hair salons in the
Free State. With the population size of 550, a sample of 200 was considered adequate for this
study through a pilot study which was conducted to identify the salons suitable for this
specific study aimed at quality improvement effort and data reliability. A probability
sampling method was adopted for the following reasons: there was a large sample comprising
550 hair salons in the region, which allowed for representativeness; there was a need to
generalize the results of the study; and the population was well defined.
Data collection
A lack of suitable previous research on the subject necessitated the construction of a custom-
made questionnaire. A pilot study using 20 respondents was conducted in the Mangaung area
of Bloemfontein to improve readability and clarity of the questions. The questionnaires were
administered personally. Thirty eight itemized Likert-type questions were used to collect the
primary data for analysis. According to Cooper and Schindler (2011), Likert-type scales
consist of statements that express either a favourable or an unfavourable (agree or disagree)
attitude toward the object of interest. Thirty eight itemized questions were used to prevent the
respondents from guessing about a choice. They needed to indicate specifically the type of
information that was required by the researcher. The structured questionnaire was made up of
two sections, the first one dealing with the drivers for service quality, customer satisfaction,
and retention, and the second requiring the respondents to answer questions on the elements
of RM practices such as confidence/trust, communication, responsiveness, tangibility,
empathy, and complaints handling.
Data analysis
Data collected was analysed using the SPSS statistical computer software package proven to
produce reliable inferential and descriptive statistics. The data was statistically analysed using
frequency counts and percentages. Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient statistic for reliability
analysis, correlation and regression models was also used for relationships.
Credibility and reliability of constructs
The Cronbach’s Alpha statistic is the main tool used to measure reliability of the various
constructs in the study. Cronbach’s Alpha co-efficient of around 0.70 is deemed acceptable
for internal consistency of a measuring instrument (Lai et al., 2010; Field 2012; Khan et al.,
2012).
LITERATURE REVIEW
This literature review discusses the main concepts on which this study focused, namely RM
and its elements and the dependent variables.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
398
Relationship marketing defined
According to Gilaninia, Danish, and Shahmohammadi (2012), RM is a strategy to attract,
retain, and promote customer relations, while Cosic and Djuric (2010) define RM as
paradigm change, which shifts the focus of business from transaction to relationship.
Alrubaiee and Al-Nazer (2010) state that RM involves the directing of all marketing activities
toward building loyalty (keeping and winning customers) by providing value to all the parties
involved in relational exchanges. These authors further maintain that the main theme in
customer RM is to acquire and retain customers.
Kanagal (2009) describes RM as the identification, establishment, maintenance,
enhancement, modification and termination of relationships with customers to create value
for customers and profit for the organisation through a series of relational exchanges that
have both a history and a future. According to Alqahtani (2011), RM is seen as a core
business activity directed towards setting up, improving, and maintaining successful
relational exchanges with customers, suppliers and even other businesses.
Implicit in the above definitions is that RM involves activities aimed at developing long-term
cost-effective links between an organization and its customers for their mutual benefit.
Organizations can maintain and enhance relationships by treating customers fairly and
offering. better service. For the service provider, a valued relationship is one that is
financially profitable in the long term.
Conceptualisation of the independent variables
Trust
Trust is viewed as an essential ingredient and a mainstay of a successful relationship (Jiun-
Sheng Chris Lin & Chung-Yuen, Wu, 2011). Sohail (2012) argues that trust is the willingness
to rely on an exchange partner in whom one has confidence, and this builds relationships.
Complaints handling
According to Komunda, Kibeera, Munyoku and Byyarugaba (2015), customers’ complaints
are the responses triggered by perceived dissatisfaction due to inadequate integrity,
reliability, responsiveness and functionality. Therefore, complaints management must be one
of the marketing tools used to bring two parties together to foster relationships.
Communication
Anabila, Nartey and Tweneboah-Kodua (2012) argue that communication has a positive
effect on customer acquisition and retention, and that the frequency of communication
between parties indicates the strength of the relationship, which has a positive effect on
customer loyalty.
Responsiveness
In their study, of Ladhari, Ladhari and Morales (2011) refer to responsiveness as the
willingness to help customers and provide prompt service. Thus, understanding customer
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
399
requirements and developing the service based on responsive feedback enhances service
satisfaction and relationship building.
Tangibility
According to Jaya and Manhalingam (2011), tangibles of services are the equipment, signage,
appearance of employees and man-made physical environment surrounding the service,
which are commonly known as the servicescape the aesthetic and visual appeal of the
business in the eyes of the customer. The visuals benefit the business by providing what the
customers need in the form of service quality and satisfaction.
Empathy
Kassim and Abdullah (2010) argue that empathy is the service dimension that focuses on
individualised attention or care, easy access, good communication and customer
understanding which leads to relationship building.
Conceptualisation of service quality, customer satisfaction and customer retention and
their influence on relationship marketing
Service quality
Service quality is seen as having an impact on customer satisfaction, customer loyalty,
profitability and business performance (Santouridis & Trivellas, 2010). Thus, it leads to
customer retention and effective RM.
Customer satisfaction
According to Ganiyu, Uche and Adeoti (2012), customer satisfaction is the heart of
marketing. These authors contend that it is an antecedent to customer loyalty and retention
which mediate between RM and business competitiveness and growth.
Customer retention
Khan (2012) defines customer retention as the continuity of the business relations between
the customer and the business. Satisfying customers in order to retain them results in
customer retention (Jawaria, Immran, Khashif, Ayse, Nadeem and Hassan, 2010).Customer
retention is similar to satisfaction in that they are the most important indicators of customer
satisfaction: the more satisfied customers are, the greater their retention, and the greater the
RM.
GAPS IN THE EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS
Table 1 shows the overall varieties of gaps in the empirical analysis. These gaps relate to RM
elements not fully practised in the salons operations, namely trust/confidence, handling of
complaints, communication, responsiveness and empathy. These gaps were used to develop
the RM model presented in Figure 1.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
400
Table 1: Gaps in the empirical evidence
Assumed practice of elements of
relationship marketing in salons
(100%)
Empirical evidence of practice of
the elements of relationship
marketing in salons (average %)
Trust
85.7%
Handling of complaints/queries
82.04%
Communication
67.4%
Responsiveness
90.3%
Empathy
66%
Explanations of the gaps
Trust
As can be seen in Table 1, about 14.3% of the salons do not consider and do not show trust
towards their customers. It means some owners of the salons do not demonstrate high levels
of integrity such as consistency, honesty, fairness, helpfulness and responsibility which go
with trust within the business. Thus, the absence of these aspects may reduce the level of
commitment in a relationship between the salon and the customers. This is consistent with
Sohail’s view (2012) that trust is higher among buyers who believe they receive more value
from a relationship, and that it is another important determinant of customer loyalty.
Therefore, the absence of trust within some of the salons is a crucial concern to be addressed
if they want to win more customers.
Handling of complaints or queries
Customers’ complaints are usually related to their queries or problems and if they are
satisfactorily resolved, the customer’s loyalty towards the organisation is enhanced. It follows
that poorly managed queries in the salon business as in any other organisation would
interfere with relationships. A 17.6% gap for this marketing practice means a great loss of
customers to those salons; therefore, complaints handling is a huge investment in time,
productivity gains and relationship building for a business.
Communication
Another gap emanates from ineffective communication systems among the salons. It seems,
for any particular organisation to be known and heard by its customers, it should consistently
communicate with its customers rather than only produce and price its products. As shown in
Table 1, 32.6% of the salons do not practise this element of RM or they may find it difficult
to inform, remind, persuade and differentiate offerings from competitors. Anabila, Narteh,
and Tweneboah-Kodua (2012) argue that communication has a positive effect on customer
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
401
acquisition and retention, and that the frequency of communication among the parties
indicates the strength of the relationship marketing.
Responsiveness
Also included among the gaps is responsiveness as an element of RM which is not well
adhered to by some of the hair salons. It denotes speed and timeliness of service delivery.
Table 1 shows that 9.7% of the salons do not practise this element as a driver for customer
satisfaction and retention and for that matter, RM. This suggests that these salons have a
negative attitude towards this relationship element. Kassim and Abdulla (2010) allude to this
aspect and describe responsiveness as a company’s ability and willingness to provide prompt
service when customers have questions or problems. Thus, understanding customer
requirements and developing the service based on responsive feedback enhances service
satisfaction, loyalty and relationship building.
Empathy
Empathy as an element of RM is another driver for building the customer-provider
relationship. It reflects personal attention, preferences, understanding and caring of the
customer. Empathy pre-supposes that owners of businesses are expected to implement
customer-oriented strategies whereby businesses must show sincere interest in solving
clients’ problems and requirements. Table 1 shows that 34% of the salons do not practise
empathy within their businesses. This means that these salons do not personalise services and
generally do not demonstrate caring behaviour in all of their interpersonal dealings with
customers these represent a gap in the literature to be addressed.
Therefore, the issue that stands out from all these gaps is that there is a critical need to
address them if RM can succeed within the hair salons.
THE RELATIONSHIP MARKETING MODEL
The graphical representation of the RM model presented in Figure 1 here is based on the
conclusion derived from the gaps in the empirical data analysis (see Table 1). It is hoped that
this framework will support and promote RM success in small businesses, particularly hair
salons, through the application of RM elements identified to be effective in influencing
service quality, customer retention, and satisfaction.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
402
Figure 1: Proposed relationship marketing model for hair salons
Discussion of the relationship marketing model
The key variables of the model were extracted from some of the gaps found in the empirical
analysis which are: trust/commitment, communication, handling of complaints/queries,
responsiveness, and empathy as independent variables. The mediating variables are customer
satisfaction, service quality and customer retention. It is assumed that if these gaps or
perceptions are addressed and the business addresses them, it would be able to provide
quality service, customer satisfaction, and retention, which would ultimately lead to
competitiveness, profit/market share, and relationship building.
Application of the relationship marketing model
The model can be used to influence customer perceptions that have to do with the way in
which customers view and react to the products and services that are available to them
especially when the product or service is a novelty. The management strategies in the model
could be applied to the operations of marketers. For example, marketers in their campaigns to
get customers’ attention by convincing them to purchase a specific product or service use
marketing communication strategy. The purpose of this model is to ensure that management
functions are aligned with service quality strategies, cutting across the marketing activities,
determining customer satisfaction and retention of the adoption process. It supports the
challenges that management of the hair salons face that have become imperative with the
increase of, for example, new demands of customers for service quality, current fashionable
hairstyles and even current hair chemicals within the industry context.
With increased competition, changes in customers’ taste for current hairstyles and lifestyles
in the context of hair salons, this model can be used to communicate differentiated features of
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
403
services and products offerings. By so doing, hair salons’ competitive abilities would benefit
from the application of the model.
Application of the model to relationship management
Since the customer is the central block of RM building, one of the benefits of the model is the
fostering of long-term customer relationships. It is noteworthy that long-term customer
relationships build mutual rewards that benefit both the firm and the customer, while the
organization can also gain quality sources of marketing intelligence for better planning of the
marketing strategies (Jesri et al., 2013:56). In addition, this RM model allows flexible access
and interaction of a business with customers as opposed to traditional marketing practices
where customers were passive partners.
The model can be used to encourage hair salon businesses to develop a competitive plan by
fostering intense, difficult-to-duplicate marketing relationships with customers, employees
and even competitors as partners. For example, this could be done by the management
developing special treatment such as extra services, special prices, coupons, free hair
products and higher priority over other customers, or providing fast and flexible salon
services or product information to customers.
The model assumes that the management steps up the marketing management process to
manage all the marketing activities with commitment, trust, empathy and responsiveness.
Management’s commitment is essential in promoting the concept of customer relationship
management within and outside of the business. It is necessary to institute frequent changes
in marketing activities and introduce support structures such as trained staff that are required
to make the model a success because RM is a partnership in nature.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Response rate
The questionnaires were administered to a sample of 200 hair salons out of which 145 were
completed and returned. This represents a response rate of 72.5%. All the returned
questionnaires were correctly completed.
PERCEIVED RELATIONSHIP MARKETING AWARENESS AND PRACTICES
An overall measure of perceived awareness and elements of RM practices were calculated,
using frequency distribution and percentages.
The information in Table 2 shows the average percentages of the items of the questions under
each construct as summaries.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
404
2: Summary of the statistics of the perceived RM awareness and practices
Constructs
No. of
Respondents
No. of items
Agree
/strongly
agree
Average %
Comments:
Perceived
relationship
marketing
practice
Awareness of
relationship
marketing
145
5
63.7
Not very much
Service quality
145
7
97.0
Practice
Customer
satisfaction
145
6
94.4
Practice
Customer retention
145
4
88.4
Practice
Confidence/trust
145
4
85.7
Practice
Complaints
handling
145
5
82.04
Practice
Communication
145
4
67.4
Not very much
Responsiveness
145
3
90.3
Practice
Tangibility
145
3
90.6
Practice
Empathy
145
2
66.2
Not very much
All 10
constructs
43
CONCLUSIONS
The conclusions that follow are based on the literature review and the empirical findings. It
was found that some of the salons needed to address certain gaps in practising some of the
RM variables. The majority of the respondents strongly agreed that it is very good to practise
the elements of the RM in the salons. Therefore, these findings support the need for an RM
model for hair salon competitiveness and growth.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
405
RECOMMENDATIONS
Formalization of the hair salon industry
The study revealed that most of the hair salons in the industry are not formalized and not
registered. Efforts must be made by the Free State government, in partnership with small-
business-oriented NGOs to formalize these informal hair salons into economically viable
ventures by registering them to be sustainable commercial industry. The financial implication
for the formalization would make them get provincial guarantees enabling them to access
financial credit facilities from the banks and other financial institutions. With this financial
back-up, hair salons would be able to finance any marketing practices such as RM
management, which may be costly to undertake.
Development of hair salon academies
The study shows that already hair salon academies are spreading across in some major cities
of the country illustrating the importance, financial, job creation, and self-employment
potential of the business, which seems to be limited in the Free State. It is suggested that such
training centres be established in the various cities of the province. There must be a
curriculum blend of both hair care and marketing practices such as RM and other business
skills to stimulate growth in this market. In order to boost its potential for novelty and
growth, and in collaboration with the Skills Education and Training Authority (SETA), such
academies could be accredited. This step would draw more unemployed into the industry to
make it of value.
Development of skills training
It is recommended that basic training in business management and entrepreneurship be
incorporated in the academies mentioned earlier to assist salon owners to overcome skills
shortages. The aim is to prepare the students to run their own businesses with the knowledge
gained. The local municipalities and private collaborators could practise capacity training by
setting up development and training programmes for salon operators. In these programmes,
areas such as marketing management, marketing practices, simple financial management,
marketing research, and more importantly the knowledge of RM could be included, so that
the operators of these salons would gain mastery of RM management to enhance customer
relationships
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH
The results of this empirical research necessitate further research on the following pertinent
issues:
Whether the findings of this study are applicable to other parts of South Africa by
replicating this research on a larger scale, preferably nation-wide;
Why RM is not practised by some hair salons to any appreciable extent in the Free
State province;
To validate the findings of this study to suggest that the RM framework influences
hair salon competitiveness, performance, and growth.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
406
References
Alqahtani, A.Y (2011). Toward a clarification of the concept of relationship marketing.
International Journal of Management, 28(2) 585-590.
Alrubaiee, L. and Al-Nazer, N. (2010). Investigate the impact of relationship marketing
orientation on customer loyalty: the customer’s perspective. International Journal of
Marketing Studies, 2(1) 155-174.
Anabila, P., Narteh, B., and Tweneboah-Kodua, E.Y. (2012). Relationship marketing
practices and customer loyalty: evidence from the banking industry in Ghana. European
Journal of Business and Management, 4(13) 51-61.
Chattananon, A. and Trimestsoontorn, J. (2009). The link between export relationship
quality, performance and expectations. International Journal of Emerging Markets. 4(3)
252-273.
Che, A.B., Che, W. and Jamil, B. (2009). Determining relationship marketing instruments.
IUP Journal of Marketing Management, 8(3/4) 25-42.
Cosic, M. and Djuric, M. D. (2010). Relationship marketing in the tourist service sector.
UTMS Journal of Economics, 1(1) 53-61.
Deng, Z., Lu, Y., Wei, K.K. and Zang, J. (2009). Understanding customer satisfaction and
loyalty: An empirical study of mobile instant messages in China. International Journal
of Information Management, 3 (2) 289-300.
Ganiyu, R.A., Uche, I. I. and Adeoti, O.E. (2012). Is customer satisfaction an indicator of
customer loyalty? Australian Journal of Business and Management Research, 2(7) 14-
20.
Gilaninia, S., Danesh, S.Y.S., and Shahmohammadi, M. (2012). Examination of the
relationship between relationship marketing and customer satisfaction. Journal of Basic
and Applied Scientific Research, 2(10) 10721-10725.
Gilaninia, S., Almani, A.M., Pournaserani, A. and Mousavian, S.J. (2011). Relationship
marketing: a new approach to marketing in the third millennium. Australian Journal of
Basic and Applied Sciences, 5(5) 787-799.
Gilaninia, S.G. and Ghashlagh, B.G. (2012). Relationship marketing system and its impact on
customer buying behaviour. Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences Research, 2(3) 2473-
2480.
Hinson, R.E. and Mahmoud, M.A. (2011). Qualitative insight into market orientation in small
Ghanaian businesses. International Journal of Marketing Studies, 3(1) 35-44.
Islam, M.A., Khan, M.A., Obadullah, A.Z.M. and Alam, M.S. (2011). Effect of entrepreneur
and firm characteristics on the business success of small and medium enterprises in
Bangladesh. International Journal of Business and Management, 6(3) 289-299.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
407
Jawaria, F.A., Imran, A., Kashif ur R., Ayse, K.Y., Nadeem, S. and Hasan, A. (2010).
Determinants of consumer retention in cellular industry of Pakistan. African Journal of
Business Management, 4(12) 2404-2408.
Jaya, S. and Mahalingam, S. (2011). Service quality models in banking: A review.
International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 4(1) 83-
103.
Jesri, P., Ahmadi, F. and Fatehipoor, M. (2013). Effects of relationship marketing on
customer loyalty (Case Study: Mehr Bank. Kermanshah Province, Iran).
Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in Business, 4(11) 304-312.
Jham, V. and Khan, K.M. (2008). Determinants of performance in retail banking:
perspectives of customer satisfaction and relationship marketing. Singapore
Management Review, 30(2) 35-44.
Jiun-Sheng Chris, L, and Chung-Yueh, W. (2011). The role of expected future use in
relationship-based service retention. Managing service quality, 21(5) 535-551
Kanagal, N. (2009). Role of relationship marketing in competitive marketing strategy.
Journal of Management and Marketing Research, 2, 1054-1068.
Kassim, N. and Abdullah, N.A. (2010). The effect of perceived service quality dimension on
customer satisfaction, trust, and loyalty in e-commerce settings: A cross-cultural
analysis. Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, 22(3) 351-371.
Khan, I. (2012). Impact of customer satisfaction and customer retention on customer loyalty.
International Journal of Scientific and Technology Research, 1(2) 106-110.
Komunda, B., Kibeera, F., Munyoki, J. and Byarugaba, J. (2015). Improving customer
complaining behaviour for loyalty in the services sector: A case of mobile telephone
companies in Uganda. African Journal of Business Management, 9(12) 521-530.
Ladhari, R., Ladhari, I. and Morales, M. (2011). Bank service quality: comparing Canadian
and Tunisian customer perceptions. The International Journal of Bank Marketing, 29(3)
224-246.
Po-Tsang, C. and Hsin-Hui, H. (2010). The effect of relational benefits on perceived value in
relation to customer loyalty: An empirical study in the Australian coffee outlets industry.
International Journal of Hospitality Management, 29, 405-412.
Rezvani, M., Gilaninia, S. and Mousavian, S.J. (2011). The effect of relationship marketing
dimensions by customer satisfaction to customer loyalty. Australian Journal of Basic
and Applied Sciences, 5(9) 1547-1553.
Santouridis, I. and Trivellas, P. (2010). Investigating the impact of service quality and
customer satisfaction on customer loyalty in mobile telephony in Greece. TQM Journal,
22(3) 330-343.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
408
Sohail, M.S. (2012). The antecedents of relationship marketing and customer loyalty: a
conceptual framework to determine outcomes. 2012 International Conference on
Economics, Business Innovation; IPEDR, 38, 238-240, Singapore.
Yuen, E.F.T. and Chan, S.S.L (2010). The effect of retail service quality and product quality
on customer loyalty. Journal of database Marketing and Customer Strategy
Management, 17(3-4) 222-240
Zahedirad, R. and Shivaraj, B. (2011). Supply chain: barriers and benefits Indian SMEs.
Journal of Indian Management, 8(6) 11-22.
IJRDO - Journal of Business management
ISSN: 2455-6661
Volume-5 | Issue-9 | September, 2019
409
... The health and beauty practitioners (HBP) involved in beauty industries are cosmetologists, aestheticians, beauticians, or hairdressers [2]. Typically, the beauty treatments in these beauty centers are more focused on In particular, there are several past researchers [9], [19], [34]- [37] found that the competency level of communication skills among the cosmetology students is still at a lower level. Among the factors that cause they have lack of communication skills in the workplace is their weakness in mastering the basic knowledge or theory in cosmetology field [35] and incompetency to transfer the learned theories into a practical form [9]. Whereas, the skills of transferring theory into the practical form will indirectly help in increasing the level of self-confidence among the cosmetologists to communicate with their clients better [38]- [40]. ...
... The cosmetology students should have high self-confidence to communicate with the customers as they need to provide quality beauty treatment and consultation services to customers [13], [65]. For the less confident cosmetology students, they will negatively impact the customers, such as making the customers feel insecure and dissatisfied with the beauty treatment services provided [34]. The customer's confidence in the abilities and capabilities of the cosmetology students when providing quality consultation indirectly encourages the customers to convey positive information from word-of-mouth communication [66]. ...
... The cosmetology students need to have high self-confidence as they need to provide quality beauty treatment and consultation services to the customers [13], [65]. Those who are not confident in providing consultation to the customers will be unconfident and dissatisfied with the services offered [34]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The quality of beauty treatment services will be evaluated by the clients subjectively whether they are satisfied or otherwise with the services provided. However, the reports and complaints related to customer dissatisfaction when receiving beauty treatment services at beauty centers are increasing. Unfortunately, the suggestions for improvement from the previous studies are still insufficient. Therefore, this study was conducted to examine the importance of proficiency in communication skills and the need for training modules in the teaching and learning process (T&L). It is required to improve communication skills among cosmetology students for Upper Secondary Vocational Education Program (USVEP) in beauty arts course. The data were collected through the interview method on six USVEP teachers and a beauty salon entrepreneur. The findings of the study found that the proficiency in communication skills among the cosmetology students is an important requirement for employers in selecting their employees, increasing customer loyalty and the customer's frequency to visit beauty salons, and maintaining the excellent performance of cosmetology students in the workplace. In addition, there is also a high demand for the development of communication skills training modules in helping cosmetology students to constantly updated with new knowledge and skills needed from time to time. Therefore, adequate training is required to improve the competency in communication skills among the cosmetology students.
Article
Full-text available
The present competitive landscape in Ghana's banking industry has accentuated the need for effective management of relationships as a customer retention strategy. The objective of this study is to explore the relationship between Relationship Marketing (RM) and customer loyalty in Ghana's banking industry. In order to achieve the objective of the study, data was collected using questionnaires from 247 relationship marketing staff of universal banks in Ghana. Reliability test and multiple regression analysis were carried out using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS). The study found that the six RM constructs cumulatively had significant positive effect on customer loyalty. Individually, competence, commitment and communication were found to be significant drivers of customer loyalty. The study recommends that banks desirous of achieving customer loyalty and retention should consider RM as a strategy since it effective practice leads to customer loyalty. In addition, top management must demonstrate genuine commitment and active involvement in relationship marketing issues.
Article
Full-text available
Cellular industry of Pakistan has grown many folds in recent years. Many new entrants have also joined the market to reap the potentials of this growing industry. This situation has originated a hyper competition among major cellular service providers in Pakistan. Companies are working hard to introduce more innovative and eye-catching products to attract customers. The companies with large consumer base are striving to reduce their switching costs. However the main concerns of the cellular service providers is to retain the existing customers. This research is designed to find out the determinants of consumer retention in cellular industry of Pakistan. This is an exploratory study based on primary data which was collected from University students of Pakistan. The study found user friendliness, price reasonability and call clarity as strongest determinants of consumer retention in cellular industry of Pakistan. Although the findings of this study are specific to cellular industry in Pakistan, these may be generalized to any other market passing through transitional phase of rapid growth and characterized by low paying capacity of customers.
Article
Customer satisfaction and loyalty is a well known and established concept in several areas like marketing, consumer research, economic psychology, welfare-economics, and economics. And has long been a topic of high interest in both academia and practice. The aim of the study was to investigate whether customer satisfaction is an indicator of customer loyalty. The findings of the study supported the contention that strong relationship exist between customer satisfaction and loyalty. However, customer satisfaction alone cannot achieve the objective of creating a loyal customer base. Some researchers also argued, that customer satisfaction and loyalty are not directly correlated, particularly in competitive business environments because there is a big difference between satisfaction, which is a passive customer condition, and loyalty, which is an active or proactive relationship with the organization.
Article
According to private banks activation and markets fragmentation' communications and information development at the international level and customers being more informed and expert' today customers absorption and maintenance in banking industry has been complicated by many degrees and only those banks whose activities main pivot is customer absorption and maintenance benefit from a good position in competition arena. In such situation this question is raised whether using relational marketing in country banking industry can influence customers' loyalty through customers' satisfaction. The aim of this research is examination of stronger dimensions of relational marketing upon insurance customers' loyalty' which is considered on the basis of a model offered by Doisy including reliance' commitment' communications ' and confliction control. Current research is of causative type and research statistical assembly includes total customers of Ardabil province bank branches. Questionnaire gathered data were examined by using LISREL software in structural equation modeling style and all of the assumptions were confirmed.
Article
Satisfaction with banking services is an area of growing interest to researchers and managers. Building on the synthesis of existing literature on satisfaction and relationship marketing, this study explores the satisfaction variables within the banking industry. The key findings of an empirical research are based on the data collected from 555 customers. Systematic methodology, including design and validation of questionnaire, factor analysis and regression analysis were utilised to enhance reliability of the findings. The study reinforces that customer satisfaction is linked with performance of the banks. The authors demonstrate how adaptation of satisfaction variables can lead to better performance.
Article
Because of strong competition, fragmentation of markets, short life cycles of products and increasing customer awareness and complexity, the necessity of relationship marketing approach is felt more than ever. Relationship marketing involves creating, maintaining, and enhancing strong relationships with customers and other stakeholders. A relationship orientation implies that the focus of marketing is on retaining customers by maintaining and strengthening win-win relationships over time. Relationship marketing is more about maintaining existing customers than to attract new customers and it is just in contrast to the transactional marketing. This article first describes the concept of relationship marketing and views it from two American and European perspective. The reason for emergence of relationship marketing and its historical roots is presented and finally the most important relationship marketing models which are presented by various experts has been analyzed. Organizations and companies, using relationship marketing approach can gain competitive advantages and increase customer satisfaction and loyalty. Since customer retention, loyalty and satisfaction are crucial to survive business, so today using an approach that better achieves these goals is highly regarded. Relationship marketing as a new approach has proven in theory and practice that it is one of the most successful approaches.
Article
Purpose Customer uncertainty of future contacts with the service provider creates a wide range of expectations of the relationship. Such variation and effective management of customer expectations have been not been well studied. The purpose of this research is to investigate the role of customers' expected future use in relationship based customer retention for continuously provided services, proposing and testing an empirical model that explores the interconnectedness of relationship quality, expected future use and customer retention. Design/methodology/approach A theoretical framework is developed to suggest the role of expected future use in relationship‐based retention. Extant research from various academic fields, including marketing and psychology, is reviewed, deriving our hypotheses. Data collected from customers of a health club is examined through structural equation modeling (SEM). Findings The study supports the assertion that that the effect of relationship quality (trust, commitment, and satisfaction) on service retention is mediated by customers' expected future use. Results show that relationship quality (satisfaction, trust and commitment) is related to expected future use and retention, while expected future is also related to retention. Research limitations/implications This study represents an early attempt at exploring the role of customer's anticipation of future use in service retention. Future research is discussed, with an emphasis on developing additional indicators of relationship quality and future expectation related variables. Practical implications Service firms can increase retention through enhancing relationship quality and expected future use. Customers' expected future use plays an important role in service retention, and represents a valuable marketing opportunity in customer relationship management. Marketing managers will find it beneficial to integrate expected future use into marketing communication, retention‐based marketing, and other marketing interactions. Originality/value This research represents one of the first studies in service retention literature by empirically examining the role of expected future use in relationship‐based retention. Existing theories of relationship quality may also be improved with such an inclusion of customer psychological mechanism. The model provides insights into the effects of customer's expectations of future usage on customer intentions beyond traditional relationship marketing models.
Article
With the rapid development of mobile technology and large usage rates of mobile phones, mobile instant message (MIM) services have been widely adopted in China. Although previous studies on the adoption of mobile services are quite extensive, few focus on customer satisfaction and loyalty to MIM in China. In this study, we examine the determinants of customer satisfaction and loyalty. The findings confirm that trust, perceived service quality, perceived customer value, including functional value and emotional value, contribute to generating customer satisfaction with MIM. The results also show that trust, customer satisfaction and switching cost directly enhance customer loyalty. Additionally, this study finds that age, gender, and usage time have moderating effects. Finally, implications for the marketing of MIM are discussed.