ArticlePDF Available

Man a Kill a Man for Nutin’: Gang Transnationalism, Masculinities, and Violence in Belize City



Belize has one of the highest homicide rates in the world; however, the gangs at the heart of this violence have rarely been studied. Using a masculinities lens and original empirical data, this article explores how Blood and Crip “gang transnationalism” from the United States of America flourished in Belize City. Gang transnationalism is understood as a “transnational masculinity” that makes cultural connections between local settings of urban exclusion. On one hand, social terrains in Belize City generated masculine vulnerabilities to the foreign gang as an identity package with the power to reconfigure positions of subordination; on the other, the establishment of male gang practices with a distinct hegemonic shape, galvanized violence and a patriarchy of the streets in already marginalized communities. This article adds a new body of work on gangs in Belize, and gang transnationalism, whilst contributing to theoretical discussions around the global to local dynamics of hegemonic masculinities discussed by Connell and Messerschmidt (2005) and Messerschmidt (2018).
Man a kill a man for nutin’:
Gang transnationalism, masculinities, and
violence in Belize City
Adam Baird
Author post-print (accepted)
Original citation & hyperlink:
Baird, A. 2019, 'Man a kill a man for nutin’: Gang transnationalism, masculinities, and
violence in Belize City' Men and Masculinities, vol. (In-Press), pp. (In-Press).
DOI 10.1177/1097184X19872787 ISSN 1097-184X
ESSN 1552-6828
Publisher: Sage
Copyright © and Moral Rights are retained by the author(s) and/ or other copyright owners. A
copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission
or charge. This item cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining
permission in writing from the copyright holder(s). The content must not be changed in any way or
sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright
This document is the author’s post-print version, incorporating any revisions agreed during the
peer-review process. Some differences between the published version and this version may
remain and you are advised to consult the published version if you wish to cite from it.
Man a kill a man for nutin’:
Gang transnationalism, masculinities, and violence in Belize City
Belize has one of the highest homicide rates in the world, however the gangs at the heart of
this violence have rarely been studied. Using a masculinities lens and original empirical data
this article explores how Blood and Crip ‘gang transnationalism’ from the USA flourished in
Belize City. Gang transnationalism is understood as a ‘transnational masculinity’ that makes
cultural connections between local settings of urban exclusion. On one hand, social terrains in
Belize City generated masculine vulnerabilities to the foreign gang as an identity package with
the power to reconfigure positions of subordination; on the other, the establishment of male
gang practices with a distinct hegemonic shape, galvanised violence and a patriarchy of the
streets in already marginalised communities. This article adds a new body of work on gangs in
Belize, and gang transnationalism, whilst contributing to theoretical discussions around the
global to local dynamics of hegemonic masculinities discussed by Connell and Messerschmidt
(2005; 2018).
1. Introduction
Belize is a small country of 350,000 people on the Caribbean Sea sharing borders with Mexico
to the north and Guatemala to the west. It is unique being both Central American, a member of
SICA, and Caribbean, a member of CARICOM
. Belize is also a fledgling nation, a former
colony named British Honduras in 1878 which gained independence 1981. Although
popularised as a tourist destination there is another side to the country. National murder rates
reached 45 per 100,000 in 2017 making Belize one of the most violent countries in the world,
comparable to its ‘noisy neighbours’ in the Northern Triangle countries of El Salvador,
Guatemala and Honduras (Peirce, 2017). Murders are driven by gang violence in the poor
Central America Integration System; Caribbean Community and Common Market
Southside area of Belize City located on the coast, which is so severe one local school teacher
lamented “young men round here have become an endangered species” (Greta 14/11/2017).
Despite copious amounts of scholarship on gangs in neighbouring countries, besides the
research presented here, Gayle et al are the only other international scholars to publish on
violence in Belize that draws from original data with gang members (2016).
This article explores how Blood and Crip ‘gang transnationalism’ emanating from the United
States of America (US) became established and then flourished on Southside, and why high
levels of violence persist today. Whilst this is a rare empirical contribution about gangs in
Belize, masculinities are front and centre of the analysis, which is built inductively from the
street (see Methodology below). The impacts of exclusion are gendered and on Southside
created a palpable masculine vulnerability amongst youths to transnational Blood and Crip
culture as an aspirational site of identity formation. In this way, the social terrain was rendered
receptive to the establishment of gangs, which is significant for contexts of urban exclusion
beyond Belize.
Whilst this provides a narrative frame for the rapid embedding of gangs, this article adds to
theoretical discussions around the global, regional, and local dynamics of hegemonic
masculinities. For the first time, gang transnationalism is conceived as a form of transnational
masculinity’ after Connell and Messerschmidt, who have discussed the potential for localised
models of hegemonic masculinity (2005; 2018).
This article is mindful not reduce gangs to a rigid hegemonic identity, recognising that
individual and collective practices are multifaceted and complex, and that masculinities are
indeed multiple. It draws upon sociological interpretations of gangs to argue that the gang
displays and performances i.e. the gang persona and ‘gangsta culture’ - established by the
Bloods and Crips in Belize have a concerted ‘hegemonic shape’ that has galvanised violence
and a patriarchy of the streets. Despite the rapid Creolisation (also kriolisation, see Hall, 2015),
and fragmentation of street gangs on Southside in recent years, the hegemonic shape of certain
gang behaviours persists. This article aims to provide a rigorous empirical and conceptual
exploration of gang practices as a form of localised hegemonic masculinity. Given that the
overwhelming majority of gang interventions are masculinities blind, understanding gang
activities as a form of localised hegemonic practice is presented as a way rethink and
reinvigorate the approach to gang interventions to reduce the harm done to marginalised urban
The article is structured as follows: (2) reviews the relevant literature subdivided into ‘gang
transnationalism’ and ‘gangs and masculinities’; (3) outlines the methodology used, which
draws upon the authors unique experience of designing the only masculinities focused gang
prevention programme on Southside; whilst (4) provides a contextual background to gang
violence in Belize City. These are followed by substantive analytical sections on (5) gang
transnationalism as a form of transnational masculinity, (6) and the ‘hegemonic shape of
gang practices and the continuity of violence.
2. Literature and contribution
Gang Transnationalism
Gang transnationalism is a subsection of the broader academic literature on gangs dominated
by the US deportation experiences of the Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13) and Barrio/Calle 18
gangs, often collectively termed maras. Up to 50,000 individuals were sent back to their emigre
countries El Salvador, Honduras, Guatemala, and Nicaragua in Central America during the
1990s, although maras did not emerge significantly in the latter (Cruz, 2014; Zilberg, 2011).
Most research on gang transnationalism concludes that they are social forms of street level
youth gang with no clear federal or transnational criminal structure, and are migratory socio-
cultural phenomenon as opposed to the expansion of an international criminal network
(Jütersonke, Muggah, & Rodgers, 2009; Roks & Densley, 2019). Maras first developed in
Northern Triangle countries as a localised cultural capital populated by disenfranchised male
youths. Evidence of gang transnationalism as a cultural or subcultural phenomenon is
corroborated through studies of the Latin Kings and Queens who migrated from the US to
Ecuador, and later Europe (Brotherton, 2007; Cerbino & Barrios, 2008; Quierolo Palmas,
2009). As Rodgers and Baird (2015) have argued, the literature indicates that transnational
gangs are a globalised socio-cultural and political youth phenomena that tend to arise as a
diaspora in the country of return in contexts of persistent exclusion, either organised in situ by
migrant gang members, or by disaffected youths that aspire to gang membership.
Northern Triangle countries were contending with legacies of post-war violence, undergoing
transitions to democracy from dictatorship, military oppression and civil conflict, which shaped
the societies that gangs inserted themselves into (Levenson, 2013; Savenije & van der Borgh,
2015). A range of factors are attributed to the rise of maras including exclusion, connectedness
to organised crime and drug trafficking, and the role of politics (Berg & Carranza, 2018),
including counter-productive mano dura crackdowns (e.g. Gutierrez Rivera, Strønen, &
Ystanes, 2018; Wolf, 2017).
The literature on Blood and Crip transnationalism is sparse. Exceptions in the Americas include
include Flores, Gemert, Hagedorn, and Johns (2009; 2001; 2008; 2014) and Roks & Densley
in Europe (2017; 2019). In the Belizean case only Miller Matthei & Smith (1998) have focused
on transnatnioalism, although this research took place before the dramatic rise in gang violence
in the country. In stark contrast to maras, research on gangs in Belize is scarce. Although this
is not a comparative article, key similarities and divergences between the maras and the Bloods
and Crips will be referred to in section (4) to contextualise the Belizean gang experience within
the Central American region. Finally, amongst the gang transnationalism literature, this is the
first masculinities reading of the phenomenon.
Gangs and masculinities
Historically, scholars have written about the polymorphous threats of marginality that render
disenfranchised young men susceptible to the lure of gang life. The notion of ‘protest’
masculinity is not a new one (Adler, 1928) and early studies in the US referred to gangs as a
male backlash against socio-economic exclusion where working class young men were blocked
from achieving conventional male goals (e.g. Bloch & Niederhoffer, 1958; Cloward & Ohlin,
1966). These ideas permeated later studies where the gang has been consistently seen as an
opportunity structure for ‘capital acquisition’ or ‘masculine capital’ that generates status,
esteem and respect for men in subordinated contexts (Baird, 2012a; Mullins, 2006; Mullins &
Lee, 2019). The literature has tended to present gangs as a homosocial enactment, display or
performance, based on variants of the ‘code of the street’ (notable examples include: Anderson,
2000; Bourgois, 1995, 2001; Brotherton, 2007; Venkatesh, 2008). Bourgois’s framing of
young men in search of respect’ has gained significant traction amongst those seeking to
explain the masculine dynamics of contemporary urban violence (e.g. Zubillaga, 2009). The
ganging process(Baird, 2018a) has been conceptualised as a form of gendered socialisation
that insulates boys and young men from the threat of emasculation in the urban margins,
reflected in findings across the globe (e.g. Barker, 2005; Buller, 2015; Heinonen, 2011; Jensen,
2008). Most notably in sociology and anthropology, gangs have been considered socially
generated epiphenomena of structural violence, and this frames the protest, resistant, rebellious
and compensatory reactions by young men to societal expectations to achieve predominantly
traditional, normative, and hegemonic forms of masculinity.
Critically, feminist scholarship (e.g. Cobbina, Like-Haislip, & Miller, 2010; Maher, 1997;
Miller, 2001) has warned against masculinist criminological assumptions that essentialise gang
members to their aberrant or violent traits, and fail to recognise multiple masculinities,
glossing-over the textures of gender relations in gang settings (these debates are well covered
by Fraser, 2017; Panfil & Peterson, 2015; and Peterson, 2018); how violence affects women
(Saunders-Hastings, 2018; Zulver, 2016); and the strategies women use to negotiate violent
ganglands (Baird, 2015; Cobbina et al., 2010).
The richness of recent ethnographic literature shows that the pursuit of masculinity amidst
exclusion provides an important, although partial insight into the subjectivities that lead some
into gang violence (Levenson, 2013; Mullins & Cardwell-Mullins, 2006). Notably, labelling
gang members’ masculinities as a ‘hyper’ or ‘exaggerated’ has limited explanatory power when
presented as a monotone identity. Furthermore, de la Tierra (2016) roundly criticises the recent
work of Contreras, Goffman and Rios (2012; 2014; 2011) as one dimensional presentations of
‘perilous masculinity’ that obscure the potential range of situationally enacted, relationally
constructed, and hierarchical masculinities expounded by Connell and Messerschmidt’s
rethinking of hegemonic masculinities in 2005. However, scholarship in Latin America has
taken noteworthy strides in teasing out the meanings of masculinity, particularly how these
relate to violence (such as Gutmann & Viveros Vigoya, 2005; Theidon, 2007).
Contemporary analyses gangland masculinities have advanced sociological ideas about
violence as a situationally dependent phenomenon, where the ganging process promotes the
‘baddest’ to leadership positions (Baird, 2018a). As opposed to a reductive exercise that
essentialises the gang experience, this applies a masculinities lens to explain violence as one
component, albeit an important one, of a repertoire of potential behaviour. In this vein,
Levenson-Estrada refers to the marero [who] has turned into a gendered killer/killed persona,
a male warrior” (2013, p. 97). This allows for multiple masculinities that are both contextually
and situationally dependent. In recent studies, gang members have been shown to be loving
fathers, sons or boyfriends in certain socialisation spaces, whilst murders or rapists in others,
all of which can occur within the same community, on the same day (Baird, 2018b; Fontes
2018). Fundamentally, the masculine ‘protest’ of the gang may be an insurrection against
structural constraint, but it rarely challenges local gender hierarchies that subjugate women and
non-hegemonic masculinities. On balance, they are more likely to reinforce them.
Progress in the theorisation of masculinities as configurations of practice allow for nuanced
interpretations of gangs as a form of localism that can be applied to contexts in the global south.
Jewkes et al (2015) have debated this at length reflecting Connell and Messerschmidt’s (2005)
efforts to rethink their concept of hegemonic masculinity, suggesting they can be analysed as
multiple collective hegemonic projects, at global, societal, and local levels. In 2018
Messerschmidt revisited these, arguing that at a regional level hegemonic masculinities can
provide cultural materials to be adopted or reworked, providing models of masculinity that are
important in local gender dynamics, practices and interactions (p. 53). These dynamics provide
conceptual leverage for understanding gang transnationalism as a form of transnational
masculinity established in the local.
This article argues that gang transnationalism is a migrant form of gendered localism that
requires a receptive terrain to bed-in effectively. Most obviously, the race, class, and rebellious
cultural dynamics of Blood and Crip gang identities appealed to poor young Creole Belizeans
as a site of opportunity, elevated gender status and aspirational manhood. The Bloods and Crips
brought Messerschmidt’s ‘model’ of masculinity with them, which was adopted, then reworked
and kriolised by vulnerable young men. Clearly, we should not reduce the gang experience to
hegemonic masculinity alone, likewise we cannot deny the distinct hegemonic shape of gang
practices, including violence.
3. Methodology
Based on four research trips to Belize between 2011 and 2018
, the methodology was built
cumulatively as an ethnographic revisit, by layering together short-term trips of three to four
weeks. Whilst this is not an unusual approach to research, what gave the methodology
sufficient rigour to peer beneath the surface was the author’s experience of designing the
Southside Youth Success Programme (SYSP) in 2011 (Baird, 2011). This was the first
masculinities focused gang intervention project attempted in Belize, which ran in collaboration
with UNDP and the Ministry of Youth Development, Social Transformation, and Poverty
Alleviation, until 2014. This created a foundation of relationships with individuals across
government, state, and civil society, which were key to making short-term research trips
effective. For example, colleagues at SYSP facilitated numerous interviews with young men
from Southside that had passed through the programme. Being known as a foreigner who had
worked on Southside was a crucial in gaining trust from respondents who otherwise may have
been unwilling to speak candidly about sensitive issues. Belize City is a small town and locals
are understandably reluctant to talk about gangs, crime, and political corruption to outsiders.
Interviews were conducted with six active and six former gang members; eight male youth
participants in two gang intervention programs
; a local rapper and dancehall singer, both
former gang members; the wife a murdered gang leader; one individual from drug trafficking
family; and, six recorded interviews and numerous informal conversations with inhabitants
The author acknowledges the important role played by the British Academy, Leverhulme Trust, and Coventry
University in funding the research; further thanks UNDP Belize and the University of Belize for sponsoring a
Masculinities and Violence conference held in Belmopan, March 2018, to disseminate and discuss the research
Southside Youth Success Program; Belize National Youth Apprenticeship Program.
from Southside. This was supplemented by four focus groups on Southside, one with young
men, one with young women, a mixed group, and one group of mothers. Fifty-six local experts
were interviewed comprising of youth workers, teachers, NGO staff, academics, police
officers, prison wardens, magistrates, civil servants, politicians, UN and embassy staff.
The methodology included time spent on the streets with gangs, in youth detention centres, and
Belize Central Prison. However, interviewing gang members is clearly not without risk
. This
was mitigated through the use of gatekeepers, including; a local Iman to enter the prison, a
well-liked youth worker who helped conduct impromptu interviews on Southside, and a
politician who arranged meetings with gang leaders at her office. The author’s experience of
gang research in the region also provided a foundation of ‘ethnographic safety’, an intuitive
understanding of the rules of the game around street violence (Baird, 2018b), although risks
cannot be assuaged completely. These experiences helped the collection of primary data with
gang members which is rare precisely because it is hard to obtain, although sometimes a little
fortune is needed: the first leader of the Crips in Belize (Angel, below) who was long ‘retired’,
was a driver contracted regularly during the fieldwork, although it took several years of
bonding before he finally revealed his former identity and agreed to be interviewed.
4. Gang violence in Belize
Below the Haulover Creek that bisects Belize City and it’s 60,000 inhabitants, Southside is
comprised of ramshackle neighbourhoods, many built on unforgiving peri-urban marshlands.
Southside and one notorious downtown street called Majestic Alley, has played host to gang
violence since the 1980s. Belize is a country characterised by elitism and inequality and
residents south of the creek have long been at the bottom of the country’s socio-economic strata
Ethical approval was secured from the Centre for Trust, Peace, and Social Relations at Coventry University.
(UNICEF Belize, 2011; Warnecke-Berger, 2019, p. 197). The country has decidedly mixed
heritage, with sizeable Mayan, Spanish, Mestizo, and Garifuna (afro-indigenous) populations.
The Creole minority of African descent makes up 15% of the national population but accounts
for the majority of Southside’s residents. It is therefore unsurprising as Gayle says, that the
majority of gang members there are black and brown (2016, p. 192).
In 1961 Hurricane Hattie laid waste to Belize City creating a national emergency. A lack of
housing in addition to already fragile livelihoods and severe unemployment prompted a
significant exodus north and by the turn of the millennium 30% of the entire population resided
in the US (Vernon, 2000). Migration to the US proved pivotal as the deportation of Blood and
Crip, red and blue ‘colors’, gang members back to Belize City was the spark for the country’s
gang culture.
Whilst Belize shares the Northern Triangle deportation model of gang transnationalism it most
noticeably diverges along the lines of ethnicity and language. The Creole, and to a lesser extent
Garifuna migrants that joined gangs understandably gravitated towards the English-speaking
African-American Bloods and Crips, not the Latino, Spanish speaking 18th Street and MS 13
mara gangs, thus defining the gang identities of future deportees. Those who joined the Bloods
and Crips in the US were deported for the first time in the early 1980s. These were the pioneers
of gang transnationalism in Belize, arguably pre-dating the emergence of the maras in Central
America. There are no reliable figures for 1980s deportations, but across a decade between
1992-2002 there were 1,122 deportees (Warnecke-Berger, 2019).
The first wave of Bloods and Crips met a nascent democratic system with limited
institutional capacity to enforce the Rule of Law. Angel, who was deported in 1981 for his
part in a drive-by shooting in Los Angeles was due to serve the remainder of his sentence in
Belize: I was taken to di plane in da US, then [when I landed in Belize] notin’ happen! [his
emphasis] I jus’ walk off di plane. I cum home to my aunty here in Belize City, in Majestic
Alley (20/05/2016)
. He went on to become the first leader of the Majestic Alley Crips in
1981. In contrast to post-conflict countries saturated with weapons in the Northern Triangle,
Angel noted the absence of firearms upon arrival when Blood and Crip street culture began:
Firs’, we were selling weed, crack-cocaine hadn’t even touched Belize. I started sellin’,
hustlin’, whateva, jus’ to mek a buck. There weren’t gangs den, jus’ little hoodies, guys who
hang out and try to hustle… There weren’t really any guns, we used to chase our enemies
wid a stick and machete… den we started ta walk round in blue rags, blue clothes, y’know.
Both Bolland and Shoman (1997; 2011) recorded the post-independence role of political
clientelism in underpinning the emergence of the United Democratic Party (UDP) and the
People’s National Party (PNP). Whilst there is no specific literature referring to the role of
political parties in gang development in Belize City, numerous interviewees, including gang
leaders Angel, Shorty and Vartas, referred to clientelist relationships that peaked in the run-up
to elections, “People only vote for what they getting off the politicians” (Shorty 19/11/2016).
Locals stated that the 1990s Generals (leaders) of the George Street Bloods and Majestic Alley
Crips were connected to political parties and ran a ‘tight operation’ with structure and discipline
that kept a lid on factional gang spats (Bill 15/11/2017; Muhammad, 2015, p. 71). One
frustrated local politician even regretted the eventual loss of the Generals Boys don’t respect
gang structure anymore, they just want a gun… they steal, they lie, and are out of control”
(Shirley, 18/05/2016), reflecting the way clientelist control of the streets has declined.
By the early 1990s gangs were being taken seriously by authorities. In 1991 a Crimes
Commission was set up to create legislation responding to growing public concern around the
gang phenomenon. Responses included mano dura type crackdowns, representing clear
dissonance with clientelist forms of gang engagement, and for the first time in the country’s
Quotations from interviews have been written phonetically where the interviewees spoke with a pronounced
Creole accent. These tended to be young people and gang members, whilst expert interviewees would typically
‘lighten their tongue’ or ‘speak American’ for the benefit of foreigners.
history the Belizean Defence Force was deployed to the streets (Miller Matthei & Smith, 1998),
although present day responses are led by the specially created Gang Suppression Unit. As
with the maras these measures have proved to be counter-productive, driving the
“overutilization” of juvenile incarceration where young men are regularly held for lengthy pre-
trial periods on misdemeanour charges, as they say locally “fi wan stick o weed”, for one joint
(Peirce, 2017, p. 5; UNDP 2013).
The crack-downs of the 1990s failed, giving way to party-led attempts at gang negotiations,
but these proved unsustainable. Murder rates rose from 9 per 100,000 in 1995, to 17 in 2002,
to 30 in 2006, and 45 in 2017 (Peirce, 2017; UNODC, 2018). By 2008 there were over 30
gangs in Belize City with 500 youth members, and in 2015 gang membership had tripled to
1,500 as gang territories packed closer together (Haylock, 2013, p. 46; Peirce, 2017, p. 21).
One seventeen-year-old gang member said that in the St Martins neighbourhood alone there
were four gangs; Peace in the Village, Bacalan (Back-of-land) Crips, the Complex City Crips,
and the Third World Bloods, estimating that half of all young males in the area were in gangs
(Smalls 12/05/2016). Instead of becoming more institutional, organised criminal enterprises
like some cliques of maras, Southside gangs have splintered into ever smaller groups,
multiplying ‘beefs’. As one civil servant put it “It’s interpersonal violence at a gang level”
(9/11/2017). Shorty moved to Los Angeles at six years old, later joined the Bloods, and was
deported back to Belize in 2011, becoming a local gang leader. When interviewed in Belize
Central Prison he said:
It about small beefs, [gang members] be like chil’ren. One beef started because
someone step on someone else’s shoe in a club, and now they can’t even remember
what the original beef was about Like a dog in a cage, then you put another one in,
and it ok. Then you throw a piece of meat in and they gonna kill each otherMan a
kill a man for nutin’, for no reason, it’s fucked up
This fragmenting process meant that, counterintuitively, gang violence has risen whilst gang
institutionalisation has gone backwards over the last two decades. Despite spanning some four
decades, gangs in Belize are currently very much at the margins of organised crime and
transnational drug trafficking networks. Although gangs sold crack-cocaine in the late l980s,
Shorty said nowadays cocaine only ended up on Southside when someone found a bale
jettisoned by traffickers washed up at the beach. This was corroborated during an interview
with a member of a significant drug trafficking family from the coast who said their clandestine
networks deliberately avoided street gangs (interview, 22/05/2016).
In 2017 Belize City’s murder rate reached 99 per 100,000, placing it amongst the top ten most
violence cities in the world, with an estimated rate on Southside at 128 per 100,000 (Arciaga
Young, 2019; Peirce, 2017). Violence and trauma amongst boys in the city is now estimated to
be higher than anywhere else in Caribbean (Gayle et al., 2016). Belize reflects the male
demographic of gang violence regionally, where the vast majority of victims and perpetrators
of murder are poor young men, or as Muhammad said in prosaic terms, Belizean gangs are “a
black thing, a youth thing, an urban thing, a poor thing, an unskilled, undereducated and
unemployed thing” (2015, p. 69).
5. Gang transnationalism as transnational masculinity
The modern identity of Belize has been moulded by colonialism and migration. One local
academic lamented Colonial history means we have been taught to embrace and value the
foreign more than our own history. Everything that is great is fucking foreign, even Jesus is
foreign” (Raul 15/11/2017), and another that “there is an inherent sense of shame about
Belizean culture and history” (Nia 15/11/2017). A confluence of historic, cultural and socio-
economic circumstances on Southside contributed to a propensity amongst a number of youths
to “embrace that [US] ghetto culture… because Creole culture is not held sacred, young gang
members have no recollection of history” (Raul 15/11/2017). Evoking Espange’s notion of
‘cultural transfer’ (1999), US gangs represented a rebellious black youth identity that
transposed fluidly into Belize City’s urban margins as gangs “discursively appeared”
(Warnecke-Berger, 2017, p. 256) in blue and red:
Media images of the gangster in the 1980s and 1990s were the black youth of Los Angeles,
New York… his gait, his stance, his mannerism and language formed a prototype that was
made a global iconic figure… whilst these images were foreign in style, there were socio-
economic and historical conditions for our own crop of gang activity… in Belize today we
see more than the imitation of a foreign culture, we see the creations of [gang members]
with their own set of values and definitions of what society is about and what means they
will use to survive in a social environment they view as increasingly hostile and unfair…
they lost hope and as a result became rebellious to the status quo (Muhammad, 2015, pp.
His gait, his stance, his mannerism’ noted by Muhammad underscore the gender dynamics of
this cultural transfer, hence gang transnationalism can be understood as a ‘transnational
masculinity’ that makes cultural connections between local settings of urban exclusion; i.e.
from South Central Los Angeles to Southside Belize City. On Southside, multiple and historic
marginality generated masculine vulnerabilities to the foreign gang as an identity package with
the apparent power to radically reconfigure positions of subordination. From this perspective,
gang transnationalism is a migrant form of gendered localism that requires a receptive
destination terrain that reflects (at least some of) the intersections of race, class, and
subordination found in the originating locale.
Blood and Crip culture spread in a fertile environment. The aforementioned ‘global iconic
figure’ of the disenfranchised young black man striking back at structural violence was a
compelling symbol in a post-colonial Belize disposed to revere the foreign. Early Bloods and
Crips quickly gained influence over young men and boys pledging allegiance to them, as Carlos
an eclectic former gang member, then prison officer, and current youth worker explained:
Carlos: So [in the 1980s] Belizeans now have these American [Bloods and Crips] guys here
who are deported, saying this is how we have to dress… they would bring back a couple of
barrels of clothes, and den share dat wid de guys.
Author: So, they were building like a cultural identity?
Carlos: Exactly! Y’understand. Den when clothing come in, it would be basically for dat
specific gang… At da time you wud wear di khaki pants and da white t-shit, wid your red
rag, den you wud be a Blood… Or red pants, red shirt, red bandana. And di Crip wud have
di blue rag… dis ting was comin’ from America, y’undersand? Because we did not have da
finance to purchase them. So, di gang leader would distribute [clothes] and he would be seen
as good, ‘Hey! He’s looking out for us!’ So that is his defence now, he is giving them money,
clothes, he protects them, he gives them weapons as a form of defence. So, people [young
men] start to pledge allegiance to these guys (11/05/2016)
Two principle factions developed, the George Street Bloods and the Majestic Alley Crips.
Angel, the first leader of the Crips recalled how earnest beginnings scaled-up into lethal
My friend he started acting real gangster da way America does it, you know. He’s da one
dat decide dat Majestic Alley wud be blue, and anyting over swing-bridge [George Street],
dat’s red.
Yeah, in ‘87, ‘88, we use to go fight at a local disco. If you from over di bridge, we pick a
fight wid’you, wid knife an’ machete. Dey were serious fights, but not really wid guns.
First, we were selling weed, crack cocaine hadn’t even touched Belize [in the early 1980s].
Da cocaine came in lik di ‘85. I started hustlin’, whateva, jus’ to make a buck. There weren’t
gangs den, jus little hoodies, there weren’t really guns. I tink I was about 17 maybe, I hold
ma firs’ gun, an’ da first man dat talk big, I shoot in his chest.
I buy my firs’ [gun] from a farmer. Den we go an’ kidnap di watchman, an’ took his 16
[gauge shotgun] an cut di barrel shaaf [shaft]. We call it saadaaff [sawn-off], you could stick
it in your side, you run up into your enemy and you jus’ bus-it [fire it] and run aff (Angel,
Smoking in Belize City predates transnational gangs, and relatively benign Base Boys who
sold marijuana on the streets were swiftly subsumed by the new gang identities and began
selling small amounts of crack cocaine. Successful gang leaders achieved notoriety and by the
1990s Generals George ‘Junie Balls’ McKenzie a Crip form Majestic Alley, and later ‘Shiney’
from George Street Bloods (Muhammad, 2015, p. 169) had become iconic figures amongst the
local population and pivots for political party clientelism. It is telling that within a generation
the Bloods and Crips emerged as a standout model for young male Creole success across
Southside. Those with the capacity for violence such as Generals and gunmen were admired,
even reified, by younger generations as ‘big men’:
Yah. More money, more bigger you get. Den man com’ to trade gun for crack, gun for weed.
So, I sell weed, but if I have no army, man [rival gang member] com an’ tek it away. I use’
to pack a 9mm and a 357… dat a barrel gun, it sound lik a bomb exploded, so everybody
respec’ you. Dat a Big Man gun you know (Angel, 20/05/2016).
Being red or blue had become aspirational and ontologically salient amongst local meanings
of masculinity, mirroring gang research in Colombia and Guatemala (Baird, 2018a; Saunders-
Hastings, 2018). Whilst this analysis chimes with previous interpretations of gangland
masculinities as a protest against structural constraint, we should be wary of presenting gang
members straightforwardly as disenfranchised rebels. In the Belizean case the assertion of
transnational gang identities in the local simultaneously established the gang as a hegemonic
masculine project with negative outcomes for host communities. Whilst gangs are in part a
male reaction to deprivation, many of their activities reassert hegemonic practices that
reinforce a patriarchy of the streets. The gang persona becomes a vessel that vulnerable young
men fill with their gendered ambitions and fantasies of manhood built around their “soldier
heroes” (after Dawson, 1994).
Complex histories of poverty on Southside generated a deeply gendered vulnerability to gang
transnationalism which arrived as an aspirational and accessible form of masculinity at a time
when a young nation was finding its feet. The following section considers how the hegemonic
shape’ of gang practices, particularly violence, have remained consistent across generations of
gang members, even when gang structures themselves have changed rapidly.
6. The hegemonic shape of gang practices
As Southside gangs began to splinter at the turn of the millennium, micro-level ‘beefs’
proliferated. Gangs are now broadly acknowledged to be disorganised with fast-flowing
ephemeral membership, a far cry from the early days of the Generals. As Shorty said “Gangs
here are childish, they don’t know what they’re doing… Everyone spend their money and be
broke the next day(19/11/2016). The Blood and Crip identities that had previously been
adopted wholesale passed through a culturally syncretic process, blending with Belizean
identities. Whilst present day gangs still bear remnants of US gangsta culture, seen in the
ongoing use of red or blue ‘rags’ and imported Dickies trousers, the influence of the Bloods
and Crips as an organisational structure has been eroded over the last two decades. Local
politician Shirley surmised Boys are confused about what they are fighting about, they don’t
know what wearing red or blue means” (18/05/2016). Gang leader Vartas added “Now it’s ‘an
enemy of my enemy is my friend’, Bloods and Crips don’ matter no more” (Vartas
This section draws upon Messerschmidt’s proposal that regional level hegemonic masculinities
can provide cultural materials to be adopted or reworked, providing models of masculinity that
are important in local gender dynamics (2018, p. 53). The arrival of the Bloods and Crips
reconfigured street patterns of masculinity establishing a gangsta culture with discernible
hegemonic practices. Jewkes et al (2015) suggested that multiple hegemonic projects can be
observed in the local, which supports the possibility of gang transnationalism being established
as a model of localised hegemonic masculinity. A key finding from Belize is that these local
models or projects of masculinity are not static templates, but culturally and intergenerationally
adaptable, which is why the term ‘hegemonic shape’ is used.
The original Blood and Crip structures in Belize City established a lasting set of social practices
perceivable in contemporary gangs; the aesthetics of language, the pose, the cars, or gold
chains, and the symbolic shotta notoriety and fear, sexual access to women, street parties,
drinking and drug-taking. This can be understood as significant capital, flaunted to an
audience in the ghetto to acquire meaning (Baird, 2012a; 2012b; 2015; Fraser, 2013; Sandberg,
2008). These displays are a version of hegemonic masculine localism, a set of socially and
culturally adaptable and relational notions, practices and displays, performed under specific
social and economic conditions.
This hegemonic shape runs through the history of street gangs in Belize. As the Bloods and
Crips fragmented and the Generals died off, smaller factions were run by new generations of
Big Men, Boss Men, Shottas, Killer Men and Strike Men who picked up the mantle as the new
gangsta personas driving the localised hegemonic masculine ideal. Tiger, a young man on the
fringes of gang life stated:
Tiger: Mi father was a member of a gang, but he ded. Mi brother a was a member of
Bakatown gang, but Ghost Town [gang] end up kill him, like tree year ago.
Author: Why they kill him, what was the beef about?
Tiger: Mi brother was [laughs self-consciously], mi brother was their killer-man. He was
the strike-man for Bakatown, and Ghost Town wanted revenge
Author: Why do they fight?
Tiger: Dey fight for respec’ an’ ting. ‘Coz mostly ting happen when dey got a party on.
When all da gang members meet up, and ting just start to flick-up [flare-up]. Their beef
done start simple. Simple ting cause beef down here. They teef [steal] a bike down dere,
small tings! Den dey come up into bigger problems, y’know? (12/05/2016)
The narratives of young gang members discussed identities consistently linked to domination
and the rejection of non-hegemonic traits, where “Everybody wanna be a man, you da man if
you kill somebody, if you don’t do it, ya pussy” (Vartas 18/05/2016). Haylock’s research with
male youth offenders corroborates this “Everybody wants to be known as the ‘big man’ out on
the streets. We want everyone to think we are ‘bad’ enough, being a ‘killer, murderer, or a
prisoner’ is respected.” (2013, p. 31). Messiah, a former gang member-turned rapper,
connected violence to male status, There’s niggaz who have respect from the streets and
niggaz know, ‘don’t fuck wid dat nigga ‘coz he will shoot the fuck out of you’” (16/11/2016).
These identities set out a gendered framework for gang membership. Sufficient numbers of
Southside boys learn these rites-of-passage to facilitate the fluid intergenerational handing-
over of the baton, what Jabaar refers to below as a fast ‘transition’:
Like, right now the leader of George Street is a guy dey call ‘Baby’, because he’s unknown,
he’s a young fellow, and he’s more ruthless coz he knows what happened to his seniors
[murdered gang leaders]. So, da killers are more ruthless now. Dey are new, dey are young,
and da transition is faster. Some are 13 years old. I saw a young guy who I know is a shotta
[gunman], and he is not more than 11 years old. So basically, what we have in Belize is child
soldiering (11/05/2016).
A former manager of a gang prevention programme referred to the vulnerability of the young
boys she worked with on Southside who were almost all from struggling single mother
households: “The only men that talk to these boys are gangs on the streets, who they look up
to and idolise” (Sally 10/05/2016).
Boys think that being rude and acting like a gang member is how you get respect off
someone. There is no longer manhood. We have overgrown adolescents, right?
There’s no male role model. Actually, the role model that most of our young males
seem to be gravitating towards are gangsters. Back in the day, when you went to jail
you got scorned. Now, you get stripes, street credibility. So, street credibility has taken
over masculinity (Jabaar 11/05/2016).
The ganging process demands the practice and display of ‘baddness’ that subordinates non-
hegemonic masculine traits (Baird, 2018a). Gang performance asserts a patriarchy of the streets
encompassing the treatment of women and sexual violence, demonstrated by Shorty’s
Besides my other whores, I had this beautiful woman [goes on to talk about teenage
girlfriend. Shorty was thirty-three at the time]. The bitches who love gangstas only
love the dude for the stuff he’s doin’ on the streets… they all want the same, they only
like him because of his name, then they always fuck their best friends! Yeah, we train
[gang rape] them. I’ve seen ten gangbangers do one woman [called Pleasers]. Some
are forced, some wanna do it to show that they are down, it shows they love them
the dudes don’t really hang out with the home girls, they hang out in their own groups,
they are separated. Women don’t hold guns… but I know one who killed two people,
because I taught her how to be a real, real, real home girl (19/11/2016).
This section has not set out to be an essentialist appraisal of poor young men, rather it uses
empiricism to demonstrate how gang culture plays a role in gendering identities of the street.
Particularly the gang persona occupies significant ontological ground in terms of local
meanings of masculinities because of its hegemonic power, displayed in the public practices
and capital of gang members. Arguably then, hegemonic masculine practice as a form of
localism is at the heart of gang continuity. A notable finding is that this hegemonic power is
derived from multiple sources. This allows Southside gangs to have influence through a range
of masculine capitals even if they may be financially poorer than more organised criminal
gangs in other contexts. For example, despite this relative poverty a recent report stated that
73% of gang members interviewed still felt the gang brought them significant ‘respect’
(Arciaga Young, 2019, p. 86). As one government official said, “gangs might not be well
resourced, but they are an important social organism in the human ecology of Southside. That’s
why people join gangs. It’s like a factory” (Bob, 21/11/2017).
Finally, reflecting on Beske’s work, who said that rising violence in rural Belize has come to
redefine the cultural order itself (2016, p. 63), gang transnationalism has come to redefine the
cultural order on the streets, whose hegemonic shape underpins the continuity of violence in
the city to this day.
6 Conclusions
By focusing on gangs in Belize this article has framed gang transnationalism as a form of
transnational masculinity. Drawing on Connell and Messerschmidt’s (2005; 2018) notions of
localised hegemonic masculinity, models or projects (the latter after Jewkes et al, 2015),
empirical evidence has been put forward to argue that gang transnationalism has established
localised hegemonic gang practices on Southside, most visibly in displays of violence and
symbolic and material masculine capital, leading gangs to acquire and maintain prominence as
aspirational sites of male identity formation, leading to their self-perpetuation.
Much has been said about the social terrain into which gang transnationalism inserts itself.
Clearly, historical exclusion on Belize City’s Southside created vulnerabilities amongst the
disenfranchised, poor, male, Creole population to the lure of transnational gang culture. It has
been argued that gang transnationalism is a migrant form of gendered localism that requires a
receptive terrain that reflects the intersections of race, class, and subordination found in the
originating locale. The experience on Southside indicates that the transnational gangsta persona
can become established rapidly - within a generation in vulnerable terrains, precisely because
it is a hegemonic masculine model that inflects the vulnerabilities of local men. This is a
significant claim, but one that opens lines of enquiry for further, particularly comparative,
research: Can other experiences of gang transnationalism be understood as a form of
transnational masculinity; do destination terrains need to reflect the setting where gang
transnationalism originates from, and; would comparative analysis make it possible to predict
where gang transnationalism may emerge in the future?
Localising hegemonic masculinities is in itself a challenge. To what extent can men
subordinated by race and class even represent a hegemonic ideal? In response, this article has
attempted to tease out some nuances of gangland masculinities. Although gang members have
not been cast as simple victims of ‘perilous masculinity’ (after de la Tierra, 2016) it is vital to
read the social terrain from which gangs emerge. Reading exclusion as gendered helps us
understand how gang transnationalism embeds effectively. The vulnerability of local boys and
young men was palpable during the fieldwork; for many, gang membership was a socially
cohesive sub-cultural guarantor of identity and dignity, a conduit for masculine power that
offset the multiple subordinations wrought by legacies of exclusion. However, the image of the
emasculated and imperilled Creole gang member striking back at the system as a form of
protest, rebellious or compensatory masculinity, is only part of the picture. Whilst gang
practices should be considered a subversive reaction to structural constraint, they rarely
challenge the gender hierarchies of the street that subjugate women and non-hegemonic
masculinities. In the Belizean case, the gangsta persona reinforced them, often with violence,
reasserting the patriarchies of the street and multiplying the harm done to communities already
structurally excluded.
We should be measured in our use of this analysis, however. Perceiving gang practices,
displays or performances as an expression of hegemonic masculinity may be an apposite way
to unpack the violence often inherent to them, but it should not be used to essentialise the lives
of individual gang members. Masculinities are multiple, relational, and setting dependant;
away from gang socialisation spaces, these young men are likely to be loving sons, boyfriends
or fathers. In short, gang members are part victim, part perpetrator; both vulnerable men and
violent hegemonic men.
If vulnerable young men respond to gangs, how can alternative masculinisation opportunities
be promoted in marginalised communities to prevent gang membership? These types of
questions are are rarely considered in gang focused interventions which are overwhelmingly
masculinities-blind. Therefore to conclude, it is worth reflecting upon the Southside Youth
Success Programme (UNDP Belize & Government of Belize, 2013), a masculinities focused
pilot project designed by the author that targeted school drop-outs and other youths at high risk
of joining gangs, such as those in conflict with the law. It was notable from interviews with the
participants on this program that they valued the men-talk’ component as the only time they
critically engaged with meanings of masculinity. Most came from fractured homes and gang
members were often their male role models on the streets. The mentoring delivered at a drop-
in centre on Southside encouraged them to find positive pathways to manhood and to reject the
gang as a site of male success. This was further bolstered by weekly male ‘motivational
speakers’ who covered topics such as ‘Not choosing the path of a gangster’, ‘Losing a loved
one as a result of gang rivalry’, ‘Sexual exploitation’, and ‘Changing the course of your life’
(SYSP Annual Report, 2014). The program evaluation showed that the masculinities focus was
instrumental in reaching out to boys and young men who were tempted by the gang because it
gave them tools to critically appraise the gang as a site of male success. During the project life-
cycle from 2012-2014, 89 of the 106 participants ended up in work, a paid apprenticeship, or
back into full-time education (SYSP Annual Report, 2014). A key lesson from this experience
was that whilst masculinities matter, mentoring was only effective when twinned with tangible
alternative pathways for youths back into education or gainful employment; in other words,
visualised and viable alternative pathways to manhood prevented gang membership. The better
we grasp the masculine dynamics of gang practices, the better positioned we will be as scholars
and practitioners to reduce the harm done by gangs to already vulnerable communities,
particularly homicidal and sexual violences, and the pernicious impact of fear that lies just
beneath the surface.
Adler, A. (1928). Understanding human nature. London: Allen and Unwin.
Anderson, E. (2000). Code of the street: decency, violence, and the moral life of the inner
city. New York.
Arciaga Young, M. (2019). Community Gang Assessment, Belize. Interamerican
Development Bank, Washington D.C.
Baird, A. (2011) South-Side Youth Success: Pathways to employment for young men at-risk
of joining gangs, UNDP, Belize (open access at:
for_young_men_at-risk_of_joining_gangs_in_Belize_City )
Baird, A., (2012a), The violent gang and the construction of masculinity amongst socially
excluded young men, Safer Communities, 11(4): 179190.
Baird, A., (2012b), Negotiating Pathways to Manhood: Rejecting Gangs and Violence in
Medellín’s Periphery, Journal of Conflictology, 3(1): 30-41.
Baird, A., (2015), Duros & Gangland Girlfriends: Male Identity, Gang Socialisation and
Rape in Medellín, in Auyero, J., Bourgois, P. & Scheper-Hughes, N. (Eds), Violence at the
Urban Margins in the Americas, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Baird, A (2018a) Becoming the Baddest: Masculine trajectories of gang violence in Medellín,
Journal of Latin American Studies, 50(1), 183-210.
Baird, A (2018b) Dancing with Danger: Ethnographic safety, male bravado and gang
research in Colombia, Qualitative Research, Sage.
Barker, G. (2005). Dying To Be Men: Youth, masculinity and social exclusion. London:
Berg, L.-A., & Carranza, M. (2018). Organized criminal violence and territorial control:
Evidence from northern Honduras. Journal of Peace Research, 55(5), 566581.
Beske, M. (2016). Intimate Partner Violence and Advocate Response: Redefining Love in
Western Belize - 9781498503600 | Rowman & Littlefield. Lanham, Maryland:
Rowman & Littlefield.
Bloch, H., & Niederhoffer, A. (1958). The Gang: A Study of Adolescent Behavior. New
York: Philosophical Library.
Bolland, N. (1997). Struggles for Freedom: Essays on slavery, colonialism and culture in the
Caribbean and Central America. Belize City: The Angelus Press Limited.
Bourgois, P. (1995). In Search of Respect: Selling crack in El Barrio (2nd ed.). New York:
Cambridge University Press.
Bourgois, P. (2001). In Search of Masculinity: Violence, Respect, and Sexuality among
Puerto Rican Crack Dealers in East Harlem. In Men’s Lives. Kimmel, M; Messner, M
Eds, Boston, Pearson.
Brotherton, D. (2007). Proceedings from the transnational street gang/organization seminar.
Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal.
Buller, A. M. (2015). Young men and structural, symbolic and everyday violence in Lima,
Peru. In J. Parkes (Ed.), Gender Violence in Poverty Contexts: The Educational
Challenge. Education, Poverty and International Development. London: Routledge.
Cerbino, M., & Barrios, L. (2008). Otras Naciones: Jóvenes, transnacionalismo y exclusión.
Quito: FLACSO.
Cerbino, M., & Rodríguez, A. (2008). La Nación imaginada de los Latin Kings: criminología
cultural y la banda transnacional. In M. Cerbino & L. Barrios (Eds.), Otras Naciones:
Jóvenes, transnacionalismo y exclusón (FLACSO). Quito.
Cloward, R. A., & Ohlin, L. E. (1966). Delinquency and opportunity: a theory of delinquent
gangs. Glencoe, Illonois: Free Press.
Cobbina, J. E., Like-Haislip, T. Z., & Miller, J. (2010). Gang Fights versus Cat Fights: Urban
Young Men’s Gendered Narratives of Violence. Deviant Behavior, 31(7), 596624.
Cruz, José Miguel. (2010). Central American maras: from youth street gangs to transnational
protection rackets. Global Crime, 11(4), 379398.
Dawson, G. (1994). Soldier heroes: British adventure, empire, and the imagining of
masculinities. London; Routledge.
de la Tierra, A. L. (2016). Essentializing Manhood in “the Street”: Perilous Masculinity and
Popular Criminological Ethnographies. Feminist Criminology, 11(4), 375397.
Espagne, M. (1999). Les transferts culturels. Paris: Press Universitaires e France.
Flores, J. (2009). The diaspora strikes back Caribeo tales of learning and turning. New
York, NY: Routledge.
Fontes, A. W. (2018). Mortal Doubt: Transnational Gangs and Social Order in Guatemala
City. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Fraser, A. (2013). Street habitus: gangs, territorialism and social change in Glasgow. Journal
of Youth Studies.
Fraser, A. (2017). Gangs & Crime: Critical Alternatives. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.
Gayle, H., Hampton, V., & Mortis, N. (2016). Like Bush Fire: A study on male participation
and violence in urban Belize. Belize City: Cubola Productions.
Gemert, F. V. (2001). Crips in Orange: Gangs and Groups in the Netherlands. In W. E. G. M.
Klein M.W., Kerner HJ., Maxson C.L. (Ed.), The Eurogang Paradox: Street gangs and
youth groups in the U.S. and Europe. Dordrecht: Springer.
Gutierrez Rivera, L., Strønen, I., & Ystanes, M. (2018). Coming of Age in the Penal System:
Neoliberalism, ‘Mano Dura’ and the Reproduction of ‘Racialised’ Inequality in
Honduras (pp. 205228).
Gutmann, M. C., & Viveros Vigoya, M. (2005). Masculinities in Latin America. In M.
Kimmel, J. Hearn, & R. W. Connell (Eds.), Handbook of Studies on Men and
Masculinities. London: Sage Publications.
Hagedorn, J. (2008). A World of Gangs. London: University of Minnesota Press.
Hall, S. (2015). Creolité and the Process of Creolization*. In Creolizing Europe. Liverpool
University Press.
Haylock, N. (2013). National Public Policy Proposal: Prevention of Youth-Involved Violence
in Belize 2012-2022, Belize Crime Observatory, Belmopan.
Heinonen, P. (2011). Youth Gangs and Street Children: Culture, nature and masculinity in
Ethiopia. New York: Berghan Books.
Jensen, S. (2008). Gangs, Politics & Dignity in Cape Town. Oxford: James Curry Ltd.
Jewkes, R., Morrell, R., Hearn, J., Lundqvist, E., Blackbeard, D., Lindegger, G., … Gottzén,
L. (2015). Hegemonic masculinity: combining theory and practice in gender
interventions. Culture, Health & Sexuality, 17 Suppl 2(sup2), S112S127.
Johns, A. (2014). Bloods, Crips and Southern Cross Soldiers: Gang Identities in Australia. A
Critical Youth Studies for the 21st Century. Brill.
Jütersonke, O., Muggah, R., & Rodgers, D. (2009). Gangs, Urban Violence, and Security
Interventions in Central America. Security Dialogue, 40(45), 373397.
Levenson-Estrada, D. (2013). Adiós niño: the gangs of Guatemala City and the politics of
death. Duke University Press.
Levenson, D. T. (2013). Adiós Niño: The Gangs of Guatemala City and the Politics of Death.
Durham: Duke University Press.
Maher, L. (1997). Sexed work: gender, race, and resistance in a Brooklyn drug market. New
York, Oxford University Press.
Messerschmidt and R. W. Connell, J. W. (2005). Hegemonic Masculinity. Rethinking the
Concept. Gender and Society, 19(6), 829859.
Messerschmidt, J. W. (2018). Hegemonic Masculinity: Formulation, Reformulation, and
Amplification. Rowman & Littlefield.
Miller, J. (2001). One of the Guys: Girls, Gangs and Gender. New York: Oxford University
Miller Matthei, L., & Smith, D. (1998). Belizean ‘Boyz ‘n the ‘Hood’? Garifuna Labor
Migration and Transnational. In M. P. Guarnizo & L. E. Smith (Eds.), Identity
inTransnationalism from Below (pp. 270290). NewBrunswick, N.J.: Transaction
Muhammad, N. (2015). Insights into Gang Culture in Belize: Essays on youth, crime, and
violence. Belize City: Reynolds Desktop Publishing.
Mullins, C. W. (2006). Holding your square: masculinities, streetlife, and violence. Willan.
Mullins, C. W., & Cardwell-Mullins, R. M. (2006). Bad Ass or Punk Ass? The Contours of
Street Masculinity. Universitas, 2(2), 117.
Mullins, C. W., & Lee, S. (2019). “Like Make Up on a Man”: The Gendered Nature of Gun
Norms. Deviant Behavior, 117.
Panfil, V. R., & Peterson, D. (2015). Gender, Sexuality, and Gangs. In The Handbook of
Gangs (pp. 208234). John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Peirce, J. (2017). Gap Analysis Report: Citizen Security in Belize. Washington D.C.,
Interamerican Development Bank.
Peterson, D. (2018). Gender and Gang Involvement. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of
Criminology. Oxford University Press.
Quierolo Palmas, L. (2009). Pandillas en el Atlantico Latino: identidad, transnacinoalismo y
generaciones. ICONOS, 13(2), 125138.
Rios, V. (2011). Punished: Policing the lives of black and Latino boys. New York: New York
University Press.
Rodgers, D. & Baird, A., (2015), Understanding Gangs in Contemporary Latin America, in
Decker, S. & Pyrooz, D. (Eds.), The Wiley Handbook of Gangs, Oxford: John Wiley & Sons.
Roks, R. A. (2017). In the ‘h200d’: Crips and the intersection between space and identity in
the Netherlands. Crime, Media, Culture: An International Journal, 174165901772900.
Roks, R. A., & Densley, J. A. (2019). From Breakers to Bikers: The Evolution of the Dutch
Crips ‘Gang’. Deviant Behavior, 118.
Sandberg, S. (2008). Street capital: Ethnicity and violence on the streets of Oslo. Theoretical
Criminology, 12(2), 153171.
Saunders-Hastings, K. (2018). Red zone blues: Violence and nostalgia in Guatemala City.
Ethnography, 146613811879597.
Savenije, W., & van der Borgh, C. (2015). San Salvador: Violence and Resilience in
Gangland: Coping with the Code of the Street. In K. Koonings & D. Krujt (Eds.),
Violence and Resilience in Latin American Cities. London: Zed Books Ltd.
Shoman, A. (2011). A History of Belize in 13 Chapters (2nd ed.). Belize City: The Angelus
Press Limited.
Theidon, K. (2007). Transitional Subjects: The Disarmament, Demobilization and
Reintegration of Former Combatants in Colombia. International Journal of Transitional
Justice , 1(1), 6690.
UNDP Belize, & Government of Belize. (2013). The Good, The Bad, The Nobody Road.
Belize City.
UNDP. 2014. Southside Youth Success Project Annual Report, Belmopan.
UNICEF Belize. (2011). The Situation Analysis of Children and Women in Belize 2011 An
Ecological Review. Belize City.
UNODC. (2018). Statistics,
Venkatesh, S. (2008). Gang Leader for a Day: A Rogue Sociologist Takes to the Streets. New
York: The Penguin Press.
Vernon, S. (2000). In-Transit: The story of a journey. Belize City: The Angelus Press
Warnecke-Berger, H. (2017). Forms of Violence in Past and Present: El Salvador and Belize
in Comparative Perspective. In S. Huhn & H. Warnecke-Berger (Eds.), Politics and
History of Violence and Crime in Central America. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Warnecke-Berger, H. (2019). Politics & Violence in Central America & the Caribbean.
Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Wolf, S. (2017). Mano Dura: the politics of gang control in El Salvador. Austin: University
of Texas Press.
Zilberg, E. (2011). Space of detention: The making of a transnational gang crisis between
Los Angeles and San Salvador. Duke University Press.
Zubillaga, V. (2009). “Gaining respect”: The logic of violence among young men in the
barrios of Caracas, Venezuela. In G. A. Jones & D. Rodgers (Eds.), Youth Violence in
Latin America: Gangs and Juvenile Justice in Perspective in Perspective. London:
Zulver, J. (2016). High-risk feminism in El Salvador: women’s mobilisation in violent times.
Gender & Development, 24(2), 171185.
Author biography:
Adam Baird is a sociologist and ethnographer who uses masculinities as a lens to
understand gangs and community violence. He has conducted research across Latin
America and the Caribbean, including Colombia, Trinidad and Tobago, and Belize.
... A number of these countries later became transhipment points for more nefarious cocaine trafficking from Andean South America, which first appeared as early as the 1980s, gaining traction in the early 1990s with the rise of the notorious Medellín and Cali cartels in Colombia. Trinidad and Belize are now recognised as important transhipment points (Townsend, 2009;Baird, 2019); the former has busy maritime trade links with the USA, Europe and west Africa (Reichel and Randa, 2018), the latter can be reached by speedboat from Colombia's north coast in a few hours, a midway point en route to the USA. ...
... Fine-grain empirical data from each individual project is unpacked in more detail in two dedicated articles (Baird, 2019;Baird, Bishop and Kerrigan, 2021). In both cases, older community members and middle-aged former gang members were key informants precisely because they had lived through of the homicide booms in the early 2000s. ...
... Disenfranchised, poor, young, black and brown people were receptive interlocutors for imported gangsta culture or the power of the new automatic weapon wielding gangs. This has been framed in both countries and elsewhere in the region as 'masculine vulnerability', deliberately placing emphasis on the way gender intersects with excluded social terrains to make the gang stand out as a 'capital' laden site of success and possibility (Baird, 2012(Baird, , 2019. As one lady on Southside remarked, "boys look up to and idolise" gangs (interview, May 2016). ...
Full-text available
At the end of the 1990s gang driven homicide rates in Belize and Trinidad boomed and today remain amongst the highest in the world. That these homicide booms occurred as drug transhipments increased, makes casual connections between drugs and violence an intuitive and frequent assumption. This article argues that the role that drugs transhipment plays in sparking transitions to violence is often assumed and overstated, and alone is a weak predictor of violence. The comparative research presented finds that historic, chronic vulnerability in the poor neighbourhoods of eastern Port of Spain and southside Belize City played a defining role in the rise of street gangs; whilst increased lethality is directly attributable to inflows of firearms, which had different transhipment routes and political economies to drugs when homicide booms occurred. Ominously, once a violent street culture is established, it is resilient, guns stay, gangs evolve, and homicide levels persist.
... A number of these countries later became transhipment points for more nefarious cocaine trafficking from Andean South America, which first appeared as early as the 1980s, gaining traction in the early 1990s with the rise of the notorious Medellín and Cali cartels in Colombia. Trinidad and Belize are now recognised as important transhipment points (Townsend, 2009;Baird, 2019); the former has busy maritime trade links with the USA, Europe and west Africa (Reichel and Randa, 2018), the latter can be reached by speedboat from Colombia's north coast in a few hours, a midway point en route to the USA. ...
... Fine-grain empirical data from each individual project is unpacked in more detail in two dedicated articles (Baird, 2019;Baird, Bishop and Kerrigan, 2021). later rolled out to hundreds of young people in Trinidad by (Kerrigan, 2019 explores this methodology in more detail). ...
... American majority Bloods and Crips (red and blue colors gangs) in Los Angeles, Chicago, New York and beyond. Those who were incarcerated were deported for the first time as early as 1981, becoming pioneers of gang transnationalism as Bloods and Crips took root on Southside (Muhammad, 2015;Baird, 2019 (Muhammad, 2015, p. 169). ...
Full-text available
At the end of the 1990s gang driven homicide rates in Belize and Trinidad boomed and today remain amongst the highest in the world. That these homicide booms occurred as drug transhipments increased, makes casual connections between drugs and violence an intuitive and frequent assumption. This article argues that the role that drugs transhipment plays in sparking transitions to violence is often assumed and overstated, and alone is a weak predictor of violence. The comparative research presented finds that historic, chronic vulnerability in the poor neighbourhoods of eastern Port of Spain and southside Belize City played a defining role in the rise of street gangs; whilst increased lethality is directly attributable to inflows of firearms, which had different transhipment routes and political economies to drugs when homicide booms occurred. Ominously, once a violent street culture is established, it is resilient, guns stay, gangs evolve, and homicide levels persist.
... Compared to the other narratives, this one stands out for the identification between the self and the violence without compromising their self. Being an aggressor can be a successful presentation in the context of the interview (Baird, 2019). ...
... He does not identify as a delinquent, a 'lowlife', a 'drifter', as other men did. This presentation differs from cases in which violence was linked to neighbourhood dynamics (Auyero, Bourgois, & Scheper-Hughes, 2015;Auyero et al., 2015) or criminal trajectories (Baird, 2019). Violence was not justified or experienced as self-righteous (Katz, 1988), but presented as a last resource. ...
Full-text available
This paper identifies the explanatory narratives used by perpetrators of male-male homicide in Buenos Aires (Argentina) to make sense of this crime. Drawing upon narrative criminology and masculinities theories, this study enquires into the rationalisations of perpetrators, considering their emic terms, rationalities and stories. Fieldwork was conducted between 2016 and 2020, and a convenience sample strategy was employed for participant recruitment. The analysis is based upon seventy-three narrative-biographical interviews with offenders, and field observations in prisons and homes of former convicts. The corpus was analysed following an inductive thematic coding strategy using Atlas.Ti. Eight narratives were typified, considering how men talked about agency and change, and the explanatory locus of the stories: 'rebel', 'affected', 'idiot', 'either him or me', 'repeating the story', 'gang', 'betrayed' and 'victim'. These accounts revealed two paradoxes about violence perpetration storytelling and its discursive management: men can commit a homicide and present themselves as not responsible for it and, simultaneously, they use, reconfigure and negotiate expert theories and scientific labels to explain away, excuse and justify lethal violence. This study argues that accounts are not merely neutralisation strategies, but the ra-tionalisations of the perpetrators' experiences, and the foundation for how they relate to and inhabit penal institutions. This paper contributes to the understanding of how those explanations shape past and future actions, and how masculinities, biographical processes and violence performance are interconnected.
... Por último, destaco que, como plantean tanto Zubillaga (2007) como Baird (2018aBaird ( , 2019, cada forma de amenaza específica que es percibida por los varones, y la demanda particular de respeto bajo la cual los varones "invierten" estas amenazas, implican sentidos diferentes. El Chino, Bolívar, Juampi y Dalmiro, por ejemplo, experimentan diferentes formas de amenazas, que los interpela en diferentes aspectos subjetivos: las realidades materiales concretas, las relaciones sexo-afectivas, los vínculos de estatus en el barrio, y el "quedar bien" con los amigos. ...
... El prestigio es, por este motivo, una dimensión central de esta narrativa. Tal como se ha señalado en otros estudios sobre homicidio y femicidio (Baird, 2019;Di Marco y Evans, 2020;R. Dobash y Dobash, 2020;Goussinsky y Yassour-Borochowitz, 2012;Kessler, 2010, pp. ...
¿Quiénes son los varones que cometen homicidios? ¿Cómo son sus vidas y qué eventos las marcan? ¿Qué sentido le dan a la muerte violenta? Y, ¿cómo experimentan el momento del crimen? Desde una perspectiva microsociológica y narrativa, este libro indaga sobre los relatos de vida de varones cisgénero que produjeron la muerte de otros varones en peleas y enfrentamientos en el Área Metropolitana de Buenos Aires. La propuesta teórica y empírica de este libro es tanto el resultado de una vacancia académica en comprender las vidas de perpetradores de violencia letal, como también una respuesta a la parcialización disciplinar en el campo de estudios de la violencia. Esta investigación surge del interés por integrar diferentes dimensiones que permitan complejizar este fenómeno. Las vidas previas al evento, la dinámica experiencial durante los enfrentamientos y las explicaciones del acto son, de este modo, tres modos de abordar, desmenuzar y estudiar qué ocurre en la vida de estos varones. Esta tesis doctoral explora y examina los sentidos con los que se gestiona el haber cometido un homicidio y, a su vez, da cuenta de la lectura estoica con la que los varones reconstruyen los enfrentamientos. El hecho de que el homicidio no siempre sea experimentado como un giro biográfico, que los conflictos entre varones seas vividos como inevitables y viscerales, y que los varones empleen diferentes historias para justificar, racionalizar, neutralizar y, en algunos casos, legitimar el matar son algunos de los resultados que esta tesis explora. Las preguntas y respuestas sobre el campo de la violencia que aquí se desprenden tienen como intención contribuir a las miradas que se han encargado de comprender las condiciones de posibilidad sociales y subjetivas de la violencia letal. Este libro se encuadra en la profunda convicción de hacer visibles los modos dominantes en que las identidades masculinas se vinculan, a la vez que producen y reproducen ciertos sentidos sobre la agresión física cómo práctica legítima, viable o “inevitable” para abordar conflictos interpersonales.
... Compared to the other narratives, this one stands out for the identification between the self and the violence without compromising their self. Being an aggressor can be a successful presentation in the context of the interview (Baird, 2019). ...
... He does not identify as a delinquent, a 'lowlife', a 'drifter', as other men did. This presentation differs from cases in which violence was linked to neighbourhood dynamics (Auyero, Bourgois, & Scheper-Hughes, 2015;Auyero et al., 2015) or criminal trajectories (Baird, 2019). Violence was not justified or experienced as self-righteous (Katz, 1988), but presented as a last resource. ...
Conference Paper
In Latin America, qualitative research on violence has traditionally been focused on marginalised and criminalised populations. Within Social Sciences, studies on gang violence, criminality and police abuse have shown a thorough understanding of how violence is produced and reproduced in the context of secluded neighbourhoods, shantytowns and informal settlements. Nonetheless, the urban settings themselves have been predominantly considered as mere scenarios where crime and violence occur. In the field of homicides, the links between urban life, marginalisation and violence has been equally neglected as a key component in the configuration of this phenomenon. From a biographical perspective, the main objective of this paper is to enquire how neighbourhood dynamics and biographies of homicide perpetrators intertwine in shantytowns and poor neighbourhoods in the outskirts of Buenos Aires Capital City, Argentina. A narrative study was developed, focused on the life stories of young male perpetrators of intentional homicide. Open-ended interviews were carried out and participant observations were conducted in the neighbourhoods (parks, schools, hospitals, homes, etc.). In this paper, three main dimensions are analysed: a. how neighbourhoods are described and signified, b. how neighbourhood dynamics (residential changes, located practices, gang activities, etc.) are narrated as interwoven aspects in their life stories, c. how the infrastructural setting is experienced by these men. Two main aspects can be highlighted from the narratives. Firstly, the actual physical and infrastructural configuration of shantytowns and poor neighbourhoods has an impact on the accessibility of public and private institutions, and this is experienced as a major conditioning factor in their lives. Secondly, feeling locked up in the neighbourhood and its physical arrangement (“encerrado en el tatetí de la villa”) was a common experience in the interviewees and this was narratively used to give meaning to their life trajectories.
... Compared to the other narratives, this one stands out for the identification between the self and the violence without compromising their self. Being an aggressor can be a successful presentation in the context of the interview (Baird, 2019). ...
... He does not identify as a delinquent, a 'lowlife', a 'drifter', as other men did. This presentation differs from cases in which violence was linked to neighbourhood dynamics (Auyero, Bourgois, & Scheper-Hughes, 2015;Auyero et al., 2015) or criminal trajectories (Baird, 2019). Violence was not justified or experienced as self-righteous (Katz, 1988), but presented as a last resource. ...
Conference Paper
Academic literature on homicide has a long tradition of focusing on socio-demographic and criminological data of both perpetrators and victims. Critical hermeneutic studies have stressed the need to link homicide trends with in-depth knowledge of perpetrators and their social contexts. However, little attention has been paid to emic interpretations of homicide itself. In the context of a research project on life stories of young men who have committed intentional homicide in marginalised neighbourhoods in the outskirts of Buenos Aires City (Argentina), the objective of this paper is to analyse how homicide perpetrators give meaning to the homicide(s) and provide narrative explanations. A hermeneutic biographical approach was employed, conducting open-ended interviews which were carried out in prisons, juvenile centres and residential houses. For this paper, 15 cases were reconstructed and analysed using an inter-testimonial approach. Special attention was given to the identification of indexes and turning-points in life stories, and to “lay theories” of violence. Firstly, comprehensive analysis of their narratives shows that, while homicide itself appeared as an index in life stories, it does not always represent a major turning-point. This is comprehensible due to prior experiences with violent deaths, daily contact with firearms and the fact that physical violence was seen as a legitimate means to deal with conflict and negotiations. Secondly, three main explanations of their homicides could be typified according to where they narratively positioned the locus of responsibility and intelligibility: contextual explanations (the action is linked to macro-economic processes and related situations), network explanations (the locus is positioned on the relationships, usually peers which are referred as “bad company”) and individual explanations (interviewees explain homicide as a consequence of individual aspects, whether moral, psychological or other sort).
... La tolerancia alta a la violencia también ha sido un foco común de atención para analizar cómo se minimizan y normalizan los actos violentos tanto en las rutinas diarias (Heilman & Barker, 2018) como en circunstancias extraordinarias (Roy, 2008). Además, estudios etnográficos han ilustrado cómo la perpetración de homicidios está estrechamente asociada con formas específicas de masculinidad que se negocian como parte de la formación de la identidad (Baird, 2018(Baird, , 2019. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Los estudios de género, los estudios sociales de violencia y las diversas ramas de la criminología han mostrado el carácter sistemático y estructural que tiene la violencia basada en relaciones de género en América Latina. No obstante, la perspectiva de quienes ejercen esta violencia ha sido un eje comparativamente menos explorado, más aún cuando se trata de femicidios. En el marco de un estudio socio-narrativo sobre varones que cometieron femicidio, en esta ponencia nos preguntamos por las narrativas y nociones sobre las mujeres de los varones que cometieron femicidio íntimo. Para ello se realizaron y analizaron 19 entrevistas narrativas con varones condenados por femicidio en el Área Metropolitana de Buenos Aires y se llevó a cabo un análisis intertestimonial a partir de una estrategia de codificación temática. Las nociones referidas a las mujeres (y lo femenino) se organizaron alrededor de tres grandes temas: la amenaza, el control, y el contexto. Se discute la posible construcción de una tipología narrativa sobre las nociones en torno a las mujeres, y el vínculo con los relatos de vida.
Trending upwards since 2000, Belize consistently tops the list of countries with the highest homicide rates in the world. A report published by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) in 2009 outlined the detrimental effects of youth gangs in Belize and predicted that 6% of Belizeans were not expected to reach age 40. The availability of guns and pervasive gang involvement coupled with elevated school desertion rates and few employment opportunities for youth, Belize’s high homicide rate has hovered around 40 per 100,000 in recent years. According to Belizean authorities, territorial rivalries between gangs are the main driver of homicidal violence and account for an estimated 85% of all murders. This chapter considers gun and violence data from the Belize Crime Observatory from 2011 to 2020 and describes past and present trends in gun violence and gangs in postcolonial Belize.
This study draws on interviews with 29 former gang members to investigate changes in masculinity practices over time, which we term masculinity maturation. We find that perceptions of masculinity embodied dominant values while in the gang as well as later in the life course. For instance, respondents expressed that men should always act with respect, honor, and integrity toward others. We observed changes, however, in the ways that men accomplished their masculinities reflecting individuals’ shifting perceptions about the gang’s ability to be a resource to gain a masculine identity. Perceptions that the gang was not upholding masculine values spurred masculinity dilemmas that were associated with new dominant practices of masculinity centered on different social institutions like family, work, and religion as they grew older. The level of masculinity maturation that took place was linked to the strength of incongruence between perceptions of age-appropriate masculinity and gang masculinity.
Full-text available
The murder rate in Port of Spain, Trinidad, rose dramatically around the turn of the millennium, driven overwhelmingly by young men in gangs in the city’s poor neighborhoods. The literature frequently suggests a causal relationship between gang violence and rising transnational drug flows through Trinidad during this period. However, this is only part of a complex picture and misses the crucial mediating effect of evolving male identities in contexts of pronounced exclusion. Using original data, this article argues that historically marginalized “social terrains” are particularly vulnerable to violence epidemics when exposed to the influence of transnational drug and gun trafficking. When combined with easily available weapons, contextually constructed male hegemonic orders that resonate with the past act as catalysts for contemporary gang violence within those milieus. The study contributes a new empirical body of work on urban violence in Trinidad and the first masculinities-specific analysis of this phenomenon. We argue that contemporary gang culture is a historically rooted, contextually legitimated, male hegemonic street project in the urban margins of Port of Spain.
Full-text available
Based on ethnographic fieldwork and a content analysis of secondary sources, the current study presents an in-depth case study of gang evolution. We chart the history and development of the Dutch Crips, from playgroup origins in the 1980s to criminal endeavors in the 1990s, to its rebirth as an Outlaw Motorcycle Gang in the 2000s. At each evolutionary stage, we examine the identity of the group, its organization, the nature of its criminal activities, and branding. We highlight how, over 30 years, the Crips constantly reinvented themselves to meet their members’ age-defined needs and to attract future generations to the group. © 2019, © 2019 The Author(s). Published with license by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.
Full-text available
Prior research has established that women involved in criminal social networks and streetlife subculture tend to have high levels of personal victimization. Despite high levels of risk, and an apparent wide availability, these women typical neither carry nor use firearms, specifically handguns. Drawing upon interviews with 31 criminally involved women, this paper explores these women’s victimization experiences and their experiences with, and attitudes towards, firearms, especially handguns. Overall, we find that many norms held by women towards firearms in mainstream culture are shared by their peers involved in streetlife subculture.
The fear of violent crime dominates Guatemala City. In the midst of unprecedented levels of postwar violence, Guatemalans struggle to fathom the myriad forces that have made life in this city so deeply insecure. Born out of histories of state terror, migration, and US deportation, maras (transnational gangs) have become the face of this new era of violence. They are brutal organizations engaged in extortion, contract killings, and the drug trade, and yet they have also become essential to the emergence of a certain kind of social order. Drawing on years of fieldwork inside prisons, police precincts, and gang-dominated neighborhoods, Anthony W. Fontes demonstrates how gang violence has become indissoluble from contemporary social imaginaries and how these gangs provide cover for a host of other criminal actors. Ethnographically rich and unflinchingly critical, Mortal Doubt illuminates the maras’ role in making and mooring collective terror in Guatemala City while tracing the ties that bind this violence to those residing in far safer environs.
A preeminent authority on El Salvador's street gangs reports on three nongovernmental organizations that, advocating for human rights, have attempted to reform the country's gang policy-only to be stifled by sweeping, politically popular Mano Dura (Iron Fist) laws.
This book develops a comparative study on violence in Jamaica, El Salvador, and Belize based on a theoretical approach, extensive field research, and in-depth empirical research. It combines the Caribbean and Central America into a single comparative research that explores the historical (from the conquista onwards) as well as contemporary causes of violence in these societies. The volume focuses on forms of violence such as gang violence, police violence, every day forms of violence, vigilantism, and organized crime. The analysis provides a theoretical perspective that bridges political economy as well as cultural approaches in violence research. As such, it will be of interest to readers studying development, violence, political, Central American, and Caribbean studies. Hannes Warnecke-Berger is Senior Researcher at the Collaborative Research Centre 1199 “Processes of Spatialization under the Global Condition” and member of the Institute of Political Science at University of Leipzig, Germany.