ArticlePublisher preview available

Probing the origin of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays with neutrinos in the EeV energy range using the Pierre Auger Observatory

IOP Publishing
Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Neutrinos with energies above 1017 eV are detectable with the Surface Detector Array of the Pierre Auger Observatory. The identification is efficiently performed for neutrinos of all flavors interacting in the atmosphere at large zenith angles, as well as for Earth-skimming τ neutrinos with nearly tangential trajectories relative to the Earth. No neutrino candidates were found in ~ 14.7 years of data taken up to 31 August 2018. This leads to restrictive upper bounds on their flux. The 90% C.L. single-flavor limit to the diffuse flux of ultra-high-energy neutrinos with an Eν−2 spectrum in the energy range 1.0 × 1017 eV –2.5 × 1019 eV is E2 dNν/dEν < 4.4 × 10−9 GeV cm−2 s−1 sr−1, placing strong constraints on several models of neutrino production at EeV energies and on the properties of the sources of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays.
JCAP10(2019)022
ournal of
Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics
An IOP and SISSA journal
J
Probing the origin of ultra-high-energy
cosmic rays with neutrinos in the EeV
energy range using the Pierre Auger
Observatory
The Pierre Auger collaboration
E-mail: auger spokespersons@fnal.gov
Received June 19, 2019
Accepted September 5, 2019
Published October 8, 2019
Abstract. Neutrinos with energies above 1017 eV are detectable with the Surface Detec-
tor Array of the Pierre Auger Observatory. The identification is efficiently performed for
neutrinos of all flavors interacting in the atmosphere at large zenith angles, as well as for
Earth-skimming τneutrinos with nearly tangential trajectories relative to the Earth. No
neutrino candidates were found in 14.7 years of data taken up to 31 August 2018. This
leads to restrictive upper bounds on their flux. The 90% C.L. single-flavor limit to the diffuse
flux of ultra-high-energy neutrinos with an E2
νspectrum in the energy range 1.0×1017 eV–
2.5×1019 eV is E2dNν/dEν<4.4×109GeV cm2s1sr1, placing strong constraints on
several models of neutrino production at EeV energies and on the properties of the sources
of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays.
Keywords: cosmic ray experiments, cosmological neutrinos, ultra high energy cosmic rays,
neutrino astronomy
ArXiv ePrint: 1906.07422
c
2019 IOP Publishing Ltd and Sissa Medialab https://doi.org/10.1088/1475-7516/2019/10/022
... The separation is based on the fact that electrons in the shower suffer multiple scattering and are expected to arrive more spread in time than muons that travel almost in straight lines to the detector inducing shorter signals. In the ES channel, the average area-over-peak ⟨AoP⟩, which is the ratio of the time trace integral in an SD station to its peak value, averaged over all triggered stations in an SD event, is used as the key discriminating observable based on this idea [7]. In the DG channel, the analysis is also based on AoP values. ...
... In the DG channel, the analysis is also based on AoP values. However, in this case, additional observables are constructed from the individual AoP values of the stations, and these are then combined in a Fisher discriminant analysis [7]. ...
... Also shown are upper limits from IceCube and ANITA and the expected neutrino fluxes under different theoretical assumptions and scenarios, including ones based on Auger data (cf.[8]). For details and references see[7]. ...
... Therefore, neutrinos from nuclei photodisintegration have a much lower energy-flux and are much harder to detect when compared to their GZK analogues. This fact combined with the apparent absence of a cosmogenic neutrino flux has been used by IceCube [15,16] and Pierre Auger (PA) [14] to place upper limits on the proton fraction of CRs. ...
... Another hypothesis is that this event corresponds to a recovery or feature in the astrophysical neutrino flux from, e.g., the GZK process [24,25]. This cosmogenic hypothesis is also in > 3σ tension [22] with IceCube [16,26] as well as with PA searches [14,27] thanks to their larger effective area in E ν ≳ 100 PeV energy region. Nevertheless, given the neutrino energy interval estimated for the event and its consistency with the expected location of the cosmogenic neutrino energy-flux peak, in the rest of the paper, we proceed to entertain a cosmogenic origin for the event. ...
... The data point in different shades of blue shows the 1σ, 2σ, and 3σ ranges of the neutrino flux to explain the KM3-230213A event at KM3NeT under the assumption of a clipped single-power law flux of constant E 2 Φ 1f ν+ν in the range 72 PeV < Eν < 2.6 EeV. Also shown are the existing limits on a diffuse cosmogenic flux from IceCube [16,26], Pierre Auger [14], and ANTARES [43], as well as the measured astrophysical neutrino spectrum in three IceCube analyses: High-Energy Starting Events (HESE) [21] Northern Starting Tracks (NST) [44], and the Downgoing PeV (DPeV) sample [45]. n − n ′ transitions with UCNs such as in the nEDM experiment at PSI [37]. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Current data on ultra-high-energy (UHE) cosmic rays suggest they are predominantly made of heavy nuclei. This indicates that the flux of neutrinos produced from proton collisions on the cosmic microwave background is small and hard to observe. Motivated by the recent extremely-high-energy muon event reported by KM3NeT, we explore the possibility of enhancing the energy-flux of cosmogenic neutrinos through nuclear photodisintegration in the presence of new physics. Specifically, we speculate that UHE neutrons may oscillate into a new state, dark (or mirror) neutron nn' that in turn decays injecting large amount of energy to neutrinos, nnνUHEn\to n'\to \nu_\text{UHE}. While this mechanism does not explain the tension between the KM3NeT event and null results from IceCube, it reconciles the experimental preference for a heavier cosmic ray composition with a large diffuse cosmogenic flux of UHE neutrinos.
... The band captures the uncertainty stemming from the different cosmic-ray evolution models and spectra, namely, QSO (aggressive) and SFR (conservative). We consider the QSO model aggressive in part due to it having the largest enhancement (see discussion below) but more because the QSO model is constrained by the null detection of cosmogenic neutrinos, although this conclusion depends on the cosmic-ray maximum energy and cosmic-ray composition [30]. Overall, the uncertainty arising from the models considered is ∼1 order of magnitude at most. ...
... As a result, previous studies of cosmic-ray propagation have explored various maximum cutoff energies [24]. The cutoff affects directly the cutoff of the boosted neutrino spectra, which also has an impact for detection prospects with cosmic-ray and neutrino experiments like IceCube, ANITA [31], and Pierre Auger [30]. We caution that in this work we have not performed a full propagation calculation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Energetic cosmic rays scatter off the cosmic neutrino background throughout the history of the Universe, yielding a diffuse flux of cosmic relic neutrinos boosted to high energies. We calculate this flux under different assumptions of the cosmic-ray flux spectral slope and redshift evolution. The nonobservation of the diffuse flux of boosted relic neutrinos with current high-energy neutrino experiments already excludes an average cosmic neutrino background overdensity larger than ∼ 10 4 over cosmological distances. We discuss the future detectability of the diffuse flux of boosted relic neutrinos in light of neutrino overdensity estimates and cosmogenic neutrino backgrounds. Published by the American Physical Society 2025
... Here we show that JCAP02(2025)059 IceCube-2021 represents the measured astrophysical neutrino flux using muon track events only by the IceCube collaboration [60]. The solid curves labeled ARA, ARIANNA, and Auger are constraints set by these experiments [61][62][63]. Dashed lines represent the sensitivity of future experiments [10]. The initial PBH abundance in this figure is set at β = 10 −29 · (m BH0 /g) 1/3 . ...
... It spans from ∼ 10 TeV up to a few PeV. At higher energies, ARA [61], ARI-ANNA [62], and Auger [63] have set important constraints on the flux, represented by those solid lines. In the near future, a multitude of experiments including IceCube-Gen2 [48], KM3Net [64], GRAND [49], BEACON [65], RET-N [66], TAMBO [67], and Trinity [68], will be capable of probing the ultra-high-energy regime with unprecedented sensitivities -see ref. [10] for a recent review. ...
Article
Full-text available
Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) are capable of emitting extremely energetic particles independent of their interactions with the Standard Model. In this work, we investigate whether PBHs evaporating in the early universe could be responsible for some of the observed high-energy neutrinos above the TeV or PeV scale in the present universe. We compute the energy spectrum of neutrinos directly emitted by PBHs with a monochromatic mass function and estimate the wash-out point, which determines the maximum energy of the spectrum. We find that the spectrum generally extends to high energies following a power law of E ν ⁻³ until it reaches the wash-out point, which crucially depends on the PBH mass. For PBHs of 10¹³ grams, the spectrum can extend up to the PeV scale, though the flux is too low for detection. We also consider an indirect production mechanism involving dark particles that are emitted by PBHs and decay into neutrinos at a much later epoch. This mechanism allows lighter (such as those in the gram to kilogram range) PBHs to produce more energetic neutrino fluxes without being washed out by the thermal plasma in the early universe. In this scenario, we find that ultra-high-energy neutrinos around or above the EeV scale can be generated, with sufficiently high fluxes detectable by current and future high-energy neutrino observatories such as IceCube and GRAND.
... However, the direction of the observed pulses implies that the neutrinos would need to travel about 6000-7000 km through the Earth before interacting below the ice surface [2]. This corresponds to about 8-10 interaction lengths at the required neutrino energy E ν ≳ 0.2 EeV [5], causing severe attenuation and requiring a ν τ flux that should have been observed with IceCube and the Pierre Auger Observatory [6][7][8], the latter being particularly sensitive to Earth-skimming tau neutrinos [9,10]. An astrophysical explanation of the events under standard model (SM) assumptions has also been severely constrained by IceCube [11]. ...
Article
Full-text available
A dedicated search for upward-going air showers at zenith angles exceeding 110° and energies E > 0.1 EeV has been performed using the Fluorescence Detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory. The search is motivated by two “anomalous” radio pulses observed by the ANITA flights I and III that appear inconsistent with the standard model of particle physics. Using simulations of both regular cosmic-ray showers and upward-going events, a selection procedure has been defined to separate potential upward-going candidate events and the corresponding exposure has been calculated in the energy range [0.1–33] EeV. One event has been found in the search period between January 1, 2004, and December 31, 2018, consistent with an expected background of 0.27 ± 0.12 events from misreconstructed cosmic-ray showers. This translates to an upper bound on the integral flux of ( 7.2 ± 0.2 ) × 10 − 21 cm − 2 sr − 1 y − 1 and ( 3.6 ± 0.2 ) × 10 − 20 cm − 2 sr − 1 y − 1 for an E − 1 and E − 2 spectrum, respectively. An upward-going flux of showers normalized to the ANITA observations is shown to predict over 34 events for an E − 3 spectrum and over 8.1 events for a conservative E − 5 spectrum, in strong disagreement with the interpretation of the anomalous events as upward-going showers. Published by the American Physical Society 2025
... The neutrino floor for a strong negative (pessimistic) and strong positive (optimistic) source evolution are shown in Fig. 2, along with existing data [8,[31][32][33][34] and upper-bounds [35][36][37][38], as well as, the projected sensitivity of the proposed IceCube-Gen2 experiment [39] for reference. While the uncertainty in the UHE neutrino floor due to source evolution spans more than an order of magnitude, it is clear that current UHECR data is compatible with a very low UHE neutrino flux. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
In this review we motivate ultrahigh energy neutrino searches and their connection to ultrahigh energy cosmic rays. We give an overview of neutrino production mechanisms and their potential sources. Several model-independent benchmarks of the ultrahigh energy neutrino flux are discussed. Finally, a brief discussion of approaches for model-dependent neutrino flux predictions are given, highlighting a few examples from the literature.
... However, the direction of the observed pulses implies that the neutrinos would need to travel about 6000-7000 km through the Earth before interacting below the ice surface [2]. This corresponds to about 8-10 interaction lengths at the required neutrino energy E ν ≳ 0.2 EeV [5], causing severe attenuation and requiring a ν τ -flux that should have been observed with IceCube and the Pierre Auger Observatory [6][7][8], the latter being particularly sensitive to Earth-skimming tau neutrinos [9,10]. An astrophysical explanation of the events under Standard Model (SM) assumptions has also been severely constrained by Ice-Cube [11]. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
A dedicated search for upward-going air showers at zenith angles exceeding 110110^\circ and energies E>0.1E>0.1 EeV has been performed using the Fluorescence Detector of the Pierre Auger Observatory. The search is motivated by two "anomalous" radio pulses observed by the ANITA flights I and III which appear inconsistent with the Standard Model of particle physics. Using simulations of both regular cosmic ray showers and upward-going events, a selection procedure has been defined to separate potential upward-going candidate events and the corresponding exposure has been calculated in the energy range [0.1-33] EeV. One event has been found in the search period between 1 Jan 2004 and 31 Dec 2018, consistent with an expected background of 0.27±0.120.27 \pm 0.12 events from mis-reconstructed cosmic ray showers. This translates to an upper bound on the integral flux of (7.2±0.2)×1021(7.2 \pm 0.2) \times 10^{-21} cm2^{-2} sr1^{-1} y1^{-1} and (3.6±0.2)×1020(3.6 \pm 0.2) \times 10^{-20} cm2^{-2} sr1^{-1} y1^{-1} for an E1E^{-1} and E2E^{-2} spectrum, respectively. An upward-going flux of showers normalized to the ANITA observations is shown to predict over 34 events for an E3E^{-3} spectrum and over 8.1 events for a conservative E5E^{-5} spectrum, in strong disagreement with the interpretation of the anomalous events as upward-going showers.
... In this work, we investigate the specific hypothesis of a proton-only composition of UHECRs with the GZK-cutoff generating the observed suppression of UHECRs at EeV energies. The method was proposed in [9], and in a similar fashion applied to the neutrino measurement by the Pierre Auger collaboration [24]. We find, at 90 % CL, that the observed fraction of UHECRs that are protons at Earth above ≃ 30 EeV cannot exceed 70 % if the source evolution is comparable to the star formation rate (SFR) -a general tracer of matter density in the Universe. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
We present a search for the diffuse extremely-high-energy neutrino flux using 12.6 years of IceCube data. The non-observation of neutrinos with energies well above 10PeV10 \, \mathrm{PeV} constrains the all-flavor neutrino flux at 1018eV10^{18} \, \mathrm{eV} to a level of E2Φνe+νμ+ντ108GeVcm2s1sr1E^2 \Phi_{\nu_e + \nu_\mu + \nu_\tau} \simeq 10^{-8} \, \mathrm{GeV} \, \mathrm{cm}^{-2} \, \mathrm{s}^{-1} \, \mathrm{sr}^{-1}, the most stringent limit to date. Using this data, we constrain the proton fraction of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) above 30EeV\simeq 30 \, \mathrm{EeV} to be 70\lesssim 70\,% (at 9090\,% CL) if the cosmological evolution of the sources is comparable to or stronger than the star formation rate. This result complements direct air-shower measurements by being insensitive to uncertainties associated with hadronic interaction models. It is the first such result to disfavor the ``proton-only" hypothesis for UHECRs using neutrino data.
... Right: footprint of an event detected by the SD-750 array in combination with the HEAT-Coihueco fluorescence telescopes, same color code gate the nature of astrophysical sources and particle interactions in a kinematic and energy region well beyond that covered by current particle accelerators. The main results include measurements of the cosmic-ray arrival directions [4,5], energy spectrum [6,7], and mass composition [8] along with their interpretation [9], the possible presence of neutral primaries such as photons and neutrinos [10,11], and particle physics [12]. Moreover, its potential as a multi-messenger [13] and multi-disciplinary [14][15][16][17] observatory has been proven. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Pierre Auger Collaboration has embraced the concept of open access to their research data since its foundation, with the aim of giving access to the widest possible community. A gradual process of release began as early as 2007 when 1% of the cosmic-ray data was made public, along with 100% of the space-weather information. In February 2021, a portal was released containing 10% of cosmic-ray data collected by the Pierre Auger Observatory from 2004 to 2018, during the first phase of operation of the Observatory. The Open Data Portal includes detailed documentation about the detection and reconstruction procedures, analysis codes that can be easily used and modified and, additionally, visualization tools. Since then, the Portal has been updated and extended. In 2023, a catalog of the highest-energy cosmic-ray events examined in depth has been included. A specific section dedicated to educational use has been developed with the expectation that these data will be explored by a wide and diverse community, including professional and citizen scientists, and used for educational and outreach initiatives. This paper describes the context, the spirit, and the technical implementation of the release of data by the largest cosmic-ray detector ever built and anticipates its future developments.
Article
In this review, we motivate ultrahigh energy neutrino searches and their connection to ultrahigh energy cosmic rays. We give an overview of neutrino production mechanisms and their potential sources. Several model-independent benchmarks of the ultrahigh energy neutrino flux are discussed. Finally, a brief discussion of approaches for model-dependent neutrino flux predictions is given, highlighting a few examples from the literature.
Article
Full-text available
The ANtarctic Impulsive Transient Antenna (ANITA) NASA long-duration balloon payload completed its fourth flight in December 2016, after 28 days of flight time. ANITA is sensitive to impulsive broadband radio emission from interactions of ultrahigh-energy neutrinos in polar ice (Askaryan emission). We present the results of two separate blind analyses searching for signals from Askaryan emission in the data from the fourth flight of ANITA. The more sensitive analysis, with a better expected limit, has a background estimate of 0.64−0.45+0.69 and an analysis efficiency of 82±2%. The second analysis has a background estimate of 0.34−0.16+0.66 and an analysis efficiency of 71±6%. Each analysis found one event in the signal region, consistent with the background estimate for each analysis. The resulting limit further tightens the constraints on the diffuse flux of ultrahigh-energy neutrinos at energies above 1019.5 eV.
Article
Full-text available
The world largest exposure to ultra-high energy cosmic rays accumulated by the Pierre Auger Observatory led to major advances in our understanding of their properties, but the many unknowns about the nature and distribution of the sources, the primary composition and the underlying hadronic interactions prevent the emergence of a uniquely consistent picture. The new perspectives opened by the current results call for an upgrade of the Observatory, whose main aim is the collection of new information about the primary mass of the highest energy cosmic rays on a shower-by-shower basis. The evaluation of the fraction of light primaries in the region of suppression of the flux will open the window to charged particle astronomy, allowing for compositionselected anisotropy searches. In addition, the properties of multiparticle production will be studied at energies not covered by man-made accelerators and new or unexpected changes of hadronic interactions will be searched for. After a discussion of the motivations for upgrading the Pierre Auger Observatory, a description of the detector upgrade is provided. We then discuss the expected performances and the improved physics sensitivity of the upgraded detectors and present the first data collected with the already running Engineering Array.
Article
Full-text available
We study the implications of ultrahigh-energy cosmic-ray (UHECR) data from the Pierre Auger Observatory for potential accelerator candidates and cosmogenic neutrino fluxes for different combinations of nuclear disintegration and air-shower models. We exploit the most recent spectral and mass composition data (2017) with a new, computationally efficient simulation code, PriNCe. We extend a systematic framework, which has been previously applied in a combined fit by the Pierre Auger Collaboration, with the cosmological source evolution as an additional free parameter. In this framework, an ensemble of generalized UHECR accelerators is characterized by a universal spectral index (equal for all injection species), a maximal rigidity, and the normalizations for five nuclear element groups. We find that the 2017 data favor a small but constrained contribution of heavy elements (iron) at the source. We demonstrate that the results moderately depend on the nuclear disintegration (Puget–Stecker–Bredekamp, Peanut, or Talys) model and more strongly on the air-shower (EPOS-LHC, Sibyll 2.3, or QGSjetII-04) model. Variations of these models result in different source evolution and spectral indices, limiting the interpretation in terms of a particular class of cosmic accelerators. Better-constrained parameters include the maximal rigidity and the mass composition at the source. Hence, the cosmogenic neutrino flux can be robustly predicted. Depending on the source evolution at high redshifts, the flux is likely out of reach of future neutrino observatories in most cases, and a minimal cosmogenic neutrino flux cannot be claimed from data without assuming a cosmological distribution of the sources.
Article
Full-text available
The interaction of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) with pervasive photon fields generates associated cosmogenic fluxes of neutrinos and photons due to photohadronic and photonuclear processes taking place in the intergalactic medium. We perform a fit of the UHECR spectrum and composition measured by the Pierre Auger Observatory for four source emissivity scenarios: power-law redshift dependence with one free parameter, active galactic nuclei, gamma-ray bursts, and star formation history. We show that negative source emissivity evolution is favoured if we treat the source evolution as a free parameter. In all cases, the best fit is obtained for relatively hard spectral indices and low maximal rigidities, for compositions at injection dominated by intermediate nuclei (nitrogen and silicon groups). In light of these results, we calculate the associated fluxes of neutrinos and photons. Finally, we discuss the prospects for the future generation of high-energy neutrino and gamma-ray observatories to constrain the sources of UHECRs.
Article
Cosmogenic neutrinos originate from interactions of cosmic rays propagating through the universe with cosmic background photons. Since both high-energy cosmic rays and cosmic background photons exist, the existence of high-energy cosmogenic neutrinos is certain. However, their flux has not been measured so far. Therefore, we calculated the flux of high-energy cosmogenic neutrinos arriving at the Earth on the basis of elaborate 4D simulations that take into account three spatial degrees of freedom and the cosmological time-evolution of the universe. Our predictions for this neutrino flux are consistent with the recent upper limits obtained from large-scale cosmic-ray experiments. We also show that the extragalactic magnetic field has a strong influence on the neutrino flux. The results of this work are important for the design of future neutrino observatories, since they allow to assess the detector volume and observation time that are necessary to detect high-energy cosmogenic neutrinos in the near future. An observation of such neutrinos would push multimessenger astronomy to hitherto unachieved energy scales.
Article
Cosmogenic neutrinos are produced when ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) interact with cosmological photon fields. Limits on the diffuse flux of these neutrinos can be used to constrain the fraction of protons arriving at Earth with energies Ep≳30 EeV, thereby providing bounds on the composition of UHECRs without fully relying on hadronic interaction models. We show to which extent current neutrino telescopes already constrain this fraction of protons and discuss the prospects for next-generation detectors to further constrain it. Additionally, we discuss the implications of these limits for several popular candidates for UHECR source classes.
Article
We present a detailed study of the large-scale anisotropies of cosmic rays with energies above 4 EeV measured using the Pierre Auger Observatory. For the energy bins [4, 8] EeV and E ≥ 8 EeV, the most significant signal is a dipolar modulation in R.A. at energies above 8 EeV, as previously reported. In this paper we further scrutinize the highest-energy bin by splitting it into three energy ranges. We find that the amplitude of the dipole increases with energy above 4 EeV. The growth can be fitted with a power law with index β = 0.79 ± 0.19. The directions of the dipoles are consistent with an extragalactic origin of these anisotropies at all the energies considered. Additionally, we have estimated the quadrupolar components of the anisotropy: they are not statistically significant. We discuss the results in the context of the predictions from different models for the distribution of ultrahigh-energy sources and cosmic magnetic fields. © 2018. The American Astronomical Society. All rights reserved..
Article
We report a quasidifferential upper limit on the extremely-high-energy (EHE) neutrino flux above 5×106 GeV based on an analysis of nine years of IceCube data. The astrophysical neutrino flux measured by IceCube extends to PeV energies, and it is a background flux when searching for an independent signal flux at higher energies, such as the cosmogenic neutrino signal. We have developed a new method to place robust limits on the EHE neutrino flux in the presence of an astrophysical background, whose spectrum has yet to be understood with high precision at PeV energies. A distinct event with a deposited energy above 106 GeV was found in the new two-year sample, in addition to the one event previously found in the seven-year EHE neutrino search. These two events represent a neutrino flux that is incompatible with predictions for a cosmogenic neutrino flux and are considered to be an astrophysical background in the current study. The obtained limit is the most stringent to date in the energy range between 5×106 and 2×1010 GeV. This result constrains neutrino models predicting a three-flavor neutrino flux of Eν2ϕνe+νμ+ντ≃2×10−8 GeV/cm2 sec sr at 109 GeV. A significant part of the parameter space for EHE neutrino production scenarios assuming a proton-dominated composition of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays is disfavored independently of uncertain models of the extragalactic background light which previous IceCube constraints partially relied on.