Preprint

Blockchain Imperialism in the Pacific

Authors:
Preprints and early-stage research may not have been peer reviewed yet.
To read the file of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

PLEASE see the open access and peer reviewed version of this work either on my research gate page or at Big Data & Society

No file available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the file of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Although blockchain is often posed as a revolutionary and disruptive technology, its politics and socio-technical configurations often align with aims to maintain the status quo, and/or aims to concentrate wealth and to make existing powers more efficient. I empirically describe how colonial-contingent, neoliberal economic policies in Puerto Rico have incentivized the techno-capitalist industries of cryptocurrency and blockchain. Portions of the archipelago are being re-made into a so-called “crypto-utopia” to satisfy the desires of new settlers in a new form of crypto-colonialism. Puerto Rican government organizations, institutions, and businesses are also engaging blockchain technology with differing intents, all using rhetoric as a covert design tool. In this paper I will focus on blockchain and cryptocurrency as neoliberal and libertarian technologies adopted by governmental agencies, businesses, organizations, and individuals, as well as efforts of resistance through alternative, decolonial design.
Article
Full-text available
This paper describes one of Oxfam's pilot projects exploring blockchain technology, focusing on the non-technological, institutional challenges faced by the organization. There is an emerging literature on blockchain for social good, however, this predominantly focuses on the use cases and issues relating to applying the technology in international development projects. A gap in the literature exists regarding the non-technological aspects of blockchain projects both within the sector and more broadly. Addressing this gap is critically important as many of the promises of blockchain technology will only eventuate in their fullest when whole ecosystems are using the technology. To get there requires a transition period and it is this transition period that holds the key to success for organizations exploring the technology. This paper goes some way to addressing this gap. It does so by describing a specific case study and unpacking some of the organizational challenges associated with implementing a blockchain-based project in the international development and humanitarian sector. This has important implications for the sector as blockchain technology becomes ever more present as a tool capable of reducing inequality and addressing power imbalances. The Oxfam case study described in this paper highlights the difficulty many not-for-profits are having engaging with the technology. The lessons are drawn from a specific use case of a current pilot project using blockchain technology in a cash transfer preparedness project in a small island developing state. Although important and insightful, this paper does not focus on the specifics of the application of the technology but rather discusses the myriad non-technological challenges faced from Oxfam Australia's perspective. These are categorized into three main areas: awareness and understanding of the technology, capacity constraints of in-house support services in providing relevant support for a nascent technology, and issues related to engaging in non-traditional partnerships. The paper concludes by recommending further areas of research and suggestions to develop practical tools and guidance to help the international development and humanitarian sector navigate this emerging technology.
Article
Full-text available
Digital innovation and data practices are increasingly central to the humanitarian response to recent refugee and migration crises. In this article, I introduce the concept of technocolonialism to capture how the convergence of digital developments with humanitarian structures and market forces reinvigorates and reshapes colonial relationships of dependency. Technocolonialism shifts the attention to the constitutive role that data and digital innovation play in entrenching power asymmetries between refugees and aid agencies and ultimately inequalities in the global context. This occurs through a number of interconnected processes: by extracting value from refugee data and innovation practices for the benefit of various stakeholders; by materializing discrimination associated with colonial legacies; by contributing to the production of social orders that entrench the “coloniality of power”; and by justifying some of these practices under the context of “emergencies.” By reproducing the power asymmetries of humanitarianism, data and innovation practices become constitutive of humanitarian crises themselves.
Article
Full-text available
A number of small South Pacific nations suffer from a lack of robust international banking relationships and a shortage of foreign reserves. The Republic of the Marshall Islands decided a solution to these problems was to create a sovereign cryptocurrency for the country. Other small nations in the region are attempting to follow the Marshall Islands and create their own cryptocurrencies. This case explores the opportunities and threats of such a bold financial experiment and raises questions concerning the future of sovereign cryptocurrency in the region and beyond.
Article
Full-text available
Yochai Benkler defines commons-based peer production as a non-market sector of information, knowledge and cultural production, which is not treated as private property but as an ethic of open sharing and co-operation, and is largely enhanced by the Internet and free/open source software. This paper makes the case that there is a tension between Benkler’s liberal commitments and his anarchistic vision of the commons. Benkler limits the scope of commons-based peer production to the immaterial production of the digital commons, while paradoxically envisaging the control of the world economy by the commons. This paradox reflects a deeper lacuna in his work, revealing the absence of a concrete strategy as to how the immaterial production of the digital commons can connect to material production and control the world economy. The paper concludes with an enquiry into some of the latest efforts in the literature to fill this gap.
Article
Full-text available
In the present techno-political moment it is clear that ignoring or dismissing the hype surrounding blockchain is unwise, and certainly for regulatory authorities and governments who must keep a grip on the technology and those promoting it, in order to ensure democratic accountability and regulatory legitimacy within the blockchain ecosystem and beyond. Blockchain is telling (and showing) us something very important about the evolution of capital and neoliberal economic reason, and the likely impact in the near future on forms and patterns of work, social organization, and, crucially, on communities and individuals who lack influence over the technologies and data that increasingly shape and control their lives. In this short essay I introduce some of the problems in the regulation of blockchain and offer counter-narratives aimed at cutting through the hype fuelling the ascendency of this most contemporary of technologies.
Article
Full-text available
“Code is law” is a form of regulation whereby technology is used to enforce existing rules. With the advent of Blockchain and Machine Learning, we are witnessing a new trend, whereby technology is progressively taking the upper-hand over these rules.
Article
Full-text available
We introduce Casper, a proof of stake-based finality system which overlays an existing proof of work blockchain. Casper is a partial consensus mechanism combining proof of stake algorithm research and Byzantine fault tolerant consensus theory. We introduce our system, prove some desirable features, and show defenses against long range revisions and catastrophic crashes. The Casper overlay provides almost any proof of work chain with additional protections against block reversions.
Article
Full-text available
"Code is law" refers to the idea that, with the advent of digital technology, code has progressively established itself as the predominant way to regulate the behavior of Internet users. Yet, while computer code can enforce rules more efficiently than legal code, it also comes with a series of limitations, mostly because it is difficult to transpose the ambiguity and flexibility of legal rules into a formalized language which can be interpreted by a machine. With the advent of blockchain technology and associated smart contracts, code is assuming an even stronger role in regulating people's interactions over the Internet, as many contractual transactions get transposed into smart contract code. In this paper, we describe the shift from the traditional notion of "code is law" (i.e., code having the effect of law) to the new conception of "law is code" (i.e., law being defined as code).
Article
Full-text available
The global food crisis of 2008 presented the neo-liberal development model with its sharpest international challenge since the Asian economic crisis of the late 1990s. Responding to the crisis, many of the world's poor vociferously protested their condition, forcing world leaders, international institutions and the global media to take stock of the systemic failure. This article is concerned with gauging the response of neo-liberal discourse to the crisis as articulated through the global media and institutions. Political Economy of the Media and Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA), are here utilized as a means to identify the hierarchy of actors and the political formations that are mobilized in response to the crisis, at the level of international projection. The article argues that what emerges from the food crisis is a defining causal structure of economism/urgency/new consensus, which manages to simulate radical self-reflexivity while securing further terrain for the expansion of neo-liberalism.
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, the world of social media and online networking has met with the world of international development, leading to rapid changes in development practice and to the emergence of new fields of study. Proponents of this change argue that the Internet provides the tools for global cooperation and participation. However, the reality is less clear, with critics asserting that much of the Information and Communication Technology and networking discourse and practice is rooted in past approaches to development. This reflects a wider debate about whether ICT provides space for alternative views and social movements, or if it represents a new form of networked “information colonialism.” Drawing on ethnographic research with the online development-oriented network projecthonduras.com, this paper reflects on these debates, and on the wider implications of social media in development practice. An early model of peer-to-peer collaboration in development, projecthonduras.com has over a decade of networking experience and has been the catalyst for many connections and encounters, which have, at times, literally saved lives. However, while research with this network highlights some potential for disintermediated and inclusive networking, it also provides an example of a conventional development approach operating within an online space, and illustrates the impact of digital exclusion and homophily. Using the networking concepts of disintermediation, participation and diversity/homophily, this paper explores the structure and discourse of projecthonduras.com and illustrates the paradoxical nature of ICT and social media in development, providing a cautionary note to those who look to social media to provide answers to contemporary development dilemmas.
Article
According to many observers, economic globalization and the liberalization of telecoms/internet policy have remade the world in the image of the United States. The dominant roles of Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Google have also led to charges of US internet imperialism. This article, however, argues that while these internet giants dominate some of the most popular internet services, the ownership and control of core elements of the internet infrastructure—submarine cables, internet exchange points, autonomous system numbers, datacenters, and so on—are tilting increasingly toward the EU and BRICS (i.e., Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa) countries and the rest of the world, complicating views of hegemonic US control of the internet and what Susan Strange calls the knowledge structure.
Article
Biometric technologies are routinely used in the response to refugee crises with the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) aiming to have all refugee data from across the world in a central population registry by the end of 2019. The article analyzes biometrics, artificial intelligence (AI), and blockchain as part of a technological assemblage, which I term the biometric assemblage. The article identifies five intersecting logics that explain wider transformations within the humanitarian sector and in turn shape the biometric assemblage. The acceleration of the rate of biometric registrations in the humanitarian sector between 2002 and 2019 reveals serious concerns regarding bias, data safeguards, data-sharing practices with states and commercial companies, experimentation with untested technologies among vulnerable people, and, finally, ethics. Technological convergence amplifies risks associated with each constituent technology of the biometric assemblage. The article finally argues that the biometric assemblage accentuates asymmetries between refugees and humanitarian agencies and ultimately entrenches inequalities in a global context.
Article
This article proposes a conceptual framework of how the United States is reinventing colonialism in the Global South through the domination of digital technology. Using South Africa as a case study, it argues that US multinationals exercise imperial control at the architecture level of the digital ecosystem: software, hardware and network connectivity, which then gives rise to related forms of domination. The monopoly power of multinational corporations is used for resource extraction through rent and surveillance – economic domination. By controlling the digital ecosystem, Big Tech corporations control computer-mediated experiences, giving them direct power over political, economic and cultural domains of life – imperial control. The centrepiece of surveillance capitalism, Big Data, violates the sanctity of privacy and concentrates economic power in the hands of US corporations – a system of global surveillance capitalism. As a feature of surveillance capitalism, Global North intelligence agencies partner with their own corporations to conduct mass and targeted surveillance in the Global South – which intensifies imperial state surveillance. US elites have persuaded people that society must proceed according to its ruling class conceptions of the digital world, setting the foundation for tech hegemony. The author argues for a different ecosystem that decentralises technology by placing control directly into the hands of the people to counter the rapidly advancing frontier of digital empire.
Book
Over the past five centuries, advances in Western understanding of and control over the material world have strongly influenced European responses to non-Western peoples and cultures. In Machines as the Measure of Men, Michael Adas explores the ways in which European perceptions of their scientific and technological superiority shaped their interactions with people overseas. Adopting a broad, comparative perspective, he analyzes European responses to the cultures of sub-Saharan Africa, India, and China, cultures that they judged to represent lower levels of material mastery and social organization. Beginning with the early decades of overseas expansion in the sixteenth century, Adas traces the impact of scientific and technological advances on European attitudes toward Asians and Africans and on their policies for dealing with colonized societies. He concentrates on British and French thinking in the nineteenth century, when, he maintains, scientific and technological measures of human worth played a critical role in shaping arguments for the notion of racial supremacy and the “civilizing mission” ideology which were used to justify Europe’s domination of the globe. Finally, he examines the reasons why many Europeans grew dissatisfied with and even rejected this gauge of human worth after World War I, and explains why it has remained important to Americans. Showing how the scientific and industrial revolutions contributed to the development of European imperialist ideologies, Machines as the Measure of Men highlights the cultural factors that have nurtured disdain for non-Western accomplishments and value systems. It also indicates how these attitudes, in shaping policies that restricted the diffusion of scientific knowledge, have perpetuated themselves, and contributed significantly to chronic underdevelopment throughout the developing world. Adas’s far-reaching and provocative book will be compelling reading for all who are concerned about the history of Western imperialism and its legacies. First published to wide acclaim in 1989, Machines as the Measure of Men is now available in a new edition that features a preface by the author that discusses how subsequent developments in gender and race studies, as well as global technology and politics, enter into conversation with his original arguments.
Chapter
This chapter explores a new medium for documenting Pacific tourism between the world wars: Kodachrome. Vast increases in tourism coincided with intense transitions in the region, with European colonial networks still entrenched and US expansionism soon to exert its greatest impact. Many locales tourists encountered were on the verge of total militarization, the culmination of centuries of political and commercial competition. These rare films can provide insights not only into color film history and shifting perceptions of cinematic realism, but into the fashioning of imperial and cosmopolitan selves during a period when ‘old’ colonial networks were yielding to ‘American Pacific’ ambitions.
Article
We are often told that data are the new oil. But unlike oil, data are not a substance found in nature. It must be appropriated. The capture and processing of social data unfolds through a process we call data relations, which ensures the “natural” conversion of daily life into a data stream. The result is nothing less than a new social order, based on continuous tracking, and offering unprecedented new opportunities for social discrimination and behavioral influence. We propose that this process is best understood through the history of colonialism. Thus, data relations enact a new form of data colonialism, normalizing the exploitation of human beings through data, just as historic colonialism appropriated territory and resources and ruled subjects for profit. Data colonialism paves the way for a new stage of capitalism whose outlines we only glimpse: the capitalization of life without limit.
Book
Neoliberalism--the doctrine that market exchange is an ethic in itself, capable of acting as a guide for all human action--has become dominant in both thought and practice throughout much of the world since 1970 or so. Writing for a wide audience, David Harvey, author of The New Imperialism and The Condition of Postmodernity, here tells the political-economic story of where neoliberalization came from and how it proliferated on the world stage. Through critical engagement with this history, he constructs a framework, not only for analyzing the political and economic dangers that now surround us, but also for assessing the prospects for the more socially just alternatives being advocated by many oppositional movements.
Article
In recent years, much has been written on ‘big data’ in both the popular and academic press. After the hubristic declaration of the ‘end of theory’ more nuanced arguments have emerged, suggesting that increasingly pervasive data collection and quantification may have significant implications for the social sciences, even if the social, scientific, political, and economic agendas behind big data are less new than they are often portrayed. Compared to the boosterish tone of much of its press, academic critiques of big data have been relatively muted, often focusing on the continued importance of more traditional forms of domain knowledge and expertise. Indeed, many academic responses to big data enthusiastically celebrate the availability of new data sources and the potential for new insights and perspectives they may enable. Undermining many of these critiques is a lack of attention to the role of technology in society, particularly with respect to the labor process, the continued extension of labor relations into previously private times and places, and the commoditization of more and more aspects of everyday life. In this article, we parse a variety of big data definitions to argue that it is only when individual datums by the million, billion, or more are linked together algorithmically that ‘big data’ emerges as a commodity. Such decisions do not occur in a vacuum but as part of an asymmetric power relationship in which individuals are dispossessed of the data they generate in their day-to-day lives. We argue that the asymmetry of this data capture process is a means of capitalist ‘accumulation by dispossession’ that colonizes and commodifies everyday life in ways previously impossible. Situating the promises of ‘big data’ within the utopian imaginaries of digital frontierism, we suggest processes of data colonialism are actually unfolding behind these utopic promises. Amid private corporate and academic excitement over new forms of data analysis and visualization, situating big data as a form of capitalist expropriation and dispossession stresses the urgent need for critical, theoretical understandings of data and society.
Article
In this article I assess the challenges and opportunities of using online social network services as international platforms for development and for networking global civil society. A human rights framework and information ethics approach are used to identify principles as they are transposed to the internet, to evaluate dominant trends in social network sites (SNSs) and to theorise how human rights might be embedded into the technical design of new and existing online social networks. The central research question is ‘how can SNSs affirm and uphold a “people centered, inclusive and development-oriented information society” (WSIS 2005)?’ Ideal values and outcomes of a public service social network include interoperability, privacy, transparency, autonomy, participatory design, cultural and linguistic diversity, support for oral cultures and non-technical populations, open access and the commons. Affordances and functions of existing SNSs include sociability, sharing, interaction, homophily, social capital and power, and network effects. Examining tensions between values and affordances, public and private interests, can help guide the design and implementation of SNSs for international networking and development.
Article
At the center of contemporary discourse on technology — or the digital discourse — is the assertion that network technology ushers in a new phase of capitalism which is more democratic, participatory, and de-alienating for individuals. Rather than viewing this discourse as a transparent description of the new realities of techno-capitalism and judging its claims as true (as the hegemonic view sees it) or false (a view expressed by few critical voices), this article offers a new framework which sees the digital discourse as signaling a historical shift in the technological legitimation of capitalism, concurrent with the emergence of the post-Fordist phase of capitalism. Technology discourse legitimated the Fordist phase of capitalism by stressing the ability of technology and technique to mitigate exploitation. It hence legitimated the interventionist welfare state, the central planning in businesses and the economy, the hierarchized corporation, and the tenured worker. In contrast, contemporary technology discourse legitimates the post-Fordist phase of capitalism by stressing the ability of technology to mitigate alienation. It hence legitimates the withdrawal of the state from markets, the dehierarchization and decentralization of businesses, and the flexibilization of production and the labor process.
Game changer': Oxfam is trialling a stablecoin for disaster response
  • A Fenton
Fenton A (2019) 'Game changer': Oxfam is trialling a stablecoin for disaster response. Micky. Available at: https://micky.com.au/gamechanger-oxfam-is-now-giving-crypto-to-disaster-victims/ (accessed 30 July 2019).
Building the Caribbean digital economy bit by bit
  • D Gallegos
Gallegos, D. (2019). Building the Caribbean digital economy bit by bit. World Bank Blogs. Retrieved from: https://blogs.worldbank.org/latinamerica/building-caribbean-digitaleconomy-bit-bit.
Attack of the 50 foot blockchain
  • D Gerard
Gerard, D. (2018). Attack of the 50 foot blockchain. Author.
Facebook's new currency has big claims and bad ideas
  • D Gerard
Gerard, D. (2019). Facebook's new currency has big claims and bad ideas. Foreign Policy. Retrieved from: https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/06/24/971554-facebook-bitcoin-libra-cryptobad/.
Launch of the Blockchain TechCamp
  • M Goldman
Goldman, M. (2018). Launch of the Blockchain TechCamp, US Embassy in Fiji, Kiribati, Nauru, Tonga and Tuvalu. Retrieved from: https://fj.usembassy.gov/charge-daffaires-michael-goldman-speech-launchof-the-blockchain-techcamp/.
Bitcoin as politics: distributed right-wing extremism. Moneylab Reader: An Intervention in the Digital Economy
  • D Golumbia
Golumbia, D. (2015). Bitcoin as politics: distributed right-wing extremism. Moneylab Reader: An Intervention in the Digital Economy. Amsterdam: Institute of Network Cultures.
The Politics of Bitcoin
  • D Golumbia
Golumbia D (2016) The Politics of Bitcoin. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
A chat with Amanda Gutterman, CMO at ConsenSys and Ethereal co-creator Ethereal Summit
  • A Gutterman
Gutterman A (2019) A chat with Amanda Gutterman, CMO at ConsenSys and Ethereal co-creator Ethereal Summit. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=89&v=y9B2PeHTfVI (accessed 22 July 2019).
Blockchain' is meaningless. The Verge
Jeffries A (2018) 'Blockchain' is meaningless. The Verge. Available at: https://www.theverge.com/2018/3/7/17091766/blockchain-bitcoinethereum-cryptocurrency-meaning (accessed 1 July 2019).
  • J Käll
Käll J (2018) Blockchain control. Law Critique, 29(2): 133-140.
Personal Communication
  • K Katafono
Katafono K (2019) Personal Communication. July 12.
2047: A retrospective from the other side of the trust revolution
  • J Lubin
Lubin J (2019) 2047: A retrospective from the other side of the trust revolution. ConSenys. Available at: https://media.consensys.net/highlights-from-joe-lubins-ethereal-nykeynote-2019-7683c65d6d95 (accessed 27 July 2019).
Identity and Reputation, ConsenSys Academy
  • C Lundkvist
  • A Keys
Lundkvist C and Keys A (2015) Identity and Reputation, ConsenSys Academy. Available at: https://consensys.net/academy/blockchainbasics-book/self-sovereign-identity-and-reputation/ (accessed 16 August 2019).
Networking the world 1794-2000 Minneapolis
  • A Mattelart
Mattelart, A. (2010). Networking the world 1794-2000 Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
To Save Everything Click Here
  • E Morozov
Morozov E (2014) To Save Everything Click Here. New York: Public Affairs.
Camp to explore blockchain potential. The Fiji Times
  • L Movono
Movono L (2018a) Camp to explore blockchain potential. The Fiji Times.
Blockchain tech. The Fiji Times
  • L Movono
Movono L (2018b) Blockchain tech. The Fiji Times. April 12. Available at: https://www.fijitimes.com/blockchain-tech-2/ (accessed 9 August 2019).
The people versus the commission: Resistance to land registration in Fiji's early colonial history
  • R Nicole
Nicole R (2016) The people versus the commission: Resistance to land registration in Fiji's early colonial history. Conference Proceedings. Available at: http://repository.usp.ac.fj/9090/ (accessed 27 August 2019).
Fiji Imports, Exports and Trade Partners
OEC (2019). Fiji Imports, Exports and Trade Partners. Retrieved from: https://oec.world/en/profile/country/fji/.
Marshall Islands launches 'the Sovereign', the world's first crypto tender Finance Magnates
  • J Patterson
Patterson J (2018) Marshall Islands launches 'the Sovereign', the world's first crypto tender Finance Magnates. Available at: https://www.financemagnates.com/cryptocurrency/news/cryptocurrencyn ewsmarshall-islands-launches-sovereign-worlds-first-crypto-tender/ (accessed 30 July 2019).
TLTB working closely with ADB to improve it land price index, Fiji Village
  • L Reece
Reece L (2019). TLTB working closely with ADB to improve it land price index, Fiji Village. May 5. Available at: https://fijivillage.com/news/TLTB--working-closely-with-ADB--to-improve-its-land-price-index-2r95ks/ (accessed 28 August 2019).
US blockchain startup to operate special economic zone in Papua New Guinea ETHNews
  • A Reese
Reese A (2018) US blockchain startup to operate special economic zone in Papua New Guinea ETHNews. Available at: https://www.ethnews.com/us-blockchain-startup-to-operate-specialeconomic-zone-in-papua-new-guinea (accessed 30 July 2019).
Bypassing banking with bitcoin In The Black
  • A Rollins
Rollins, A. (2017). Bypassing banking with bitcoin In The Black. Retrieved from: https://www.intheblack.com/articles/2017/08/01/bitcoin-bypassesbanks.