Conference PaperPDF Available

Game-based learning - a long history

  • Mid Sweden University, Östersund, Sweden


Several studies on Game-based learning (GBL) start out in the era of Tetris and PacMan and are limited to digital learning games. However, the GBL concept has a long prehistory with board games like Kalaha, Xiangxi, Chess and other forms of game having been used for thousands of years in educational contexts, training strategic and tactical thinking, as well as language skills, mathematics and other subjects. Games and play-based learning were well-known didactic ideas in ancient Greece and during the Roman Empire. The oldest African board games were built more than 5000 years ago. The aim of this study is to analyse and discuss ideas on the role of games in education from a historical perspective. A literature study was carried out with a focus on the intellectual history of educational theory, followed by discussions of a number of key texts. Authors have analysed the changing conceptions of play and games in the context of the philosophy of education. Findings indicate that the view of games and game-based learning varies between the studied époques. However, the idea of complementing theoretic and abstract education with concrete and motivating play seems to have a constant value. A concept that for several reasons can be even more important in contemporary, technology enhanced mass education.
Game-based learning - a long history
Andreas Hellerstedt and Peter Mozelius
Stockholm University and Mid Sweden University, Sweden
Several studies on Game-based learning (GBL) start out in the era of Tetris and PacMan and
are limited to digital learning games. However, the GBL concept has a long pre-history with
board games like Kalaha, Xiangxi, Chess and other forms of game having been used for
thousands of years in educational contexts, training strategic and tactical thinking, as well as
language skills, mathematics and other subjects. Games and play-based learning were well-
known didactic ideas in ancient Greece and during the Roman Empire. The oldest African
board games were built more than 5000 years ago.
The aim of this study is to analyse and discuss ideas on the role of games in education from a
historical perspective. A literature study was carried out with a focus on the intellectual history
of educational theory, followed by discussions of a number of key texts. Authors have analysed
the changing conceptions of play and games in the context of the philosophy of education.
Findings indicate that the view of games and game-based learning varies between the studied
époques. However, the idea of complementing theoretic and abstract education with
concrete and motivating play seems to have a constant value. A concept that for several
reasons can be even more important in contemporary, technology enhanced mass education.
Keywords: Game-based learning, GBL, Play-based learning, The history of GBL, Spieltrieb
1. Introduction and aim
The use of play and games in educational contexts goes way back in history, with mathematic,
combinatory skills and logic taught and trained with board games such as Chess and Mancala.
Chess has Asian roots and has been played in various forma for thousands of years and the
African board game Kalaha was played in Egypt as early as in the era between 1500 1150
B.C. (Barnes, 1975). Human general play is even older, and probably older than human culture,
and as described by the Dutch cultural theorist Johan Huizinga: "We can safely assert, even,
that human civilization has added no essential feature to the general idea of play" (Huizinga,
2016, p 1.).
The aim of this study is to analyse and discuss ideas on the role of games in education from a
historical perspective. Main research questions to answer are:
1. How were games understood to contribute to learning in the ancient world, the
Renaissance, and in the modern period?
2. What role did games play in the educational ideas of the thinkers in question?
3. Did they consider games/play to have a complementary function to learning or did they
wish games to be an integral part of the educational process?
4. What factors prevented the widespread acceptance of games in learning before the modern
5. How did the concept of game/play (ludus, paidiá) in educational contexts develop over
2. Method
The study was carried out as a central and comparative literature study. Central in the aspect
of reviewing a body of literature central to the chosen topic, and comparative in the aspect
that texts describing GBL concepts from ancient eras have been compared to contemporary
ideas. Historical texts were studied using a contextual method, viewing the older works as
moves in an argument. Attention was also paid to historical shifts in the meaning of concepts
(using methods of Begriffsgeschichte or the ‘History of Concepts’).
3. Findings and discussions
The comparison revealed interesting patterns, themes and similarities, but also important
differences and long-term changes. GBL is older than the use of dice in games, and while
hazard games and gambling often have been condemned and moralised upon, GBL concepts
have had a high status throughout history. There are several examples of how games have
been used to educate princes, military officers and politicians. Furthermore, the ancient
peripatetic idea of playing in outdoor environments seems to be experiencing a renaissance
today, with the popularity of location-based games.
Aristotle’s Politics (1337b-1338a) presents play (paidiá) as a form of relaxation or rest from
more serious study or work. As such, Aristotle considered its value to be instrumental at best.
Plato’s Laws (643B-C) proposes a more constructive role for play in education. Plato viewed
the linguistically related concepts of paidiá and paideía (education, Bildung) as fundamentally
distinct, and his view resembles Aristotle’s in this respect. However, Plato still considered play
to be necessary for education, as he saw it as a first step on a ladder towards true knowledge.
In the Renaissance, educators such as Vittorino da Feltre re-introduced the idea that
games/play could have a role in education. Vittorino was consciously following Plato,
referencing the latter’s discussion in the Laws. However, he also specifically attributed the
idea of using games in the teaching of mathematics to the ancient Egyptians (Goeing, 2014),
probably a reference to a Mancala game.
In the 17th century, John Amos Comenius presented a systematic theory of education, in which
he viewed the game (ludus) to be the ideal form of learning. He presents his comprehensive
theory of ludus in Schola Ludus (Comenius, 1654). This work is a preface to a work on language
education through dramatization, but the theory is not specific to that form, but a universal
ludology. It was revolutionary in the way it proposed games/play to be fully integrated with
the learning process: the fun and the serious” should go hand in hand. A testament to the
Renaissance idea of the dignity and liberty of man, Comenius’s work is full of optimism and
foreshadows many modern contributions in discussing the relationships between spontaneity
and rules, cooperation and competition, and many other issues (Hellerstedt & Mozelius,
a strong earlier influence is the book Homo Ludens, published in 1938 by the Dutch cultural
theorist Johan Huizinga. One of Huizinga's main ideas is the one of human beings' fundamental
need of playing and that play is a fundamental human right (Huizinga, 2016).
In the 20th century game-based learning was introduced as a pedagogical approach at
university level in the 1970s by Jean Piaget (1973) and Lev Vygotsky (1978). Piaget was also
the pedagogue that created a new audience for Comenius’s game-based ideas (Piaget, 1966).
Later in the 1980s the idea of using games in educational contexts got a renaissance when
after Mark Lepper (1975) and Thomas Malone (1981) first separately presented their analyses
of why computer games are engaging and stimulate intrinsic motivation. Their common
findings of games stimulating intrinsic motivation was later conceptualised as the taxonomy
of intrinsic motivation (Malone & Lepper, 1987). One of several links between Comenius’s
didactics and Lepper and Malone’s ideas on intrinsic motivation is the American pedagogue
and philosopher John Dewey. Comenius and Dewey both questioned the overuse of root
learning, and advocated the idea of learning by activities outside the classroom without
divorcing life from learning. (Snelgrove, 2017)
In the 21st century there has been a rich production of digital games with a wide variety of
game genres and gaming platform. With the phenomenon of new so called 'casual games ',
frequent playing has reached new target groups and age groups (Juul, 2010). Today, when the
human race more than anytime earlier is meeting the idea of homo ludens, it must be realistic
to increase the use play and game-based learning as a way of mass individualisation in modern
mass education.
4. Conclusion
Although Aristotle’s concept of autotelism seems to anticipate modern ideas of intrinsic
motivation, it was Plato who first truly gave games and play a place in education. Aristotle and
many other early educators tended to view games and study as opposites. Despite this, Plato
explicitly recommended games/play as a teaching tool, and his ideas were taken up by
Vittorino da Feltre in the Renaissance. From that foundation they were developed and
systematized in the 17th century by Comenius, who in turn inspired Piaget, Vygotskji and
many other modern philosophers of education.
Comenius stands out in that he envisioned education and play/games to be truly integrated.
The purpose of this was to achieve something very close to modern ideas of intrinsic
motivation. In a broader context, Comenius was quite aware that intrinsic and extrinsic
motivation are both necessary. However, intrinsic motivation was the element which was
lacking in the schools of his day. In his view, the concept of ludus could remedy this by turning
school into a game.
Goeing, A. S. 2014. Summus Mathematicus et Omnis Humanitatis Pater: The Vitae of
Vittorino da Feltre and the Spirit of Humanism. Dordrecht: Springer.
Hellerstedt, A. & Mozelius, P. 2018. From Comenius to Counter-Strike: 400 years of Game-
based Learning as a didactic Foundation, Proceedings of the 12th European Conference on
Game Based Learning. Sophia Antipolis: Academic Conferences and Publishing International.
Huizinga, J. 2016. Homo Ludens, a study of the play element in culture. Angelico press.
Juul, J. 2010. A casual revolution: Reinventing video games and their players. MIT press.
Lepper, M. R., & Greene, D. 1975. Turning play into work: Effects of adult surveillance and
extrinsic rewards on children's intrinsic motivation, Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology, 31(3), 479.
Malone, T. W. 1981. Toward a theory of intrinsically motivating instruction, Cognitive
science, 5(4), 333-369.
Malone, T. W., & Lepper, M. R. 1987. Making learning fun: A taxonomy of intrinsic motivations
for learning, in Aptitude, learning and Instruction III: Cognitive and affective process analysis.
Ed. Snow, R. E. Hillsdale: Erlbaum.
Piaget, J. 1968. The Significance of John Amos Comenius at the Present Time, in John Amos
Comenius on Education, Classics in Education 33. New York: Teachers College Press.
Piaget, J. 1973. To understand is to invent, Grossman, New York (Original work published
Plass, P. 1967. ’Play’ and Philosophic Detachment in Plato, Transactions and Proceedings of
the American Philological Association, vol. 96.
Snelgrove, D. (2017). Testing, Experience, and Reason: Perspectives from Comenius and
Vygotsky, L.S. 1978. Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes,
Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
... For this new and younger learner audience, there is a new need for an alternative instructional design to support a more joyful learning process. A classic concept for motivating learners that has been digitalised and enhanced during the last decades is the concept of game-based learning [3] [4]. The use of educational games in science, technology, engineering, mathematics (STEM) and programming education, is today a frequently occurring phenomenon with promising results [5] [6]. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Learning games have become mainstream in many educational contexts, where one of them is programming education. Today there exists a wide variety of games where the players can learn about different programming concepts. However, earlier research reports that far from all these games appeal to a female audience. If game-based learning should reach the identified potential of a highly motivating learning environment, the game design must be an inclusive one where girls feel welcome. This study examines three games for learning fundamental programming in a test group with girls only in an after-school Maker community. The research question in the study was: "Which game design concepts do girls find appealing?" Data were collected through interviews with girls in a makerspace after testing 3 games on computer programming. The tested games were: Minecraft Education Code Builder, CodeCombat, and imagiLabs. The interviews focused on the girl's perceptions of the games and of programming. Thematic analysis with a six-phase process of coding were used to analyse the collected data and cluster the codes in themes that supported in answering the aim and research question. The study shows that all three games were perceived as engaging and that they supported development of programming skills. When asking which of the three games the girls would like to spend more time on to learn programming, opinions were divided. The girls also disagreed on which type of game graphics they found most appealing. However, findings indicate that there are clear patterns in what game design concepts the girls find important. These patterns can be grouped in the following categories: Creativity, customisation, flow, reward and feedback, exploration and programming skills. Firstly, the game should encourage exploration and creativity in both playing and programming. Secondly, for the programming tasks to be fun and challenging it is important to keep players in a flow state with help of rewards, instant feedback and a low threshold at start. Lastly, the possibility for customization and an engaging backstory were also appreciated by the girls in the study. These findings are recommended to take into consideration in future game development.
... GBL has also been used frequently with promising results in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM), and in programming education [6][7]. The use of games for educational purposes has been around for thousands of years, and long before the appearance of digital video games in the 20th century [8]. In the 21st century the so-called casual revolution [9]. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Gaming is a ubiquitous phenomenon today, and game-based learning has become a main stream teaching and learning activity. Despite the long history of using games in educational contexts, the concepts of inclusive game design and enjoyable educational games still have challenges. The aim of this study is to gather requirements for design of educational games on programming where girls and boys find it joyful to play together. To meet this aim, the data sets from two earlier studies have been combined, compared, discussed, and finally merged into a preliminary framework. This study was carried out as a requirement-fo-cused design science study, with a focus on gathering requirements for a future design and implementation of an educational game on fundamental programming. Data were collected in a combination of a scoping literature review, and through a questionnaire answered by elementary school students after playing an educational game on programming. Main themes in the framework for Girl Inclusive Educational Game Design are Exploration Without Violence, Collabora-tive Interaction, Character Diversity, Customisation, Graphics, Game Mechanics, Game Content, and Learning and Motivation. If these factors are thoughtfully considered it could be possible to achieve the idea of a game with Wide Walls, a High Ceiling, and a Low Threshold, where girls and boys could play together and learn how to program.
... However, its origin can be dated back to the olden days. The great philosopher, Plato held the belief that play was important for education since he saw it as the first step on the path that leads to true knowledge (4). The fusion of games in learning today, either in the form of gamification or game-based learning is used as a functional tool to motivate people (5). ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Player type theory in which its earliest study done by Richard Bartle segments players into different categories based on their interaction with games. Other related studies were then conducted by various researchers consecutively. The authors came upon a question in which to what extent can player motivation in games be projected onto intrinsic motivation. Thus, this study is done by assigning Nick Yee’s player motivation test and Intrinsic Motivation Inventory test to 57 undergraduate students from the School of Educational Studies who are partaking in an Instructional Technology course in an online gamified learning environment. Reliability, correlation, and regression tests were done on the data obtained. Later, the researchers evaluated and interpreted the results by presenting them in table and graph forms. The authors of this article aimed to determine the possibility of the convergence of player motivation in a game-like context towards intrinsic motivation within a real-life context with the hope of contributing to its respective field.
... Games and game-based learning have been around for thousands of years, long before the appearance of digital video games (Hellerstedt & Mozelius, 2019). After the so-called casual revolution , gaming is a ubiquitous activity today in a larger target group than ever. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Gaming is a ubiquitous activity today where many children spend considerable amounts of time playing various games. Serious games have also become a mainstream educational tool in a wide variety of school subjects. Despite this, many games still have a design that mainly appeals to boys where girls are less frequent players. The aim of this study was to gather requirements for a design of serious games where girls should not feel excluded. The research question to answer was: "Which design concepts are important if girls should be engaged in serious gaming?". Furthermore, the results from this study could be useful for future implementations of educational games. This study strives to address the research gap in the field of inclusive game design, and to gather important requirements for games where girls and boys want to play together. This study was carried out as a scoping literature review to map literature in the field of game design to identify key concepts that can attract the younger girl audience. Scoping literature reviews offer a method of mapping key concepts in a research field to identifying the main sources and types of evidence available. A central aim of a scoping literature review is to synthesise research results to a specific target group as a foundation for future research. For this study, the future research will consist of implementing the found design factors in an educational game on computer science. Findings indicate that there are specific game design concepts that girls find appealing. Important main themes to consider are Creativity and customisation, Character diversity, Collaborative interaction, and Exploration without violence. However, there seems to be several challenges related to the concept of designing specific girl games. The conclusion from this study is rather to choose a more inclusive game design where girls and boys would like to play together. A concept for game design that could be described as having a low threshold, wide walls and a high ceiling. The recommendation for a girl inclusive design is to carefully consider factors such as narration, backstory, social interaction, game graphics, sound design, and personalisation.
... The tradition of using games and play in educational contexts is far older than using computers. Various types of games have for thousands of years been used for training in areas such as mathematics, logics, and combinatorics (Vankúš, 2005;Hellerstedt & Mozelius, 2019). Areas that all are useful in the process of developing fundamental programming skills and for the general understanding of computer science. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Programming education at university level has often been identified as problematic learning. At the same time, prognosis for future labour market is increased need for professionals with programming and related skills. To meet demands of future society, K-12 schools around the world have integrated programming in the curriculum. However, research show challenges for integrating programming in K-12 education. Challenges include students' and teachers' struggle with learning and teaching programming, lack of time to properly incorporate programming in existing teaching and learning, and insufficient support for teachers. This study addresses these challenges by designing, developing, and evaluating an educational game on programming that combines the idea of game-based learning with digital escape rooms. In the game, the player develops knowledge about programming concepts to escape 10 rooms. The study's main research question was: What are K-12 students' perceptions of the game and what do they considered to be important design factors for a digital escape room game on computer programming? A design science approach was used for designing, developing, and evaluating a web-based escape room game on programming. This was conducted in a five-step process: 1) Explicating the problem, 2) Defining the requirements, 3) Designing and developing the artefact, 4) Demonstrating the artefact, and 5) Evaluating the artefact. The game was tested and evaluated by 32 K-12 students with a questionnaire during the autumn semester of 2021 and spring semester of 2022. Collected data were then analysed and grouped into categories to answer the study's aim and research question. Findings of the study show several suggestions for further development and important design factors to consider when developing a digital escape room game. The next steps of research are to combine these findings with evaluations from teachers, and to incorporate this in an updated version of the game.
... As a result, rather than playing specialised games, learners study knowledge with the idea that they were playing a game, making the educational experience challenging and enjoyable (4). Gamification in learning had become rather quite popular these days, however, the existence of such a concept might be earlier than we thought, dating back to the era ranging from 1500-1150 BC (5,6). Because of the games' ability to teach and the fact that they reinforce not only knowledge but also critical skills like problem-solving, cooperation, and communication, using educational games as learning tools is a viable method (7). ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The situation of the Covid-19 pandemic had prompted the educational sector to conduct teaching and learning online, but such a learning environment affects students in various ways including motivation, engagement and more. Gamification, a term coined by Nick Pelling in 2002 is the concept of applying game elements and game mechanics in a non-game situation in hope of changing a person’s behaviour. The use of gamification in the learning environment by previous researchers had shown the possibility of overcoming such problems. However, with the failure of technological infrastructure in the context of Malaysia, multiple dilemmas arise. This study is done by interviewing 30 university students from the School of Educational Studies and the analysation of data is done using an inductive approach of thematic analysis. The study further discussed the dilemma faced by educators from the perspectives of students. Thus, hoping to provide certain new insight to educators and other researchers.
... (2)(3)(4)(5) Games are always associated with the feeling of amusement and have existed in different forms since ancient times, suggesting that the nature of human/learner are closely knitted with the idea of fun and play. The idea of integrating games into education (Game-based learning) is revolutionary, the earliest use of games in education can be traced back to ancient civilization in which Kalaha, Xiangxi, Chess, and other board games have been utilised in educational settings for thousands of years to teach strategic and tactical thinking, as well as language skills, Mathematics, and other topics (6). Games have incredible motivational power; they use various techniques to entice people to play them, frequently without any monetary incentive, just for the fun of it and the chance to win (7). ...
... The concept of game-based learning predates digital video games and has evolved with time and technological advancement [26]. Video-game-based learning can be categorized into two main models, 'Gamification' and 'Serious Games', presented in detail in the following sections. ...
Full-text available
Digitally enhanced advanced services (DEAS), offered currently by various industries, could be a challenging concept to comprehend for potential clients. This could result in limited interest in adopting (DEAS) or even understanding its true value with significant financial implications for the providers. Innovative ways to present and simplify complex information are provided by serious games and gamification, which simplify and engage users with intricate information in an enjoyable manner. Despite the use of serious games and gamification in other areas, only a few examples have been documented to convey servitization offers. This research explores the design and development of a serious game for the Howden Group, a real-world industry partner aiming to simplify and convey existing service agreement packages. The system was developed under the consultation of a focus group comprising five members of the industrial partner. The final system was evaluated by 30 participants from engineering and servitization disciplines who volunteered to test online the proposed system and discuss their user experience (UX) and future application requirements. The analysis of users’ feedback presented encouraging results, with 90% confirming that they understood the DEAS concept and offers. To conclude, the paper presents a tentative plan for future work which will address the issues highlighted by users’ feedback and enhance the positive aspects of similar applications.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The Czech philosopher John Amos Comenius has been presented as the father of modern didactics. He also favoured learning by doing and believed in "the art of turning all our schools into games". Furthermore, Comenius had the idea of a flipped classroom with a four-hour school day, divided into two hours in the morning and two hours in the afternoon. The time in between is recommended to be spent on preparation, play and to explore nature. Comenius saw play as an important didactic strategy since play is an imitation of life itself. Most importantly, Comenius wished games/play and learning to be integrated. He envisioned "a school in which the serious and the fun are mixed" (Comenius, 1657B, [xviii]). This study has been carried out as a central and comparative literature review. Central in the sense of reviewing a body of literature that is central to the chosen topic, and comparative in the sense that texts describing ideas from the Comenius era have been compared to contemporary ideas. The historical texts were studied using a contextual method, viewing Comenius's works as moves in an argument, as described by Skinner (1996). The comparison reveals both similarities and differences. The concepts of learning by doing, 'facilitas' and to flip the classroom, are all didactic ideas aligned to game-based learning today. Some examples of learning initiatives and schools fundamentally built upon the idea of 'learning by gaming' were found, but the idea still seems radical to most educators. Comenius would probably have loved the rich abundance of games and gamification today, but certainly not shooting games like Counter-Strike. Comenius's vision was more one of a peaceful utopia with enlightened citizens. Finally, it is hard to tell if Comenius, alive today, would find the 21 st century digital games to support or to interfere his Epicurean idea of a 'direct vision'.
Full-text available
80 preschool 4-5 yr olds participated in a novel activity in individual sessions. In the expected reward conditions, Ss expected to win a chance to play with highly attractive toys by engaging in the activity; in the unexpected reward conditions, Ss had no prior knowledge of this reward. Orthogonally, Ss in the surveillance conditions were told that their performance would be monitored via a TV camera; Ss in the nonsurveillance conditions were not monitored. 2 wks later, unobtrusive measures of the Ss' intrinsic interest in the activity were obtained in their classrooms. 2 significant main effects were obtained reproducing and expanding findings from earlier studies. Ss who had undertaken the activity expecting an extrinsic reward showed less subsequent interest in the activity than those who had not expected a reward, and Ss who had been placed under surveillance showed less subsequent interest than those not previously monitored. (19 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
We used to think that video games were mostly for young men, but with the success of the Nintendo Wii, and the proliferation of games in browsers, cell phone games, and social games video games changed changed fundamentally in the years from 2000 to 2010. These new casual games are now played by men and women, young and old. Players need not possess an intimate knowledge of video game history or devote weeks or months to play. At the same time, many players of casual games show a dedication and skill that is anything but casual. In A Casual Revolution, Jesper Juul describes this as a reinvention of video games, and of our image of video game players, and explores what this tells us about the players, the games, and their interaction. With this reinvention of video games, the game industry reconnects with a general audience. Many of today's casual game players once enjoyed Pac-Man, Tetris, and other early games, only to drop out when video games became more time-consuming and complex. Juul shows that it is only by understanding what a game requires of players, what players bring to a game, how the game industry works, and how video games have developed historically that we can understand what makes video games fun and why we choose to play (or not to play) them.
First, a number of previous theories of intrinsic motivation are reviewed. Then, several studies of highly motivating computer games are described. These studies focus on what makes the games fun, not on what makes them educational. Finally, with this background, a rudimentary theory of intrinsically motivating instruction is developed, based on three categories: challenge, fantasy, and curiosity.Challenge is hypothesized to depend on goals with uncertain outcomes. Several ways of making outcomes uncertain are discussed, including variable difficulty level, multiple level goals, hidden information, and randomness. Fantasy is claimed to have both cognitive and emotional advantages in designing instructional environments. A distinction is made between extrinsic fantasies that depend only weakly on the skill used in a game, and intrinsic fantasies that are intimately related to the use of the skill. Curiosity is separated into sensory and cognitive components, and it is suggested that cognitive curiosity can be aroused by making learners believe their knowledge structures are incomplete, inconsistent, or unparsimonious.