ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

Primary atrophic rhinitis is a disease of the nose and of paranasalsinuses characterized by a progressive loss of function of nasal and paranasal mucosa caused by a gradual destruction of ciliary mucosalepithelium with atrophy of serous–mucous glands and loss of bonestructures.The aim of this study was to evaluate the therapeutic effects of topic α-tochopherol acetate (vitamin E) in patients with primary atrophicrhinitis based on subjective and objective data.We analyzed 44 patients with dry nose sensation and endoscopic evidence of atrophic nasal mucosa. We analyzed endoscopic mucosascore, anterior rhinomanometry, and nasal mucociliary clearance before and after 6 months of topic treatment with α-tochopherol acetate. For statistical analysis, we used paired samples t test (95% confidence interval [CI], P < .05) for rhinomanometric and muciliary transit time evaluations and analysis of variance 1-way test (95% CI, P < .05) for endoscopic evaluation. All patients showed an improvement in “dry nose” sensation and inperception of nasal airflow. Rhinomanometric examination showed increase of nasal airflow at follow-up ( P < .05); nasal mucociliaryclearance showed a reduction in mean transit time ( P < .05); and endoscopic evaluation showed significative improvement of hydration of nasalmucosa and significative decreasing nasal crusts and mucusaccumulation ( P < .05). Medical treatment for primary atrophic rhinitis is not clearly documented in the literature; in this research, it was demonstrated that α-ochopherol acetate could be a possible treatment for atrophic rhinitis.
This content is subject to copyright.
Clinical Study
Role of α-Tocopherol Acetate on Nasal
Respiratory Functions: Mucociliary
Clearance and Rhinomanometric
Evaluations in Primary Atrophic Rhinitis
Domenico Testa, MD, PhD
1
, Giuseppina Marcuccio, MD, PhD
1
,
Nicola Lombardo, MD
2
, Salvatore Giuseppe Cocuzza, MD, PhD
3
,
Germano Guerra, MD, PhD
4
, and Gaetano Motta, MD, PhD
1
Abstract
Primary atrophic rhinitis is a disease of the nose and of paranasalsinuses characterized by a progressive loss of function of nasal and
paranasal mucosa caused by a gradual destruction of ciliary mucosalepithelium with atrophy of serous–mucous glands and loss of
bonestructures.The aim of this study was to evaluate the therapeutic effects of topic a-tochopherol acetate (vitamin E) in patients
with primary atrophicrhinitis based on subjective and objective data.We analyzed 44 patients with dry nose sensation and
endoscopic evidence of atrophic nasal mucosa. We analyzed endoscopic mucosascore, anterior rhinomanometry, and nasal
mucociliary clearance before and after 6 months of topic treatment with a-tochopherol acetate. For statistical analysis, we used
paired samples ttest (95% confidence interval [CI], P< .05) for rhinomanometric and muciliary transit time evaluations and
analysis of variance 1-way test (95% CI, P< .05) for endoscopic evaluation. All patients showed an improvement in ‘‘dry nose’
sensation and inperception of nasal airflow. Rhinomanometric examination showed increase of nasal airflow at follow-up (P< .05);
nasal mucociliaryclearance showed a reduction in mean transit time (P< .05); and endoscopic evaluation showed significative
improvement of hydration of nasalmucosa and significative decreasing nasal crusts and mucusaccumulation (P< .05). Medical
treatment for primary atrophic rhinitis is not clearly documented in the literature; in this research, it was demonstrated that a-
ochopherol acetate could be a possible treatment for atrophic rhinitis.
Keywords
primary atrophic rhinitis, rhinomanometry, nasal mucociliary clearance, a-tochopherol acetate, dry nose, rhinitis
Introduction
The definition of dry nose involves several clinical conditions
such as the anterior dry rhinitis, primary atrophic rhinitis (PAR)
and secondary atrophic rhinitis (SAR), and their complications
like ozena and empty nose syndrome.
1
Atrophic rhinitis (AR) is
a disease of the nose and paranasal sinuses of considerable clin-
ical interest in otolaryngology. Fraenkel described it for the first
time in 1876, but its etiopathogenesis is still debated nowadays.
1-
2
According to its etiology, it is classified into PAR and SAR and
it is characterized by a progressive loss of function of nasal and
paranasal mucosa caused by the gradual destruction of the ciliary
mucosal epithelium or respiratory epithelium, by the atrophy of
exocrine serous-mucous glands, and by the loss of underlying
bone structures.
1
Moreover, the disease involves the metaplastic
replacement of the squamous epithelium and subsequent loss of
1
Department of General and Specialistic Surgery—Head and Neck Unit,
University of Campania ‘‘L Vanvitelli,’ Napoli, Italy
2
Department of Surgical and Medical Science, Otolaryngology, ‘Magna Grecia’
University, Catanzaro, Italy
3
Department of Surgical and Medical Science and Advanced Technologies
‘‘G.F. Ingrassia,’ Otolaryngology, University of Catania, Catania, Italy
4
Department of Medicine and Health Sciences ‘‘V Tiberio,’ University of
Molise, Campobasso, Italy
Received: July 02, 2019; accepted: July 26, 2019
Corresponding Author:
Giuseppina Marcuccio, MD, PhD, Department of General and Specialistic
Surgery—Head and Neck Unit, University of Campania ‘‘L Vanvitelli,’ via
Sergio Pansini, Ed. 17, Napoli, Italy.
Email: giuseppina_marcuccio@hotmail.it
Ear, Nose & Throat Journal
2021, Vol. 100(6) NP290–NP295
ªThe Author(s) 2019
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/0145561319870483
journals.sagepub.com/home/ear
Creative Commons Non Commercial CC BY-NC: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further
permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
mucociliary clearance.
1
This morphostructural damage of nasal
mucosa leads to clinical manifestations such as nasal congestion
and paradoxal nasal respiratory obstruction, despite an increase
in nasal spaces (paradox stuffy nose) and persistence of secre-
tions; these conditions are mainly determined by the loss of the
nasal nerve sensitivity due to submucosal atrophy.
1-2
The diagnosis is clinical based on the subjective and objec-
tive findings: increased mucociliary clearance transit time,
alteration in rhinomanometric values, nasal symptoms (conges-
tion, dry nose, nasal respiratory obstruction, nasal crusts,
mucus secretion, and hypo/anosmia), and epistaxis.
1-2
Several authors have investigated the role of a-tocopherol
acetate for its anti-inflammatory, immune, and antioxidant
functions have been widely documented in the literature with
restoration of epithelium in skin, in oral and vulvovaginal
mucosa, and in gastric mucosa and nasal mucosa.
3-14
Vitamin E acts as a cofactor for the binding of different
enzymes for oxidative cascade reaction: it prevents oxidation
and destruction of membrane lipids; it interacts with different
cellular proteins that regulate the transcription and the expres-
sion of genes that code for cytokines and chemokines.
3,9,13
The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of the
therapeutic protocol with a-tocopherol acetate in patients with
PAR without infection, based on the subjective and objective
measures.
Patients and Methods
From October 2017 to September 2018, we enrolled 44 patients
(29 female and 15 male) aged between 34 and 70 years, mean age
57.2 years old, with clinical history and objective findings of PAR.
Most of the patients referred hyposmia/anosmia associated with
the sensation of dry nose. Informed consent was obtained from all
individual participants included in the study. The research proto-
col was approved by University Control Group; this study was
conducted according to the World Medical Association Declara-
tion of Helsinki. This is a retrospective observational research.
Theinclusioncriteriawereclinical evidence of paradox
nasal stuffiness sensation, hyposmia/anosmia, sensation of
‘dry nose,’’ and endoscopic and computed tomography (CT)
scan evidence of mucosal epithelium atrophy with abnormal
expansion of paranasal sinuses and nasal spaces. Patients with
the history of previous nasal surgery, allergic chronic vasomo-
tor rhinitis, chronic granulomatous disease, use of topical nasal
drugs, diagnosis of Sjogren syndrome, prior radiotherapy of the
head and neck, and complications of the disease such as septal
perforation and crusts infections were excluded. Patients
underwent, after general ear, nose and throat examination, a
CT scan of the nose and paranasal sinuses, endoscopic rhino-
logic evaluation, rhinomanometry, and nasal mucociliary clear-
ance (NMC) test with charcoal and saccharine powder.
At endoscopic rhinologic evaluation, using a quantitative
scale, we analyzed:
State of hydration of nasal mucosa (0, dry mucosa; 1, par-
tially wet mucosa; and 2, wet mucosa);
presence of nasal crusts (1, 2, and 3 for poor, moderate,
and severe crusting; 0 for absence of crusting);
presence of mucus accumulation (1, 2, and 3 for poor,
moderate, and severe mucus accumulation; 0 for absence
of mucus accumulation).
The endoscopic evaluation was performed always by the
same specialist since this score was a subjective data.
Bilateral anterior rhinomanometry (evaluated at 150 Pascal
drop pressure) was conducted in basal condition and 5 minutes
after nasal decongestion with naphazoline 0.1%nasal spray
(1 puff each nostril) in order to analyze nasal flow rates (cm
3
/s)
and nasal resistances (Pa/cm
3
/s) using ATMOS1Rhino 31
(anterior measurements using olive measuring probe). We
obtained 8 groups of results before and after topic treatment with
a-tocopherol acetate:
Nasal airflow basal before topic treatment (AFbasalT0);
nasal airflow basal after topic treatment (AFbasalT1);
nasal resistance basal before topic treatment (RbasalT0);
nasal resistance basal after topic treatment (RbasalT1);
nasal airflow after decongestant before topic treatment
(AFdecongT0);
nasal airflow after decongestant after topic treatment
(AFdecongT1);
nasal resistance after decongestant before topic treatment
(RdecongT0);
nasal resistance after decongestant after topic treatment
(RdecongT1).
The NMC test was performed 2 hours before rhinomanome-
try using a mixture of charcoal and 3%of saccharine powder, at
1to3PM in order to eliminate the influence of circadian nasal
rhythms.
15
Patients waited in a chair 15 to 30 minutes to get
acclimated with room temperature and humidity and to control
for effects of mucosal decongestion due to exercise. The end-
point of this examination was detected by the perception of
sweet taste and appearance of the dye at the pharyngeal inspec-
tion (subjective and objective methods).
The treatment scheme used for this study was the nasal
administration of pure a-tocopherol acetate 2 puffs in each
nostril, 3 times a day, for 6 months, so the follow-up was
performed at the end of medical treatment.
For statistical analysis, we used descriptive data, means, and
standard deviations of each group of results at both rhinomano-
metric and NMC transit time values before and after topic
treatment; and then we compared means between different
groups by means of paired samples ttest (95%confidence
interval (95%CI), P< .05). For endoscopic scores, we used
analysis of variance 1-way test (95%CI, P< .05).
Results
In all patients selected for treatment, we analyzed endoscopic
evaluation, nasal airflow, and nasal resistances rates at basal
and after decongestant rhinomanometry and NMC transit time
(Tables 1 -3).
Testa et al NP291
We observed at endoscopic examination a greater hydration
of the nasal mucosa than before topic treatment and a decrease
of crusts and mucus accumulation (P< .05; Table 1). Before
topic treatment with a-tocopherol acetate, we observed dry
mucosa with severe crusting and moderate mucus accumula-
tion; after topic treatment, mucosa was wet with poor of
absent crusting and mucus accumulation (Figures 1 and 2).
At rhinomanometric examination, the analysis of nasal air-
flows before and after medical treatment, both at basal and
after decongestant evaluation, demonstrated increased airflows
at follow-up with statistical significance (P< .05); while nasal
resistances did not have significative differences before and after
topic treatment with a-tocopherol acetate (P> .05; Table 4).
The NMC test before topic nasal treatment showed a severe
prolonged time (mean 31.52 minutes) instead after medical
topic treatment with a-tocopherol acetate, the mean transit time
was 21.55 minutes (prolonged transit time) with statistical sig-
nificance (P< .05; Table 5).
All patients showed an improvement in ‘‘dry nose’ sensa-
tion and in the perception of nasal airflow (apparent remission
of paradoxical stuffy nose sensation) with an improvement of
hyposmia/anosmia.
Discussion
Nasal-sinusoidal walls are lined by nasal mucosa providing to
several functions like heating up, humidifying and purifying
inspired air, and nonspecific and specific acting against envi-
ronmental pathogens and others. Nasal mucosa functions are
regulated by several factors like nervous system and sex hor-
mones acting in different manner during life.
16
Dysregulation or dysfunction of these mechanisms leads to
several clinical conditions characterized by dry nose such as
PAR, SAR, and their complications.
1,2
Primary chronic AR is a clinical condition with a higher
prevalence in women after puberty, associated with hereditary
factors, endocrine imbalances, racial factors, nutritional defi-
ciencies such as lack of vitamin A or D, iron, and autoimmune
disorders.
16
The diagnosis was clinical while CT scan was indicated
when signs of chronic rhinosinusitis are found or to obtain
adjunctive evidence of PAR.
1,2
Treatment for PAR is not well defined, and it is often empiri-
cal.
17-18
The saline washes must be considered as the first choice
for several authors to promote the cleaning of the nasal cavity
and to remove secretions and crusts, which could provoke sec-
ondary infections.
17-18
Other therapeutic approaches propose the
use of bicarbonate antiseptic solutions in which the diborated
sodium acts as an antiseptic and antibacterial substance; bicar-
bonate sodium helps to dissolve the crusts; and the chloride
sodium makes the solution isotonic.
17-18
Glycerin drops or spray
associated with glucose can be used because they allow the
lubrification of the nasal mucosa.
17-18
The glucose fermentation
acidifies the pH and hinders bacterial growth.
17-18
Bacterial superinfections are treated with specific antibio-
tics such as rifampicin 600 mg daily for 12 weeks; ciproflox-
acin 500 to 750 mg for 8 weeks.
19
Surgical treatments, instead, provides for the partial or com-
plete closure of the nostrils with autologous or synthetic
implants.
19
Other alternative treatments described in the litera-
ture propose the use of liposucked with autologous platelet-
reached plasma, subcutaneous fat, cancellous bone, autologous
bone marrow grafts, grafts of placenta, or adipose tissue.
20
Table 1. Hydration of Nasal Mucosa, Nasal Crusts and Mucus Accu-
mulation Mean Scores at Endoscopic Evaluation Before and After
Topic Treatment With a-Tocopherol Acetate.
a
Hydration of
Nasal Mucosa,
Mean Values
Presence of
Nasal Crusts,
Mean Values
Mucus
Accumulation,
Mean Values
Before topic
treatment with a-
tocopherol acetate
0.06 +025 2.88 +0.32 1.91 +0.74
After topic treatment
with a-tocopherol
acetate
2.36 +0.65 0.47 +0.5 0.48 +0. 5
Pvalues, ANOVA 1-
way paired variable
<.00001 <.00001 <.00001
Abbreviation: ANOVA, analysis of variance.
a
State of hydration of nasal mucosa (0, dry mucosa; 1, partially wet mucosa;
2, wet mucosa); presence of nasal crusts (1, 2, and 3 for poor, moderate, and
severe crusting; 0 for absence of crusting); presence of nasal mucus (1, 2, and
3 for poor, moderate, and severe mucus accumulation; 0 for absence of
mucus accumulation).
Table 2. Rhinomanometric Medical Treatment.
a
Variable Mean Std Dev Minimum Maximum
AFbasalT0 521.89 131.26 183.00 691.00
AFbasalT1 671.70 105.07 379.00 757.00
RbasalT0 0.56 0.02 0.54 0.60
RbasalT1 0.42 0.02 0.38 0.46
AFdecongT0 533.07 129.37 191.00 706.00
AFdecongT1 672.93 102.91 381.00 765.00
RdecongT0 0.52 0.02 0.47 0.54
RdecongT1 0.40 0.03 0.33 0.43
Abbreviations: AFbasalT0, nasal airflow basal before topic treatment; AFba-
salT1, nasal airflow basal after topic treatment; AFdecongT0, nasal airflow after
decongestant before topic treatment; AFdecongT1, nasal airflow after decon-
gestant after topic treatment; RdecongT0, nasal resistance after decongestant
before topic treatment; RdecongT1, nasal resistance after decongestant after
topic treatment; RbasalT0, nasal resistance basal before topic treatment; Rba-
salT1, nasal resistance basal after topic treatment; std dev, standard deviation.
a
Evaluation at 150 Pa; AF in cm
3
/s; R in Pa/cm
3
/s.
Table 3. NMC (Transit Time) Results Expressed in Minutes.
a
Variable Mean Std Dev Minimum Maximum
NMCT0 31.52 2.05 28.00 36.00
NMCT1 21.55 1.97 18.00 27.00
Abbreviations: NMC, nasal mucociliary clearance; std dev, standard deviation;
T0, before medical treatment; T1, after medical treatment.
a
Valid cases ¼44, cases with missing value(s) ¼0.
NP292 Ear, Nose & Throat Journal 100(6)
In our previous study, we found a decreased healing time in
elderly patients affected by chronic rhinosinusitis after endo-
scopic sinus surgery treated with topic nasal a-tocopherol acet-
ate for 3 months.
14
In consideration of our previous research,
14
the treatment
scheme used for the present study was the nasal administration
of a-tocopherol acetate 2 puffs in each nostril 3 times a day, for
6 months. The follow-up was performed after 6 months of
medical treatment and consists of the endoscopic rhinologic
examination, basal and after decongestant rhinomanometry,
and NMC transit time test.
All patients showed an improvement in nasal respiratory
function for increased nasal airflow; the patients had a better
response to rhinomanometric tests after treatment (increased
nasal airflow). Nasal resistances, according to the literature,
did not have significative differences before and after medical
treatment proposed in this research, neither after decongestant:
maybe due to a vascular depletion in AR and to the duration of
treatment.
18
Furthermore, the NMC test, after treatment, showed a reduc-
tion of the mean transit time near the normal transit time (up to
20 minutes but less than 31 minutes). The duration of NMC in
normal individuals is up to 20 minutes, it is prolonged if it is 21
to 31 minutes; it is considered severely or grossly prolonged if
it is 31 to 60 minutes or up to 60 minutes.
21
The results obtained suggest the use of a-tocopherol acet-
ate in PAR; this study investigated an aspect scientifically
poorly explored: What is the most correct strategy in the
pharmacological treatment of PAR? Moreover, we also want
to give an impulse for scientific studies on the effect of vita-
min E, and specifically of a-tocopherol acetate, in the nasal
tropism.
PAR and ozena are often used to indicate the same clin-
ical condition, even if it is important to distinguish them
because of in the second one, we find bacterial infection.
Medical treatment for PAR is not clearly documented in the
literature in terms of follow-up and clinical evaluation with
subjective (symptoms) and objective methods (endoscopic
evaluation, rhinomanometry, and NMC transit time) and
medical treatment. In the present study, we showed relevant
results in nasal functions after medical topic treatment with
a-tocopherol acetate (vitamin E), and these results lay the
foundation for further application of this molecule in sino-
nasal pathology.
Figure 1. Endoscopic view of nasal mucosa (inferior turbinate) in primary atrophic rhinitis before medical treatment: (A) medial face;
(B-D) head.
Testa et al NP293
Figure 2. Endoscopic view of nasal mucosa (inferior turbinate) in primary atrophic rhinitis after medical treatment: (A) inferior face; (B-D) head.
Table 5. Paired Samples t-Test for Nasal Mucociliary Clearance Transit Time Values.
Paired Differences
Mean Standard Deviation Standard Error of the Mean
95% Confidence Interval
of the Difference tdfSig (2-Tailed)
NMCT0-NMCT1 9.98 0.79 0.12 9.74-10.22 83.56 43 <.001
Abbreviations: NMC, nasal mucociliary clearance; T0, before medical treatment; T1, after medical treatment.
Table 4. Paired Samples tTest For Rhinomanometric Values.
a
Mean Standard Error of Difference 95% Confidence Interval of the Difference tdfSig (2-Tailed)
AF basal T0-AFbasalT1 149.81 25.34 200.2 to 99.42 5.91 86 <.0001
b
Rbasal T0-RbasalT1 0.06 0.27 0.48 to 0.6 0.22 86 <.8275
AFdecongT0-AFdecongT1 1139.86 24.92 189.4 to 90.32 5.61 86 <.0001
b
RdecongT0-RdecongT1 0.06 0.28 0.5 to 0.62 0.21 86 <.315
Abbreviations: AFbasalT0, nasal airflow basal before topic treatment; AFbasalT1, nasal airflow basal after topic treatment; AFdecongT0, nasal airflow after
decongestant before topic treatment; AFdecongT1, nasal airflow after decongestant after topic treatment; RdecongT0, nasal resistance after decongestant before
topic treatment; RdecongT1, nasal resistance after decongestant after topic treatment; RbasalT0, nasal resistance basal before topic treatment; RbasalT1, nasal
resistance basal after topic treatment; sig, significance.
a
AF in cm
2
/s; R in Pa/cm
2
/s.
b
p< 0.05.
NP294 Ear, Nose & Throat Journal 100(6)
Authors’ Note
Giuseppina Marcuccio and Domenico Testa contributed equally to
this work.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared the following potential conflicts of interest
with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
article: All participants in peer-review and publishing have no con-
flicts of interest since they have no financial or personal relationship
that might bias or be seen bias their work.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, author-
ship, and/or publication of this article.
ORCID iD
Giuseppina Marcuccio https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9211-5523
Gaetano Motta https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7899-5691
References
1. Hildenbrand T, Weber RK, Brehmer D. Rhinitis sicca, dry nose
and atrophic rhinitis: a review of the literature. Eur Arch Otorhi-
nolaryngol. 2011;268(1):17-26.
2. Ly TH, de Shazo RD, Olivier J, Stringer SP, Daley W, Stodard
CM. Diagnostic criteria for atrophic rhinosinusitis. Am J Med.
2009;122(8):747-753.
3. Hosomi A, Arita M, Sato Y, et al. Affinity for alpha-tocopherol
transfer protein as a determinant of the biological activities of
Vitamin E analogs. FEBS Lett. 1997;409(1):105-108.
4. Yadav SK, Adhikary B, Chand S, Maity B, Bandyopadhyay SK,
Chattopafhyay S. Molecular mechanism of indomethacin-induced
gastropathy. Free Rad Biol Med. 2012;52(7):1175-1187.
5. Trapanese A, Gambardella V, Scaldarella LO, et al. L’utilizzo di
tocoferolo acetato nel trattamento sintomatico delle distrofie vul-
vari. Giorn It Ost Gin XXVII 3 Marzo. 2005;XXVII:84-87.
6. D’Avenia G, Zanchi M. Due casi di psoriasi vulvare trattati con
a-tocoferolo acetato gel per uso topico. Rivista di ostetricia gine-
cologia pratica e medicina perinatale. 2002;XVII(4):2-5.
7. Galuppi A, Perrone AM, La Macchia M, et al. Local a-tocopherol
for acute short-term vaginal toxicity prevention in patients treated
with radiotherapy for gynecologic tumors. Int J Gyn Cancer.
2011;21(9):1708-1711.
8. Gambardella V, Sorrentino N, Ciotola A, et al. Utilizzo del toco-
ferolo acetato nella terapia delle vaginosi batteriche in gravi-
danza. Giornale Italiano di Ostetricia e Ginecologia. 2008;
XXX(1-2):13-18.
9. Meydani M. Vitamin E. Lancet. 1995;345(8943):170-175.
10. Osnengo G, Massarenti I, Panin G, Grio R. Tocoferolo acetato in
ovuli vaginali: nuovo trattamento topico dopo conizzazione cer-
vicale. La Colposcopia Italia. 2006;XXI(2):23-26.
11. Casella G, Di Prima T, Ferlito S, Rapisarda E. Stomatite aftosa
ricorrente: patologia multifattoriale dalle nuove possibilita` tera-
peutiche. Il Dentista Moderno. 2007;XXV(5).
12. Gastaldi G, Bardellini E, Flocchini P. Topical alpha-tocopherol in
the treatment of decubitus ulcers due to prothesic trauma in
patients with oral lichen planus. Doctor OS. 2003;14(8):883-886.
13. Azzi A. Molecular mechanism of a-tocopherol action. Free Radic
Biol Med. 2007;43(1):16-21.
14. Testa D, Marcuccio G, Panin G, et al. Nasal Mucosa healing after
after endoscopic sinus surgery in chronic rhinosinusitis of elderly
patients: role of topic alpha-tocopherol acetate. Aging Clin Exp
Res. 2017;29(1):191-199.
15. Rusznak C, Devalia JL, Lozewicz S, Davies RJ. The assessment
of nasal mucociliary clearance and the effects of drugs. Resp Med.
1994;88(2):89-101.
16. Nappi C, Di Spiezio Sardo A, et al. Functional and Morphological
evaluation of the nasal mucosa before and after hormone replace-
ment therapy in postmenopausal women with nasal symptoms.
FertilSteril.2003;80(3):669-671.
17. Dutt SN, Kameswaran M. The aetiology and management of
atrophic rhinitis. J Laryngol Otol. 2005;119(11):843-852.
18. Moore EJ, Kern EB. Atrophic rhinitis: a review of 242 cases. Am J
Rhinol. 2001;15(6):355-361.
19. Nielsen BC, Olinder-Nielsen AM, Malmborg AS. Successful treat-
ment of ozena with ciprofloxacin. Rhinology. 1995;33(2):57-60.
20. Park MJ, Jang YJ. Successful management of primary atrophic
rhinitis by turbinates reconstruction using autologous costal car-
tilage. Auris Nasus Larynx.2018;45(3):613-616.
21. Deborah S, Prathibha KM. Measurement of nasal mucociliary
clearance. Clinical Res Pulomonol. 2014;2(2):10-19.
Testa et al NP295
... У всех пациентов наблюдалось улучшение ощущения сухости в носу и нарушения восприятия носового потока воздуха. Риноманометрическое исследование показало увеличение носового потока воздуха при последующем наблюдении (P < 0,05), мукоцилиарный клиренс носа -сокращение среднего времени транзита (P < 0,05), эндоскопическая оценка -значительное улучшение гидратации слизистой оболочки носа и значительное уменьшение корок в носу и скопления слизи (P < 0,05) [34]. В исследовании среди пожилых пациентов с хроническим риносинуситом в послеоперационном периоде после эндоскопической хирургии придаточных пазух носа наблюдали более быстрое заживление и меньшее количество рецидивов осложнений у пациентов, проходивших местное лечение ацетатом α-токоферола (оценивали восстановление слизистой оболочки, используя суммарный балл риноскопии, и качество жизни, используя анкету для шести назальных симптомов) [35]. ...
Article
Introduction. Dry nose syndrome is a polyetiological condition that is common among patients of all age groups from infancy to profoundly old age. The low effectiveness of treatment is associated with the progression of atrophic mucous membrane degeneration, which also affects the cartilaginous and bony parts of the nasal cavity. Significant impairment of the protective, respiratory and olfactory function leads to decreased quality of life of patients, delayed adaptation, and arrested psychosomatic and physical development of children. Herbal medications refer to the agents that have minimal toxicity and side effects and effectively facilitate the restoration of functional integrity of the mucous membrane. Aim. To discuss the results of studies on the effectiveness of natural medicines in the treatment of patients with dry nose syndrome. Materials and methods. We conducted a literature search and studied publications (articles and relevant abstracts) containing information on various diseases that are accompanied by dry nose syndrome, as well as therapeutic options for this syndrome in Russian and foreign databases. The material was selected according to the following keywords: dry nose syndrome, atrophic rhinitis, mint essential oil, pine essential oil, eucalyptus essential oil. The study was conducted using the search engines Scopus, PubMed, CyberLeninka, Elibrary.ru, Google Scholar. Results and discussion. The study results suggested the potential and benefits of the topical use of a combination medicine containing essential oils of eucalyptus, mint, and pine as a treatment and prophylactic medication in patients with dry nose syndrome. Conclusion. Dyshesol, a herbal medicine that is an oil solution, meets the requirements for complex pathogenetic therapy in patients with dry nose syndrome of various etiologies, and can be recommended as a preventive and therapeutic medication for all age groups, and children from the age of two.
Article
Full-text available
Vitamin E (VE) is a lipophilic vitamin, and Evans and Bishop demonstrated the existence of a hitherto unrecognized dietary factor essential for normal reproduction in rat. During 100 years after the discovery, α-tocopherol (α-Toc) has been the representative species in VE homologues, and both naturally occurring and synthetically prepared α-Toc have been widely used and studied. Although it is indicated by a single-word VE, research on VE involves various chemical species. It is important to understand the fine structure and accurate characteristics of individual VE species when using VE. Each VE sample has compositional and/or isomer issues, and furthermore, the usability greatly varies depending on the modified species of esterification. The VE industry involves many interdisciplinary fields. Improvements in formulation technology and confirmation of the novel biological activity of VE greatly owns its utility and opens up new applications. As the interim period between the start and end of the agenda for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), in this minireview, the recent trends and future guidelines of VE, especially α- Toc, in relation to the SDGs have been demonstrated. graphical abstract Fullsize Image
Chapter
Primary atrophic rhinitis (PAR) is a progressive chronic degenerative condition of unknown aetiology affecting the nasal mucosa. Klebsiella ozaenae is the commonest organism associated with this condition. Diagnosis is based on clinical history, examination and impaired mucocilliary clearance as well as changes on CT sinus imaging. Endoscopic examination reveals a markedly large and wide nasal cavity, turbinate atrophy and visibly dry mucosa, crusting and fetor. Patients complain of nasal blockage, dryness, crusting and fetor. Treatment aims to provide symptom relief, reduce aggravating factors and promote regeneration.
Article
Objective: Atrophic rhinitis (AR) is a rare clinical condition affecting the nasal mucosa. It is characterized by progressive nasal congestion and thick, bothersome nasal secretions. In this narrative review, pathogenesis, differences between the 2 types of AR, new management modalities, and the impact of management on lifestyle have been highlighted. Materials and Methods: An extensive literature search was conducted using PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Saudi Digital Library databases. The articles were investigated to extract information on the pathogenesis, types, new treatment modalities, and the impact of management on lifestyle. Results: AR has primary and secondary types that affect different populations and have specific clinical presentations. Primary AR is common in women and countries with long, warm seasons. Secondary AR is the most common disease in the industrialized world. It is more common among adults who have systemic disease, have undergone extensive nasal surgery, and have experienced nasal trauma. Certain infections, autoimmune disorders, chronic sinusitis, hormonal imbalance, poor nutritional condition, and iron deficiency anemia have been suggested as etiological factors. Conservative treatment is safe, inexpensive, and effective. Hygiene, a well-balanced diet, smoking cessation, and early detection and treatment of nasal pathology can help prevent AR. Some interventions shown to improve quality of life was explained in detail. Conclusions: This paper reviewed published relevant literature on AR related to pathogenesis, types, new treatment modalities, and the impact of treatment on lifestyle, thus, providing a comprehensive view of the management and prevention of AR.
Article
Objective: To review the research progress of the feasibility of a new treatment method for atrophic rhinitis (ATR) based on tissue engineering technology (seed cells, scaffold materials, and growth factors), and provide new ideas for the treatment of ATR. Methods: The literature related to ATR was extensively reviewed. Focusing on the three aspects of seed cells, scaffold materials, and growth factors, the recent research progress of ATR treatment was reviewed, and the future directions of tissue engineering technology to treat ATR were proposed. Results: The pathogenesis and etiology of ATR are still unclear, and the effectiveness of the current treatments are still unsatisfactory. The construction of a cell-scaffold complex with sustained and controlled release of exogenous cytokines is expected to reverse the pathological changes of ATR, promoting the regeneration of normal nasal mucosa and reconstructing the atrophic turbinate. In recent years, the research progress of exosomes, three-dimensional printing, and organoids will promote the development of tissue engineering technology for ATR. Conclusion: Tissue engineering technology can provide a new treatment method for ATR.
Article
Chronic rhinitis encompassing both allergic and non-allergic rhinitis affects a significant portion of the population worldwide, having a great impact on patient quality of life, and associated co-morbid conditions, with an important societal economic burden. Allergists are often the first to evaluate and treat allergic and non-allergic rhinitis, addressing the individual triggers of the disease as well as the patient specific responses to these triggers. This review focuses on the advances that have been made in the diagnosis, management and treatment of non-allergic and allergic rhinitis over the past 10 years, including specific allergen immunotherapy, care pathways and digital health.
Chapter
Atrophic rhinitis is defined as “a chronic debilitating disease of the nasal passages that is characterized by progressive nasal mucosa atrophy, nasal crusting, fetor, and enlargement of the nasal space with paradoxical nasal congestion.” In this case, the discrepancy between the subjective sensation, the objective parameters, and the endoscopic picture is so evident that the symptom is defined as “paradoxical congestion.” Recently, the use of four-phase rhinomanometry (4PR) has been recommended for the assessment of nasal obstruction. In this method, the nasal airway resistance is calculated using hundreds of resistances continuously recorded during the whole breathing cycle. RM has been used also to evaluate the effects of nasal treatments in patients with atrophic rhinitis. In a comprehensive review on the surgical procedures used for the empty nose treatment, authors concluded that given the complexity of the condition and the high degree of failure (up to 21% of patients may report only marginal improvement), before undertaking any surgical procedure in these patients, along with the subjective evaluation, an objective measurement of nasal resistances should also be performed in order to demonstrate the effects of the surgery. Regarding olfactive impairment in atrophic rhinitis, even if it is often described, very few studies were conducted, and fewer again have a well-designed protocol.
Chapter
Atrophic rhinitis (RA) is a progressive disease in which its management, both medical and surgical, largely serves to mitigate but not to stop this process.
Chapter
Atrophic rhinitis represents a chronic disease of unknown origin, characterized by the progressive atrophy of the nasal mucosa and turbinate bones. Common symptoms are nasal obstruction, nasal crusting, foul smell, and sometimes epistaxis. It constitutes a heavy burden affecting patient’s quality of life. The aims of treatment are to eliminate the incriminating factors, to moisturize the nasal mucosa, to clear the nasal crusts, and to improve the functionality of the mucosa of the nose and paranasal sinuses. The treatment should be individualized, according to the disease etiology. Symptomatic approach for atrophic rhinitis includes several methods, such as nasal lavage, local ointments, topical or systemic antibiotics, crusts removal, and eliminating the promoting factors for the mucosal atrophy. Other alternative treatments have been tested during the last years, though results are uncertain and need further investigation. Despite the correct maximal medical treatment, the majority of patients will have nasal crusting and disease relapses, every time the therapy is ceased.
Article
Full-text available
Background Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) in European country ranges in elderly patients from 4.5 to 12% of population and has a significant effect on quality of life. In these patients, rhinosinusitis is linked to immune functions changes with age and to mucosal paraphysiological alterations such as crusting formations with atrophic epithelium, variations of nasal airflow and modifications of the mucociliary clearance. Failure of medical treatments leads to surgery in patients with persistent symptoms and radiographic signs of CRS. The choice of appropriate post-surgical topic treatments is important for healing time and for preventing mucosal complications such as synechiae, crusting formation and atrophy with secondary bacterial and fungal infections. AimsDefining the effects of topic alpha-tocopherol acetate administration on nasal mucosa healing after endoscopic sinus surgery in CRS of elderly patients. Methods In this study were included 32 patients, mean age 68.6, who underwent FESS because affected by CRS not responsive to medical treatments. After surgical treatment, we distinguish two groups basing on local nasal therapy. ResultsWe investigated, in the postoperative time, the role of alpha-tocopherol acetate compared to gomenol oil. Follow-up was performed at 7–15 days and 1–3 months after surgery. We evaluated mucosal restoration using Rhinoscopy Sum Score and quality of life using Nasal Six Items Symptom Questionnaire. We observed a faster healing time and less recurrence of complications in patients who underwent topic treatment with alpha-tocopherol acetate. DiscussionIn our research, we observed that alpha-tocopherol acetate has no contraindications and side effects. Conclusions Our study showed the effectiveness of alpha-tocopherol acetate topic treatment in elderly patients affected by CRS after FESS, in improving and speeding up the process of restoring the sinonasal mucosa, compared to another topic medication.
Article
Full-text available
Data in literature about the use of adjuvant treatment to reduce acute adverse effects of radiotherapy on the pelvis are scant, with the exception of a few reports on the topical use of estrogen, which promotes proliferation of epithelium. In this prospective trial, α-tocopherol acetate was topically administered to patients affected by endometrial and cervical cancer and undergoing radiation treatment to avoid acute vaginal complications. Vaginal application of α-tocopherol reduced vaginal toxicity and pain, although vaginal secretion was not significantly different in the 2 groups studied. The histological scoring system showed a significant reduction of inflammation, no difference in fibrosis, and an increase of acanthosis. The use of α-tocopherol as adjuvant treatment to reduce the acute adverse effects of radiotherapy on the vagina should be considered.
Article
Initial management of primary atrophic rhinitis is conservative, with nasal ointments, saline irrigation, and antibiotics prescribed to relieve symptoms. However, in cases that show no improvement, a surgical approach is considered. Recently, many studies have reported successful surgical outcomes using various nasal implants. However, no study has reported implantation of autologous costal cartilage in PAR patients. We report here the case of a 63-year-old woman diagnosed with PAR that was intractable to medical therapy. Under general anesthesia, bilateral inferior turbinate reconstruction with autologous costal cartilage was successfully performed without any complications. One month after surgery, her symptoms improved dramatically. At the 2-year follow-up, her Sinonasal Outcome Test 25 (SNOT-25) score was 6, down from an initial score of 108. Her OMU CT showed improved sinonasal mucosal thickness and disappearance of thick mucosal secretion compared with preoperative CT image. Although this is a single case experience, it is suggested that turbinate reconstruction using autologous costal cartilage can serve as promising surgical modality for management of atrophic rhinitis.
Article
Atrophic rhinitis is a chronic, debilitating and recalcitrant disease of the nasal cavities that is prevalent in several parts of the world. It has unique epidemiological features and clinical characteristics. Clinicians and researchers for decades have tried to postulate theories for the aetiology of the primary form of the disease. Management of the disease has seen several medical therapeutic regimens including alternative forms of medicine. Surgical options for the condition are also not completely satisfactory with a number of failures and recurrences. The authors provide here a comprehensive review of the existing literature as regards the aetiology and management of this refractory condition.
Conference Paper
Atrophic rhinitis is a debilitating nasal mucosal disease of unknown etiology. It is characterized by, progressive nasal mucosal atrophy, nasal crusting, fetor, and enlargement of the nasal space with paradoxical nasal congestion. Primary atrophic rhinitis has decreased markedly, in incidence in the last century. This probably relates to the increased use of antibiotics for chronic nasal infection. Secondary, atrophic rhinitis resulting from trauma, surgery, granulomatous diseases, infection, and radiation exposure accounts for the majority of cases encountered by, the rhinologist today. Excessive turbinate surgery, has been both acquitted and accused in the literature as an etiology, for secondary, atrophic rhinitis. We saw 242 patients with the diagnosis of atrophic rhinitis between 1982 and 1999. The diagnosis vt,as confirmed by, physical examination, biopsy, and imaging studies. Patients were diagnosed with primary atrophic rhinitis if their condition det,eloped in a, previously healthy nose and secondary atrophic rhinitis if their condition developed after sinonasal surgery, trauma, or chronic granulomatous disease. Prevention and treatment of the disease is discussed.
Article
Atrophic rhinitis is a chronic, debilitating and recalcitrant disease of the nasal cavities that is prevalent in several parts of the world. It has unique epidemiological features and clinical characteristics. Clinicians and researchers for decades have tried to postulate theories for the aetiology of the primary form of the disease. Management of the disease has seen several medical therapeutic regimens including alternative forms of medicine. Surgical options for the condition are also not completely satisfactory with a number of failures and recurrences. The authors provide here a comprehensive review of the existing literature as regards the aetiology and management of this refractory condition.
Article
The probable cross talk among large numbers of inflammatory and angiogenic parameters in indomethacin (IND)-induced gastropathy and the associated signaling mechanism were studied in a mouse model. A single dose of IND (18 mg/kg, po) produced robust gastric ulceration in mice without any mortality, which peaked on the third day, but started healing from the fifth day onward. The ulceration was associated with increased myeloperoxidase activity and expression of proinflammatory (TNF-α, adhesion molecules, COX-2) and antiangiogenic (endostatin) parameters. The levels of proangiogenic factors such as COX-1, prostaglandin E, VEGF, and von Willebrand factor VIII were downregulated by IND. Our results revealed that although the maximal and minimal levels of these parameters were attained sequentially at different time points, TNF-α upregulation was the primary event to initiate and induce gastric ulceration. IND also activated NF-κB and all the MAP kinases, but only the inhibitors of TNF-α, NF-κB, and JNK MAP kinase could abrogate the IND-induced damages. Further TNF-α inhibition also reduced the IND-mediated activation of NF-κB and JNK MAP kinase. All this evidence strongly suggests that mitigation of TNF-α may offer a potential solution to IND-mediated gastropathy.
Article
Despite the fact that many people suffer from it, an unequivocal definition of dry nose (DN) is not available. Symptoms range from the purely subjective sensation of a rather dry nose to visible crusting of the (inner) nose (nasal mucosa), and a wide range of combinations are met with. Relevant diseases are termed rhinitis sicca anterior, primary and secondary rhinitis atrophicans, rhinitis atrophicans with foetor (ozena), and empty nose syndrome. The diagnosis is based mainly on the patient's history, inspection of the external and inner nose, endoscopy of the nasal cavity (and paranasal sinuses) and the nasopharynx, with CT, allergy testing and microbiological swabs being performed where indicated. Treatment consists in the elimination of predisposing factors, moistening, removal of crusts, avoidance of injurious factors, care of the mucosa, treatment of infections and where applicable, correction of an over-large air space. Since the uncritical resection of the nasal turbinates is a significant and frequent factor in the genesis of dry nose, secondary RA and ENS, the inferior and middle turbinate should not be resected without adequate justification, and the simultaneous removal of both should not be done other than for a malignant condition. In this paper, we review both the aetiology and clinical presentation of the conditions associated with the symptom dry nose, and its conservative and surgical management.
Article
Patients with atrophic rhinosinusitis have intractable upper airway symptoms that result from loss of the normal nasal epithelium. There is no consensus on how to diagnose this condition, and diagnostic criteria are not available to perform multicenter treatment trials. We sought to establish diagnostic criteria for atrophic rhinosinusitis. Twenty-two patients for whom there was a consensus on the diagnosis of atrophic rhinosinusitis were compared with a control group of 22 randomly selected patients with garden-variety chronic rhinosinusitis. Medical records were reviewed on all patients and clinical data were tabulated. Clinical variables included the presence of nasal obstruction, epistaxis, anosmia, purulence, crusting, chronic inflammatory disease involving the upper airway, and multiple sinus surgeries. Both groups had similar degrees of persistent nasal obstruction (82% vs 77%). The other 6 clinical features occurred more frequently in patients with atrophic rhinosinusitis than controls (P <.05). Patients with chronic rhinosinusitis and recurrent nasal purulence had a 25-fold (95% confidence interval [CI], 2.9-221.7) increased probability, those with recurrent epistaxis had a 12-fold increased probability (95% CI, 1.3-106.8), and those with 2 or more sinus surgeries had a 15-fold (95% CI, 3.5-66.7) increased probability of having atrophic rhinosinusitis. As the number of symptoms increased, there was an increasing probability of the predetermined diagnosis of atrophic rhinosinusitis (P <.05). The presence of chronic rhinosinusitis and any 2 of the 6 clinical features for 6 months or longer resulted in a sensitivity of 0.95 and specificity of 0.77 for the diagnosis of atrophic rhinosinusitis. The diagnosis of the common secondary form of atrophic rhinosinusitis may be made with certainty if a patient with chronic rhinosinusitis demonstrates 2 or more clinical features for 6 months and longer. These features are patient-reported recurrent epistaxis or episodic anosmia; or physician-documented nasal purulence, nasal crusting, chronic inflammatory disease of the upper airway, or 2 or more sinus surgeries.