Content uploaded by P. Matthijs Bal
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by P. Matthijs Bal on Jan 23, 2023
Content may be subject to copyright.
Chapter
THE PSYCHOLOGY OF ROBOTIZATION OF WORK:
FOUR FANTASIES OF TECHNOLOGY1
P. Matthijs Bal
!
"#
$%
ABSTRACT
&#'()
#'*&
()#'*&
#()#
#'(#*
$#'()(
##
*
Keywords:#'
+&#), %-."-/+0 $
%*
1%23#4**)*
INTRODUCTION
(#'-(()
' * &
'( ( (
()()$#*&5#)(
###(
#*&#
# ' ()
'
6** #7*&
8
( ( #
*
9 5
*& )
(#$+0#*
#(67
67#((
# $+0 3 : * &
# # ( 2 (
$ ( (
:( $(
* & : (
# ( :
(
:#*
& #' () 6 #' at
()7#(#;<*
=2 # 5
=2(=2=2
( ()
:#6**98(#-/+>7*&
( discourse #
5#*9
=2 =2
( ( ( =#*2 &
5*%##(9#)&(
(( # =*2 & (
#$6**5$
(###=27#(#
*&(#
)( #(#
-&#''(
*
The Psychology of Robotization of Work
(=2*%##(
3##
()((
(6**ideological (7*%
=*2
)
#*?
=2 #* & ## )
:
#*
THREE VIEWS OF TECHNOLOGY
$# #
(*9$()(
#=2*
(
(*?(;<exponential
###*% :
) #
##5##
()6$+07*%(
#$$# (#
*@$
(##6(#-/+>7*
$$:
6 ** A# -/+07* & () 2
# (6** B#7
: # ) # ( (
(C9#)2
*!(
##5(6
$+0 7* ? $
5
: * $ (
*B#
#*B(#)(
##*(
6((((
7#(($
#not )((#*
##) #)2
(5$$$$*
.
P. Matthijs Bal
&(67( #$
(*&()#(
##)*&
()?6-/+D7 )6-/+07
6-/+E7*&(
=2(6**-/+07*
) #( ((
* & # ( B#
# 6 $+0 7* ,
# ## (
*,#
)#(#'
6#BFG)7*9
(*@
( )
:#
##*?)#
( # * 9
(#*
Fantasy #1: Robots Replace Humans at Work
&#()##
()*&##B#(
2()(#()#
#*&8B#(#
( ) # * ?( C# 6-/+H7
##
B# ( 5 *
C#6-/+H7)##B#B#
()#*?(
C#(((
=2B#5
# B# 6-/+E7B#=
2=2(*?:
(B##(
5B#*)
( ) 5 I &
$+0(#(B#B#
# *J(:
(B#(B##
(6**($#7#
() (
*
;
The Psychology of Robotization of Work
()FG)6+0H0-/+/7=5
25*%
5!J$
(*##=#2*
<#' 55
(=)2B#().*@
#'
# (# #
*#
' C 9#)(
# # (*?
5=2(()#
B#*(5##
#(((*
# # 5
=#2#*@:
(B##2#
( B#;* #
: ( B# ( ( #
# human-like # ( # robot-like*
2 5 # 3
((((
*#'5'
8()( #
'(5D*,
(#'()*(
() # '
#()$($
()67*?:
)(B##
( # $
#5>I
Fantasy #2: Technology Saves Humanity
##
* % # $* &
. & ( # =) 2 (
*
; % ) 5
*,#
(*
D! ()*&
'()678##*
> : # 5' # '
= 2 #
:*
D
P. Matthijs Bal
)#)
*@#
(*&
6**()7##
#*C$
#=(2=2
# ($ $ 6&
C-/+07* &$ #
($#
((*5 #(
# # #( J$ 5 #
#(*#6 #-/+07()
(*
(#(#
# # 6** 7*
$K$
:(*9
JE6**#+//)6J
-/+07+*E(6-/+07J7
#6J,,-/+07*&=2'
:#
#()#
( 67* & # $ (
( *
# (
2 ( ' 6$
7(#
*25##
(*!(
##
##(
(6LM
-/+H7*@ ' )
= 2 B $
5 # 5
(6$+0(8#=)(2
(#7*
Fantasy #3: No Work, But Income
E5
5'*)'
N$9#%<*
>
The Psychology of Robotization of Work
$#')
5*J#
96(#-/+>7()(
: # )* ?(
( ( ( # # $)
!9*&B#(
#(##$($(
#*&(3(#()B#(#
67()##*%
($B#(#=2()
(####*&()
O(*&#'67
##*&
J'2)8(J'
()((5
#(
55(()(
5*#$#
()(()##*&(##
#*
9(##
(*
+D$ ()() (
( ()() (*
# ) ()
() * % (( 5
$#()(
'()()
* =#2 ()
(#)()(*&
=2 ()* !
#
*#(
6$7
6**#B#7
() =2 #6 #
7* %#(#
*
?( ( # #
* # #
#5(=2#'*&
# 5# (((#*%
55 #
%)9##'*
((
((=2# *?(
E
P. Matthijs Bal
(#
:(##*$#6(
7 # ()
# ( ( 5* 9
(#5#(
( (#*
(##6
=(27##*
((#)(
#=2#*!
##5
(:###(
# (B * ( #
)#=2##5)
((*&
(# '= 2
56(5#
8&C-/+0#75##(
)#(
(*
Fantasy #4: Technology Will Free Humanity
J( 6$7##
(#*&
((*@
2 (
*,67#()
#* ()(((
#*&# (#8#
(( (* % (
*
)((#*&
##*
(B#8#
' ' 5 (
*(#=@#2
6**!-/+07*
?(
# * ( )( =2
#((#O5
' * 9#) #
2 #*
*&(
*&#
H
The Psychology of Robotization of Work
5
* @A##)6-/+07(
( ( ( #
*& other
((
#(
##=#*2#
((
##*@(
()(##(6#
7
#*&##)
92 6+0EE7 (
*6**(
C9#)!%'%7(
#6(7*%
$(#)
*
Work Psychology and Technology
&:#(
() *&
()(#*()
(
(
(#B"
% 6*-/+E7*<(()
()
()P!5':
''Q6L!-/+>*.>07*
())
#()
#*
#:(5'
(':6**7*
958
(((*&)
5:(#('
( # 6 C ? ! 6C -/-/7
)7*())
:((((((((
*#()
) !69,
#-/-/7()*%
0
P. Matthijs Bal
'()
)(#(*
REFERENCES
%! 6-/+07* ?( @# R !) ! SS*
3OO(((*#*O(ITC B*#%-/%-/-/*
!* 6-/+E7*UDignity in the workplace: New theoretical perspectives* %3
*
* !* L M * 6-/+H7* J# () '
*UEuropean Journal of Work and Organizational PsychologyU276D7D.>$D;H*
J* 6-/+E7* % # & C < ?*
3OO(((*#*O(IT: D,"EN*#%-/%-/-/*
* 9* L ! <* 6-/+>7* ?( ()
'*UAnnual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational
BehaviorU3.;0$.ED*
6-/+07*'B3('#B
)* 3OO*O+/;E;O$$$'$B$$$$('$
$$#B$$)OD>;-.HE.+0;E/$..>->I#T(%<-A
!,-(H&C'%J(A>(%VJ<?N!<"ED.#5+* #
%-/%-/-/*
9!* 6+0EE7* Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison* J( @)3 R
)*
9,, 6-/-/7* & 9 ) ,' * 3OO(((*
(*O*#-/%-/-/*
C 6-/-/7* C ? !* 3OO**OOWW*
#%-/%-/-/*
C#*6-/+H7*UBullshit jobs*J(@)3L*
?@*6-/+D7*@?3P&$< QX&)C*
3OO(((*#*O(IT>DNW#*#%-/%-/-/*
J 6-/+07* J3 B* 3OO(((*
)*O$$B*#%-/%-/-/*
"* "* V* * * L9C* 6-/+E7* 3%
(*UJournal of
Applied PsychologyU1026E7+/ED*
J,, 6-/+07* 3 = 2 ( (*
3OO*)(*OO(O#$$$$$$$($
(*#%-/%-/-/*
# 6-/+07* %<, & <#* 3OO(((*#*O* #
%-/%-/-/*
) * 6-/+07* J(*** X ) X &) C*
3OO(((*#*O(IT') ,?-<)*#%-/%-/-/*
+/
The Psychology of Robotization of Work
(# * 6-/+>7* The Fourth Industrial Revolution: what it means, how to respond.
3OO(((*(*OO-/+>O/+O$$$$($$
$$($$O*#%-/%-/-/*
6-/+07* Total number of dairy cows in the Netherlands from -//E -/+E 6
+///7* 3OO(((**OO>;>E+.O$#$$$($$$
O*#%-/%-/-/*
& C 6-/+07* C* 3OO(((**OO
*#%-/%-/-/*
& C 6-/+0#7* Rise in EU citizens not getting UK settled status causes alarm*
3OO(((**OO-/+0OO./O$'$)$$$*
#%-/%-/-/*
FG)*6+0H07*&##B*R*
A')*6-/+/7*ULiving in the end times*R*
A#*6-/+07*UThe age of surveillance capitalism: The fight for a human future at the new
frontier of power* )*
++